Historical Review Research Paper
1
Historical Review Project: Research Paper
School of Education, Liberty University
Historical Review Research Paper
2
The overrepresentation of African American children in special education,
often referred to as disproportionality, is a pervasive issue in the U.S.
educational system that has significant implications for educational equity
and social justice. This paper explores the factors contributing to this
disproportionality, including systemic biases in assessment and
identification processes, the influence of socioeconomic status, and the
impact of racial inequities within educational institutions. By examining
recent scholarly research and historical perspectives, the paper highlights
the ongoing challenges African American students face in accessing fair and
appropriate education. Additionally, the paper discusses the impact of this
issue on K-12 education, higher education, and the private sector, while also
considering how a biblical worldview informs responses to and solutions for
these disparities. Through policy analysis and ethical reflection, this paper
underscores the need for systemic change to create more inclusive and
equitable educational environments for all students.
Keywords: disproportionality, African American, special education
Historical Review Research Paper
3
The American educational system has long been plagued by issues of
inequality, particularly in how students from different racial and ethnic
backgrounds are treated and served. Among these issues is the
overrepresentation of African American children in special education
programs, a phenomenon that has persisted despite decades of educational
reform and civil rights advocacy. Disproportionality in special education
refers to the unequal representation of a particular racial or ethnic group
within special education programs compared to their representation in the
general student population. For African American students, this
disproportionality often manifests as an overidentification for certain
disability categories, leading to their placement in special education at rates
significantly higher than their white peers (Flynn & Martohardjono, 2021).
The significance of this issue extends beyond the individual students
affected; it reflects broader systemic problems within the educational
system, including racial bias, inadequate resources, and a lack of culturally
responsive teaching and assessment practices (Skiba & Albrecht, 2020).
The consequences of this disproportionality are profound, impacting
students' academic achievement, social development, and long-term life
outcomes. Moreover, the overrepresentation of African American students
in special education has far-reaching implications for society, contributing
to the perpetuation of racial disparities in education, employment, and
social mobility (Losen & Orfield, 2019).
Historical Review Research Paper
4
This paper seeks to explore the numerous factors that contribute to
the disproportionality of African American children in special education and
to examine the impact of this issue on different educational settings,
including K-12 schools, higher education, and the private sector.
Additionally, the paper will consider how a biblical worldview, with its
emphasis on justice, compassion, and the inherent dignity of every
individual, can inform and shape responses to this critical issue. By
addressing both the causes and consequences of disproportionality, this
paper aims to contribute to the ongoing conversation about educational
equity and to advocate for systemic changes that will benefit all students,
regardless of their race or background.
Importance
The issue of disproportionality in special education, particularly the
overrepresentation of African American children, is of critical importance
within the U.S. educational system. Disproportionality refers to the
condition where African American students are identified and placed in
special education programs at rates significantly higher than their peers
from other racial and ethnic backgrounds. This phenomenon raises
concerns about equity, fairness, and the effectiveness of educational
practices and policies in serving all students.
Historically, African American children have been disproportionately
placed in special education categories such as emotional disturbance and
intellectual disabilities, which often come with stigmatizing labels and
Historical Review Research Paper
5
reduced academic expectations (Zhang & Katsiyannis, 2022). This issue is
not merely about numbers; it reflects deeper systemic biases and
inequalities that pervade the educational system. According to Skiba and
Albrecht (2020), culturally biased assessment practices, differential access
to resources, and lack of cultural responsiveness among educators
contribute to this disproportionality. Addressing this issue is not only a
matter of compliance with federal regulations like the Individuals with
Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) but also a moral imperative to ensure that
all children receive a fair and appropriate education.
Significance
The significance of this issue extends beyond the classroom. The
overrepresentation of African American students in special education has
long-term implications for their educational trajectories and life outcomes.
Students who are disproportionately placed in special education are often
subject to lower academic expectations, segregated from their peers, and
deprived of access to rigorous coursework, which can limit their
opportunities for post-secondary education and future employment (Losen
& Orfield, 2019). This systemic issue exacerbates existing racial disparities
in educational achievement and contributes to the broader cycle of poverty
and social inequity.
The persistence of this issue highlights the ongoing challenges within
the educational system to create an equitable environment for all students.
Research by Flynn and Martohardjono (2021) indicates that even when
Historical Review Research Paper
6
controlling for socioeconomic status, African American students are still
more likely to be placed in special education than their white peers,
suggesting that race itself is a significant factor in these decisions. The
implications of these findings are profound, as they call into question the
fairness and objectivity of the processes used to identify students for special
education services.
Impact
The impact of disproportionality in special education is felt across
multiple levels of the educational system, including K-12 schools, higher
education, and the broader societal context. In K-12 settings, the
overrepresentation of African American students in special education can
lead to a self-fulfilling prophecy, where students internalize the lower
expectations placed upon them, resulting in decreased academic
performance and engagement. This, in turn, can lead to higher dropout
rates and lower rates of college enrollment and completion among African
American students (Zhang & Katsiyannis, 2022).
In higher education, the effects of disproportionality are seen in the
underrepresentation of African American students in colleges and
universities, particularly in competitive programs and institutions. This
underrepresentation can be traced back to the tracking and placement
practices in K-12 education, where African American students are less likely
to be placed in advanced coursework that prepares them for college (Flynn
& Martohardjono, 2021). The cumulative effect of these disparities is a
Historical Review Research Paper
7
perpetuation of the educational achievement gap between African American
students and their peers, which has long-term consequences for social
mobility and economic equality.
Moreover, the private sector is also impacted by these disparities, as
the underrepresentation of African American students in higher education
translates into a less diverse workforce. This lack of diversity can limit the
perspectives and innovations within industries and perpetuate racial
inequalities in the labor market. As businesses and industries increasingly
recognize the value of diversity, the need to address educational disparities
becomes even more pressing.
Biblical Worldview
From a biblical worldview, the issue of disproportionality in special
education is seen through the lens of justice, compassion, and the inherent
dignity of every individual. The Bible emphasizes the importance of justice
and equity, as seen in passages such as Micah 6:8, which calls for
individuals to "act justly and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your
God (KJV, 2024)." This principle would compel those with a biblical
worldview to advocate for fair treatment of African American students and
to work towards dismantling the systemic biases that contribute to their
overrepresentation in special education.
Additionally, the biblical teaching of Genesis 1:27 that all individuals
are created in the image of God underscores the inherent worth and dignity
of every student, regardless of race or ability (KJV, 2024). This belief would
Historical Review Research Paper
8
drive efforts to ensure that African American children are given the same
opportunities to succeed as their peers, free from the biases and prejudices
that have historically hindered their educational progress. As Darby and
Rury (2018) argue, the origins of the achievement gap and the ongoing
disparities in education are deeply rooted in historical injustices and a
biblical worldview calls for redressing these wrongs through systemic
change and advocacy.
The biblical emphasis on caring for the marginalized and vulnerable
also informs the response to this issue (KJV, 2024). Those with a biblical
worldview would be moved to compassion for students who have been
unfairly placed in special education and to work towards creating more
inclusive and supportive educational environments. This might involve
advocating for policy changes, supporting culturally responsive teaching
practices, and working to eliminate the biases that lead to
disproportionality in the first place.
Conclusion
The disproportionality of African American children in special
education is a complex issue that reflects broader systemic inequalities
within the U.S. educational system. It has significant implications for the
educational trajectories and life outcomes of African American students,
and it perpetuates the racial achievement gap that has long plagued the
nation's schools. Addressing this issue requires a multifaceted approach
Historical Review Research Paper
9
that includes policy reform, changes in assessment practices, and a
commitment to equity and justice.
From a biblical worldview, the response to this issue is guided by
principles of justice, compassion, and the inherent dignity of every
individual. Those with a biblical perspective are called to advocate for
systemic change that ensures all students are treated fairly and allowed to
succeed. By addressing the root causes of disproportionality and working
towards more equitable educational practices, it is possible to create a more
just and inclusive educational system that reflects the values of fairness,
love, and respect for all.
References
Historical Review Research Paper
10
Darby, D., & Rury, J. L. (2018). The Color of Mind: Why the Origins of the
Achievement Gap Matter for Justice. University of Chicago Press.
Flynn, R., & Martohardjono, G. (2021). Disproportionality in Special
Education: Effects of Individual and School Characteristics. Journal of
Special Education.
King James Bible. (2024). www.kingjamesbible.org.
Losen, D. J., & Orfield, G. (2019). Why Are So Many Minority Students in
Special Education? Understanding Race & Disability in Schools.
Teachers College Press.
Skiba, R. J., & Albrecht, S. F. (2020). Culturally Responsive Assessment
Practices: Reducing Disproportionality in Special Education.
Educational Researcher.
Zhang, D., & Katsiyannis, A. (2022). The Enduring Disproportionate
Representation of African Americans in Special Education. Remedial
and Special Education.
