Discussion Assignment 4.1

���������� ��� ��� �

��� ����������� ������������� ������������������ ��� � ������� � � ����!� ������ � "� ����� ��#

$%&'( )

*+,-)$./+01)10)/123456/3)+.,7.06/)/3,+36*-

*+,-)$./+018

/9:(;<=>();?>)@==')A%9B(?@C=D)E9'>=E:(&F=CGD)H9%)IJ)G=?%>K)+L?&'D)&')?')&'M:>(%G)<;=%=)(;=)'9%N)&>

@?'O%:A(EGD)(;=GP%=)A%9B(?@C=K).')H?E(D)=F=')&')(;=);9%%&@C=)G=?%D);9%%&@C=)&')N?'G)%=>A=E(>D)@:()A?%(&E:C?%CG

B'?'E&?CCG)H9%)(;=)?&%C&'=>)9H)JQQRD)(;=&%)A%9B()<?>)M9<'D)@:()(;=G)>(&CC)<=%=)A%9B(?@C=)&')JQQRK)+)G=?%)(;?(

<&A=M)9:()KKK)+>)>=F=%?C)?&%C&'=>)BC=M)@?'O%:A(EGK)7=(P>)(;&'O)?@9:()(;=N)?>)?)%=?CCG)&'(=%=>(&'L)=S?NAC=K

T&%>()9H)?CCD)(;=G);?F=)?)%=?CCG)EC=?%)>(%?(=LGK)3;=&%)>(%?(=LG);?>)@=='D)A%9F&M=)?)C9<)KKK)3;=GP%=)?)C&((C=)E;?CC='L=M

@G)(;&>D)>9N=(;&'L)<=)E?')(?CO)?@9:()&')?)N&':(=K)U:()@?>&E?CCGD)H9%)N9>()9H)(;=)C?>()IJ)G=?%>D)(;=&%)>(%?(=LG)&>D

A%9F&M=)?)C9<)E9>(D)N9%=)E9'F='&='()?C(=%'?(&F=)(9)(%?F=C)@=(<==')N&MV>&W=)E&(&=>)(;?()?%=)?@9:()XQQ)(9)RDQQQ

N&C=>)?A?%(K)U?>&E?CCG)(;=&%)E9NA=(&(&9'D);&>(9%&E?CCGD);?>)@==')E?%>D)(%?&'>D)@:>=>D)?'M);:@)?'M)>A9O=)Y&L;(>K

.H)G9:)<?'(=M)(9)L9)H%9N)Z?'E;=>(=%D)0=<)4?NA>;&%=)(9)U?C(&N9%=D)<;?()?%=)G9:%)?C(=%'?(&F=>[)-9:)E?')M%&F=[

.(P>)?)C9'L)M%&F=K)-9:)E?')(?O=)?)(%?&'K).(P>)?)@&()&'E9'F='&='(K)-9:)E?')(?O=)?)@:>D)<;&E;)&>)%=?CCG)&'E9'F='&='(K

-9:)E9:CM)YGD)@:()N9>()?&%C&'=>)G9:);?M)(9)YGD)G9:PM)A%9@?@CG)YG)Z?'E;=>(=%)(9)\;&E?L9K)3;=')\;&E?L9)9F=%)(9

U?C(&N9%=K)-9:)N&L;()(?O=)]=C(?K).()<9:CM)(?O=)?CC)M?GK)/9)(;=G)>?&MD)̂7=(P>)YG)A9&'()(9)A9&'(K)7=(P>)B'M)(;9>=

E&(&=>D)?'M)YG)A9&'()(9)A9&'(D)@=E?:>=)(;?(P>)N9%=)E9'F='&='(K)$=9AC=)?E(:?CCG)<9:CM)%?(;=%)YG)A9&'()(9)A9&'(K

U:()<=)<?'()(9)O==A)&()%=C?(&F=CG)E;=?AK̂

09<)(;?(P>)?);?%M)>(%?(=LG)(9)A:CC)9_D)@=E?:>=)G9:)?>O)G9:%>=CHD)̂5;G)M&M'P()9(;=%)?&%C&'=>)M9)(;?([̂)3;=)%=?>9'

(;?(P>)?)%=?CCG);?%M)>(%?(=LG)(9)A:CC)9_D)&>)?)E9N@&'?(&9')9H)?&%AC?'=>)?%=)=SA='>&F=K)3;=G)M=A%=E&?(=)%?A&MCGK

3;=)A%9@C=N)&>D)&H)G9:)YG)>;9%();?:C>)(9)E&(&=>)(;?()?%='P()A?%(&E:C?%CG)@&LD)G9:);?F=)?):(&C&W?(&9')A%9@C=NK)-9:

;?F=)(;&>)F=%G)=SA='>&F=)?>>=(D)(;?()>A='M>)'9()N:E;)(&N=)YG&'LD)@:()?)C9()9H)(&N=)9')(;=)L%9:'MK

.H)G9:%)>(%?(=LG)&>)E9'F='&='E=D)G9:)<?'()(9)YG)?)C9()9H)Y&L;(>K)-9:)M9'P()<?'()(9)M9)9'=)Y&L;()?)M?GD)H%9N)>?GD

Z?'E;=>(=%D)0=<)4?NA>;&%=)(9)U?C(&N9%=K)-9:)<?'()(9)M9)>=F=')Y&L;(>K)5=CC)(;9>=)?%='P()@&L)E&(&=>D)>9)'9<

G9:)%=?CCG);?F=)?):(&C&W?(&9')A%9@C=ND)?'M)G9:)L9()?CC)(;&>)=SA='>&F=)E?A&(?CK)3;?(P>)<;G)=F=%G@9MG)=C>=)M&M);:@

?'M)>A9O=K)5=)@?(E;)G9:):AK)5=)(?O=)G9:)H%9N)AC?E=>)C&O=)Z?'E;=>(=%D)?'M)$%9F&M='E=D)?'M)/G%?E:>=D)?'M)<=

YG)G9:)&'(9)\;&E?L9K)3;=')<=)%=M&>(%&@:(=)G9:K)5=)E?')N?O=)@=((=%):>=)9H)9:%)E?A&(?CK)U:()(;=G)E;?'L=M)(;=

=E9'9N&E>)9H)(;=)@:>&'=>>)(;%9:L;)(;=&%)9A=%?(&9'>)>(%?(=LGD)<;&E;)&>D)(;=G)H9E:>=M)F=%G);=?FG)9')(;=)(:%'

?%9:'M)(&N=K

.H)G9:)C99O=M)?()(;=)?&%C&'=)&'M:>(%GD)(;=)?F=%?L=)(&N=)&()(?O=>)(9)(:%')?%9:'M)?)AC?'=D)H%9N)(;=)(&N=)&()L9=>)&(

L9=>)&'(9)?)L?(=D)(9)(;=)(&N=)&()L9=>)9:(D)&>)IQ)N&':(=>K)09<)IQ)N&':(=>D)&H)G9:)(;&'O)?@9:()&(D)&>)(;?()?)C9'L

(&N=[)5=CCD)&()M=A='M>K).H)G9:P%=)/&'L?A9%=)+&%C&'=>D)(;=)?F=%?L=)Y&L;()C='L(;)9')/&'L?A9%=)+&%C&'=>)&>)>=F=')?'M

?);?CH);9:%>K)/9)IQ)N&':(=>)&>)'9()?)C9'L)(&N=)H9%)(;?()A&=E=)9H)E?A&(?C)(9)@=)9')(;=)L%9:'MD)@=H9%=)&()L=(>):A

?'M)Y&=>)(9)?'9(;=%)C9E?(&9'K).H)G9:%)?F=%?L=)Y&L;()C='L(;D)<;&E;)H9%)/9:(;<=>()&>)?@9:()?');9:%)?'M)?);?CHD)IQ

N&':(=>)&>)?)C9'L)(&N=K)-9:PF=)̀:>()<&A=M)9:()aQb)9H)G9:%):(&C&W?(&9')9H)(;=)?>>=()%&L;()(;=%=K)3;=')'9()=F=%G

>=?()&>)BCC=MD)>9)G9:P%=)C9>&'L)N9%=):(&C&W?(&9'K

U:()@G)%=M:E&'L)(;=)(:%'?%9:'M)(&N=D)(;=G)%=M:E=M)(;=&%)(:%'?@9:()(&N=)(9)JQ)N&':(=>D)(;?()<?>)?)E9%=)A?%()9H

(;=&%)>(%?(=LGK)/9)@G)M9&'L)&(D)&H)G9:)(;&'O)?@9:()9F=%)>=F=')Y&L;(>)?)M?G)(;?()G9:)L=()9')(;?()O&'M)9H)C='L(;D)G9:

L=()9'=)=S(%?)Y&L;()A=%)M?GK),&L;(D)@=E?:>=)&H)G9:P%=)O&'M)9H)A&EO&'L):A)?@9:()JQ)N&':(=>)A=%K)UG)(;=)='M)9H)(;=

M?GD)G9:PF=)L9()='9:L;)(&N=)(9)L=()&')9'=)N9%=)Y&L;(K

���������� ��� ��� �

��� ����������� ������������� ������������������ ��� � ������� � � ����!� ������ � "� ����� ��#

$%&'()*(+,'*'-%./01(102'3415'*,,1(6'78-1'2%9+:1';%9<)('()1'*=>/0*81?'=(+,'51/>1-=*(=8<6'@)1'%802'.*><=8*0'-%,(

%A'*'B=<)('=,'()1'A910?'&)=-)'=,'*;%9('CDE'%A'()1'(%(*0'%/1>*(=8<'-%,(6'@)1'->1&'=,',*0*>26'@)12+>1'()1>1?';*,=-*002

*82&*26'F'.1*8?'()1>1+,'8%('*'0%('%A'.*><=8*0'-%,(6'F(+,'*'34'*,,1(6'@)%,1',1*(,'*>1',=((=8<'()1>16'FA'2%9'<1('%81

14(>*'B=<)('/1>'5*2?'*00'()*('>1:1891'<%1,',(>*=<)('(%'()1';%((%.'0=816

G)18'F'(1*-)'()=,'-*,1'&=()'.2'HIJ,?'2%9'-*8',)%&'()1=>'18(=>1'/>%3(*;=0=(2?'21*>'*A(1>'21*>?'=,'=8'()*('%81

14(>*'B=<)('/1>'5*26'@)*(+,'&)2'()12+>1'/>%3(*;016'K%9'-*8'*-(9*002'(>*-1'=('(%'()*('%81'14(>*'B=<)('/1>'5*2?'/1>

/0*81?'=,'()1'5=L1>18-1';1(&118';1=8<':1>2'/>%3(*;01?'*85'8%(';1=8<'/>%3(*;01'*('*006'$%&?')%&'5=5'()12'5%

()*(M'I1-*9,1'=(+,'%81'()=8<'(%',*2?'NK1*)?'%9>',(>*(1<2'=,'(9>8*>%985'(=.16N'O%&'5%'2%9'141-9(1'()*(M'O%&'5%

2%9'141-9(1'()*(M'G100?'*('P%9()&1,(?'=(+,'()>%9<)'*'&)%01',2,(1.'%A'-)%=-1,6

Q9=-R'(9>8'%--9>,?'8%(';1-*9,1'%A'%81'51-=,=%8?';1-*9,1'%A'*;%9('DS'()=8<,'()12'5%'()*('*>1'*00'A%-9,15'%8

T9=-R'(9>86'P%'1:1>2;%52'R8%&,?'()1',=<8'%:1>'()1'5%%>',*2,'T9=-R'(9>86'P%'8%'.1*0,?'8%'/>1*,,=<815',1*(=8<?

)=,(%>=-*0026'@)*(+,',(*>(=8<'(%'-)*8<16'I9('2%9')*:1'*8'=8-18(=:1'(%'<1('()1>1'1*>026'U801,,'2%9'0=R1'.=5501

,1*(,?'/1%/01'<1('()1>16'@)1'&)%01'=51*'%A'*',(*85*>5'VWV'/0*(A%>.?'2%9')*:1'%81'(9>8*>%985',->=/(6

X:1>2;%52'R8%&,')%&'(%'(9>8*>%985'%81'%A'()%,1'/0*81,6'K%9'5%8+(')*:1'(%'&%>>2'*;%9('666'I1-*9,1'*-(9*002'=(

(9>8,'%9('()*('0%*5=8<'09<<*<1'%8'/0*81,?'*85'F+:1'5%81',%.1'-*,1',(95=1,'=8'()=,'=859,(>2?'()12':*>2

5>*.*(=-*002';2'/0*816'P%'1:1>2()=8<'=,',->=/(156

@)12+:1'->1*(15'*'-90(9>1'&)1>1?'*,'*'&%>R1>'%8'()1'(*>.*-?'=A'2%9'-%.1'9/'&=()'*8'=51*'()*('2%9'()=8R'&=00

,*:1'CY',1-%85,'A>%.'()1'(9>8*>%985'(=.1?'2%9'/9('=('=8(%'*',9<<1,(=%8';%46'F(+,':=<%>%9,02'*8*02Z15?'0%%R15'*(?

14/1>=.18(15?'*85'()18'()12'>%00'=('%9(6'P%'-%8(=89*0'=./>%:1.18(?'*'0%('%A'()=8<,'()12'5%6'K%9+:1'/>%;*;02

,118'()1=>';*<<*<1'*5,6'@)%,1'&%851>A90'*5,?'NG1'0%:1'2%9>';*<,?'&)2'&%905'&1'-)*8<1'A%>'()1.MN'@)1';=<

;9>02';*<<*<1')*8501>,'*>1'(1*>2'1215'*,'()12+>1'&*:=8<6'G)2'*>1'()12'5%=8<'()*(M'G)2'5%8+('()12'-)*><1'A%>

;*<,M'X:1>2;%52'10,1'=,'-)*><=8<'A%>';*<,6

F8'A*-(?'=A'2%9'()=8R'*;%9('=(?'2%9'-%905'<=:1'0%&1>'A*>1,?'*85'-)*><1'A%>';*<,6'P%.1'/1%/01'&%905';1';1((1>'%L

38*8-=*0026'F'(2/=-*002'5%8+('(>*:10'&=()'*';*<?',%'F+5'>*()1>'<1('*'0%&1>'/>=-1?'*85'01('%()1>'/1%/01'/*2'A%>'()1=>

;*<,6'I9('()=8R'*;%9(?'>1B1-('()1'0*,('(=.1'2%9'&1>1'%8'*8'*=>/0*816'G)*('(%%R'()1'0%8<1,('(%'0%*5'()1

*=>/0*81M'K1*)?'=(+,'/1%/01',)%:=8<'()1=>';*<,'=8'()1'%:1>)1*56

FA'2%9+:1'1:1>';118'%8'666'F'&*,'%8-1'B2=8<'%9('%A'[%85%8?'*;%9('1=<)('21*>,'*<%?'&)18'A%>',1-9>=(2'>1*,%8,?'2%9

&1>1'8%('*00%&15'(%';>=8<'*82'-*>>2%86'F'5%8+('R8%&'=A'*82;%52')*5'()*('14/1>=18-16'F('&*,'*;%9('*'&11R'%>

(&%6'F'<%('%8'*'V\V?'*85'=('(9>8,'%9('=('(*R1,'*;%9('3:1'.=89(1,'(%'0%*5'*'V\V?'=A'8%;%52')*,'*82';*<,6'F'.1*8

()=8R'*;%9('=(?'2%9']9,('<1('%86'K%9'&*0R'%8'()1'/0*816'K%9',=('5%&86'@)*(+,'=(6'WSS'/1%/01'-*8'5%'()*('=8'*;%9(

3:1'.=89(1,6'I9('=A'2%9'(*R1'()%,1'WSS'/1%/01?'*85'1*-)'<=:1'()1.';*<,?'*85'*,'&1'R8%&?',%.1';*<,'*>1';=<?

()18'()12'(*R1'()1.'%L?'()*('R=00,'(9>8*>%9856'$%&'A%>'*'0%('%A'*=>0=81,?'()*(+,'8%('*';=<'51*0?';9('=A'2%9+>1

P%9()&1,(?'()*('-0%-R'=,'(=-R=8<6

F(+,'*'<>1*('14*./01'&)1>1?'5%'2%9'()=8R'()*(+,'*'51-=,=%8'.*51';2'()1'̂X7'*('P%9()&1,(M'_%'2%9'()=8R'()1

X̂7'&*,'.*,(1>.=85=8<'*00'()*(M'J;,%09(102'8%(6'@)1'̂X7')*,'<%('%()1>'()=8<,'(%'5%6'@)1>1+,'/>%;*;02

,%.1;%52'&)%'=,'=8'-)*><1'%A';*<<*<1'/%0=-2?'0=R1'*':=-1'/>1,=518('%A';*<<*<1'/%0=-26'@)*(+,'()1=>']%;?'(%'()=8R

*;%9(';*<<*<1'/%0=-26'$%&'=('&%905';1':1>2'1*,2'A%>',%.1;%52?'F+.',9>1',%.1;%52?',%.1/0*-1'5=5'*

,/>1*5,)11(?'()*(',)%&15')%&'.9-)'14(>*'>1:1891'2%9'-%905'<1(';2'-)*><=8<'A%>';*<,6'̀aS'*';*<?'&1')*:1'()=,

.*82';*<,?'()*(+,'<%=8<'(%';1'<>1*(6

@)*(+,'&)1>1',(>*(1<2'-%.1,'=8(%'/0*26'FA'2%9+:1'<%('*',(>*(1<2?'2%9'9851>,(*85'>=<)('%L'()1';*(?';1A%>1'2%9

1:18'0%%R'*('()1'89.;1>,?'&)1()1>'()*('.*R1,',18,1'%>'8%(6'P%9()&1,(',(>*(1<2'=,'(9>8*;%9(?',%'1:1>2()=8<'=,

30(1>15'*<*=8,(?'N_%1,'()=,')10/'9,'&=()'(9>8*;%9(M'7>'5%1,'=(')9>('9,'&=()'(9>8*>%985MN'@)12'R=85'%A'-%.1'9/

&=()'()*('51-=,=%8?';1-*9,1'()12'()=8R'=(')10/,'()1.'&=()'(9>8*>%9856'b%%5',(>*(1<2'18*;01,'A%0R,'(%'5%'()=8<,

&=()%9('*,R=8<'1:1>2;%52'10,1?'=8'<181>*06'b%%5'%/1>*(=%8',(>*(1<=1,'5%'()*(?';1-*9,1'*<*=8?'()1,1'*>1'*00

51-=,=%8,'()*(')*:1'(%'<1('.*51'=8'0%(,'%A'5=L1>18('/*>(,'%A'()1'%><*8=Z*(=%86'P%'()*(+,'*'R=85'%A')=<)'01:10':=1&?

*,'(%'()1'1,,18-1'%A'&)*('%/1>*(=%8',(>*(1<2'=,'*;%9(6

���������� ��� ��� �

��� ����������� ������������� ������������������ ��� � ������� � � ����!� ������ � "� ����� #�#

$��� ��%� ���%�%������&�%����� %�����'���� %#��%$��� ��