Business Law
yxy1993
journal_entry2.docxJournal Entry - Chapter 25
Chapter 25: International Law in a Global Economy - Chapter 25 - Journal Entry
INTERNATIONAL LAW IN A GLOBAL ECONOMY (Page 730) Robco, Inc., was a Florida arms dealer. The armed forces of Honduras contracted to purchase weapons from Robco over a six-year period. After the government was replaced and a democracy installed, the Honduran government sought to reduce the size of its military, and its relationship with Robco deteriorated. Honduras refused to honor the contract by purchasing the inventory of arms, which Robco could sell only at a much lower price. Robco filed a suit in a federal district court in the United States to recover damages for this breach of contract by the government of Honduras.
1. Should the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (FSIA) preclude this lawsuit? Why or why not?
2. Does the act of state doctrine bar Robco from seeking to enforce the contract? Explain.
3. Suppose that prior to this lawsuit, the new government of Honduras had enacted a law making it illegal to purchase weapons from foreign arms dealers. What doctrine might lead a U.S. court to dismiss Robco’s case in that situation?
4. Now suppose that the U.S. court hears the case and awards damages to Robco, but the government of Honduras has no assets in the United States that can be used to satisfy the judgment. Under which doctrine might Robco be able to collect the damages by asking another nation’s court to enforce the U.S. judgment?
FOR TWO BONUS POINTS:
The U.S. federal courts are accepting too many lawsuits initiated by foreigners that concern matters not relevant to this country. Our federal courts are already overwhelmed by normal lawsuits that concern purported wrongs committed on U.S. soil that involve residents of this country. Why should we become the preferred jurisdiction for lawsuits that involve human rights issues in other countries? Why should we become the preferred jurisdiction for purported employment discrimination that might have taken place outside of the U.S.? We are not the world’s conscience.
