Business w/healthcare case study5 pages not including title and reference page apa format

Needs Development

Fair

Good

Excellent

Introduction

Short introduction that does not cover the case scenario for the reader clearly, or missing introduction

0-2 points

Fair synopsis to introduce case – may need more details or be too lengthy.

3 points

Adequate synopsis to introduce case.

4 points

Brief, clear and succinct synopsis to introduce case.

5 points

Key Issues

Minimal to no detail covered for key issues.

0-2 points

Brief coverage on just one or a few key issues that need more thought and details.

3-6 points

Good succinct coverage of several key issues identified and explained.

7-9 points

Several strong points demonstrating critical thinking on several key issues covered succinctly.

10 points

Situation Analysis

Further details needed on the case situation.

0-4 points

Brief description of situation covered. Further analysis details needed.

5-9 points

Adequate case situation explained that also incorporates several areas of significance.

10-14 points

Detailed description summarizes the situation and covers probable causes and/or significant areas. Critical thinking is evident.

15 points

Organizational Strategy

Brief suggestion or two with impact of ideas on organizational strategy attempted.

0-4 points

Two short suggestions addressed to consider and some elements of organizational strategy impact covered. More details needed.

5-9 points

Elements of applicable organizational strategy covered for two suggestions that include pros/cons to consider and possible impact.

10-14 points

Elements of applicable organizational strategy to consider for three alternatives along with pros/cons and any possible ramifications of suggestions.

15 points

Implementation Plan

Further specifics and details needed on how to put suggestion(s) into place. Information may be brief or missing.

0-5 points

At least one feasible and realistic suggestion explained.

6-13 points

Several implementation suggestions covered in depth that incorporate some time elements to put ideas into place.

14-19 points

Detailed suggestions on how to implement recommendations that include time frames and possible contingency plan. Critical thinking demonstrated.

20 points

Benchmarks to Measure Success

Further details needed. Benchmark suggestions may be brief or missing.

0-4 points

Brief monitoring points are addressed to measure progress and success.

5-9 points

Some realistic monitoring plan suggestions are covered.

10-14 points

Monitoring and measure action plan suggestions show insight and are realistic to demonstrate critical thinking.

15 points

Scholarly Research of Literature

Required scholarly research of literature was not met. Some research attempt evident,and/or only text is referred to.

0-5 points

Credible outside research evident. Two scholarly research sources may not have been met.

6-13 points

Scholarly research for two recent peer-reviewed journal articles was met. Other credible outside research may be evident.

14-19 points

Scholarly research for three recent peer-reviewed journal articles was met and applied in various elements of analysis. There may be additional credible outside research support applied.

20 points

Writing Mechanics

More than 11 writing errors including grammar, punctuation, and spelling. Writing may be unfocused and contain serious errors, lacks detail and information, and may be poorly organized.

0-4 points

5-10 writing errors including grammar, punctuation, and spelling. Writing may not be clear or concise, contains numerous errors, lacks information and/or organization.

5-9 points

1-4 writing errors including grammar, punctuation, and spelling. Writing is accomplished and contains only a few errors. Includes sufficient details and well organized.

10-14 points

Free of writing errors including grammar, punctuation, and spelling. Writing is organized, clear and concise with thorough details.

15 points

APA

Have over 12 APA issues.

0-4 points

6-11 APA issues

5-9 points

2-5 APA issues

10-14 points

Zero to 1 APA issues – Proper APA format used, and APA reference sources and in-text cites requirements met. Headings applied for rubric areas.

15 points