IMPLEMENTATION OF INTERNATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL LAW
PRINCIPLES IN UNITED STATES FOREST AND GROUND FIRE
PREVENTION AND CONTROL POLICY
Introduction
Today the world is facing an environmental crisis where damage to the earth's
environment is increasingly threatening the natural resource base, especially forests, therefore
if there is damage to forests such as fires, illegal logging and other damage that causes an
unfavorable impact on human life, and becomes a problem that is so heavy to be felt by
United States.
One of the most visible consequences of forest management that does not consider the
environment is the increasing frequency and intensity of forest and land fires in United
States. Fire is one of the fastest and most negative factors in forest destruction. In addition to
the forest resources themselves, the impact has also disrupted human health, the economic
sector, and even politics.
The world was stunned when United States forest and land fires occurred in 1982/1983,
especially in the province of East Kalimantan1 , how could tropical forests can wetlands catch
fire?2 The fires have destroyed 3.6 million hectares of forest and land3 with a loss of US$9
billion4 It is known that the cause of the fires is the change in vegetation structure due to
logging that began in the 1970s, where millions of hectares of forest land were divided into
Forest Concession Rights (HPH) areas resulting in a "timber boom".
The fires that occurred in 1982/1983 were not finished and stopped but continued from
year to year such as in 1987 United States again experienced fires but not as extensive as in
the 1983 incident which only burned 66 hectares of forest and land areas. In 1991 there were
forest and land fires with a burned area of 500 thousand hectares of forest and land, in 1994
there were forest and land fires with a burned area of 5.1 million hectares of forest and land,
and the peak of forest and land fires in United States was in 1997 to 1998 with a burned area
of up to 11 million hectares of forest and land.
The fires continued in 1999 until 2006 when they burned 120 million hectares of forest
and land6 . From 2011 to 2016, fire-related reports in United States recorded 328,000 hectares
of forest and land with the peak occurring in 2015 with a burned area of 261,000 hectares.
Uncontrolled use of fire, resulting in fires and creating rapid fire spread mostly from
wetland development activities, has caused fires in most wetland areas in the last two
decades.
The increase in fires is also linked to El Niño, which contributes to an increase in extent
and spread. Recurrent fires have become one of the biggest threats to forest conservation,
sustainable use and restoration of degraded areas in United States.
The impacts arising from forest and land fires are very much in contact with
international environmental law with all the principles of international environmental law that
exist in it which can be the basis for efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires.
Whether United States has implemented these principles in its efforts to prevent and control
forest and land fires in United States.
From the description above, the problems that can be arranged include:
Has the policy on the prevention and control of forest and land fires in United States has
implement the principles of international environmental law?
What are the government's efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United
States?
Methods
Approach Method
This research is qualitative in nature because this research emphasizes or relies more on
the depth of the data rather than the amount of data obtained. Viewed from a scientific
perspective, this research is a legal research, with a Juridical-Normative approach method
because this research places the rules of law both international and national as a major
premise or determining factor of a legal research.
Research Specifications
The research specifications used in this legal writing are prescriptive and applied,
because legal science with its characteristics as a prescriptive science is a legal science that
studies legal objectives, values, justice, the validity of legal rules, legal concepts and legal
norms. As an applied science, legal science establishes standard procedures, provisions, signs
in implementing legal rules.
In this research the author uses legislative approach and historical approach (statue
approach) and historical approach. This is because the author uses national and national and
international law as the initial basis for analyzing so that the legislation is the focal point of
this research. Legislation is the focal point of this research. The author also uses a historical
approach by examining the background and development of the material under study.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.
Legal Material Collection Method
Based on the approach method used, namely Juridical-Normative so that in this study the
main data source used is secondary data. To collect secondary data, data collection
techniques are needed by means of literature studies, namely reading and selecting provisions
of national and international law and other legal provisions related to research. This literature
study is also Data collection is carried out through book sources as well as journals, the
internet, and articles. In addition, it is also necessary to collect data sourced from sources and
respondents, the data is obtained purposively, namely collecting data intentionally according
to the object of research needed or directly related to the research.
Results and Discussion
Overview of the State of United States Forests
Forests are places where various flora and fauna develop, from microforms to large
animals such as elephants. The interaction of the components contained in the forest
ecosystem continues to run, which makes the forest very beneficial for the sustainability of
living things. The benefits produced by forests make humans carry out activities to utilize
forest areas, utilize environmental services, utilize wood and non-timber forest products and
collect wood and non-timber forest products optimally. As a result, forest utilization and
management have become uncontrollable and caused damage to the forest. Large-scale
destruction and loss of natural forests began to occur in United States since the early 1970s,
when forest concession companies began operating.
One of the things that contributes to forest loss in United States is forest loss due to fire.
Deforestation can happen quickly when fires sweep away forest cover or forests that have
been cut down for land clearing and road building for oil palm and timber plantations.
Deforestation caused by forest fires can be seen in the high number of hotspots in deforested
areas.
In 2014, Riau Province (21,372 hotspots), Central Kalimantan (13,436 hotspots) and
West Kalimantan (9,076 hotspots) experienced the most forest and land fires. Based on
Figure 2, there is a trend in several provinces that have high gross deforestation rates, namely
Riau and Central Kalimantan. Central Kalimantan also show areas with a large number of
hotspots. Based on the results of hotspot data analysis In 2014, hotspots in the three provinces
were influenced by land clearing activities that often occurred from August to October.
There are several triggers for fire, such as the chemical process of combustion due to
nature and deliberate human-made combustion for certain purposes. Fires arising suddenly
from the forest appear naturally due to natural processes, but more than 95% (ninety-five
percent) of the main causes of fires in most countries including United States are caused by
human activities, both intentional and negligent.
The most important natural causes are lightning and volcanic eruptions but these are very
rare in United States which has a tropical climate, because when lightning strikes forest
vegetation it will be immediately extinguished by rainwater because lightning will always go
hand in hand with the emergence of rain in tropical climates. The routine cause of forest and
land fires is a side effect of human activities in fire users, climate factors and daily weather
are very supportive of accelerating the process of fire occurrence. Large-scale fire incidents
are sometimes inseparable from the occurrence of a long dry season. The dry season is caused
by the natural phenomenon of El Nino or El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO).
Natural factors only support the occurrence of fires The main cause of forest and land
fires is human activity, both intentional and negligent. Intentional forms consist of the use of
fire for farming, deliberate but uncontrolled burning of vegetation such as the clearing of HTI
areas, plantations and land preparation by communities, burning during hunting and wildlife
expulsion, burning during fishing, burning agricultural and household waste, burning to repel
mosquitoes by galam wood seekers, as well as other negligent fire users such as campfires lit
by mountain climbers and the absence of fire fighting and fire prevention facilities and
infrastructure.
State Responsibility in Prevention And Forest and Land Fire Management in United
States
Forest and land fires are contrary to the principles of international environmental law,
especially the impacts caused by the fires themselves, especially the emergence of
transboundary haze pollution, although this impact is not the only one that is contrary to the
principles of international environmental law, but this is a direct impact caused by forest and
land fires that cause losses to other countries.
According to international law, state responsibility arises when a state harms another
state. In the 2013 fires and In 2015, the haze problem became an international problem
because it caused transboundary pollution in neighboring countries (transboundary
pollution), so Singapore and Malaysia officially sent a memorandum of protest due to the
haze caused by fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan that reached their country. To resolve this
transboundary pollution issue, the provisions of international law should be considered,
especially customary international law.
At Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001 adopted
by the International Law Commission (ILC), it is stated in Article 1 that Every internationally
wrongful act of a State entails the responsibility of that State (Every act or omission
prohibited by international law entails the international responsibility of that State).
Although, Draft Articles Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001
adopted by the International Law Commission (ILC) is not binding as an instrument of
international law because it has not been enacted as a legal product. However, the binding
force of the ILC Draft is not seen from its form as an instrument, but from its content. The
ILC Draft can be used as an additional source and is binding as customary international law.
ASEAN leaders formulate pattern for handling haze pollution in Asia Southeast Asia in
an ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution) which regulates the distribution of responsibility and
handling of haze pollution in the Southeast Asian region, the agreement has been ratified by
United States through the Law of the Republic of United States Number 26 of 2014
concerning Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Agreement On Transboundary Haze Pollution.
The ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution does not
eliminate the state's responsibility in Satisfaction to maintain relations and as United States
good faith to haze-affected countries.
Principle This becomes important in policy prevention and control of forest and land
fires because most forest and land fires occur on wetlands, especially peatlands. The form of
embodiment of the Wise Use Principle carried out by United States by ratifying the
Convention. Ramsar Convention through Presidential Decree No. 48 of 1991 on ratification
of the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat.
As a result of the Presidential Decree, United States has 7 (seven) Ramsar Sites covering an
area of 1,372,976 hectares, 5 of which are peatlands that are vulnerable to forest and land
fires.
All of these Ramsar Sites are protected through Government Regulation No. 28/2011 on
the Management of Nature Reserves and Nature Conservation Areas. In addition, they have
also been designated by the Government as National Parks through the Decree of the Minister
of Environment, which makes the protection and supervision of peatlands in the 5 sites better
in terms of management and supervision so as to minimize forest and land fires caused by
humans who want to convert the land.
Another form of implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
control policies in United States can be seen in the Law on Environmental Protection and
Management where environmental protection and management aims to control the wise use
of natural resources, this is in accordance with Article 3 Letter h. In addition, in Government
Regulation No. 57/2016 on the Amendment to Government Regulation No. 71 The adoption
of the Wise Use Principle can be seen in Article 9 Paragraph (2) Letters a and b where the
wise use of peatlands is divided into two functions, namely the protection of peat ecosystems
and the cultivation of peat ecosystems.
At the sectoral level, the Ministry of Agriculture issued Minister of Agriculture
Regulation No. 14/Permentan/Pl.110/2/2009 on Guidelines for the Utilization of Peatland for
Oil Palm Cultivation. This more technical regulation regulates the management of peatlands
used for cultivation so that so that This more technical regulation regulates the management
of peatlands used for cultivation, so that the utilization of peatlands cannot be done carelessly
and must meet the rules of peatland management, especially on land with a thickness of more
than 3 meters, as an effort to prevent forest and peatland fires outside of protected areas by
the government.
The implementation of this principle even underlies the United States constitution. The
adoption of this principle is contained in Article 33 Paragraph (3) and Paragraph (4) of the
1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States as a constitutional foundation that requires
that the earth, water and land be protected. The natural resources contained therein are
controlled by the state and used for the greatest prosperity of the people and in its
implementation must be carried out in an environmentally sound manner. The Constitution
itself has mandated this principle as the foundation of natural resource management.
In addition to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of United States, the form of
implementation carried out by United States is by ratifying the Agreement On The
Conservation Of Nature And Natural Resources 1985 which expressly includes this principle
in Article 20. In the UUPPLH, this principle is stated in the explanation of Article 2 letter a
and letter e where the state prevents natural resource utilization activities that cause pollution
and / or environmental damage and all business and / or development activities carried out
are adjusted to the potential of natural resources and the environment to improve people's
welfare and human dignity in harmony with the environment.
The real form of implementation of this principle is stated in the Forestry Law Article 50
paragraph (3) letter d which reads Everyone is prohibited from burning forests, UUPPLH
Article 69 paragraph (1) letter h contains a prohibition on clearing land by burning as it reads
everyone is prohibited from clearing land by burning.
The form of implementation of this principle by United States can be seen in the
explanation of Article 2 letter b of the UUPPLH which states that everyone bears obligations
and responsibilities towards future generations and towards their neighbors in one generation
by making efforts to preserve the carrying capacity of the ecosystem and improve the quality
of the environment.
The implementation of this principle is also in line with United States commitment to the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) agreed at the September 2015 World Summit.10 The
SDGs adopted by United States will also complement the Nawacita vision-mission of
President Trump and Vice President Jusuf Kalla and accelerate the achievement of the NDP.
National Medium Term Development Plan (RPJMN) 2014-201911 . Related to forest and land
fires, the presence of SDGs in United States can prevent and overcome forest and land fires
that occur through the goal or goal 13 of the SDGs about taking immediate steps to address
climate change and its impacts and goal 15 of the SDGs present to ensure the conservation,
restoration and sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems and inland waters and their
environmental services.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the realm of implementation by the
government through the National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas) is drafting the
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of United States on the Implementation of
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The United States government under the Ministry of Environment and Forestry also
issued a regulation of the Directorate General of sustainable production forest management
number: P.14 / PHPL / Set4 / 2016 concerning Standards and Guidelines for Implementing
Performance Assessment of Sustainable Production Forest Management (PHPL) and Timber
Legality Verification (VLK) with the existence of sustainable production forest management,
the sustainable development of the forest is maintained and forces forest management permit
holders to protect the forest and forest security where forest resources must be safe from
disturbances that include forest fires.
The implementation of this principle in the policy of prevention and control of forest and
land fires in United States is contained in the ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution strengthening the implementation of this principle through
Articel 4 which explains that countries must Cooperate in developing and implementing
measures to prevent and monitor transboundary haze pollution as a result of land and / or
forest fires that must be overcome and to control the source of the fire, including fire
identification, development, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of information
and technology and provisions for mutual assistance to help countries experiencing forest and
land fires take legislative, administrative and / or other measures to prevent and control forest
and land fires development, monitoring, assessment and early warning systems, exchange of
information and technology and provision of mutually beneficial assistance to assist countries
experiencing land and forest fires to take legislative, administrative and/or other measures to
prevent and suppress land and forest fires.
The concrete implementation of this principle is the establishment of the Terms of
Reference of the ASEAN Coordination Center for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control
through Annex 1 of the agreement which aims to establish and maintain an orderly
relationship with ASEAN countries in order to improve their preparedness and response to
land and/or forest fires or haze pollution resulting from such fires.
Policies for the Prevention and Management of Forest and Ground Fires in United
States
The United States Government's action as a form of implementation of this principle in
responding to forest and land fires that have a direct impact on humans and the environment
such as the emergence of haze that pollutes the environment and causes ARI in most areas
affected by haze is through the Ministry of Health with the issuance of the Decree of the
Minister of Health of the Republic of United States Number 289 / MENKES / SK / III / 2003
concerning Procedures for Controlling the Impact of Air Pollution Due to Forest Fires on
Health where this decision contains procedures for controlling the impact of air pollution due
to forest fires on health, including pre-disaster, disaster and post-disaster phases of forest
fires. It is a reference for health workers at the District or City Health Office in charge of
environmental health, disease eradication and health workers in other units appointed in
accordance with their respective fields of duty.
The Presidential Instruction, signed by the President on October 24, 2015, assigned 23
Ministers or ministerial-level officials as well as Governors and Regents or Mayors
throughout United States. United States to improve control fire. The Presidential Instruction
itself contains instructions to improve the control of forest and land fires, namely by striving
to prevent, extinguish and handle post-fire / forest and land recovery prevention, suppression
and post-fire handling/recovery of forest and land fires, in addition, the President also
encourages the strengthening of coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the local government in forest and land fires the role of In addition, the
President encourages strengthening coordination across agencies (central and regional),
increasing the role of the community/stakeholders and realizing law enforcement against
perpetrators involved in land and forest burners, either individuals or legal entities. The
Presidential Instruction is a form of the government's rapid response in overcoming forest and
land fires that occurred in 2015.
Implementation of the Intergenerational Justice Principle in United States Forest and
Ground Fire Prevention and Management Policy
The technical implementation of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and
management policies in United States is contained in Government Regulation of the Republic
of United States Number 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
Number 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems. Considering
that forest and land fires in United States often occur in peat ecosystem units that affect the
condition of peatlands to meet the needs of future generations, the implementation of the
principle of intergenerational justice in the Government Regulation in article 4 regulates
Protection Planning and Management of Peat Ecosystems. The management of Peat
Ecosystems is carried out through the stages of inventorying Peat Ecosystems; determining
the function of Peat Ecosystems and preparing and determining plans for the Protection and
Management of Peat Ecosystems.
Planning for the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems aims to realize the
protection of options which has the objective of whether the next generation has the same
options as the current generation in the management of peat ecosystems so that they must be
protected, the protection of quality which has the objective of maintaining the quality of peat
ecosystems so that the quality of peat ecosystems received by the next generation is not
worse than the quality that we have received today and the protection of access where there is
a balanced allocation of rights and access to peat ecosystems between different generations
between members of the current generation.
The government also established the National Strategy and Action Plan for Sustainable
Peatland Management, which has the following objectives purpose the need for wise and
sustainable utilization and management of peatlands. United States peatland management
strategy was developed with reference to the framework of the ASEAN Peatland
Management Initiative (APMI) and the ASEAN agreement on transboundary haze pollution
which was later translated into the ASEAN Peatland Management Strategy (APMS). Land
management strategy It also refers to the provisions of the Ramsar Convention, the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the National Wetland Management
Strategy.12
The implementation of this principle can be seen in the issuance of plantation business
licenses regulated in the Plantation Law Article 45 where in obtaining a plantation business
license must have an environmental permit. Article 36 paragraph (1) of UUPPLH states that
every business and/or activity that is required to have an AMDAL or UKL-UPL must have an
environmental permit. Where in the plantation AMDAL document must contain provisions
for facilities and infrastructure to prevent forest fires and land clearing techniques that are in
accordance with environmental conditions.
Criminal punishment is also a means of implementing the principle of prevention in the
prevention and control of land fires in United States. We know that criminal law sanctions
have a preventive influence on the occurrence of violations of legal norms.
The realization of this principle in forest and land fire prevention and suppression
policies is contained in the regulation of peat water levels and land clearing without burning
(PLTB). Prudence in water management on peatland, which is one of the most important
lands for forest and land fires. Wet peatlands are very important in preventing and tackling
forest and land fires. Peatlands where the peat water table is maintained and always wet will
not be prone to fire. Regulation of the Minister of Environment No. 10/2010 on Mechanisms
for the Prevention of Pollution and / or Environmental Damage Related to Forest and / or
Land Fires in Article 5 Paragraph 1 states that the person in charge of businesses and / or
activities that utilize peatlands must apply water management technical standards.
Carefulness in the land clearing process is also important in the prevention and
suppression of forest and land fires because land clearing without burning is a means of
preventing forest and land fires most important in preventing land fires.
Implementation of Polluter Pays Principle in Prevention Policy And Forest and Land
Fire Management in United States
The application of this principle in the prevention and handling of forest and land fires in
United States is based on administrative sanctions, civil and criminal sanctions and other
forms regulated by laws and regulations. All of which are regulated in the Law of the
Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and
Management. In the process of implementation through the process of proving whether each
person responsible for their business and/or activities has caused pollution and/or damage to
the environment causing pollution and/or damage to the environment.
Technically, the calculation of environmental losses is regulated in the Regulation of the
Minister of Environment of the Republic of United States Number 7 of 2014 concerning
Environmental Losses Due to Pollution and / or Environmental Damage. This Ministerial
Regulation aims to provide guidelines for Central Environmental Agencies and/or Regional
Environmental Agencies in determining environmental losses and calculating the amount of
Environmental Losses.
Government Efforts to Prevent and Control Forest and Land Fires in United States
Preventive efforts by the government to overcome forest and land fires in United States
are carried out by issuing regulations that can prevent forest and land fires. Some of the laws
and regulations issued emphasize heavy sanctions for perpetrators of forest and land fires,
namely Law No. 41 of 1999 concerning Forestry, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning
Plantations, Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management,
Government Regulation No. 57 of 2016 concerning Amendments to Government Regulation
No. 71 of 2014 concerning Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems, Government
Regulation No. 4 of 2001 concerning Control of Damage and or Environmental Pollution
Related to Forest and or Land Fires and more technical regulations such as Minister of
Environment and Forestry Regulations and Minister of Agriculture Regulations.
In addition to the national level, prevention efforts through legislation are also carried out
at the regional level by issuing regional regulations both in provinces and districts / cities on
the prevention and control of forest and land fires.
Prevention efforts are also through the information system information system on the
possibility of a fire occurrence that is well distributed to relevant stakeholders up to the field
level is one of the components of successful fire prevention measures. Nowadays, with the
help of modern technology (computers, telecommunication tools, internet, remote sensing
(geographic information system), a fire information system can be developed based on
factors that influence the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions, climatological
conditions and fire behavior.
Other efforts that can be made by involving communities directly in fire management
activities can also encourage public awareness of the importance of early fire management
around their area. This can be realized through the formation of Fire Brigade Teams at the
community level, which function to tackle forest and land fires early on in their area. Fire
brigades are formed from community members, with the village head in charge, while NGOs
and relevant fire control agencies act as guides and mentors.
Suppression Efforts by the Government to Overcome Forest and Land Fires in United
States
The involvement of various elements of the community, NGOs, agencies, related
agencies and others, in fire-fighting actions is very necessary considering that in fire-fighting
actions quite a lot of human resources are needed, this is where the role of MPA and KTPA is
included in the Fire Control Team. The existence of the Fire Brigade Team will be very
helpful in suppression actions. In a fire case, the Fire Brigade Team is the first posse in the
fire control action, which then coordinates with the Forest and Land Fire Control
Implementation Unit (Satlakdalkarhutla) and the Fire Management Task Force.
In addition, a Forest and Land Fire Fighting Squad Organization was formed, namely
Manggal Agni, which is assisted by elements of the TNI, POLRI, BPBD, Plantation and
Forestry Companies, Community Organizations, Fire Care Communities and Fire Care
Farmer Groups (KTPA). Manggala Agni is a forest and land fire control organization at the
Central Government level that has the duties and functions of prevention, extinguishing, post-
fire handling, evacuation and rescue support, and management support formed and is the
responsibility of the Minister.
Mandala Agni is under the coordination of the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire
Control, which is one of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change
Control (DG PPI). Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Environment and Forestry
Number: P.18 / MenLHK- II / 2015 concerning Organization and Work Procedures of the
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Directorate of Forest and Land Fire Control is one
of the directorates under the Directorate General of Climate Change Control.
The Government's Post-Fire Response to Land and Forest Fires in United States
Enforcement efforts after forest and land fires are carried out in accordance with the Law
of the Republic of United States No. IX. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection
and Management, namely by administrative sanctions, government rights, community rights,
environmental organization rights and criminal prosecution.
In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through natural
succession, vegetation rehabilitation, new planting and hydrological restoration which are the
responsibility of the central government, local governments, communities (including
customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses and/or activities. Delaying
the granting of new licenses and improving the management of primary natural forests and
peatlands are means of restoring land after forest and land fires.
Conclusions
Based on the results of research and discussion of cases in this legal writing, the
following conclusions can be drawn:
The implementation of the principles of international environmental law both contained in
international treaties that have been ratified by United States, as well as the rules of
international environmental law that are soft law have been implemented through the
provisions of national laws governing the environment. The implementation is done through
incorporation, transformation and adoption methods.
We know that some principles of the principles are wise use, the principle of state
sovereignty over natural resources and the responsibility not to cause environmental damage
to other countries or areas outside their national jurisdiction, the principle of sustainable
development, the principle of good neighborliness and international cooperation, the principle
of justice within one generation, the principle of intergenerational justice, the principle of
prevention, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle and the principle of
common but differentiated responsibility which have been contained in the Law on
Environmental Protection and Management, the Law on Forestry, the Law on Plantations, the
Law on the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution and
other provisions relating to forest and land fires in United States. Law on Plantations, Law on
the Ratification of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, Government
Regulation on the Protection and Management of Peat Ecosystems and other provisions
relating to forest and land fires in United States.
In addition, the implementation of international environmental principles The
implementation of international environmental principles is also found in provisions that
regulate the technical aspects of forest and land fire prevention and control in United States,
such as the Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation, Minister of Agriculture
Regulation, Minister of Health Regulation, AMDAL, ISPO, PROPER, certification of timber
products, establishment of forest and land fire prevention and control areas protection of
forest and land areas prone to fire and enforcement based on international environmental
principles.
Government efforts to prevent and control forest and land fires in United States are generally
carried out through three efforts, namely prevention, suppression and post-fire handling.
Prevention efforts are carried out through the issuance of regulations that can prevent forest
and land fires, information systems about the possibility of forest and land fires with the help
of modern technology (computers, telecommunications equipment, the internet and remote
sensing through geographic information systems) with the development of fire information
systems based on factors that affect the occurrence of fires such as fuel conditions,
climatological conditions and fire behavior can prevent and detect forest and land fires early
so that the government can take anticipatory steps against the possibility of fire occurrence
and prevention through community participation by providing basic education to the public
about the dangers of forest and land fires.
In post-fire efforts, the government takes action after forest and land fires in accordance
with the Law of the Republic of United States Number 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental
Protection and Management, namely by taking administrative sanctions, the right to sue the
government, the right to sue the community, the right to sue environmental organizations and
criminals. In addition, recovery efforts after forest and land fires are carried out through
natural succession, vegetation rehabilitation, planting new nutrients and hydrological
restoration which are the responsibility of the central government, local governments,
communities (including customary law communities) and those responsible for businesses
and/or activities.