JHR 425 -TEMPORARY WORKER PROGRAMS; ECONOMIC BENEFITS AND ETHICAL CONCERNS

P a g e | 1

TEMPORARY WORKER PROGRAMS: ECONOMIC BENEFITS AND ETHICAL

CONCERNS

1. INTRODUCTION TO TEMPORARY WORKER PROGRAMS

Global Temporary Worker Program, an especially important component of workers in the

present-day world, provide for the relocation from one state to another of the individuals

interested, for a limited term. These programs have been receiving more attention in the recent

past since the benefit accrued to the host and home countries are numerous in terms of economic

returns. Here we will glimpse at these advantages and accompanying ethical issues in this course

as we dissect the complexity of temporary worker program’s formation and roles.

From an economic perspective, temporary worker programs can be seen as fitting into the

solution to problems of shortage of skilled workforce that many industrialized countries face. In

this way, by recruiting workers from areas where there is surplus human capital, these nations are

able to meet acute human capital shortages that exist; and all this boosts the productivity of the

economy and accelerates economic growth. Also, they bring in attitudes, skills, techniques, and

solutions that are new and different from those possessed by the national work force, thus

enhancing the creativity and global workout of the host countries.

Economically, these programs are also financially valuable on the global market. These workers

often send back home a significant chunk of the money they earn and they can cause a positive

circulation of cash both in the host and the origin countries. This is well illustrated in countries

with increased number of immigrants, affecting incoming remittances that play a significant role

in national income and eradicating poverty and encouraging sustainability.

P a g e | 2

Temporary worker programs also have lots of advantages to the home countries as mentioned

below. These programs assist their citizens to find jobs in foreign nations, hence assist in

eradicating poverty within the society empower individuals and families. This in itself can

attribute to social stability, which lower the chances of labor and social upheaval.

However, such programs also have several ethic issues that deserve consideration. Others

support the mandate saying that these temporary worker programs take advantage of a foreign

worker by denying him necessary safe working condition and legal protection. Just moving to a

new country is grueling and stressful, which might lead to stress-related health problems among

the members of a Latino household.

Another issue of concern relates to the effects on the labor market of the host country. As much

as temporary worker programs might be useful to meet the demand for specialized agents in the

employer’s country, it can also bring negative wages effects by worsening the income disparity

among native workers. Therefore, there is a need for policymakers to also consider benefits of

these programs, without compromising on the rights of all the workers employed.

Moreover, Temporary worker programs can sometimes foster dependency and subsequently it is

not possible for individuals under that program to integrate into the host community in terms of

employment and other social aspects. This could in the long run result to compartmentalization,

difficulty in solving problems and social strife.

It is necessary to state that such programs have definite opportunities to produce rather

significant economic effects. At the same time, it is possible to suppose that there are certain

risks and disadvantages connected with temporary worker programs that need to be considered at

any cost. Taking into consideration the principles of the proper treatment of people and cultural

P a g e | 3

diversity, within the framework of temporary worker programs, the welfare of all participating

countries and their citizens, policymakers have managerial possibilities to contribute to the

development of international cooperation.

- History and evolution of temporary migration programs

The existence and development of temporary migration programs have had a dynamic course

which mainly depended on socio-political and economic factors. As societies developed, they

grew more complex and intertwined thus creating the need for an industrial relation system

where employment change and flexibility was easily done thus the development of temporary

worker programs in the world. These programs which can be dated back to the post war

employment of foreign labor in order to reconstruct most affected economies due to the war

called for recruiting of workforce in areas like construction, agriculture and manufacturing

industries among others.

These programs have evolved with time from short term migration measures to more intricate

structures for creating systems for global migration of employees. Temporary worker programs

have therefore been introduced with a view to meeting dynamic supply and demand of labor, to

fill some skills gaps and to improve overall competitiveness of the economy. Due to

globalization of economic systems, temporary migration systems have been subject to change to

suit international business entities, international trade relations, and portable human capital

markets.

Temporary migration policies have also changed dramatically regarding political conditions and

other factors in the world. Terrorism after September 11, 2001 and increasing security threats

have led governments around the globe to reconsider and reshape temporary worker programs

P a g e | 4

for increased border security. This has led to the establishment of the harsh standards on visa,

policed integrity and the decreasing size of liberalization of temporary migration.

The availability of enhanced technologies of communication and transport has made it easier to

have other forms of remote work and this has made the difference between temporary migration

and virtual work very thin. This change has encouraged a rethink by nations on the concept of

Temporary Migration programs with a focus of the programs becoming geared towards extreme

flexibility to suit the dynamism of work.

There has also been a right mix of economic gains and ethical issues with coming up with the

concept of a temporary worker programs. Of course, these programs have offered numerous

economic advantages to host countries, including increased productivity, more investments, and

access to talents worldwide. However, fearing the exploitation of temporary workers, the cutoff

of their access to social services, and strains in the labor markets, people have many questions to

temporary workers.

Even as the world advances further, temporary migration program can only be expected to

transform or make new alterations due to new challenges and opportunities in the future. It is

therefore possible for the policymaker to determine the economic gains and rightly decide how

better to align the ethical issues that affect temporary workers for the improvement of host

countries as well as the workers themselves, for the enhancement of the labor market all over the

world.

- Key global examples and variations

Temporary worker programs, which allow organizations to employ workers of a particular

country on a short-term basis have therefore been developed to suit the dynamic economic

P a g e | 5

environment. These programs are very important to supplement shortages in labor markets, to

increase economic competitiveness, as well as promoting international exchange between people.

These programs differ around the world, where every country has adopted different paradigms

for their context of labor market and socio-political setting.

North America’s temporary worker programs have evolved with the country-specific program for

the United States and Canada. In the USA, there are two types of work visas; H-2A that permits

temporary agricultural workers, and H-2B for non-agricultural employees. On the other hand,

Canada’s Temporary Foreign Worker Program and International Mobility Program import

qualified people worldwide for employment scarcity. The two countries have equally enjoyed the

economic returns of such programs because they help organizations to look for human capital

beyond their borders, source for talents, avoid shortage of skills in the job market and boost the

economy.

In European Union, regulation of temporary worker programs has been influenced by the

Schengen area, freedom of movement. For this reason, the new mechanism called the European

Blue Card was introduced to facilitate the hiring of international highly specialized personnel.

Germany, France and United Kingdom have aligned their temporary worker policies such that

they target specific areas to boost on skills and knowledge. However, these programs have also

come under controversy and negative reception from the public mainly due to issues such as

exploitation, lower wages, and competing with local employment.

For temporary worker programs elsewhere in Asia, the case of the Japan and South Korea is a

case in point since they embarked on labor migration policies due to increasing demographic

friendly aging population and shortage of labor. As a matter of fact, the Technical Intern Training

Program in Japan was originally designed to provide skills to foreign workers involved in that

P a g e | 6

program. But it has been criticized for labor exploitation and abuse most of the time. In a similar

manner, South Korea’s employment permit system was initially designed to provide low waged

labor for low skilled workers from countries such as China, Vietnam, and the Philippines and has

been accused of poor working conditions, and language barriers.

The examples above show that, although there are many economic advantages to temporary

worker programs, those programs should be carefully worked out and controlled in order to

become fairer for each participant. Therefore, temporary worker programs in countries will

require to change in line with the flows of the global economy though understanding the

multifaceted ethical issues associated with the programs as the world economy unfolds. The

members of the international community should adopt an open discussion and an integrated

approach to temporary workers programs to improve them for everybody.

- Legal frameworks governing temporary workers

Temporary worker programs, an essential component of the transient population, have attracted

extensive attention within the spheres of economics and labor relations. These programs give

organizations a chance to staff their organizations with employees for short periods thus helping

in the flexibility of labor market. However, they are not without issues, which we experience

today where the legal status of temporary workers is still volatile to determining behavior that

holds the balance and fairness. This introduction will set out to examine the advanced economic

rationale for such schemes as well as pointing out significant issues likely to arise in their

operation.

Thus, temporary workers in the United States are mainly governed by the Fair Labor Standards

Act (FLSA) that deals with issues of wage and hours. This act guarantees reasonable wage for

P a g e | 7

wages earned for temporary employees alongside safeguarding them against being paid

inadequately or not at all. Also, the Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act

(AWPA) provides extra protection concerning the agriculture industry which guarantee to

workers adequate working conditions. Such legal protections, among others, provide some

Regulation 30 oversights of the stake-out and flexibility that temporary workers vie with

employers.

Temporary work agencies in all European countries operate in accordance with the provisions of

the Temporary Agency Work Directive which aims at equal integration of the temporary agency

workers and equalization of employment conditions within the European Union. This directive –

which became operational in 2008 – acknowledges the increasing importance of TAW to today’s

economies yet at the same time affords temporary workers the same rights as permanent staff as

far as remuneration is concerned, staff privileges and training.

Notable legal instruments include the national legislation and international conventions and

recommendations Standards for temporary work have been provided under the International

Labor Organization ILO, Convention No. 94 dealing the minimum standard of social security.

These provisions guarantee to temporary workers healthcare, insurance of unemployment and

pension rights irrespective of the employment status of the worker.

Looking at how the economics and ethics interconnect in the sphere of temporary work raises

conditions pertinent to any program. These necessary conditions of any program also present

challenges, which we will analyze to get an answer to how these programs may decrease

unemployment, increase productivity, advance innovation and work for creating workplaces safe,

paying adequate wages, and protecting workers. By so doing we hope to achieve a perspective

with a view to elucidating some of the legal dimension of temporary work not as a mere set of

P a g e | 8

legal formalities but as structural prerequisites for effecting a just and efficient labor market for

the improvement of both the employers and the employed.

- Role of international organizations in shaping policies

Temporary Worker Programs have emerged as an issue of great interest for research in the last

few years, given the dual face of profit-making and ethically dubious practices. Since the world

economy is integrating at a growing pace, international premises are unavoidable in aural

legislation of temporary worker policy. Such organizations include the International Labor

Organization (ILO), the world Bank and the organization for economic cooperation and

Development (OECD) for the formulation of guidelines and framework to these programs since

they come with different socio-economic structures of different countries.

In this regard, the ILO has a crucial function to play with regard to decent work and the defense

of the Fundamental Principles and Rights at work in the formation of the policies concerning

temporary worker programs. This organization strives to provide the framework of support to

safeguard migrants especially personally employed people and guarantee they are protected and

treated with the respect of their dignity and fairly treated in a workplace (ILO, 2020). Also, with

the vision of ending extreme poverty and boosting shared prosperity, the World Bank also links

temporary worker programs as key components in its suggested development plans while calling

for inclusive growth, employment opportunities, and skill building (World Bank, 2018).

Likewise, the OECD’s focus on international migration and development seeks to promote the

international discussion of the management of migrant workers and to offer recommendations

and tools for migration governance (OECD, 2021).

P a g e | 9

Some of these policies concerning the temporary worker programs are well exhibited in the

International Migration and Mobility Pact, signed during the UN Climate Change Conference

(COP24) in 2018. This framework takes cognizance of coordinated international action to

manage the issues and opportunities relating to temporary worker programs; including

reasonable liberalization of migration for work, the legal and safe mobility of workers across

borders and protection of vulnerable migrants.

The economic benefits and ethical concerns of temporary worker programs, therefore, requires a

clear understanding of the work of international organizations as it addresses the topic in the

middle of the extensive network of interrelated programs. By dispassionately analyzing the

economic advantages, ranging from productivity enhancement, ability to meet the demands of

skills gaps, and facilitating innovation, as well as potential ethical issues like violation of human

rights, exploitation and social marginalization of workers under temporary worker programs.

This knowledge can be further enriched by reviewing the policies and recommendations

rendered by the ILO, World Bank, and the OECD focusing on the experience of developing and

implementing these programs leading to the first principles of effectiveness to create equitable,

inclusive and sustainable impact for the host and the home country.

Therefore, the given work demonstrates the activity of international organizations with regards to

temporary worker programs as an example of the organizations’ efforts to facilitate international

cooperation and address complex and diverse issues and trends within the framework of

international migration. Thanks to the work of these organizations, much has been done to

establish an international understanding of the fact that on the one hand, programs to place

temporary workers are potentially economically advantageous to certain countries, while on the

other hand, many of the negative consequences that have arisen and continue to appear around

P a g e | 10

these programs are due to insufficient attention paid to the interests of both the host countries and

the countries of origin of these workers. Meanwhile, the ongoing discourses about the nature and

effects of international migration still underscore the relevancy of international organizations in

setting up of the policies and policy directions that surround temporary worker programs; and as

such, these organizations are virtually the only important actors that can properly champion the

economic gains while fairly and adequately comprehensively addressing the ethical dilemmas

bounced off by such programs.

- Political debates surrounding temporary worker programs

Temporary worker programs also called guest worker programs have been a contentious policy

agenda in the realms of economic systems, cultures, and politics across the globe. They are

designed to provide labor in certain sectors or fields and shortage of domestic workers with the

result of the seasonal movement of foreign employees to the host countries. On the one hand,

champions of such programs claim that they bring a number of economic advantages to their

participants, such as the access to a diverse and a compliant workforce and economic growth On

the other hand, the critics have voiced their concern with such matters as workers’ exploitation

and social tensions arising the temporary worker programs. Consequently, the political disputes

concerning temporary worker programs are characterized by the promising economic effects and

the human rights issues that the programs might bring in terms of concern for the participants. In

the context of the temporary worker programs, economic advantages and ethical issues in

temporary worker programs course however stakeholders will differentiate on the different areas

that make up the politics of the temporary worker programs. By incorporating current

information and knowledge needed to define their thoughts and speculations on the utility and

success of temporary workers program so that they can collectively contribute to further onsight

P a g e | 11

about the importance of these kinds of programs in the global economy and society. The

principles of economics means that for the duration of the course the learners will be able to

learn the economic advantages of such programs thus the effect on labor market as well as

economic growth/technology and also the ethical issues such as workers’ rights and social justice

that may be associated with such programs. By exploring both the positive economic aspects and

the negative ethical perspective of temporary worker programs the course allows the students to

look at the material with open mind and gain comprehensive insight of the argument underlying

the contemporary temporary worker programs.

2. ECONOMIC BENEFITS OF TEMPORARY WORKER PROGRAMS

The nature, characteristics and benefits of temporary worker programs have impressed many

countries of the world that have adopted them as important solutions to their labor market

conditions. The following are the economic advantages associated with these programs; A

nation’s GDP is improved, technological improvement is boosted, unemployment level is

lowered, and general productivity is increased. Through provision of working permits for

detailed periods to people from other countries, these programs cover up the gaps in

competencies in given sectors which leads to improvement of the competition in the job market

hence improving on the innovation. Further, the arrival of foreign workers introduce new ways

of thinking; new concepts which are important in the development of a country’s economy.

The injection of additional capital thought temporary workers remittance is another observable

fiscal advantage of these programs. Since these workers contribute income to their families, the

development in this transfer industry not only strengthens the national currency but also

encourages the development of industries like, banks, remittance companies, and money transfer

P a g e | 12

services. This further boost economic activities and makes the market to be more active for

products and services to be sold.

Besides, from the point of view of providing highly skilled labor force, temporary worker

programs can develop certain sectors that can otherwise exist in shortage of qualified personnel.

This is quite apparent in companies that need professionals with unique skills or employees

during certain months like farming, hotels, construction. These industries will thus be able to tap

a dependable workforce which would help them sustain their operations hence enhance their

contribution towards the economy of the country and their place in the national economy.

One of the concerns that need to be grouped around these programs is that of possible economic

inefficiency and exploitation of workers in particular. Such concerns need to be addressed

through regulation, enforcement, which guarantees that employees are paid fairly and treated

fairly. Thus, the outcome of such programs and employment of different categories of employees

can be less negative if governments pay close attention to the functions of such programs and or

policies ad strictly adhere to labor laws.

Economic utilities of temporary worker programs are indeed diverse and extensive. The nature of

national labor requirement is met through these programs leading to economic growth and is

therefore beneficial to the national economy. Despite the relative novelty of such programs, and

despite the risks and ethical concerns involved, the benefits of the use of temporary workers have

to be weighed against the drawbacks, and positive steps have to be taken to accommodate the

needs of such employees. Finally, based on a strategic and responsible outlook paid internship

programs can offer substantial and positive impact to any given country economy.

P a g e | 13

- Contributions to national economies: GDP and tax revenue

Temporary worker programs are economically advantageous since they bring a productivity

factor and additional revenue in terms of taxes and contribution to the GDP in the various

countries that these programs are affected. Such programs generate employment for temporary

workers who are most often qualified and experienced; thereby enhancing the effectiveness of

the labor market and adding to the GDP of the country that hosts the program. Producers end up

producing more enabling the government to collect increased taxation since everyone in

productive business activities wishes to pay taxes. Third, temporary worker programs increase

the flow of foreign direct investment capital into local economies and start a chain reaction of

economic growth that in turn affects the lives of common citizens. This is particularly true where

countries are either experiencing a change in demographic profile or suffering from lack of

skilled workers that creates a challenge for companies looking to staff their projects, in such a

scenario temporary worker programs play a very important role of providing reliable and skilled

workers that fill a void in the labor market for the growth of specific industries. In addition, a

temporary pool of workers presents with new skills and specialized knowledge they can apply in

innovation and diversifying a country’s economy and hence elevate such economies to higher

levels of competitiveness. In addition, open temporary worker programs which are used by other

countries have been proven to enhance technology development through knowledge transfer

among the temporary workers and the host country personnel; this results in productivity and

growth. Therefore, these temporary worker programs have not just positive implication to the

host country’s economy but also to the home country economy of the worker since their

remittances can catalyze the development of the home economies. Consequently, the programs of

temporary workers are beneficial on the economic level in regard not only to the opportunities

P a g e | 14

they open for the employment but also in terms of contribution to various economic values and

indicators including GDP, taxes, and economic development.

- Filling labor shortages in key sectors

Temporary worker programs have been shown to bear many economic returns for countries that

adopt it primarily in addressing human labor deficit in certain industries. More recently, there has

been an effort to appreciate the use of temporary worker programs as a way of supplementing

labor demands in industries such as farming, construction, and hospitality most of which have

long-standing and seasonal difficulties employing people permanently. Such programs – people

are employed under which for a specified period of time with the purpose of their work being to

fill a social need and to contribute to the growth of the economy of a country – can be useful in

helping industries in need of staff by filling its vacancies with foreign workers. By improving

business efficiency Temporary worker programs allow for improved work productivity and

minimized costs on labor, thereby increasing chances of profitability and in return job

opportunities in different sectors. This in its own turn may be beneficial to the given location

with the facts of local companies growing and developing, as well as investing in infrastructures

and local development. However, the success of these programs may lead to demand stimulation

of local goods and services, which will also push development.

Additionally, the FTA it can attract hundreds of thousands or millions of temporary workers with

substantial amounts of taxes and consumer spending. The migrant workers, like any other

workers, remit taxes and make contributions to the social security organizations of their countries

of work hence can relieve the burden on the social services. Thus, such workers can also help

grow the home country –and other parts of the world– economies every time they wire money to

kin back home, contributing to both regional and international development especially in

P a g e | 15

emergent markets. Moreover, temporary worker programs can contribute to solving the problems

of aging population and shortage of domestic workers in the healthcare and care services. In this

regard, temporary workers offer a way of catering for the growing need for qualified human

resource in these sectors to enhance their growth and future sustainability.

However, the IAA is obliged to admit possible ethical drawbacks of using temporary worker

programs, namely, exploitation and employer’s lack of concern for workers. While these

programs have substantial economic potentials, the substance of these programs and how they

are implemented and controlled must fuse and respect equity or fairness to working people.

Employing host governments, companies, and recruitment agencies should take measures to

ensure and eliminate such problems, including the proper payment for workers, access to

competent legal counsel and also protection from physical injuries. In this vein, this paper posits

that if temporary worker programs are well managed, they stand to significantly enhance the

developmental status of the countries of temporary workers while respecting the rights and worth

of every worker in the host countries.

- Employer perspectives on temporary workers

Temporary worker programs have a lot of economic advantages to both the employer as well as

the economy in general. In this perspective, these programs are cheap and versatile means that an

employer can turn to in order to meet his/her requirements. Using temporary employees has extra

advantages because businesses can easily adjust the number of employees as needed without

worrying about contracts or providing benefits – this can save a lot of money. In addition,

temporary workers can be hired to do specific activities and this is as an advantage because firms

get to enjoy the skills possessed by these employees yet they do not have to spend much time and

money training such individuals.

P a g e | 16

Moreover, that through temporary worker programs it is possible to have a more various and

creative staff pool. Managers might also use employees with diverse backgrounds and level of

skilled to solve problems in new ways, with such approaches as bringing in more creativity and

productivity to the job. Thirdly, through outsourcing labor, the employers minimize the chances

of developing monopolies, which might bring stagnation and slow development.

The economic gains and functional space of temporary worker programs can be extended to the

economy too. This kind of programs make the business environment more competitive hence

increasing chances of investments hence boosting the economy. Besides, through the hiring of

temporary workers, other expertise or new approaches to designing new products and services

can also be introduced thus contributing to economy growth.

When it comes to the issues with ethical ramifications of temporary worker programs that has

been discussed above, it is crucial to understand that not all the programs are alike. Although

some agencies may take advantage of their subordinates or deny the workforce satisfactory

conditions to work under, there are many agencies with temporary workers where efforts are

made to respect their employees’ dignity as well as support them through training. These

concerns may be addressed by employers to a particular extent by using the services of a

reputable agency and making certain that the agency does not engage in unfair labor practices.

Finally, continuous engagement of all the stakeholders, including policymakers, businesses, and

CSOs, in the debate and in addressing the issue of temporary worker programs and sharing of

experience and lessons learned in the implementation of such programs.

Therefore, active temporary worker programs are still valuable for the employers as well as other

stakeholders and the overall economy since they are cheap, flexible and innovative solution in

the present and future respective workforce. The diversity and dynamism of the labor force can

P a g e | 17

thus be championed through these programs and translate into improved productivity, increased

innovation, and economic growth. Moreover, good temporary worker programs as long as they

can meet the employer’s need as well as provide benefits to temporary workers, that social

ethical issue can be solved via cooperation and following fair treatment employment.

- Impact on job creation and skills transfer

Governance is therefore an inevitable element in temporary worker programs, which generally

has considerable economic value, especially in generating new entrance employment and

developing new sets of skills. What these programs provide to business is the opportunity for

organizations to meet short and/or seasonal demands within the internationalized labor market,

create more jobs for native and foreign employees and workers while avoiding complicated long-

term contracts with employees. Outsourcing guarantees that every firm focuses its limited

resources to critical tasks and makes it possible for a firm to offer employment to a set of

workers for a temporary period without sacrificing the productive capability of the company.

Moreover, the introduction of temporary workers increases overall consumption of the products

and services which in turn promotes industrial, social and economic growths within their regions.

This element is just as important, and the temporary worker programs serve a role of arranging

the transfer of the skills. Migrants are valuable assets in their host countries, since they offer

variety of skills, knowledge and experiences that are beneficial for the economic development of

the hosting countries. They are much willing to work in positions that require low skills, which

are very essential to them, as these offer training to the qualified and experienced local talents,

and hence more likely to acquire enhanced skills and prospects for career progression. This

exchange fosters a vibrant labor market since skills and expertise are traded, therefore creating

permanent improvement in staff proficiency. In the same respect, by employing temporary

P a g e | 18

workers, a country’s native workers gain exposure to global practice and the general pool of

workers becomes more competitive.

Intermediate mobility can be seen to increase innovation; because different people with different

level of skills may come into contact with one another, work on the same team, and therefore

find ways to combine their talents to effectively solve problems. Thus, temporary worker

programs turn into the decisive ways of constructing a powerful and flexible staff that will be

able to meet the requirements of the changing economic environment.

Nonetheless, it is crucial to analyze the ethical problematic with reference to temporary worker

programs which are the orchestrated meet rates; income disparities; working conditions; and

social inclusion. For temporary work, the governments and businesses should offer policies and

measures that will protect temporary’s health, wellbeing, and future, plus the temporary workers

should have similar access to the permanent worker’s opportunities to earn a decent wage and

enhance their employment competence. It is important to balance these economic gains with

consideration of social justice and fair treatment at the time when temporary worker programs

should be maximized in its contributions to the generation of economic growth and the

enhancement of the effects of labor market.

- Long-term sustainability of temporary migration policies

The temporary workers program which aims at importing a specialized workforce into the

country to work for a limited time has been established to boost the economy. Such programs

have been linked to enhanced economic growth, development, and increased efficiency mainly

because it offers an important source of shortages of talent within a given country. The long-term

P a g e | 19

sustainability of temporary migration policies is intrinsically linked to the economic benefits of

temporary worker programs, as both are crucial components of the temporary worker programs.

The reasons for claiming that these programs create the economic benefits are explained by the

impact of temporary work force in the technological, medical or agriculture fields. Because of

the above aspects they are able to bring into individual companies, different skills as well as

angles that bring about innovations for better quality products, efficiency, and competitiveness of

the companies. Foreign talent can also bring in demand for other products, generate employment

opportunities as well as the sources of income for other workers within the country. Also,

temporary worker programs are pro for wealth redistribution since the involved temporary

worker programs boost the economy of both the host and the home country. This double

advantage is guaranteed to make the temporary migration policies less economically

cumbersome in the future.

The gains that come with these temporary worker programs should be achieved without

jeopardizing the rights of these temporary workers. This means it is important to examine ethical

issues in the context. It is therefore only reasonable to insist that temporary workers are given

reasonable working terms and conditions, social security, and protection against unfair treatment

in the Host country to realize that the country benefits fully from the temporary workers’

presence without harming the latter. If these concerns fail to be taken then it could create short

term economic gains for temporary migration policies at the long run it would erode the

sustainability of the policies.

The governments also need to put up right policies to ensure that the business organizations and

the importing countries get the right number of skilled professionals while at the same time

protecting the temporary workers. This could be done through some legislation and

P a g e | 20

administrative means which enable the temporary migration of workers, protect their rights, and

stop the exploitation of these people. These measures when properly applied to the legal

temporary migration policies, promote economic growth as well as innovation, thus making their

policies sustainable in the long-run.

There are great benefits from temporary worker programs with reference to strengthening

efficient economic performance and competitive advantage. However, for these programs to

deliver long-term sustainability and value-added benefits to the host as well as home countries, it

is important that the flow of policies that shape these programs accord respect to rights, welfare

and well-being of temporary workers. As the temporary worker programs: Recognizing, as does

the Hurd center Environmental and Economic Benefits and Ethical Concerns course, that

economic benefits and ethical considerations are inextricably linked – a delicate dance between

the two is required for the successful policy of temporary migration and its practical application.

3. ETHICAL CONCERNS AND HUMAN RIGHTS

The temporary worker programs which are intended to support economic migration are one of

the crucial components of the global labor market. These programs could therefore be able to

develop considerable economic advantages since they solve the problems of labor shortages in

some countries, as well as offer growth and development in other countries. However, the issue

of ethical factors and human rights plays a crucial role while considering the issue of temporary

worker programs and its giving and operation. There are potential dangers of exploitation, abuse,

and human rights violations which has to be considered.

Temporary employees have significantly less employment entitlements and legal statuses

compared to residents, and as such, they are likely to encounter unfavorable workplace

P a g e | 21

conditions, low wages and substandard accommodations. Any of them can further entrench

poverty and inequality by perpetuating a cycle in the women’s home countries. Also, these

programs can lead to the overall deterioration of labor conditions in the host countries, as

employers look to hire workers from TPS countries because they are in a less powerful position

legally.

Interests have also been raised over the possibility of human trafficking and forced labor. There

are some bad people who will take advantage of the vulnerable, promise them a better life and

then force them into slavery or worst, abusing them when hired. These risks are compounded by

the fact that many temporary worker programs are lacking sufficient supervision and sanctioning

authorities.

In addition, through put more stress to family and community structures as the participants are

not allowed to take their families with them or go home to be with them for some time. This may

lead to long-term detrimental impact of civil-social relations, quality life of the workers and their

families, and social structure back home.

To avoid these risks, it is essential that all temporary worker programs are fully protection of

human rights, have effective requisite enforcement mechanisms and have the best interest of all

stakeholders at heart. This might include increasing the quality of the temporary workforce,

which concerns the recruitment process as well as social protection. The fact is, that temporary

worker programs are managed by governments, companies and civil society organizations and

thus it is the responsibility for all these entities to ensure that all parties get an opportunity to

benefit while at the same time safeguarding the basic rights of workers. In this way, it will be

possible to optimize economic effects arising from temporary worker programs without

P a g e | 22

engendering undesirable consequences which would depart from a more just world order

regarding the labor market.

- Exploitation and abuse of temporary workers

Contractual employees are prevalent in today’s different industries in many countries adding to

the global employee population. It reveals that temporary worker programs providing sectoral or

global benefits of flexibility or adaptabilities for changing labor demands, ethical issues and

possible Human rights abuses. One problem that has been pointed out is the mistreatment and

abuse of the temporary workers, mainly since they do not enjoy pretty much of the legal rights,

they fail to get appropriate wages, and they undergo rather poor working conditions. These

temporary workers can easily work under poor conditions as they would have been attracted by

job vacancies without knowing that they will be working under very poor conditions, most likely

to be paid very little wages than they expect, they will be provided with insufficient social

benefits, and they are most likely to work for extended shift hours. This issue falls under the

topic of Ethical Concerns and Human Rights since it underscores two of the major problems

affecting the workers: wage discrimination and rights to reasonable wages and just working

conditions.

Temporary workers can be easily exploited, and in most cases, they are at the receiving end from

employers, recruiters, and in some instances the government departments that are supposed to

regulate the market. This is not to mention the forced overtime or outright denial of wages,

threats of physical and sexual violence. Temporary workplace workers are also deprived of even

humane living standards including living in congested rooms, denial of adequate and sufficient

food and medical care. In addition, temporary workers hardly interact with native individuals,

and in cases they do, language differences and cultural differences make them easily segregated

P a g e | 23

from the rest of the society. This makes them more vulnerable to abuse; they do not know when

and how to fight for their rights or report abuse lest they be punished.

Besides the direct repercussions, which temporary workers face, exploitation and abuse are also

capable of having consequences at the societal level. This is because, temporary workers, unlike

other more permanently employed individuals, do not have adequate legal protection or adequate

recompense for their work, hence driving the race to the bottom of wages and other labor

conditions offered by employers. It can lead to a vicious cycle of degraded quality of jobs,

diminished ability to negotiate better terms by employees, and lowered standard of living,

however, it become necessary to understand fairly treatment and rights of temporary workers

which is important on the basis of human rights principles and sustainable development.

Therefore, the government combined with employers and civil society organizations need to

work to ensure that the rights of the temporary workers are protected as those of other workers.

One way of so doing is by developing proper labor policies and laws that will ensure that

temporary workers are paid their deserved wages, given proper working conditions, as well as

being accorded their rightful social benefits. Further, government needs to regulate the

recruitment agencies and implement accessible accountable procedure for the temporary worker

programs to avoiding the exploitations and adherence to international labor laws. In addition,

increasing awareness of the problem and discussing it can encourage temporary workers and

create a fairer, more sustainable climate in the global labor market.

Consequently, the mistreatment of temporary workers raises an ethical issue that deserves a

proper treatment when addressing TWPs. Realizing that equal opportunities and rights of

temporary workers are critical factors for advancing sustainable development, we can raise

awareness of the human rights of workers in the global market.

P a g e | 24

- Wage disparities and labor conditions

Wage disparities and labor conditions are pivotal concerns in the realm of Ethical concerns and

human rights, particularly in the context of Temporary worker programs: Primarily, this paper

will focus on the economic gains and speculates on potential ethical implications of the brands

sourcing garments from developing nations owing to competitive prices. Since the use of

temporary worker programs as a means of building a diverse workforce becomes more popular,

it is crucial to respond to the often-observed wage differentials and labor relations that fail to

meet most of the principles of human and labor rights. Just as the name suggests, Temporary

worker programs, involves participants who are mostly from developing countries earning low

wages and other unfavorable working conditions, which has caused a major controversy

regarding the efficiency of Temporary worker programs for facilitating economic development

and benefit while respecting human rights.

The matter of wage discrimination mainly concentrates on whistle- blowing primarily on account

of power relations between the host nations where temporary workers are hired and the home

countries of those workers consequently implying a considerable pay differential. These workers

are exploited by host countries, which pay them very low wages relative to those of other

workers within their host nations, and in most instances these wages are below the minimum

wages set for the host countries’ workforce. This clash not only undermines the basic human

rights of these workers but also the integrity of these programs and the countries of these

programs fail to make good on the commitment they have made for providing fair work for

everyone.

Besides the wage discrimination that entails distorting the ILO conventions, the management

systems of temporary workers do not conform to proper standard labor circumstances that

P a g e | 25

aggravate matters concerning human rights. Such workers are exposed to poor working

conditions, poor working hours, poor shift work and poor workplace environment hence; the

workers develop poor health through stress and strain. While the temporary worker programs

might be economically beneficial to host countries, they disadvantage the workers violating their

human right to fair working conditions thus leading to an unfair and unsustainable working

condition regime.

Solving these problems is possible by the use of various strategies among them being,

governments, international organizations, corporations, and civil society. Employing countries’

policy and receiving countries’ policy makers should collectively formulate good policies and

wage models when recruiting temporary workers so as not to abuse these vulnerable people

through ungoverned discriminating and inhuman waging policies. This can be brought through

adoption of well monitored temporary worker programs whereby companies are made to answer

for their treatment of the workers and usually they are penalized for violation of rights of

workers as well as violation of human rights.

Other international bodies like ILO and UN in coming up with international policies and

measures that need to be adopted when implementing the programs for temporary workers,

equality in wages and treatment of the workers. They can help countries talk to each other, gather

and share information, enforce standards and observe the adherence to respect for human rights

by countries, thus enhancing respect for human rights.

Corporations that engage in temporary worker programs should also have policies that are civil

in regards to treatment of the employees and respect to human rights. Employers should desist

from profiting from hiring the temp employees by paying them reasonable wages which will

allow them to have decent working conditions. In the same regard, they should establish ways

P a g e | 26

through which the workers can give their complaints and grievances a channel then offering

them safe and secure work station.

Non-governmental organizations can be used in rallying people to the causes of wages and

conditions of service of casual workers. They can act for improving the policies and practices

with reference to the temporary worker programs and also can supervise the execution of the

formulated policies regarding the workers’ rights.

Thus, it is pertinent to level the wages and working standards threatened with disenfranchising

temporary worker programs for realizing the apparent economic advantages of such enrolment.

To attain the objectives of protecting the rights of temporary workers and promote decent

working conditions, implemented partnerships between governments, international

organizations, business enterprises and Civil Society.

- Workers' rights and protections under international law

Place of workers’ rights and protection under the international law becomes decisive in the

sphere of the ethical concern and human rights for temporary worker program which shows more

economic advantages potently with the relevant ethical dilemmas. There is a large volume of the

IL recognizing workers’ rights; these conventions include; freedom of association and the right to

bargain collectively, forced labor, and discrimination among others by the international labor

organization (ILO). Further, the United Nation’s Universal Declaration of Human Rights

(UDHR) and International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR)

reaffirms that individual’s basic rights in that to work, to equal and fair treatment, and reasonable

remuneration.

P a g e | 27

Moreover, international human rights law enjoins states to undertake requisite legislative and

administrative requisites for the safeguard of workers and essential liberties. Further, the Migrant

Workers Convention (1990) can be referred to as one of the key tools in this field and plays a

crucial role in offering an overarching guide to the rights and entitlements of migrant workers as

well as their families. Therefore, those states who have incorporated temporary worker programs

have to meet these legal requirements not only as a part of their international commitments but in

order to contribute to the creation of fair global workforce. This accountability requires caution

of all the risks and vulnerabilities that may arise from temporary work agreements which

includes exploitation, restricted social service access, and job insecurity among others.

Furthermore, the economy and ethicality on the temporary worker program requires focus on

particular areas in recruitment, working conditions as well as reasonable treatment by employers

in all aspects. This role applies to the employers and the host countries as they have to ensure

that a proper legality is put in place to uphold the rights of the temporary employees. The policy

implication of extending such workers the same rights as nationals will go along way in

decreasing exploitation, improving labor and standards as well as social cohesion thus mitigating

some of the tension between economics and human rights. Finally, maintaining an optimal

balance between earning revenues and preventing the infringement on the rights of the

employees in the global workplace is staunch for the creation of a better world for working

people. In doing so, states and international organizations must collectively publish efforts that

encourage a culture that values human right and ethical issues to foster an environment that will

lead to temporary worker programs existing as a component of international law though the

intended benevolence.

P a g e | 28

- The ethics of dependency on migrant labor

Controversial issues of ethical concerns and human rights in connection with programs that

envisage the usage of temporary workers as a source of labor have always been an acute subject

in the globalized world. An important question in this domain is the issue of progenitor

dependency on migrant labor which has important economic and social aspects, not to mention

ethical ones. Before proceeding to examine the advantages and disadvantages of the specified

temporary worker programs it is important to consider the possible discrimination and abuse

which may be inherent to the migrant workers. These programs are usually created in order to

solve the skilled workforce deficit or when there is no desire of the population to work in

selected sectors. These initiatives are associated with its positives like productivity increase and

competitiveness while the over-dependence on temporary work raises some very pertinent issues

regarding the employment status, legal status and treatment of temporary workers.

Quite often it results in migrant workers getting locked in cycles of risk due to language, lack of

information, and isolation. Their living conditions are generally poor, wages are low and most

work long hours; they cannot form unions to complain. Such an imbalance of power relations

finally culminates in the process of what the contemporary world is reluctant to label modern day

slavery, it erases the formal consideration and disregard the rights of these workers, and their

input. In addition, the reliance on migrant employees also has various considerations on skill

development of substantive workforces since employers rarely offer staff development programs

that can transform them into valuable assets. Another disadvantage of outsourcing is that it

socially isolates such workers resulting in social hostility and prejudice by the host country

population as they are seen as competition or threats.

P a g e | 29

The management of such concerns calls for an aggressive perception that involves the legal

redreaming, employers’ responsibility, and the improvement of labor protection. These suggest

that there would be a need to set standard policies to guarantee that fair wages, reasonable

working and living hours, and access to basic services of the temporary worker that will not be

mechanically implemented in the workplace. Employers should be made to answer to these

standards and should be made to pay for the consequences of noncompliance. In the same

respect, host countries should invest into the fair incorporation of migrant employees into society

given their usefulness to the system. This paper has sought to argue that the concept of outright

rejection of migrant workers and direct political intervention has uninformed and unwarranted

negative impacts on the European societies and advantage has on the other end of the societal

pole by addressing issues of dependency on temporary workforce, increase acknowledgement of

migrants, therefore decrease conflict within societies.

The ethical issue in relation to dependency on migrant labor can be considered as one of the

crucial factors of the whole temporary worker program’s discussion since it reveals one of the

practical concerns in employing migrant labor, such as an unknown balance between rational

economic solution and the human worth. In this manner, the strengths of the temporary worker

programs can be maximized together with the minimizing the risks that are associated with bad

rights and welfare of the various talents and hardworking people who are added value to the

various societies all over the world.

- Addressing vulnerabilities of temporary workers

When focusing on Ethical Concerns and Human Rights category, the issue of temporary

workers’ welfare is one that should not be ignored. In theory, there are a number of advantages

that temporary worker programs could have on the economies of both host countries and for the

P a g e | 30

worker, but unfortunately, these are not realized in assessing and protecting the rights of these

workers. It is important to examine the causes which lead to such weaknesses and develop proper

means that would enhance the given circumstances for temporary workers.

The first challenge that arises in relation to temporary workers is that such personnel can easily

be exploited and abused. They are easily exploited by their employers/employment agencies

since they depend on the temporary work permits to sustain them in countries of work. By being

paid poor wages, long hours of work and poor living conditions being offered to them. Also

importantly, these workers lack information on their policy rights as well as other necessary

assistance to combat such forms of exploitation. In addition, temporary workers are also likely to

suffer social isolation and exclusion resulting to language barriers, cultural differences, and

limited access to basic needs services that will make their situation worse.

Protecting the vulnerable temporary workers, the benefits associated with the programs that

provision these workers like filling the skills demand and catalyzing the economy growth will be

of full potential. This can be done by adoption of co-ordinate legislations and policies which

protect the rights of temporary workers, promote their equity and grant them equal access to

health care facilities, shelters, and education. However, there is also a need to effectively

communicate and socialize the temporary workers: through the encouragement of intercultural

contacts, language training, perception and understanding campaigns.

More also, the performance of the recruitment agencies and employers should be investigated to

know if they are taking advantage of the temporary worker. This can be scrutinized through

compliance to regulatory measures, utilizing contractual provisions, and conducting compliance

audit to evaluate compliance to labor laws. Furthermore, the special measures for addressing

P a g e | 31

complaints and remedies may also enhance the chances of temporary workers who experienced

violations of their rights to lodge complaints and sue for their rights.

Therefore, it can be concluded that the management of the Temporary Worker Programs is an

essential aspect of safeguarding temporary workers who can also influence the competitive

advantage of organizations in different industries. In this case, the laws should be developed and

implemented to foster equality, integration and provision of necessary services for temp workers

while economic values added to these programs should also be achieved as the justification of

human rights of such migrant workers is enhanced. In essence, it is host countries, employers and

recruitment agencies that need to ensure the best welfare to such workers, not leaving them

behind as they seek a better life and a better future.

4. TEMPORARY WORKER PROGRAMS AND SOCIAL INTEGRATION

Temporary worker programs remain part of the global economy and concern in the present time,

they have brought a number of economic advantages to host countries and countries of origin for

temporary workers. However, a fair number of issues are related to these programs, such as

questions regarding the integration of foreigners and social problems which influence

communities. However, the future of temporary worker programs does not need to be an

unhappy one; integration issues and enhanced experiences for both the host country and the

temporary workers are not impossible given that the governments and organizations consider the

problems presented in this paper and design improvements for the relevant programs.

Employment programs for temporary workers, established as a part of migration for employment

reasons, contribute significantly to the labor demand of developed countries and to the economic

development of source countries. These programs enable foreign workers to find temporary

P a g e | 32

employment in other countries and, in so doing, give employers what they need: a ready, willing

and cheap workforce. However, this migration comes with some social vices such as conflicts

between the country’s citizens and the imported expatriates, language differences and problems

that border on accommodation and schooling. In many instances, temporary workers are

confined to their respective housing and get to have minimal interaction with the residents in the

community. This can lead to retrospect feelings and lack of understanding of the cultural

differences that may in turn have adverse effects on both the employers who are temporary

workers and the host country.

There are nonetheless some disadvantages of maintaining temporary worker programs but these

should not be construed as negating total exclusion of social integration. Measures should be

introduced into the host countries targeted to the construction of the positive social attitudes

toward temporary workers. One of them is to provide language lessons because during their

work, foreign personnel may encounter difficulties in interacting with the population of the

countries they are in. Availability of affordable housings and education can enhance the social

integration as it relieves the influx of temporary workers from resentful feelings of solitariness.

However, another important organizational component that has to be considered while designing

the temporary worker programs is possible labor exploitation. Although many temporary workers

seek employment legally, they are often reluctant to report cases of abuse, because they are non-

English speakers, have undocumented immigration status, and lack knowledge of the host

countries’ labor laws. In order to overcome this, the host countries should be in a position to

provide repressive measures for the violation of the labor laws and should also come up with

rigorous punitive measures against the employers who subject their employees to ruthlessness.

Hence, host countries can do more in ensuring that temporary workers are well integrated

P a g e | 33

through adoption of practices that respect and embrace diversity and fairness to the imported

workforce.

Altogether, numerous problems accompany temporary worker programs in terms of social

integration, but it is reasonable and feasible to develop coherent political actions for the

advantage of the countries of temporary workers’ residence and the workers themselves.

Politicians need to provide language classes, affordable dwelling and schooling for folks, and

protect the rulers of such a significant position in distinct segments of the population as

temporary workers. It is especially crucial in the light of the present trends toward enhancing the

social integration and reducing the potential negative social effects of TW programs, as well as to

turn these programs into more effective in achieving the goals of both sending and host countries

in terms of economic gains.

- Social and cultural impacts on local communities