Holism vs. Reductionism Research Paper
Running head:
HOLISM VS. 1 REDUCTIONISM 1 HOLISM VS. REDUCTIONISM 3
Holism vs. Reductionism
Student
Institution
Date
Reductionism
2 THIS IS THE BELIEF THAT THE BEHAVIOR OF HUMAN CAN BE EXPLAINED THROUGH BREAKING IT INTO SMALLER COMPONENT PARTS. 3 REDUCTIONISTS ARGUE THAT THE BEST WAY THROUGH WHICH WE CAN UNDERSTAND WHY WE BEHAVE THE WAY WE DO IS TO LOOK CLOSELY AT SMALL PARTS, WHICH MAKE OUR SYSTEMS. 4 THE SIMPLEST EXPLANATIONS CAN BE USED TO UNDERSTAND HOW THINGS WORK. The concept of reductionism was introduced by Descartes. He introduced the concept while arguing that the world is like a machine that has got pieces of parts. The whole machine can be understood properly through looking at its smaller parts (Jackson, 2006). This is by taking the smaller parts and studying separately, and putting the smaller pieces together after studying them so as to see the larger picture.
1 REDUCTIONISM IS BASED ON THE SCIENTIFIC ASSUMPTION TERMED AS PARSIMONY. 4 PARSIMONY STATES THAT PHENOMENA THAT ARE COMPLEX CAN BE EXPLAINED BY THE SIMPLEST PRINCIPLE POSSIBLE. 3 THOSE WHO STRONGLY SUPPORT REDUCTIONISM BELIEVE THAT MENTAL PROCESSES AND BEHAVIOR SHOULD BE EXPLAINED THROUGH UTILIZATION OF BASIC SCIENCE FRAMEWORK.
5 A COMPLEX SYSTEM IS NOTHING, BUT THE TOTAL OF THE PARTS OF THE COMPLEX SYSTEM. This is a philosophical position of reductionism. 2 THE ACCOUNT OF A COMPLEX SYSTEM CAN BE REDUCED TO ACCOUNTS FOR INDIVIDUAL CONSTITUENTS. This approach also argues that everything that is existence in nature is made up of a small number of basic substances. These substances behave in regular ways.
3 REDUCTIONISM OPERATES AT DIFFERENT LEVELS. It has highest and lowest levels (Verschuren, 2001). 3 THE HIGHEST SOCIOCULTURAL LEVEL HAS EXPLANATIONS THAT DIRECT MUCH FOCUS ON THE INFLUENCE OF BEHAVIOR OF HOW AND WHERE WE LIVE. The lowest level provides physiological explanations, which try to explain behavior in terms of brain structure, gene, and neurochemical. 3 BETWEEN THE TWO EXTREMES, THAT IS, THE HIGHEST AND LOWEST LEVELS, THERE ARE COGNITIVE, BEHAVIORAL AND COGNITIVE EXPLANATIONS.
Looking at the components of a problem may make it possible to understand the bigger picture. 3 FOR EXAMPLE, MENTAL DISORDER, SUCH AS DEPRESSION MAY BE UNDERSTOOD THROUGH PUTTING TOGETHER EXPLANATIONS FROM SOCIOCULTURAL, COGNITIVE, AND PHYSIOLOGICAL LEVELS. This approach of reductionism can easily explain the successes that are being when it comes to drug therapies.
6 EXAMPLES OF REDUCTIONISM IN PSYCHOLOGY
· Behaviorism – believes that behavior can be broken down to its simple building blocks of S-R (stimuli and response). Additionally, it also argues that complex behaviors are made up of a series of stimuli-response chains.
3 · STRUCTURALISM – THIS WAS ONE OF THE FIRST APPROACHES WHEN IT COMES TO PSYCHOLOGY. It attempts to break down conscious experience into its constituent parts or basic parts. The constituent parts of the conscious experience are feelings, sensations, and images.
· Biopsychology – reductionists are usually the explanation for the mental illness cause. The cause of mental disorder is neurochemical imbalance and genetics. 3 LOOKING AT SCHIZOPHRENIA AS ANOTHER EXAMPLE, THE PRODUCTION OF EXCESS NEUROTRANSMITTER CALLED DOPAMINE IS THE CAUSE OF THIS DISORDER.
The methods and thinking of reductionist are the foundation for many areas of modern science that is well-developed. What is commonly known it that many aspects of chemistry trace their roots to physics. The importance of reductionist approach relies on the reason to which they are put. For instance, investigating the response of brain to faces may show a lot about how people recognize faces.
Holism
Holism is a concept that calls for looking at something as a whole, but not the constituent parts. It argues that looking at something as a whole is better than the sum of its parts. Holistic position is reflected by humanistic approach. 3 HOLISTIC VIEW IS ALSO TAKEN BY SOCIAL PSYCHOLOGY. 7 IT IS SUGGESTED THAT THERE ARE DIFFERENT LEVELS OF EXPLANATION ACCORDING TO HOLISTIC APPROACH. There are emergent properties at each and every level of explanation. These emergent properties cannot be reduced to ones that are below. The explanations of reductionists that may work during some situations are seen to be inappropriate when it comes to holism. The study of human subjectivity cannot be studied through the use of reductionism since the emergent properties that one is required to consider is that of the whole person.
Holistic approach makes it possible for researchers to look at processes by themselves and arrive at conclusion with regards to complex information, such as pattern, configuration, and process. The approach also turns out to be important when understanding a system in a collective manner. Examples of some elements that can be understood in a collective manner are an organization as a whole, group culture, and team spirit among others. Observation through a holistic view makes it easy to understand the verbal and physical behavior spontaneously. Most of holistic observations begin with a research question. 8 THE RESEARCH STRATEGIES THAT ARE UTILIZED WITH HOLISTIC APPROACH APPLY QUALITATIVE COMPARISON INSTEAD OF QUALIFICATION. This promotes theory building and assists in causal interferences. Provision of the holistic approach makes it possible to understand the whole system.
9 EXAMPLES OF HOLISM IN PSYCHOLOGY
· Humanistic – this psychology looks at all aspects of a person together with one’s interaction with other people (Jackson, 2006).
· Social – social psychology analyzes the behavior of people with regards to the social context. 3 GROUP BEHAVIOR, SUCH AS DE-INDIVIDUALIZATION OR CONFORMITY MAY GIVE SIGNS OF CHARACTERISTICS, WHICH ARE BIGGER THAN THE SUM OF PERSONS WHICH COMPRISE IT.
· ABNORMAL PSYCHOLOGY – MENTAL DISORDERS IN PEOPLE ARE EXPLAINED BY AN INTERACTION OF ENVIRONMENTAL, PSYCHOLOGICAL, AND BIOLOGICAL FACTORS. 1 THERE IS AN APPROACH TO THERAPY THAT MAKES USE OF BOTH PSYCHOTHERAPY AND DRUGS. This approach is termed as eclectic.
· Perception – this is a process where the brain is able to understand and interpret sensory information. Visual illusion gives evidence that human beings perceive more than the small parts of the sensations in the retina.
Holism holds a better edge when compared to reductionism. This is because of interconnection, nature, and complexity of systems. Many organizations that have been facing problems with regards to performance have managed to move past their problems due to the use of holistic approach. Many changes that these organizations have managed to come up with are as a result of looking at their problems from the whole organization’s perspective. Wholes, such as a whole organization are composites. They have internal structure together with characteristic or function that differentiates them from mechanical contractions, aggregates, and addition. For example, science makes assumptions based on mechanical hypothesis. An organization can be termed as holistic when employees within the organization find their in the whole organization. This can also apply to a society when person can find his or her identity from the whole organization (Jackson, 2006).
10 COMPARE AND CONTRAST HOLISM VERSUS REDUCTIONISM
Both reductionism and holism are philosophical concepts that relates to the analysis of any system. There is difference when one looks at the origin of the two theories. The origin of reductionism can be traced back to 1600 when Newton and Descartes made use of the law of thought of Aristotle to explain their theories. Holism, on the other hand, was first used in the year 1926 by a South African statesman known as Jan Smut. Smuts first used the concept in his book titled Holism and evolution.
Holism argues that entity or natural system can be viewed as a whole. For example human behavior and human mind can be looked at as a whole. Looking at components parts is not enough to explain one’s behavior. Reductionists, on the other hand, try to explain their argument through the use of machine. They state that machine is the sum of its smaller parts.
Emotions, such as sarcasm and anger cannot be understood by analyzing the individual body parts. It is only possible to study them through the holistic view point that is, looking at it as a whole. Turbulence, which is a phenomenon usually learned in fluid dynamics cannot be explained by reductionist view point. The concept is about irregular motion of air. It can only be explained through holism. When it comes to neurology, those supporting holism state that human brain is a homogeneous part, which has no specific sub parts. However, localizationists argue in a different manner. They argue that human brain is organized in unique cortical areas. These unique cortical areas function differently.
References
11 JACKSON, M.C (2006). Creative holism: 12 A CRITICAL SYSTEMS APPROACH TO COMPLEX PROBLEM
situations. 6 SYSTEMS RESEARCH & BEHAVIORAL SCIENCE, 23(5), 647-657. doi: 13 10.1002/SRES.799.
Malanson, G. P. (1999). Considering complexity. Annals of The Association Of American
14 OSTRENG.PDF VERSCHUREN, P.M (2001). 6 HOLISM VERSUS REDUCTIONISM IN MODERN SOCIAL SCIENCE RESEARCH,
13 QUALITY AND QUANTITY, 35(4). 389.
Citations (14/14)
1. 1Another student's paper
2. 2Another student's paper
3. 3http://www.simplypsychology.org/reductionism-holism.html
4. 4Another student's paper
5. 5Another student's paper
6. 6Another student's paper
7. 7Another student's paper
8. 8Another student's paper
9. 9http://epublications.marquette.edu/dissertations/AAI8422829/
10. 10Another student's paper
11. 11Another student's paper
12. 12Another user's paper
13. 13Another student's paper
14. 14Another student's paper
Matched Text
Suspected Entry: 100% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
REDUCTIONISM 1 HOLISM VS
Source - Another student's paper
HOLISM VS REDUCTIONISM 1
Suspected Entry: 69% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
REDUCTIONISM IS BASED ON THE SCIENTIFIC ASSUMPTION TERMED AS PARSIMONY
Source - Another student's paper
Reductionism is based on the scientific supposition of parsimony
Suspected Entry: 62% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
THERE IS AN APPROACH TO THERAPY THAT MAKES USE OF BOTH PSYCHOTHERAPY AND DRUGS
Source - Another student's paper
Moreover, diverse approach to therapy is applied with the use of psychotherapy and drugs
Suspected Entry: 86% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
THIS IS THE BELIEF THAT THE BEHAVIOR OF HUMAN CAN BE EXPLAINED THROUGH BREAKING IT INTO SMALLER COMPONENT PARTS
Source - Another student's paper
It is the belief that human behavior can be explained by breaking it down into smaller component parts
Suspected Entry: 76% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
THE ACCOUNT OF A COMPLEX SYSTEM CAN BE REDUCED TO ACCOUNTS FOR INDIVIDUAL CONSTITUENTS
Source - Another student's paper
An account of it can be reduced to accounts of individual constituents
Suspected Entry: 66% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
REDUCTIONISTS ARGUE THAT THE BEST WAY THROUGH WHICH WE CAN UNDERSTAND WHY WE BEHAVE THE WAY WE DO IS TO LOOK CLOSELY AT SMALL PARTS, WHICH MAKE OUR SYSTEMS
Source - http://www.simplypsychology.org/reductionism-holism.html
Reductionists say that the best way to understand why we behave as we do is to look closely at the very simplest parts that make up our systems, and use the simplest explanations to understand how they work
Suspected Entry: 62% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
THOSE WHO STRONGLY SUPPORT REDUCTIONISM BELIEVE THAT MENTAL PROCESSES AND BEHAVIOR SHOULD BE EXPLAINED THROUGH UTILIZATION OF BASIC SCIENCE FRAMEWORK
Source - http://www.simplypsychology.org/reductionism-holism.html
Strong supporters of reductionism believe that behavior and mental processes should be explained within the framework of basic sciences (eg physiology, chemistry
Suspected Entry: 75% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
REDUCTIONISM OPERATES AT DIFFERENT LEVELS
Source - http://www.simplypsychology.org/reductionism-holism.html
Reductionism works at different levels
Suspected Entry: 84% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
THE HIGHEST SOCIOCULTURAL LEVEL HAS EXPLANATIONS THAT DIRECT MUCH FOCUS ON THE INFLUENCE OF BEHAVIOR OF HOW AND WHERE WE LIVE
Source - http://www.simplypsychology.org/reductionism-holism.html
At the highest sociocultural level, explanations focus on the influence on behavior of where and how we live
Suspected Entry: 65% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
BETWEEN THE TWO EXTREMES, THAT IS, THE HIGHEST AND LOWEST LEVELS, THERE ARE COGNITIVE, BEHAVIORAL AND COGNITIVE EXPLANATIONS
Source - http://www.simplypsychology.org/reductionism-holism.html
Between these extremes there are behavioral, cognitive and social explanations
Suspected Entry: 73% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
FOR EXAMPLE, MENTAL DISORDER, SUCH AS DEPRESSION MAY BE UNDERSTOOD THROUGH PUTTING TOGETHER EXPLANATIONS FROM SOCIOCULTURAL, COGNITIVE, AND PHYSIOLOGICAL LEVELS
Source - http://www.simplypsychology.org/reductionism-holism.html
So for example, we might better understand a mental disorder such as depression by bringing together explanations from physiological, cognitive and sociocultural levels
Suspected Entry: 71% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
· STRUCTURALISM – THIS WAS ONE OF THE FIRST APPROACHES WHEN IT COMES TO PSYCHOLOGY
Source - http://www.simplypsychology.org/reductionism-holism.html
Structuralism – One of the first approaches in psychology
Suspected Entry: 68% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
LOOKING AT SCHIZOPHRENIA AS ANOTHER EXAMPLE, THE PRODUCTION OF EXCESS NEUROTRANSMITTER CALLED DOPAMINE IS THE CAUSE OF THIS DISORDER
Source - http://www.simplypsychology.org/reductionism-holism.html
In the case of schizophrenia for example excess production of the neurotransmitter dopamine is seen as a possible cause
Suspected Entry: 73% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
HOLISTIC VIEW IS ALSO TAKEN BY SOCIAL PSYCHOLOGY
Source - http://www.simplypsychology.org/reductionism-holism.html
Social psychology also takes a holistic view
Suspected Entry: 70% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
GROUP BEHAVIOR, SUCH AS DE-INDIVIDUALIZATION OR CONFORMITY MAY GIVE SIGNS OF CHARACTERISTICS, WHICH ARE BIGGER THAN THE SUM OF PERSONS WHICH COMPRISE IT
Source - http://www.simplypsychology.org/reductionism-holism.html
Group behavior (eg conformity, de-individualization) may show characteristics that are greater than the sum of the individuals which comprise it
Suspected Entry: 74% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
· PSYCHOANALYSIS – INTERACTIONIST APPROACH WAS ADOPTED BY FREUD BY CONSIDERING THAT BEHAVIOR OF PEOPLE BEING DUE TO DYNAMIC INTERACTION BETWEEN SUPEREGO, EGO, AND ID (MALANSON, 1999)
Source - http://www.simplypsychology.org/reductionism-holism.html
Psychoanalysis – Freud adopted an interactionist approach, in that he considered that behavior was the results of dynamic interaction between id, ego and superego
Suspected Entry: 92% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
· ABNORMAL PSYCHOLOGY – MENTAL DISORDERS IN PEOPLE ARE EXPLAINED BY AN INTERACTION OF ENVIRONMENTAL, PSYCHOLOGICAL, AND BIOLOGICAL FACTORS
Source - http://www.simplypsychology.org/reductionism-holism.html
Abnormal psychology – mental disorders are often explained by an interaction of biological, psychological and environmental factors
Suspected Entry: 67% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
THE SIMPLEST EXPLANATIONS CAN BE USED TO UNDERSTAND HOW THINGS WORK
Source - Another student's paper
And to use the simplest explanations to understand how they work
Suspected Entry: 64% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
PARSIMONY STATES THAT PHENOMENA THAT ARE COMPLEX CAN BE EXPLAINED BY THE SIMPLEST PRINCIPLE POSSIBLE
Source - Another student's paper
Reductionism is based on parsimony, that complex phenomena should be explained by the simplest underlying principles possible
Suspected Entry: 63% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
A COMPLEX SYSTEM IS NOTHING, BUT THE TOTAL OF THE PARTS OF THE COMPLEX SYSTEM
Source - Another student's paper
Reductionism of a complex system is nothing but the sum of its parts
Suspected Entry: 73% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
EXAMPLES OF REDUCTIONISM IN PSYCHOLOGY
Source - Another student's paper
The following are the some of the examples of Reductionism in psychology
Suspected Entry: 99% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
SYSTEMS RESEARCH & BEHAVIORAL SCIENCE, 23(5), 647-657
Source - Another student's paper
Systems research & behavioral science, 23(5), 647-657
Suspected Entry: 100% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
HOLISM VERSUS REDUCTIONISM IN MODERN SOCIAL SCIENCE RESEARCH,
Source - Another student's paper
Holism versus Reductionism in Modern Social Science Research
Suspected Entry: 69% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
IT IS SUGGESTED THAT THERE ARE DIFFERENT LEVELS OF EXPLANATION ACCORDING TO HOLISTIC APPROACH
Source - Another student's paper
In that case, it is right to assert that the holistic approach suggests that there are different levels of explanation
Suspected Entry: 69% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
THE RESEARCH STRATEGIES THAT ARE UTILIZED WITH HOLISTIC APPROACH APPLY QUALITATIVE COMPARISON INSTEAD OF QUALIFICATION
Source - Another student's paper
The research strategy adopted with holistic approach uses the qualitative comparison instead of qualification
Suspected Entry: 78% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
EXAMPLES OF HOLISM IN PSYCHOLOGY
Source - http://epublications.marquette.edu/dissertations/AAI8422829/
holism in psychology
Suspected Entry: 85% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
COMPARE AND CONTRAST HOLISM VERSUS REDUCTIONISM
Source - Another student's paper
Compare and contrast Holism and Reductionism
Suspected Entry: 100% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
JACKSON, M.C (2006)
Source - Another student's paper
Jackson, M.C (2006)
Suspected Entry: 90% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
A CRITICAL SYSTEMS APPROACH TO COMPLEX PROBLEM
Source - Another user's paper
A Critical Systems Approach to Complex Problem Situations
Suspected Entry: 100% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
10.1002/SRES.799
Source - Another student's paper
10.1002/sres.799
Suspected Entry: 100% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
QUALITY AND QUANTITY, 35(4)
Source - Another student's paper
Quality and Quantity,35(4)
Suspected Entry: 75% match
Uploaded - holism_vs._reductionism1.doc
OSTRENG.PDF VERSCHUREN, P.M (2001)
Source - Another student's paper
Verschuren, P.M (2001)