1
Involuntary Celibacy as a Deviant Identity
Student’s Name
Institutional Affiliation
Course
Instructor’s Name
Date
2
Involuntary Celibacy as a Deviant Identity
1. Deviant groups
Because of the heavily uncontrolled nature of internet forums, certain digital groups show
interest in the content that others may find objectionable. These communities have embraced
such interactions. The anonymity provided by most sites may further amplify the misuse of
insults and hate speech, such as racism and misogynistic remarks. Incels, a well-known online
subculture of involuntary celibates, is an example of such a group. Incels have gotten a lot of
press in recent years. Incels have received a lot of negative attention, which is understandable.
Yet, there is a distinct shortage of works that theorize why they engage in behavior that is
harmful to others. The current research investigated the case of the celibates’ movement to gain a
better understanding of the cultural contexts of current reactionary groups and their potential for
current mobilization in the digital world.
2. Reasons why the groups may be considered deviant
Numerous deviant cyber communities are founded on ideals that promote prejudice
against a minority population. For modern hate organizations, online media are critical for the
building of these shared ideas. These groups can now recruit and sustain their membership by
exchanging rituals, iconography, and other online propaganda (Conley, 2020). This is
particularly true in nations where hate-based communication delivered via non-digital means is
heavily banned or prohibited. Hate groups' ability to motivate their members to achieve their
aims is enhanced by promoting a strong sense of collective identity.
Several characteristics bind reactionary movements together. Unlike progressive
movements, these social movements attempt to retain a group's existing power in reaction to
challenges to a dominant group's standing in economic or cultural hierarchies, according to the
3
"power devaluation" paradigm. Right-wing activists' ability to mobilize depends on a
conservative movement's ability to efficiently communicate to its base numerous "grievances"
about their loss of power to marginal groups. To gain empathy for their cause, white supremacist
Incels groups frequently portray themselves as "victims" of minority groups (Currier, 2021).
3. Threats to society
Because of its accessibility, the incel movement's rise is problematic. This is not an
ideology that requires brainwashing through sophisticated political writings or expertise in
ancient religious theory. Instead, it plays on the emotions and frustrations that young men
worldwide face daily, and it appeals to angry or lonely people rather than those who already have
extreme tendencies (Leidig, 2021). These sentiments of solitude and sexual frustration are co-
opted by the incel ideology, which then weaponized them into a cruel worldview that targets
women, men, minorities, and those with mental illnesses.
The lack of evident legislative restrictions or counterterrorism intelligence activities is
perhaps the most challenging component of the incel movement's commitment to violence
(Currier,2021). Because the movement is fully decentralized, with no hierarchy or leaders, there
are no offline organizing or financial channels that may be targeted. It's also difficult to find and
enlist people who hold similar extremist ideas but don't use violence as interlocutors, as with
previous counter-violent extremism efforts. Domestic law enforcement authorities cannot legally
trace internet speech or police language, yet incels take pride in their noted shit posting tendency
(Conley, 2020).
There is a lot of emphasis on understanding the manosphere as a source of male sexism
on the internet. The term first appeared in online men's rights forums in 2009, before being
popularized by media attention focused on the websites' harsh content (Ribeiro et al. 2020). It is
4
thought to be a loose confederation of organizations whose goals include delegitimizing women's
rights and developing a militant vocabulary for the men's rights movement (Schmitz & Kazyak,
2016). Journalists and academics have identified the concept at the center of the manosphere: the
metaphorical Red Pill. The term>Red Pill originated from Matrix, the 1999 film, in which the
protagonist is given a physical red pill that would open his eyes to the truth about the bleak
society in which he lives. In the manosphere, the word refers to one's embrace of an imagined
reality in which males are weak and women openly misandry. Members of the manosphere live
in a world amidst an existential crisis that necessitates them to abuse, harass, and criticize
feminists and their sympathizers for permanently toppling the patriarchy.
Before establishing the present manosphere, comparable concerns about the loss of
masculine dominance, which resulted in aggressive responses toward women, were noted among
men's rights movements (Conley, 2020). This is a reasonable attempt to define a group of
communities that share an ideology suggesting that Western culture is indifferent to challenges
that males suffer, such as loneliness, incarceration, and unreported sexual and physical assault.
However, because the manosphere has been expanded to accommodate organizations that may
be opposed to one another, there is a great deal of variety within these groups.
4. How the groups justify their actions
Incels, as one of the most prominent reactionary subcultures online, has recently emerged
as a crucial illustration of how digital hate organizations may mobilize their members into
violent action. Members of the Incel organization have been responsible for several instances of
mass violence in recent years. Eliot Rodger's 2014 Isla Vista massacre, motivated by a sexist
worldview and psychosexual frustration, is likely the most recognizable illustration of Incel mass
violence (Currier, 2021). Despite following typical financial success metrics, such as buying fine
5
clothing and automobiles, Rodger complained about his inability to even have sex with a woman
in his writings. Rodger believes that his lavish spending qualifies him for female admiration.
Because of his inability to attract women, Rogers declared that women are a fundamentally
flawed group that must be eradicated to end what he saw as systemic oppression of men like him.
Rodger planned and carried out a mass attack due to the charges, which left seven people dead,
including Rodger, and 14 others injured (Currier, 2021).
Rodger represented members of the Manosphere, a term that refers to a group of online
forums centered on toxic masculinity, the incels. Individuals who identify with the
"Manosphere" often exhibit extreme Misogyny and reveal terrorists like Rodger (Hoffman &
Ware, 2020). Incels like Rodger commonly describe themselves as "lonely," "inferior," or
"socially impaired," claiming that they are incapable of finding love partners or participate in
sexual encounters. Incels think that their incapacity to match the sexual demands of customary
masculinity results from general women oppression, particularly feminists, against "unattractive"
men and that their emotions of social insufficiency are portrayed as a sense of masculine
victimization.
5. Conceptualization of Incel
Misogyny, which stems from a failure to match heteronormative masculinity's sexual
demands, and the "black pill," or incel members' collective anarchism and comprehensive
rejection of conventional societal ideals, define the Incel community's culture. Incels use their
forum posts to show their collective and personal scorn for women, which frequently include
personal shortcomings or imagined snubs by women toward the Incel or other men. If incels fault
women for lacking any sexual success, their recommended solutions must address how to
6
overcome this problem (Leidig, 2021). Similarly, if Incels use violent language to frame their
grievances, this may incite violence as a means of resolving their problems.
Incels are an interesting case for studying reactionary movement mobilization techniques.
Because Nihilism and rebellious behavior are crucial to their character, the movement frequently
dismisses the likelihood of change. While some Incels argue for possible mobilization
techniques, many others propose options that include a collective change toward recognition of
their social situation while working for greater>widespread recognition of their "predicament."
"LifeFuel" and "Coping" are two primary categories of incel threads that identify this approval
(Currier,2021). Unlike many other Incel forum posts, "LifeFuel" has topics in which Incels
celebrate other people's troubles, especially women. "Coping" is a mix of postings criticizing
women and non-Incel men, as well as threads describing Incels' various tactics for dealing with
sexual and social failures. When collective action is perceived as useless or unattainable, these
subcategories show how an unreasonable social group reframes its goals (Hoffman & Ware,
2020). The movement's goal is not to change society but to alter their values into an unwilling
acceptance of their situation.
While incel-related violence appears to be entrenched in white male internet subcultures
in developed Western countries, it may find sympathy in Asia. Asian males who consider
themselves sexually disadvantaged have already embraced incel status in several diaspora
communities in North America. Ethnicels claim that their ethnicity is the source of their incel
status. "Currycels" refers to South Asians, whereas "ricecels" refers to Southeast Asians.
Misogyny can be found in both developed and emerging countries. According to a 2019 UN
research of three Asian nations, Misogyny is principally violence against women, which is
predictive of backing for violent radical groups (Hoffman & Ware, 2020). The study further
7
identifies that the attack on women and their rights activists present early warning indications of
extreme violence. The rising gender disparity in Asia might lead to several issues, including
increased violence.
It has been argued that it would necessitate "securitizing Incel” to preventing incel-
motivated violence. Given the current discussion over whether Incel can be regarded as a unified
political philosophy, it's best to proceed with care (Leidig, 2021). The mentioned Minassian
accusation has been dubbed the "world's first incel show trial" by some. Like any other Internet
subculture, the incel online community enjoys posting garbage "idiotic and sensationalist
content." In the North American environment, determining what entails credible threats of
radicalizations versus comedy are has been recognized as an administration difficulty (Ware,
2021).>On the other side, Asian countries afflicted by larger, more deadly radical extremist
groups may regard the dangers presented by incels as insignificant.
6. Conclusion
The current research has studied the celibates' movement to understand better the cultural
frameworks of modern reactionary groups and their potential mobilization in digital spaces.
Members of the Incel subculture rarely call for violence against women in online forums, but the
promotion of violence towards women and non-Incel men is widespread in their society.
Previous research on the association between toxic masculinity and aggressiveness has shown
that this creates a climate favorable to lone-wolf acts of violence. Some high-profile terror
actions carried out by Incel members, notably Elliot Rodger, demonstrate this. Despite their
limited power to promote systemic change, the Incels embody a more significant digital
misogyny trend, escalating anomie and social reaction.
8
References
Conley, J. (2020). Efficacy, Nihilism, and Toxic Masculinity Online: Digital Misogyny in the
Incel Subculture (Doctoral dissertation, The Ohio State University).
Currier, K. (2021). Personal Anguish or Public Spectacle?: Understanding Involuntary Celibacy
as A Deviant Identity.
Hoffman, B., & Ware, J. (2020). Incels: America’s Newest Domestic Terrorism Threat.>Lawfare
blog,>12.
Leidig, E. (2021). Why Terrorism Studies Miss the Mark When It Comes To Incels.
Ribeiro, M. H., Blackburn, J., Bradley, B., De Cristofaro, E., Stringhini, G., Long, S., ... &
Zannettou, S. (2020). From pick-up artists to incels: a data-driven sketch of the
manosphere. arXiv preprint arXiv:2001.07600.
Schmitz, R. M., & Kazyak, E. (2016). Masculinities in cyberspace: An analysis of portrayals of
manhood in men’s rights activist websites. Social Sciences, 5(2), 18.
Ware, J. (2021). Beta Uprising. Counter Terrorist Trends and Analyses, 13(2), 10-15.
