FUTURE-FOCUSED CORPORATE MANAGEMENT STRATEGY
ARIZONA STATE UNIVERSITY
CIS 235 - INTRODUCTION TO INFORMATION SYSTEMS
WEEK 2
PURPOSE OF DISCUSSION
❖
Discussing the influence of the use of Information Technology on corporate strategy
❖
Explain the change strategy from power to empowerment
❖
Discuss the role of Information Technology in the company
❖
Explaining Information Transformation as knowledge
Introduction:
The internal and external environment of the company is always evolving and
dynamic, giving rise to opportunities or obstacles to the growth of the company. Another
cause is the decisions made by management. Company management is tasked with making
decisions, but this task is a critical aspect of the task that requires managerial ability to
integrate and develop various relevant elements into the overall company situation. In
carrying out their duties, management will be concerned about time, face risks that may
threaten the stability of the company, and these decisions must be able to be communicated to
the implementing party (company operational officers).
To deal with environmental obstacles and challenges and the ability to make decisions,
company management requires the right strategy, so that company goals can be achieved
optimally. In determining what strategy the company management will use, it requires
appropriate considerations, because it will concern the company's existence in the future.
Before determining the strategic steps that must be chosen in company management, it will
first be explained what is meant by strategy.
According to Glueck (2008:6), a strategy is a comprehensive and integrated plan that
connects the organization's strategic strengths with the environment it faces, all of which
ensure that organizational goals are achieved.
According to Robson (2007:5) strategy is a pattern of decisions on the allocation of
resources made to achieve organizational goals.
Furthermore, according to Glueck, strategic management is a number of decisions and
actions that lead to the preparation of a strategy or a number of effective strategies to help
achieve organizational goals.
Strategic management is a decision to choose a strategy and how to plan the strategy,
will have an impact on the progress of the organization through the activities of analysis,
selection and implementation of strategies that have been set (Johnson and Scholes (2003:
153).
From the above understanding, the main conclusion can be drawn that the strategy; First,
is a comprehensive and integrated organizational plan needed to achieve organizational goals;
Second, the preparation of strategies requires environmental analysis, because the
environment will determine the strengths and weaknesses of the organization; Third, the
achievement of organizational goals is faced with various alternative strategic choices that
must be considered; Fourth, the strategy that has been chosen will be implemented by the
organization and requires evaluation.
To illustrate more clearly the elements of strategic management, Robson (2012: 10)
provides an illustration in Figure 3.1.
From Figure 3.1, there are three stages that must be passed in implementing a strategy.
Company leaders before determining the strategy to be carried out, are expected to be able to
first analyze the strategy to be implemented, by analyzing the environment both internal and
external to the company, then analyzing the culture of the environment, and considering the
resources owned both natural resources, human resources and other resources. After
analyzing the strategy, then select the strategy to be implemented, by identifying alternative
options, then preparing an evaluation to then choose one of the most appropriate strategies.
The next stage is the implementation of the chosen strategy by determining the system and
personnel to be empowered in the institution, then creating an organizational structure to then
plan and allocate available resources.
From the three elements of strategy that have been stated above, according to Mintzberg
(2003) in Robson (2012: 16), there are ten provisions in planning corporate strategy which
are distinguished prescriptively how the strategy can be formulated and what must be done to
plan the company. Prescriptive interpretation will include designing, planning and
positioning the company. While descriptively will concern; ownership, awareness,
production process, political sensitivity, culture and corporate environment. The strategic
planning process is illustrated in the following figure:
3.1
The Effect of Information Technology Use on Corporate Strategy
Information technology (IT) is potentially a strategy, this implies that technological strength
is a description of the company's competitive strategy to be able to compete through changes
in industrial structure. The IT community environment views that IT applications are a part of
corporate strategy, because they are related to the planning and control functions of corporate
organizational management. To further optimize IT, how IT can generate strategic
advantages and what forms of designs or principles are available to exploit and utilize
strategic advantages To answer these two questions, the following diagram will be drawn:
At the top level, everything that is strategic is in the top position, which distinguishes it
from other groups of information systems. At this level it is commonly called the Executive
Information System, meaning that the need for strategic information is the authority of senior
managers or executives. While in the middle (Decision support System) is the responsibility
of managers who are at the middle level, managers who are in that position must be
responsible for implementing the plans that have been set by the executive. Middle-level
managers need information to perform the management control function. The implementation
of each plan can be carried out effectively with the availability of information through the
design of appropriate, effective and efficient information systems.
At the lowest level is part of the responsibility of operations managers by functioning
and monitoring every activity of the company. This means that the responsibilities carried out
are daily transactions, therefore the type of information system needs should be able to
provide facilities for activities that can be taken appropriately, this part is called (Transaction
Processing System).
To further optimize the information technology strategy, it is necessary to discuss in
advance the design architecture needed so that the objectives of the Information Technology
strategy can be achieved. The technology work design architecture consists of 4 elements as
follows:
1.
The processing of data into information through hardware and its relationship with the
software operating system (computing).
2.
Communication is an interrelationship and there is an interrelationship between work or
information (communication)
3.
Data is a company asset that can be used, accessed, controlled and stored (data).
4.
The main application system is the application and use of data to become more
informative. The information technology architecture can be illustrated in the following
Data
Application
Communication
Computing
figure:
The figure above shows the interdependence that each element affects each other. To
restructure information technology in a company, it is necessary to take appropriate steps to
further validate the principles or factors that affect it in the form of parameters, schemes,
policies and plans. Therefore, architectural actions are often associated with changes in the
management of corporate information resources.
There are 4 levels that guide the technology work design, the four levels form a work
design as follows:
1.
Parameters; are general design parameters for each architectural element. They show the
essential needs, constraints and time preferences in achieving the overall goal.
2.
Schemas; are the physical logic and models required for each architectural element and
how it should work.
3.
Policies; is a practical and tangible statement of how each technology element is
delivered, by including elements of technology policies, procedural guidelines and
standards.
4.
Plan; each company makes a number of plans with their own goals, where each plan
implementation consists of several stages, then the implementation shows movement
from the previous stage to the next stage, which is called evolution.
The formulation of information technology strategy has an impact on the information
management carried out, in a way:
1. Information technology information is a resource that is needed and managed effectively
and efficiently.
2. Information technology can affect business management, because information
technology is an integral part of the overall management of the company.
3. Business strategy depends on the availability of adequate information technology
4. Information technology is something that is inherent in business and corporate
management and organizational life.
Information technology is a company's competitive strategy, information technology
applications are the embodiment of strategic plans that have been set in the form of planning
and controlling the implementation of strategies. Information technology can assist
companies in creating products and services, which are able to compete with other
companies, in addition to being able to create product advantages that are different from their
competitors.
The confusion that occurs over the company is made possible by various basic policies
and implementation strategies that are not based on the integrity of concepts and
philosophies. A lot of thought is only devoted to micro issues, which are directly related to
the routine activities of the company. Even so, there are still many micro problems that have
not been resolved properly, due to the lack of clarity of the company's psychological and
philosophical foundations. No less important in this case is the lack of a solid foundation of
the company that can be seen from a macro perspective, social, cultural, economic and
political foundations. There is also a lack of consistency and coherence between one
foundation of thought and another at the micro and macro levels.
In the broadest sense or macro order, it is necessary to develop from being reactive and
proactive towards the development of society to being socially reconstructionistic. Being
socially reconstructionistic means that the company actively participates in giving shape and
direction to the development of the society it aspires to. In order to be self-reliant and reach
excellence, this philosophy needs to be translated into The company's strategy is visionary,
provides more strategic added value, and can improve human dignity. The company's
strategy needs to be designed to be able to reach long-term alternatives that can produce
significant changes for the company's future sustainability, in order to have a comparative
and competitive advantage over other companies.
In order for the company to have an advantage and be accepted by its consumers, it is
necessary to apply various supporting criteria, namely:
1.
Implementation of Integrated Quality Management (TQM); in line with the demands of
national and global markets, a company must be able to produce quality products and
services. Quality products/services cannot be achieved without integrated quality control
implemented through the consistent application of the company's integrated quality
management (TQM). To achieve this goal, the most important TQM occurs within the
scope of each division of the company as the spearhead in an effort to improve the
quality of the company in an integrated manner, called by Arcaro (1995) with Total
Quality Services (TQS). He mentioned five pillars of TQS, namely; (a) Focused on the
Customer (service users), (b) The total involvement of all elements (total involvement),
(c) The existence of certain measures (standards), (d) The existence of commitment (e)
Continuous improvement. These five pillars are based on beliefs, trust, cooperation and
leadership.
2.
Implementation of Company Management Professionalism; One of the factors that
causes the quality of company products/services to be not encouraging is the low level of
professionalism of company management. This is related to many factors, the most
important of which is the weak commitment of bureaucrats and company management to
achieve excellence and their lack of skills in managing companies with an increasingly
complex spectrum of tasks and problems. To streamline the implementation of company
programs, the principles of professionalism in company management must be applied.
For this reason, company management is required to continuously improve knowledge,
attitudes, and skills in managing the company. It is not enough for company managers to
only capitalize on the will or trust imposed on them, but they must also master strategic
management professionally, so that the existence of the company can be relied upon as a
hope that will realize individual goals, company goals and stockholder goals.
3.2
Change Strategy from Power to Empowerment
Change is key in an increasingly complex and turbulent business environment. Driven by
increasingly intense technological developments, global competition, the crisis of economic
and environmental conditions and the development of other external macro conditions, each
company will make changes in unpredictable and uncertain situations.
In addition, it is necessary to understand 3 paradigms of information evolution, namely:
First, the application of information in all its forms as a commodity or asset parallel to (Man,
Money, Material); Second, the application of the order caused by the existence of information
dynamics as a separate ecosystem identical to the physical-biological system; Third, the
development of information technology that is applied as an enabler of corporate
organizations in addition to human resources.
Developments in the field of organizational management in the last 10 years are a global
product of information evolution, this is the impact of the application of Knowledge
Management (Knowledge Management) and Organizational Learning (Learning
Organization). Information Technology, Knowledge Management, and Organizational
Learning based on information or assets, is the work of managers of large companies in
developed countries as one of the conditions if a company wants to have competitiveness,
innovative power and effectiveness in controlling the 3 M assets (man, money, material).
Mastery of the 3 M as an asset has power, while mastery of information or knowledge as a set
is called Empowerment. Ownership of power is vertical, meaning that the higher up, the
stronger an organization is. On the other hand, ownership of empowerment is horizontal,
meaning that the wider the empowerment, the stronger an organization. The reality that
occurs in the process of globalization, which is less realized by various groups, is that anyone
who has empowerment is able to outperform those who only rely on power.
Davenport (2006) first described the existence of a non-physical environment as a reality
in life that has similar properties to the physical biological environment. This environment is
referred to as an information ecology or Information Ecosystem. The existence of this
ecosystem has existed for a long time, but the growth rate of information in the form of
knowledge is relatively low. Since computer science has advanced rapidly accompanied by
the rapid development of information technology, the quantity of information in the form of
knowledge has more than doubled. The rapid development of information technology is
exponential, resulting in the complexity of the environment and the complexity of the
substance of decision making. Thus, the ecosystem in the decision-making pattern
experiences obstacles due to this complexity. So it requires the integration of several
diversities of information that have the ability to evolve, the need for observation and
description that focuses on humans and the behavior of information itself.
Understanding the information ecosystem is essential to understanding the era of high
uncertainty, as well as a bridge to understanding the role of information technology,
knowledge management and organizational learning.
3.3
The Role of Information Technology
Management Information System:
Information technology is a manifestation of the development of information science
or theory. The development of information technology in the form of application systems,
operating systems and hardware in the last decade is very rapid resulting in an exponential
increase in the quantity of knowledge as a result of information transformation, the
transformation in question is a human product with or without the help of information
technology.
The exponential increase in knowledge not only brings a lot of benefits to the company,
but on the other hand it becomes a burden for company managers. The burden is the problem
of adapting company management to an information ecosystem full of turbulence,
complexity and uncertainty. Therefore, the role of information technology is needed, without
the help of adequate information technology, the existence of the company will be threatened,
this is possible because the existence of information technology will help the quantity of
human resource work transactionally, geographically, automatically and sequentially.
The phenomenon of information technology in practice is less able to be appreciated by
the company's top managers, leaders and decision makers, because there are some groups of
people in the company that the existence of information technology is "feared" because it is
too sophisticated, this is because the socialization of information technology lacks
educational aspects. But if it is observed more deeply that the ability of information
technology will facilitate the operationalization of the company, because seen from the nature
of information technology aims at adaptive not optimization.
According to Browning (2000) information technology is no longer considered a
business resource, but is considered a business environment. As Malhotra (2003) states; the
growth and development of an organization depends on the effective use of information
technology that combines organizational structure with environmental preferences and the
creation of symbiosis between organizational elements. The advantages of existing
information technology are inseparable from limitations, among the limitations of
information technology, are: First, no matter how high the advantages of information
technology, decision making remains in the strength and skills of the company's human
resources. This is because the level of development of information technology to date has not
been able to transform knowledge of wisdom. So humans are still required as experts in
strategy. Second, that there is no correlation between the selection of the type and price of
information technology with the profits obtained by a company, because no matter how good
the technology owned depends entirely on the process and strategy of managing information
by humans.
3.4
Information Transformation as Knowledge
Information can be transformed into knowledge after the information is understood in
terms of patterns and principles. The method of transforming information in individuals
depends on the results of previous learning in the form of cognitive (accumulated
knowledge), psychomotor (motor skills) and affective (behavior) experiences. Both
individuals and organizations must learn and function in transforming knowledge
information. The quality and quantity of the transformation of information into knowledge is
a key issue in the era of globalization, because transformed knowledge becomes policy in the
decision-making process. After information into knowledge has 6 characteristics, namely:
Practicality, Contextual, Experiential, Historical, Social and Individual. Currently, knowledge
has been recognized in corporate organizations as an asset that is equal to 3M, although it is
still intangible. Cumulatively for audit purposes, knowledge is referred to as intellectual
capital.
(Intellectual capital must be identified, documented and measured.
One of the methods used to measure knowledge or intellectual capital is the Balanced
Scorecard, which in addition to traditional financial measures, includes aspects of customers,
internal business processes and learning/growth: The Balanced Scorecard, in addition to
measuring traditional financial aspects, includes customer aspects, internal business processes
and learning/growth processes. Thus, wealth empowerment can also be measured, meaning
that in this era of globalization, the knowledge aspect (intellectual capital) has been
recognized as a very important asset in the company due to the development of knowledge
management oriented as a commodity.
Knowledge management is closely related to the adaptability of an organization in the
face of complex environmental changes, knowledge management is essentially centered on
the process of improving the ability to process data and information into intellectual assets
(knowledge) aimed at increasing productivity, creativity competitiveness and new values in
human resources. For knowledge management to be effective, there must be collaboration
with those responsible for information technology and organizational learning, with the aim
of auditing knowledge, establishing the ontology (nature of occurrence) of knowledge,
managing implementation strategies and establishing software to support the decision-making
process.
Some of the rapidly growing implementation strategies regarding knowledge
management practices are; Bencmarking, Downsizing, Outsourcing, Micro Management,
Business Process Reengineering (BPR), and Internet data Mining. These strategies basically
aim to make the organization leaner or horizontal, clearer core competencies, distributed
control, centralized communication mechanisms that make all elements of the organization
more empowered. One of the An alternative method of technology for companies to get
empowered results is through total reform that is carried out systematically by adhering to
knowledge management patterns through Business Process Reengineering (BPR). According
to Obolensky (1994), total reform is a company's effort to change its internal processes and
controls from a traditional functional vertical hierarchy, to a leaner and horizontal structure,
cross-functional and teamwork that focuses on the process of customer satisfaction and
comfort.
Total reform efforts that embrace business process reengineering (BPR) will be
characterized as fundamental, radical, dramatic and process-oriented. It will "hurt" many
parties as a sacrifice. Total reform can be planned starting from top strategic planning in the
form of vision and mission, then translated into mid-level planning that enters all sectors of
corporate life and finally to the operational level in the form of "Standard Operational
Procedures" (SOP).
Nowadays it is increasingly realized that only by learning a company is able to adapt to
its uncertain and complex environment, although individual human resources have learned,
but it does not guarantee that the company itself has learned and is able to face the tight
competition that exists. Learning organization can be achieved with the characteristics of the
learner is a team or team learning, common vision, mental models, individual deepening, and
system thinking. Thus, the learning organization has similar goals with elements of
technology and knowledge management, namely increasing the ability to face global
competition.
In addition to the learning organization, elements of technology and knowledge
management without adequate leadership criteria, in the face of global competition the
company is considered unable to compete because all of these elements must be controlled by
strong leadership and character. Strong leadership and character contain 3 potential elements
as follows: (1) principle-center leadership (principle-center leadership) means that leaders
must master and carry out the principles of regulating the effectiveness of human and
corporate organizations, (2) Character-based leadership (Character-based leadership)
leaders must have moral integrity, (3) value-based leadership (value-based leadership)
leaders who are able to adapt to the dynamics of the times. For the current competitive era,
value-based leaders are needed, able to adapt to the development of technology and
information as well as having empowerment, therefore the preferred company leader is to
have a forward-looking vision that has horizontal strengths that are able to manage
knowledge assets, information technology and learning organizations. This kind of corporate
leader has empowerment and ensures the growth of competitive, innovative companies in
global competition.
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY FROM AN ENTERPRISE PERSPECTIVE:
Information Technology (IT) is another term for computer technology, which is
specialized in processing data into useful information for a company. IT continues to develop
in terms of shape, size, speed, and the ability to access multimedia and computer networks.
This development is due to the high level of competition between computer processor
manufacturers such as Intel, Motorola, Apple, DEC and others.
The development of processors has reached a very high level of speed in the last ten
years. If you look in detail at the development of each processor series, it almost coincides
with the creation of new processors with increasingly higher specifications.
Competition in processor development has driven the growth of the IT industry, as each
new processor is created, requiring new specifications, specifically associated with RAM and
secondary memory capacity such as hard disk. The creation of processors with new
specifications has challenged software manufacturers to keep up by creating new operating
systems and applications capable of optimizing processor specifications and hardware
devices as a whole;
4.1
Waves of Innovation Technology
Information technology has now become a very interesting conversation, considering that
information technology is one of the important elements that can encourage the competitive
advantage of a company, both business organizations and social organizations. It is believed
that a company that can master information technology will win the competition. For
example, in the banking business world, currently the excellence and success of a bank,
especially private banking, is very much supported by information technology, such as Bank
Central Asia (BCA) which offers various types of products loaded with information
technology, for example to facilitate customer service provided by Internet banking klick
BCA, ATMs which are all based on information technology, so that customers to transact
with the bank are easier, faster and the results are more accurate. In addition, there are many
more benefits of information technology developed by BCA in order to maintain its
marketing performance. BCA's success in developing information technology based on
internet banking is now followed by almost all banks in Indonesia, both private and
government-owned banks. This proves how powerful the ability of information technology is
in pampering its customers, in addition to being a very strong competitive tool.
Not only in the service-based banking world, manufacturing companies today do not
want to be left behind, which have successfully developed information technology in
supporting their learning process. Both primary, secondary and tertiary education institutions.
In addition to being able to develop networks with related parties such as the Ministry of
National Education, educational institutions at home and abroad, so that they can adopt
learning patterns that are easier, faster, have added value (value added) and are innovative in
finding new formulations to provide additional knowledge and skills for their students.
According to Budi Sutedjo (2012: 49), the wave of internet-based information
technology has developed through the following stages:
1.
In the first wave, IT utilization is focused on increasing productivity and minimizing
costs. Organizations that began to implement the technology would automate their
routine activities, such as correspondence, presentation slides, making tables and balance
sheets. Applications used include Word, Excel, Power Point and Access.
2.
The second wave; IT focused on improving the effectiveness of computer equipment use
through the construction of computer networks. This network is built by connecting
computers using cables and network cards so that printers, hard disks and other
equipment can be used simultaneously. This network can save investment costs and
speed up the distribution of data and information.
3.
The third wave, IT is focused on generating profits through the development of
information system programs. As in a University building a network of academic
administration service information systems, financial administration service information
systems and general service information systems, all of which are based on information
technology and benefit both the University and the students served.
4.
The fourth wave; IT is focused on assisting the decision-making process from qualitative
data. Such as the development of a decision support system (DSS/Decision Support
System) for employee recruitment, employee performance appraisal, employee career
advancement and so on (back office).
5.
Fifth wave; IT focused on reaching customers (consumers) through the development of
internet networks. Building a massive exploration of the internet. So in this case, what is
called electronic Business (e-Business), e-Commerce was born in the business world,
which is able to reach unlimited local, national and global consumers.
6.
The Sixth Wave; IT is developing wireless networking systems. The system allows a
person to access the internet through a computer connected to a cellular phone. Even in
the future, the internet can be accessed directly through cell phones. This wave of
innovation shows that IT can be used for effective communication with consumers and
partners.
4.2
Positive and Negative Synergies of Information Systems and Corporate Strategy
In developing a corporate strategy plan, one of the tasks is to create a portfolio of company
operations and recommend suitable strategies for each company. The portfolio is built by
considering various things such as the company's financial performance, the company's
competitive position, estimated future conditions and various other aspects. Conceptually, the
creation of a company's strategic planning is nothing difficult, but when starting to collect
information in making portfolios in the field, various obstacles arise such as competitive
conditions, company growth, company market share, and predictions of the company's future.
These constraints have an impact on the judgment made on strategic issues, and this will
affect the quality of the company's strategic planning that will be produced.
But there is one company in the process of collecting information for portfolio creation
can do it easily, because the company has synergized Information Systems with all company
activities, especially in creating a database to prepare strategic planning, and it can certainly
accelerate the process of preparing the company's strategy.
Reflecting on the discourse above, there are negative and positive synergies between
information systems and corporate strategy. In the first picture, information systems are not
able to provide the information needed by company management in the decision-making
process because they are not supported by existing information systems. In the concept of
information systems that has been known for a long time, information plays a very important
role in making decisions, including strategic decisions. The inability of the company's
information system to provide the information needed will have an impact on the company's
strategy. The resulting impact is a corporate strategy that doubts decision makers, because it
is compiled based on limited information and this is the resulting negative synergy.
Meanwhile, positive synergy is the synergy between a well-presented information
system and an adequate understanding of corporate strategy. Both will produce a good
corporate strategy and can be accounted for.
The matrix presented in the figure above is compiled based on phenomena that exist in
companies in general. If the synergy of the two elements (Information Systems and Corporate
Strategy) can be carried out ideally, then the synergy that occurs is positive, while on the
contrary, if the two elements are synergized inappropriately, negative synergies will occur. If
you look at what is meant by information systems conceptually, namely information systems
that are able to provide relevant, accurate and understandable information, adequate
simulation facilities, and on time to management, so that they can be used to make decisions.
In Quadrant I, the role of the consultant is not too great and in this case the company's
consultant is only a second opinion. Because the company has successfully developed the
strategy it implements.
In Quadrant II, the use of company consultants is not effective, because what is needed
is the search for information sources, the more appropriate consultant needed is an
Information Systems Consultant. So that the information system to be used can find the right
strategy in improving the company.
In Quadrant III, the company's condition is quite severe, because the company needs
fundamental improvements, both revamping information systems and understanding of
company strategy.
The company's consultant will be effective if the company's condition is in quadrant IV,
because in this condition the consultant can be a guide for the process of preparing the
company's strategic planning. To analyze the company's position on the matrix, because the
company will make decisions on various steps forward, whether to make fundamental
improvements or make improvements for improvement, able to provide relevant, accurate
and understandable information, adequate simulation facilities, and timely to management, so
that it can be used to make decisions.
4.3
Human-Centered Approach to Management Company
In line with the development of human life, the development of science and
technology in various fields of life has made rapid progress. The progress of science in the
field of business is no exception, which has given rise to new concepts and strategies. These
new concepts and strategies are then applied in practice by several companies that have the
opportunity to take advantage of the efficacy of these concepts and strategies. In practice, the
application of a company's concepts and strategies usually requires the application of other
concepts, either because of their inherent nature or as a support for the main strategic
concept. In addition, the application of one of the concepts and strategies implemented in the
company will affect the entire company system.
The emergence of various concepts and strategies in the company is related to the
competitive situation between existing companies. However, the emergence of the
phenomenon of competition is triggered by the rapid development and changes in
information technology that are increasingly sophisticated. The rapid development of
information technology has made many companies so valuable, because the value of the
information produced has a strategic meaning in the pattern of developing company
management. Thus information technology will be a must in managing a company, in order
to be able to develop a higher quality learning pattern and have value for its customers.
To be able to master optimal information technology, at least general prerequisites are
needed which include the readiness of both human resources and material resources.
Resource readiness is not something that is easy to fulfill, therefore companies must look for
certain alternatives that are most profitable and appropriate. One of these efforts is the
information technology outsourcing strategy, which is a strategy of mastering and utilizing
information technology by companies through third parties (Ludigdo, 2007). But this strategy
does not always provide optimal benefits and contains a number of risks, so insourcing in the
utilization of information technology becomes the main alternative.
Considering the fact that the operationalization of information technology will involve
humans and at the same time have the impact of changes caused by it, information
management should pay attention to human factors that affect the successful use of
information technology. The importance of paying in-depth attention to the existence of
human factors in information management will be related to the technological factors
themselves. Because as revealed by Luthans (2005: 27), the existence of information
technology has dramatically affected the overall organizational structure. In addition,
information technology (related to its advantages); has played a striking role in forecasting
changes in organizational structures and processes (Robey and Azevedo, 2004).
In this regard, we will elaborate on; (1) Information Technology and Competitive
Advantage, (2) Human Factors in Information Management, (3) Human-Centered
Approaches VS Machine-Centered Approaches.
1.
Information Technology and Competitive Advantage; The relationship between information
technology and competitive advantage of institutions is that institutions need to cost-
effectively develop information technology capabilities for information technology
investment, produce appropriate systems, and achieve learning objectives with information
technology implementation. Another thing that institutions might do is to consider two
relatively new strategic approaches that, when combined appropriately, will increase the
institution's resources.- in increasing its competitiveness. According to Quinn & Hilmer,
2004) there are two strategies that can be combined, namely: (a) Concentrate resources to
achieve excellence and provide unique value to customers. (b) Seeking more strategic
external resources. This shows that the existence of information systems and the right
strategy will play a role in the institution -, and allow the institution - to obtain information
about the internal conditions of the institution -, the position of the institution - in the
competitive arena, the position of the institution - competitors, and changes in the external
environment of the institution - in order to determine the next strategy. As a component of
information systems, information technology has played a role in various aspects, ranging
from the development of services, to support services to its customers, as well as providing
tools for analyzing the decision-making process.
Information technology is a controller for the emergence of various demands and
efforts to make changes, both in the structure and organizational processes of institutions,
such as reengineering, restructuring, reorganizing or redesigning as well as changes in the
form of replacing manual systems to automation. In addition, there are several benefits from
the application of information technology by an institution including institutions - in order to
achieve competitive advantage, although not all benefits can be quantified financially.
Expectations for the mastery and development of information technology capabilities are
actually related to its consistency in providing, identifying and implementing opportunities to
meet strategic needs faster, better and cheaper than competitors.
2.
Human Factors in Information Management; An institution - can succeed in competition
not because it only applies certain information technology, but has developed a certain
capability to apply information technology in the face of change. The capability in question is
an investment in information technology that is not limited to the value of information, but
concerns the process of mastering it. Who uses the information value, when it is used and in
what situations it is used. The value of the institution's information technology capability -
depending on human assets, technology and the relationship between technology and
institutional management -, also shows that human assets have a very important role in
mastering and developing information technology. Thus, human assets together with the
other two assets can increase the value of the institution. Institutions with valuable human
assets distribute the responsibility for solving management problems to each member of the
information technology staff. The characteristics of valuable human assets are staff who
consistently solve management problems and point out opportunities for improvement
through available information technology. With a combination of formal training, work
experience, and focused leadership, information technology staff can accumulate competence
and technological knowledge to become relevant. The relationship between people as
institutional assets - with technology assets and relationship assets in order to increase the
value of the institution - so that it is able and can win the competition, as illustrated in the
figure below:
The picture shows and at the same time becomes an argument regarding the importance
of human factors to achieve success in mastering and utilizing information technology. But in
reality, it is not uncommon for company management in an effort to achieve competitive
advantage to prioritize information technology elements, and instead ignore human resources.
3.
Human-Centered Approaches Vs Machine-Centered Approaches; For users of various
information in institutions -, only one thing must be considered, namely effective information
management starts with thinking how people use information instead of thinking how people
use machines. The approach used in information management that emphasizes thinking
about how people use information is the Human-Centered Approach. Meanwhile, those
that emphasize how people use machines (tools) are called Machine-Centered Approach or
Information architecture (Dapenvort, 2004). Some things that distinguish between Human-
Centered and Machine-Centered in information management are technology and process
design. In machine-centered, technology and processes are designed to simplify what
machines (computers) will process, and humans are expected to adjust to the weaknesses and
limitations of computers. Whereas in Human-Centered design, it is stated that technology and
processes are designed to make human work systems more effective and satisfying. This
shows that information technology is not a very important thing in the mastery of information
management funds, because as a human-centered design, the technology and processes are
designed to make human work systems more effective and satisfying.
4.4
Information System Security, Moral, Ethical and Legal Information Technology:
A.
System Security Information:
Information system security is a very important part of ensuring the integrity of data and the
quality of information to be produced. Several procedures have been formulated to protect
data and information, both from intentional factors and technical and ethical problems that
are expected to damage, eliminate or hinder the distribution of data and information.
The efforts made technically to overcome this are by developing a shared vision to
protect and secure data and information. The vision that has been prepared is outlined in the
form of control management procedures so that all components in the organization are
involved in security. Therefore, securing data and information is not only the responsibility of
the information stem section, but the responsibility of all components involved in the
organization.
According to Hary Gunarto in Budi Sutedjo (2012: 191-210} there are three types of
data and information control as follows: (a) Information System Control, (b) Procedural
Control, (c) and Facility Control. The three control procedures, if formulated and
implemented properly, are believed to provide optimal security for the data and information
contained in the Information System, and are able to reduce the risk of security disturbances
to the Information System as a whole.
1.
Information System Control; this control is a way and effort to ensure that the accuracy and
validity of information system activities can be carried out when and where the activity is
operated. Control needs to be created to carry out data input activities, processing activities,
and data storage, so that system implementation can be carried out properly and safely.
Control in this case is planned to monitor and maintain the quality and security of input
equipment, processes, outputs, storage activities and distribution of information systems.
First, the quality of input determines the final result of processing, so in this case it is known
as garbage in, garbage out, meaning that errors when inputting data will produce incorrect
information. Input control consists of: (a) the use of a password and log-in name system will
limit who can access the information system, (b) detection of the data entry process, for
example, numeric fields cannot be filled in alphabetically and vice versa, (c) code entry, if in
the Administrative Services section.
For example, male and female student codes, department codes, class codes and
others. Second, process control where the computer will process data with predetermined
procedures. Process control is needed to ensure that the procedure is free from arithmetic and
logical calculation errors. Process control related to computer equipment will include: (a)
connection of supporting equipment to check code detection, (b) ensuring that the processor
used has no errors, (c) checking the compatibility of the previous program with the new
program used, (d) the availability of procedures to prevent errors from occurring, it is
necessary to provide prevention procedures through the appearance of dialog boxes that
provide information about the correct procedure. Third, output control is carried out to ensure
that the information produced does not occur errors. This is very important, considering that
the output of the Information System will be used for decision support. Standard output
control steps are carried out through; (a) checking the documents and reports produced,
whether they are in accordance with the actual calculation results, (b) checking all outputs
whether they are in accordance with the input given. Fourth, storage control of both the
process and the equipment used, this type of control includes; (a) Harddisk damage can be in
the form of physical damage or end of life, so to secure data is done with efforts; Disk
Mirroring, which is an effort to duplicate the hard disk on one data line, so that at the same
time the data is directly stored on two hard disks. Or with Disk Duplexing, which is an
attempt to duplicate the hard disk but on a different data path. This method is similar to the
disk mirroring method, the difference is that in the disk duplexing method the first and
second hard drives are made on different paths, so that if there is damage to one herdisk data
path, the server can still operate.
(b) Viruses, is a problem that is quite complicated because computer viruses can
spread quickly, both through the medium of diskettes and computer networks and the
internet. To deal with viruses practically, steps can be taken by installing and activating anti-
virus programs, such as McAfee.com Clinic (www. mcafee. com\ McAfee VirusScan Asap
(www. mcafeeasap. com), Symantec Norton AntiVirm 2001 (www. Symantec, com) and so
on. The program must be continuously updated in order to keep up with the development of
the types of viruses that are spread. (c) Control of Information Systems related to the
distribution process of data and information. Control of this distribution process includes;
1). Checking the network system used to distribute data from the transaction terminal to the
server and the information distribution path from the server to the intended terminals, 2).
Unstable electrical voltage or sudden blackouts can cause damage to a number of hard disks
connected in the network system. 3) Threat of damage to data and computers from skipping
free electrons due to lightning, especially for the network and internet environment in an
institution/organization.
2.
Procedural Controls; To keep information services secure enough, in addition to
Information System controls, procedural controls are needed that regulate effective and
efficient personnel administration operating procedures. Matters that must be formulated in
preparing procedural controls include: (a) data and program backup procedures that are
adjusted to the level of urgency, (b) procedures for entering the computer network
environment in the organizational environment and procedures when leaving and leaving it,
(c) work division procedures between information technology management staff based on
their expertise and abilities.
3.
Facility Control and Security Efforts; this is done to protect the physical facilities of
Information Technology-based Information Systems and their supporting equipment from
damage and theft. Facility control efforts can be carried out, among others, by compressing in
order to maintain the level of data traffic density on the network, encryption and description
to maintain the security of data on the hard disk or that is passing through the network.
B.
Morals, Ethics and Technology Law Information
According to McLeod in Budi Sutedjo (2011: 90) Moral is a habit of believing in good or bad
behavior, therefore morals are social institutions that have a history and a series of rules
where all individuals must have responsibility for the behavior of their society, these morals
learn rules about behavior since a person is a child. Meanwhile, ethics is a set of guidelines
that must be followed, has standards or ideals that are accepted by individuals, groups or an
information technology community.
According to James H. Moor in Budi Sutedjo (2011: 208) information technology ethics
acts as a tool for analyzing the nature and social impact of information technology, as well as
formulating and justifying policies for using information technology. Ethics is used to
analyze the nature and socio-economic impact of the use of information technology and
efforts to accept and appreciate all activities that lead to the operation and improvement of
information technology services, as well as efforts to avoid or prevent things that threaten,
damage, and kill information technology activities directly or indirectly.
The most important ethical issues include violations of intellectual property rights, such
as the use of pirated software, e-mail bombs, hackers, crackers, privacy, freedom of access to
pornography and information technology law. Recently, many discussion forums have
encouraged the establishment of information technology law, which is expected to be the
foundation for managing the internet community.
According to Hary Gunarto in Budi Sutedjo (2011: 209) the basic ethical philosophy that
will be outlined in information technology law is often expressed in four kinds of universal
human values including; the right to solitude (the right not to be disturbed), anonymity (the
right not to be known), intimicy (the right not to be monitored) and reserve (the right to be
able to maintain individual information, (so that it is kept confidential). Hinca Panjaitan in
Onno W Purbo, (2000) adds that what needs to be accommodated again is the right to access
information or knowledge and the right to communicate. Deborah Johnson (2008) gives an
opinion that needs to be considered in the ethics of information technology, namely the right
to computer access, the right to computer expertise, the right to computer specialization, the
right to computer decision making.
Obstacles to the application of ethics and law in information technology and the internet
include the different understanding of ethics and law in each social group, both in developed
and developing countries.
According to Hary Gunarto and Budi Sutedjo (2011: 210) although the ethical and legal
issues of information technology and the internet are very complex, some actions and
behaviors that are considered unethical according to international agreements have been
successfully formulated, such as:
a)
Access to places they are not entitled to
b)
Damaging computer and network facilities
c)
Wasting every resource related to people, computers, hard disk space, and
communication bandwidth.
d)
Eliminate or damage the integrity and cooperation between computer systems
e)
Interfering with the confidentiality of individuals or organizations
Laws are formal rules of behavior, authority or power, governance that define subjects or
citizenship. Some countries have succeeded in concretizing regulations to address actions that
are considered to violate ethics into the form of laws or Information Technology laws, for
example
a)
Canada with types of legislation; Telecommunication Act, BroadcastingAct,
Radiocommunication Act, and Criminal Code
b)
The United States with laws; Freedom of information Act, Privacy Protection Act, Computer
Security Act, Electronic Communication Privacy j Act, Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, Wire
Fraud Act, and Telecommunication Act.
After discussing the boundaries of morals, ethics and law put forward by McLeod, then
the relation to information technology used in the order of The organization must meet these
three criteria, namely morally, ethically and applicable law. Information technology used in a
company is a guide for a leader and his subordinates who must have moral values, ethics,
special information and as a form of law enforcement application. Therefore, the use of
information technology in every organizational activity, especially companies, requires a
better ethical culture, where the company is the center of ethics that is used as an example for
employees and all human elements involved in the company.
The need for ethical culture is needed especially in the pattern of relationships between
leaders and companies, this is the basis for determining ethical culture. If in a company will
realize ethics, then first the leadership of the company must implement ethics both through
words and deeds, because the leadership of the company is an example for subordinates.
In instilling an ethical culture in the company, there are three forms of implementation
that must be considered, namely:
1.
Establish a corporate credo, which is a short statement that upholds the company's
values, formed through commitments with its customers, the actors involved in the
company, and commitments with society in general.
2.
An Ethics Program is a system that designs multiple activities to facilitate leaders and
subordinates involved in the company to understand the company ethically.
3.
Developing a company's own code of ethics or adapting to codes of ethics created by
other institutions; for example, professional codes of ethics, business ethics, etc.
The elements that make up the ethical culture in the company can be depicted in the
diagram in Figure 4.3.
Furthermore, Leod (2012) suggests that in planning ethical information technology
operations, it must fulfill 10 stages of ethical standards, namely:
a.
Formulating the notion of ethics
b.
Establish procedures through existing regulations
c.
Setting sanctions
d.
Acknowledging ethical behavior
e.
Focusing on training programs
f.
Carry out assigned responsibilities
g.
Encourage ethical rehabilitation programs
h.
Encourage the participation of professional societies to create a code of ethics
i.
Establishing an exemplary culture
Logical Malleability, Transformation Factor and Invisibility Factor, these are explained
as follows:
a)
Logical Flexibility; that information technology application tools will do the things that their
creators, namely programmers, want. The programmer himself will use his analysis to
capture the type of user needs, as a basis for designing the application he makes. Because for
information technology users, computers are black boxes made by information technology
practitioners.
b)
Transformation Factor; the presence of information technology in the business world is not
only able to increase the effectiveness and efficiency of work, but will directly change the
ways in which company employees carry out their daily activities. For example, how
Electronic Mail (e-mail) can replace traditional correspondence communication, the internet
replaces the information center, the database system replaces the archive storage cabinet. The
concept of ethics develops in the transformation phenomenon, because it has shifted the
paradigm and mechanism of the company's daily activities, both between internal
components and external components. Without ethics, the world of information technology
will easily take advantage of the transformation trend.
c)
The Invisibility Factor; Computer as a black box and information technology will work
according to the installed application. This Invisibility Factor is the "opportunity" that is most
widely used by information technology criminals, because often the leaders of organizations
including companies leave the development of applications entirely to the appointed
programmers.