1 / 45100%
1
THE ROLE OF NOSTALGIA IN MARKETING AND CONSUMER BEHAVIOR
1. Explaining the concept of Nostalgia as used in the marketing
domain
Marketing nostalgia; uses memories that make the target group feel good in an attempt to
control their purchasing decisions. This strategy appeals to the human’s need to return to the past
or nostalgia, youth or the preferable history. When developed correctly, emotional appeals
provoke consumers’ affections may lead to long-term relationships with the associated brands
and purchase intentions. It is imperative to grasp the psychological underpinnings of nostalgia
marketing coupled with the present-day trends so that calls for nostalgia can be aptly propagated
in today’s Marketplace.
Defining nostalgia
Nostalgia, whose etymology comes from the Greek words ‘nostos’, meaning return home and
‘algos’ meaning pain, is a subjective and intricate phenomenon that varies in definitions
nowadays. While in the 17th century nostalgia was considered as a medical issue, at present, this
concept is defined as a combination of nostalgia and delight or joyful recollection of the past
events. In other words, nostalgia can be defined as beliefs that are favorable to some extent about
objects, experiences, or brands that were more abundant in the youth of the consumer or in
different past periods (Holbrook, 1993). Such a feeling can be either self-referential and based on
a social actor’s own history of events or cultural history, that is history of the specific cultural
group to which the actor belongs (Wildschut et al., 2014). Historical nostalgia is the
remembrance of a time period earlier than the consumer’s own life and may be further from the
present than personal nostalgia. Nostalgia cannot be restricted to memories but is a combination
of feelings, imagination, and physical items that have associations with one’s past (Holak &
2
Havlena, 1998). Nostalgia in marketing practice is used to influence the consumers’ emotions as
it is in line with consumers’ desire for continuity, belongingness and positive affect linked to past
episodes or history (Sedikides et al., 2008).
Historical context
Analysis of nostalgia in the framework of its impact on consumption and marketing has been
developed on the basis of sociological and psychological researches of the phenomenon. Fred
Davis's seminal work "Yearning for Yesterday: The paper “A Sociology of Nostalgia” (1979)
opened up a way of considering nostalgia as a social affect with huge relevance to consumer
culture. Most studies in the marketing literature had been conducted during the 1990s and
focused works like Holbrook and Schindler (1991) who embraced nostalgia as a factor
influencing consumers’ preference for particular products. It was introduced during the time
when pop culture trends were shifting towards nostalgia and renaissance of past styles and
motives mostly in 50s and 60s styles. With the change of the millennium, having grown attention
to the nature of nostalgia in the create and sustenance of individual and shared self-
organizational identities (Belk, 199}; Sierra & McQuitty, 2007). Since the consumer experience
has been largely affected by digital technologies, studies have started exploring nostalgia through
the lens of new media (Youn & Jin, 2017). The history of nostalgia as an object of study in
marketing is presented as a development in parallel with the historical trends from the postwar
prosperity of the West to the millennials’ melancholy and shows how the past continually
structures consumption options.
Psychological foundations
Theoretical basis of nostalgia in consumers’ decision-making is rooted in different psychological
theories. Self-continuity hypothesis asserts that people use nostalgia to help them establish and
maintain the self-continuity (Sedikides et al., 2009). This partly explains why a consumer will
3
feel comfortable buying a brand or a particular product that somehow brings back memories of
the previous years. The concept of nostalgia ties in with autobiographical memory since when
people reminisce, they usually focus on the positive things in their personal chronology, in this
case perhaps even through rose-tinted glasses, (Sujan, 1985). In accordance with the
socioemotional selectivity theory, older consumers become more inclined towards experiences
that have emotional relevance and can be music-induced nostalgia appeals (Goulding, 2002).
Besides, nostalgia serves as a defense in reaction to loneliness, threats of existence, and
discontinuity (Zhou et al., 2008; Juhl et al., 2010; Routledge et al., 2011). The second component
of nostalgia is the collective one which have been described by Wildschut et al (2014) being
significantly important in the aspect of social relatedness, these psychological bases reveal why
nostalgia is such a compelling and effective concept in marketing that can mobilize ad renewal,
sentimental appeal and bailey’s contention that it reliably impacts the decision making of
consumers.
Current trends in nostalgia marketing
The tendencies characteristic for modern ideology of nostalgia marketing correspond to the
technological progression as well as the evolution of cultural values. New forms of nostalgic
content have also arisen due to the social media platforms where one can look at what they
posted on such a day on sites like Facebook or share posts with hashtags like #tbt on Instagram
that have their photos representative of a previous era (Youn & Jin, 2017). Different brands and
companies have lately used user-generated content to develop campaigns that trigger people’s
memories. The idea of ‘retro modernism’ began to evolve; this is where traditional designs are
incorporated with modern features in order to cater for the feeling of nostalgia coupled with the
need for modernity (Loveland et al., 2010). They include using nostalgia in an appealing manner;
this is a practice of presenting traditional or retro products as green products that can counter
4
modern consumerism. Nostalgia marketing has become even more resonant with the COVID-19
outbreak as brands seek to appeal to consumers’ desire to return to pre-pandemic life. Further,
with the new concept of nostalgia economy many new brands have been reintroduced and new
experiences have been developed to find those bonds with the past which consumers have always
sought for (Kessous & Roux, 2010).
Impact on consumer behavior
Nostalgia impacts different facets of consumers’ behavior A main survey and findings Several
studies have shown that nostalgia affects various consumer characteristics. Empirical studies
have revealed that stimuli which evoke nostalgic feelings can help boost the purchase intentions
for products that are linked to past experiences or cultural standards (Pascal et al., 2002).
Nostalgia also plays an important role in loyalty because consumers develop tendencies to relate
to brands which evoke special feelings or memories of the past (Kessous & Roux, 2013). South,
(2011) has stated that nostalgic appeals have a positive effect on the brand attitude ad reactive
towards the ad and brand with a comparison to non-nostalgic ads. It has been identified that
nostalgia often awakens different positive associations and consumers, for instance, do not mind
paying a lot of money for a toy that brings back their childhood memories or a car representing
the, to them, idealized times (Holbrook & Schindler, 2003). In addition, various authors have
observed that consumed products encompass the past, making nostalgic experiences more likely
to encourage word-of-mouth communication of the brands or products that consumers enjoy
(Sierra & McQuitty, 2007). The author also acknowledges that age is also a factor when it comes
to decision making due to the effect of nostalgia; consumers may react differently to nostalgic
marketing cues depending on their age as revealed by Muehling et al. (2014). First, nostalgia in
the advertising context is considered to induce predominantly positive consumer responses, and
yet there are possible negative implications that may be felt by consumers, as cited in Baker and
5
Kennedy (1994) including perceived insincerity and fatigue due to over-exposure to nostalgia
appeals.
2. Theoretical Frameworks
The conceptual models present important guide of knowledge with reference to marketing
applications of nostalgia, one needs to consider such psycho-social frameworks of individual and
collective nostalgia derived from psychology, sociology, and marketing research. They provide
information about the thinking, feeling and relating that occur with nostalgia also about the
context that shapes the experience. It is important therefore for marketers to have knowledge
about these theories so as to be in a position to deploy nostalgia in the marketing strategies and
most importantly to be in a position to work out how consumers are likely to react to the
nostalgia marketing communication appeals.
Collective memory theory
Collective memory theory is derived from sociology and social psychology and concern with
how memory of any event is created socially and shared by lots of people when such memory
concerns certain phenomenon in history or culture. As for nostalgia marketing, this theory
contributed to understanding why specific products, brands or advertisements can trigger
nostalgia of several generations, culture, etc., Wildschut et al. (2014) explored collective
nostalgia as a form of emotions experienced by a group of people for a particular thing or event
that is beneficial to the group. Using this created common nostalgic platform, marketers are
therefore able to achieve an emotional appeal that is derived from appealing to common culture
that most people within a given society can easily associate with. For example, re-introduction of
a product that was famous in the 1980s will create nostalgia to people who grew up in that
decade whether or not they actually used the product. According to the theory, collective
6
memories are also socially created, negotiated through cultural objects, media and people’s
interactions. In this context, brands can act as the embodiments of the cultural memories and
enroll marketing communications procedures that affirm or exoticize the given history. This
approach is well illustrated by campaigns that allude to significant picture scenes from the
popular culture or history, activities whose occurrences are still remembered to this particular
day, marketers need to be aware of the possible problems that are connected with the usage of
collective nostalgia. While Baker and Kennedy perfectly identify the key advantages of historical
advertising appeals, they also raise the danger Sign, that historical references can be
overestimated or even turned into a “false nostalgia” Appeal that will not be interpreted by all the
consumers of the target audience as natural. In addition, the last element regarding collective
memory theory links to the generational cohort concept in the field of marketing. It may
therefore be argued that different age groups have different collective memories that would result
to different nostalgic stimuli and / or reactions. This notion was investigated by Holbrook and
Schindler (1991) and it can be argued that consumers develop long-term attitude toward cultural
goods that originated from their childhood and youth may be useful in creating effective
segmentation for advertising. If applying to global marketing it is also important to remember
that collective memories can often be very distinct across cultures, thus affecting the ways that
nostalgia might be employed.
Self-continuity hypothesis
According to the self-continuity hypothesis the people need to have a coherent self-narrative
over time and thus nostalgia helps in keeping the continuity intact. According to Sedikides et al.
(2009), nostalgia facilitates self-continuity because it links the past and present selves, which
enhance the perception of stability and organization in one’s life. It is apt for explaining
consumer attraction to brands or products that are associated with their past or resume the old
7
personality. When marketing products or services, thus the self-continuity hypothesis is that
when the consumer nostalgia is activated in a way that connects the past with the present, it will
produce a positive effect. For instance, a brand that has been associated with the consumers from
a tender age will likely appeal to the consumers’ self-continuity perhaps contributing to high
brand allegiance. The psychological need that marketers can exploit in building a brand
encompasses the consistency aspect where marketers should come up with campaigns implying
that the brand or product has been a companion of the consumers throughout their stages in life,
the theory also tells why consumers may avoid change to known products or brands known to
them because these changes can imply some threat to self-continuity. This finding would be
useful when a marketer of a product is planning on conducting a redesign or change of a brand
identity, since the frequency of the product being associated with the consumer’s past is
significant, it is advisable to retain some aspects of the brand identity that are associated with the
consumer’s history. Also, the self-continuity hypothesis can be used to manage communication
processes connected to the introduction of new goods to the consumers as these new goods are
related to the brand the consumer has a relationship with. In the study by Loveland et al. (2010)
the authors described that people with a higher level of need for belonging exhibited increased
preference for nostalgia products which may be as a result explained by self-continuity
hypothesis. Thus, nostalgic objects can be objects individuals directly and tangibly connect to
one’s past, and as a result, remind consumers of who they are and where they come from. This
research finding implies that marketers could derive value in adopting a two-dimensional
approach to audience segmentation – by the basal strength of people’s attachment needs – in
order to target the nostalgic appeal effectively.
8
Cognitive appraisal theory
Another theory that was derived from the quality of emotion research is the cognitive appraisal
theory a framework that attempts to describes how in templates respond to stimuli, including
nostalgic cues. In this theory, emotions are held to stem from one’s appraisal of an event or
situation in the environment. Cognitive appraisal theory also directs attention on why some
stimuli elicit nostalgia and how the feelings elicited affect the consumers in the context of
nostalgia marketing. In its prediction, it is clear that nostalgic responses are not an inherent
psychological function or reflexive response but a product of one’s cognitive evaluations. Such
evaluations can be personal significance, goal congruency, and coping anticipating. For
marketers, this means that the use of nostalgia appeals should be synchronized with the target
clients’ cognitive assessment. For example, a nostalgic appeal can be Viewed as more persuasive
if the reminiscence it elicits aligns with the consumer’s current and ideal self and if the appeal
supports the associated cognition. In their study about the emotional content of nostalgia, Holak
and Havlena (1998) identified that nostalgia being a bittersweet emotion, consists of both,
pleasant and unpleasant feelings. This is in line with cognitive appraisal theory stating that
emotions can be complex and may have more than one aspect grounded on appraisal dimensions.
Marketers using nostalgia should be cognizant of this psychological state; positive emotions may
be mixed with negative ones when consumers are targeted with familiar, nostalgic stimuli in a
marketing context. Similarly, cognitive appraisal theory would posit that even within the same
nostalgic stimulus, people could have different tendencies on how they would appraise the event
hence leading to differences in the emotional levels. In this regard, the matters expounded in the
paper are helpful for marketers to grasp the reason why some nostalgic campaigns would elicit
distinct reception among different segments of the population.
9
Autobiographical memory
Episodic memory, is an area known for bearing records of various events and experiences in an
individuals’ life refers to nostalgia and its use in marketing, this type of memory is focused on
consumers’ interactions and responses in relation to brands, products, and advertisements that
trigger their personal history. Sujan (1985) also emphasized autobiographical memory which she
defined as memory that captured moments of the consumer activity and found out that memory
captures had a huge impact on consumer judgments thereby affecting their purchasing decisions.
Kirsh (2010, p. 165) carried out a study to understand the role of autobiographical memories that
link to the effects of nostalgia marketing whereby it was noted that such memories are ideal in
allowing brand recall. When the campaign recalls a consumer’s autobiographical memory, it
brings up a specific experience and is followed by robust positive affect. These outcomes
associated with the brand could translate into higher levels of brand affect, purchase intentions
and consequent loyalty, marketers can build upon this by developing communication initiatives
that require the consumer to reminisce about a particular experience or link the company’s brand
to major life events or incidents. Still, one must remember that autobiographical memories are
not always accurate and mirror past events in a way. According to Stern’s (1992) work on
nostalgia in advertising, people do not always tell the truth to the selves in the past, and tend to
think more positively of the past than it was. Thus, this inclination towards what has been
referring to as ‘rose-tinted period’, can be rather helpful to marketers since they would be able to
navigate into such an idealized past that is wanted back. It is therefore possible for the use of
autobiographical memories that are at the core of nostalgic themed marketing appeals to differ
across generations. Another study by Holbrook and Schindler (1991) indicated consumers’
cultural product preference is for life beginning in the late teens in the early twenties what is
10
referred to as the reminiscence bump This should inform marketers that the formative years are
the right time to address nostalgia.
Socioemotional selectivity theory
Socioemotional selectivity theory introduced by Carstensen further states that since people do
not want to lose time in life, they try to target goals, highlighted by their desired positive affect
and significance irrespective of their relevance to the gains in the future period. There are
important implications arising from this theory on the role of nostalgia in marketing and
specifically for the marketing of products to older consumers and the results of the current study
provide further support as to the usefulness of this theory for predicting the effectiveness of
appeals that are based on nostalgia and the patterns of age groups’ responses to such appeals,
referring to consumers’ behavior, socioemotional selectivity theory indicates that older people
might be more likely to be susceptible to nostalgia-based appeals since they tend to value
emotional gains and past associations more than younger people. In the context of aesthetic
consumption, Goulding (2002) established that such practice is done by older consumers with the
intention of relating to their younger selves. What this means for marketers is that campaigns
predicated on people’s yearning for the past could be more resonant when applied to products or
services desired by the aged. However, the relevance of this theory is far from being applied for
the conservative consumers alone hence requires further discussion on various emerging issues.
Socioemotional selectivity can be activated in the young people, if the situation causes them to
focus on primary motives of semicentennial nature, for instance, in the period of significant life
changes or in the period of the crises. They applied it, for instance, to the situation where the
mortality threat is heightened with all population age groups affected by factors such as COVID-
19 deaths, which can raise the prospect of nostalgia as a marketing strategy more applicable
across demographics, the theory also assists in understanding the fact that why in certain
11
situations, some specific forms of nostalgic appeals could be more influential than others. Thus,
it can be suggested that marketing appeals based on the sentimentality, social interactions, and
relationship aspects are especially appropriate for appealing to consumers with a socioemotional
selectivity perspective. Therefore, those brands which may offer the qualities associated with
emotion comfort and the connection to certain feelings and positive associations can claim more
success in this regard. Moreover, marketers should also be aware of how socioemotional
selectivity theory complements other elements of consumers’ behavior. For example, Routledge
et al. (2011) demonstrated that nostalgia can be used as an existential asset, which enabled the
subjects of the study to discover a purpose in their lives. This accords with the theory since it
posits that when people are faced with the unbearable nature of time, they look for the emotional
value in life. Thus, nostalgia marketing will be most effective when it is especially creative and
leads to positive associations as well as the detection of meaning or purpose.
3. Nostalgia-Driven Consumer Behavior
Nostalgia-consumption unveils various aspects of how consumers’ sentimental sins are the
driving force to make purchasing decisions and brand affiliation. This phenomenon appeals to
consumers’ nostalgia for the past or personal nostalgia which in turn leads to a higher likelihood
of brand loyalty and customers’ willingness to pay a higher price as well as the increased interest
in the marketing content. It is therefore imperative for marketers and other similar personalities
to especially comprehend the root cause of the actions influenced by nostalgia.
Emotional responses to nostalgic stimuli
Consumers experience mixed emotions based on the positive and the negative emotions that are
generated by nostalgia stimuli. Holak, and Havlena (1998) found that nostalgia composes of
several emotion such as warmth, joy, and gratitude and affection with a tint of loss or longing, it
12
also proves helpful to the use of nostalgia as a marketing tool since it provides a wide range of
emotions connected to the past for consumers’ associations. The sentimental aspect of nostalgia
may be more effective because it is often associated with vital events in a person’s life or
historical moments. In their study, Wildschut et al., (2006) note that nostalgia experiences
automatically activate self-images of the self’s role in positive events and things shared with
other close figures. Such self-centered nature of nostalgic recollections makes the personalized
nostalgic appeals as very effective in the selling strategies, nostalgia also has some psychological
utilities that concern the behavioral process of the consumers. Sedikides et al. (2008) have
introduced the idea that nostalgia works to bolster positive judgments about the self and to create
social included feelings and meaning in one’s life. These functions make relations with the past
very attractive for consumers, especially when they are worried or concerned. As Zhou et al
(2008), showed that nostalgia can actually help to reduce the level of loneliness hence might be
used as a coping strategy. This emotional strength also arises from taking the consumers mentally
to the desired foundations of the past radar. Stern (1992) found that nostalgia in advertising tend
to paint history in a rosy hue, and hence what advertising portrays as the past could have been far
from being enjoyable for, at least, some of the consumers. This can create positive associations
that range from enjoyment even if the depicted period or events weren’t witnessed by the
consumer. However, it has to be noted that the emotional responses to the nostalgic stimuli may
depend on individual factors as well as context factors. Batcho (2013) noted that although
nostalgia is widely accepted to be a ‘good’ affect, it is capable of sometimes evoking negative
affect, if it brings into focus, loss. It is such specific variations that marketers should pay
attention to when developing and designing their campaigns that are based on nostalgia.
13
Purchase intentions and decision-making
The general finding is that consumers’ purchase intentions were significantly affected by
nostalgia, some previous research by Pascal et al. (2002) also shows that using nostalgia in an
advertisement increases the perceptive evaluation of the advertisement and the brand which
enhances the buying intention, such an impact is frequently associated with the possibility that
nostalgia brings positive feelings and social relations. Thus, the influence of nostalgia following
the notion of decision-making is partially attributed to the decrease in the sensitivity to price.
Consumers have a tendency to spend more money for products that remind them a certain period
in their lives. Thus, evaluating previous research, Loveland et al. (2010) proved that consumers
with a stronger need for belonging experienced the desire for the products that have a
sentimental value and were ready to spend more on it. This implies that nostalgia is capable of
switching the consumers’ attention from rational appeals to the emotional and social aspects of
life, nostalgia also helps to make decisions because it brings up autobiographical memories.
Consumers’ knowledge is what Sujan (1985) explained about how consumers’ past experiences
influence their decisions on the products to purchase. When a product or brand is associated with
the consumers’ past, it creates a positive attitude towards the product or brand, and the person
will consider it for purchase. This process can often eliminate more logical, attribute-based
decision making in favor of emotion instigated decision making. Thus, nostalgia goes beyond
being just a manipulator of day-to-day purchased consumer goods but pervades deeper into
creating distinct brand constellations. Kessous and Roux, in a 2010 research paper, aimed at
providing an overview of the extant research work done in this area and presented an integrative
model of nostalgia in consumption where it was pointed out that a nostalgic attachment to brands
would result in preference for the brand, purchase intention, as well as repeat purchase intention.
This model shows how a principle such as nostalgia forges long-term value in the process of
14
branding that goes beyond the current purchase behaviors, it is revealed that activation of past
time related nostalgia could be more influential in terms of purchase intentions than the past
place related one. Regarding the type of ad nostalgia, Muehling and Pascal (2011) also
categorized the ads into personal nostalgia, historical and non-nostalgic; the results showed that
personal nostalgia ads were far more likely to trigger positive responses. This just goes to show
that nostalgia needs to be marketed in a way that hits home with the intended audience in order
to affect its buyer behaviors.
Brand loyalty and attachment
The need for general moods of emotions such as nostalgia is very significant in influencing the
consumer’s commitment to the brand. Kessous and Roux (2013) further investigated the
relationship mas created by nostalgic brands with the consumers, and concluded that these
brands were firmly embedded in the consumers’ view of self. It creates a strong bond with the
consumer this may have them stick with a particular brand even in the event that there are better
brands or some drastic change in the market. Thus, the impact of nostalgia in promoting brand
loyalty is mainly because it encourages a sense of legitimacy. This may be because brands that
have been present in the consumer’s life for longer or brands that create the feeling of a shared
history are more honest and trustworthy. Such perception may result to what Holbrook and
Schindler (2003) referred to as ‘‘nostalgic bonding’’, whereby consumers develop long-term
emotional ties with brands that they have used in the past. In addition, nostalgic brand
experiences help to prevent a negative generalization of the brand or the occurrence of negative
emotions as a result of a failed product. Consumers who have high brand nostalgia are likely to
exhibit brand forgiveness since they have high brand attachment with the brand. Such resilience
of brand relationships can also be attributed to Sedikides et al. ’s (2009) self-continuity
hypothesis which posits that through nostalgic brands, consumers are able to retain a stable,
15
consistent Self-identity, it can be concluded that nostalgia does not only affect loyal consumers,
but it affects all brand consumers, including already iconic brands. This means that even brands
that only debuted in the past few decades contain retro and nostalgic components to which
consumers can become emotionally attached. Thus, according to Stern (1992), advertising
establishes another kind of nostalgia, dubbed as pseudo-nostalgia, for epochs which people may
not have been personally witness or may not have been personally part of but which they would
nevertheless consider to be pretty good. For brands, this strategy means forming appeals based
on cultural memories or on the cultural memories that people would like to achieve in order to
appeal to emotions and create loyalty. Nonetheless marketers should exercise a lot of care in their
approach towards the creation of Brand loyalty using nostalgia. Thus, it was found that the
overuse of nostalgia in appeals or insincerity in nostalgic communication can have negative
effects. As Baker and Kennedy rightly pointed out in 1994, it is possible to build what they
termed as ‘false nostalgia’ which does not appeal to the consumers instead may even repel
them. The strategy of nostalgic branding can be a success only if it has the ability to respect the
past and, at the same time, to be present.
Word-of-mouth and social sharing
The influence of nostalgic consumption on consumers’ word-of-mouth communications and
information sharing is highly relevant. This is because many brand and product experiences,
associated with nostalgic appeal for the consumer, tend to influence him to share it with others.
The results of Sierra and McQuitty (2007) show that the philosophical concept of nostalgia is
widely promoted through the product as many people who experience the feeling buy products
with the purpose of sharing this sensation and thus contributing to word-of-mouth
communication. The advancement of the social media has actually augmented the impact of
through the influence of the phenomenon of nostalgia of word-of-mouth communication. Youn
16
and Jin (2017) on the same note looked at how new media technologies enable nostalgia-driven
sharing pointing out that social media offer appropriate theatrical spaces where consumers can
engage in collective reminiscing about nostalgia content. This digital word-of-mouth can
substantially increase coverage and effectiveness of the marketing campaigns which are based on
the concept of nostalgia. Being social, nostalgia also helps to increase the chances of generating
word-of-mouth efficiently. According to wildschut et al, (2014), collective nostalgia by
individuals, enhances the feeling of belonging to a certain group. This collective aspect is more
inclined to engage the consumers in a discussion of nostalgic brands or products hence
promoting the consumers to be brand activists. In addition, the very process of recalling
nostalgically familiar experiences can also be enjoyable to the consumers. Another study by Van
Tilburg et al. (2015) showed that nostalgia also increases the creativity and openness to
experience; thus, it is possible that consumers get some pleasure from creating with others the
story of their nostalgic brand experiences. This enjoyment paves the way for more sharing and
participation with more nostalgic posts and less with prosaic ones. Nonetheless, marketers should
note that communication through status-consistent broadcasts of word-of-mouth appeals rising
from nostalgic emotions may not be equally effective among all consumer segments. On the
subject of childhood brand exposure and responses to nostalgia related advertisements, Muehling
et al., observed that consumers’ reactions varied. From this, it can be concluded that the
likelihood of sharing nostalgic brand experiences might also be different which means that there
is warranted need to employ specific strategies of inciting word-of-mouth among consumers.
Generational differences in nostalgic responses
The effectiveness and nature of nostalgic appeals can vary significantly across different
generations reflecting distinct historical experiences, cultural touchstones, and life stages.
Holbrook and Schindler (1991) proposed that individuals form lasting preferences for cultural
17
products from their youth, particularly their late teens and early twenties. This "critical period"
hypothesis suggests that different generations will respond more strongly to nostalgia related to
their formative years. Millennials, for instance, often respond nostalgically to elements from the
1990s and early 2000s, while Baby Boomers might have stronger nostalgic connections to the
1960s and 1970s. Marketers need to carefully tailor their nostalgic appeals to resonate with the
specific memories and cultural references of their target generational cohort. Stern (1992)
distinguished between personal and historical nostalgia, noting that younger generations might
respond to historical nostalgia for eras they didn't personally experience, while older generations
might have more powerful responses to personal nostalgia. The socioemotional selectivity
theory, as explored by Goulding (2002), suggests that older adults may be more prone to
nostalgic consumption as they prioritize emotionally meaningful experiences. This could mean
that older generations are generally more receptive to nostalgia-based marketing. However,
recent research has shown that younger generations, particularly Millennials and Gen Z, also
exhibit strong nostalgic tendencies, often for periods they experienced only in childhood or
through media representations. Generational differences in technology use and media
consumption also influence nostalgic responses. Youn and Jin (2017) noted how new media
technologies have changed the way younger generations experience and express nostalgia. For
example, social media platforms have created new forms of "digital nostalgia" that may resonate
more strongly with younger consumers. It's crucial for marketers to recognize that while
generational differences in nostalgic responses exist individual variations within generations can
be significant. Factors such as personal experiences, cultural background and individual
personality traits can all influence how a person responds to nostalgic stimuli, regardless of their
generational cohort. Muehling et al. (2014) emphasized the importance of considering both age
18
and childhood brand exposure when predicting responses to nostalgia-themed advertisements,
highlighting the complex interplay of factors beyond just generational membership.
4. Implementing Nostalgia in Marketing Strategies
Application of nostalgia within the concept of marketing entails the exploitation of sentimental
feelings that one has toward the past so as to boost the attractiveness of a brand and engage
consumers. This is why a much finer understanding of target audiences’ past, as well as their
individual experiences, is necessary for this approach. Successful implementation pertains to
diverse marketing issues such as product differentiation, the message in advertisements, use of
narratives and approaches to online platforms, properly using childhood memories can bring up
to a four-fold increase in brand recognition and loyal consumption in different segments.
Product design and packaging
Nostalgia can be considered as a valuable tool creating emotional bonds with the brand in the
moments of product design and packaging, this approach is usually done by including aspects of
visuals, material, or functions, that would make consumers to be associated with certain past
times or experiences. Holbrook and Schindler (2003) pointed out that nostalgia can be associated
with the bonding: it is likely that all the senses be enlisted when it comes to the haptic
multimodality triggering the feel of nostalgia. Another strategy whereby products are rendered to
have an antique look is whereby companies use the designs of past products as a source of
inspiration, this can range from bringing back old products which may have been phased out of
production, making current products’ ‘retro’ editions or even adding some elements of design
from the old products into new products. For example, revival of old game consoles or the retro
style of the packaging of food products actively appeals to consumers’ childhood memories.
According to Belk (1990), possessions hold an important place in the creation of history and the
19
present article underlined how nostalgia is capable of enhancing product design in order to give
consumers the feeling of being history. Packaging design plays a unique role in nostalgia
marketing because this is the aspect that promotes first contact with the product. retro style could
include typography, colors, and graphics from specific eras, or eras in general with which people
tend to reminisce. In a similar manner, Stern (1992) described the notion of ‘fin de siècle effect’
when identifying advertising text from the turn of the twentieth century, but this design aesthetic
in use on packaging sought to evoke turn of the century aesthetics even amongst people who
could not have been alive then. Yet, nostalgia cannot be just copied to the product design and
packaging in its entirety due to certain issues. It is essential not to forget that the purpose is to
remind people of certain positive associations and foster positive feelings, but at the same time
the message should be functional and relevant to the consumers of the modern world. In their
study Loveland et al. (2010) identified that there is a positive correlation between consumers’
need for belonging and their preference for products with nostalgic design; thus, such elements
as nostalgia should be complemented by cues that signal of the group identification/belonging.
However, it is noteworthy that the use of nostalgia in product design may be beneficial
differently depending on the part of the target audience. As pointed by Muehling et al. (2014),
the subjects’ age and brand exposure during childhood should be taken into account while
predicting the reaction to products that are associated with nostalgia. This means that there is the
need for companies to carry out market research with a view of ascertaining if their selected
nostalgic design features are acceptable by target consumers. Further, as Youn Jin (2017) pointed
out, changes in new media technology also affected the younger generations’ perception of
nostalgia elements and how the nostalgic products should be re-design in the context of sharing
the information age.
20
Advertising and promotional campaigns
Lifestyle is a major driver of advertising and promotion strategies as influenced by the element
of nostalgia. These campaigns appeal to consumers’ emotions in relation to the past and thus
appeal to their reason through storytelling that is quite captivating. Pascal et al. (2002) confirmed
that when nostalgia is appealed to within an advert, there are improved attitudes towards it and
the brand which affects consumer choices. When creating possessive and sentimental advertising
appeals, marketers use graphics, tunes and stories that make the consumers feel as though they
are back in a superior past. Stern (1992) has made a distinction between self-referent nostalgia,
which is about one’s own era, and reference-referent nostalgia, which is more than just a
consumer’s era of origin. Both can be quite useful; however, it is likely that one might find more
favor among certain target groups as compared to the other. For example, where the campaign is
directed to the Baby Boomers, personal nostalgia may refer to popular icons from the era under
advertisement, whereas, where the campaign is aimed to the Millennial generation, historical
nostalgia may be used where the period being advertised is 1980’s, but the generation being
targeted has no firsthand experience of it. Ad- makers prefer using music so much in the creation
of ad jingles especially when a line of the ad is aimed at creating nostalgia. Holbrook and
Schindler (1991) observed that people tend to develop long-term consumption preferences which
are likely to be linked to music preferences in the ages beyond teenage years, but not many years
beyond that. Advertisers can build upon this by introducing music that is relevant to the specific
period, or even recording new versions of now famous songs, which are bound to induce feelings
of nostalgia. While being quite direct and clear, this form of retroactivity secures the effect of
auditory nostalgia and means a powerful tool with regard to affective bonds with the brand.
Another determinant of the efficacy of nostalgic advertising is also the cultural environment
Yzerbyt et al, (1997). This is especially likely during economic turmoil or societal change when
21
relying on familiar and idyllic narratives transforms into a need. Baker and Kennedy (1994)
further Talked about how nostalgia can act as a form of coping, this would account for why
nostalgic advertising could be more effective at a times of difficulty. However, the marketers
should exercise a certain level of cautions when incorporating nostalgia in their advertisements.
Nostalgia often works as an appeal to the consumer’s sense of romanticism, and too much of it or
uses that seem fake can annoy the consumer or cause them to not believe that the product can
live up to the promises of the marketing. Looking at the level of recall, Muehling and Pascal
(2011) argued that personal nostalgia advertisements were consistently rated higher compared to
historical nostalgia or non-nostalgic ads, implying that for campaigns, the more the linkers can
relate the messages to consumer’s personal memory/ experience, the better. Further, Youn and Jin
(2017) agreed that, with the advancement of the new media, the manifestation of ‘’nostalgia’ has
shifted and existing in a different form among the youth, the adaptation of nostalgic components
raises further questions about how nostalgia can be incorporated coherently into modern media
kinds and media communities.
Storytelling and brand narratives
Both storytelling and brand narratives can be used as the key moves to implement the concept of
nostalgia in marketing, these kinds of narratives can enable brands to find ways of eliciting an
emotional response from the audience through storytelling with nostalgic fragments. According
to Davis (1979), nostalgia as a social force is based on sociological argumentation and it
determines that through the use of nostalgic stories people can understand their personal and
group history. This applies to marketing in the sense of brand stories which provide context to
products or services to have a social narrative behind them so as to fit within history or culture.
Generally, a good nostalgic message is when the audience is tricked into believing that there is a
link between the past and the present. Sedikides et al. (2009) argued that nostalgia makes it
22
possible for one to achieve temporal integration – or self-continuity. This is where brands can
capitalize on this by creating stories that associate their product into the consumers’ long-term
associations, thus the connection to previous experiences and present products, for instance, a
technology-based firm may narrate a story from a historical basis of computing to the present
smartphones, creating a sense of the past and the need in the present. Brand narratives can also
engage the communal type of nostalgia, as discussed by Wildschut et al. (2014). Such stories
refer to some cultural nuances or historical happening familiar to all the consumers, thus creating
a ness. Thus, associating the brand with these collective memories can help create an appealing
shared emotional appeal that fosters the consumers’ bond with the brand. It is especially helpful
when the brands are historical or have participated in some way in cultural events. Authenticity
of the nostalgic brand narratives plays an important role in making them work. Stern (1992)
stated that in confusing referent, nostalgia in advertising seeks to construct what Stern termed as
‘the myth of the past’ which could very well be more appealing than the actuality of it. Though
this optimism and ideal will be effective, the brands can’t be fully idealistic but must contain
some aspects of realism in order to be credible. This may comprise acceptance of there being
good and bad things with the past or blending actual consumers’ experiences and tales into the
branding story. Digital storytelling has given a new prospective to nostalgic brand stories. In the
paper, Youn and Jin (2017) presented how new media technologies alter the context of nostalgia
advertising. Due to such brand integration, the brands can now share sequentially connected
narratives containing media that encourages the consumers to interact with memories in a new
and profound way. For example, a brand might design a communicative interface with the
timeline of the brand’s development where users can remember the different time periods and
share them. This interactivity does not only extend the nostalgic feeling but also has the potential
23
of incorporating the consumer’s touch in contributing to shareable content, which cements the
bond between the consumer and the brand.
Retro and vintage marketing approaches
Retro and vintage marketing strategies target the rather appealing and relatable visual from
different periods in the past. They mainly refer to the acts of bringing back to life or recycling,
designs, products, and advertising trends of older decades. Therefore, based on the work of
Holbrook (1993) the idea of nostalgia is relevant to consumer attitude since the exploitation of
retro and vintage techniques is usually quite beneficial when it comes to grabbing the consumer’s
attention and encouraging brand preference. One of the most typical retrospective marketing
tactics is returning the previously recalled products to the market or the favorite varieties of the
present products. This approach stands the ability to elicit what Havlena and Holak (1991)
described as the ‘‘good old days’’ phenomenon whereby consumers have paragon images of
products they used in the past. When a brand returns to the market favorite product or the
packaging that was familiar to every buyer, this causes the desired psychological reaction and
consumers’ reminiscence. Also, these revivals can interest car consumers interested in ‘original’
brands, which they might have heard of from their parents or grandparents. Another marketing
element that is related to the concept of retro marketing is the use of vintage style
advertisements, this might mean employing some of the visual attitudes of the corresponding
decades, phosphorescent mottos or jingles. Stern (1992) analyzed that even people who were too
young to know the earlier specificities of the social past are immersed in an idealizing picture by
the advertisers. Such a technique is helpful when the goal is to create timeless and historic appeal
of a brand and, therefore, increase the perceived value of a brand’s goods, for retro and vintage to
be implemented properly, it must be considered who the target consumers are. Goulding, living
by his discoveries, proved that people of different ages use nostalgia in different ways which
24
confirm that it is welcome to adopt specific retro approaches to target specific generations’
experiences. For example, something which is dear to Baby Boomers and they would consider as
iconic, Millennials simply refer to it as outdated. It is the duty of marketers while passing down a
piece of history and its perception to the target customers, simultaneously target consumers must
be appealed. With the help of the introduction of IT and Electronics in the modern world, retro
and vintage marketing has got an addition to its dimensions. Youn and Jin (2017) explained how
the advancement in communication technology rendered the concepts of nostalgia advertising to
be more participatory and sharable. Companies can design digital advertising campaigns that are
based on the seventies, eighties, or other years, while including the current possibilities of the
Internet, for example, Facebook Filters or games based on the chosen theme. Such forms of
indirect vaporization of marketing can particularly appeal to young consumers who may have the
feeling of the ‘mediated nostalgia’; thus, the feeling characteristic to the period they did not
experience personally yet was popular culturally and mediated massively.
Digital and social media applications
Approaches that deal with successful implementation of nostalgia in marketing have
experienced a paradigm shift with the introduction of digital technologies and the ubiquitous
social media. These new channels create not only a new way of stirring and tapping into the
brand nostalgia factor for which the established channels never provided the media leverage.
New media technologies were discussed by Youn and Jin (2017) who mentioned that social
media is an appropriate communication environment in which people can come together to share
memories and nostalgic content. Social networks, inter alia, can be regarded as means largely
applicable for the formation of nostalgic marketing. People willingly come across such updates
daily, such as Facebook’s ‘On This Day,’ or tag their posts with #TBT, indicating that they want
to see old material. It’s possible for brands to use such behaviors by developing campaigns that
25
call on users to share their personal memories associated with brand or product, it develops the
interest and stimulates the desire to share an emotion, especially the one which ties people
together into a community, as Wildschut et al. (2014) mention in their study on collective
nostalgia. Digital technologies make it possible to obtain personalized nostalgic products, based
on statistical data, which unveil consumer’s preferences and their past activities brands can
generate individualized nostalgia-related content. It complements Sujan’s (1985) research on
autobiographical memory in consumers’ judgment, indicating that nostalgic approaches might be
especially persuasive to consumers for enhancing their purchases. As the article pointed out, the
characteristic of digital media is interactive, which provides new means of using nostalgia in the
advertising strategies. Relationship marketing can be achieved through virtual and augmented
technologies of offering consumers a tour in time and pointing out brand history in an engaging
way with the help of interactive timelines, or application that incorporate vintage looks into the
present reality. These experiences can develop more powerful feelings than the traditional
commercials; that might result in the improvement of the consumers’ attitudes as well as their
purchase intentions according to Pascal et al. (2002). Still, it is crucial to use the findings of this
study to be aware of the peculiarities of functioning digital nostalgia for modern marketers.
When it comes to products, Holbrook and Schindler (2003) observed that nostalgic preferences
are generally developed during one’s childhood. For the younger generations, the ‘youth’ period
now has digital aspects incorporated in them. Therefore, the implementation of nostalgia
marketing in digital contexts could be based on the topics related to the early Internet, video
games from different periods, or the appearance of social networks. At the same time, due to
technological development, even things created during the last five to ten years can become a
source of nostalgia, as long as they tap into the consumer’s primary, or even secondary,
26
memories, which opens up the possibility of the ‘digital nostalgia’ campaign, especially among
the Millennial and Gen Z audiences.
5. Case Studies and Best Practices
A review of literature on case studies and best practices presents information on how
organizations can engage nostalgia marketing and possible errors to avoid, through reviewing
and analyzing these actual nostalgic campaigns, marketer can obtain the best practices for
making people have feeling responding, and strengthen their loyalty for the advertised brands,
these researches also explain the potential pitfalls of nostalgia advertising and how to avoid
them; specifically the necessity of accurate values appeals, cultural relevance and the right
choice of the target audience.
Successful nostalgia-driven campaigns
Established marketing approaches that target the idea of nostalgia in marketing have shown that
the sale of products can be effective by appealing to people’s emotions. These campaigns are
good at appealing to the consumer’s seek for nostalgia and therefore work greatly in developing
friends with brands. A study by Holbrook and Schindler (1991) is accounted for as one of the
most relevant to the case, which discusses the creation of long-term preferences for products that
were used in the early period of life. These campaigns are not only trying to target the older
gamers and consumers who used the older rounds of the products but also the younger gamers
interested in the classic games. Another good idea is to repurpose old commercials, or sketches
imitating older advertisements of a product’s packaging. Stern (1992) described how the adverts
employ cultural references of a bygone age which are referenced even if the consumer never
lived it. This strategy has been applied by many companies including the coca cola company that
occasionally introduces bottles with old styles of branding. Such campaigns utilize what Baker
27
and Kennedy (1994) described as perceiving nostalgia, making even young customers feel like
they are from that period which is an opposite of real nostalgia. Other examples of effective and
popular campaigns include music based nostalgic ones. As Holbrook and Schindler (1989) had
stated, music consumption reaches the highest level of bald consumption in the age of late
adolescence and early adulthood; thus, music is also a powerful stimulus for nostalgia.
Companies which use hit songs from certain generations or replicate the original compositions in
today’s music industry usually record high levels of emotional appeal. Such a strategy is in line
with the studies done by Pascal, Bouche, and Antona (2002) who observed that processes of
nostalgia can enhance perceived attitudes regarding ad and the brand. Internet and free social
networks accessible in the Internet create new opportunities in the sphere of successful nostalgia
marketing. According to Youn and Jin (2017), the advancement of the new media technologies
required the modification of nostalgia advertising in a manner that makes it more engaging and
easier to share. This is because people are tradition-bound and therefore, such campaigns elicit
enthusiasm from participants in the form of sharing their own experiences or engaging in a
themed effort. Such campaigns appealed to what Wildschut et al. (2014) referred to as collective
nostalgia that creates a perception of the consumers as a community. Finally, some of the
futurology, which has been attached most successfully to nostalgia, have concerned continuity
between past and present for the brand image. In this context, Sedikides et al. (2009) suggested
that through nostalgia, people are able to optimize self-continuity, which means that one’s
identity can be constant over time. Those companies that succeed in establishing associations
between their long history and the current products are likely to experience enhanced trust from
the buyers. For instance, automakers such as Volkswagen enter the market and relaunch some
classic models with contemporary attributes, which satisfy market demand’s traditional,
28
sentimental side as well as its progressive, or innovative aspect. These campaigns prove what
Loveland et al. (2010) called as the ‘nostalgic innovation,’ which is the blend of old is style with
new age comfort.
Failed attempts and lessons learned
Generally, it is acceptable to use nostalgia as a strategy in marketing; however, not all
companies that try to do so are successful. That is why some disappointment can be observed in
cases of failed nostalgia campaigns due to the failure to relate to the intended audience,
misrepresentation of the past, or the selection of a wrong time to introduce the campaign. One of
the risks is “false nostalgia” which Baker and Kennedy defined as the marketing desire for an
organization to draw consumers’ attention to experiences or products that they have no affinity
for (1994). Less creatively satisfying can result in stunted or mediocre campaigns that seem like
the brand is trying too hard or being insincere. The other reason cited was ‘nostalgia fatigue.’
Stern (1992) explained that the consumers are usually comforted by the advertising appeals that
romantic the past, but this was said to be counterproductive if overused as it would bore the
consumer and make him or her develop negative attitudes towards the commercials. One can
easily fall for the ‘sentimental’ cliché of a brand associating itself with ‘the good old days,’ when
in reality they could not care less for today’s learner or the innovators. Basically, cultural
insensitivity also costs an organization heavily if shown in nostalgic campaigns. According to
Holbrook (1993), nostalgia affects consumers’ expectations, but such expectations are ingrained
in psyche and socio-cultural contexts. In my experience, campaigns that do not address potential
criticism, particularly on how they may disrespect diversity, or that idealize some aspects of the
past as good might be severely criticized. This goes a long way to explain why research has to be
done and diverse opinion used when it comes to the campaigns to be made. Technical
management is also a weakness in nostalgia marketing, especially in the digitization of television
29
commercials. Youn and Jin (2017) examined the shift of the application of nostalgia advertising
and media technologies in its execution. It is also possible to have an alarming and wrong
combination of retro style and modern technology, which will hardly fitting the relation to an
advertisement campaign. This is maybe even more pertinent for younger genera, which might
perceive ‘retro’ or ‘vintage’ design in a different way. Misconceived campaigns are usually those
that go wrong in trying to associate the victory factor with the brand or the product. Muehling et
al. (2014) stressed that age, as well as childhood brand exposure, should be taken into account
when assessing people’s reactions to nostalgia appeals. While the attempt to capitalize on the
sentiments that are associated with the mentioned period or event can depict sincerity, it can
produce a counterproductive effect when the citing brand is not associated with the referenced
time period, it shows that brands themselves and their target audiences should be taken into
account to apply notions of nostalgia successfully.
Cross-cultural considerations
The application of nostalgia in marketing strategies across different cultures presupposes the
latter’s sensitivity to the differences in historical experience, values, and memories. It is apparent
that what graced one culture’s memory, is inept or provocative to another. According to Holbrook
and Schindler (1991), the consumer’s preferences for cultural goods from their childhood are
long-standing and stable, although they might differ in various cultures. As seen earlier the
notion of time and perceptions toward the past may vary from culture to culture; therefore, it is
quite relevant to explore how nostalgia is received in any given culture. For example, cultures
with the cyclic approach towards time space might have different references to nostalgia in
comparison with the cultures, which have a linear view of time. Consumers’ engagement in
nostalgic marketing is a crucial factor to understand, and therefore marketers should have
adequate knowledge of these cultural differences to foster appropriate nostalgic campaigns.
30
Wildschut et al. (2014) have introduced the concept of collective nostalgia, which can be viewed
as a criterion for cross-cultural marketing research since it reflects people’s common culture and
history. There are many cases in which those historical events and periods which are perceived as
positive in some culture may be perceived as negative in the other. Stern (1992) analyzed the
techniques where by the past is cast in a rosy picture and these have to be done with regard to
culture sensitivity. Period and political indices occupy a key position in the various markets and
hence, marketers require to be very sensitive to sensitive issues in these markets in order to avoid
offending the populace or reducing serious incidences to mere jokes. It is significant as a very
broad feature of contemporary globalization of media and popular culture which coproduced
cross-cultural nostalgia marketing. The authors Youn and Jin, in their publication in 2017,
pointed that with the intervention of new media technologies, nostalgia advertising has shifted to
a more globalized tendency concerning the sharing of nostalgic content. This has resulted in a
situation whereby some cultural commodities especially from the dominant media transmitting
countries can create feelings of nostalgia in the various cultures. However, marketers should
avoid the mistake of going global because they assume they have the unity of the world at their
fingertips and should design their strategies based on the country. The ‘foreign’ and cross-
cultural nostalgia rely on the linguistic and visual signs for effectively selling their products.
According to Kessous and Roux (2010), there is an integrative model of nostalgia in
consumption and the consider semiotics as an essential component of the process. It seems that
translating terms and phrases associated with nostalgia, as well as simple slogans, call for not
only being a language expert but also being culturally sensitive to restore emotional essence of
the translated text. Likewise, promotional images that compel some culture to reminisce may be
31
obscene or have no relations to another culture all together, meaning that care must be taken
when using images in marketing.
Ethical implications of leveraging nostalgia
Due to the use of nostalgia in marketing, there are several ethical issues that marketers should
consider while making their marketing strategies. With regards to the first one, there are
arguments that nostalgia could lead to romanticization of historical events and eras, as well as
their positive reinforcement. Stern (1992) pointed out that, generally, nostalgia in advertising
glorifies history and thus erases or reduces the history of social wrongs or other problems. When
using nostalgia, marketers must ensure that it does not offend the sensitive cultural aspects of
various diverse consumers and if by so doing the marketers are just concealing some negative
historical facts. Another ethical consideration is on the exploitation of the emotions of a party as
portrayed in the movie. Zhou et al. (2008) define nostalgia as a potential protective factor against
loneliness and threats linked to existence, although this psychological function contributes to
making nostalgic marketing technique effective, it brings into light the issue of morality of
eliciting such feelings for advertising purposes. Marketers need to ask themselves whether the
arousal of nostalgia is an actual benefit to the society or whether it is just a manipulation tool the
helps generate consumer interest. There are also ethical concerns when it comes to the
segmentation of aged related demographics in nostalgia marketing. In a study conducted by
Holbrook and Schindler on consumer satisfaction in 1991, it was identified that basically the
consumers tend to remain loyal to the products which they have started using or consuming from
their late teens and twenty. While this insight can be applied in the development of marketing
tactics, one has to question ageism or discrimination against age groups. Ethical nostalgia
marketing should avoid exclusion of the consumer based on his/her age or generation and this
should thus be embraced as much as possible. Some issues of privacy arise with the application
32
of the more personal data to build the experience of nostalgia. Youn and Jin (2017) explored the
way that new media technologies have changed the look of nostalgia advertising, complaining
the users’ information and their searching history. Despite this, it is possible to justify this
ethically in cases of nostalgic marketing and adherence to the three aspects of data protection:
notice, choice, and seceded security measures. Consequently, marketers need to pay heed and
satisfaction to the consumer’s right and privacy while creating and delivering nostalgic
experience. Lastly, there are ethical concerns for creating ‘’fake’ nostalgia or what Baker and
Kennedy (1994) call ‘’pseudo-nostalgia’’. Though creating nostalgia for eras or experiences that
consumers have never personally experienced is useful, there are opinions on the appropriateness
of it and whether or not it is right to deceive consumers. From this aspect, marketers must decide
whether their campaigns reflect genuine cultural or historical prerogatives or if, on the contrary,
they are ‘inventing’ cultural and historical heritages that could be perceived as manipulative.
Measuring the effectiveness of nostalgic marketing
The assessment of the effectiveness of nostalgic marketing campaigns with rely on both the
change in emotions of consumers as well as the alteration of the business statistics. While
definite indicators such as the volume of sales, brand recognition, or market share indicate the
effectiveness of promotional campaigns, they do not encompass the scope of appeal that employs
the principles of nostalgia. Attitudinal measures are thus deemed to be essential in the
determination of nostalgia marketing efficiency, having established that evoking nostalgia in an
advert can positively impact consumer attitude towards both the advert and brand as posited by
Pascal et al., (2002). These aspects are crucial to the assessment of nostalgic campaigns, which
heavily rely on the scores obtained by metrics related to emotional appeal. Holak and Havlena
(1998) have described that nostalgia involves such fine feelings as warmth, joy, pro-attitudes
such as gratitude, and affection. Chiefs can assess these feelings by poll, facial recognition
33
systems, or through physiological indices on the effect the campaign has on the audience’s
emotions. Sentiment analysis related to social networks can also be helpful, while the audience
warmly welcomes content that has a nostalgic tinge, as proved by Youn & Jin (2017) on how
new media technologies have impacted nostalgia advertising. Increasing brand association as
well as repeat customer bases are long-term measures of pastime marketing effectiveness.
Kessous and Roux (2013) researched on a theoretical facet concerning the utilization of nostalgia
as a tool to build the brand associations and found out that the overtime brand loyalty indexes
can serve and indicator of the success of the nostalgia campaign. Measures that reflect the degree
of repeat purchase behavior, retention rates, and brand advocacy (e. g., net promotor scores) can
indicate the long-term effectiveness of nostalgic marketing campaigns, brand-related outcomes
help evaluate overall success of nostalgia as a marketing strategy on its influence on the brand
image and positioning. Using nostalgia in advertisements can negatively influence the audience’s
perception of the respective brand by constructing a selective view of the past which can even be
idealized according to the author Stern (1992). Administrating surveys or focus groups to
evaluate shifts in brand attitude may also assist the marketing department to decipher how
effectively the nostalgic appeals is positioning the brand in the target consumer’s mind-set.
Further, the degree to which a brand can maintain premium price or benchmark itself against the
competitor’s performance will determine the effectiveness of nostalgic differentiation strategies.
Other marketing research methods such as the A/B tests and controlled experiments can
elaborate more on the effectiveness of nostalgic marketing. It is therefore possible to analyze the
extent of the influence that nostalgic elements have by comparing advertisements or the design
of products now and as they were in the past. This approach corresponds with Muehling and
Pascal (2011), where the authors compared personal nostalgia, historical nostalgia, and non-
34
nostalgia adverts. More experimental research can generate comparative metrics as to
productivity of nostalgic marketing with regard to its ability to attract consumers’ attention,
retention and influence their purchasing decisions, however, similar with Holbrook and Schindler
(1991), nostalgia usefulness could differ due to consumer group targeting, hence the study’s
results should be analyzed by segments.
6. Future Trends and Innovations
They are influencing the nature through which firms are capable of reaching consumers through
appeals to emotions in memory marketing which is a growing field as well as developing trends.
Considering the premises of technology change and shift in people’s attitude, it is possible to
state that there is always space for innovative and interventionist approach to awakening
nostalgia. From the VR-based campaigns, to the green products with the 90’s vibes colors and
shapes, they can illustrate that nostalgia is still dominating the marque communications but what
is changing is the digital and sustainable consumers.
Emerging technologies in nostalgic experiences
It is groundbreaking that new age technologies are being used in the approach that brands take
to build and transmit authentic value cues to the consumers. Virtual Reality (VR) and Augmented
Reality (AR) are brilliant tools when it comes to reaching for the realistic reproduction of certain
periods or environments which are nostalgic for the consumers. These technologies are in
consonant with Stern, who separately writing on advertising as a form of nostalgia asserted that a
society’s media icons can distort the picture regarding the past. As VR and AR are capable of
facilitating imaginative environments as nostalgic as the consumer’s brand loyalty, there is a
possibility that consumers are engaged more deeply at an emotional level by the branded content.
Advanced technologies such as AI and machine learning are making it possible to develop
35
techniques for processing consumers’ data which make it possible to personalize nostalgia
content. This event is consistent with the observations made by Holbrook and Schindler (1991),
who suggested that people retain lifelong preferences for cultural goods acquired during their
childhood. AI is capable of recognizing such preferences and feed the person with nostalgic
content that the person prefers. For example, music streaming services are in a position to
generate a set of the favorite songs from the different generations or user’s preferences. The
techniques like blockchain technology and NFT offer new potentials for the nostalgic marketing
within the new media environment. These technologies make it possible to build and trade
special digital items which can be the remastered pieces of Nostalgia Art, duplicated game
characters avatars and pieces from the famous Pop-Culture History. This trend relates well with
what Belk (1990) concluded about the role of possessions in maintaining an identity of the past
although this is done in cyberspace, sophisticated audio interfaces are broadening the
possibilities of sound in reminiscing of the past. Smart speakers and spatial audio will enable
brands to design soundscape experiences around a particular period or a particular event in one’s
life. This is in concordance with Holak and Havlena’s (1998) analytical differentiation of
antecedents of nostalgia and its multiple facets, one of which is auditory. Smart nostalgic
products are being built by using IoT architecture because the aesthetics of those products are
vintage and they are capable of functioning in today’s world. For instance, the radio that has an
appearance of the traditional one, but assimilates with the internet streaming option or the
appliance that has a retro design, but is compatible with home automation systems. This trend
can be accorded to what Loveland et al. (2010) referred to as the need to belong and desire for
products with a nostalgic appeal, at the same time serving the new age consumer’s needs in terms
of ease of use of technology.
36
Sustainability and nostalgia marketing
The current focus on sustainability and the integration of nostalgia aspects into marketing
strategies result in growing popularity of such product variants, this trend can be particularly
supported by Belk (1990) who described how things contribute to the construction and
maintenance of history in people’s lives. Predictably secured nostalgia marketing strategy
focuses on the timeless appeal of products underpinning consumers’ purchase decisions by
essentially offering them long-lasting products that may become part of their sentimental
possessions. Today, the market sees many brands going back to preindustrial more
environmentally friendly processes of manufacturing and presenting them as part of the vintage
concept. This approach touches on what Stern (1992) has referred to as historical nostalgia where
people tend to easily reminisce pre-specified historic periods thinking and feeling that products
which were manufactured during such eras were natural and/or ethically made. For instance,
icons of fashion may advertise apparel articles that are crafted using non-mechanized sewing
methods that are environmentally friendly and demands by those consumers looking for hatred
orientation or retro look products. For the purpose of this research, it will be observed that the
circular economy is being incorporated into the concept of nostalgia marketing. There is a focus
on prolonging the lifespan of products with guidelines promoting the repair, refurbishment, as
well as resale of vintage products in place to support sustainability and consumers’ nostalgic
tendencies. This trend supports the studies carried out by Holbrook and Schindler (2003) on
nostalgic bonding where consumers get close attachment with products that were familiar to
them offering comfort in life’s uncertainties. To this end, longevity and circularity, as well as a
focus on sustainability, support these brands to enhance those necessary emotional connections.
Campaigns conceived and marketed based on the concept of nostalgia are especially popular
where sustainability campaigns are recycled or cut/paste from earlier ones. These are based on
37
the concept of collective nostalgia by Wildschut et al. (2014) which uses people’s memories of
past environmental activism or a time when individuals and communities were not as profligate
with resources such as throwing away plastic bags, rubber shoes or unspecified discard items.
Properly designed campaigns can be especially helpful for encouraging people to act sustainably
because, instead of focusing on the problem, it unveils possible solutions to it by associating
them with positive societal events. Thus, digital sustainability can be viewed as the new frontier
of nostalgic marketing. Youn and Jin (2017) also described how in today’s modern world, thanks
to media and technological advancements, everyone has his or her way of portraying nostalgia.
Businesses are designing products and experiences that either remind the consumer of the early
days of the world wide web or gaming, or which encourage such positive uses of digital
technology as reusing, repairing, or consuming less digital technology, or computing sustainably.
Combining together elements of vintage computer sci-fi with the environment has a clear
audience – young, active users of information technology, who like to reminisce about various
Telecom eras but at the same time do not remain indifferent to pollution problems.
Personalization and AI in nostalgic campaigns
Marketing in the nostalgic appeals area is experiencing a change through personalization as
powered by the incorporation of Artificial Intelligence (AI). This finding is therefore in
conformity with Sujan’s (1985) study that recommended autobiographical memory as a vital
component of consumer reasoning. It’s possible to effectively analyze a large amount of personal
data to determine which of them causes a given consumer nostalgic feeling thus, personalizing
nostalgia. Recommendation systems with the help of the artificial intelligence are being
employed for dispensing the nostalgic content on different platforms. For instance, music
streaming services can recommend films or programs from the user’s childhood based on data
about age, and place of residence, and also the history of their viewing. This approach builds on
38
what Holbrook and Schindler (1991) referred to as consumers’ acquisition of long-term
preferences when they are young. Using and implementing AI in the process of such analysis
allows brands to conjure up more efficient and emotionally charged nostalgic appeals. NLP and
sentiment analysis are helping brands readily address consumers’ nostalgic feelings on the social
media and other online channels. This is in consonance with Sierra and McQuitty’s (2007) study
on the effect of attitudes and emotions on nostalgia consumption. Thus, brands will be able to
better target their consumers’ nostalgic appeals and even partake in real-time nostalgic
conversations with them. AI is also used to produce remastered or rewritten content, for example,
images, sounds, text, that has a vintage period theme. The use of this technology can make it
possible to create large amounts of nostalgic content to capture a large audience with different
segments within it, this approach creates an ethical dilemma touched upon by Baker and
Kennedy (1994) concerning the phenomenon of ‘simulate nostalgia.’ The appeal of nostalgia
needs to be achieved through honest branding. In nostalgic marketing, one finds customization or
personalization not only in communication but also in the products themselves and their
presentations. AI and this production technologies like 3D printing can the develop parts and
products that can bear identifiable trademarks associated with clientele or small groups in
society. Such trends relate to the study by Kessous and Roux (2013) on the application of
nostalgia as a tool for developing unique brand affiliations. Brands need to create products that
evoke nostalgic appeals; this implies that by creating nostalgic products to fit an individual’s
personality, brands stand a better chance of creating an even deeper bond with the customers.
Balancing innovation with nostalgic appeal
Keeping such aspects as innovation and, at the same time, referencing to the shared past is one
of the big concerns brands faces when aiming at utilizing the potential of nostalgia while
maintaining consumers’ interests in the constantly evolving market. Using the principle of
39
symmetrical equilibrium, the design proposed is in synergy with the ideas of ‘nostalgic
innovation’ as elucidated by Loveland et al. (2010) that appreciated the use of retro appeal or
familiar features with contemporary utility. It is therefore a strategy that can be successfully
implemented because it will tickle the consumer’s need to belong, need to follow the crowd as
well as the adventurous need that endears consumers to the new product. A strategy of achieving
this balance is through product design which features or is made from items that invoke the
memories of the past, accompanied by features of modern technology. With this, retailing points
to the works of Holbrook and Schindler (2003) on nostalgic bonding; consumers develop
affection towards commodities that would remind them of past events. The here suggested
approach with reference to the public’s over-cognitive affection to nostalgic features and
simultaneously suggesting modifications from the pragmatic perspective will ensure that
consumers’ both limbic and cognitive reactions are engaged. In marketing communications,
brands are attempting to either refer to past eras or campaigns while discussing present-day
issues, or using modern media platforms, if not both. There is no heteroglossia issue in these
examples, which relate to Stern’s (1992) analysis of historical nostalgia in advertising but apply
the concept to contemporary scenarios. For instance, a brand can modify a special advertisement
that was created in the past, and produce it with better message on issues of diversity and
inclusion or, refine the advertisement for the social media context. Therefore, engaging and
interactional components in campaigns related to nostalgia aid in narrowing down the temporal
split between the two. It is in this aspect that Youn and Jin (2017) stated that there are significant
changes on how nostalgia is being profile. People are being encouraged to incorporate these
technologies into BRANDS to facilitate the creation of new cultures associated with consumer
products whereby consumers are being encouraged to be part of new trends like use of
40
applications that overlay old cartoons aesthetics in modern environments; use of social media
challenges in which people dress in old fashion styles. In light of this, another area of integrating
innovation and nostalgic elements is through the consideration of audience factors with regard to
the past and the present. Other scholars such as Muehling et al., (2014) supported the latter,
stressing that the role of nostalgia in advertising should not rule out age and childhood exposure
to brands. Brands have to understand the diverse make-up of the generations and that they are
likely to respond to nostalgia in different ways thereby having different expectations when it
comes to innovations. A probable realization could be to develop product portfolios or
advertising appeals that appeal to some sections of the audience by referring to tradition, while
others focus on modernity.
Predicting future nostalgic trends
Forecasting future trends in nostalgic consumption is a process of analyzing the modern culture,
innovations, and different generations and their outlooks, for example, one of the up-and-coming
subjects is the longing for the beginning of digital media – young people start to miss Myspace,
Nokia 3310, or the appearance of internet memes. This is in line with Holbrook & Schindler’s
(1991) argument that preferences are obtained at their highest figure during the age of innovation
and that since digital natives are growing up with the digital sector, they will represent a rising
force as age strikes and continues to rise. Future nostalgic trends are also likely to involve
sustainability and recycling becoming more as people again long for perceived ‘simpler’ ways of
life. This trend complies with Stern’s (1992) on historical nostalgia, whereby such time periods
are idealized it might become more common for companies to develop products and services
associated with environmentally sound ideals, while also appealing to consumers’ past and active
imaginations. Thus, it can be assumed that the phenomenon of “global nostalgia” will also
receive significant attention with increasing globalization. Wildschut et al. (2014) discussed
41
collective nostalgia, and in the context of the globalized society, simultaneous trends that are
across nations, may be observed, because of shared experiences or frequency of the use of mass
media sources. This could lead to a sawdust and old-style marketing campaign that are more
universally appealing. Thus, curiously enough, based on the progress made in creating virtual
and augmented reality applications, creators have every potential to offer even more intense
experiences associated with nostalgia. This trend corresponds to Youn and Jin’s (2017) study
focusing on how new media technologies modify nostalgia advertising. The future of nostalgic
marketing can be a fully developed virtual reality where people are placed in specified
environments which mimic the old eras or augmented reality, where nostalgic aspects mix with
modern world. With regards to the richness of detail, Sujan (1985) stated that the trend of
nostalgia is becoming more personal; therefore, subsequent patterns can be expected to be highly
personalized. With the help of AI and data processing, brands will be able to construct highly
targeted and designed based on its complexity and previous experience in consuming retro
products and services based on the consumer’s past. It could result in the diversification of
signification of the nostalgic trends which means that the consumers could be nostalgic about the
individual frames of time rather than the cultural epochs.
42
REFERENCE
Baker, S. M., & Kennedy, P. F. (1994). Death by nostalgia: A diagnosis of context-specific cases.
Advances in Consumer Research, 21, 169-174.
Batcho, K. I. (2013). Nostalgia: The bittersweet history of a psychological concept. History of
Psychology, 16(3), 165-176. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0032427
Belk, R. W. (1990). The role of possessions in constructing and maintaining a sense of past.
Advances in Consumer Research, 17, 669-676.
Davis, F. (1979). Yearning for yesterday: A sociology of nostalgia. Free Press.
Goulding, C. (2002). An exploratory study of age-related vicarious nostalgia and aesthetic
consumption. Advances in Consumer Research, 29, 542-546.
Havlena, W. J., & Holak, S. L. (1991). The good old days: Observations on nostalgia and its role
in consumer behavior. Advances in Consumer Research, 18, 323-329.
Holak, S. L., & Havlena, W. J. (1998). Feelings, fantasies, and memories: An examination of the
emotional components of nostalgia. Journal of Business Research, 42(3), 217-226.
https://doi.org/10.1016/S0148-2963(97)00119-7
Holbrook, M. B. (1993). Nostalgia and consumption preferences: Some emerging patterns of
consumer tastes. Journal of Consumer Research, 20(2), 245-256.
https://doi.org/10.1086/209346
Holbrook, M. B., & Schindler, R. M. (1991). Echoes of the dear departed past: Some work in
progress on nostalgia. Advances in Consumer Research, 18, 330-333.
43
Holbrook, M. B., & Schindler, R. M. (2003). Nostalgic bonding: Exploring the role of nostalgia
in the consumption experience. Journal of Consumer Behaviour, 3(2), 107-127.
https://doi.org/10.1002/cb.127
Juhl, J., Routledge, C., Arndt, J., Sedikides, C., & Wildschut, T. (2010). Fighting the future with
the past: Nostalgia buffers existential threat. Journal of Research in Personality, 44(3),
309-314. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jrp.2010.02.006
Kessous, A., & Roux, E. (2010). Nostalgia and consumption: Towards an integrative approach.
Journal of Consumer Marketing, 27(2), 164-176.
https://doi.org/10.1108/07363761011027289
Kessous, A., & Roux, E. (2013). Nostalgia, autobiographical memories, and brand attachment.
Marketing Theory, 13(4), 453-468. https://doi.org/10.1177/1470593113496437
Loveland, K. E., Smeesters, D., & Mandel, N. (2010). Still preoccupied with 1995: The need to
belong and preference for nostalgic products. Journal of Consumer Research, 37(3), 393-
408. https://doi.org/10.1086/653043
Muehling, D. D., & Pascal, V. J. (2011). An empirical investigation of the differential effects of
personal, historical, and non-nostalgic advertising on consumer responses. Journal of
Advertising, 40(2), 107-122. https://doi.org/10.2753/JOA0091-3367400208
Muehling, D. D., Sprott, D. E., & Sultan, A. J. (2014). Exploring the boundaries of nostalgic
advertising effects: A consideration of childhood brand exposure and attachment on
consumers’ responses to nostalgia-themed advertisements. Journal of Advertising, 43(1),
73-84. https://doi.org/10.1080/00913367.2013.815110
44
Pascal, V. J., Sprott, D. E., & Muehling, D. D. (2002). The influence of evoked nostalgia on
consumer responses: An exploratory study. Journal of Current Issues & Research in
Advertising, 24(1), 39-47. https://doi.org/10.1080/10641734.2002.10505129
Routledge, C., Arndt, J., Wildschut, T., Sedikides, C., Hart, C. M., Juhl, J., & Schlotz, W. (2011).
The past makes the present meaningful: Nostalgia as an existential resource. Journal of
Personality and Social Psychology, 101(3), 638-652. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0024292
Sedikides, C., Wildschut, T., Arndt, J., & Routledge, C. (2008). Nostalgia: Past, present, and
future. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 17(5), 304-307.
https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8721.2008.00595.x
Sedikides, C., Wildschut, T., Gaertner, L., Routledge, C., & Arndt, J. (2009). Nostalgia as enabler
of self-continuity. Self and Identity, 8(2-3), 225-246.
https://doi.org/10.1080/15298860802506824
Sierra, J. J., & McQuitty, S. (2007). Attitudes and emotions as determinants of nostalgia
purchases: An application of social identity theory. Journal of Marketing Theory and
Practice, 15(2), 99-112. https://doi.org/10.2753/MTP1069-6679150201
Stern, B. B. (1992). Historical and personal nostalgia in advertising text: The fin de siècle effect.
Journal of Advertising, 21(4), 11-22. https://doi.org/10.1080/00913367.1992.10673382
Stern, B. B. (1992). Nostalgia in advertising text: Romancing the past. Advances in Consumer
Research, 19, 388-389.
Sujan, M. (1985). Consumer knowledge: Effects on evaluation strategies mediating consumer
judgments. Journal of Consumer Research, 12(1), 31-46. https://doi.org/10.1086/209033
45
Turner, J. H. (2001). Face to face: Toward a sociological theory of interpersonal behavior.
Stanford University Press.
van Tilburg, W. A. P., Sedikides, C., & Wildschut, T. (2015). The mnemonic muse: Nostalgia
fosters creativity through openness to experience. Journal of Experimental Social
Psychology, 59, 1-7. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jesp.2015.02.002
Wildschut, T., Bruder, M., Robertson, S., van Tilburg, W. A. P., & Sedikides, C. (2014).
Collective nostalgia: A group-level emotion that confers unique benefits on the group.
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 107(5), 844-863.
https://doi.org/10.1037/a0037760
Wildschut, T., Sedikides, C., Arndt, J., & Routledge, C. (2006). Nostalgia: Content, triggers,
functions. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 91(5), 975-993.
https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.91.5.975
Youn, S., & Jin, S. V. (2017). “Nostalgia ain’t what it used to be”: New media and nostalgia
advertising. Journal of Marketing Communications, 23(4), 367-384.
https://doi.org/10.1080/13527266.2015.1018146
Zhou, X., Sedikides, C., Wildschut, T., & Gao, D. G. (2008). Counteracting loneliness: On the
restorative function of nostalgia. Psychological Science, 19(10), 1023-1029.
https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.2008.02194.x
Students also viewed