Public Health Finance-1

Criteria

Exemplary - 100%

Satisfactory - 80-99%

Partially Met - 40-79%

Attempted - 1-39%

Not Evident - 0%

Count

15%

More than 10 criteria are listed in the heuristic.

At least 10 criteria are listed in the heuristic. However, one or two of the criteria don’t meet “Satisfactory” in the “Quality” criterion (of this rubric).

Less than 10 criteria are listed in the heuristic, or more than two don’t meet “Satisfactory” in the “Quality” criterion (of this rubric).

Less than 6 criteria are listed in the heuristic.

No criteria are listed in the heuristic.

Quality

40%

Criteria should produce clear, useful insights into the prospect of merging with the target organization.

Criteria are defined in such a way as isolate specific qualities of a target organization and evaluate them. The same criteria, applied to a second target organization, would produce an evaluation that could be easily compared to the first.

Some of the criteria could are vague or jumbled. The evaluations they produce may not be useful in the process of deciding what would need to be done to accomplish a successful merger with the target organization.  

Most of the criteria are insufficient to the task of evaluating what would need to be done to accomplish a successful merger with the target organization.

No criteria are listed in the heuristic.  

Coverage

30%

Criteria provide deep coverage on each of the listed aspects, and then some.  

Each of listed aspects that the heuristic is supposed to cover are addressed:

· Mission, vision and values

· Medicare / Medicaid

· Financial status

Some of the listed aspects go uncovered.

Most of the listed aspects go uncovered.

None of the listed aspects are covered.

Grammar and Mechanics

15%

There are no errors in grammar or mechanics.

There are a few errors in grammar and/or mechanics, but they are minor.

There are enough errors in grammar and/or mechanics to distract, sometimes, from the document’s intention.

There are regular, serious errors in grammar and/or mechanics.

The grammar and/or mechanics contain enough errors to regularly confuse the document’s meaning.