1 / 7100%
In this assignment, you will critically review 2 recent peer-reviewed articles in a minimum of 2 pages.
You may wish to spend some time researching critical review techniques for journal articles prior to
starting this assignment. The paper must follow current APA guidelines. The page count does not
include the title page, abstract, reference section, or any extra material. See the grading rubric for
additional guidance. You must follow the article focus prompts closely. Microsoft Word is the only
acceptable upload format.
For each review, you will select and read one article. At a minimum, you must pay particular attention to
the identification of the premise and supporting points of the article, a synthesis of the article and the
corresponding material in the textbook or a synthesis of the article with your personal experience with
the topic, and a critical evaluation of the premise(s) and supporting points of the article.
Journal Article Review 2 must be on the topic of psychological theory(ies) of crime.
TRUTH, DECEPTION, AND THE SUSPECT 1
Truth, deception, and the suspect
By: (Name)
Course:
Professor:
Institutional Affiliation:
Date:
TRUTH, DECEPTION, AND THE SUSPECT 2
TRUTH, DECEPTION, AND THE SUSPECT
Abstract
The role of criminal justice is to deliver justice to individuals who have perpetrated a
criminal act. The criminal justice system involves governmental agencies and institutions that
offer rehabilitation services to the offenders, deter crimes from recurring, and support the victims
morally. The unveiling of truth is an essential aspect of the criminal justice system since it helps
to identify guilty individuals to face punishment. Without an elaborate method of ascertaining
the truth, the suspects may use deception as a model to dupe the investigatory teams who may
end up punishing innocent civilians. Thus, this is a journal review on truth, deception, suspect,
and the psychological theories of crime.
Detection of deception journal
The abilities of the investigatory teams in detecting crimes is dependent on chances
rather than accuracy. When investigating criminal acts, it is essential to design an accurate model
of detecting deception to assist the police officers and detectives in knowing the culpable
individuals without detaining innocent persons. The police's traditional practices in conducting
investigations emanated from earlier schools of thought on lying that guaranteed liars to exhibit
street-based fears of being arrested (Zimmerman, 2016). Thus, researchers were propelled to
come up with an accurate behavioral indicator of detecting deception. In the recent past,
psychologists have shifted their focus to developing proactive strategies that interviewers can use
to establish signs of deception from the interviewees. The new models of determining truth in the
criminal justice system has the potential of revolutionizing law enforcement.
TRUTH, DECEPTION, AND THE SUSPECT 3
Most often, liars are in a state of dilemma since they create a story to account for the
time when a criminal activity took place; however, their stories are guesswork that do not
ascertain the kind of evidence the investigators are looking for. In this model, the suspect is
permitted to talk while the interviewer gradually discloses the evidence (Zimmerman, 2016). The
approach of unveiling evidence of criminal acts to the suspect enhances the detectives' capacity
to detect crimes. For an example, a research carried out by Hartwig and colleagues proved that
keeping a piece of evidence until late in an interview, gives space for guilty suspects to lie. When
the investigator reveals the evidence affirming that the suspect was in the scene of the crime
through CCTV footage, among other mechanisms, the suspect will have to fumble by creating
another lie or surrender by telling the truth. In some instances, suspects may accept being within
the said premises when the crime occurred but deny his or her involvement in such activities. In
case the interviewer has more evidence such as similar fingerprints from the crime scene, the liar
will be caged from lying due to the presented proof.
The strategies are aimed at ridding the suspects of the created fictions to protect
themselves from guilt. It is proved that liars have the potential of disclosing more evidence when
narrating their stories as they tend to create a convincing narrative to get them off the hook
(Zimmerman, 2016). If the interview grows complex, the avenues that the suspect can use to
deceive the authorities are blocked. The detectives have also increased the suspects' cognitive
abilities by demanding that they narrate the incidences from the last to the first; truth-tellers are
capable of recalling the events as they transpired without much struggle. Liars will struggle to
remember the incidents, make several errors, and become hesitant in the process.
TRUTH, DECEPTION, AND THE SUSPECT 4
Psychological theories of crime journal
These theories show that criminal behavior arises from differences in individuals’
thought processes. The theories generalize that thoughts and feelings of a person have the
potential of triggering their actions. A vital focus in criminology is to study crimes and why
members of a society indulge in criminal activities (Pointpark, 2018). The social and
psychological theories of crime are the commonly used perspectives on how criminal activities
develop. Psychological theories have been essential in shaping how society perceives crime and
delinquency, thus, adopting policies to curb such cases. These theories are embedded in
individual factors such as poor socialization and adverse early childhood experience, which may
lead to criminal thinking patterns.
The theory on behavior suggests that behavior is acquired through learning as people
advance from one level to the other; this school of thought is also known as a social theory of
knowledge and emphasizes that individual actions by far are a product of one encounter in life. A
significant assertion of this school of thought is conditioning, which is a learning style
incorporating stimuli and reward mechanisms (Pointpark, 2018). Individual actions reinforced
through conditioning, are regarded as a learned attribute of a person’s life. The environment also
plays a significant role in shaping and teaching behavioral values and attribute in a person. It is
believed that criminal behavior is typical in cultural conflicts where association with criminals
accelerates such acts. The differential association theory was broadened to incorporate how
differentiated reinforcement of deviant behavior can explain behavior. Learning theory is
empirically verified for the successful application of its principles to modify behavior in
understanding crime and delinquency.
TRUTH, DECEPTION, AND THE SUSPECT 5
The psychoanalytic theory of crime is derived from Sigmund’s argument that three
pivotal forces are responsible for shaping the personality traits of a person. These are the id
representing intellectual needs, ego implying understood social norms, and superego representing
acquired “moral reasoning” (Pointpark, 2018). Delinquent behavior arises from an imbalance
between the three aspects of an individual’s life; “id, ego, and the superego.” The disputes
between these three components compels a person to develop differentiated approaches to adapt
to the conflicts within the self. This can result in criminal tendencies, and a person's delinquency
can be seen as an identity crisis emanating from the inner turmoil. Despite its contributions,
critiques have challenged the theory citing that its premises cannot be verified empirically.
Recommendation
The journals are elaborately articulated to convey some crucial information in the field
of criminal justice. The first article is comprehensive and applies various mechanisms to
establish the truth from criminal acts so that only the responsible persons are subjected to
punishment, and applicable correctional facilities. Quest for justice is a grievance within most
societies in this age, and the responsible teams must advance their investigatory models to
disclose the truth and serve justice. The Bible records in (John 8;32) that you shall know the
truth, and the truth shall set you free; people are encouraged to speak the truth because it is a
relief to the soul, body, and mind, and it enhances harmonious coexistence in societies.
Conducting investigation based on in-depth and underlying issues provides a comprehensive
mechanism of understanding crime and criminal tendencies from the roots. Thus, it can also
serve as an elaborate mechanism of helping the victims to delink themselves from deviant
behavior as underlying issues are known.
TRUTH, DECEPTION, AND THE SUSPECT 6
References
Pointpark (2018). A primer to psychological theories of crime
https://online.pointpark.edu/criminal-justice/psychological-theories-of-crime/
John 8;32, (n.d). The truth shall set you free
Zimmerman, L. (2016). Deception detection
https://www.apa.org/monitor/2016/03/deception
Students also viewed