Discussion
RATIONAL DECISION MAKING - the process
Karen Klisch, PhD
From:
Bazerman, M. (2006). Judgment in managerial decision
making (6th ed.). New York, NY: John Wiley & Sons.
klisch
*
System Thinking
- System 1
- This thinking process involves our intuitive system.
- System 2
- This thinking process taps into our reasoning ability.
klisch
klisch
*
System 1
- Most decisions in life use this system
- It is:
- Fast
- Automatic
- Effortless
- Implicit
- Emotional
klisch
klisch
*
System 1
- This thinking process comes into play when people are busy, rushed and have a lot on their minds.
klisch
klisch
*
System 1
- System 1 thinking is very useful for many decisions.
- Relatively simple decisions that do not require much reasoning are perfect for this System.
- Ordering paperclips when they run out would be a good example.
klisch
klisch
*
System 1
- Managers are frequently rushed.
- Managerial life is often a bit frantic.
- Managers often rely on System 1 thinking even when they should not.
klisch
klisch
*
System 2
- This type of thinking should be utilized when making important decisions.
- It is:
- Slower
- Conscious
- Effortful
- Explicit
- Logical
- Well reasoned
klisch
klisch
*
System 2
- This thinking process takes purposeful effort. One must consciously think --- “I need to take my time and reason this out”.
- It takes patience and control.
klisch
klisch
*
System 2
- This thinking process works best with difficult, complex important decisions.
- Planning to enter new markets or revising the company mission would be good examples.
klisch
klisch
*
Systems 1 & 2
- Most people commonly use System 1 thinking.
- This puts one at risk of decision errors.
- It allows our biases to creep into our decision outcomes.
- We rely on heuristics and this may result in a big mistake.
- People have to stop and consider carefully what they are doing when using System 2 thinking.
- This is not the reflex behavior when confronted with a decision.
- Using this System can help avoid poor and/or biased decisions.
klisch
Rationality
Logical decision making process that is logically expected to lead to the optimal result.
klisch
*
“BOUNDED” RATIONALITY
- Attempt at making rational decisions BUT:
- Lacks important information
- Lacks clear definition of the problem
- Lacks relevant criteria
- Lacks time
- Has cost constraints
- Has limited usable memory or limited intelligence
klisch
klisch
*
Hence
“BOUNDED RATIONALITY”
- One must recognize that most decisions have some degree of boundedness even when one claims to be making a rational decision.
klisch
klisch
*
SATISFICING
- Result of bounded rationality is satisficing –
- It involves forgoing the best solution for one that is acceptable or reasonable.
klisch
klisch
*
SATISFICING
- The individual searches until an acceptable (not maximal) level of performance is found.
- ALL possibilities are NOT examined.
klisch
Result of Satisficing
- Because all possible decisions and their outcomes have not been considered – the best decision may not be made.
klisch
*
klisch
klisch
*
END
klisch