Introduction......................................................................................................................................1
Abstract..........................................................................................................................................1
Concrete Response.........................................................................................................................3
Reflection........................................................................................................................................4
Action..............................................................................................................................................5
Conclusion......................................................................................................................................6
Bibliography....................................................................................................................................7
ii
1
Introduction
Comeback Churches: How 300 Churches Turned Around and Yours Can, Too" by Ed
Stetzer and Mike Dodson is an insightful and practical guide to church revitalization. Drawing
on extensive research and real-life examples, the authors provide a comprehensive examination
of the factors contributing to the turnaround of struggling congregations.
Abstract
The book begins by highlighting the concept of the "Dirty Baker’s Dozen," which
identifies common indicators of stagnation or decline within churches. Stetzer and Dodson stress
the importance of self-assessment and acknowledgment of the need for change as the first step
towards revival. “For years, various writers and researchers have reported that the North
American church is anemic and lethargic at best. Many believe that Jesus’ commentary about
Laodicea fits the church in America today, “I know your deeds, that you are neither cold nor hot.
I wish you were either one or the other!” (Rev. 3:15 NIV).”1 This foundational insight sets the
stage for a detailed exploration of various elements crucial to church revitalization.
One of the key themes emphasized throughout the book is the significance of worship
services in fostering a vibrant church community. The authors present compelling statistics and
anecdotes to underscore the importance of celebrative and orderly worship experiences. One
statistic that stuck out to me was “In 2002, George Barna’s research indicated that 95 to 100
million Americans of all ages were unchurched (approximately one third of the population), an
estimate that was based upon a very generous definition of “unchurched”.”2 Moreover, they
1 Ed Stetzer and Mike Dodson, Comeback Churches: How 300 Churches Turned around and Yours Can, Too
(Nashville, TN: B&H Publishing Group, 2007), 24.
2 Ed Stetzer and Mike Dodson, Comeback Churches: How 300 Churches Turned around and Yours Can, Too
(Nashville, TN: B&H Publishing Group, 2007), 26.
2
advocate for the use of diverse preaching styles rooted in biblical truth, catering to the needs of
congregants while maintaining doctrinal integrity. “Almost all comeback churches identified
their mood of worship as celebrative and orderly (96% and 95%, respectively) with a significant
emphasis on being informal and contemporary (81% and 69%, respectively).”3
Additionally, "Comeback Churches" delves into the role of evangelism and outreach in
church growth. Stetzer and Dodson highlight the necessity of proactive engagement with the
surrounding community, utilizing special events as opportunities for outreach and disciple-
making. They stress the importance of strategic planning and intentional efforts to reach both
believers and non-believers effectively. Not only that, but they also incorporate strategic prayer
stating that “comeback churches are praying churches”.
The book also underscores the significance of small groups in fostering meaningful
relationships and spiritual growth within the church. Through insightful analysis and practical
advice, the authors demonstrate how small groups can address the diverse needs of congregants
while promoting accountability and discipleship. The authors teach that “people need
connection, people need community, people need commitment, and people need discipling.”
Furthermore, "Comeback Churches" places a strong emphasis on the power of prayer in
facilitating church revitalization. Stetzer and Dodson highlight the need for intentional and
systematic prayer practices, emphasizing prayer as a foundational aspect of the turnaround
process.
Concrete Response
Upon reading the list presented in the “dirty dozen” I was immediately reminded of
where my former assembly came from. Just a year ago, our church was struggling with a
3 Ed Stetzer and Mike Dodson, Comeback Churches: How 300 Churches Turned around and Yours Can, Too
(Nashville, TN: B&H Publishing Group, 2007), 78.
3
dwindling congregation, barely hovering around 60 members. It was a challenging time, filled
with uncertainty and concern about the future. However, through a series of intentional efforts
and divine intervention, our church experienced a remarkable transformation, growing to over
1000 members in less than a year.
Reflecting on this journey, I'm struck by the parallels between our experience and the
principles outlined in "Comeback Churches." Our church exemplifies the "Rebirth" type of
comeback church described in the book. We underwent a profound spiritual revival,
experiencing a renewed passion for worship, evangelism, and community outreach. Our
leadership team recognized the need for change and embraced a bold vision for growth, inspiring
the congregation to join in the journey of revitalization.
I vividly remember the sense of unity and purpose that permeated our church during this
time. There was a palpable excitement and anticipation as we embarked on this transformative
journey together. Our pastor often emphasized the importance of prayer and seeking God's
guidance every step of the way. His words, "We need to be a church on our knees," resonated
deeply with me and motivated me to prioritize prayer in my own life.
One of the key strategies that contributed to our church's rapid growth was our intentional
focus on community outreach and evangelism. We organized special events and initiatives to
reach out to our neighbors and invite them to experience God's love in tangible ways (groceries
and rental assistance). These efforts not only attracted new members but also fostered a sense of
belonging and connection within our church family.
Looking back, I can't help but marvel at the miraculous transformation that took place
within our church. It's a testament to the power of faith, prayer, and collective action. Our
experience aligns closely with the principles outlined in "Comeback Churches," reaffirming the
4
effectiveness of intentional leadership, vibrant worship, and strategic outreach in fostering
church revitalization. As I continue to reflect on our journey, I'm filled with gratitude for the
ways in which God has worked in and through our community, turning our struggles into
triumphs and our setbacks into opportunities for growth.
Reflection
In reflecting on "Comeback Churches" by Stetzer and Dodson, I found myself grappling
with certain aspects of the text that prompted critical questioning and introspection. While I
appreciate the insights presented in the book, particularly its emphasis on the need for church
revitalization and the practical strategies outlined, there were elements that left me pondering
deeper questions.
One area of contention was the authors' emphasis on contemporary worship styles as a
common feature of comeback churches. While I understand the importance of adapting to the
preferences and cultural context of congregants, I questioned whether this emphasis might
overlook the diversity of worship practices and preferences within different church communities.
Does the promotion of contemporary worship inadvertently marginalize those who prefer
traditional forms of worship? How can churches effectively balance relevance with honoring
tradition and catering to diverse worship styles? Being in a church where we minister both
traditional and contemporary music, I thought that this was an interesting take.
Furthermore, I found myself pondering how the book could have provided more clarity
on certain topics to avoid potential misinterpretations by readers. While the authors offer
valuable insights and practical advice, there were instances where I felt ambiguity or lack of
specificity. For example, when discussing the role of leadership in church revitalization, the book
emphasizes the importance of equipping and motivating church members, but it could have
5
delved deeper into specific leadership strategies and practices. How can church leaders
effectively navigate the complexities of leading change and fostering unity within
congregations? What are the potential pitfalls to avoid in the process of revitalization?
In considering how the book could have been more appealing to those in my field of
study, I believe that providing more nuanced perspectives and case studies from a diverse range
of church contexts would enhance its relevance and applicability. Additionally, offering practical
tools and resources for implementing the strategies outlined in the book would be beneficial for
readers seeking actionable steps for church revitalization. By incorporating a broader range of
voices and experiences, the book could resonate more deeply with readers from various
backgrounds and theological perspectives.
While "Comeback Churches" offers valuable insights and practical guidance for church
revitalization, it also raises thought-provoking questions and opportunities for further
exploration. By addressing these questions and enhancing clarity and inclusivity, the book could
strengthen its impact and relevance for readers in the field of church leadership and ministry.
Action
As a result of reading "Comeback Churches" by Stetzer and Dodson, I'm inspired to implement
three specific action steps in my life, ministry, and work to foster growth and revitalization:
1. Enhanced Prayer Strategy:
Commit to a daily prayer routine, dedicating specific times each day for
intentional prayer. My plan is to take the Scripture that I meditate on an pray that
topic for 5 minutes so that I can practice praying God’s word.
2. Intentional Community Outreach:
Establish partnerships with local organizations and community leaders to
maximize the impact of outreach efforts with my church and the churches that I
partner with administratively.
6
3. Leadership Development:
Implement a mentorship program in the form of a book club/Bible study club to
empower emerging leaders and equip them for greater responsibility.
By implementing these action steps, I aim to create a culture of growth, vibrancy, and
impact within my sphere of influence and in my church.
Conclusion
Overall, "Comeback Churches" offers valuable insights and actionable strategies for
church leaders and members alike. With its blend of research, real-life examples, and practical
advice, this book serves as a valuable resource for those seeking to revitalize struggling
congregations and cultivate vibrant church communities. Stetzer and Dodson's emphasis on self-
assessment, worship, evangelism, small groups, and prayer provides a comprehensive framework
for church revitalization that is both inspiring and accessible.
Bibliography
Stetzer, Ed, and Mike Dodson. Comeback Churches: How 300 Churches Turned Around and
Yours Can, Too. Nashville, TN: B&H Publishing Group, 2007.
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
