Critical Appraisal

Instructions

Purpose

In the Matrix Table assignment in Unit 3, you provided four resources that, after your survey/analysis/synthesis of the literature, support the  intervention  you determined is the optimum choice for your scholarship project. 

Directions

For this assignment, you are required to utilize the appropriate JBI Critical Appraisal Tool for each of those 4 resources. The appraisal tools can be accessed from your Unit 3 learning resources or by utilizing the following link:  https://jbi.global/critical-appraisal-toolsLinks to an external site. 

After you have determined which of the Tools is appropriate for each resource, you will download the Word file of the Tool and fill it out completely. You will have a total of 4 completed Tools. 

When completing each JBI Critical Appraisal tool, you must do more than select Yes/No/Unclear/Not Applicable.  For each checklist item, include a brief rationale (1-2 sentences) explaining why you selected that response based on the evidence from the article.

In addition, you must upload a PDF of the full-text article for each resource.  Within each PDF, highlight or annotate the specific sections of the article that correspond to your responses for the JBI checklist items. This documentation should clearly show where you located the information used to make each appraisal judgement. 

Once you have completed the 4 Tools, you will download the assignment template.  

The first 2 columns in the template are self-explanatory

Having conducted a critical appraisal of the 4 resources for this assignment, in column 3, you will discuss if the outcome of your appraisal provides satisfactory support for the intervention you have identified, OR if your appraisal suggests you need to return to the literature to find additional, more suitable support for your selected intervention.    

Indicate ‘Include’ or ‘Not Include’ in the 3rd column and provide your discussion about the outcome of your appraisal, and if it provides support for your identified intervention, or if you need to search for additional support.

Please be sure to validate your opinions and ideas with citations and references in APA format. 

The assignment requires you to upload all four PDF file of the full-text article that supports the intervention with highlighted or annotated sections corresponding to the JBI checklist items for your faculty to review.

Upload all 4 of your completed appraisal tools and the assignment template document to this assignment

Instructions

Purpose

In the Matrix Table assignment in Unit 3, you provided four resources that, after your survey/analysis/synthesis of the literature, support the  intervention  you determined is the optimum choice for your scholarship project. 

Directions

For this assignment, you are required to utilize the appropriate JBI Critical Appraisal Tool for each of those 4 resources. The appraisal tools can be accessed from your Unit 3 learning resources or by utilizing the following link:  https://jbi.global/critical-appraisal-toolsLinks to an external site. 

After you have determined which of the Tools is appropriate for each resource, you will download the Word file of the Tool and fill it out completely. You will have a total of 4 completed Tools. 

When completing each JBI Critical Appraisal tool, you must do more than select Yes/No/Unclear/Not Applicable.  For each checklist item, include a brief rationale (1-2 sentences) explaining why you selected that response based on the evidence from the article.

In addition, you must upload a PDF of the full-text article for each resource.  Within each PDF, highlight or annotate the specific sections of the article that correspond to your responses for the JBI checklist items. This documentation should clearly show where you located the information used to make each appraisal judgement. 

Once you have completed the 4 Tools, you will download the assignment template.  

The first 2 columns in the template are self-explanatory

Having conducted a critical appraisal of the 4 resources for this assignment, in column 3, you will discuss if the outcome of your appraisal provides satisfactory support for the intervention you have identified, OR if your appraisal suggests you need to return to the literature to find additional, more suitable support for your selected intervention.    

Indicate ‘Include’ or ‘Not Include’ in the 3rd column and provide your discussion about the outcome of your appraisal, and if it provides support for your identified intervention, or if you need to search for additional support.

Please be sure to validate your opinions and ideas with citations and references in APA format. 

The assignment requires you to upload all four PDF file of the full-text article that supports the intervention with highlighted or annotated sections corresponding to the JBI checklist items for your faculty to review.

Upload all 4 of your completed appraisal tools and the assignment template document to this assignment