|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Criteria
|
Level 4
|
Level 3
|
Level 2
|
Level 1
|
|
Design Requirements
|
25 points
Exceptional clarity of thought. Shows understanding of all major points. Reasonable hypothesis or targeted questions; conclusions supportable by data; creativity; some graphic representation of data or concepts. Includes detailedbudget estimate for ready reference.
|
20 points
Good clarity of thought; shows understanding of most major points.Narrative is persuasive. Providescost estimate of the project but does not attach supporting detail.
|
18 points
Begins successfully, but omits significant customer requirements. Narrative is not persuasive. Does not support conclusion with a detailedanalysis.
|
14 points
Product does not reflect goals of the assignment; or provide information requested;
restates description question without making an attempt to justify solution.
|
|
Business Requirements
|
25 points
Presents all requirements correctlyand recommends
additional requirements with justification.
|
20 points
Clearly identifies requirements and organizational goals.
|
18 points
Shows basic understanding of requirements.
But some of the requirements overlap.
|
14 points
Does not ascertain requirements beyondsuggestions provided.
|
|
Criterion 3
|
25 points
Presents all requirements correctlyand recommends
additional requirements with justification.
|
20 points
Clearly identifies requirements and organizational goals.
|
18 points
Shows basic understanding of requirements.
But some of the requirements overlap.
|
14 points
Does not ascertain requirements beyondsuggestions provided.
|
|
Essay Writing
|
10 points
Presents a logical explanation for findings and addresses most of the questions. Uses correct grammar and spelling.
|
8 points
Presents a logical explanation for findings and addresses some of the questions. Only one or two grammatical or spelling errors.
|
7 points
Presents an illogical explanation for findings and addresses only a few of the proposed questions.
More than two grammatical or spelling errors.
|
6 points
Presents an illogical explanation for findings and does not address any of the questions.
Numerous
grammatical and/or spelling errors.
|
|
Inventory List
|
25 points
Done Correctly
Identify locations and connection to devices and VLAN correctly
Inventory matches IP scheme
|
20 points
Done correctly
Missed few locations and connections
|
18 points
Done
Partly correct.
Location, connections are missing
|
14 points
Not done
|
|
IP Scheme
|
30 points
Presents correct IP design and implements complex routing protocols and subnetting
|
24 points
Uses a hierarchical design concept successfully and implements simple routing protocols and subnetting
|
21 points
Attempts to use a hierarchical design but without success.
Does not demonstrate knowledge of routing protocols and subnetting
|
18 points
Does not use IP hierarchical design.
Does not demonstrate knowledge of routing protocols and subnetting
|
|
VoIP Design
|
35 points
Uses design calculation diagram precisely to support the design. Provides evidence of in-depthunderstanding of design concepts.
|
28 points
Effectively uses design principles. Attaches diagram.
Uses design calculation correctly to get the desired results
|
24 points
Uses partial design procedure to complete task. Missed steps in design calculations.
|
21 points
No evidence of use of design procedure. Design calculations are wrong
|
|
Wireless Network
|
35 points
Designs
comprehensive
wireless network with roaming ability. Provides configuration and diagrams to support the network
|
28 points
Designs wireless network as per customer requirements and provides network design diagrams.
|
24 points
Attempts to design wireless networkbut does not complete task.
|
21 points
Design is incomplete and/or incorrect.
|
|
High Level Diagram
|
40 points
Incorporates all key devices, VLANs and link addresses without any error. Demonstrate mastery of LAN design through High Level Diagram.
|
32 points
Incorporates all key devices, VLANs and link address with few errors.
|
28 points
Limited ability in drawing the high level diagram.
Drawings are difficult to understand due to naming of devices, subnets, and VLANs
|
24 points
No evidence of use of knowledge of network design theory in drawing the diagram
.
|
|
Overall Score
|
Level 4
35 or more
|
Level 3
26 or more
|
Level 2
17 or more
|
Level 1
0 or more
|
astudent31
rubric_name_-_authentic_assessment_part-1.docx
0
