Social Science ASSIGNMENT 2 - THEORY
Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at https://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=wshc20
Social Work in Health Care
ISSN: 0098-1389 (Print) 1541-034X (Online) Journal homepage: https://www.tandfonline.com/loi/wshc20
Technology-Based Interventions in Social Work Practice: A Systematic Review of Mental Health Interventions
Alex T. Ramsey & Katherine Montgomery
To cite this article: Alex T. Ramsey & Katherine Montgomery (2014) Technology-Based Interventions in Social Work Practice: A Systematic Review of Mental Health Interventions, Social Work in Health Care, 53:9, 883-899, DOI: 10.1080/00981389.2014.925531
To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/00981389.2014.925531
Published online: 16 Oct 2014.
Submit your article to this journal
Article views: 2290
View related articles
View Crossmark data
Citing articles: 15 View citing articles
Social Work in Health Care, 53:883–899, 2014 Copyright © Taylor & Francis Group, LLC ISSN: 0098-1389 print/1541-034X online DOI: 10.1080/00981389.2014.925531
Technology-Based Interventions in Social Work Practice: A Systematic Review of Mental Health
Interventions
ALEX T. RAMSEY, PhD, and KATHERINE MONTGOMERY, PhD, MSSW
Center for Mental Health Services Research, Brown School of Social Work, Washington University in St. Louis, St. Louis, Missouri, USA
Despite concerns around the use of technology-based interven- tions, they are increasingly being employed by social workers as a direct practice methodology to address the mental health needs of vulnerable clients. Researchers have highlighted the importance of using innovative technologies within social work practice, yet little has been done to summarize the evidence and collectively assess findings. In this systematic review, we describe accounts of technology-based mental health interventions delivered by social workers over the past 10 years. Results highlight the impacts of these tools and summarize advantages and disadvantages to utilizing technologies as a method for delivering or facilitating interventions.
KEYWORDS technology, mental health, interventions, social work practice, access to care
INTRODUCTION
The field of social work has long been identified as a profession that empha- sizes personal, client-centered relationships, and social workers have been relatively resistant to the advent of technology-based tools used for ther- apeutic purposes (Parker-Oliver & Demiris, 2006; Parrott & Madoc-Jones, 2008). Traditional approaches to social work mental health practice have
Received March 31, 2014; accepted May 14, 2014. Address correspondence to Alex T. Ramsey, PhD, Center for Mental Health Services
Research, Brown School of Social Work, Washington University in St. Louis, One Brookings Drive, Campus Box 1196, St. Louis, MO 63130. E-mail: [email protected]
883
884 A. T. Ramsey and K. Montgomery
highlighted the risks associated with the integration of technology into social work practice, citing concerns related to confidentiality, client trust, and depersonalization (Parker-Oliver & Demiris, 2006). As a result, there has been slower movement towards the actual implementation of innova- tive technology-based approaches in social work practice that meet clients’ mental health needs (Parker-Oliver & Demiris, 2006). However, there is growing evidence that technological tools can allow for increased access and availability, greater anonymity and avoidance of stigma, extended care interventions outside the bounds of a social worker’s office, and enhanced communication between the client and social worker (Barak & Grohol, 2011; Mohr, Burns, Schueller, Clarke, & Klinkman, 2013). Parrott and Madoc-Jones (2008) challenge the limited use of technology for basic monitoring and managerial purposes, and instead have underscored the potential benefits of information and communication technologies that may empower clients and address social and economic isolation. Therapeutic uses of technology in a social work context are varied, including online counseling, self-guided Web- based interventions, videoconferencing with a social worker, virtual reality software, electronic social networks, e-mail, and text messaging (Reamer, 2013). Regardless of agency policy or therapist preferences, clients are realizing a wide array of options and associated advantages to receiving services through ubiquitous technologies (Mishna, Bogo, Root, Sawyer, & Khoury-Kassabri, 2012).
More recently, some efforts have been made to both emphasize and harness the power of the Internet to provide ongoing professional education and dissemination of evidence-based findings for social workers and mental health practitioners (Holden, Barker, Rosenberg, & Cohen, 2012; Holden et al., 2012; Powers, Bowen, & Bowen, 2011). Despite increasing consumer demand for using technologies in therapeutic ways, however, the field of social work continues to question the appropriateness of technology-based interventions as a direct practice methodology (Mattison, 2012). Much conceptual discussion has ensued with regard to benefits and risks asso- ciated with including technology as a method for delivering or facilitating social work practice interventions (Brownlee, Graham, Doucette, Hotson, & Halverson, 2010; Wodarski & Frimpong, 2013). For instance, Kimball and Kim (2013) raise important ethical considerations associated with the use of social media in social work practice. Mishna and colleagues (2012), however, contend that the infiltration of technology into social work practice is inevitable, urging social workers to focus their efforts on anticipating ethical and legal dilemmas and utilizing technology-based interventions in appropriate ways that preserve therapeutic relationships. For those who are open to the inclusion of technology in social work practice, there remains considerable debate regarding whether technology should be implemented as a supplement to or substitute for traditional face-to-face approaches (Barak & Grohol, 2011; Wodarski & Frimpong, 2013). Indeed, the struggle
Technology in Social Work Practice 885
to understand the appropriate role of technology in enhancing social work practice is still in its infancy.
Amid the debate and slow adoption, social workers and mental health therapists are beginning to use novel, technology-based methods (e.g., videoconferencing, Web-based interventions) in their practice with patients (e.g., Menon & Rubin, 2011). However, very few authors have summarized these efforts, and less is known about the empirical evidence associated with social workers’ involvement in interventions that use technology as a means to provide services to vulnerable clients. In fact, to our knowledge this research represents the first systematic review of published studies examin- ing the use of technology-based interventions within social work practice. In this systematic review, we describe accounts of the implementation of technology among social workers over the past 10 years, assess the reported clinical and experiential impacts of these tools, and summarize advantages and disadvantages to utilizing technologies as a method for delivering or facilitating social work interventions. In doing so, this study both evaluates the current state of technology-based interventions within social work prac- tice and highlights knowledge gaps that call for further empirical research and practice-based evidence.
METHOD
Inclusion Criteria
To be included in this review, studies: (a) quantitatively and/or qualita- tively assessed an intervention that used some form of technology to deliver and/or enhance the delivery of an intervention; (b) explicitly included a social worker in treatment delivery; (c) examined the impact of the interven- tion with at least one mental health outcome; (d) were reported in journal articles published between 2004 and 2013; and (e) were conducted in the United States.
Search Process
To identify the most appropriate articles relevant to social work and men- tal health interventions, the following academic databases were searched through EBSCO: Academic Search Complete, Academic Search Premier, ERIC, PsycINFO, CINAHL, CINAHL Plus, PsycARTICLES, MEDLINE, Social Work Abstracts, and PsycCRITIQUES. Three search strings were utilized:
1. social work, AND 2. practice OR therapy OR intervention OR treatment, AND
886 A. T. Ramsey and K. Montgomery
3. technology OR cybertherapy OR computer OR Internet OR mHealth OR m-Health OR eHealth OR e-Health OR mobile phone OR web-based OR electronic OR teleconference OR telehealth OR email OR e-mail.
The search revealed 5,289 for the initial screening of abstracts (see Figure 1). Eighty-seven full articles were assessed and resulted in six articles that reported on five studies for the final inclusion.
Data Extraction and Coding Procedures
Two reviewers independently screened all of the full articles for inclusion. Results were compared, and the reviewers were found to have 91% agree- ment. Discrepancies were discussed and resolved. For the full coding stage, a coding document was developed to identify and extract sample descriptors,
Articles identified through initial search
(n = 5,289)
Abstracts screened for eligibility
(n = 2546)
Full articles screened for inclusion
(n = 87)
Duplicates removed
(n = 2,743)
Articles deemed ineligible
(n = 2,459)
Articles deemed ineligible
(n = 81)
Studies included in the final review and synthesis
(n = 6)
FIGURE 1 Screening flow chart.
Technology in Social Work Practice 887
treatment descriptors, research methodology, and mental health and imple- mentation measures. Two reviewers independently coded all final included articles. Results were compared (76% agreement), and all discrepancies were discussed and resolved. The kappa statistic was not calculated, as it has been found to be less meaningful (Higgins & Deeks, 2008). For example, it is likely that inter-rater reliability would be lower for reviews of articles with poor methodology. For this reason, The Cochrane Collaboration rec- ommends that the double coding process and resolution of discrepancies is necessary, while the calculation of the kappa statistic is not.
RESULTS
Design and Sample
Over half (n = 3) of the studies employed a mix of qualitative and quantita- tive methodologies (see Table 1). The quantitative study designs ranged from one-group posttest (n = 1) to pretest/posttest (n = 2), repeated measures (n = 1), and a randomized controlled trial (n = 1). Intensive interviews (n = 1), responses to open-ended questions (n = 1), and content analysis meth- ods (n = 1) were used to gather qualitative data. The majority of sample sizes were generally small, as four of the five studies included 30 or fewer participants. Only one of the studies used a comparison group in their study design, and none of the articles reported on follow-up data.
Most of the studies were conducted with adults (n = 4), with an average age range from 29.2 to 76. One study was conducted with only youth, and another study included both adolescents and adults in the eligibility criteria (age 14 and above). It was unknown, however, if Rotondi and colleagues (2005) included adolescents in the final sample. With the exception of one study, most samples included participants who were primarily Caucasian males. The eligibility criteria to participate in the studies were quite var- ied: specific mental health diagnoses (such as anxiety, schizophrenia, and schizoaffective disorders), hospice caregivers, adults who were enrolled in a drug court program, or participants involved in a voluntary sexual offender self-help group.
Intervention Characteristics and Mental Health Outcomes
As indicated in Table 2, two of the interventions were delivered online to a group. For the two individually delivered interventions, one was adminis- tered via CD-ROM on a computer within a community mental health center, and the other was delivered primarily through the use of a videophone. It was unclear the format through which the fifth intervention was deliv- ered. Two interventions were manualized: Camp Cope-A-Lot (a cognitive behavioral therapy intervention) and the psychoeducational group therapy.
TA B
LE 1
D es
ig n , Sa
m p le
, an
d Se
tt in
g C h ar
ac te
ri st
ic s
C ita
tio n s
St u d y
m et
h o d o lo
gy St
u d y
d es
ig n
N C o n tr o l
gr o u p
Fo llo
w -u
p P ar
tic ip
an ts
P ar
tic ip
an t el
ig ib
ili ty
Lo ca
tio n
o f
in te
rv en
tio n
C ra
w fo
rd et
al .,
20 13
Q u an
tit at
iv e
P re
te st
/ P o st
te st
17 n o
n o
M ea
n A
ge 10
.1 R
a ce 76
% C au
ca si
an 12
% H
is p an
ic 12
% O
th er
G en
d er
70 .6
% M
al e
A n xi
et y
d is
o rd
er d ia
gn o si
s Fl
o ri d a
C ru
n ki
lto n
et al
., 20
08 an
d C ru
n ki
lto n ,
20 09
M ix
ed M
et h o d s
“I n te
n si
ve in
te rv
ie w
s” an
d O
n e-
gr o u p
p o st
te st
10 n o
n o
M ea
n A
ge 29
.2 R
a ce 80
% C au
ca si
an 20
% A
fr ic
an A
m er
ic an
G en
d er
60 %
M al
e
A d u lts
en ro
lle d
in a
D ru
g C o u rt
P ro
gr am
M ed
iu m
-s iz
ed ci
ty in
So u th
ea st
er n
U .S
.
K er
n sm
ith et
al .,
20 08
M ix
ed M
et h o d s
C o n te
n t A
n al
ys is
P re
te st
/ P o st
te st
86 n o
n o
M ea
n A
ge U
n kn
o w
n R
a ce U n kn
o w
n G
en d
er 81
% M
al e
P ar
tic ip
an ts
o f a
se lf -h
el p
gr o u p
(m o st
h ad
se xu
al ly
o ff en
d ed
ag ai
n st
o n e
o r
m o re
ch ild
re n )
U n kn
o w
n
(C on
ti n
u ed
)
888
TA B
LE 1
(C o n tin
u ed
)
C ita
tio n s
St u d y
m et
h o d o lo
gy St
u d y
d es
ig n
N C o n tr o l
gr o u p
Fo llo
w -u
p P ar
tic ip
an ts
P ar
tic ip
an t el
ig ib
ili ty
Lo ca
tio n
o f
in te
rv en
tio n
P ar
ke r-
O liv
er et
al .,
20 06
Q u an
tit at
iv e
R ep
ea te
d M
ea su
re s
2 n o
n o
M ea
n A
ge 76
R a
ce U n kn
o w
n G
en d
er 10
0% M
al e
H o sp
ic e
ca re
gi ve
r (f
am ily
m em
b er
) R u ra
l ar
ea in
M is
so u ri
R o to
n d i et
al .,
20 05
M ix
ed M
et h o d s
R an
d o m
iz ed
C o n tr o lle
d T ri al
O p en
-E n d ed
Q u es
tio n s
30 ye
s n o
M ea
n A
ge 35
.7 R
a ce 47
% C au
ca si
an 47
% A
fr ic
an A
m er
ic an
6% O
th er
G en
d er
30 %
M al
e
Sc h iz
o p h re
n ia
o r
Sc h iz
o af
fe ct
iv e
d is
o rd
er d ia
gn o si
s; A
ge 14
o r
o ld
er ; O
n e
o r
m o re
re ce
n t
h o sp
ita liz
at io
n s;
E n gl
is h -s
p ea
ki n g;
A b se
n ce
o f p h ys
ic al
lim ita
tio n s
th at
w o u ld
in te
rf er
e w
ith u se
o f a
co m
p u te
r
P itt
sb u rg
h , PA
889
TA B
LE 2
In te
rv en
tio n
C h ar
ac te
ri st
ic s
an d
M en
ta l H
ea lth
O u tc
o m
es
C ita
tio n s
N am
e o f
in te
rv en
tio n
M an
u al
So ci
al w
o rk
er ro
le O
th er
se rv
ic e
p ro
vi d er
s T ra
in in
g in
in te
rv en
tio n
T re
at m
en t
fo rm
at T re
at m
en t
se tt in
g D
u ra
tio n
o f
tr ea
tm en
t M
en ta
l h ea
lth o u tc
o m
es Im
p le
m en
ta tio
n o u tc
o m
es P ri m
ar y
re su
lts
C ra
w fo
rd et
al .,
20 13
C am
p C o p e-
A -L
o t
(C o m
p u te
r- b as
ed an
d co
m p u te
r as
si st
ed C B T )
Y es
T h er
ap is
ts w
h o
w er
e n o t ve
ry fa
m ili
ar w
ith C B T
N / A
2 d ay
tr ai
n in
g an
d w
ee kl
y su
p er
vi si
o n
Y o u th
an d
p ro
vi d er
P ar
en ts
an d
p ro
vi d er
M en
ta l H
ea lth
C en
te r
12 w
ee kl
y 50
m in
u te
se ss
io n s
A n xi
et y,
gl o b al
p sy
ch o p at
h y,
d ep
re ss
io n ,
in te
rn al
iz in
g an
d ex
te rn
al iz
in g
sy m
p to
m s
A cc
ep ta
b ili
ty an
d fe
as ib
ili ty
Si gn
ifi ca
n t
re d u ct
io n s
in an
xi et
y o u tc
o m
es .
C ru
n ki
lto n
et al
., 20
08 an
d C ru
n ki
lto n ,
20 09
D ru
g C o u rt
Jo u rn
ey M
ap p in
g
N o
N o t cl
ea r
(m ay
h av
e fa
ci lit
at ed
Jo u rn
ey M
ap p in
g en
tr y)
D ru
g C o u rt
tr ea
tm en
t p ro
gr am
d ir ec
to r
U n kn
o w
n A d u lts
an d
te ch
n o lo
gy (p
ro vi
d er
in vo
lv em
en t
is u n cl
ea r)
C o u n ty
D ru
g C o u rt
T re
at m
en t
Fa ci
lit y
A n
av er
ag e
o f
3. 1
se ss
io n s
O ve
ra ll
w el
l- b ei
n g
N o n e
E n h an
ce d
cl ie
n t’s
w el
l- b ei
n g
an d
tr ea
tm en
t p ro
gr es
s.
K er
n sm
ith et
al .,
20 08
O n lin
e Se
lf -H
el p
G ro
u p
N o
P ar
tic ip
at ed
in an
d o b se
rv ed
gr o u p
G ro
u p
fa ci
lit at
o rs
w h o
w er
e re
co ve
ri n g
o ff en
d er
s
U n kn
o w
n G
ro u p s
o f
ad u lts
an d
p ro
vi d er
U n kn
o w
n U
n kn
o w
n C o gn
iti ve
d is
to rt io
n s,
o b se
ss iv
e an
d co
m p u ls
iv e
th o u gh
ts
N o n e
Si gn
ifi ca
n t
d ec
re as
e in
co gn
iti ve
d is
to rt io
n s,
co m
p u ls
io n s,
an d
o b se
ss io
n s.
H ig
h er
u se
o f
se lf -h
el p
gr o u p
w as
si gn
ifi ca
n tly
as so
ci at
ed w
ith o u tc
o m
e b en
efi ts
.
(C on
ti n
u ed
)
890
TA B
LE 2
(C o n tin
u ed
)
C ita
tio n s
N am
e o f
in te
rv en
tio n
M an
u al
So ci
al w
o rk
er ro
le O
th er
se rv
ic e
p ro
vi d er
s T ra
in in
g in
in te
rv en
tio n
T re
at m
en t
fo rm
at T re
at m
en t
se tt in
g D
u ra
tio n
o f
tr ea
tm en
t M
en ta
l h ea
lth o u tc
o m
es Im
p le
m en
ta tio
n o u tc
o m
es P ri m
ar y
re su
lts
P ar
ke r-
O liv
er et
al , 20
06 Te
le h o sp
ic e
C ar
e N
o R ec
ru it
ca re
gi ve
rs ,
tr ai
n ca
re gi
ve rs
in te
ch n o lo
gy u se
, an
d ad
m in
is te
r as
se ss
m en
t in
st ru
m en
ts d u ri n g
o n go
in g
w o rk
w ith
ca re
gi ve
rs
G ra
d u at
e re
se ar
ch as
si st
an t an
d h o sp
ic e
n u rs
e
Y es
, b u t d o es
n o t st
at e
h o w
m u ch
tr ai
n in
g w
as p ro
vi d ed
A d u lts
an d
p ro
vi d er
H o sp
ic e
p at
ie n t’s
h o m
e
U n kn
o w
n A n xi
et y
an d
q u al
ity o f lif
e A cc
ep ta
b ili
ty an
d fe
as ib
ili ty
C ar
eg iv
er s
w er
e ge
n er
al ly
sa tis
fi ed
w ith
in te
rv en
tio n .
T h er
e w
er e
n o
o u tc
o m
es d if fe
re n ce
s.
R o to
n d i et
al .,
20 05
P sy
ch o -
ed u ca
tio n
G ro
u p
T h er
ap y
Sc h iz
o p h re
n ia
G u id
e w
eb si
te
Y es
Fa ci
lit at
ed G
ro u p
T h er
ap y
N / A
Y es
, b u t d o es
n o t st
at e
h o w
m u ch
tr ai
n in
g w
as p ro
vi d ed
A d u lts
an d
p ro
vi d er
Y o u th
an d
p ro
vi d er
P sy
ch ia
tr ic
R eh
ab ili
ta tio
n C en
te rs
U n kn
o w
n St
re ss
A cc
ep ta
b ili
ty Fe
as ib
ili ty
P ar
tic ip
an ts
in th
e tr ea
tm en
t gr
o u p
w ith
Sc h iz
o p h re
n ia
re p o rt ed
si gn
ifi ca
n tly
lo w
er le
ve ls
o f st
re ss
.
891
892 A. T. Ramsey and K. Montgomery
Both of these interventions were delivered by a licensed social worker and were considered to be evidence-based interventions. Although the social workers recruited in Parker-Oliver, Demiris, Day, Courtney, and Porock’s (2006) study were intended to have high involvement in the delivery of services, they noted that the social workers were resistant to participate. Social workers in the remaining two studies (Crunkilton & Robinson, 2008; Crunkilton 2009; Kernsmith & Kernsmith, 2008) seemed to provide fewer services. With the exception of one study (Crawford et al., 2013), the extent to which providers were trained in the intervention and specific duration of the treatment was not clear. Four studies reported on services that were delivered in different settings: mental health center, county drug court treat- ment facility, hospice patient’s home, and psychiatric rehabilitation centers. Several mental health outcomes were assessed, but the majority of stud- ies (n = 3) reported on outcomes associated with anxiety symptoms (e.g., stress, obsessive and compulsive thoughts, and general anxiety). Although one study reported no differences in mental health outcomes (Kernsmith & Kernsmith, 2008), most reported empirically or clinically significant ben- efits. In addition, over half (n = 3) reported on implementation outcomes associated with acceptability and feasibility of the intervention.
Use of Technology
Almost all (n = 4) interventions required the use of a computer, three of which also required Internet (see Table 3). The use of technology played a central role in the delivery of all (n = 5) interventions. However, it was largely unclear the extent to which implementers were trained in using the technologies. The use of the technology was generally positive across most (n = 4) of the studies, and several benefits were noted by authors. One of the key benefits across studies was improved accessibility and support that would otherwise not have been received. Although privacy and confidential- ity was considered a benefit in one study (Kernsmith & Kernsmith, 2008), it was a potential barrier in another study (Rotondi et al., 2005). Other key bar- riers included the need to have access to the technology and some difficulty around client use of the technology.
DISCUSSION
The advent of behavioral health interventions delivered or facilitated by information and communication technology is increasingly evident for many conditions, including alcohol and substance abuse, diabetes management, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and insomnia (Lovell & Bee, 2011; Mohr et al., 2013; Staton-Tindall, Wahler, Webster, Godlaski, Freeman, & Leukefeld, 2012). Interestingly, our systematic review yielded only six empirical articles
TA B
LE 3
U se
o f Te
ch n o lo
gy
C ita
tio n s
T yp
es o f
te ch
n o lo
gy u se
P ri m
ar y
co m
p o n en
t o f p ra
ct ic
e b ei
n g
d el
iv er
ed o r
fa ci
lit at
ed b y
te ch
n o lo
gy
W er
e im
p le
m en
te rs
tr ai
n ed
in u si
n g
te ch
n o lo
gy P ri m
ar y
b en
efi ts
u si
n g
te ch
n o lo
gy B
ar ri er
s u si
n g
te ch
n o lo
gy
G en
er al
co n cl
u si
o n s
ab o u t
te ch
n o lo
gy
C ra
w fo
rd et
al .,
20 13
C o m
p u te
r T h er
ap y
se ss
io n s
U n kn
o w
n •R
el ia
b le
d el
iv er
y o f
E B
Is , ea
sy to
tr ai
n p ro
vi d er
s, ef
fe ct
iv en
es s
•D o es
n o t al
lo w
fo r
fl ex
ib ili
ty in
se ss
io n
lo ca
tio n
(e .g
., cl
ie n t’s
h o m
e)
P o si
tiv e
C ru
n ki
lto n
et al
., 20
08 an
d C ru
n ki
lto n , 20
09
C o m
p u te
r In
te rn
et N
ar ra
tiv e
th er
ap eu
tic ad
d iti
o n
to D
ru g
C o u rt
tr ea
tm en
t
U n kn
o w
n •R
ec o rd
in g
o n go
in g
cl ie
n t p ro
gr es
s an
d fe
ed b ac
k
•D ru
g C o u rt
m u st
h av
e co
m p u te
rs an
d In
te rn
et
P o si
tiv e
•U se
fu ln
es s
as a
p ro
gr am
ev al
u at
io n
to o l
•F ac
ili ta
te d
in fo
rm at
io n
ex ch
an ge
an d
le ar
n in
g
•P ro
gr am
st af
f m
u st
b e
co m
m itt
ed to
th e
te ch
n o lo
gy -b
as ed
in te
rv en
tio n
K er
n sm
ith et
al , 20
08 C o m
p u te
r In
te rn
et Se
lf -H
el p
G ro
u p
U n kn
o w
n •P
ri va
cy •C
o n fi d en
tia l ac
ce ss
to h el
p •A
b ili
ty fo
r m
an y
to jo
in an
d n o t n ee
d to
b e
o n lin
e at
th e
sa m
e tim
e
•B ec
au se
th e
gr o u p
w as
co n d u ct
ed th
ro u gh
p o st
s (a
n d
n o t liv
e in
te ra
ct io
n ),
p ar
tic ip
an ts
co u ld
n o t re
ce iv
e im
m ed
ia te
cr is
is su
p p o rt
P o si
tiv e
(C on
ti n
u ed
)
893
TA B
LE 3
(C o n tin
u ed
)
C ita
tio n s
T yp
es o f
te ch
n o lo
gy u se
P ri m
ar y
co m
p o n en
t o f p ra
ct ic
e b ei
n g
d el
iv er
ed o r
fa ci
lit at
ed b y
te ch
n o lo
gy
W er
e im
p le
m en
te rs
tr ai
n ed
in u si
n g
te ch
n o lo
gy P ri m
ar y
b en
efi ts
u si
n g
te ch
n o lo
gy B
ar ri er
s u si
n g
te ch
n o lo
gy
G en
er al
co n cl
u si
o n s
ab o u t
te ch
n o lo
gy
P ar
ke r-
O liv
er et
al .,
20 06
V id
eo p h o n e
H o sp
ic e
ca re
an d
as se
ss m
en t
U n kn
o w
n •P
ro vi
d ed
ca re
gi ve
r su
p p o rt
to th
o se
o th
er w
is e
u n ab
le to
re ce
iv e
it
•P o te
n tia
lly se
en as
a b u rd
en to
p at
ie n ts
in tim
es o f cr
is is
•P at
ie n ts
’l ac
k o f
ed u ca
tio n
in vi
d eo
p h o n e
u se
•D if fi cu
lty fo
r st
af f
re ga
rd in
g tim
e re
q u ir em
en ts
, co
m fo
rt w
ith u si
n g
th e
te ch
n o lo
gy , an
d co
m fo
rt w
ith th
e re
se ar
ch p ro
ce ss
.
M ix
ed
R o to
n d i et
al .,
20 05
In te
rn et
C o m
p u te
rs W
eb -b
as ed
th er
ap y
gr o u p
Sc h iz
o p h re
n ia
G u id
e so
ft w
ar e
P sy
ch o -e
d u ca
tio n al
gr o u p
th er
ap y
Y es
, b u t d o es
n o t
st at
e h o w
m u ch
tr ai
n in
g w
as p ro
vi d ed
•I t w
as p er
ce iv
ed to
b e
va lu
ab le
, ea
sy to
u se
, an
d re
d u ce
d st
re ss
an d
lo n el
in es
s •C
o n ve
n ie
n t ac
ce ss
to p sy
ch o ed
u ca
tio n al
m at
er ia
ls
•C o gn
iti ve
lim ita
tio n s
o f p eo
p le
w ith
sc h iz
o p h re
n ia
•A cc
es si
b ili
ty is
su es
fo r
p eo
p le
w ith
o u t
co m
p u te
rs an
d In
te rn
et •D
if fi cu
lty u si
n g
w eb
si te
s •C
o n ce
rn s
w ith
co n fi d en
tia lit
y an
d p ri va
cy
P o si
tiv e
894
Technology in Social Work Practice 895
reporting on five technology-based interventions in social work direct prac- tice. The infiltration of technology into the broad mental health arena has progressed at a fairly deliberate pace (Mohr et al., 2013); however, this find- ing may suggest that the adoption of such tools specifically for social work practice is occurring even more gradually. Furthermore, given that our lit- erature search yielded only one published study since 2009 that met the current criteria, there seems to be little indication that efforts in this area are developing more rapidly in recent years. This may speak to social work values of client trust and personal relationships and, relatedly, caution, and skepticism toward innovative changes that could jeopardize these principles (Parker-Oliver & Demiris, 2006). Compared to the medical field, the rele- vance of new technological innovations to social work practice may be less obvious, perhaps suppressing increased interest in this area. However, the recently concluded 22nd National Institute of Mental Health Conference on Mental Health Services Research focused on “learning mental health care systems” and in particular, the promise and potential of technology to trans- form mental health care. This may serve to catalyze increased attention to technology-based mental health interventions within the field of social work practice. In any case, the current results call for more empirical research into the ethical, interpersonal, and mental health implications of integrating technology-based methods into social work interventions.
Despite only five studies being identified, the content and target pop- ulation of the technology-based interventions spanned widely, including manualized computer-based cognitive behavioral therapy to treat childhood anxiety, online self-help groups to manage recovery in sex offending adults, and videophone hospice care support for senior caregivers. Additionally, the treatment settings and primary components delivered varied substantially, further supporting previous findings that technology-based interventions can be applied in-home or in-office to enhance virtually the entire con- tinuum of care, including client assessment, psychoeducation, self-managed care, client–provider communication, and direct treatment (Lord et al., 2011; Marsch & Gustafson, 2013; Preziosa, Grassi, Gaggioli, & Riva, 2009). As evi- denced in this review, technology can extend the reach of care for social workers trained in a particular intervention, and may help social workers provide evidence-based care with higher fidelity. Further research is needed to better understand circumstances in which technology can be used to sub- stitute traditional provider-based care or more appropriately as a supplement to or extension of face-to-face therapy.
The largely positive reports on anxiety and well-being outcomes are encouraging, but should not be perceived as conclusive, particularly for the range of mental health outcomes. Corroborating findings from this review, the efficacy of computer-assisted interventions on anxiety symptoms has been documented in a previous meta-analysis outside the field of social work (Cuijpers et al., 2009). This review should motivate social work researchers
896 A. T. Ramsey and K. Montgomery
to test the effectiveness of technology-based interventions on a broader array of mental and behavioral health outcomes. Furthermore, although more than half of the included studies reported on the acceptance and feasibility of the intervention, the measurement of other implementation outcomes are impor- tant and largely unknown with regard to technology-based therapies. Future research in this area would benefit from examining the fidelity of intervention delivery, the appropriateness of technology-enhanced care for certain pop- ulations and settings, the cost-effectiveness relative to face-to-face therapy, and long-term sustainability of technology-based interventions with varying levels of therapist involvement.
Due to the highly disparate settings, populations, mental health con- ditions, interventions, and technologies reported on in this review, it is premature to draw conclusions about the effectiveness of technology-based interventions in social work practice. However, the wide range of ben- efits reported across studies exemplify the potentially dynamic role that technology can play as the primary mode of delivery or as a feature sup- porting a larger intervention. Traditional “low-tech” interventions that suffer from limited client reach, poor client–therapist communication, or limited therapist time or training may benefit from incorporating technology-based approaches into treatment delivery. The barriers reported reflect critical concerns that are likely to compromise therapist and/or client utilization, penetration throughout care organizations, and sustainability of technology- based interventions over time. Partnered development of these therapeutic tools that includes all stakeholders (e.g., technologists, researchers, ther- apists, clients) would likely alleviate many of the unforeseen barriers and improve implementation and client outcomes. Interestingly, however, there were no reports of therapist or client trepidation or negative reac- tions resulting from a reduced level of therapist contact inherent in the technology-enhanced interventions.
LIMITATIONS
This review is not without limitations. The literature search only included published articles retrieved through online databases and, as a result, excluded grey literature. While this approach introduces publication bias, a primary goal of this study was to examine the extent to which the use of technology-based interventions has been reported on through pub- lished articles. While this method was deemed appropriate for this study, future reviews may seek to consult unpublished papers, theses and dis- sertations, conference meeting abstracts, online sources, and study authors through personal contact in order to include a wider array of efforts to integrate technology in social work practice. Further, our review spans approximately 10 years, a period we considered to represent contemporary
Technology in Social Work Practice 897
conceptualizations and applications of technology. While the most recent applications of technology were the focus of the current study, we recog- nize that this strategy omits years, even decades, of integrating technological approaches into social work practice. In addition, it is possible that some of the articles reviewed did include social workers in the delivery of the intervention, but failed to explicitly report their involvement. Finally, this review only includes studies published in the United States, thereby exclud- ing efforts in Canada, the United Kingdom, and other countries that have explored the use of technology to facilitate social work practice. Because there are many contextual factors that differentially influence the provision of mental health services delivered by social workers around the world, we felt it important to first focus on interventions delivered in the United States. Future studies should consider examining and comparing technology-based interventions across countries.
CONCLUSION
Despite a historically cautious approach toward the integration of technol- ogy into direct social work practice, studies are beginning to report on the implementation of innovative technologies to address the mental health needs for a wide variety of populations, settings, and presenting symptoms. This systematic review of published articles summarizes the current state of technology-based interventions within social work practice and evaluates the reported findings with regard to design, sample, intervention character- istics, mental health outcomes, and the use of technology. Although several barriers to effective technology use were noted across studies, a variety of benefits were reported, and initial evidence suggests that the use of technology-based interventions may be associated with improved mental health outcomes. Further attention from social work researchers and practi- tioners into the appropriateness, effectiveness, and strategic implementation of technology-based mental health interventions is warranted.
FUNDING
This research and article preparation was supported by the NIMH T32 Training Grant (T32MH019960).
REFERENCES
Barak, A., & Grohol, J. M. (2011). Current and future trends in Internet-supported mental health interventions. Journal of Technology in Human Services, 29(3), 155–196.
898 A. T. Ramsey and K. Montgomery
Brownlee, K., Graham, J.R., Doucette, E., Hotson, N., & Halverson, G. (2010). Have communication technologies influenced rural social work practice? British Journal of Social Work, 40(2), 622–637.
∗Crawford, E.A., Salloum, A., Lewin, A.B., Andel, R., Murphy, T.K., & Storch, E.A. (2013). A pilot study of computer-assisted cognitive behavioral therapy for childhood anxiety in community mental health centers. Journal of Cognitive Psychotherapy, 27(3), 221–234.
∗Crunkilton, D.D. (2009). Staff and client perspectives on the Journey Mapping online evaluation tool in a drug court program. Evaluation and Program Planning, 32(2), 119–128.
∗Crunkilton, D.D., & Robinson, M.M. (2008). Cracking the “black box”: Journey Mapping’s tracking system in a drug court program evaluation. Journal of Social Work Practice in the Addictions, 8(4), 511–529.
Cuijpers, P., Marks, I.M., van Straten, A., Cavanagh, K., Gega, L., & Andersson, G. (2009). Computer-aided psychotherapy for anxiety disorders: A meta-analytic review. Cognitive Behaviour Therapy, 38(2), 66–82.
Higgins, J.P.T., & Deeks, J.J. (2008). Chapter 7: Selecting studies and collecting data. In J.P.T. Higgins & S. Green (Eds.), Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions (pp. 151–186). London, UK: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Holden, G., Barker, K., Rosenberg, G., & Cohen, J. (2012). Information for clinical social work practice: A potential solution. Clinical Social Work Journal, 40(2), 166–174.
Holden, G., Tuchman, E., Barker, K., Rosenberg, G., Thazin, M., Kuppens, S., & Watson, K. (2012). A few thoughts on evidence in social work. Social Work in Health Care, 51(6), 483–505.
∗Kernsmith, P.D., & Kernsmith, R.M. (2008). A safe place for predators: Online treat- ment of recovering sex offenders. Journal of Technology in Human Services, 26(2–4), 223–238.
Kimball, E., & Kim, J. (2013). Virtual boundaries: Ethical considerations for use of social media in social work. Social Work, 58(2), 185–188.
Lord, S.E., Trudeau, K.J., Black, R.A., Lorin, L., Cooney, E., Villapiano, A., & Butler, S.F. (2011). CHAT: Development and validation of a computer-delivered, self- report, substance use assessment for adolescents. Substance Use & Misuse, 46(6), 781–794.
Lovell, K., & Bee, P. (2011). Optimising treatment resources for OCD: A review of the evidence base for technology-enhanced delivery. Journal of Mental Health, 20(6), 525–542.
Marsch, L.A., & Gustafson, D.H. (2013). The role of technology in health care innovation: A commentary. Journal of Dual Diagnosis, 9(1), 101–103.
Mattison, M. (2012). Social work practice in the digital age: Therapeutic e-mail as a direct practice methodology. Social Work, 57(3), 249–258.
Menon, G.M., & Rubin, M. (2011). A survey of online practitioners: Implications for education and practice. Journal of Technology in Human Services, 29(2), 133–141.
Mishna, F., Bogo, M., Root, J., Sawyer, J., & Khoury-Kassabri, M. (2012). “It just crept in”: The digital age and implications for social work practice. Clinical Social Work Journal, 40(3), 277–286.
Technology in Social Work Practice 899
Mohr, D.C., Burns, M., Schueller, S.M., Clarke, G., & Klinkman, M. (2013). Behavioral intervention technologies: Evidence review and recommendations for future research in mental health. General Hospital Psychiatry, 35(4), 332–338.
Parker-Oliver, D., & Demiris, G. (2006). Social work informatics: A new specialty. Social Work, 51(2), 127–134.
∗Parker-Oliver, D.R., Demiris, G., Day, M., Courtney, K.L., & Porock, D. (2006). Telehospice support for elder caregivers of hospice patients: Two case studies. Journal of Palliative Medicine, 9(2), 264–267.
Parrott, L., & Madoc-Jones, I. (2008). Reclaiming information and communication technologies for empowering social work practice. Journal of Social Work, 8(2), 181–197.
Powers, J.D., Bowen, N.K., & Bowen, G.L. (2011). Supporting evidence-based prac- tice in schools with an online database of best practices. Children & Schools, 33(2), 119–128.
Preziosa, A., Grassi, A., Gaggioli, A., & Riva, G. (2009). Therapeutic applications of the mobile phone. British Journal of Guidance & Counselling, 37(3), 313–325.
Reamer, F.G. (2013). Social work in a digital age: Ethical and risk management challenges. Social Work, 58(2), 163–172.
∗Rotondi, A.J., Haas, G.L., Anderson, C.M., Newhill, C.E., Spring, M.B., Ganguli, R., . . . Rosenstock, J.B. (2005). A clinical trial to test the feasibility of a tele- health psychoeducational intervention for persons with schizophrenia and their families: Intervention and 3-month findings. Rehabilitation Psychology, 50(4), 325–336.
Staton-Tindall, M., Wahler, E., Webster, J.M., Godlaski, T., Freeman, R., & Leukefeld, C. (2012). Telemedicine-based alcohol services for rural offenders. Psychological Services, 9(3), 298–309.
Wodarski, J., & Frimpong, J. (2013). Application of e-therapy programs to the social work practice. Journal of Human Behavior in the Social Environment, 23(1), 29–36.
- ABSTRACT
- INTRODUCTION
- METHOD
- Inclusion Criteria
- Search Process
- Data Extraction and Coding Procedures
- RESULTS
- Design and Sample
- Intervention Characteristics and Mental Health Outcomes
- Use of Technology
- DISCUSSION
- LIMITATIONS
- CONCLUSION
- FUNDING
- REFERENCES