response analysis
Writing Self-Evaluation Rubric
1
2
1
Writing Self
-
Evaluation
Rubric
Criteria
1
Needs Work
2
Satisfactory
3
Exceptional
Comments
1. Structur
e
writing with all
the following elements:
·
Introduction
:
Main
points in order.
·
Main body
:
o
Each point made
with evidence.
o
Analysis.
·
Conclusion
:
Main
points summarized.
·
References.
Does not contain all
elements.
Contains all
elements.
X
Contains all
elements and each
is clearly identified
for the reader.
The structure of the post is
half way good with an
excellent introduction but a
failing body. The introduction
is also somewhat vague and
difficult to understand, but the
content becomes clearer as
one approaches the
conclusion. The perfect end
gives the p
ost the credit it
deserves. The post also has
excellent reference but fails to
cite the research
2. Follow MEAL plan for
paragraph structure.
·
Main idea stated
clearly.
·
Evidence sentence(s)
presented.
·
Evidence sentence(s)
cited.
·
Analysis (or other
critical thinking)
presented.
Does not contain
all
element
s
of the
MEAL plan.
Contains all
el
ements of the
MEAL plan.
Follows the MEAL
plan and extends
critical analysis.
X
The post agrees with the
MEAL plan. The breakdown
starts with stating the main
idea then delves to the
evidence can citation of proof
sentences. Moreover, it i
s the
critical thinking of the paper
that makes it look outstanding
together with its ability to link
one idea to the next in the
successful paragraphs.
1
Writing Self-Evaluation Rubric
Criteria
1
Needs Work
2
Satisfactory
3
Exceptional
Comments
1. Structure writing with all
the following elements:
Introduction: Main
points in order.
Main body:
o Each point made
with evidence.
o Analysis.
Conclusion: Main
points summarized.
References.
Does not contain all
elements.
Contains all
elements.
X
Contains all
elements and each
is clearly identified
for the reader.
The structure of the post is
half way good with an
excellent introduction but a
failing body. The introduction
is also somewhat vague and
difficult to understand, but the
content becomes clearer as
one approaches the
conclusion. The perfect end
gives the post the credit it
deserves. The post also has
excellent reference but fails to
cite the research
2. Follow MEAL plan for
paragraph structure.
Main idea stated
clearly.
Evidence sentence(s)
presented.
Evidence sentence(s)
cited.
Analysis (or other
critical thinking)
presented.
Does not contain all
elements of the
MEAL plan.
Contains all
elements of the
MEAL plan.
Follows the MEAL
plan and extends
critical analysis.
X
The post agrees with the
MEAL plan. The breakdown
starts with stating the main
idea then delves to the
evidence can citation of proof
sentences. Moreover, it is the
critical thinking of the paper
that makes it look outstanding
together with its ability to link
one idea to the next in the
successful paragraphs.