ETHICAL DILEMMA THE POLICE CHIEF 2
Abstract
This paper examines an ethical dilemma faced by a student working on an intellectual biography
of a well-respected police chief. This paper comprehensively analyzes how the student should
handle the dilemma after discovering harmful or unflattering information about the chief during
the research. First, the paper will provide guidelines for writing the Intellectual Biography.
Second, the paper will address how to address damaging information in research and how to
handle the problems that arise. The paper discusses how truth and privacy can conflict and why
it's important to justify ethical actions. The report advises on how to approach delicate situations
in the Christian Worldview.
Keywords: ethical dilemma, truth, privacy, justifying actions, intellectual biography,
ETHICAL DILEMMA THE POLICE CHIEF 3
The student is conducting research on the police chief for an intellectual biography. While
examining the documents, the student discovered information that could be potentially damaging
or unflattering about the chief's private life. The damaging information that was revealed about
the chief was found during the initial information gathering, such as reviewing published works
and conducting interviews with family members and colleagues. The dilemma lies in the
student's decision on what course to take regarding whether to include or exclude the information
in the biography.
According to Aera (2023), writing an intellectual biography involves delving into an
individual's life and exploring their thoughts, contributions, and personal experiences.
1 . The person's life.
2 . The intellectual and creative work of the person.
3The relationship between life and work.
4The significance of life and work historically.
However, discovering potentially damaging or unflattering information about the subject's
private life raises ethical concerns. This paper aims to explore possible ethical dilemmas
encountered by a student researching information for an intellectual biography to be written on a
well-respected police chief and discuss the justifications for actions in divulging or not divulging
unflattering information.
Writing Guidelines for the Intellectual Biography
An intellectual biography is an extensive research on a person's life, work, and
intellectual contributions. The research may include a variety of resources, such as reviewing
ETHICAL DILEMMA THE POLICE CHIEF 4
primary and secondary sources, interview correspondence, and any other material deemed
relevant to the construction of the biography; a thorough understanding of the person's
background and intellectual development is crucial. Present a balanced view of the dilemma
while considering both positive and negative aspects. Second, the researcher must be objective
and impartial when researching and interpreting a person's life and work. They must avoid bias
and remain impartial by not letting personal judgments and opinions influence the biography.
The researcher should provide an analysis that helps understand the individual and
considers the history, culture, social, and intellectual context of the person's public and personal
life. By doing this, the researcher offers insight into how the person's ideas and contributions
have shaped the individual. Another aim of the researchers is to provide a comprehensive
account of the person's intellectual journey. This area of research includes documenting the
individual's major works, ideas, influences, significant events, and experiences that may have
shaped their thinking. Also, the researcher must capture the depth of the person's contributions to
the study. These should include documenting their major works, ideas, influences, and significant
events or experiences that shaped their thinking. It is important to capture the breadth and depth
of the person's intellectual contributions.
Researchers are responsible for accurate information about the person. They should
verify facts, cite reliable sources, and avoid misrepresenting information. For the credibility and
integrity of the biography, the author must consider ethical implications when writing the
intellectual biography and respecting the person's privacy. They must seek informed consent
ETHICAL DILEMMA THE POLICE CHIEF 5
when necessary and carefully handle sensitive or controversial information, ensuring it does not
harm the person's reputation.
Researchers should also ensure that their work does not harm the person or their
reputation. Students must present critical factual information. Therefore, the researcher has to
work carefully to evaluate the impact and highlight the relevance and significance of the
information. Lastly, researchers should strive to write clearly and engage the audience regarding
clarity and readability. The biography should be accessible to multiple readers and avoid jargon
and overly technical language.
Addressing Damaging Information in Research
When a student discovers damaging information while writing an intellectual biography
of a person, they should consider the following guidelines:
First, they must verify the information for the reliability and accuracy of the damaging
information before including it in the biography and cross-reference multiple sources to ensure
the accuracy of the information. Researchers should provide a context for the damaging
information to help readers understand the significance of the materials. The researchers have to
explain the circumstances of the information, the source's credibility, and any mitigation factors
that can affect the interpretation of the information. Researchers must consider the potential
impact of including damaging information in the intellectual biography. The researcher must
assess whether the information is relevant to the person's intellectual contribution. They must
determine whether the inclusion of it has a legitimate purpose and the potential harm it may
cause to the person or their reputation cause to the person or their reputation.
ETHICAL DILEMMA THE POLICE CHIEF 6
. The researcher must know how to balance perspectives and strive to present a view of
the person's life and work. If damaging information is included, it is important to highlight the
person's positive contribution and achievements, allowing for a fair perspective of the individual.
The researcher must be transparent about the existence of the damaging information and disclose
their findings to readers. By being upfront about the information and providing a detailed
explanation of its contents, a researcher can maintain transparency and avoid misleading or
deceptive betrayals of the information. Sensitivity and respect should be utilized when handling
damaging information. It entails consideration of the potential emotional impact on the person or
their loved ones. Here, researchers must be careful in using language and tone when discussing
the controversial topic. Informed consent should be sought from the person or their family if
possible. Respecting the privacy and wishes of the person involved is significant, and obtaining
consent can ensure the ethical treatment of the information. Professional and ethical obligations,
such as those set by academic or research standards, should be adhered to. These guidelines often
provide recommendations and guidance for the handling of damaging materials.
Problematic issues for the Student and the Chief
When writing an intellectual biography for a police chief, a few ethical examples may
arise.
1. Conflict of Interests. Suppose the student has a personal connection or bias towards
the police chief, which may affect the student's ability to be objective. In such cases, the
student must be aware of this potential bias and take steps to ensure they remain fair.
They must strive to gather information from multiple sources, interviews, and multiple
ETHICAL DILEMMA THE POLICE CHIEF 7
individuals who have interacted with the police chief and present a well-rounded
perspective of the chief.
2. Confidentiality: the student might encounter sensitive or personal information during
their research. This information may harm the reputation or privacy of the police chief or
others. In this situation, the student should prioritize maintaining confidentiality and
avoid including any information that may cause harm. They should focus and remain
specific to the chief professional achievements, skills, and contributions of the police
chief while respecting their boundaries.
3. Accuracy and integrity, the student lesson, sure that the information they include in
the intellectual biography is accurate and reliable. If they encounter conflicting accounts
and are uncertain, fax these stripes to corroborate information through multiple sources or
consult experts in the field. The student should also be attentive to potential bias within
their research materials and try to present a balanced and truthful account of the police
chief's intellectual journey.
4. Impartiality and fairness, inviting the intellectual biography of the student, may
uncover controversial, sensitive aspects of the police chief's career and personal life. The
student needs to approach such matters with fairness and impartiality. They should
consider presenting different perspectives and viewpoints, allowing the police chief to
respond and provide their story. The students create a balanced narrative that accounts for
multiple interpretations and is well-maintained, respectful, and professional.
ETHICAL DILEMMA THE POLICE CHIEF 8
Therefore, when writing an intellectual biography, the student should be mindful of
potential conflicts of interest, demonstrate confidentiality, prioritize accuracy, and ensure
impartiality and fairness. The student can create a well-rounded and ethnically sound biography
by navigating through ethical dilemmas with care.
Types of Ethical Dilemmas Utilitarianism Deontology and Virtue
According to Tao et al. (2023), utilitarianism is an ethical framework that focuses on
what is the greatest good for all people involved (Tao et al., 2023). Therefore, the student must
weigh the potential harm it will cause by including the damaged information against the benefits
of truth and transparency. An example of utilitarianism is when the student finds documents,
videos, and statements concerning the police chief who committed a serious crime of assaulting
several men in his custody during his entire career. The student faces the ethical dilemma of
pursuing the truth, which puts the chief in a position that could cost the loss of his job and public
scrutiny or protect him from facing the consequences of their actions. From a practical
perspective, the student has to consider the well-being of the greater number of people affected
by their decisions. On the other hand, the student must consider upholding the principles of
justice and fairness, ensuring that the law applies to all. It would serve as a deterrent to others in
the same professional position as the chiefs in the future.
The decision could have personal and emotional consequences for the police chief and
his relationship with members of his family, friends, colleagues, and the community, causing
ETHICAL DILEMMA THE POLICE CHIEF 9
potentially damaging results that would affect the family dynamics, which could negatively
affect the overall family happiness.
On the other hand, to protect the chief from legal consequences and prioritize family
harmony is a breach of the safety of those arrested. The decision not to out the chief and uphold
the law would be perceived as a not, making the chief accountable for his actions, therefore not
upholding the law. In this example, the student must carefully balance the potential harm caused
by not reporting what was uncovered about the chief to uphold the principles of justice and
fairness. The student would ensure their accountability by choosing what would minimize harm
and maximize justice for society. Deontological ethics emphasizes adherence to moral principles
and duties. The student must consider whether there is an ethical obligation to include all
relevant information regardless of its potential impact on the reputation of the police chief.
Furthermore, virtue ethics focuses on the character and virtues of individuals. The student must
consider the virtues of honesty, integrity, and respect for privacy when deciding to include
potentially damaging information. Finally, the researcher must justify their actions. The
researcher must consider the purpose of the biography. Once the student evaluates the intended
purpose of the intellectual biography and understands the primary objective is to provide an
accurate and comprehensive account of the police chief's life and contributions, that may include
unflattering information deemed necessary for truth and justice. (Pollock 2021).
Christian Worldview
In the Christian worldview, a researcher faces the dilemma of including damaging
personal information in the intellectual biography. The student would need to consider principles
ETHICAL DILEMMA THE POLICE CHIEF 10
such as truth and justice. Here is an example, along with an explanation. To Christians, the
pursuit of truth is highly valued, and they believe in upholding honesty, integrity, and accuracy in
all aspects of life, including academic research. Hence, the study may argue that, including
damaging personal information, allies with a commitment to truthfulness. Therefore, by
presenting a comprehensive and accurate portrayal of the police chief's life, the researcher fulfills
their responsibility to provide an honest account. The researcher may argue that including
damaging personal information aligns with their commitment to truthfulness. By presenting a
comprehensive and accurate portrayal of the police chief's life, the researcher fulfills their
responsibility to provide an honest account.
However, the Christian worldview also emphasizes the principles of justice, fairness, and
love. Christians are called to seek justice and fairness while treating individuals with compassion
and understanding. With the police chief, the researcher must consider the potential
consequences of including damaging personal information if the information is unrelated to
professional conduct or has no bearing on their ability to serve the community. The researcher
may question whether it is fair to harm the chief's reputation and potentially undermine their
ability to fulfill their role effectively.
Additionally, the Christian worldview encourages forgiveness and the belief in the
potential for personal growth and transformation. The research of a pond, the weather, and the
inclusion of damaging information. It could hinder the chief's ability to learn from past mistakes,
make amends, and rebuild past errors. If this happens, the researcher can show compassion and
not share the information. This could lead to forgiveness and redemption. (New International
Bible. (2011).
Conclusion
ETHICAL DILEMMA THE POLICE CHIEF 11
In conclusion, ethical dilemmas can arise when researching and writing intellectual
biographies, particularly when potentially revealing negative information about a subject that has
never been exposed to the chief and his private life. Trust is a large part of the chief, allowing the
researcher to delve into their personal life. When speaking to others, there are times when secrets
may be exposed. It is the researcher's responsibility to use discernment while navigating through
said information, distinguishing between the ethical concerns faced as they focus on ongoing
reflection.
At times, the researcher must seek guidance from peers and mentors and adhere to the
moral principles that align with the Christian Worldview when conducting their research without
judgment. The goal should be to write a biography that honors the chiefs' privacy and dignity
while accurately representing the life and achievements of the chief. It is not supposed to destroy
or demean the chief unless the information harms their profession and the community. If it harms
his professional life, the student must seek justice and fairness while treating individuals with
compassion and understanding. It is not the student's job to judge but to write a fair biography of
the chief private and personal life. The researcher can follow the steps explained above to
minimize potential ethical issues in an ethical dilemma. Research is conducted to understand all
of society. Ethical dilemmas aim to expose injustices and, simultaneously, not cause harm to the
person they are writing intellectual bibliography.
ETHICAL DILEMMA THE POLICE CHIEF 12
References
Aera, 2023, An Introduction to Biographical Research. September 7, 2023, from
https://www.aera.net/SIG013/Research-Connections/Introduction-to-Biographical-
Research#:~:text=Another%20genre%2C%20intellectual%20biography%2C%20forsakes.
Barrow, J. M., & Khandhar, P. B. (2022). Deontology. Nih.gov; StatPearls Publishing.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK459296/
Glesne, C. (2016). Becoming qualitative researchers: An introduction. Pearson
Maile, A., Ritzenthaler, S., Thompson, A., & Kristjánsson, K. (2023). Professional policing and
the role of autonomy and discretion in decision-making: A qualitative study from a virtue
ethical perspective. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice, 17.
Mohajan, D., & Mohajan, H. K. (2022). Constructivist Grounded Theory: A New Research
Approach in Social Science. Research and Advances in Education, 1 (4), 8-16.
New International Bible. (2011). The NIV Bible. https://www.thenivbible.com/ (Original work
published 1978
Pollock, J. M. (2021). Ethical dilemmas and decisions in criminal justice. Cengage Learning
ETHICAL DILEMMA THE POLICE CHIEF 13
Sifferd, Katrina L 2016. 'Virtue Ethics and Criminal Punishment,' in Alberto Masala, and
Jonathan Webber (eds), From Personality to Virtue: Essays on the Philosophy of
Character (; online edn, Oxford Academic, 21 Apr.
2016), https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198746812.003.0003, accessed 7 Sept. 2023.
=
Tao, Y., Dong, J., Niu, H., Lv, Y., He, X., Zhang, S., & Liu, X. (2023). Fear facilitates utilitarian
moral judgments: Evidence from an honorable judgment task—psych journal.
Yip, C., Han, L. R., & Sng, B. L. (2016). Legal and ethical issues in research. Indian Journal of
Anesthesia, 60(9), 684-688. https://doi.org/10.4103/0019-5049.190627
