The Catcher in the Rye Chapters 13-14
Holden walks the 41 blocks to the hotel. The elevator attendant, Maurice, mentions that he would be able to set Holden up with a prostitute, to which Holden agrees.
Later, “Sunny” appears at his door, a girl around Holden’s age. However, Holden changes his mind, deciding that even though he has sexual urges, this is not the route he wants to take in losing his virginity. He also feels concern for Sunny, as she seems young and innocent, a concern continuing to emerge as a theme in the book. Holden pays her the agreed upon five dollars (in spite of declining her services), but she insists on being paid another five dollars at that point. Holden refuses her demand, and sends her away.
He spends a little time reflecting upon his philosophies, and dwells on memories of his deceased brother. When he answers a knock at the door around sunrise, he is met by Sunny and Maurice (the elevator operator/ pimp). Maurice then assaults Holden for not paying the additional five dollars. Sunny takes the money from Holden’s wallet.
Holden finally goes to sleep after they leave.
Analysis:
Holden struggles with his adolescent thoughts. He questions his own bravery, and has conflicting thoughts regarding sex. He wants to be a tough guy, but he wants to remain true to his values. These considerations both come into play when Holden decides that he cannot commit a sex act with Sunny, and decides that the best way to get out of the situation is by telling a lie. This only furthers his own doubt about his own courage, and his ability to become a sexually experienced man.
Sunny’s young age and the almost-childish vernacular that she uses dig deeply into Holden’s thoughts. His decision not to have sex with her is partly due to his own realization that he needs to be in a relationship with a woman before sex can happen. And partly because he feels pity for Sunny. He sees her as an innocent child who he does not wish to have a hand in defiling.
Holden’s reflection displays some feelings of guilt, especially regarding Allie. Holden feels guilt for specific times when his brother was alive that Holden did not treat him with the love he feels now towards his brother. Holden reflects upon his religious beliefs, and in doing so, reveals to the reader his strong belief in loyalty and faithfulness, but great uncertainty about the presence of God.
After Sunny and the pimp have given Holden a rough time, his adolescent conflict continues, as he fancies a heroic and glorious revenge. At the same time, he considers his own failures and weaknesses, and ponders the idea of suicide.
