self analysis

Criteria

1

Needs Work

2

Satisfactory

3

Exceptional

Comments

1. Structure writing with all the following elements:

Introduction: Main points in order.

Main body:

· Each point made with evidence.

· Analysis.

Conclusion: Main points summarized.

References.

Does not contain all elements.

Contains all elements.

Contains all elements and each is clearly identified for the reader.

2. Follow MEAL plan for paragraph structure.

Main idea stated clearly.

Evidence sentence(s) presented.

Evidence sentence(s) cited.

Analysis (or other critical thinking) presented.

Link to the next paragraph offered.

Does not contain all elements of the MEAL plan.

Contains all elements of the MEAL plan.

Follows the MEAL plan and extends critical analysis.

3. Use appropriate documentation style.

Follows APA format and style.

Incorporates internal citations correctly.

Presents references correctly.

Does not follow two or more elements or has two or more errors.

Does not follow one element or has one error.

Follows all elements and has no errors.

4. Use appropriate voice and tone.

Uses appropriate tone for the assignment.

Uses concrete language.

Uses signal phrases to separate self from sources.

Does not follow two or more elements.

Follow all but one element.

Follows all elements.

5. Write in genuine third person.

Does not write in genuine third person.

Writes in genuine third person throughout most of the assignment.

Consistently writes in genuine third person.