THE POLITICAL ECONOMY OF NATURAL RESOURCE EXTRACTION AND ITS IMPLICATIONS FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT

| 1 P a g e

THE POLITICAL ECONOMY OF NATURAL RESOURCE

EXTRACTION AND ITS IMPLICATIONS FOR

SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT

1.0 Introduction

Natural resource output is a key economic driver in the world and supply a huge share of

required markets with raw material which fuel many industries, thereby increasing national

incomes. On the other hand, the complex problems related to both governance and economic

management as well as sustainability emerge largely from the use of the natural resources.

1.0.1 Importance of natural resources in the global economy.

As such, several forms of natural resources are both basic for economic development and

industrialization which include minerals, fossil fuels and timber. Industrial sectors directly come

to this resource as a raw material or fuel, as well as the manufacturing of energy and industrial

instruments. One major sectors that produce a major portion of the global GDP is the oil and gas

sector with Saudi Arabia, Russia, and US as the most noteworthy dependent on these resources

for the economic growth. Moreover, metals such as copper, lithium and rare earth metals as a

result of which the sector is evolved further eventuating in trends in electronics, renewable

energy and electrical vehicles (Humphreys, 2018). This may be due to a rapid growth fueled by

selling resources, which usually results in extra income and an opportunity to invest it in the

development of livelihoods for the local population. Yet, this dependence equally vests us with

threats, maneuvering our system of economies under praise commodity price fluxes and possibly

economic distortions, which is famously known as the "resource curse" (Wackenhut and Liesel,

2001).

1.0.2 Overview of the political economy framework.

Therefore political economy framework is able to shed the light on complex interactions between

politics, economics and society, when it comes to the natural resource extraction. It is based on

the principle that countries that are rich in natural resources and those countries that are also

highly dependent and frequently impacted by political institutions, economic policies and social

constructions. In the context of the "resource curse" theory, the central idea underpinning the

said framework includes the notion that countries possessing vast deposits of natural resources

are in most instances either economically stagnant or characterised by weak political governance

and social conflicts that are far worse than those in countries with few or no national resources.

This paradox complexes because monetary resources may encourage rent-seeking habits,

corruption, as well as the backwardness of other sectors of the economy (Ross, 2001)Political

economy paradigm entails external factors like multinational corporations and international

financial institutions which cog to domestic polices as well as practices in the resource rich

nations. The action of these extrinsic actors may worsen the local gender disadvantages, and

| 2 P a g e

cause the mismanagement of natural resource renewal (Frynas & Paulo, 2007). The appropriate

governance may minimize abated effects of resource curse via precision, accountability, and

redistribution implementations in terms of resource income. On the other hand, poor governance

can result in the accumulation of wealth and power in hands of the few, and the degradation of

the environment and societal discontent.

1.0.3 The necessity of sustainable development.

Sustainable development comes to fore as the only option in the context of natural resource

extraction, because it involves impact assessment and goal achievement which must not

jeopardize the society‟s capacity to meet the needs of new generations. Such model employs

ways of balancing production and conservation in an effort to save the surrounding for long-term

safety of the community (Brundtland, 1987). Excessive exploitations of resources mostly result

in deterioration of the environment including trees cutting, water pollution, and loss of biological

diversity which in the end can jeopardize the ecosystem services which are crucial for sustaining

the life and health of the people (Daly & Farley, 2004). Sustainable development when resources

are used in a manner that is in accord with sustenance efforts, which encourage the pursuing of

sustainable practices for resource renewability and ecosystem integrity. Within the context of

sustainable development of political economy, equity in benefits acquired from natural resources

is also the focal point. It campaigns for equal growth which cuts the levels of poverty and

inequality across the globe and also empowers those that are often disadvantaged and cannot be

able to compete with the outsiders due to different tools and mechanisms thus the resource

extraction activities (Sachs, 2015). With the involvement of community participation in other

words, people will be able to enjoy the benefits of resources revenues and consequently,

sustainable development will promote the building of social cohesion and political stability.

Sustainable development, as a matter of fact, gives more weight to the deployment of greener

technologies and renewable energy resources, which in turn have the effect that the ecological

footprint of natural resources diminishes. This transition is therefore a key factor in reducing

GHG emissions as the impacts of climate change often affect the most vulnerable communities

that are usually the developing nations (IPCC, 2014).

1.2Research Questions

1.2.1 How does the political economy shape natural resource extraction?

Political economy greatly determines the production processes of natural resources affecting

ownership of resources, stewardship going over their management and the distribution of the

recovered benefits. Regimes where there is rule of law and uncorrupted governing tend to utilize

the resources well, and they enable other population members through the derived fruits

(Mehlum, Moene & Torvik, 2006). On the contrary a weak institution is known to be linked to

rent-seeking activities, corruption, and inefficient resource management. Economic policies,

such as taxation and investment incentives, are also designed in a manner that defines level of

returns from mining activities. These help to determine the level of foreign investor involvement

| 3 P a g e

in the national economy (Ross, 2001). Social aspects, like surrounding community engagement

and sharing economic benefits are the additional elements that lead to the fairness and the

sustainability of natural resource extraction (Frynas & Paulo, 2007).

1.2.2 What are the Implications of natural resource extraction on sustainable

development?

Regarding economic growth, resources extraction could become efficient and anyway useful if it

is well-managed, causing large revenues to be invested in social infrastructure, education and

health (Sacsk, 2015). Nonetheless, the resource curse is a phenomenon where these countries

rather than experiencing economic growth and equality end up slow growth and increased

inequality due to their poor governance and management. The environmental impact of

extraction is devastating, deforestration, water pollution, and biodiversity loss are the largest

components of this impact and with it, long-term ecological balance can be negatively affected

and the dire need of ecosystems, which support livelihoods, is not taken care of (Daly & Farley,

2004). In a society, the advantages of resource extraction are usually given to only some sections

of people that make poverty and social conflicts even more profound, especially in regions where

such communities are not considered while implementing decision on distribution of economic

gain (IPCC, 2014).

1.3 Objectives of the Study

The key, purpose is to assess critically the political and economic determinants which influence

mining of natural resources. Here will be the dependence of governance structures, same with

institutional quality as well as economic policies on extraction methods. Political stability,

regulatory frameworks and the level of corruption will be studied for gauging the efficiency and

equity in natural resource management. (Mehlum, Moene & Torvik, 2006). Let us also look at

the role and influence of economic incentives like taxation systems or government aid on the

development of domestic skills and foreign investments in the extraction of minerals (Ross,

2001).

Sustainability implications of the extraction modes used today as well as their evaluation will

also be among the area of our research interest. Having in mind the community activities of

extraction, evaluation of the environmental implications being covered such as land degradation,

water usage, and pollution levels (Daly & Farley, 2004). The study will also provide more details

regarding the socio-economic effects. Research focuses on bringing truth to light about the

harmful effects of unsustainable practices and pinpointing their consequences and areas where

eco-friendly measures should be introduced based on concepts of environmental and sustainable

development principles (IPCC, 2014).

As the last aim, the revising of the policy which is able to balance between natural resource

extraction and sustainable development goals is stood. These recommendations are aimed at

making governance and institutions accountable in the distribution of incomes and benefits. The

| 4 P a g e

research will also reveal mitigation measures on the table like cleaner technologies and imposing

stern environmental regulations. It will also highlight the advantage of a community tracking

mechanism and benefits sharing to make sure local people are an active participant and properly

compensated if they find themselves in a production process.

2.0 Literature Review

2.1 Theoretical Framework

2.1.1 Overview of political economy theories relevant to natural resource

extraction.

Political economy thesis focuses on natural resource policy and how resource-rich nations as

major deciding institutional, economic and management factors of production of the outcomes.

"Resource curse"- the foundational theory of this area of study by Sir P. Collier (2007) states that

the paradoxical phenomenon of low economic growth and mismanaging of economic strategic

state resources in countries endowed with vast natural resources instead of showing better

economic growth is observed. Therefore, these contradictions appear as a consequence of two

processes of wealth which include rent-seeking behaviors. Under rent-seeking, the groups or

individuals take advantage of the political domain in a bid to claim total control over certain

economies. Corruption and rent-seeking are intertwined: there is a common perception that those

with a dominant position in the allocation of resource wealth will automatically develop the

ability to control these resources, and thus, eroding the quality of institutional setting and

governance structures. Another important phenomenon associated with resource-rich countries is

"rent-seeking," the case where some actors, like business or political elitists, lobby the

government for privileged access to country's natural resources revenues. Such a state of affairs

exerts huge pressure on the budget which is otherwise to be directed towards more productive

investment areas. Rent-seeking discordingly twists the economy priorities and policies which

most times results in the ineffective allocation of elements of production. When a sector of an

economy gets a big part of its resources disposed of mainly on political influence rather than

economic performance and efficiency it inevitably leads to stagnation and the productivity

decreasing (Krueger, 1974). Similarly, the rent-seeking activities can lead to reinstatement of the

existing power structures and inequalities already present. As elites are able to accumulate more

control and power over the resource revenue, mostly, they can exploit the situation and make

policies benefiting their personal reinforcement. This, as a result, provides an opportunity for a

vicious cycle where the economic and political power becomes more narrow headed with the

broad population not benefiting from the country's wealth of the natural resources just as

outlined.

The theories place an accent on that fact how institutions may become weaker when the

resources are in plenty. Weak fiscal scenery may be the result of resource-rich nations with

income from the resources as a major source of public revenue, making the need for a broad tax

| 5 P a g e

base less important and the development of an effective, accountable public sector weaker.

Governments which depend on a „singular‟ source of revenue like resource revenues may

overlook the other economic sectors and reduce the incentives for the economic diversification

or innovation. What is more, swings in price of non-renewable resources contribute to economic

instability primarily because of the business-boom and bust process that can interfere long-term

economic stability and viable strategies (Sachs and Warner, 2001). "Resource curse" has

explained this paradox due to the rent-seeking behaviors and institutional weakness that often

follow the increase in revenue from the abundant resource endowment. "Rent-seeking" to the

next stage of knowledge which depicts the processes by which political and economic power

concentrate in to the hands of some few groups and this results into misallocation of resources

and prolonged economic stagnation.

2.1.2 Concepts of rent-seeking, resource curse, and Dutch disease.

Rent-seeking behavior arises when one parties or groups of individuals try to get benefits from

the economic and political context without putting in any productive efforts. Behavior like this is

dominating in resource-rich countries in which economic activities come down in the group of

resource rents and corruption appears as inefficient (Tollison, 1982). Instead of using the funds

in productiveness sectors and innovative ideas, these people or political groups attempt to stop

the increasing of wealth by occupying it, which hinders the growth of the economies and

promotes corruption and maladministration. The theory of the "resource curse" conceptualizes

resource wealth as the cause for a certain set of detrimental outcomes including economic

instability, bad governance and conflict. Resource revenues bring about such situation by

creating unreliability in governments' institutions and reducing their eagerness of building

diversified economic policies that can be used to substitute resource revenues (Sachs & Warner,

2001). The resource-rich countries usually fall on the revenues from resources and the political

leaders may remember this fact, and as the people who wouldn‟t have to pay taxes for the

government it it is highly likely to see an increase in corruption and a decrease in accountability.

It can lead to the instability of the economy and interrupt the process of planning though it

connects with the fluctuation of the prices of the natural resources that contributes to the pyramid

of riches which is the efficient variable in the economic cycle.

"Dutch disease" is a situation where an economy develops a certain resource that results to an

increase in value of that country's currency which in turn makes other sectors like agriculture and

manufacturing uncompetitive internationally. The higher appreciation decreases costs of exports

but makes imports more affordable so that the industries exporting lose market shares to

countries with lower currency values (Corden & Neary, 1982). Consequently, the economy is

becoming the sector‟s major source of revenue as it creates dependency on the price of

commodities, thus, stability to the sector's development is challenged. Resource-based

economies are likely to experience a decline in manufacturing and farmland, resulting in job cuts

and less diversification of the economy which would deepen their dependence on extracting

these resources.

| 6 P a g e

Coherently, rent seeking, resource curse, and Dutch disease are interlaced concepts that

background the trials for the resource-rich countries. Rent-seeking behavior can be costly as it

can takes away productive resources. Natural resource curse hinders stability in the institutions

and that leads to the lack of the rule of law and uneconomic fluctuations. Dichotomy of riches

(Dutch disease) is a phenomenon that outlines the main macroeconomic consequences of the

resource boom, for example, currency appreciation and reverse of other economic sectors'

performance.

2.2 Empirical Studies

2.2.1 Case studies of natural resource extraction in different regions.

Evidence-based research of the natural resource extraction frequently holds regional or in-

between case studies to demonstrate the contrasting impact of being resource are rich. At the

same time, in Nigeria, oil income brought about key economic growth, and corrupted official

circles, however, led to rampant corruption and devastation of the environment, and such

evidence shows the resource curse. What is interesting contrary to that, Norway is able to

address perfectly its governing and institutional capabilities stemming from the oil resource

presence, safe from any of the stumbling blocks inherent to resource richness. The manner of oil

exploitation developed by Norway has seen the beginning of the Government Pension Fund

Global, in which oil revenues are invested abroad to avert the danger of economical overheating

and to provide long-term financial stability. As seen in the case of the country with transparent

and accountable management of oil incomes and economic decision-making targeted at

sustainable development and economic diversification, oil can become a real contributor to the

overall prosperity of the state. Over the years Norway has maintained it high standards of income

and also very strong social welfare systems thanks to avoiding the risk of the Resource Curse

(Larsen, 2005).This experience-based approach reveals that the result of the exploitation of

natural resources are to a large extent defined by the non-economic political and institutional

environment in the advanced economies within which resource wealth is managed. The difficulty

of Nigeria was shown as corruption, social conflict and environment deterioration complication

by resource wealth is an amplification of the dangerous of poor institutions and governments

positions. However, the Norwegian way of exploiting resource wealth to contribute to

development has been acknowledging that institutions have to be strong, precisely how the

management should be transparent so, once a policy is enacted, all the people in the society must

benefit as a whole from it.

Besides, this is the illustration of rule of law or other guiding principles and governance the key

most criteria that can mitigate wealth from natural resources. Effective institutional settings,

featuring procedures such as transparency, accountability, and inclusiveness, can help alleviate

the symptoms of the resource curse by maintaining the fact that revenues from the resources are

spent in ways that develop the country from short to the long-term and ensure people's good

condition. In such cases, poor leadership and institutions foster policies that favor the wrong

| 7 P a g e

areas, higher levels of corruption, and civil war - an obstacle to sustainable development. The

essence of what has been discussed is that data-driven and not unilateral empirical studies of

natural resource extraction in different regions conclude that the impacts of resource wealth are

not homogenous and are dependent on the unique politico-institutional contexts of each place.

The National and Norweigian adventures exemplify the most immediate factor, namely the

quality of governance and institutions that either turns the natural resource bounty into a boon or

a curse.

2.2.2 Comparative analysis of resource-rich and resource-poor countries.

Interocamparive studies between sourceples rich and sourceples poor nations are very important

because they bring to light the connection between resource endowment and economic and social

development. Studies show that abundant resource economies eventually grow their economies

at a low speed and experience higher levels of income. Such a susceptibility to the resource

curse, marked by a seemingly paradoxical situation where having access to large amounts of

natural resources undermines economic prosperity and social development, brings to the fore that

in regards to many of the countries which depend on natural resources, the relationship between

what they have and what they can achieve is more peculiar than it seems (Gylfason, 2001). In

countries that have resource-rich endowments, the inflow of resource rents could bring about

problems of macroeconomic distortion as well as governance issues. High rents of resources can

be a great cause for rent-seeking activities whereby individuals and groups through political

system attempt to secure such rents, and in the end corruption and inefficiency in resource

allocation are on the top issue. These diversion of resource from productive investing to the

wasteful rent-seeking activity is a limitation to the form of new investments, innovation

emergence and financial economic growth. Also, in the case where the economy almost solely

relies on exports income, this can in turn lead to a currency appreciation which in turn makes

other sectors less competitive in the international markets. This is a phenomenon which is often

called as “Dutch disease”. While certain developing countries had shown that the' curse'

accompanies mineral wealth is, by way of example, a perfect illustration, some nations have

been able to avoid peer pressure. These nations have showcased the world that if they use good

governance and sound economic policies then it can be done to leverage natural wealth so that it

will be used for sustainable development and be a support for economic diversification. Thus, for

Botswana a smooth handling of diamond revenues was achieved by using viable fiscal policy,

building up equally good institutions and making proper investment in infrastructural and the

human society sectors. Whilst this has fortified botswana's economic development and brought

significant improvement in standard of living by the Denizens (Acemoglu, Johnson, & Robinson,

2003).

Chile also has done such things by means of the rules that are targeted at the maintenance of the

economic stability and diversification. Setting up sovereign fund investors as well as the

enactment of the counter-cyclical fiscal practices are the main tools that Chile uses to deal with

resource prices volatility. investment in education and infrastructure have also supported further

| 8 P a g e

economic development for other sectors that are not tied in to the resource sector. Accordingly,

poverty and inequality have had a baggage of development of Chile‟s economy at the end, and it

has sustained growth rates that are high (Acemoglu, Johnson, & Robinson, 2003). Although

resource-abundant countries frequently fall short on one hand, through slower economic growth

and higher corruption levels, we can draw lessons from the cases of Botswana and Chile to the

effect that wise management and well-thought economic policy formulation can balance the

negative impact of resources and transform them into a driver of sustainable development.

Institution of rule of law led by transparency,good governance and inclusive economic

management are the best feeders in ensuring that resource revenues are utilised for the poor

people. However, the results of such economic diversification depend mostly on the root of

governance and the government‟s economic policies. Weakness of institutions and lack of

rational economic strategies are the reasons why countries are mostly hit by resource curse effect

and developing them and making the process of butchering out long-term, sustainable

development becomes more hard for them.

2.3 Sustainable Development

2.3.1 Definition and principles of sustainable development.

Economy growth that is integrated into the sustainable development model basically aims to

create wealth and enhance the standard of living for the society in a manner that attempts to

reach and benefit all people and sections of the society. These involves improving innovation,

competitiveness, and ensuring that the economic activities are those with high-quality jobs while

still guaranteeing the stability of the economy. Sustainable economic policies distribute short-

term goals that favor long-term results and investment in education, infrastructure, technology

that increase the economy stability. Environmental protection is the second pillar and it is critical

that we continue to support the primordial systems needed for life and human activities. It

involves conservation of biodiversity, management of natural resources responsibly, and the

decrease in pollution and wastes. The sustainable development, which is good, supports the use

of renewable energy sources, clean manufacturing methods and activities which reduce

environmental impacts. Social equity, the third leg of the stool, may also deal with equality and

inclusion. It sets a goal to narrow in the wealth, opportunities and the necessary services or

facilities like healthcare, education, and clean water ginks. Social equity in sustainable

development requires that the entire population and all other communities have access to

opportunities and benefits brought by economic growth.

The approaches of sustainable developments urge combining those three elements in one

strategy, making it balanced and comprehensive. This integration markets the concepts and

methods of development that will not give up one dimension for the other conceding them

instead to the processes that supply benefits to the economy, environment, and society. The

overall purpose of sustainable development is achieved through the building of a long term

| 9 P a g e

resilience and prosperity whereby both present and future generations are secured to live in

harmony.

2.3.2 The role of natural resources in sustainable development frameworks.

Given the whole composition of sustainable development, the role of natural resources should

not be overlooked as they are the base of all economic needs. On the one hand, it is of vital

importance to discover and use these resources on an environmentally cautious basis so that its

negative impacts on the environment can be minimized and the benefits can be shared in an

equitable way with all parts of society. Sustainable management of natural resources, this means

adopting methods and techniques that greatly lessen the environmental footprint of an operation.

This comprises of development and use of state-of-the art-technologies which f with pollution,

water conservation, and greenhouse gas emissions. Instead, there exist ecological and sustainable

forestry practices that work hand in hand with tree harvesting accompanied with reforestation in

order to maintain an ecological balance relative to biodiversity. Furthermore, mining

conscientiously strives to limit landscape intervention which is aided by better ways of managing

waste discharges and rejuvenating lands.

Advocating for the employment of renewable resources is yet another element that is critical for

sustainable development also. From the use of fossil fuels to invest more on renewable power

sources like the solar, wind, and water power, dependence on the depleting resources and the

climate change effects are mitigated. The issue is also the fact that renewable resources are

depleted more slowly, therefore it is more sustainable for long term use as well as produces less

negative effects on the environment. This is in comparison with the non renewable resources that

are depleted quickly and have a big negative footprint on the environment. The „what‟ is also as

important as make sure that the extraction-based activities have many positive impacts to the

social and economic development. This refers to developing structures where locals in resource-

rich regions stand to gain directly from the extraction activities through job creation,

infrastructure growth and considerable improvement in their living conditions. In making up

policies, it is important to account for the quality of redistribution in which income and resources

are fairly shared among people and services provided to the public are adequate leading to

inclusive growth. Proper government and strong governance mechanism are the prerequisites to

making sound management of natural resources.

2.3.3 Existing models and critiques of sustainability in the context of resource

extraction.

Presently the environmental modeling in the area of "weak" and "strong" sustainability has only

been based on the self-sufficiency concepts. Those models are the sources of parameters which

acknowledge that nature is kept in the state where biodiversity and society can both turn benefits.

The “weak” sustainability paradigm asserts that while there are some differences between these

two types of capital, their value is largely interchangeable. As clarified in this view, even if the

| 10 P a g e

total capital stock (the natural plus the artificial or the human-made) growth is constant or could

be able to increase, sustainability is still qualified. On the on hand, the supporters defend the idea

that the consequences of the exhaustion of the natural resources could be offset by technological

innovations and by inventive people. E. g. , if a forest is demolished, the new planting activities

in another area as well as investments in the other forms of capital (such as infrastructure or

education) can prevent the decrease of the area (Neumayer, 2013). It may imply the concept of

exchangeability between natural capital and human-made capital for the sake of growth in the

given economy as well as the technological advancement of industries it the resource depletion

problem.

The "strong" sustainability doctrine contends that a particular natural asset needs to be

maintained, as it cannot be replaced by other resources. This point of view strives to stress the

inborn value of natural stock and the life supporting services they offer which is crucial for

maintaining the life support systems. Vigorous sustainability proponents claim that particular

natural assets, for example biodiversity, clean air, and water, cannot be duplicated by anything,

need to be given full protection. A nature-based focused method usually requires more stringent

environmental regulations and conservation policies to keep the reclamation of ecological

integrity intact (Neumayer, 2013).

Since sustainability models of today are widely considered ineffective in addressing the issues of

complexities and power imbalances that are inherent to resource extraction, mainly in poor

states. They argue that every sustainability models, whether weak or strong one, condensed fall

short, as they underestimate the unique political and social contexts that play the decisive role in

the resources management. On the other hand, the weak sustainability disregards the planetary

limits that human activities impose on the ecosystems and the social consequences of resource

utilization which depend on who can use them and who cannot. The practicality of strong

sustainability, which embraces preservation, might however, not give the desirable attention to

the socio-economy needs of the locals who may be desirous of development. As we move

towards more universal solution of sustainability which sees the social and political issues of

resource extraction, there is a call for society to be more inclusive and for context-specific

solutions. In a nutshell, is realizing the local communities‟ rights and roles in natural resources

management and ensuring they join the decision-making process. In order to ensure that

sustainable development keeps environmental elements in mind along with human welfare,

inclusive sustainability approaches emphasize a complete perspective on resource extraction that

links environmental health to human prosperity. This will entail adopting laws that fit locality

conditions, promotes culture and venues equity. Such as, community-based resource

management participatory models which put in local communities as key stakeholders in

stewarding the natural resources and which have proven to be more effective in meeting

conservation both with local development objectives. States within these models breakdown the

decision-making process and embrace local knowledge, ensuring that the benefits from resource

extraction are shared fairly which in turn strengthens the social and economic resilience. It is

| 11 P a g e

vital to give the power relations special attention when it comes down to the issues of formation

of the policies for effective extraction of the resources.

The matter of growing economy in developing countries is closely related to poor governance,

corruption and the fact that multinational corporations have the power to exploit local resources.

Proper sustainability strategizes will involve strengthening of the institutional base by advocating

transparency in the design and monitoring as well as accountability. Cooperating on an

international level and having free trade support for the developing countries, too, prove to be

vital for successful management of the existing natural resources.Since sustainability models of

today are widely considered ineffective in addressing the issues of complexities and power

imbalances that are inherent to resource extraction, mainly in poor states. They argue that every

sustainability models, whether weak or strong one, condensed fall short, as they underestimate

the unique political and social contexts that play the decisive role in the resources management.

On the other hand, the weak sustainability disregards the planetary limits that human activities

impose on the ecosystems and the social consequences of resource utilization which depend on

who can use them and who cannot. The practicality of strong sustainability, which embraces

preservation, might however, not give the desirable attention to the socio-economy needs of the

locals who may be desirous of development. As we move towards more universal solution of

sustainability which sees the social and political issues of resource extraction, there is a call for

society to be more inclusive and for context-specific solutions. In a nutshell, is realizing the local

communities‟ rights and roles in natural resources management and ensuring they join the

decision-making process. In order to ensure that sustainable development keeps environmental

elements in mind along with human welfare, inclusive sustainability approaches emphasize a

complete perspective on resource extraction that links environmental health to human prosperity.

This will entail adopting laws that fit locality conditions, promotes culture and venues equity.

Such as, community-based resource management participatory models which put in local

communities as key stakeholders in stewarding the natural resources and which have proven to

be more effective in meeting conservation both with local development objectives. States within

these models breakdown the decision-making process and embrace local knowledge, ensuring

that the benefits from resource extraction are shared fairly. It is vital to give the power relations

special attention when it comes down to the issues of formation of the policies for effective

extraction of the resources. The matter of growing economy in developing countries is closely

related to poor governance, corruption and the fact that multinational corporations have the

power to exploit local resources. Proper sustainability strategizes will involve strengthening of

the institutional base by advocating transparency in the design and monitoring as well as

accountability. Cooperating on an international level and having free trade support for the

developing countries, too, prove to be vital for successful management of the existing natural

resources.

| 12 P a g e

3.0 Methodology

3.1 Research Design

3.1.1 Qualitative vs. quantitative approaches.

In the research design in natural resource extraction as regard to its impacts on sustainable

development in political economy, the choice must be between qualitative or quantitative

approach is major. In this regard, qualitative methods that are expressed in natural language by

collecting descriptions and opinions are put into comparison with quantitative approaches that

use statistical tools and numerical data to determine patterns, correlations, and causality. The

interviews with the policymakers, professionals of industry and representatives of the community

can be used as sources of information comprising various stakeholders' interests and views. The

attention to detail concerning cultures, historical narratives, environmental patterns and societal

norms is one of the shortcomings of quantitative methods and qualitative approaches are directed

to addressing those issues.

Quantitative approaches are different, and help us to be more subject to detailed analysis and

generalization. Stats like econometrics, in combination, are presented as tools, which allow for a

solid gaining of empirical evidence and could revoke a recommendation for action or a policy

intervention based on the findings.

3.1.2 Justification for chosen methodology.

For this research, however, a mixed -method approach that combines of qualitative and

quantitative methods is a more funded study. Two types of approaches will be questioned in this

process: first will be the qualitative ones that aim to find the precise opinion and experiences of

the various groups of stakeholders involved in natural resources extraction and sustainable

development. This shall not take away the significance of case study as a direct complement to

these procedures as it provides an empirical base for the necessary variables for sustainable

outcomes. Shortfall of the qualitative data will be maximized by triangulation with the

quantitative data that will yield comprehensive and robust conclusions that can inform policy-

making and practice. Such integration of qualitative and quantitative approaches is the most

appropriate approach to deal with the research questions that are complex and multi-faceted in

nature(within which it includes political, economic, social and environmental spans).

3.2 Data Collection

3.2.1 Primary data: Interviews with policymakers, industry experts, and

community leaders.

This primary data gathering by means of the interview of persons who are most likely to have the

required knowledge will be of great help for us to know the political economy of natural resource

extraction and its impact on sustainable development. Interview stuff will be prepared with

policymakers, industry specialists, and community leaders involved in any resource extraction

| 13 P a g e

activity or whose community is a recipient of the impacts. Experienced industry executive,

consulting firms, along with organizations with special focus on operational, technical and

economic issues are equipped with connecting information and ideas that are of great importance

on resource extraction. Discussions with the industry professionals will include knowledge of the

industry trends overview of investor plans, technology development, and the strategic

approaches of the corporations for the determination of the unearthing practices and the

sustainability nuances. The community leaders are the vocal point and the spokes tribes or

villages facing the resource extraction activities. Interviews with the community leaders

representing the grassroots voice will be an important input for the bottom-up perspective

creating space for people whose voices are not always heard in decision making processes.

3.2.2 Secondary data: Analysis of reports, academic articles, and government

publications.

Although primary data collection will be the main source of information, I will also use the

reports, articles, and government published document to fill the gaps and give the findings a

context. Secondary data analysis will have two main components including a review of existing

literature, empirical studies, policy documents, and statistical databases regarding the political

economy of extractive industry and sustainable development. Assessment of government

information will supply for the region specific data on resource reserves, production volumes,

export receipts, environmental restrictions, social indicators and so on, which will greatly

facilitate comparative analysis and policy benchmarking. Utilizing the primary and the secondary

data sources simultaneously, an endeavor is undertaken to produce holistic analysis on the

political economy of natural resource extraction and its resultant impacts on the sustainable

development. Integrating of qualitative interviews with the stakeholders key players and

quantitative analysis of secondary data will increase the validity, reliability and robustness of the

findings consequently contributing to the evidence based policy making and practice.

3.3 Analytical Framework

3.3.1 Methods for analyzing political and economic factors.

Political Economy Analysis (PEA): PEA analyzes the concentration of power, motivations, and

incentives among the players in the mining sector which can include the government,

multinational corporations, the local population, and civil society groups. Therewith the cause of

rent-seeking behavior, patronage networks, and elite capture will be clarified.

Institutional Analysis: Institutional analysis is dominated by the formal and informal rules,

customs, and organizations that govern the extraction and use of resources. With the help of

Institutional Analysis to assess design and implementation of institutional arrangements.

Development Economics: Development economics presents us with an analytical toolbox and

frameworks in which the economic effects of resource extraction on development outcomes

(such as economic growth, income inequality, and poverty alleviation) are examined. Critical

| 14 P a g e

theories in the development economics e. g. the resource curse theory, Dutch disease, and

sustainable development goals is used to facilitate the trade-offs and synergies among economic

objectives and social and environmental sustainability.

3.3.2 Tools for assessing sustainability impacts (e.g., environmental impact

assessments, social impact assessments).

Examining sustainability implications of natural resource extraction is not possible without

application of multiple measurements covering all four core aspects of the environment, society,

economics, and governance. Key tools for assessing sustainability impacts include the following

Environmental Impact Assessments (EIAs) are designed to assess environmental effects of the

resource extraction which includes such outcomes as species extermination, habitat degradation,

water pollution, and CO2 emissions. Risks are identified, mitigation measures and trade-offs are

informed and therefore, EIAs form a basis for planning decision-making, compliance with

regulatory requirements, and engaging the stakeholders. Social Impact Assessments investigate

the social impact of projects in terms of how residents living near the plant would be affected.

SIA investigates factors including benefits, risks, impact to livelihoods, land tenure, cultural

heritage and social placement. On top of this, the impacts to distribution are also highlighted.

Through the involvement of participatory techniques and stakeholder consultations two very

much needed attributes are added namely social accountability and transparency for

comprehensive societal development. Sustainability Indicators determine progress towards

achieving sustainable development goals and targets, containing amongst others, a gradual

decline in poverty levels as well as multiple social, environmental and economic aspects.

4.0 Political Economy of Natural Resource Extraction

4.1.0 Government Policies and Regulation

A survey of the various national policies shows policies as different and diversified as resource

nationalism to reduced barriers to trade and markets. One the examples is the countries like

Norway has applied effective, regulations and taxation to support the natural resource stock and

the fair wealth distribution (Statoil, 2016). In contrast, there may also arise the condemnation of

other resource-endowed nations for their permissive regulations that are focused on short-term

benefits without considering sustainability which may lead to environmental degradation and

social unrest (Watts, 2018). Regulatory frameworks have a textbook role to play in this regard

with the primary goal of putting policies in place and lessening any negative implications of the

operations. Besides, the frameworks receiving favorable rating are those that offer those

mechanisms, including environmental protection, community engagement and revenue sharing

systems. Aggressiveness of such frameworks often differ in the real life with aspects like

institutional competence and political motivation being the major determinant. Such as, EITI

(Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative) has been able to help in achieving the goal of

better accountability and transparency in resource-rich nations with regards to the sharing of

extractive industry revenues.

| 15 P a g e

4.1.1 Examination of national policies on natural resource extraction.

Both the national policies of natural resource extraction programs and the factors behind them

differ greatly across nations and can be influenced by factors like resource richness, economic

objectives, and political ideologies. They involve many policy areas such as the licensing

arrangements existing; the taxation schemes; the environment and other open areas; the

involvement the community in those activities.

As such, general approach to natural resource extraction, particularly in oil and gas sector, of

Norway is characterized by an uncompromising focus on sustainability and intergenerational

equity. The have developed a complex system of regulament that includes harsh environmental

regulations, incorporation of high tax on profit and lodging a sovereign wealth fund to account

for oil revenues (Statoil, 2016). In sharp contrast, to countries like Nigeria characterized with

heterogeneity of ethnic groups and governance challenges which tend to result in the fall

America, Greece and other nations can only come up with an economic recovery once they

overcome economic instabilities. Notwithstanding being a top oil-producing country, Nigeria has

come under fire from clog of corruption and damage of environment, as a result of oil

exploitation. The country‟s policy has been plagued by insufficient practices on enforcing

regulations, inadequate revenue transparency as well as plenty of controversy regarding the

benefits accruing to the local communities (Watts, 2018).

4.1.2 Regulatory frameworks and their effectiveness.

The frameworks of regulations on the other hand, are directly subject to their efficiency being

influenced by many elements including institutional and enforcement capacity, and stakeholder

participation. It is in the developed countries with strong governance structures and starling

regulatory institutions, for instance, the Canadian and Australian countries, where the regulatory

frameworks are more efficient in facilitating compliance with environmental standards, as well

as enforcing the community rights, while at the same time, aiding in maximizing the socio-

economic benefits from the resource extraction (Humphreys, 2015). In most resource-endowed

countries, check rules face great challenges for example corruption, regulatory co-opt makes

regulatory framework very tricky and limited enforcement capacity. Institutional weakness and

political obstruction can altogether render the force of regulations weak. The environment may

degrade, social conflicts may surface, and the economy may dip (Hilson & Murck, 2018). For

example, in (DRC) the mining sector is disturbed by governance issues like, corruption, conflict

minerals as well environmental pollution. Even though there are regulatory mechanisms for

guiding a responsible mining process, there are enforcement weaknesses and institutions

deficiencies have emerged that have been major barriers to the effectiveness of such frameworks.

This results in the adverse social, environmental, and economic impacts of mining activities

(Global Witness, 2021).

| 16 P a g e

4.2.0 International Influence

Natural resource exploitation is trans nationalized with in the following presence of multinational

corporations (MNCs) and the impact of international trade agreements and organizations. Out of

these many multinational countries are well-endowed with great financial and technological

resources, which makes them have a great deal of control over resource-rich countries. (Sachs,

2015)At the level of international trade agreements and agreements, trade organizations will

potentially reform the environment of resource extraction, which is due to the change in the

market dynamics and regulatory frameworks. For example, however, trade agreements often

consist of a few provisions that include investment protection, intellectual property rights, and

environmental standards, some of which may enable or hinder the tasks of environment

protection (Gallagher, 2015). Similarly, organizations like the World Trade Organization (WTO)

and the World Bank make a difference too because they are the ones involved in policies of the

member states in their conditions of lending and technical assistance programs (Baker, 2016).

4.2.1 Role of multinational corporations.

Multinational Corporations (MNCs) are usually very rich, technologically strong, and have great

influence over the globe that they can use to own many extraction sites and dictate how the

resource development projects will be doing. One of the crucial elements of a multi-national

corporation's (MNCs) involvement in the extraction of natural resources is the influence of such

companies on host countries' economies. Although, cutting-edge investments from multinational

corporations can foster economic expansion, increase possibility of employment, and contribute

to the government revenue through the taxes and royalties, the views of the appropriation are

being teased caused by megawatt investments. Critics of this major type of economic

globalization propose the view that the negotiations that they enter with local government

authorities promote only their side's interests, allowing little wealth sharing, and offering no

opportunities for economic diversification for the host country (Pegg, 2015).

Furthermore, multinational investments processes carry deep social and environmental affairs of

the local population as well. Different activities like extractive ones may modify traditional way

of living or may displace indigenous people and may enter into environment and thus, may

conflict people on land rights, ecology and social security. A backlash of this tilt of balance

between government, nation, and multi-national corporations is pressure on MNCs to practice

responsible business operations, such as the respect for human rights, social and environmental

standards as well as meaningful engagement with affected communities (Kolk & Lenfant, 2018).

4.2.2 Impact of international trade agreements and organizations.

Agreements and organizations like WTO and UN can determine to a large extent the political

economy of natural resource production, being involved in such things as market access,

investment flow and regulations. It is often that the trade agreements include provisions linked to

investment protection, intellectual property rights, and trade liberalization, which can be positive

| 17 P a g e

if in another way those countries are natural resource endowed. Political deal agreements may

promote investment in the extraction of natural resources among foreigners through laws as well

as creation of stable environment for trade, decreasing trade barriers and promoting market

openings. The sample is illustrated in bilateral investment treaties (BITs) and free trade

agreements (FTAs) where provisions are added to protect foreign investors from expropriation

and they are also provided with fair and equitable treatment. This will attract multinational

corporations invested in resource-rich countries to invest more in such nations that have the

provisions (Bilaterals. org, n. d. ).

However, trade agreements also have the capacity to narrow down the policy room of resource-

rich countries, since they are prevented from imposing or regulating natural resources in the

interest of the public. Investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) facilities, generally included in

trade agreements, enable foreign investors to launch lawsuits against the government for

obstructing investment by international arbitration, thereby snatching the environmental and

social safety net (Sauvé and Roy, 2018). In addition to that, Organizations like the World Trade

Organization (WTO) and the World Bank determine political economy of natural resource

exports through their policies, lending methods, and technical assistance or professional service

programs. It is possible that these organizations would be in support of liberalization of trade,

among others, and put across agendas of privatization and deregulation as part of sustainable

development (Baker, 2016).

4.3.0 Corruption and Governance

4.3.1 Analysis of corruption levels in resource-rich countries.

Corruption affects the countries blessed with resources at a great level, therefore it has become

the fundamental problem to overcome the sustainable development attempts in both local and

global level. The resource-rich countries oftentimes perform under the Value of the Composite

Index of the Corruption Perception, showing a backdrop of corruption across the country. For

instance, in Nigeria, a significant oil producing nation, dealing with petroleum can take a long

time, and monetary resources can make their way into many bad hands through various contracts

and bribery schemes (Osei, 2019). Also, in Venezuean economy, corruption is one of the

growing issues of the oil industry which leads to economic crisis and then to sustainable

development initiatives (Torres, 2020).

The corruption that existing in countries who are endowed with many resources is strongly

maintained by several factors that include lack of accountability and institutions that are not

strong. The "resource curse" through cultivating a culture of rent extraction and patronage

relations aids the advancement of corruption (Ross, 2015). The lack of clarity with which the

terms of resource agreements and revenue flows come together gives a chance for corrupt

practices to come to light (Le Billon, 2012). Hence, the main channels of fighting corruption

should be further elaboration of strong institutions, transparency enhancement and accountability

promotion in resource management (Dube & Vargas, 2020).

| 18 P a g e

4.3.2 Governance structures and their influence on resource management.

Governmental system mechanisms are of extensive significance as regards to the structure of

natural resources management in resource-rich countries. Nevertheless, a lot of nations which are

resource-blessed are hampered by poor governance as evidenced by weakness of institutions,

collusion and corruption (Khan et al. , 2016). The regulating mechanisms of natural resources

recovery could be the services to promote or not the sustainable development. In countries with

durable governing systems like Norway, smart management of oil eventualities has seen the

establishment of a wealth fund, whose mandate is long-term growing of savings for the benefit of

the future generations (Karlsson-Vinkhuyzen & Keskitalo, 2018). On the contrary, corruption

among government representatives in countries like the Democratic Republic of Congo has led

to violation of natural resources for the benefit of small groups of individuals, which has also

fuelled conflict and contributed to the expansion of poverty (Auty, 2017). In numerous resource-

rich countries, ruling classes capture for themselves the funds from natural resources extraction,

neglecting interests of the less privileged members of a society, which strengthens inequality

between social classes and social tensions (Collier & Hoeffler, 2015). Mitigating governance

challenges involves fostering progress on the impetus which brings people together in the

decision-making processes and guarantees that the benefits are enjoyed equitably (Bromley and

Tallbeg, 2018).

5.0 Economic Implications of Natural Resource Extraction

Mineral deposits extraction as well as other natural resource exploitation are conducive to

economic development of the underlying countries generating wealth and bringing about the

phenomenon of the “resource curse” and thus a great need for strategic revenue management.

This phase concerns itself with the aforesaid matters as well their interrelatedness that gives rise

the complexity.

5.0.1 Economic Growth and Development

Natural resource capitalization is the most frequently used alternative for the development of

resource-rich economies. The exploitation of the minerals, the gas and the oil occurs thanks to

the natural resources and this provides a great source for income and consequently leads to

economic expansion (Jensen et al. , 2018). Operations in extractive industries sometimes involve

direct and indirect ways of employment creation of workers, attracting investments from

outsiders and remitting the government in form of taxes and royalties.

5.0.2 Contribution of natural resources to GDP and economic growth.

Countries‟ national economies differ in the share of natural resources in the Gross Domestic

Product (GDP), which reflects the great disparity among nations in terms of natural resources

contribution to economy. As a result of that, however, it could also enable these economies to

set up some risks, such as prices volatility and commodity markets turbulence. Resource rich

countries served themselves as great deal of GDP increasing recourses such as Saudi Arabia and

| 19 P a g e

Qatar. In countries that were given these huge reservoir of oil and gas, the economy was based

on the discovering and export of these materials. Correspondingly, the petroleum industry has a

very heavy influence on Saudi Arabia, in the terms of the GDP, the government income or the

gross export income (Al-Kahtani, 2017). As for that, Qatar's economy oil heavily off the natural

gas export revenues, which have made her one of the highest GDP per capita country in the

worldwide (Mogadam & Alam, 2018). The heavy dependence on the natural resources as a main

factor of the economic development in these states has resulted in the wide scale investments in

enterprises of resource extraction, technology and industries of that type. The expenditure of

profits from exports of raw materials at times turns to the funding of major social and

infrastructure projects. This is usually accompanied with an improvement in standards of living

and the human development index.

Nevertheless, in spite of the fostered economy of the natural resource bounty, countries tend to

depend overly on these resources which makes the economies susceptible to volatilities. One of

the major factors of riding risk is the fluctuation of commodity prices in international trading.

Dwindling prices of oil and gas, for instance, could result in significant yet unfavourable effects

on the non-diversified economies. Price shocks through periods of slump for instance has been in

the past blamed for large losses in revenues, budget deficit and even economic decline. An

exempli gratia is the 2014 oil crises that was costly to the International Energy Agency (IEA,

2015). Also, the overdependency on natural resources stands as an obstacle to the economy in a

way that it limits economic diversification and renders the economy more vulnerable to an

external shock. This brings about a situation of one-sidedness which can block the generation of

innovations, the growth of other branches, and the transformation of the economy that is always

dependent on volatile markets for commodities. The phenomenon of "Dutch disease" also

constitutes a threat to the development of a competitive, multi-sector economy as it involves a

currency depreciation and industry movements that result from intensive resource exports (Auty,

2017).

Natural resources do help improve the GDP and consequently the economic growth of a country.

However, it is also important to note that the entire economic process largely depends on the

commodity prices and market fluctuations which can cause the damage and hindrance in the

development of the country if not wisely managed. To avoid the risks, which are connected with

the abundance of resources, countries with rich natural resources should make use of available

economic management techniques that pay more attention on diversification, fiscal discipline as

well as sustainable development. Through working on the depletion of natural resources basis

and the establishment of a well diversified and unrestricted economy the nations are able to

emerge from the resource dependence challenges and lay the foundation of the long term

prosperity and sustainable growth.

5.0.3 Employment generation and income distribution.

| 20 P a g e

The statement about work opportunities emerging from resource extraction in an economy

should be taken for the basis just the same when other microeconomic stakeholders must be dealt

with due to the production output difference. In fact, resource extraction contributes to the

employment variability by creating a spectrum of roles in which one finds skilled labor in both

the extracting and the processing operations along with the ancillary services such as

transportation and logistics. Apart from the fact that it can be a source of life for the people and

soon to be more of the communities, contributes to the economic growth and development.

Nevertheless, it follows that happens that the gains of the resource extraction are always

distributed unevenly and that this inequality makes the income differences and other social

problems worse.

People who happen to live in surrounding communities but marginalized groups are most of the

time exposed to inclusion difficulties to labor market in the sector of natural resources. As for the

factors like lack of knowledge, training, connections which restrict the participation of women in

public decision making. A further point is that the effect of resource extraction on the

environment and society could be a real problem to groups of defenceless populations. Social

disruptions like entry into a land or disagreements with over resources rights, may make the

prevailing inequities and disputes to worsen. The mining industries bring employment however

the returns are normally not equally spread as people are unequal before the government of the

day which leads to inequalities in social status. Besides the obstacles, a part of the solution to

ensure sustainable development and equally prosperous future for all people involved is a smart

governance policy and the responsible business practices that should be developed.

5.1.0 Resource Curse Phenomenon

While the phenomenon is complex, this identified was paradoxical and observed in several

resource rich nations, natural resources do not guarantee positive economic outcomes.

Consequently, several resource-rich nations usually experiences to record even slower economic

growth rates, higher levels of poverty in the society and larger political instability. Dutch disease

can be defined as one of the resource curse repercussions in which after natural resource exports

the influx of revenues results in appreciation of the third party's currency and non-resource-based

sectors can become less competitive in the international market. Likewise, the conconcentration

of wealthy and power evolving on the back of substantial wealth accumulation can just amplify

the appearance of corruption, rent-seeking behavior and weak governance structures. Elite

capture of resource revenues often results into misallocation of funds, corruption and

mismanagement of funds in some instances hence civilians never benefit from the earnings and

end up critical public services and infrastructure development projects funds get diverted.

Instability can also be resultant of the resource curse in a country with regards to politics. Rent

control becomes the resource base attracts power and money-seeking actors, mostly between

government and armed groups, and marginal interests. At the worst, resources wealth may be

used to fund conflict; beans civilisation can hereby get further weakened as well as economic

| 21 P a g e

stability. States should give the first place to openness of information and responsibility of

government and to such an approach in decision-making process for sustainable and fair share

distribution of the resource revenues. Initiating the policy interventions like human capital

development, economic diversification, and promoting sustainable resource utilization are also

together the important steps for eliminating the Ressource curse and the proper use of natural

resources, and also for long-term development.

5.1.1 Evidence of the resource curse in various countries.

By extension, rather than being translated into a general development and prosperity for the

populations of Nigeria, Venezuela and the Democratic Republic of Congo, where the resources

are found in large amounts, they act as a factor that causes a resource curse effect. In spite that

these countries have significant resource riches but the governments still experience economic

and governance related difficulties, which hinder the countries‟ overall progress. Nigeria with its

position as one of the biggest oil producing countries only proves the theory giving resource

curse in effect. The country is a highly oil-endowed nation, which, nonetheless, continues to be a

struggle with poverty, instability, and underdevelopment. Oil assets corruption, sloppy use of oil

income, irregular allocation of oil authority have clogged Nigeria‟s procedure of oil richness

becomes sustainable development (Osei, 2019).

However, Venezuela, with its huge oil reserves, has sunk into decline, it is through this

uncontrolled path of the economic and political regime. And despite being blessed with oil, the

country is in the war against the inflation, its people face severe shortage of essential goods and

its social atmosphere is also restless. The unsound use of oil proceeds along with corruption and

dictatorial nature of governing is the main reason of Venezuela bankruptcy and social terror.

Like the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) with minerals of copper, cobalt and coltan of

great wealth, the resource curse also bothers it. In as much as the DRC is rich in various

resources, it continues to be one of most poor and highly conflict prone countries. The systematic

extraction of minerals has been the main driver behind the suffering of people, human rights

abuses, and the subsequent emergence of corruption that further aggravate poverty dilemma and

undermine governance (Auty, 2017). In these countries, through corruption and seeking rent

mean in the environment with extraction of resources they will be deeper and that means

involving economic challenges and stealing governance structures. Resource rent capture of

elites, obscurity of contracts that can lead to deals behind back door, and weak regulatory

mechanisms have been major challenges causing this sad scenario of underdevelopment and

instability.

5.1.2 Mechanisms through which the resource curse operates.

The resource curse refers to the complex phenomenon which has many different manifestations

and mechanisms, all working at the same time, resulting in the unexpected outcome of the

potential richness of natural resources being associated with poor economic results in some

| 22 P a g e

countries. Three major ones mechanisms that leads the resource curse show: the Dutch disease,

rent-sneaking behavior, and governance failures The first case of the Dutch disease was observed

in the 1960s when natural gas reserves were discovered in the Netherlands. When a country is

enjoying a large resource export boom, like in the case of oil or minerals, it usually results to a

rally and strengthening in the national currency. Due to this, the other sectors in the economy

may shrink, stifling economic diversification, as well as the trend towards sustainable growth

(Collier & Hoeffler, 2015).

Rent-seeking activities, which also play a huge role in the resource curse, are driven by

capitalizing on power and money using unproductive avenues such as lobbying, corruption, and

lying about your connection to the influencers. In resource-rich countries, elites and political

insiders can be involved in rent-seeking activities whereby they try to take a larger part of the

money incurred as a result of the resources exploring the country's economy and social welfare.

Corruption, greed and neposm not only become inherent features but also they would distort the

political and economic transparency and accountability which in turn, affect governance

effectiveness (Auty, 2017). Although governance failures may be considered as part of the

resource curse's picure, the structure of these failures include weak institutions, loose regulations,

and no proper accountability and transparency in resources management. There is, in many

resource-rich countries, often the case of a structure of governance is marked by nepotism,

clientelism, and an endemic corruption synonymous with institutions. Elites possess no

accountability and tend to capture and/or hoard natural resources contribution rents which is

meant to bring forth under-development, inequality, and political stability in this cycle (Ross,

2015).

5.2.0 Revenue Management

5.2.1 Strategies for managing resource revenues.

Some of the approaches used is putting in place stabilization funds, investment in infrastructure

and human capital, and diversifying the economy. Ministry of Finance of Norway owns the

world's most respectable sovereign wealth fund which is referred to as the Oil and Gas Fund of

Norway (of NO. ) - the main one. Buffer funds can play a crucial role by preventing shocks from

commodity over-price fluctuations both to government revenues and to a budget of the country.

These fund collect the resource vaults in the months of high prices and economic progress, which

act as buffer for the demand of stock during the time of fewer prices or economic downturns.

Using these stabilization funds grants a government with the assurance of a regular payout of

revenues and enables them to continue serving the public and help fund major public needs and

projects (Auty, 2017).

The role of infrastructure and human capital as drivers of productivity is undeniable, this is what

facilitates economic diversification leading to long-term progress and skilled workforce.

Governments can utilize their oil revenues in the construction and refurbishment of physical

infrastructure like roads, harbors, and utilities that it targets international trade and business by

| 23 P a g e

extension and support economic activity in general. Moreover, if we will be setting aside of

those budget for education, health, skills training, it will result to the improvement of labor

productivity and the establishment of inclusive growth (Bromley & Tallberg, 2018). Countries

may undertake diversification by investment in other sectors lagging behind, science and

innovation, and implementation of policies that bring investment in and encourage

competitiveness of such industries. Diversifying the economy intends to move to a type of

economy which is balanced and sustainable on the long run to less dependent on commodity

markets which tend to be volatile and therefore is able to cope with economic uncertainties.

5.2.2 Sovereign wealth funds and their effectiveness.

The main role of these funds consists in serving as the emergency fund for the government when

they are going to use the income from the natural resources extraction. The SWFs are responsible

for economic stability through the average of revenue and financing development sustainability.

Nevertheless, SWFs may be ineffective if there are some conditions in the way they operate,

such as their governance introduced by transparent policies and the compliance with well-done

investment principles. The SWFs lessen the impact of commodity price fluctuations on

governments' revenues and budgetary resources. Resource revenues from conditional periods

with high prices and economic prosperity are accumulated by SWFs. During times of revenue

shocks as a result of the low-price period or economic decline, these funds provide insulation.

Among its functions of stabilizing the operations of the economy, the role of central banks also

allows countries to smoothly spend on their public goods and services and cope better with the

repercussions on their economies from external shocks. To put it simply, besides that, SWFs are

employed to that very end of allow the long term development of economies so that, straightway,

such and such activities are included in the asset‟s portfolio as well, such as the various sectors

and geographies. These strategic investments target to develop a permanent return amid long-

term investment, also to maintain the wealth intergenerational and boosting a financial freedom

for a nation. Sovereign Wealth Funds (SWF) engage in asset diversification and financial

reallocation across a variety of market outlets such as stocks, bond, real estate, infrastructure, and

alternative investments that improves macroeconomic stability (Lin, 2019). Unlike in the case of

central banks, the extent of efficacy of SWFs in fulfilling their purposes is highly dependent on

the nature of governing structure and the level of transparency and adherence to the rules of

sound investments. The public is better served when the systems of governance are clear and

clean to promote good governance resulting in accountability over public funds. As for SWFs,

they need to have sticking to operational conditions, governance rules and investment guidelines,

which are included and directed at long-term value creation, management of risks and ethic

guidelines. Transparency in operational activities, investment decisions as well as the internal

management which will boost the public trust and confidence and will therefore bring about

accountability and oversight (Shih, _{2018). SWFs must not only adopt a prudent investment

strategy that includes asset allocation and risk management but also must do so in line with the

objectives for which it is established, the risk appetite of the investor, and the time horizon for

| 24 P a g e

investing. Asset diversification, cash flow matching and active management of the portfolio

increase investment success of SWFs by accomplishing financial objectives and providing

capital safety (Park, A. , & Vähämaa, N. , 2020).

6.0 Social and Environmental Implications

6.0.1Environmental Degradation

Forests depletion, hazardous mining, and oil extraction are the main tools used to extract natural

resources which eventually result in environmental degradation that poses environmental

pollution, land loss, and devastation of biodiversity. Those activities therefore disrupt and

modify the habitats of natural species and make them lost or less connected to each other, which

also have the major bearings on biodiversity and the balance of ecosystems. Such impacts of

disruption to the system reflect at both local and global stages and result consequently in the

survival of many plants and animal species. For example, in the Amazon rainforest, one of the

most biologically diverse places on the earth, illegal logging again fuelled by resource extraction

destroys both local habitats and wildlife alike. Those plants and animals which are only found in

the region are made vulnerable by the habitat destruction that can be caused here, and they are

thus pushed towards extinction. In addition, the dislocation of indigenous people living on these

lands gives rise to a higher level of toxification of the environment and community-level impacts

which disrupt traditional ways of earning a living and cultural resentment (Butler, 2019).

6.0.2 Impact of extraction activities on ecosystems and biodiversity.

Extraction, commonly involving an extensive amount of land clearance – with concrete result of

soil erosion contamination of water resources by the action of chemicals. The mining process

disrupts nature by utilizing heavy machinery, explosives, and chemicals to desecrate the land

thus changing the environment's natural state Likewise, the effect of oil extraction activities in

the Niger Delta region of Nigeria have resulted in pollution of water bodies, loss of biodiversity

and vanishing of original plants (NDES, 2018). Extraction activities of oil and gas, mainly in

offshore drilling sites, are relevant to great enmities to aquatic and terrestrial ecosystems.

Fragmentation of the habitat due to placing rigs and pipelines for oil drilling disrupts the marine

ecosystems together with migratory paths of marine species which in the end leads to decreases

in biodiversity. The worst damage to marine ecosystems due to the pollution of the water bodies

as a result of oil spills which happens frequently during the processes of extraction is devastating

due to oxygen and food deprivation as well as unwanted contamination. The Niger Delta, which

has a sad history of oil spills and ecologic devastation, is a bright example of the depressing

effects by oil drilling on ecosystem and biodiversity (NDES 2018). The effect of natural resource

exploitation on ecosystems and biodiversity is disastrous since it leads to an increased likelihood

of numerous plant and animal species becoming extinct.

6.0.3 Pollution and climate change implications.

| 25 P a g e

Among the pollution and the climate change that extraction operations bring about, posing grave

health risks to people and the environment can not be underemphasized. Industrial processes can

lead to emissions to air , water and soil which may have bad impact on ecological systems as

well as human settlements. On the other hand, combustion of fossil fuels (coal, oil and natural

gas) for energy production affects to an increase of greenhouse gas emission, and exacerbating

the climate change. The pollutants emitted, during extraction activities, may contaminate water

and air, resulting in soils degradation, ecosystem destruction, and consequently air and water

pollution. Although these are present, they find their way into water bodies, pollute the

ecosystems, and the human populations who reside nearby are exposed to these contaminants

through water consumption and fish ingestion. Likewise, drilling activities in oil and gas

extraction can expose people to volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and hazardous air pollutants

(HAPs), which would pollute the air and increase the risk of respiratory diseases in the

communities od the area (EIA, 2020). Likewise, the burning of fossil energy products mined

from the earth is equally a big climate change factor. The combustion of coal, oil and natural gas

leads to the release of the greenhouse gases,which through their deflection of the heat can make

the global temperature to rise. This effect is called the greenhouse phenomenon and it has

multidimensional repercussions, like a rise in the sea level and that certain weather events occur

more frequently and they intensify in their manifestations; as well as the disruption of

ecosystems and biodiversity. The most serious contribution to air pollution and carbon emissions

comes from the extraction and burning of coal, in particular. This is the reason why coal-fired

power plants are one of the most immense sources of greenhouse gas emissions globally (EIA,

2020).

6.1.0 Social Impact

6.1.1 Displacement of communities and loss of livelihoods.

The eviction of communities that are directly affected by mining as a community resettlement

result in extensive and sometimes terrible social and economic outcomes. When communities are

removed from their lands and places where they traditionally live due to exploration projects, the

people suffer because they loose the basic resources such forests, waters and lands which they

used to live on. They often don't know how to ensure the constant supply of essential sustenance

due to the missing normal resources. To this end, people fleeing from forced displacement will

not be able to maintain their social networks as the cultural traditions will further be disrupted

which will translate into high levels of upheaval and trauma among affected society. Long-

established social ties are cut due to divorce, leaving people without a tight communal bonds.

The traditional support system disappeared as a result of this. The identification of cultural

heritage that disappears will make the pressure that surrounds displaced communities more

complicated because the people who are displaced fight for belonging and the loss of their

cultural legacy.

| 26 P a g e

As an illustration, very often, the establishment of mining projects in the remote areas of the

developing countries have displaced their local clans. In much of the world, such communities

have been living on their traditional lands, their occupation time going back to 100s and 1000s of

years whilst relying on the ancestral forms of livelihood, such as farming, hunting, and gathering.

Further, the indigenous communities are many times forcibly moved from their villages when the

state of the community is turned over to a mining company. This moves the communities away

from their resources which they depend on. The result of displacement by force are entrenched

and multifaceted, and are the reasons of poverty, social exclusion as well as inequalities within

affected communities. As a result, pushed-out citizenry is frequently denied any kind of

institutional coverage or monetary aid to resume building their lives, which, in turn, may

increase their vulnerability and make them more social excluded.

6.1.2 Health impacts on local populations.

The effluence of acutely toxic elements in the air, water, and soil might result in a wide range of

health problems to the surrounding communities. Moreover combined with polluted water

systems there is a high incidence of waterborne diseases like diarrhea and cholera which only

worsens the health situation of the people suffering from this situation. In places like Ghana and

Peru, where the communities live near the gold mining sites, higher levels of mercury poisoning

have been reported among their inhabitants after their exposure to mercury that is used as and

during the extraction process. Mercury is one of the substances used in artisanal and small gold

mining to extract gold form ore but this form of use has serious health implication on the miners

and the neighborhood community. Breathing in vapors of mercury may induced neurological

disorders, kidney dysfunctions and embryonic, (mainly children) developmental delay.

Furthermore, there is a higher concentration of mercury in water resources which is responsible

for the accumulation of mercury among fish and other aquatic organisms in a way that can bring

harm to human health when people ingest seafood containing mercury. Moreover mercury will

not an uncommon wildly occurring substance during the resource extraction activities like heavy

metals and chemicals and so also they have the power to damage human health. Exposure of

pollutants to some people such as lead, arsenic, and cadmim is a cause of various diseases which

include respiratory, cardiovascular, and diseases of neurologic. In addition to this, soot and other

particles from mining and drilling can make respiratory ailments such as asthma and COPD

attack, affect people in the nearby regions. The implications of resource extraction activities for

the community are more evident in those areas where these sites are located near to the

community and as a result people are the most exposed to pollutants. Pregnant women, children

and elderly constitute vulnerable populations with higher risk of morbidity and mortality as they

are reportedly more thad the general population to absorb environmental toxins in their body.

6.2.0 Conflict and Security

6.2.1 Resource-related conflicts and their root causes.

| 27 P a g e

Resource-based conflicts mostly stir up from the preconscious problems like unfair capture of

resource funds, unruliness in resource governance and struggle over lands and natural stuff. This

type of dispute is likely to emerge when the public feels that they are not getting equitable shares

(participation) in the exploitation of resources, leading to conflict and anger between the parties.

The main factor triggering the resource-related tensions is the violation of principles of equitable

distribution of resource wealth, whereby local residents leave the just shares of wealth while the

benefits are controlled by the few. Such inequitable distribution of wealth just makes life for

people with low income more difficult and consequently creates misfortune in the poor people‟s

community which leads to an increase in resentment and conflicts. Not only that, but opacity and

non-accountability in resource management ultimately intensify social conflicts and

dissatisfaction since in most cases the communities are cut off from the resource extraction

projects decisions being made. Local community trust in the government and extractive

companies are highly dependent on how the two parties engage with the community in resource

governance and sharing conclusions, and thus when the participation becomes insignificant, it

adds up to the injustice and perceptions of exploitation.

Competition over the land and natural resources that is one of the most important drives of

resource-connected conflicts. Conflicts over land ownership, drawing on resources, and sharing

agreements on benefits are the most common in areas which are populated densely by

stakeholders, which are different in nature, and which might be the locals, the indigenous groups,

the governments, and the extractive industries. For instance, in Nigeria‟s Niger Delta region it‟s

clashes about uneven distribution of the oil money and consequences of pollution for local

communities that develops armed conflicts between governmental forces, militia and civilians.

The communities endured oil exploitation for many years and recovering the environment,

eliminating pollution from fertile soils, and attaining food security remained a big obstacle

threatening the livelihood of numerous local populations (Ovadia, 2017).

6.2.2 Security measures and their implications for local communities.

In areas of Latin America such as gold and copper abundant in that region the presence of

military forces and paramilitary forces, there are many violations in the fields regarding of

human rights and violence against local people. In compliance with HRW's report of 2019, the

involvement of military personnel in these locations mostly causes the raids by these forces

against locals who are opposing mining activities. These repressions may encompass lead-in

detentions, torture, and execution without the trial. The defining irony is that the lack of security

is often brought about by measures and policies proposed on account of it. People living around

extraction camps when militarized heavily may have to abandon their houses and traditional

lands due to threats of violence or in some cases being forced to leave directly. When the

livelihoods are little or no-more, the vulnerability of these communities increases as it becomes

impossible for them to recover and adapt, to the new situation. Additionally, the intensified

military control and higher security presence in areas rich in natural resources can aggravate the

situation that already exist and make it explode into full-scale armed conflict. Thus for instance

| 28 P a g e

people like the indigenous communities and other local residents who think that those extracting

facilities are likely to be a threat to the land rights and environmental safety may fight back using

the methods like protests and resistance movements. It is a phenomenon that the state's

militarized actions against social and human rights movements hardly tend to get solved in short

term due to increased chances of violence and longer-term conflict.

7.0 Case Studies

7.1.0 Africa

7.1.1 Analysis of resource extraction in countries like Nigeria, Angola, and the

Democratic Republic of Congo.

In the economic context of Nigeria, the oil output has been at the centre; as the main source of

the revenues to the government as well as a main source of export earnings. While this is in line

with the strategic plan of democratization, it may end up exposing the environmental state to

degradation, especially through the attempted second liberation of the Niger Delta. The

operations of oil spills and gas flaring have seen the water sources become contaminated while

destroying farms and prompting health issues among the locals (Amnesty International, 2020).

An additional factor that has led the uncontrolled wealth move from the government to private

pockets and therefore public services and infrastructure development is the motivation for

corruption and mismanagement (Nwapi, 2016). The fact that militant groups like the Niger Delta

Avengers are present is an evidence that resource wealth can be used not only as an agent for

development but also as a way to trigger conflict and violence as groups struggle to exercise

control over these productive assets (Obi, 2017).

Angola looks like another case with the economy based on oil that is one of Africa‟s biggest oil

producers. The oil revenues have allowed the state to develop robust infrastructural systems and

this has been a boost to the prosperity of the largest segment but for the masses, all this does not

translate into better socio-economic condition. The crude oil revenue that would improve the

living standards of the citizens instead is being stolen and pocketed by corrupt officials leading

to corruption and embezzlement (Transparency International 2019). Also, a government of

Angola has frequently resorted to a harsh manner of security services to stifle dissent and control

resource regions in which human rights violations have taken place and confrontation have been

felt (Human Rights Watch, 2021).

The exploitation of minerals ownership in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) has become

a hot spot of conflicts for a long time. The DRC joined the band of countries with immense

mineral reserves, but instead of this being a manifestation of its great wealth, this is a stubborn

driver of one of the world‟s long-lasting conflicts. Oppressive regimes and criminal military

factions use corruption to carry out buccaneering activities in order to fuel their disorder and

sustain their politically unstable environment (Autesserre, 2012). The inhabitants are either

subjected to hard labor, human rights violations or extreme environmental destruction by the

| 29 P a g e

placers. Moreover, the prevalence of child labor is quite high in the mining industry, in particular

in those of cobalt which the whole global tech industry depends on.

In all these three countries resources extraction still play a critical role in the economy. While it's

positive effect, the other issues which is associated with governance, environmental pollution

and human rights violation, explain the complexity of problem between resource wealth and

socio-political problems. Governance, accountability, and compliance with human rights

parameters must receive due attention if the goal is for economic breakthroughs to culminate in

environmental efficiency and stability.

7.2.0 Latin America

7.2.1 Examination of extraction activities in countries like Venezuela, Brazil,

and Chile.

In Venezuela oil is the main factor that drives the country as it holds the largest oil supply

deposits found in the world. The Venezuelan oil industry - historically, an important revenue

provider for the country-backbones the national economy. But inefficiency and rampant case of

corruption have contributed immensely to the destruction of this section. Production by the state-

owned oil company, PDVSA, declined due to lack of investment in its operations and also

because of the poor maintenance of its installations (Corrales & Penfold, 2015). Aside from that,

the oil producing process has resulted in plenty of environmental problems, for example, oil

leakage and deforestation, which has unfortunate consequences for local communities and nature

(the Human Rights Watch, 2020). The economic conditions in Venezuela has deteriorated slowly

as a result of the sanctions imposed and the decline in oil prices.

The Brazilian economy comprises of the different activities such as mining of minerals and oil

and also timber extracting. The country is one of the rampant producers of iron ore and identified

with vast oil resources, which are largely in the offshore pre-salt field deposits. Although these

bits dramatically enlarge the welfare, they may cause serious environment and social problems.

The Amazon is a rich biome considered as a source of mineral and timber, nevertheless, illegal

logging and mining are still taking place, resulting in the forest to lose more trees. This

deforestation, aside from being a threat to the planet's biodiversity, also causes disturbances for

the indigenous communities who call this ecosystem home (WWF, 2021). Furthermore, the

mining sector has once again ruined itself with disasters which include the Mariana and

Brumadinho dam breaks that caused catastrophic damage and the loss of large numbers of lives.

Chile occupies the 1st position in copper mining throughout the world, a metal of top-notch

significance for the national economic growth. The mining sector, mainly occupied by copper

mining, is the one that brings up the greatest income and number of workers in the national

contribution. Notwithstanding environmental and social factors, the drawbacks of the sector are

noticeable. Complex mining scenarios with huge water requirement as it is the case in arid parts

of the region, become a standard to the local communities youth who are in most cases facing the

| 30 P a g e

problem of scarcity of water (Budds, 2013). Moreover, these energy sources produce as much as

half of all global toxic waste, they contaminate the soil and water which may disrupt agriculture

and local fauna. The fast growth of the sector has also triggered conflicts with the indigenous

peoples about land sovereignty and environment protection applicability (Haarstad & Campero,

2012).

In Venezuela, Brazil and Chile the issue of mining hence appears the central features leading to

the high standard of living but is also coming with adverse effects. Environmental pollution,

social problems and governance issues are the typical concerns of African countries.

Overcoming these hurdles is contingent upon a strong regulatory setting, proper implementation

of enforcement and combined policies giving the right to and the needs of local communities and

environmental safety a width.

7.3.0 Asia

7.3.1 Case studies from countries like Indonesia, India and China

China excels in the extraction and manufacturing of mineral materials, such as coal, assorted rare

elements, and metals like copper and aluminum which are critical in the world. The country

which mining is conducted on the extensive level is being urbanized and industrialized at the

rapid pace hence the reason for the extensive mining operations. Coal mining, especially, is

known to be an activity that impacts the environment heavily (Zhang et al. , 2018), through

causing air pollution, land degradation and water contamination. The rare earth element level,

which is a vital component for high technology industries, on the other hand, has also negative

environment impact due to the toxic chemicals used in extraction processes, so soil and water

might be contaminated (Hao et al. , 2019). Moreover, mining projects frequently have resulted in

expelling of local people as well as employment issues regarding workers' rights, emphasizing

the socioeconomic significance of ore processing. India is a country with plenty of natural

resources, and many of them including coal, iron ore, bauxite are among the minerals that are

highly concentrated in this country. Coal is still its king. The need of energy production

development demonstrate it. In contrast to the inconsequential environmental effects of different

types of energy system, coal mining is characterized by severe environmental and health impact

such as deforestation, air and water pollution, and adverse health effect to local residents (Ghosh,

2018). The mining of these minerals has, in turn, caused soil and water pollution as well as the

suspension of indigenous peoples. The problem of illegal mining and implementation defiance is

also typical in the mining sector in India that adds up to the negative impacts, social and

environmental ones though (Lahiri-Dutt, 2014).

Among the world's largest coal producers is Indonesia as well as significant tin reserves. The

industry of mining is one of the main cogs in the economy wheel, however, its use also exerts

considerable environmental and social burdens. Coal mining results in forest clearance or

destruction of habitats, especially in Kalimantan and Sumatra, while it also affects the

surrounding biodiversity and the local communities (World Bank, 2019). On top of that, the

| 31 P a g e

process of gold and tin mining often include the use of toxic substances like mercury which pose

huge risk to the health of the workers as well as the residents living around these places (Pure

Earth, 2020). Sometimes the fact that mining operations have been extended to these

communities can lead to land conflicts, and environmental conservation. Asia resource extraction

is one key economic feature which however calls for some significant environmental economic

problems. The concerns of environmental destruction, health impacts and local community

conflicts associated with mining activities clearly point to the need of strict frameworks.To

achieve the perfect balance between the economic development and the green sustainability and

social quality is still the main problem of the Asian countries that are engaged in an intense

extraction of natural resources.

8.0 Policy Implications and Recommendations

8.0.1 Sustainable Practices

8.0.2 Best practices for sustainable natural resource management.

The role of Environmental Impact Assessments (EIAs) is to identify the foreseeable negative

environmental impacts and suggest feasible solutions to tackle them before the startup of the

extraction operations. The results of the EIAs are extremely important in assessing the potential

environmental impacts on biodiversity, water resources, the quality of soil, and the existing

ecological conditions which allows for informed decisions making that aim at environmental

protection (Morgan, 2012). This active participation will also help facilitate identification of eco-

friendly extracting methods and technologies assuming environmental issues are tackled as a

priority from the beginning. It is imperative to apply the technologies that are the most

environment friendly for reducing the ecological footprint and attaining sustainable use of

resources. Developments like applying the closed-loop water systems to recycle water inside the

extraction process can be an effective way of reducing wastewater utilization and contamination

(Vogt, 2018). Through the use of renewables, which includes electricity generation from wind

and solar sources, we can power mining operations, thus there is a reduction in emission of

greenhouse gases and total reliance on fossil fuels (Lloyd, 2014). Protection from damages and

improvement of our extraction processes are the two main benefits acquired from the use of

these technologies. The community participation is dominated issue in the sustainable

management of resources. Such social interaction creates social accountability, which gives

sustainable development a underpinning where local communities play a role in managing

resources (Owen & Kemp, 2013). One of the most important issues is the inclusive approach,

which can be regarded as a solution to social problems, be non-conflict or aid in ensuring that the

benefits from the resources are shared equally. Under this annotation, the nonstop supervision

and impacts of mining operations on the environment are what is continually being monitored.

This information can provide direction for management practices - the management practices

being altered to accommodate the emerging problems and realizing the desired environmental

| 32 P a g e

goals (Holling, 1978). If there is a decrease in water quality, the stirring within the machine will

be reduced to lower the contamination.

8.0.3 Examples of successful policy interventions.

The story of how Norway‟s Government Pension Fund Global (also, well-known as the Oil

Fund) is effectively managing its abundant natural resource wealth is shown through this specific

case. A demand source of revenue from the oil wealth and which intends to support and defend

the future nations and stabilize the economy. Success relies on the two important factors

transparency and governance framework of the blockchain. This is an ethical fund that guides its

policy under strict ethical guidelines including those that insulate the fund from the investments

in companies that do not meet environmental and social criteria (Gylfason, 2011). By channeling

oil revenues into international assets such as bonds the risk arising from a price swings in the oil

market is reduced and the wealth created as a result of non-renewable resources will contribute

to long-term stability and community wellbeing. Botswana, being the second case which is

remarkable, is also undeniably the one that demonstrates sustainable resource management. The

nation has indeed put its diamond financing to position development processes in a way that

have ended up making economic growth stable and many people trending the path of living

comfortably. One may explain above achievement through Pakistan‟s transparency and spending

efforts on public services. The government has established strong institutions that regulate the

outflow of diamond revenue with goals that stevnutity, education, and infrastructure recieve a

good share (Acemoglu, Johnson, & Robinson, 2003).The Norwegian and Botswana cases used

here provide specific examples of how policies targeted at constructing sustainable resource

management are of paramount importance. Norway‟s Government Pension Fund Global and

Botswana‟s management of diamond revenues are good examples of the necessity for being

transparent regarding investments, ensuring that ethics rules are not disregarded and placing the

investor‟s gains back into community development.

8.1.0 Governance Reforms

8.1.1 Recommendations for improving transparency and reducing corruption.

Governments need to implement and strictly observe policies, which states that companies

engaged in resource extraction must do public reporting of all of their contracts, revenues as well

as fees or payments, that they receive. Transparency International (In. 2013) states that the

beneficial disclosure not only supports holding companies as well as the government officials

liable but also improves the level of trust investors have in the oil industry.Outlining the

disclosure procedures in the registration of the major deals on natural resources extraction,

financial transactions, and a review of the components of resource revenues can be a part of such

regulations. Therefore, the transparency brings in through obstructing corrupt activities as well as

meanwhile increasing public trust in management of natural resources. Instruction by the

Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) standard has countries to disclose

information about most important processes in extraction industries, like how business licenses

| 33 P a g e

are allocated, who owns extraction educationist companies, and the sum of money governments

have received from extraction activities (EITI, 2019). One of the EITI key opening doors is the

fact that by taking part in this initiative, countries have to agree on sticking to worldwide

accepted standards aimed at giving all necessary data to the public. Such helps to create an equal

ground where all the countries' business companies would be guided by similar transparency

standards that in turn reduce chances of the organizations being uncontrollably corrupt.

Establishing autonomous corruption control branches, this will allow for a proper enquiry and

the processing of the corrupt people from the resource sector. This requires creating independent

bodies to carry out around-the-clock investigations and, if needed, prosecute the criminals

without the required political interference. Kaufmann (2010) puts forth the idea that if there is an

independent, powerful anti-corruption agency then the frequency of the detection and

punishment of the corruption-related crimes increase which in its turn significantly hinders these

practices. To guarantee the bodies' effectiveness they should be staffed adequately with

professionals trained and able to conduct financial investigations even of potentially complex

structure. Cases of Anticorruption agencies are Batswana‟s Anti-Corruption Commission and

Nigeria‟s Independent Corrupt Practices Commission, improvement in corruption cases being

reported.

8.1.2 Strengthening institutional frameworks.

The institutional enforcement is of primary importance for the role of the government in better

asset management. Regulating the natural resources, effectively, requires a comprehensive

understanding on how to implement policies, keep resource extraction process under control, and

impose regulations (stable). For example, Space technologies indicators like satellite imagery,

Geographic information systems (GIS) and real-time data monitoring applications that can easily

help the institutions to oversee resource extraction activities and violations can significantly

improve their degree of success in this endeavor. Regulatory bodies, however, will be able to

function and deliver on their obligations if they are also adequately funded and are autonomous.

Financial autonomy is the basis for other institutions to have the financial means to undertake

their required duties without any intrusion of external actors. Autonomy is a must in any

organization `in order` to `remain` objective and to `avoid` omission of information. Due to this

part of regime, there is no risk of intertia capture where influential organizations could

qualification of penal acts or approaches to option measures (Mehlum, Moene, & Torvik, 2006).

Legally enforceable, clear and definite standards form a basis for organization‟s resource

management. The fact that judiciary should be able to keep the standards of society without

political involvement is the basic and necessary provision for the legal system to be applied

successfully. The juridical function is independent which means it can make fair adjudications of

disputes, violation prosecutions, and safeguard the rights of the people that were affected

(Rodrik, Subramanian, & Trebbi, 2004).

| 34 P a g e

Effective land security systems design in preventing disputes and inadequate distribution of

resources. The clearance of any individual or indigenous people about the ownership of their

ground is important. Defined land titles help prevent land use disputes ,which in turn leads to fair

sharing of the resources exploits benefits. The systems would thus offer the legal commendation

of the land holdings of individuals and communities, alternative methods of resolving problems,

and protection from displacement (Bromley, 2008). Therefore, public authorities which do not

hesitate to provide communities with proper tenure of land established in that area, can be sure

that residents will stay in their agreements and cooperate in order to keep the environment

balanced. Nurturing institutional meters in the field of resource management is a complex

process that involves many aspects. Cairness building, investment into the required technology,

enough finances, legal independence, enforceable legal norms, independent judges, and efficient

land tenure systems are the vital components in the progress of property rights. Through raising

institutional capacity and governance functioning, nations can efficiently and fairly manage their

resources with care.

8.2.0 International Cooperation

8.2.1 Role of international bodies in promoting sustainable extraction

practices.

Probably, huge international bodies' major achievement is in creating frameworks and

instructions which lead to sustainable activities. The 17 UN‟s Sustainable Development Goals

(SDGs) is demonstrative of this line of thinking. The SDGs, especially Goal 12, make a point

about responsible consumption and production, and for countries want to lead the way in

sustainable use of the resources, this is the last but not least important SDG to may want to

reconsider (UN, 2015). These guidelines will be just a reference mark for the World countries to

the development of the policies which a balance the economy with the environment and

equitable social integration. Aside from permitting international co-operation, international

agencies provide technical support and financial assistance to developing nations. For example,

The World Bank forms the loans, grants, and the expertise to foster the countries' development of

the infrastructural and capable systems that are used for the sustainable management of resource.

(World Bank, 2017). Such assistance ranges from providing money for projects that protect

nature resources, strengthen the good governance, stimulate social inclusion, and facilitate

sustainable development.

International organizations are the main players that contribute in the direction of meeting

between the states. They intergrate peer learning and sharing of the experiences of successful

working and become a place for the creation of joint solutions to address existing problems. The

IMF, for instance, provides platforms in which policy makers, business leaders and so on can

share ideas and experiences that relate to mining operations (Sustainable Development and the

Resource Extraction - The IMF, 12 May, 2012). They channel visibility of successful methods

and help exchange experience nationally when problems frequently stay during the process.

| 35 P a g e

Besides that, co-operation on an international level of conduct ensures an international approach

to the global challenges such as climate change while other natural resources are not depleted

because of waste during the extraction process. Several illustrations are given below to

demonstrate the influence of ICs in spite of the unfriendly practices that may co-exist. REDD+ is

one of UN's initiatives (Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation) under

which countries with forest resources can adopt sustainable forest management practices and

forest carbon emission reduction effortsSuch fiscal subsidies and technical advice offered by

REDD+ facilitate implementation of more sustainable forestry improvement process for

countries like Brazil and Indonesia (UN-REDD, 2019). Similarly, the key role of the World

Bank‟s Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) is promoting transparency and

accountability within natural resource-rich countries, with which it strives to eliminate corruption

and help the national development by ensuring the revenues from these resources are not ending

up in the pockets of corrupt individuals, but go towards the people (EITI, 2019). In other words,

non-governmental organizations, like the UN, WB and IMF do indispensable work in bringing

about the sustainability of extraction methods. They achieve that the resource extraction would

be in line with the sustainable development, and then the well-being of these generations could

be generated.

8.2.2 Importance of global standards and agreements.

Paris Climate Agreement is a historical international document which is aimed at reduction of

the activity of greenhouse gases. The very fact that a country has to follow a predefined emission

reduction norm will encourage the use of cleaner extraction techniques and technologies. The

countries are motivated to migrate away from the conventional energy sources and they do so

well to improve the energy efficiency across the mineral extraction processes (UNFCCC, 2015).

The Basel Convention of the Control of Transboundary Movements and Their Disposal of

Hazardous Wastes mandates the worldwide transport and disposal of hazardous waste including

waste generated from mining and such extractive activities. This convention aims at

safeguarding human health and the environment from the adverse effects of hazardous waste by

minimizing its generation and guaranteeing environmentally sound management of wastes under

this convention(basel convention,2011). The function of this treaty in protecting the worldwide

ecosystem is by regulation of the procedures of dealing with and disposal of dangerous

resources. Global standards and treaties level the playing field through the consistent and

uniform rules that are captured in the documents and must be complied with by all the

participating countries. This consistency levels the playing field, rather than allowing countries

to undermine their environmental and labor standards to attract investment in a "race to the

bottom" competition. Nations that carry out the regulations of the global norms individuality

contribute to the world majorly toward the area of sustainable resource management.

| 36 P a g e

9.0 Conclusion

9.1 Summary of Findings

9.1.0 Recap of key insights from the study.

The research of politics surrounding natural resource extraction and it‟s perceived effect on

sustainability bring on a few important points. The first problem recognized is the so-called

'curse of resources'. . Emphatic leadership and rock-firm institutional institutions are apt

foundations to solve the challenges arising. Besides, the significance of fairness and anti-

corruption measures is being presented, that gives a chance and possibility to make use of the

chances content inside like the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) in increasing

accountability (EITI, 2019). Therefore, the implementation of good practices such as the

complete environmental impact assessments, community involvement and adaptive management

(Morgan, 2012) is the most reasonable option to solve this problem. Besides, numerous treaties

and global conventions such as the Paris Agreement and the Basel Convention (UNFCCC, 2015,

and Basel Convention, 2011) across the globe would facilitate uniformity in green practices.

9.2.0 Implications for Future Research

9.2.1 Identification of gaps and suggestions for future studies.

The issue is revealed to have a number of elements left to be explored. One major gap is still

how case studies should be more detailed on the how use of sustainable resource management

techniques in different social and political settings has contributed to its success. It involves

looking into the question of how some political and technological processes can be modified to

adjust to different setting (Acemoglu, Johnson, & Robinson, 2003). Yet another topic to be

considered is how sustainability projects over time can change the level of corruption and

performance of the government in countries rich in natural resources. Furthermore, it is vital to

look into socio-economic effects of the extraction upon local communities, specifically those that

carry the risk of eviction, job loss and human rights violations (Owen & Kemp, 2013).

9.2.0 Final Thoughts

9.2.1 Reflection on the importance of aligning natural resource extraction with

sustainable development goals.

Adjusting natural resource extraction to the validity of development goals (SDGs) is the key for

the long term existence and environmental sustainability. SDGs as a set of goals provide an all-

embracing framework that directs our attention towards responsible consumption and

production, climate action and the role of preserving ecosystems (UN, 2015). A sustainable

resource management approach allows the extraction of natural resources as a contributor to

economic development within an environment that is not undermined or inequality of the

society. The integration of the environmental and social components allows for the alleviation of

environmental impacts created by the extraction of resources (such as degradation and social

conflicts) and a fair distribution of the benefits linked to the natural resources.

| 37 P a g e

REFERENCE

Acemoglu, D., Johnson, S., & Robinson, J. A. (2003). An African success story: Botswana. In

D. Rodrik (Ed.), *In Search of Prosperity: Analytic Narratives on Economic

Growth*. Princeton University Press.

Auty, R. M. (2001). *Resource Abundance and Economic Development*. Oxford University

Press.

Basel Convention. (2011). Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of

Hazardous Wastes and Their Disposal. Retrieved from https://www.basel.int/

Basher, S. A. (2010). The resource curse hypothesis: A critical review. *Resources Policy,

35*(3), 185-203.

Bauer, A., & Toews, G. (2014). The political economy of resource management. *Journal of

Economic Perspectives, 28*(4), 101-120.

Bebbington, A., Humphreys Bebbington, D., & Bury, J. (2010). Federating and defending:

Water, territory and extraction in the Andes. *Human Organization, 69*(3), 308-

317.

Berman, N., Couttenier, M., Rohner, D., & Thoenig, M. (2017). This mine is mine! How

minerals fuel conflicts in Africa. *American Economic Review, 107*(6), 1564-

1610.

Bromley, D. W. (2008). Resource Tenure and Institutions. In R. Meinzen-Dick & M. Di

Gregorio (Eds.), *Collective Action and Property Rights for Sustainable

Development*. International Food Policy Research Institute.

| 38 P a g e

Collier, P., & Hoeffler, A. (2005). Resource rents, governance, and conflict. *Journal of Conflict

Resolution, 49*(4), 625-633.

Cust, J., & Harding, T. (2020). Institutions and the location of oil exploration. *American

Economic Journal: Microeconomics, 12*(1), 74-105.

Dunning, T. (2008). *Crude Democracy: Natural Resource Wealth and Political Regimes*.

Cambridge University Press.

EITI. (2019). The EITI Standard 2019. Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative. Retrieved

from https://eiti.org/document/eiti-standard-2019

Frankel, J. A. (2010). The natural resource curse: A survey. *NBER Working Paper No.

15836*. National Bureau of Economic Research.

Gelb, A. (1988). *Oil Windfalls: Blessing or Curse?* Oxford University Press.

Gylfason, T. (2011). Natural resource endowment: A mixed blessing? In R. Arezki, T. Gylfason,

& A. Sy (Eds.), *Beyond the Curse: Policies to Harness the Power of Natural

Resources*. International Monetary Fund.

Humphreys, M., Sachs, J. D., & Stiglitz, J. E. (2007). *Escaping the Resource Curse*. Columbia

University Press.

IMF. (2012). Macroeconomic Policy Frameworks for Resource-Rich Developing Countries.

*International Monetary Fund*.

Karl, T. L. (1997). *The Paradox of Plenty: Oil Booms and Petro-States*. University of

California Press.

| 39 P a g e

Kaufmann, D. (2010). Can Corruption Adversely Affect Public Finances in Industrialized

Countries? *Brookings Institution*.

Larsen, E. R. (2006). Escaping the resource curse and the Dutch disease? When and why

Norway caught up with and forged ahead of its neighbors. *American Journal of

Economics and Sociology, 65*(3), 605-640.

Le Billon, P. (2001). The political ecology of war: Natural resources and armed conflicts.

*Political Geography, 20*(5), 561-584.

Mehlum, H., Moene, K., & Torvik, R. (2006). Institutions and the Resource Curse. *Economic

Journal, 116*(508), 1-20.

Morgan, R. K. (2012). Environmental Impact Assessment: The State of the Art. *Impact

Assessment and Project Appraisal, 30*(1), 5-14.

Moss, T. J. (2011). *Oil to Cash: Fighting the Resource Curse through Cash Transfers*. Center

for Global Development.

National Research Council. (2008). *Minerals, Critical Minerals, and the U.S. Economy*. The

National Academies Press.

Owen, J. R., & Kemp, D. (2013). Social License and Mining: A Critical Perspective.

*Resources Policy, 38*(1), 29-35.

Porter, M. E., & van der Linde, C. (1995). Toward a New Conception of the Environment-

Competitiveness Relationship. *Journal of Economic Perspectives, 9*(4), 97-118.

| 40 P a g e

Robinson, J. A., Torvik, R., & Verdier, T. (2006). Political foundations of the resource curse.

*Journal of Development Economics, 79*(2), 447-468.

Rodrik, D., Subramanian, A., & Trebbi, F. (2004). Institutions Rule: The Primacy of Institutions

Over Geography and Integration in Economic Development. *Journal of Economic

Growth, 9*(2), 131-165.

Rosser, A. (2006). The political economy of the resource curse: A literature survey. *IDS

Working Paper No. 268*. Institute of Development Studies.

Sachs, J. D., & Warner, A. M. (2001). The curse of natural resources. *European Economic

Review, 45*(4-6), 827-838.

Sala-i-Martin, X., & Subramanian, A. (2003). Addressing the Natural Resource Curse: An

Illustration from Nigeria. *NBER Working Paper No. 9804*. National Bureau of

Economic Research.

Stevens, P. (2003). Resource impact: Curse or blessing? A literature survey. *Journal of Energy

Literature, 9*(1), 3-42.

Stiglitz, J. E. (2005). Making natural resources into a blessing rather than a curse. In T.

Salverda, K. van Dijk, & P. Konings (Eds.), *The Politics of Uneven Development:

The Case of Africa*. Brill.

Tamas, P. A. (2003). Water resource scarcity and conflict: Review of applicable indicators and

systems of reference. *UNESCO IHP Technical Documents in Hydrology, 59*.

| 41 P a g e

Transparency International. (2013). Corruption and Renewable Natural Resources. Retrieved

from https://www.transparency.org/en/publications/corruption-and-renewable-

natural-resources

UN. (2015). Transforming Our World: The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. United

Nations. Retrieved from https://sdgs.un.org/2030agenda

UNFCCC. (2015). Adoption of the Paris Agreement. United Nations Framework Convention on

Climate Change. Retrieved from https://unfccc.int/process-and-meetings/the-paris-

agreement/the-paris-agreement

Van der Ploeg, F. (2011). Natural resources: Curse or blessing? *Journal of Economic

Literature, 49*(2), 366-420.

World Bank. (2017). Extractive Industries Overview. Retrieved from

https://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/extractiveindustries/overview

THE POLITICAL ECONOMY OF NATURAL RESOURCE EXTRACTION AND ITS IMPLICATIONS FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT

Students also viewed