1 / 15100%
FAMILY COUNSELING APPROACH 1
Family Counseling Approach
Ryan Chrzanowski
School of Behavioral Sciences, Liberty University
Author Note
Ryan Chrzanowski
I have no known conflict of interest to disclose.
Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to Ryan Chrzanowski
Email: RWChrzanowski@liberty.edu
FAMILY COUNSELING APPROACH 2
Abstract
Cognitive-Behavioral Family Therapy is an important approach to family therapy in
general as it leads to improvement in children, their parents, as well as families in general,
especially after a referral for concerns regarding parenting practices which may include physical
abuse of a child, or a child’s behavioral problems. Any family that experiences excessive
conflict, coercion, and/or abuse can cause serious developmental issues for the children in the
home including poor social skills, aggression, and emotional reactivity that should be addressed
immediately.
FAMILY COUNSELING APPROACH 3
PART I
Leading Figures
When discussing Cognitive-Behavioral Family Therapy, it would be impossible not to
talk about Dr. Frank M. Dattilio. He “is one of the leading figures in the world in cognitive
behavior therapy. He maintains faculty appointments in the Department of Psychiatry at Harvard
Medical School in Cambridge, Massachusetts, and the University of Pennsylvania School of
Medicine in Philadelphia” (APA, 2023). Dr. Dattilio has published over 250 professional
publications in areas such as; clinical psychology, forensic psychology, anxiety disorders, as well
as marital and family discord.
“Dr. Dattilio is board certified in both clinical psychology and behavioral psychology
through the American Board of Professional Psychology and received a certificate of training in
forensic psychology through the Department of Psychiatry at the University of Pennsylvania
School of Medicine, Philadelphia. He is also a founding fellow of the Academy of Cognitive
Therapy. Dr. Dattilio has been a visiting faculty member at many major universities and medical
schools throughout the world” (APA, 2023).
Development of the Theory/Historical Events
Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy, whether it is individual based or utilized in a family
therapy setting is based on the principles that it is a talking therapy that revolves around
identifying and changing unhelpful and unhealthy thoughts. It is a process of helping individuals
discuss through their issues and helping them identify alternative methods of thinking or thinking
patterns and behaviors so they can be changed, allowing the client to improve the way they feel
about a situation or in general.
FAMILY COUNSELING APPROACH 4
CBT has evolved from two different schools of psychology; behaviorism and cognitive
therapy. Behavioral therapy “is based on the idea that behaviors can be measured, modelled, and
changed” (Morrow, 2022). This first iteration of behavioral therapy emerged between 1930 and
1940 due to the emotional state that many WWII veterans were returning home with from the
war. It was created as a short-term therapy for the veteran’s depression and anxiety which also
allowed for further research into how individuals behave and react to certain situations in life.
Cognitive therapy was the brainchild of Albert Ellis who was a key figure in CT’s
development. He believed and stressed the importance of individuals feelings/thoughts and
behaviors and initially created a therapy called Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy (REBT) in
the 1950s. This is one of the earliest recorded instances of cognitive psychotherapy and is
founded in the belief that the emotional distress a person experiences is derived from their
thoughts of an event, rather than the actual event itself.
However, it was not until the 1950s and 1960s that psychologist Aaron T. Beck identified
“automatic thoughts” which he described as random thoughts that pop into people’s heads that
they do not necessarily have control over. It were these automatic thoughts that lead to him
noticing patterns with his clients that suffered from depression. No matter how much exploration
of a person’s past was accomplished, individuals still held negative views of themselves. It was
not until he began researching ways to help individuals release those negative thoughts in a
health manner, and from that point on, Cognitive Behavioral Therapy was up and running.
Basic Assumptions and Key Philosophy
The main tenant of CBT whether individual or family based in built on the predication
that an individual’s or group’s behavior and emotions are derived “largely from their appraisal of
any given situation (not so much what the issue is but rather their interpretation of the issue) and
FAMILY COUNSELING APPROACH 5
one’s appraisal is influenced by their beliefs, assumptions, images, etc.” (Galica, 2023). This
principle is further asserted through the three main assumptions of this type of therapy which are;
1) Behavior and emotions develop through cognitive processes; 2) procedures based on the
human learning laboratory are effective in influencing cognitive processes; and 3) the therapist
serves as a diagnostician-educator to help the client uncover maladaptive cognitive processes and
then create learning experiences which will allow the client to alter those processes.
Ultimately, CBT’s key philosophy is that, how an individual thinks (cognition), how they
feel (emotion), and how they act (behavior) are all linked and interact together. More
specifically, our thoughts determine how we feel, and how we feel determines how we act. This
means that negative thoughts, personal bias’, and unrealistic ideas whether intentional or
“automatic thoughts” can cause us personal distress and lead to issues with behavior, feelings,
and even more unwanted thoughts. This is why identifying and altering negative cognitive
processes is so vital.
Key Concepts
“Cognitive behavioral family therapy (CBFT) involves assisting clients with changing
their self-defeating or irrational beliefs to change their feelings and behaviors. It assumes that
family relationships, cognitions, behaviors, and emotions have a mutual influence on one
another; cognitive inference evokes emotion and behavior; and emotion and behavior can
influence cognition. When this cycle occurs among family members, dysfunctional cognitions,
behaviors, or emotions can result in conflict” (Hutcheson, 2011).
The core or key concept of CBFT is that the actions, feelings, and thoughts of one
member of the family or group can lead to behaviors, cognitions, and emotions within other
family or group members which in turn will cause them to reciprocate those same thoughts,
FAMILY COUNSELING APPROACH 6
feelings, and actions back onto the originating individual whereby creating an endless cycle of
vulnerability, volatility, and negativity in a spiral of conflict unless something in the dynamic is
shifted or changed.
The approach of CBT/CBFT is to first identify an individual’s or group’s core beliefs,
then, through thorough conversations and with the help of a counselor, distortions and deviations
from those core beliefs are identified, discussed, and altered to allow the individual or group to
return to their core beliefs. This allows the individual or group to realign their thought processes
which could have been previously distorted due to erroneous information, outside influence, or a
simple misunderstanding. Once these realignments and adjustments are made, the individual or
group should notice a drastic improvement to their interactional patterns.
Techniques
There are quite a few varying techniques used in CBT/CBFT, and the use of each
individual one is based not only on the counselors choice that they base on the individual or
group he/she is working with, but these techniques are also chosen based on what the individual
or group is comfortable with. First and foremost is psychoeducation wherein the counselor
educates the individual or family about CBT and how their thoughts, emotions, and actions play
a role in shaping their experiences.
Another helpful technique would be communication skills training. This is a process of
educating an individual or family in methods of positive communication which involve active
listening, assertiveness, and conflict resolution. By using this communication technique, the
counselor is then able to work with the family using yet another technique which is problem-
solving skills training. The entire purpose of problem-solving skills training is to help the
FAMILY COUNSELING APPROACH 7
individual or group identify and solve problems constructively as opposed to lashing out and
acting out of pure emotion.
Some counselors may also choose to employ the behavioral activation technique. “This
technique revolves around encouraging an individual or group to engage in some positive and
rewarding activities even if they are not necessarily in the mood to do so” (Bhalla, 2023). By
forcing themselves to participate in such activities they can actually improve their overall mood
and reduce some of those negative thinking patterns that normally spring up during daily life and
stressful times.
Similarities and Differences in Leading Theories
When comparing theories such as CBT/CBFT and, for example, Bowen’s Family
Systems Therapy model, there are some noticeable similarities as well as differences. While they
are similar in the respect that both therapy types endeavor to create better communication and
understanding within the family unit, CBT is used more on a one-on-one aspect, attempting to
change the thought patterns of each individual, whereas Family Systems Therapy “focuses not
solely on the individual, but rather the individuals relationship to the family/group as a whole.
While again, both therapies are similar in the respect that they can be used to alter not
only the family group perception of a specific event or issue but help create a better
understanding of how each individual member will act/react given specific circumstances.
However, they are different in the regard that FST focuses on the “complexities of the family
dynamic as a whole, the meaning of each individual relationship within the group, and how each
individual can support each other through problems they may be experiencing.
CBT can also be very individualized initially as to identify problems and issues that each
group member is bringing to the table as opposed to FST that examines family problems as a
FAMILY COUNSELING APPROACH 8
whole unit, i.e. one person’s problems are everyone’s problems. This creates issues as parents
may project their own failings onto their children and can cause the children to develop those
problems where none previously existed.
New Knowledge Acquired
One of the first pieces of new information discovered while researching this topic was
that CBT/CBFT focuses on or places a “heavy emphasis on schema or what is otherwise known
as "core beliefs." The primary aim of the approach is to help family members recognize
distortions in their thinking based on erroneous information and restructure their thinking and
modify their behavior in order to improve their interactional patterns” (APA, 2023). This is
important when working with a family or group because it is vital to identify what is ultimately
important to them.
Another piece of new information or knowledge was in how CBT/CBFT helps families,
but moreover helps individuals within the families to identify their own personal distortions in
thinking that may create problems for the family as a whole. This is why communication with
CBT is vital so that misunderstandings and miscommunications can be avoided, addressed, and
resolved. By gaining a better understanding of yourself as an individual and how you view things
is the first step to understanding the behavior and motivations of others within the family unit.
PART II
Personal Integration
Integrating CBT/CBFT into my own personal family counseling approach would not only
be easy but logical. Based on how I was personally raised and the benefits of this model on my
own family dynamic, long before I even knew the process had a name are undeniable.
Personally, my parents raised my brothers and to always have open and honest communication
FAMILY COUNSELING APPROACH 9
with them, even if we disagreed with a decision they made. This allowed us as children to learn
not only effective communication, but also parenting techniques that we would use with our own
children one day.
The goal of CBFT is to permanently change interaction patterns between family
members. This is accomplished by exposing distorted beliefs held by each family member and
can only be successful through open, honest, and non-judgmental communication. Let’s be
honest, “because I said so” is often a parental response to a lot of things, but it is a lot easier for
the child to understand WHY you said so, if they understand your motivations. A simple example
of this would be telling a child “do not touch the stove, because I said so.” Well of course the
child will be curious and will probably end up touching it and getting burnt.
However, if a parent says, “do not touch the stove, because I do not want you to burn
yourself,” then the child will most likely heed their parents warning and avoid an accident. This
is the same for any issue that arises within a family, especially the larger the family is. Families
are not single celled organisms that think, move, and act the same way. Families are made up of
individuals with individual thoughts, feelings, and behaviors, and it is not until we strive to
understand that individuality that we can come together as a whole.
One of the main ways to successfully integrate CBT/CBFT into any counseling approach
is to first and foremost approach the therapy, and everyone involved in that therapy as a partner.
It is important that in CBFT that no one person is singled out or made to feel better or worse than
the others. The goal of CBFT is inclusion, understanding, and resolution. This is most effective
when all members of the family are involved in the decision-making processes of the therapy as
a whole. Just as a counselor allows an individual client to decide what type of therapy works best
FAMILY COUNSELING APPROACH 10
for them, so to is it just as important in family therapy so that all members feel important, valued,
and heard.
It is also vital to stick with whatever treatment plan is mutually decided upon without
deviations. This is not only important in helping clients understand that results will not happen
overnight or instantaneously, but also allows for better monitoring of progress of each individual
as well as the family as whole. This allows the counselor as well as other family members to
suggest alterations if the current treatment plan is not as effective for some family members as it
is for others.
Finally, incorporating CBT/CBFT into a counseling approach must be accompanied by
open, honest, and constant communication. This does not simply apply to each member of the
family, but also between the family and the counselor. If the therapy is not working for an
individual or the family as a whole, there needs to be a safe space to voice those concerns and
adjust accordingly. There is nothing more detrimental to any therapy process than pursuing a
course of treatment that does not work as it just adds feelings of failure to an already difficult
situation.
PART III
Symbis Assessment
Upon completing the SYMBIS assessment there are four main areas that were requested
for discussion. Those areas are; Marriage Mindset, Five Issues in Real Relationships, Walking
Together with God, and Theory and Spiritual Integration. While these sections are important
overall in a relationship, these areas are not the only portions of a relationship that matter, nor
will they make or break a relationship.
FAMILY COUNSELING APPROACH 11
Marriage Mindset
Both my partner and I share the same “Reluctant Mindset” when it comes to marriage.
This is not to say that we do not want to marry each other, or that we will not one day eventually
get married, but since both of us have been married with children previously, neither of us are
exactly in a rush to do so again. “This is highly unusual. You're both very skeptical about life-
long love. The two of you have the lowest marriage motivation of any segment. Not only do you
both fear commitment, you both see divorce as perfectly acceptable when the going gets tough. It
begs the question: Why are you marrying?” (SYMBIS, 2023).
I am not sure the question should be why we are marrying, but more of a simple
understanding as to why we have not gotten married yet. We both had very difficult and messy
divorces that involved children previously, and both divorce processes were very lengthy, so in
light of our shared experiences, we decided, from the first date, that we would not rush anything,
because if either of us got married again, it would be a forever marriage.
Five Issues in Real Relationships
The first section in how we each define love is actually rather close to one and other.
Respect, Honesty, and Trust are all listed in our top five with varying differences in Friendship,
Supportiveness, Respect, and Loyalty. This is not surprising as to why we each chose what we
did. My partner did not feel supported or respected in her previous marriage so those two are
very important for her, whereas respect and loyalty are vital for me as I was disrespected, cheated
on, and had a very disloyal ex-wife.
At the time of taking this assessment we are both dealing with some personal issues
outside of the relationship and it has thrown a few wrenches in the mechanics of how we deal
with things. This would explain why both of our resilience levels are between 60%-75%. We
FAMILY COUNSELING APPROACH 12
have talked about this recently as a matter of fact and are both just tired of life throwing us
curveballs and having to adjust. Just when we feel like things are going well, finally, then
something goes wrong, so it can be hard to adjust after a while.
This assessment also states that my partner and I communicate very well with each other,
which is honestly true. Whether there is a small issue that only effects one of us, or something
major that effects both of us and possibly anyone else, we are always discussing it and working
out ways to resolve matters together. We have had a saying between each other for the last 4
years, “we always figure out a way, even if not today.” What we mean by this is that we may not
come up with a solution on the spot, but we always work together and overcome our challenges
together.
Finally, with this section, there is nothing listed that we have not already addressed. For
example; for my partner “You sometimes use gestures or facial expressions more than words to
communicate” (SYMBIS, 2023) this is because my partner is deaf, so her face and hands are
very expressive as opposed to using actual words. An example in my case would be; “You
hesitate to act on a problem unless a solution is clear or the risk is small” (SYMBIS, 2023) and
this is because after being in the military and having been a crime scene investigator for years, I
tend not to sweat the small stuff or try to resolve an issue without a clear plan of action.
Walking Together with God
While I am aware that my partner was raised religious as was I, she is understanding that
I am not a very religious person anymore, or at least right now. While I have no issues with her
going to church, bible study, or volunteering in some manner, she takes no issue that I worship
and pray in my own way, and that I have my own type of relationship with faith. This boils down
to simple respect and understanding between two people that have been through a lot on their
FAMILY COUNSELING APPROACH 13
own in their lives before even meeting each other, and not wanting to force our own beliefs on
each other, because it is just one small aspect of our relationship.
Theory and Spiritual Integration
With regards to theory and spiritual integration within my relationship, my partner and I
have discussed this topic in length, and both agree that it is something that has to happen
naturally. She knows that if she attempts to force me to go to church or bible study with her, I
could end up hating it, resenting her, or being pushed further away from God. Just as I know that
she needs to have the freedom to not only go to church but to express to me and converse with
me regarding her spiritual beliefs otherwise she will resent me or feel that she is not allowed to
be her true self.
With regards to theory and spiritual integration with my counseling clients, I respectfully
leave that decision in their hands. I was raised Catholic, but also Baptist, and have studied
various other religions in an effort to better understand God. I have no issues including a
religious worldview in my sessions with my clients if that is something that is important to them
and can discuss theology with them in length. On that same principle, however, I will never push
a religious aspect into therapy unless requested by the client simply due to the fact that so many
people practice so many various religious beliefs, with varying degrees of faith, I would never
want to make a client feel uncomfortable or unwelcome simply because of a choice or lack of
choice in religious beliefs.
Conclusion
Ultimately, CBT/CBFT is a great method and theory of counseling because at the heart of
this practice is simply a conversation between people about any and all topics for the benefit of
the client. It is about creating a safe space for the client or family to discuss issues and explore
FAMILY COUNSELING APPROACH 14
resolutions to said issues. Some of these issues may involve a religious aspect, some of these
issues may just boil down to a matter of mutual respect, understanding, and compassion, and
once those honest conversations begin within that safe space, then the healing can also begin.
FAMILY COUNSELING APPROACH 15
REFERENCES
Alternatives for families: A cognitive-behavioral therapy (AF-CBT). Children’s
Bureau/ACYF/ACF/HHS. (2012, January 1).
https://www.childwelfare.gov/pubPDFs/cognitive.pdf
Bhalla, K. (2023, March 23). Cognitive behavioral family therapy: Types and techniques. Mantra
Care. https://mantracare.org/therapy/parenting-family/cognitive-behavioral-family-
therapy/#Techniques_Used_In_CBFT
Dattilio, F. M. (2012). Cognitive–behavioral family therapy. American Psychological
Association. https://www.apa.org/pubs/videos/4310891?tab=2
Galica, J. (2023). Behavioral/Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy. Theravive Counseling.
https://www.theravive.com/research/cognitive-behavioral-therapy#:~:text=The%20three
%20common%20assumptions%20of,educator’%20to%20uncover%20maladaptive
%20cognitive
Hutcheson, C. L. (2011). Cognitive Behavioral Family Therapy. Marriage and Family Therapy,
XVI, 95–118. https://doi.org/10.1891/9780826161253.0001
Morrow, M. (2022, September 28). The history of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT).
Klearminds. https://www.klearminds.com/blog/history-cognitive-behavioural-therapy-
cbt/
Students also viewed