For Prof Tutor Only (others will be deleted)

HSC 312: Final Project –Complied Case Analysis Scoring Rubric

The following criteria will be used to grade your Complied Case Analysis. Keep in mind that the score requirement described

under each score point on the scale defines the minimum performance that must be demonstrated in order to achieve that score.

Evaluation

Criteria

A

20 points

B

17 points

C

15 points

D

13 points

F

11 points

1.) Introduces the case

analysis by

describing

the ethical

dilemma

requiring

resolution

Introduction is:

• Comprehensive

• Includes a

thorough, clear and

concise description

of the case and

ethical dilemma

proposed.

Introduction:

• Includes minor

omissions in

description of

either the case

or ethical

dilemma.

Introduction:

• Lacks detail in

part

• Includes minor

omissions in

both the

description of

the case and the

ethical dilemma.

Introduction:

• Lacks detail

• Includes major

omissions in

either

description of

the case or the

ethical

dilemma.

Description is either

missing or contains

major omissions

throughout.

2.) Identifies the

primary

stakeholder

(s) and

provides a

description

of the

situation

from the

stakeholder

perspective

Description is:

• Comprehensive

• Includes

identification of

stakeholder

• Provides clear

stakeholder

Description:

• Has minor

omissions or

errors in

identification of

stakeholders or

in describing the

stakeholder

perspective.

Description:

• Lacks detail

• Omits some

significant

content or

contains several

minor errors.

Description:

• Lacks detail.

• Is superficial

and contains

multiple errors.

Description is:

• Missing or

incorrect

• Inconsistent

with selected

stakeholder

 Does not identify any

or identifies

irrelevant

stakeholders.

3.) Analyzes the scenario

from the

perspective

of the

primary

stakeholder

and includes

a description

of at least

two ethical

theories that

relate to the

issue being

identified

Analysis and Description

are:

• Comprehensive

• Include responses

to all

subcomponents of

the question.

• Provides clear

description of two

or more ethical

theories and their

relation to the

issue.

Analysis and

Description:

• Include minor

omissions.

• Includes 1-2

minor errors in

regards to the

scenario of the

stakeholder or

the description

of the ethical

theories.

Analysis and

Description:

• Include a major

omission, OR

• Includes

several errors in

regards to the

scenario of the

stakeholder or

the description

of the ethical

theories.

Analysis and

Description:

• Includes a

major omission,

AND

• Includes

several errors in

regards to the

scenario of the

stakeholder or

the description

of the ethical

theories.

Analysis and Description are:

• Missing

OR

• Response

contains

significant

errors or

omissions

throughout the

response.

4.) Provides a reasonable

recommendat

ion based

upon the

analysis

presented

Recommendation is:

• Comprehensive.

• Clear and logical

• Summarizes key

points.

Recommendation

has:

• Minor

omissions or

errors

• Is clear and

logical

• Summarizes

most key points.

Recommendation:

• Omits some

significant

content and

contains several

minor errors

• Is clear or

logical but not

both

• Summarizes

minimal

points.

Recommendation:

• Is superficial

and contains

multiple errors

• Is not clear or

logical

• Summarizes 1-

2 points.

Recommendation is:

• Missing or

incorrect.

5.) Format Format is:

• Clear and

consistent.

• contains accurate

and proper

grammatical

conventions,

spelling,

formatting, and

referencing.

• Follows specific

instructions.

Format is:

• Clear and

mostly

consistent.

• Contains few

errors of

accuracy

• Follows

specific

instructions

with minor

omissions.

Format is:

• Clear but not

concise.

• Contains

multiple errors

of accuracy.

• Follows

specific

instructions

with multiple

omissions.

Format is:

• Not clear or

concise.

• Contains

serious errors.

• Specific

instructions are

barely followed.

Format:

• Is not clear.

• Does not

follow specific

instructions.