|
|
Levels of Achievement
|
|
Criteria
|
Beginning
|
Developing
|
Accomplished
|
Exemplary
|
|
Title: An interesting/creative title that captures the attention of the audience and reflects the main point of the memoir.
|
Title may be somewhat dull and/or mislead readers about the main point of the memoir.
|
Title may be less creative and/or doesn’t clearly enough convey to readers the main point of the memoir.
|
Title conveys to readers the main point of the memoir, but could be more interesting/engaging.
|
Title conveys to readers the main point of the memoir, and is interesting/engaging.
|
|
Main point: your own experience is focused and demonstrates meaning and value for the reader
|
Main point is missing/unclear.
|
Main point is included, but needs more focus/may be somewhat confusing to audience.
|
Main point is clear and focused, but might not be as meaningful/valuable for the audience as exemplary category.
|
Main point is clear/focused and demonstrates obvious meaning and value for the audience.
|
|
Narrative: interesting and effective use of narrative techniques and descriptive details (and perhaps dialogue) that show, not tell, the reader.
|
Passages mostly “tell” the audience; need more descriptive details.
|
Descriptive details are included at times, but need more.
|
Descriptive details are included but could be more vivid.
|
Descriptive details are interesting and vivid.
|
|
Reflective: the ability to reflect upon your memories to show emotion.
|
Your reflections upon your memories are missing,obscure, or less engaging for this audience.
|
Your reflections upon your memories may be somewhat included but are not entirely clear or might be less engaging for this audience.
|
Your reflections upon your memories are included.
|
Your reflections upon your memories are included and articulated in an exemplary manner.
|
|
Rhetorical strategies: structure, style, tone, vocabulary are appropriate for audience(s)/purpose/ genre of memoir.
|
Rhetorical strategies: structure, style, tone, vocabulary are articulated in a manner that might be confusing to audience
|
Rhetorical strategies: structure, style, tone, vocabulary are somewhat appropriate, but could be confusing to audience.
|
Rhetorical strategies: structure, style, tone, vocabulary are articulated in an effective manner.
|
Rhetorical strategies: structure, style, tone, vocabulary are articulated in an exemplary manner and demonstrate a high level of thinking about the rhetorical situation.
|
|
Ethos: writing reflects correct grammar, spelling, and punctuation.
|
Many errors that obscure the meaning of the sentences/passages and impact the writer’s credibility.
|
Contains at least two errors, which obscure the meaning of a sentence or passage and impact the writer’s credibility.
|
Contains one error which does not obscure the meaning of the sentence or passage, but slightly impacts the writer’s ethos.
|
Is completely free of errors, which reflects well on the writer’s ethos.
|