Response Paper
Chapter 2
The Process and Problems of Educational Research
Check/Schutt, Research Methods in Education
© 2012 SAGE Publications
1
How does a child learn to read?
Check/Schutt, Research Methods in Education
© 2012 SAGE Publications
Research Question
2
Three Stages
Identifying questions for study
Refining the questions
Evaluating the questions
Feasibility
Educational importance
Relevance
Check/Schutt, Research Methods in Education
© 2012 SAGE Publications
Formulating a Research Questions
3
Finding Information
Search the literature
Critically review information
Online resources
Refereed journals
Check/Schutt, Research Methods in Education
© 2012 SAGE Publications
Educational Research Basics
4
Specify the research question
Identify appropriate bibliographic databases
Choose a search technology
Create tentative list of search terms
Narrow search
Refine search
Use Boolean search logic
Use appropriate subject descriptors
Check the results
Read the articles
Check/Schutt, Research Methods in Education
© 2012 SAGE Publications
Searching the Literature
5
Check/Schutt, Research Methods in Education
© 2012 SAGE Publications
6
Clarify goals
Quality is not guaranteed
Anticipate change
One size does not fit all
Be concerned about generalizability
Evaluate the sites
Avoid web addiction
Cite your sources
Check/Schutt, Research Methods in Education
© 2012 SAGE Publications
Searching the Web
7
Web
Caveat emptor
Scholarly journal articles
ERIC
Psychological Abstracts
Assess each article separately
Assess implications for entire set of articles
Check/Schutt, Research Methods in Education
© 2012 SAGE Publications
Reviewing the Research
8
The research question
The research design
The research findings and conclusion
Integrated literature review
Check/Schutt, Research Methods in Education
© 2012 SAGE Publications
Single Article Review
9
Summarize prior research
Three questions
Critique prior research
Three questions
Present pertinent conclusions
Three guidelines
Check/Schutt, Research Methods in Education
© 2012 SAGE Publications
An Integrated Literature Review
10
Theory
Logically interrelated sets of propositions that help us make sense of many interrelated phenomena and predict behavior or attitudes that are likely to occur when certain conditions are met
Building and evaluating theory is one of the most important objectives of educational research
Check/Schutt, Research Methods in Education
© 2012 SAGE Publications
The Role of Educational Theory
11
Research circle
Deductive research
Hypothesis
Two or more variables
Independent
Dependent
Empirical generalizations
Check/Schutt, Research Methods in Education
© 2012 SAGE Publications
Explanatory Research
12
Check/Schutt, Research Methods in Education
© 2012 SAGE Publications
13
Begins with data which is then used to develop an explanation to account for the data
Exploratory research
Qualitative
Check/Schutt, Research Methods in Education
© 2012 SAGE Publications
Inductive Research
14
Doesn’t connect theory to data
Begins with data and makes empirical generalizations based on data
Cornerstone of scientific research
Stimulates deductive and inductive research
Check/Schutt, Research Methods in Education
© 2012 SAGE Publications
Descriptive Research
15
Validity
Measurement
Generalizability
Causal
Internal
Check/Schutt, Research Methods in Education
© 2012 SAGE Publications
Educational Research Goals
16
Researchers who are skeptical about establishing validity
Subjective nature of educational world
Understanding of how others view the world
Check/Schutt, Research Methods in Education
© 2012 SAGE Publications
Authenticity
17
So what?
Educators investigating their own practice and using results to modify instruction
Programs such as No Child Left Behind
Popularity of participatory school/classroom based research methods
Check/Schutt, Research Methods in Education
© 2012 SAGE Publications
Practical Significance
18
Five Sections
Introductory statement
Literature review
Methodological plan
Ethics statement
Statement of limitations
Check/Schutt, Research Methods in Education
© 2012 SAGE Publications
Educational Research Proposals
19
Authenticity
Debriefing
Deductive research
Dependent variable
Empirical generalization
Generalizability
Hypothesis
Independent variable
Inductive research
IRB
Practical Significance
Replication
Research circle
Educational research question
Theory
Validity
Variable
Check/Schutt, Research Methods in Education
© 2012 SAGE Publications
Key Terms
20