Ancient African Civilizations

Surname 1

1

AFR 336 - African Art

Arizona State University

September 20, 2019

Ancient African Civilizations

Introduction

ideas or emotion and may also represent their worldview and it is said to be gradual in nature

from one generation to the other (Visonà et al. 228). According to Visona et al. (229), every

culture undergoes civilization which is a steady and endless in nature bringing changes in the

people’s worldview. The peoples’ culture also uses various artistic productions for various

purposes such as communication, and it is interrelated with civilization as every culture uses

different art to communicate and express ideas or emotion. The cyclical human phenomena mean

that the cultures of the world, as well as human history, is a progressive process that takes unique

and new directions every time and it is interrelated to civilization and artistic production.

Viewed cultural refinement is just one measure of development, civilization can also be

interpreted as a cyclical reconfiguration of the human value system, epistemology and systems of

Surname 2

2

systems that propel human development (Guo 139). This observation suggests that artistic

creation is inextricably woven with the economic and ecological adaptive patterns that sustain a

civilization. When the material substratum undergoes evolution, aesthetic and symbolic systems

face of change.

Changes in technology have profound impacts on culture as evidenced in from Richta’s

analysis on social relation during technological revolutions. Changes in technology have

profound impacts on culture as evidenced in from Richta’s analysis on social relation during

technological revolutions. Having sociologists as consultants for film projects seems to indicate

an appreciation of the finer nuances of social interaction. Changes in technology have profound

impacts on culture as evidenced in from Richta’s analysis on social relation during technological

revolutions. The new functions that art can take on during this time include critique as well as

enjoyment. It is this very tension between material advancement versus humanistic values that

the more simplistic functions of art fail to capture. More simplistic functions of art often fail to

Surname 3

3

that incorporates new media or digital aesthetics. As Richta has said, all civilizations have some

measure of technology.

Even though they are intertwined, culture and civilization serve fundamentally different

the capacity of a sensitive measure to the evolving ethical and intellectual climate. When the

cycle of civilization stagnates, it is the vitality of art that is most often the first sign of potential

revival (Sakaeva et al, 441). Thus, the circularity of particular human phenomena can be

interpreted as a dialogue between the firm discipline of spontaneous imagination and the

looseness of structures. In this way, the internal equilibrium of the culture and socio-political

structures of each succeeding civilization is preserved.

Certain cyclical phenomena tend to transcend the context of human civilization. For

example, Gunn et al. suggest that the human condition develops within geo cultural time as an

ever-changing system of linearly conditioned growth (10). In this model, civilization exists

within a planetary metabolism, with its artistic and cultural expressions as adaptive responses to

Surname 4

4

situate themselves in nature (Khairullina et al. 2314). The climate change-induced circular crises,

as cycles of crisis, provoke new artistic engagements with questions of sustainability, continuity,

and human vulnerability. Such constraint induced creativity is a manifestation of the

Yoruba and Fon civilizations

development patterns, contributions to the African culture as well as the global culture. Yoruba,

for instance, inhabit the south-western Nigeria and are spread throughout the world due to

civilization and leading to their migration. They have developed various artistic productions such

as pottery, beadwork, weaving, mask making, and metal work. They made most of this art for the

purpose of appeasing their gods as well as for communication purposes. Visonà et al. (233) says

that this culture emanated from the Ile-Ife and the long distance trade with the Portuguese has

made it the most popular culture in West Africa. They settled in the southwest parts of Nigeria

after being pushed by the Fulani people who emerged as their close enemies. Most of its people

are non-muslin, and hence worships numerous gods. They live in groups and cities instead of

small villages. They form the largest ethnolinguistic group in Nigeria and the West Africa region

Surname 5

5

percentage of them live in other parts of Africa and the world through the Atlantic trade. Most of

the Caribbean people claim to be Yoruba, and their ways of life reflect the same. Their migration

and settlement in most parts of the world have led to the adoption of their religious beliefs,

kept in various Museums around the world, and their migrations have led to the adoption of

some of their cultural values and beliefs.

The example of the Yoruba civilization shows that both political organization and artistic

symbolism evolved mutually to maintain social balance and civic values. Usman and Falola

observe that Yoruba polities before colonialism were built on a system of federated kingship in

which political authority was distributed between councils of elders and advisory councils of

priests (142). This system depicts that the way governance was participatory in nature founded

on moral equilibrium as opposed to hierarchical superiority. This political system had advocated

community decision making and had made it mandatory that leadership was based on divine

harmony as opposed to personal authority. Harmony of this kind placed leadership as a godlike

Surname 6

6

legitimacy and cosmic order (Abiodun 67). These symbols represented the abstract rules of

justice and balance and incorporated the religious persistence of the political and religious

existence. The visual codes translated the political into art and placed politics inside the moral

high level of insight of human fate that is connected with the divine communication. According

to Enaikele and Adeleke, the Ifa system is a divinatory science and a philosophical system used

to explain human purpose (7). This duality is a mirror image of the Yoruba philosophy of the

human knowledge that should always reconcile intuition with the cosmic order. The system

illustrates the Yoruba belief that knowledge is the result of a conversation between the man and

the metaphysical, and intermediated by ritual art and oral poetry. This mediation makes the

cultural belief that the creativity is epistemic and sacred. Ifa corpus is a dynamic library of ethics,

history, and metaphysics delivered in the form of symbolic performance, rhythm of the language

(Jegede 36). These aspects turn the intangible to the tangible as it gives the participants the

ability to involve knowledge in an interaction of sensory and spiritual nature. This creative act of

Surname 7

7

brings artistic practice into something of worship, combining the intellectual and the sacred in

one cultural process. In this operation, the Yoruba civilization expresses an aesthetic

epistemology where the beauty and wisdom are in identity, and the power of imagination has the

balance, respect, and harmonious coexistence. These are artistic expressions of moral values in

material language that anyone in the community can read. Prominence of performative art like

masquerades in art puts audience and aesthetic experience together and ritual is incorporated in

participatory knowledge (Willis 88). This participatory nature reconfirms the point that

according to the Yoruba culture, learning is communal and experience-based. This stage

performance emphasizes the Yoruba concern with art as social expression as opposed to

individualism. With such joint artistry this Yoruba creativity is pedagogy and celebration. Such

forms of artplace beauty in morality in the Yoruba society transforming creativity into a publicly

ethical practice (Abiodun 81). This incorporation of virtue and aesthetics enhances the power of

art as a civic institution and a kind of morality guide.

Surname 8

8

especially in Cuba reflects their flexibility in geography and centuries (195). This survivorship

highlights the fact that Fon people could preserve their religious integrity in the face of

displacement and dismemberment. This continuity is a confirmation of the Fon people that they

theology as a tool, the Fon people made the living archive of spiritual identity to oppose colonial

interference (Munoz 198). These creative persistence bear witness to the adaptive and intact

nature of the African spiritual thought. The strength of their unity, art, becomes a means of their

culture and cultural survival and communication with the cosmos.

A profound scientific and cosmological awareness, and, importantly, ethno-astronomy is

also present in the Yoruba worldview. Segla describes how the Yoruba explanation of the sky

links the systems of heaven to the gods and forms a cosmological science, which links

observation and spirituality (1054). This integration brings together the empirical consciousness

and theological fantasy, breaking any strict line between religion and science. This combination

of astronomy and religion highlights how there should be unity of knowledge in the Yoruba

Surname 9

9

astronomical calculations of both the stars and seasons guided the agricultural cycles, the

calendar of rituals and social gatherings and human activity became in tandem with the celestial

patterns (Segla 1056). These balances made sure that every day life reflected the perfection of

justified authority and recounted the history of people. According to Peel, the leaders of the

Dahomey kingdom used grand rituals and artistic commissions to establish divine approval and

political survival (117). A combination of authority and beauty meant that the governance was

meant to be just as spiritual as it was aesthetic. Such artistic creations as banners with royal

applique and sculptures in the palaces encoded the stories of dynasties and a heavenly order.

They made the court into a historical theatrical stage. Fon artisans then took the political power

beyond the sight of the eye and into an aesthetic form of visualism and reverence. By so doing,

they made certain that virtue, rather than dominance, was put across by statecraft. The religion

and political integration was further solidifying the society, as royal art consisted of the

protective role of spirituality and the role of historical recollection (Munoz 199). Such a

Surname 16

intergenerational creativity that sustains the relationship between knowledge and faith

(Alivizatou 81).

The relationship between art and religion can be examined through the lens of both

nonlife, thus moving away from an anthropocentric view of creation (184). This interpretation

suggests that through sacred art, this broader notion of kinship is visible, representing all beings

as part of an unbroken continuum. In a related observation, Meyer argues that visual religious

expressions often contain, in a sense, eco-ethical imperatives, transducing a metaphysical

equilibrium of sorts to sensate form (352). These intersections articulate that faith-inspired art

engages with existence in ways that goes beyond illustrating theology, but in ways that fosters

existence of sustainable life systems.

Reflective philosophical thinking enables religious art to move between revelation and

rationality. As Buber points out, a deep religious experience occurs in the dialogic between the

human and the divine, where art can function as an encounter and not as a doctrine (118). This

Surname 17

make visible the invisible through a symbolic frame (428). This relationship reveals an invisible

commonality between wanting to make the ungraspable more graspable and, thus, more

accessible. As Shaw describes it, Islamic art does this through a form of abstraction, through

as a mechanism of social thinking. In a specific example of epistemological criticism, the author

notes that the generation of knowledge is not simply a function of mental work, but it is a social

and cultural system that signifies in and through social systems (Machlup 42). This implies that

knowledge is created and licensed through boundaries wider than those of institutions. In his

work, Latour mentions that arts and science have in common the use of visualization to make the

invisible visible and to communicate it (430). This results in a shared perception ground in which

perception serves as a means of revelation. As Grieser observes, the religion and science

boundaries are, at times, indistinguishable, giving birth to hybrid knowledges that are both

evidential and metaphorical (239). This shows that in Eastern Africa, the religious cultural

production is not just artistic, but also conceptual experimentation. Abdullah broadens this view

Surname 18

emphasizes the civilization approach, in which the creative process inspired by religious faith is

underlying the knowledge structure, as worked out devotionally, rationally, and artistically in

one uninterrupted spiral of revelation.

indeed life, the proportions of design, and rhythmic balance of forms within a composition, as

well as the arrangement of images, embodies visual harmony within ethical order (112). Buber

states that a responsibility meets an expectation, and within this interaction, within this

expectation, is a divine anticipation of social order. Alivizatou argues and emphasizes strongly

the importance of rituals which serve as repositories of the communal values, and which become,

in a sense, the vessels that transmit these values for posterity (88). Therefore, religion and art, in

an integrative sense, form the moral consciousness and social order in the East African culture.

Integrating artistic knowledge into economic activities and educational systems is yet

another facet of religion's purpose toward achieving cultural sustainability. As Machlup

observes, knowledge production is economically robust when it is anchored in cultural ingenuity

Surname 19

heritage industries as living systems, rather than stagnant ecosystems (573). This interpretation

of preservation as dynamic and engaged participation in cultural renewal is rather novel. Kagan

further adds that artistic ingenuity nurtures learning in the community enabling it to absorb new

paradigm shift transforms preservation into collaboration and strengthens local agency.

Stylianou-Lambert et al. further highlight that cultural institutions function as social venues

where religious objects attain new value through interpretation, teaching, and learning (575).

This observation demonstrates how museums prolong the life of sacred practices beyond the

confines of ritual. As Meyer notes, these visual settings foster spiritual contemplation by

allowing people to encounter transcendence through art (357). This scenario exemplifies the

ability of public culture to develop contemplative awareness. Shaw also insists that curators of

Islamic art in secular settings must achieve a balance between the artistic display and the sacred

meaning of the work (131). These changing practices indicate that contemporary preservation is

no longer seen as strictly archival, but as a dialogue that fosters religious art without losing the

Surname 20

Art, religion and science during the Anthropocene and the immediate aftermath also

require a rethinking of our imaginative custodianship. Aloi argues that modern ecological art

needs religious aesthetics to settle the ecological crisis, synthesis of praise and critique (164).

custodianship (201). All these indicate the sustaining and ethically life-affirming character of

sacred art.

The fusions of religion, art, and knowledge construction validate the human ability to

envision and re-envision the sacred as a living reality. Buber argues that genuine religiousness is

relational and therefore, through artistic creation, one can concretize dialogue between the

human and divine (131). This perspective frames creation as a continuous revelation rather than

a belief frozen in time. Latour supports this perspective when he claims that both art and science

engage in mediating activities that perpetually reconstruct a shared understanding of truth (439).

This reconstruction indicates civilization’s reliance on symbolic creation to provide meaning; on

the other hand, Meyer notes that the religious’s artwork’s visual language constitutes the

Surname 21

becomes a part of a collective rhythm. When faith-inspired knowledge, Abdullah argues,

synthesizes the aesthetic and the rational, it nurtures a vision of progress that is anchored in

compassion and imagination, and which is integrative and holistic (203). These perspectives, in a

cultures from the historical establishment. The prove that Bernal provides for his thesis makes

me agree with his hypothesis. He shows the distinctive links such as the borrowing of religion by

the Greek from the civilizations of Egypt. For instance, he provides a connection between the

Cretan Bull Cult among the Minos and further provides a link between Min, the Egyptian god,

and the Minotaur that always needed bovine sacrifices.

Watching the film made me think differently about the African civilization, the ancient

Greece, and its continuity. On the African civilization, it made me think that the ancient African

civilization was sophisticated and more organized to the point of being adopted in Greece. The

influence that ancient African civilization has on the Greek society through cultural diffusion

accounts for the major achievements in Greece today (Bernal). The religion and religious beliefs

Surname 22

most of its artistic productions are based on African art. The arts also prove that the Greek

civilization was not entirely shaped and influenced by the Indo-European settlers’ but the ancient

African civilization. The acceptance of Bernal’s hypothesis that Greece thrives more on

pluralistic enlightenment to human progress (74). His understanding indicates that decolonizing

history is not only the process of obtaining facts but also of reorganizing world self-

consciousness. Field also notes that the African literature and classical studies show that

reinterpretations promote cross-cultural literacy and cross-cultural recognition (79). This

relationship makes history a dialogical field and not an array of roots. Fraser goes a step further

to opine that Black Athena revives the lineage of philosophical rationalism in the Greek tradition

but reconnects to African spirituality (56). The outcome is an intellectual reconciliation in which

Africa has permanently played its part in the search of meaning of man curbing the study of

classics into an inclusive human science.

The revision of classical roots in the argument made by Bernal also faces the symbolic

Surname 23

experience European exceptionalism by creating a cultural other according to the criticism (362).

These representations show cultural power as having mostly been sustained through visual and

narrative exclusion. Lefkowitz and Rogers argue that such distortions continue to exist since the

about historical correction, but also it is a film, in some way, taking on the project of

philosophically intervening in the morality of seeing and remembering.

The hypothesis of Bernal is enriched by the concept of cultural sustainability and

collective memory. According to Stylianou-Lambert et al., museums and heritage organizations

need to acknowledge oppressed history as a part of cultural sustainability on the global level

(568). Their discussion highlights that it is morally important that institutions can reinstate

multiplicity in historical accounts. Field also writes that reinterpretation of the African classics

continues into a living dialogue, which maintains the relevance of the past to the cultural identity

of the present (87). This perpetuation makes heritage a creative survival mechanism and not a

form of rigid commemoration. Lefkowitz and Rogers also say that the recognition of the African

Surname 24

appropriation, but as interdependence. Another person, Aloi, continues the idea with saying that

plotting art reinterpretation, as well as natural history itself, develops in according cycles of

reinvigoration and moral adjustment (172). In this way, Black Athena may be interpreted as

retrieves wholeness in civilizations that were disjointed by the colonial thought. Haley asserts

that feminist recuperation of classical texts is the same healing desire by creating marginalization

into empowerment (35). Her style of approach makes reinterpretation a historical correction and

ethical creation. According to Meighoo, the Western monopoly of knowledge is ending, which

leads to the appearance of a genuinely global humanities with the ability of self-criticism (106).

These observations indicate that the film directed by Bernal is engaged in a greater history of

narrative healing, in which the path to cultural and psychological revitalization looks back to the

past.

Philosophically, the project by Bernal prompts the Buberman concept of dialogue

between the finite and the infinite as the essence of true encounter. According to Buber, truth

Surname 25

engaged in the construction of human thought as collaborators. Meighoo notices that this

relationality does not preserve the myth of western isolation because Greece is placed in the

context of an African wisdom tradition (113). The interdependence which he observes as the

of representation is still disputed. Kompatsiaris maintains that the racialized jokes of popular

culture and the nationalistic imagery strengthen the exclusionary discourses of the Black Athena

(369). This association reveals how entertainment can build up historical amnesia. Haley

underlines that the redefinition of classics in terms of Black feminist interpretations turns the

field of representation into the field of resistance, allowing oppressed voices to take the

intellectual field back (37). The cultural production is redefined with a hint of at least political

activism. In his discussion of Afrofuturist cinema, Marks explains how movieland could

juxtapose historical memory in a form of imaginative futures that confront colonial time (118).

This rewriting fits with the cinema style that Bernal applies in integrating both learning and

poetry to reveal repressed lineages. Meighoo finds that by challenging mythic nationalism, such

Surname 32

Africa functions as a historical record and as a political instrument which sustains memory

through rhythm and performance (104). Her opinion supports the statement that music serves to

be an intermediation between art and activism. Smith claims that without these cultural

and deviation. Gikandi sees this contradiction as an effect of racial modernity in which Africa

had become a symbolic place of renewal despite becoming a peripheral political entity (153). It

is revealed through his understanding that aesthetic appropriation reflected the overall colonial

contradictions. Ferdinand extends this debate by connecting spatializing of modern art to

colonial geography by stating that representation tried to mask dependency with discovery (56).

This reading can make one reconsider art as a way of building empire using visual language.

Meier claims that the inclination now toward being able to acknowledge Indigenous modernisms

reinstates the sense of agency to non-Western artists who defined the global aesthetic order

(223). The totality of these orientations reveals that the strength of modernism is neither

excluding but suppressed African lineages.

Surname 33

combines native philosophy and critical self-reflection in order to provide an African thought as

the source of universal knowledge (118). His argument recovers philosophical modernity as a

colonial legacy. Mathuray continues that African stories use postmodern methods not to

the self-conceptualization of modernity.

The spread of African performance aesthetics globally emphasizes the shift out of local

ritual to global media. According to Osumare, the African-based styles of performance,

especially the dance and hip-hop, create a transnational aesthetic that unites the diaspora

communities together by means of embodied storytelling (57). This practice play shows the way

art can be a form of social resistance. Jaji demonstrates that such world shapes bear the historical

memory, the sounds of jazz, reggae, and Afrobeat are connected to the beats of liberation (116).

Her viewpoint underlines the relatedness of music and political awareness. According to

Gikandi, the entry of African expressive culture into global modernity exposes the false

intertwining of race and creativity in the process of making modern sense (160). His summary

Surname 34

facilitating hybrid and collaborative creativity (14). These concepts reveal that African aesthetics

do not flourish based solely on conservation but must always continue to be transformed and

redefined in new cultural circumstances.

points out that African contemporary writers and artists are acutely aware of aesthetic form to

refute the colonial epistemologies and celebrate local knowledge (162). In his analysis, he

associates beauty to decolonial knowledge. According to Mathuray, African modernism attains

universality by merging myth, memory, and materiality and offers a whole picture of human

experience (1112). African art, therefore, makes knowledge production a creativity and a moral

process based on cultural self-consciousness.

African aesthetic cosmopolitanism goes beyond stylistic hybridity, as well, to ethical

universality. According to Siskind, cosmopolitan desires manifest the needs of human beings to

recognize each other within an order that is common to all people over the earth (18). His idea is

echoed across African Ubuntu relationality-determined philosophies of existence. According to

Surname 35

makes philosophy sound. Kaur and Dave-Mukherji believe that the cultural flows of

globalization break up the fixed classifications of tradition and modernity and demand non-rigid

systems of aesthetics that acknowledge plurality (22). They are in line with African pluralism as

Ferdinand concurs that digital art is a type of mapping that brings to visual reality the invisible

networks of identity and migration (77). His interpretation places digital aesthetics in a similarity

with the diasporic experience of Africa. Osumare further notes that online performance cultures

bring the Africanist aesthetic into virtual spaces enabling voices of the threshold to remake the

global cultural narrative (69). These computerized manifestations increase artistic independence

and flexibility. According to Gikandi, the continued presence of African creativity in media

across the globe indicates that cultural resilience is in a position to adjust to the recent changing

technological circumstances without compromise of authenticity (164). These intersections keep

making the African aesthetics challenge modernity in the form of a developing dialogue between

technology, identity, and imagination.

Surname 36

not as a linear evolution, in which artistic practice restages historical consciousness (82). His

interpretation is reflecting African cyclic idea of time, which considers creation to be the

constant renewal. This cyclical temporality, according to Mathuray, exists in the African

African aesthetics philosophy offers a guide towards resolving spirituality, modern

consciousness, and creativity. Mellor and Shilling suggest that in the aesthetic experience of

modern reflexivity, the renewed contact between body and spirit is possible (282). This

sentiment is echoed in the African art of holistic expression and faith. Lamola and Mathuray,

working on the same premises, view African postmodern art as a spiritual dialogue that unites

metaphysics with political awareness (127; 1118). This synthesis shows the revelation and

critique in art. According to Gikandi, through the incorporation of spirituality into the

modernistism aesthetic, African artists reverse the Western dichotomy of the sacred and secular

creativity (165). The African art is placed in his view as an African theology of presence. Siskind

will add that this integrative aesthetic becomes the building block of global cosmopolitanism

Surname 37

philosophy does not just redefine art, but recaptures the modernity as a divine human activity

that is an integration of reason, emotion, and transcendence.

Philosophy of Cultural Memory

collective identity crises usually occur when the memory loses its coherence in symbols and

there is a lack of connection between the present and the past (14). This break illustrates the way

through which cultural continuity may be broken by forgetting. Ruin further includes that

forming memories is a hermeneutic process that reconstitutes the self by reconsidering the lack

and loss (200). Combined with the prior views, these also show that memory is not a passive

reserve, but rather whereby an active philosophical process re-creates meaning and stabilizes

civilization through time.

Philosophy of memory is concerned with how world communities are reconstructing the

past in order to find moral and cultural renewal. Meretoja maintains that storytelling is a moral

activity through which collective memory resolves the difference between fact and possibility

Surname 38

prefer narratives that ensure continuity and intent (298). It is this bias that makes memory into a

tool of cultural survival. Rieff, though, cautions the danger of the excess that fills in the

memorial, whereby the failure to forget makes communities unable to reconcile and move on

demonstrates how geography is an archives of group mind. Costea builds up on this image of

space as he speaks of architecture as a memory museum in which buildings hold the moral and

emotional sub-surface of a civilization (120). These constructions make memory material. Le

Roy, an interpreter of Walter Benjamin, views these lootings as philosophical residues that bring

concealed pasts into manifestation through pieces of the past (129). In his understanding,

memory is the continuation of decay, which implies that there is an ethics of attention to the

discarded. Rigney highlights that narrative and space overlap through aesthetic forms that allow

societies to live in the present of memory (71). These views portray that memory does not exist

as abstract reflection but as embodiment through space and determines cultures by continuity and

belonging.

Surname 39

swift technological acceleration is a danger to the permanence of the digital archives (12). His

worry reflects on how conservatory relies on the unstable material conditions. Bilbao

demonstrates that film and visual media produce emotional archives that help communities to

innovation and the precariousness of cultural inheritance.

Cultural memory is also an instrument of reestablishing of identity and political

opposition. Makarov believes that the restoration of buried histories assists communities to cure

identity crises brought along by imperialism (15). Memorizing is converted into political action

by this process. Rigney points out that aesthetic forms, including music, performance, and

narrative, facilitate this recovery process in the context of translating trauma into common

meaning (70). She notes that art has catharsis and reconstruction. Rieff also makes this opinion

more complex, claiming that too frequent memorialization can make people stay as victims,

trapping societies in the plots of misery (47). His reasoning cautions us that we should not be

obsessed with obsessing and idolizing memory instead of transformation. Ruin sees the memory

Surname 40

equilibrium between grief and regeneration, such that the past does not dictate and rather inform

cultural identity.

The forms of narrative memory disclose how storytelling presents individual and social

humans. Bernecker and Michaelian also assert that there is always an element of imagination in

the process of remembering, and fact and interpretation have become hard to tell apart (3). All

these converging points of view represent narrative as an ethical and epistemological process

wherein memory becomes the creative basis of civilization.

Cultural memory helps make the civilization, but in changing the loss into continuity.

According to Ruin, anamnesis, or the act of philosophical remembering, turns forgetting into

reflection and enables societies to redefine the absence of something as something meaningful

(205). This idea of his reveals the way in which the process of remembering becomes a creative

one: a reconstruction. Hutton continues that history is a rewriting of memory, a subjective

experience in collective knowledge that determines the moral dimensions of a culture (300). His

Surname 41

memory can be a strong barrier to reconciliation (50). The dual ethical potential of memory is

highlighted by such a paradox. Makarov argues that the collective identity becomes stable when

the communities learn to redefine, and not to idealize their pasts (17).

historical consciousness because remembering is an ethical reorganization of past time (303).

According to his analysis, memory is a moral continuum resource. Rigney notes that cultural

mediation cultural mediation, consisting of literature, ritual and visual art, forms a temporal

dialogue between past and present (74). Such meanings point in the direction of philosophy of

memory transposing linear history into a conversational process of life, in which loss and

renewal are both parts of the moral progression of civilization.

Cultural memory today serves both as an aesthetic practice that combines morality and

artistic devolution. According to Rigney, the aesthetic aspect of memory allows the societies to

redefine trauma with beauty and integrates remembrance into emotional and moral education

(73). Her point of view puts an emphasis on the redemptive nature of art. Bilbao notes that the

Surname 48

representation more-than sustains to the marginalized life. In this way, Blanton turns art into a

repository of metaphysical endurance. Lionnet further argues that postcolonial cinema is

hybridized and often brings together mythology and realism bounded by the West's repression of

Foucault's power relations, when viewed in a postcolonial context, show how the order of space

within colonial rule is a means of domination control of power (272). Such a fusion geography

and philosophy is rare. Barnett observes that the act of postcolonial space reclamation entails

rewriting the symbolic geographies which continue to construct power relations globally (169).

His proposition dismantles the claims to the singularity of Western spatial imagination. McEwan

supports this through the notion that decolonial spatial practices, such as community mapping

and storytelling, recover the voices of the people muted by colonial borders (63). Collectively,

these ideas are powerful in demonstrating space as both tangible and conceptual where

sovereignty is silenced, yet easily reclaimable and rethought.

Postcolonial storytelling ethics reconstitute a narrative as a collective act of resistance. In

Surname 49

(111). Such a philosophy recasts narrative as a form of political discourse. Lionnet shows that

postcolonial writing by women employs hybridity as a mode of resistance to self or other binary

representations, thus transforming the act of writing into cultural negotiation (44). In this way,

vulnerability, and epistemic humility. Phillips describes knowledge as fragile, resting with

difference and uncertainty (147). His framework proposes an openness to difference as a

prerequisite for learning. McEwan connects this vulnerability to development issues, claiming

that decoloniality requires mutual learning between the global North and the global South, and

not only South-to-North export of expertise (68). This reconceptualizes research as collaborative.

Barnett insists that postcolonial critique ought to refrain from replacing one order of dominance

for another in order to sustain critical reflexivity concerning the claims it makes about knowing

(171). This is a safeguard against ideological reversal. Blanton, through a theological lens, sees

this humility as the spiritual strength “to recognize the finitude and utter dependence, and see

these as a way of wisdom” (153). These positions agree that knowledge, in its unadulterated and

Surname 50

Postcolonial reconstruction of archives and heritage has constructed who controls cultural

memory as a problem. Do-dam shows that the creation of memory places influences collective

belonging and therefore influences how societies understand their past (82). This suggests that

failing to address the past, but the ethical recontextualization of the past, and transformation of

archives to spaces of collective reconciliation.

Postcolonial knowledge is not just a critique, but an attempt to imagine what a future

understanding of humanity could look like. “Dabashi argues that to intellectual decolonize is to

go beyond the binary of West and non-West to construct a genuinely global philosophy of

mutual recognition” (75). Such a vision endorses the idea of domination-free epistemic

universality. Meretoja considers narrative the instrument through which such universality is

ethically anchored, allowing humanity to transform difference into a dialogue (118). Her

explanation brings together the questions of aesthetics and ethics. McEwan insists that the

decolonial should always attend to new geocentric inequalities and syntheses of global ecological

Surname 51

knowing. This is the power of postcolonialism (173). These insights, taken together, demonstrate

that postcolonial knowledge is lived philosophy; an ever-evolving reconstruction of meaning that

is deeply anchored to justice, plurality and intellectual emancipation.

Gender, Myth, and Power

This concept accentuates the fact that myths institutionalize moral regimes and replicate social

values over time. Their point is performative of myth in the preservation of social cohesion.

According to the Yoruba cosmology, Abiodun notes that feminine orishas, such as Oshun, are a

symbol of aesthetic and moral beauty, which is metaphorical enough to depict creativity and

justice (56). This understanding relates art to the sacrosanct femininity. Usman and Falola

contribute that gender in Yoruba civilization was relative, not absolute, but by building a

relationship of mutual respect between male and female gods (214). Collectively, these

fundamentals demonstrate that mythic femininity was neither secondary, however, but the focus

in the expression of balance in ancient moral and cosmological frameworks.

The continuity and renewal through feminine symbols is a relational emphasis of the

Surname 52

feminine archetypes to tend to carry such a regenerative cycle of destruction and renewal. His

idea is comparable to the mythical role played by maternal figures that restore cultural order

when a chaos occurs. Khairullina et al. address cyclical rhythms of human phenomena, which

the system of wisdom and nurturing power through Ifa system (8). Based on these readings, the

issue of civilization is characterized as being reliant on feminine symbolism as a metaphysical

and ecological restoration agency.

African and Greek myths of gender depict the way female divinity became power and

pedagogy. According to Willis, Yoruba masquerade ceremonies code teachings about kinship,

gender, and power, and through which female divinities direct the ethical framework of social

performance (92). This observation brings out the didactic language of ritual, as women transmit

their sacred power symbolically. His explanation shows that ritual art makes gender

philosophical. Ojaide associates folklore with indigenous knowledge regimes and claims that the

mythical women figures are responsible in being custodians of folklore and continuity of culture

Surname 53

the Orisa religion, Peel demonstrates that the female spiritual beings serve as an intermediary

between the sacred law and the social life in the community and thus releasing moral power in

the ethics of the community to them (119). His perception places gender as the pivot between

cultural revolution is both disruptive and reliant upon conventional moral frameworks that often

have myth-like beginnings (72). In this view, cultural renewal must largely involve re-involving

ancient feminine virtues of balance and empathy. Such continuity is the reason why gendered

archetypes remain even in modern times. Usman and Falola record the history of Yoruba politics

being dependent on women ritual and economic power, which meant that, power was spiritual

just like it is administrative (233). At the expense of their research a combination of

cosmological order and social governance is shown. Abiodun connects the portrayals of female

divinity to social power saying that the visual representation institutionalized political morality in

the aesthetic language (61). All these analyses, together, confirm that feminine myth acted as a

template of the fair power structures.

Surname 54

abstract truths tangible ideals but mold collective moral imagination as embodiments of symbols

(136). This is to say that myth is a demonstration of a cognitive role - it directly informs us in a

way that philosophy instructs us in argument. His claim explains the reason why female deities

structure of culture is based on the symbolic the equilibrium between masculine and feminine

values (440). The overall implication of these readings is that mythic gender was the civil

structure of moral architecture in a variety of cultural settings.

In the African societies, art and religion have always incorporated feminine energy as a

creative energy. According to Abiodun, the Yoruba art is an interplay between visual language

and theology and symbolizes the divine femininity as both creative and reactive (74). It is in his

statement that the creativity, in its essence, is kind of sacred when connected to the femininity.

This method places the aesthetics of beauty as an educational method. Willis points out that,

although the masquerade is usually enacted by men, it represents feminizing gods, and this plays

out the indeterminacy of gender as a performative and spiritual interaction (101). This duality

Surname 55

power. Peel shows that Orisa religion encourages a mutual feminine and masculine impact in

which the divine and human relations reflect dependence on each other (128). It is this

reciprocity that makes up the ethical basis of the Yoruba civilization. Ojaide builds on this

memory. Their writing shows the ability of myth to rejuvenate a culture. According to Richta,

civilization at crossroads implies that technological development should reconnect with its moral

core by rediscovering a humanistic, usually feminine, set of values (88). Through his words, he

suggests that a lack of ethical foundation in progress leads to self-destruction. This is equivalent

to African appeals to ethical moderation in modernization. Khairullina et al. demonstrate that

human development is cyclical and that balance has to be established between the forces of

nature and those of social aspect to prevent crisis (2315). Their claim fits into the feminine type

of keeper of balance. Canu claims that the recuperation of indigenous gender systems presents a

variant of democracy where people cooperate and are morally keen (15). These readings confirm

that the re-invention of myths of the feminine is not a nostalgia but a strategy of epistemology of

Surname 56

Feminine power in myths is also overlapping with ecological and cosmic sign. Gunn et

al. explain the process of civilization as a helical one as the forces of the environment and

spiritual forces are in constant action to transform the complexity of the social sphere (7). This

mythical doctrines of oneness with nature. Ojaide adds that the indigenous literature entrenches

ecological care in feminine-focused narratives, which perceive the land as mother and instructor

(180). All these views put together show mythic femininity as a principle of civilisation, which

integrates ecology, morality, and the responsibility of creativity in a sacred field.

Gendered myth is also a form of historical consciousness, which is keeping civilizational

values intergenerational. According to Santayana, civilization moves forward by maintaining the

ideals of the spirit which are written in art and myth (142). Having foresight, his insight is that

memory itself, as aestheticized, is continuity itself and criticism itself. In his statement, he

identifies memory as the moral motor of civilization. Enaikele and Adeleke discover that the Ifa

system records human destiny, orally, when feminine wisdom protects the survival of moral law

Surname 57

Usman and Falola divulge that oral female performance in the past served to act as a communal

education as it allowed the mythical teachings to be connected with societal morality (252).

Their conclusions demonstrate that narrative supports cultural coherence. Sakaeva et al. contend

ideology places mythical femininity in the role of the conscience of civilization. According to

Abiodun, Yoruba divine iconography is perceived as a visual theology that codes feminine virtue

into ethics within the community (90). The implication of this reading is that art acts like

scripture, which influences moral consciousness by way of beauty. This once again upholds art

as moral speech. It is important to note that gendered spirituality was a vital aspect to African

political systems in the past that ensured social harmony, and provides examples of moral

balance in modern governance (Kanu 18). It is the civic aspect of gender that was brought to

light through his insight. Richta concludes that the reestablishment of the civilization lies on the

attainment of a reconnecting of spiritual wisdom and scientific progress (94). It is the

convergence of these views that declare the symbol of femininity is not a by-product of mythic

Surname 64

Blanton, Ward. A materialism for the masses: Saint Paul and the philosophy of undying life.

Columbia University Press, 2014.

Blanton, Ward. A materialism for the masses: Saint Paul and the philosophy of undying life.

Enaikele, M. D., and A. T. Adeleke. "Yorubas' Ifa system and human destiny: An oral narrative

account." Fourth World Journal 16.2 (2018): 5-17.

Ferdinand, Simon. Mapping beyond measure: Art, cartography, and the space of global

modernity. U of Nebraska Press, 2019.

Field, Roger. "The classics, African literature, and the critics." English in Africa 44.1 (2017): 73-

95.

Fraser, Robert. "Of Sirens, Science and Oyster Shells: Hypatia the Philosopher from Gibbon to

Black Athena." Literature, Music and Cosmopolitanism: Culture as Migration. Cham:

Springer International Publishing, 2018. 51-64.

Gikandi, Simon. "Race and the modernist aesthetic." Writing and Race. Routledge, 2017. 147-165.

Surname 65

Gunn, Joel D., et al. "Geo-cultural time: advancing human societal complexity within worldwide

constraint bottlenecks—a chronological/helical approach to understanding human–

planetary interactions." BioPhysical Economics and Resource Quality 4.3 (2019): 10.

Theory 57.2 (2018): 292-305.

Jaji, Tsitsi. Africa in stereo: Modernism, music, and pan-African solidarity. Oxford University

Press, 2014.

Jazeel, Tariq. "S ubaltern geographies: Geographical knowledge and postcolonial

strategy." Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography 35.1 (2014): 88-103.

Jegede, Charles Obafemi. "Ifa mythology on human variations and global African identity and

global contact." Canadian Social Science 12.10 (2016): 34-41.

Kagan, Sacha. Art and sustainability: Connecting patterns for a culture of complexity. Vol. 25.

transcript Verlag, 2014.

Kanu, Anthony Ikechukwu. "African traditional democracy with particular reference to the Yoruba

Surname 66

Kaur, Raminder, and Parul Dave-Mukherji, eds. Arts and aesthetics in a globalizing world. Taylor

& Francis, 2015.

Khairullina, Elmira R., et al. "Global climate change: Cyclical nature of natural and permanent

Le Roy, Frederik. "Ragpickers and Leftover Performances: Walter Benjamin’s philosophy of the

historical leftover." Performance Research 22.8 (2017): 127-134.

Lefkowitz, Mary R., and Guy MacLean Rogers, eds. Black athena revisited. UNC Press Books,

2014.

Legg, Stephen. "Beyond the European province: Foucault and postcolonialism." Space, knowledge

and power. Routledge, 2016. 265-289.

Lionnet, Françoise. Postcolonial representations: women, literature, identity. Cornell University

Press, 2018.

Machlup, Fritz. "Knowledge: Its Creation, Distribution and Economic significance: Knowledge

and Knowledge Production." (2014): 1-304.

Surname 67

Short Papers, Industry Cases, Workshop Descriptions, Doctoral Consortium papers, and

Keynote abstracts-Volume 2. 2014.

Makarov, Andrey I. "Philosophy of Memory and Crisis of Collective Identity." Logos et

Modernist World. Routledge, 2015. 214-224.

Meighoo, Sean. The End of the West and Other Cautionary Tales. Columbia University Press,

2016.

Mellor, Philip A., and Chris Shilling. "Re-conceptualising the religious habitus: Reflexivity and

embodied subjectivity in global modernity." Culture and Religion 15.3 (2014): 275-297.

Meretoja, Hanna. The ethics of storytelling: Narrative hermeneutics, history, and the possible.

Oxford University Press, 2018.

Meyer, Birgit. "Picturing the invisible: visual culture and the study of religion." Method & Theory

in the Study of Religion 27.4-5 (2015): 333-360.

Munoz, Fr Louis J. "Cuba has been called the island of the black fidelity. There, African traditions-

Surname 68

although at times in a fragmentary and simplified form, have continued." Compass-

Comparative Literature in Africa: Essays in Honour of Willfried F. Feuser (2015): 193.

Ojaide, Tanure. "Indigenous Knowledge and Its Expression in the Folklore of Africa." Indigeneity,

Phillips, John WP. "Force and Vulnerability in Philosophy and Science: Husserl, Derrida,

Stiegler." Cultural Politics 11.2 (2015): 145-161.

Phillips, Ruth B. "Aesthetic primitivism revisited: The global diaspora of'primitive art'and the rise

of Indigenous modernisms." Journal of Art Historiography 12 (2015): 1.

Qing-feng, Y. A. N. G. "Memory Studies in Modern Philosophy." Journal of East China Normal

University (Philosophy and Social Sciences) 49.5 (2017): 26.

Richta, Radovan. Civilization at the crossroads: Social and human implications of the scientific

and technological revolution (international arts and sciences press): Social and human

implications of the scientific and technological revolution. Routledge, 2018.

Rieff, David. In praise of forgetting: Historical memory and its ironies. Yale University Press,

Surname 69

Rigney, Ann. "Cultural memory studies: Mediation, narrative, and the aesthetic." Routledge

international handbook of memory studies. Routledge, 2015. 65-76.

Rodríguez, Encarnación Gutiérrez. "Decolonizing Postcolonial Rhetoric 1." Decolonizing

Reason in Art. Vol. 7. Mit Press, 2015.

Sègla, Dafon Aimé. "Yoruba Ethnoastronomy-“Orisha/Vodun” or How People’s Conceptions of

the Sky Constructed Science." Handbook of Archaeoastronomy and Ethnoastronomy.

Springer, New York, NY, 2015. 1051-1058.

Shaw, Wendy MK. What is “Islamic” art?: Between religion and perception. Cambridge

University Press, 2019.

Shefer-Mossensohn, Miri. Science among the Ottomans: The cultural creation and exchange of

knowledge. University of Texas Press, 2015.

Siskind, Mariano. Cosmopolitan desires: global modernity and world literature in Latin America.

Vol. 14. Northwestern University Press, 2014.

Surname 70

Stylianou-Lambert, Theopisti, Nikolaos Boukas, and Marina Christodoulou-Yerali. "Museums

and cultural sustainability: stakeholders, forces, and cultural policies." International

Journal of Cultural Policy 20.5 (2014): 566-587.

278.

Willis, John Thabiti. Masquerading Politics: kinship, gender, and ethnicity in a Yoruba town.

Indiana University Press, 2018.