a 1500 word essay about the cost and benefit of olympic game(need do some reading)
724254675
2.pdf
The View Dispatch
24 TIME February 1, 2016
economy is in tatters, with projections that growth declined by some 3% in 2015. President Dilma Rousseff faces impeachment for allegedly violating budget laws. Its transport infrastructure is outdated. Rio’s waters are polluted, threatening the health of thousands of athletes and spectators who will de- scend upon the city for the Games. And now the country’s leaders are facing community opposition to the Games that are meant to be Rio’s showcase.
Vila Autódromo, settled as a fishing village along the Jacarepaguá Lagoon in 1967, now occupies prime water- front real estate in Rio’s upscale Barra da Tijuca neighborhood. Residents are convinced that after the Olympics, de- velopers will build luxury condos with sweeping views of the lagoon—condos none of them will ever live in.
In a visit in December, however, Vila Autódromo is in rubble. A tire, a closet, rags, bottles, a bathtub and other remnants of destroyed homes lie amid the rocks, tiles, smashed con- crete and mounds of dirt. A dog with
FROM THE ROOF OF HIS CONCRETE HOME, LUIZ CLAUDIO looks out at the bulldozers and construction cranes assem- bling the Olympic Park of Rio de Janeiro. (Opening ceremonies coming Aug. 5!) The sadness seeps through his sharp green eyes. Claudio points to a moss-covered entryway below, which is crowded with a bicycle, refrigerator, wheelbarrow and red couch with a stuffed animal dangling off the armrest. “I got married there,” Claudio says. The cove served as a community chapel for over a half-dozen years. And if the city of Rio had its way, it would be razed, along with the rest of Claudio’s home that he shares with his wife, mother-in-law, daughter, brother and sister, all to make room for the Olympic party this summer.
Claudio, 53, lives in Vila Autódromo, one of the hundreds of poor neighborhoods in Rio, or favelas, scattered across the streets and lush hills of a cidade maravilhosa (marvelous city). The backhoes have already leveled most of Vila Autódromo, leaving his community in ruins. According to the nonprofit World Cup and Olympics Popular Committee of Rio de Ja- neiro, throughout the city more than 4,100 families have been removed from their homes because of the Olympics.
But Claudio, who’s wearing a white T-shirt that reads RIO SEM REMOÇÕES (Rio Without Removals), and a few dozen other final holdouts refuse to leave, forcing a final standoff between
the city and impoverished Vila Autódromo residents. This matchup carries real-life consequences greater than any Olympic event.
Will the city forcefully evict the last Autódromo holdouts, a move not exactly in keeping with the Olympic spirit of fair play? Will it just build around the last rough- shod homes, threatening the pristine veneer this Brazilian megacity wants to splash all
over its Games, the first ever held in South America? Or will the city finally fulfill its vow to incorporate the favela into Olympic planning, and improve infrastructure and services within the community in ways that will last well after the Olympic flame has moved on?
Given that Vila Autódromo looks like a war zone, thanks to razing already well under way, that last outcome seems about as likely as a racewalker winning the 100-m sprint. “The Olympics are being used as a pretext,” says Claudio, “to destroy life stories.”
THE FATE OF THE FAVELAS is hardly the only challenge facing Rio’s beleaguered Olympic planners. The Brazilian
△ A partially demolished
building in Rio’s Vila Autódromo
neighborhood
The favela residents who won’t make room for the Olympics By Sean Gregory/Rio de Janeiro
‘When Rio got the Olympics, people in the favelas could feel change. But since 2013, the mask has been taken off.’ THERESA WILLIAMSON, executive director of Catalytic Communities and editor in chief of RioOnWatch.org
A t l a n t i c O c
e a n
BRAZIL
Rio de Janeiro
M A
R IO
T A
M A
— G
E T
T Y
IM A
G E
S
25
a bloodied, partially bitten-off ear scampers through the streets; people say he was the pet of a family who moved out. A nude doll sits atop a gutted wall. A rainy day turns streets into slop. “It looks like Afghanistan,” says Maria De Loures da Silva, a Vila Autódromo resident.
It may seem surprising that any- one would choose to stay put in such conditions. Especially when the gov- ernment is offering residents ei- ther cash compensation—Claudio says he’s heard his plot of land is worth $500,000—or relocation into government-sponsored housing in the area. Catalytic Communities—a Rio- based NGO that works with favelas— says that of the some 700 families that lived in Vila Autódromo before clear- ance began, around 40 remain. Why do they want to stay?
“When we got here, we had noth- ing,” says one resident who’s lived in the favela for 20 years and declined to give his name in fear of government retri- bution. “We developed this land.” He points out at his house. “There are 72 truckloads of earth in here. This home is everything to me.” While gangs still control many favelas, Vila Autódromo residents praise the safety of their com- munity. “Nothing justifies me leav- ing here,” says Sandra de Souza, who’s raised four daughters, ranging in ages from 11 to 20, in Vila Autódromo. “I don’t think the money they’re offering is valid. It’s dirty money.”
IN VILA AUTÓDROMO, residents ex- press their frustration through the graf- fiti scrawled all over shattered homes and the wall separating the Olympic construction zone from the neighbor- hood. A BARRA C/ POBRES A POLITICIA SEM CORRUPÇÃO (Barra [da Tijuca] with the poor, politics without corruption). AS OLIMPIADAS PASSAM A JUSTICIA FICA SUJA (The Olympics come, justice gets dirty). NÃO SOMOS BOBOS! SABEMOS QUEM ESTÁ NA LUTA E QUEM ESTÁ AQUI POR DINHEIRO! (We are not fools! We know who’s with us and who’s in it for the money!) RIO DE JANEIRO NA LAMA (Rio de Janeiro in the mud).
One message is scrawled in English, facing what used to be dozens of homes along the lagoon: GAME OVER.
Even an Olympic construction worker, who is benefiting from the burst of building, shares sympathy for the residents. “Brazil is a party,” he says while sipping on a beer in front of an Autódromo shop during a break. “But Olympic money could have gone to improving education or improv- ing security. They’re taking away the homes of these humble people to make this event.”
“When Rio got the Olympics, people in the favelas could feel change,” says Theresa Williamson, executive direc- tor of Catalytic Communities and editor in chief of RioOnWatch.org, a commu- nity reporting site. “There was a strong sense of hope across all economic brack- ets. But since 2013, the mask has been taken off. It’s become clear to many peo- ple that it was all a facade.”
In response to questions about promises to incorporate Vila Autó- dromo into Olympic planning, the uses of the community’s land before and after the Games, and the government’s response to residents who say they just want to stay and be left alone, a city of Rio spokesperson sent an email. “The families who had to leave Vila Autó- dromo were either on the route of the public lanes under construction or in areas of environmental protection by the lagoon,” the spokesperson wrote. The city government also noted that to resettle the residents, it built new housing—“with green areas, a swim- ming pool, a gourmet lounge, nursery and commercial space”—or offered compensation. “The negotiation pro- cess with the Vila Autódromo residents has always been transparent.”
Delmo de Oliveira doesn’t seem in- terested in any offers. As the Olympics encroach on his community, he pounds on a hammer while constructing an additional floor to his house. The city wants him out; de Oliveira doubles down. “If I leave now, how am I going to live?” de Oliveira says. “I have no other choice.” He says he won’t consider com- pensation. “They’re not trying to buy my house,” says de Oliveira. “They’re trying to buy my dignity.” NEM TODOS TEM UM PRECO, reads a sign on the side of his house.
Translation: Not everyone has a price. □
4,120 Number of Rio families
moved from their homes for the Olympics
4.5% Year-over-year drop in
Brazil’s GDP in the third quarter of 2015
$11.5 billion Estimated public
spending on Summer Olympics venues and
infrastructure in Rio
© Time Inc., 2016. All rights reserved. No part of this material may be duplicated or redisseminated without permission.
