1 / 11100%
Surname 1
Lennis Yesenia Ortega
Professor Forcey
Advanced Expository Writing
(Date)
The Negative Contribution Of Media In Identity Construction
Identity is a crucial issue that plagues humanity. Identity issues trouble people of all ages,
especially adolescents advancing into adulthood. The press has splendidly shaped the theme of
identity. Facets that characterize identity include disability, self-image, personality,
understanding of the self, gender in terms of masculinity and femininity, racial and sexual
orientation. The media falls into two categories; the mainstream and the social media. The
mainstream media primarily includes television and films. Gündüz (pp. 85, 2017) defines social
media as a unique platform that allows all users to share some content and express individual
opinions on them digitally or virtually, provided they have access to the internet. Social Media
neither restricts time nor dictates the place in which these interactions take place. The exchange
involves sharing pictures and personal views that stir the debates/communication, express views
by liking and disliking contents, or commenting on the content posted.
Unlike social media, the general 'media' broadcasts information through channels such as
television and film. The mainstream media similarly advocates/ critique some aspects of the
topic mentioned above. Some even run reality shows that address these views. As mentioned
earlier, those facets of identity are some of the issues that form the basis for critical debates and
expressions of thoughts. This paper provides a critical analysis of the negative roles the media
plays in influencing the concept of identity. The media has more detrimental effects on
individuals’ identity duty to its biased portrayal of facts.
Surname 2
Media and disability.
The media barely recognizes people with disability. The world acknowledges disability
cases ranging from blindness, people with mental illnesses such as Down Syndrome, those
without feet, and so on. Hudson (2018) writes about Helen Keller, a renowned writer and
influencer who was blind. Her story trends all over the media since her parents paid for her
publication. People have mixed ideas about disabilities, for such related issues barely go beyond
the walls in which these people reside. Some have stayed in the dark, and none of their stories
gets featured anywhere. Hudson admits the media's partiality in advocating different content;
Keller's story, for instance, gets all the fame since she came from well-off families. Even though
thousands of people exist who have disabilities, the media biasedly chooses what to focus on,
making the rest of those with disabilities feel unwanted.
The United Nations (n.d) identifies the negative light with which the media showcases
people with disabilities' stories that taints their identity. UN points out the media's mistakes that
portrays those with disabilities as pity parties instead of treating them with the dignity accorded
to every member of the society, whom the media considers complete. As a powerful instrument
of self-awareness, the UN poses a challenge to the media; to change the misconceptions and
instead make people aware of individuals with disabilities' contributions and strengths instead of
dwelling on the negative aspects only, which distorts the world’s view of them.
Media and Body Image
Body image is one of the topics passionately discussed in the media. People have chosen
to conform to the new standards set by the press due to its great influence. Social media has
posed a significant challenge by advocating for some measure of beauty that dictates specific
body features/ sizes as the only beauty elements, thus negatively affecting people's identity,
Surname 3
particularly those who may not reach these thresholds set. According to research done by
Vartanian, Giant & Passino (2001), women fall victim to snares the media sets for specific body
sizes. It emphasizes thinness, a notion that women fall for, consequently leading to eating
disorders to lose weight and attain the "perfectness" the media advocates. Surprisingly, men, too,
find themselves in this predicament, with some striving to be thin while the rest of them aiming
to gain weight.
Vartanian et al. (2001) report teasing resulting from the media due to specific body
shapes that raise identity concerns. With the media continually posing pictures and perceptions
of the ideal bodies, many people have fallen victims, with the posts affecting how they view
themselves. The only reported groups whose identity does not receive much attention are those
with high esteem and, therefore, not easily swayed by media's demands. A more recent study
associated with body image and media report abuse and poor representation of women by the
media. David &Warner (2019) report that the 'media' objectifies women through the adverts
where at least a half-nude woman appears to trade or advertise some products. Stereotyping
women as sex objects taints the value of women. Objectifying women interferes with their
identity so that their bodies get objectified instead of appreciating them for who they are as
individuals.
The media’s portrayal of race
The issue of race features among the most heated topics of all time. The minorities such
as the African Americans have always raised cries detailing their marginalization because of
their colour. Dukes & Gaither (2017) report that the media continuously portray these groups on
the opposing side. The media intentionally overrepresent the people of colour as criminals
compared to their white counterparts, inciting hostility from the public. The media’s actions in
Surname 4
presenting contradicting information about the identity associated with African-American
descent threatens the innocent who becomes victims due to media representation. Dukes &
Gaither (2017) further elaborate on the adverse effects the media plays, which results in the
dehumanization of the minorities [especially African Americans]. Even though the people of
colour get mistreated and killed faultlessly, the media partially chooses to focus on the issue such
as victims' criminal records, their body sizes, crime scene locations, and the victims' ways of life.
The irony of the media is that it blames all the atrocities done to the victims themselves. The
study, therefore, brings out the negative role the media plays on racial identities. One of them is
the stereotypic portrayal of blacks as lazy (Mastro, 2017), an aspect that affects their self-esteem.
Media's influence on identity through gender representation.
Gender is a social construct that differs from one CultureCulture to another. Due to
technology, the world has gained access to multiple gender perceptions, roles played, and their
positions in society as defined by the respective cultures. Parsons, Reichl & Pedersen (2017)
acknowledge the media's influence in determining gender, which at times proposes wrong
notions. The press, even in the past, has subsequently channelled information that perpetuated
stigmatization. Their content sidelines those perceived as unattractive and unsuitable for media
coverage through advertisements. The media's choice on what features and what does not
negatively affects people's perceptions. It prompts prejudice concerning gender and disability.
Parsons et al. (2017) cite invisibility as one of the consequences of biased media. Invisibility
causes stigmatization and isolation of people based on gender and disability. In doing this, the
press either masks their identity or adds mud to their identity, robbing these individuals of their
true selves.
Surname 5
Women are one of the unlucky groups that the media marginalizes. Society is still
adjusting to the fact that women are equally able beings, and like their male counterparts, they
can excel in several areas. However, since different cultures are yet to adapt to this fact, women
continue being at risk of marginalization. —unfortunately, a woman bearing any form of
disability experiences alienation/stigmatization more than those without disabilities. Especially
in societies that devalue women, the media in film and advertisement is likely to harm the
females due to corrupted perceptions it feeds to the public. Parsons et al. (2017) note that even
the male and female genders' population get misinterpreted. Parsons et al. (2017) similarly
critique women's media portrayal, which they believe gives women an unclear/distorted identity.
With the reinforcement of 'ideal' female bodies and the harsh criticism on disability, women with
a disability automatically get marginalized by the media, condemning them as powerless.
The media and sexuality
The concept of sexuality in the recent past has ignited debates without reaching a
consensus. The traditional society, unfortunately, only acknowledges heterosexuality. With the
rising cases of Lesbians, Gays, Bisexual, and Transgender activism, the media has chosen to
involve itself by allowing the publication of views, some of which distort the truth. The media's
proactivity in LGBTQ is straightforward since it showcases shows that unravel the mysteries of
these sexual orientations. The perfect example is the "I am Kate" show featuring Jenner, a
transgender person. But is the effort quite enough to explain the identities linked to these sexual
orientations?
In research, Bond (2015) notes the challenges the young adolescents battling sexual
orientation issues face. Due to stigmatization, youths who are either lesbians, gays, trans, or
bisexuals have always resorted to alternate sources of information such as social media for
Surname 6
answers. Bond (2015) also notes that the information sources these groups resort to have unclear
information defining their identities, thus placing them in a dilemma regarding what pertains to
having a different sexual orientation other than the heterosexual one advocated by society. Bond
writes that in portraying heterosexual content full time on the media, the gay community feels
marginalized for the lack of exposition to information involving them. The media's reclining on
one side poses threats to gays who get attacked by heterosexuals, for they see them as useless/
purposeless in society.
The challenge the LGBT groups face is the reluctance of mainstream producers in
generating content addressing their issues due to fear of offending the heterosexuals who
constitute the largest population of content consumers. Bond (2015) also reports the existence of
LGB depictions of stereotyped and devaluing content in the mainstream media, an aspect that
negatively influences LGB consumers. With all these at play, identity construction becomes a
complicated process, with the media playing a significant role in distortion.
The media in influencing mental health disorders
Mental health is critical. The majority of mental health sufferers experience a change in
their identity since society tends to alienate or stigmatize them due to their conditions. The
media's role in broadcasting information, on the other hand, is significant, and we cannot snub its
contribution in educating the public about current happenings. The media provides entertainment
programs for its consumers and news/documentaries for further knowledge on world issues.
Nevertheless, in assessing the content posted mostly in terms of news/ documentary, it becomes
evident that some content threatens individuals' mental health. Uvais (2020) pinpoints the
adverse effects of news on individuals' mental health by recounting the story of a woman who
Surname 7
followed the proceedings broadcasted on people affected by floods. The woman not only
developed phobia but also exhibited the post-traumatic stress disorder symptoms.
Healing of mental health disorders is challenging. Several interventions exist, yet they
only aid and not fully treat these disorders. Since complete recovery is not guaranteed, these
individuals' identity usually takes a shift, and without proper psychological and family support,
these individuals' lives get distorted. Even though censorships are involved in the content, the
media provides the public for consumptions; the levels still differ and may adversely cause a
permanent alteration in individuals' mental health, subsequently affecting their identity. Those
without support in trauma cases may end up with a distorted character that society frowns at,
leading to their marginalization.
Counter-argument: media plays a positive role in shaping the identity of
individuals.
Critiques acknowledge the positive contribution of media in enhancing identity. The
media, which is not limited to televisions and film alone, also recognizes the various identity
construction contributions due to social media. The majority of the world's people have sort
solace in Social Media, as Gündüz (2017) reports. One of the social media's benefits is that
people having doubts can quickly find answers by posting what plagues them. People contribute
variously by either agreeing, disagreeing or giving individual opinions, thus enhancing people's
perception of themselves. People fighting personality battles, sexuality stances, and esteem
issues also seek solace in social media. The mainstream media's inability to enhance personal
communications with people worldwide makes social media a vital platform for such business.
Gündüz (2017) also notes that social media is the platform that encourages very intense
interactions between individuals and the promotion of communication. What is even better is that
Surname 8
social media permits communication between users unknown to each other yet provides the
support they need. What is even more encouraging is the chance of seeing content shared.
Manago (2015) writes on the contributions social media has on identity. According to
Manago (2015), most social media users in this age are the youths who seek independence from
parents by recreating a new form of "self." To achieve this, most join social media to gather tips
on manoeuvring as they grow into young adults/grown-ups. Through countless social
interactions, youths create new connections, which allows them to set forth the kind of identity
they would want to get associated with everywhere. Manago's study shows the vital role social
media plays. With the anonymity that social media provides, most youths dare to express
themselves by airing views or commenting on posts they know and reading content written by
others. Therefore, how is the media influencing aspects such as identity, gender, and sexuality?
The study Manago ( 2015) showed that individuals' offline identity influences their
virtual identity and vice versa, an aspect that enhances these individuals' self-esteem. Gender
identities, on the other hand, endows the youths with the power to reconstruct and express their
views about sexuality and gender. Social media also plays a significant role in helping the
minority create and disseminate information about discrimination and the minority's rights. The
platform also permits addressing views and fears about ethnicity, and even allows individuals to
draw support from their social media “ families.” Social media's contribution to improving the
self-worth of individuals is significant. Individuals, through social media, have regained self-
worth and even set standards that negotiated their public identity. The above are some of the
arguments that support acclaim social media as a contributing factor to identity construction.
Conclusion
Surname 9
The media [inclusive of the mainstream media and social media alike] significantly shape
individuals' identities. The mainstream media, through television and film, broadcast content that
affects individuals. Some of the facets that media perpetuate include racial discrimination
through bias portrayal of the minority. The press also broadcasts content or adverts that are
gender-biased since they objectify women, therefore tainting women's true identity. On the same
note on gender, the media portrays women as weak, and for those who may have a disability, the
effects doubles, making them feel inferior. That is not all; the media continually comes up with
body image standards that alienate both men and women who may not reach the threshold.
Women and a few men have ended up with eating disorders with a bid to trim and fit in the
standards of beauty, a trend that robs people of their identity as they strive to adapt to other
people's identity.
The following are some of the arguments presented to assess the counter-arguments
supporting the media's involvement in identity construction. Sexual orientation is an issue that
the media tries to address. With the mainstream media avoiding the topic due to the domination
of heterosexual supporters, social media, on the other hand, explicitly addresses the sexual
orientation issues, allowing all groups, including the LGBT's contribution. The press also gives
those struggling to build different identities the chance to explore, evaluate opinions, and decide
what they find fit to adopt. One significant aspect that media contribute towards identity
construction is the self-worth which social media allows one to establish. Adolescents, too, find
solace in social media, which helps them create a new identity as they grow towards adulthood.
Surname 10
Works Cited
Bond, Bradley. “Portrayals of Sex and Sexuality in Gay-and Lesbian-Oriented Media: A
Quantitative Content Analysis.” Sexuality & Culture, vol. 19, no. 1, March. 2015, pp.37-
56. EBSCOhost, DOI:10.1007/s12119-014-9241-6
David, Sonia, and Uma Warner. "Media and Adolescent Body Image: A qualitative Meta-
Analysis." Indian Journal of Health & Well-being, vol. 10, no. 10-12, Oct.2019, pp.377-
381. EBSCOhost, search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?
direct=true&db=aph&AN=141146237&site=ehost-live
Davis, N, A. "Disaster-related Media Exposure and its Impacts on Mental Health." Journal of
Medicine & Primary Care, vol. 9, no.1, January 2020, pp.448-449. EBSCOhost,
DOI:104103/jfmpc_981_19
Dukes, Kristin Nicole, and Sarah, E. Gaither. "Black Racial Stereotypes and Victim Blaming:
Implications for Media Coverage and Criminal Proceedings in Cases of Police Violence
against Racial and Ethnic Minorities." Journal of Social Issues, vol. 73, no.4, Dec. 2017,
pp. 789-807, EBSCOhost, DOI:10.1111/josi.12248
Emerging Trends in the Social and Behavioral Sciences. Edited by Robert Scott and Stephan
Kosslyn. © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. ISBN 978-1-118-90077-2
Gündüz, Uğur. “The Effect of Social Media on Identity Construction.” Mediterranean Journal of
Social Sciences. Vol 8(5) September 2017 pp. 85-92. Doi: 10.1515/mjss-2017-0026
Hudson, Mike. “Why Is Helen Keller The Only Blind Person Anyone Knows?”Future
Reflections, vol.37, no. 3, Summer 2018, p. 50. EBSCOhost,
search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=mih&AN=131615613&site=ehost-
live.
Surname 11
Manago, Adriana. "Media and the Development of Identity." Emerging Trends in the Social and
Behavioral Sciences. Scott and Kosslyn (Editors). John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Retrieved on
October 10, 2020, from
https://cpb-us-e1.wpmucdn.com/sites.ucsc.edu/dist/5/491/files/2014/09/Media-and-the-
Development-of-Identity.pdf.
Mastro, Dana. “Race and Ethnicity in US Media Content and Effects.” Oxford Research
Encyclopedia of Communication. September 26, 2017. Oxford University Press.
Retrieved on October 16, 2020, from
https://oxfordre.com/communication/view/10.101093/acrefore/9780190228613.001.0001
/acrefore9780190228613-e-122
Parsons, Alexandria, Reichl, Arleigh & Pedersen, Cory. "Gendered Ableism: Media
Representation and Gender Role Beliefs' Effect on Perception of Disability and
Sexuality." Sexuality, vol. 35, no. 2, June 2017, pp. 207-225. EBSCOhost, DOI:
1007/s11195-016-9464-6
United Nations (n.d). “Disability and the media.” Department of Economic and Social Affairs,
United Nations. Retrieved on October 10, 2020, from
https://www.un.org/development/desa/disabilities/resources/disability-and-the-
media.html
Vartanian, Les Rae, Giant, Carrieet & Passino, Rhonda. "Mass Media, Interpersonal Feedback,
and Gender as Predictors of Body Satisfaction." Social Behavior & Personality Journal
vol.29, no. 7, Nov. 2001, pp. 711-723. EBSCOhost, DOI: 10.2224/sbp.2001.29.7.711
Students also viewed