Business w/healthcare DQ 475 words w 3 references apa
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT OF
HEALTH CARE ORGANIZATIONS 7TH EDITION
*
Developing Strategic Alternatives
Chapter 6
*
- Understand and discuss the steps involved in the decision logic of strategy development.
Chapter 6 Learning Objectives
- Understand and discuss the steps involved in the decision logic of strategy development.
- Synthesize and integrate strategic thinking accomplished in situational analysis into a strategic plan for an organization.
Chapter 6 Learning Objectives
- Understand and discuss the steps involved in the decision logic of strategy development.
- Synthesize and integrate strategic thinking accomplished in situational analysis into a strategic plan for an organization.
- Identify the hierarchy of strategies and strategic decisions required in strategic planning.
Chapter 6 Learning Objectives
Understand and discuss the steps involved in the decision logic of strategy development.
Synthesize and integrate strategic thinking accomplished in situational analysis into a strategic plan for an organization.
Identify the hierarchy of strategies and strategic decisions required in strategic planning.
Understand the nature of directional strategies, adaptive strategies, market entry strategies, and competitive strategies.
Chapter 6 Learning Objectives
- Identify strategic alternatives available to health care organizations.
Chapter 6 Learning Objectives
- Identify strategic alternatives available to health care organizations.
- Provide the rationale as well as advantages and disadvantages for each of the strategic alternatives.
Chapter 6 Learning Objectives
Identify strategic alternatives available to health care organizations.
Provide the rationale as well as advantages and disadvantages for each of the strategic alternatives.
Understand that strategies may have to be used in combination to accomplish the organization’s goals.
Chapter 6 Learning Objectives
- Identify strategic alternatives available to health care organizations.
- Provide the rationale as well as advantages and disadvantages for each of the strategic alternatives.
- Understand that strategies may have to be used in combination to accomplish the organization’s goals.
- Map strategic decisions showing how they are linked as an ends–means chain.
Chapter 6 Learning Objectives
The Strategic Planning Process
Strategic Planning
Situation Analysis
Strategy Formulation
Planning the Implementation
External Analysis
Internal Analysis
Directional Strategies
Directional Strategies
Adaptive Strategies
Market Entry Strategies
Competitive Strategies
Service Delivery Strategies
Support Strategies
Action Plans
*
Strategy Formulation
Strategy formulation is the deciding what the organization should explicitly be doing
- What the organization is NOW doing but should STOP doing?
- What is the organization NOT doing but should START doing?
- What the organization is currently doing that should be DONE
DIFFERENTLY?
*
Linking Today and Tomorrow
Profile of Today
Vision (hope
for the future)
Profile of
Tomorrow
Strategy
year
1
year
2
year
3
year
4
year
5
plans
plans
plans
budgets
budgets
budgets
budgets
budgets
plans
plans
plans
plans
plans
plans
plans
budgets
budgets
budgets
budgets
budgets
*
Linking Strategic Alternatives
| Check List | Strategy 1 | Strategy 2 | Strategy 3 |
| Addresses an External Issue? | |||
| Draws on a Competitive Advantage or Fixes a Competitive Disadvantage? | |||
| Fits with Mission, Values? | |||
| Moves the Organization Toward the Vision? | |||
| Achieves One or More Strategic Goals? |
Decision Logic of Strategy Formulation
Directional
Strategies
Adaptive
Strategies
Market Entry
Strategies
Competitive
Strategies
Implementation
Strategies
Strategy
Formulation
Strategy
Implementation
Decision Logic of Strategy Formulation
Directional
Strategies
Adaptive
Strategies
Market Entry
Strategies
Competitive
Strategies
Implementation
Strategies
Ends Means Ends Means
Ends Means Ends Means
Strategy
Formulation
Strategy
Implementation
Strategy Formulation
| Directional Strategies | The broadest strategies that set the fundamental direction of the organization by establishing a mission for the organization (Who are we?) and vision for the future (What should we be?). In addition, directional strategies specify the organization’s values and the strategic goals. |
Strategy Formulation
| Directional Strategies | The broadest strategies that set the fundamental direction of the organization by establishing a mission for the organization (Who are we?) and vision for the future (What should we be?). In addition, directional strategies specify the organization’s values and the strategic goals. |
| Adaptive Strategies | These strategies are more specific than directional strategies and provide the primary methods for achieving the vision (adapting to the environment). These strategies determine the scope of the organization and specify how the organization will expand scope, reduce scope, or maintain scope. |
Strategy Formulation
| Market Entry Strategies | These strategies provide the method of carrying out the adaptive strategies (expansion of scope and the maintenance of scope strategies) through purchase, cooperation, or internal development. Market entry strategies are not used for reduction of scope strategies. |
Strategy Formulation
| Market Entry Strategies | These strategies provide the method of carrying out the adaptive strategies (expansion of scope and the maintenance of scope strategies) through purchase, cooperation, or internal development. Market entry strategies are not used for reduction of scope strategies. |
| Competitive Strategies | Two types of strategies, one that determines an organization’s strategic posture and one that positions the organization vis-à-vis other organizations within the market. These strategies are market oriented and best articulate competitive advantage. |
Planning the Implementation
| Implementation Strategies | These strategies are the most specific strategies and are directed toward value added service delivery and the value added support areas. In addition, individual organizational units develop objectives and action plans that carry out the value added service delivery and value added support strategies. |
Strategic Thinking Map
Hierarchy of Strategic Decisions and Alternatives
Directional Strategies
- Mission
- Vision
- Values
- Goals
Implementation Strategies
Service Delivery
- Pre-service
- Point-of-service
- After-service
Support
- Culture
- Structure
- Strategic resources
Unit Action Plans
- Objectives
- Actions
- Timelines
- Responsibilities
Competitive Strategies
Strategic Posture
- Defender
- Prospector
- Analyzer
- (Reactor)
Positioning
Market-wide
- Cost leadership
- Differentiation
Market Segment
- Focus/Cost
leadership
- Focus/
differentiation
Market Entry Strategies
Purchase
- Acquisition
- Licensing
- Venture capital
investment
Cooperation
- Merger
- Alliance
- Joint venture
Development
- Internal
development
- Internal
venture
Adaptive Strategies
Expansion of Scope
- Diversification
- Vertical Integration
- Market Development
- Product Development
- Penetration
Contraction of Scope
- Divestiture
- Liquidation
- Harvesting
- Retrenchment
Maintenance of Scope
- Enhancement
- Status Quo
*
Normative Model of
Strategy Formulation
Strategy Formulation Example Decisions
Directional Strategies
Organizational Scope
Strategies
Marketing Entry
Strategies
Competitive Strategies
Implementation Strategies
Strategy
Content
Mission, Vision, Values
Diversification, Vertical
Integration
Acquisition, Alliance,
Merger
Cost Leadership, Defender
Marketing, Structure
Strategic Thinking Map
Hierarchy of Strategic Decisions and Alternatives
Directional Strategies
- Mission
- Vision
- Values
- Goals
Adaptive Strategies
Expansion of Scope
- Diversification
- Vertical Integration
- Market Development
- Product Development
- Penetration
Contraction of Scope
- Divestiture
- Liquidation
- Harvesting
- Retrenchment
Maintenance of Scope
- Enhancement
- Status Quo
*
Adaptive Strategic Alternatives – Expansion
Expansion of Scope Types
Diversification
Vertical Integration
Market Development
Product Development
Penetration
Related
Unrelated
Forward
Backward
Geographic
Segment
Product Line
Product Enhancements
Promotion
Distribution
Pricing
Adaptive Strategies – Expansion
| Strategy | Definition | Rationale |
| Related Diversification | Adding new related product or service categories. Often requires the establishment of a new division | Pursuit of high-growth markets Entering less-regulated segments Cannot achieve current objectives Synergy is possible from new business Offset seasonal or cyclical influences |
Adaptive Strategies – Expansion
| Strategy | Definition | Rationale |
| Related Diversification | Adding new related product or service categories. Often requires the establishment of a new division | Pursuit of high-growth markets Entering less-regulated segments Cannot achieve current objectives Synergy is possible from new business Offset seasonal or cyclical influences |
| Unrelated Diversification | Adding new unrelated product or service categories. Typically requires the establishment of a new division | Pursuit of high-growth markets Entering less-regulated segments Cannot achieve current objectives Current markets are saturated or in decline Organization has excess cash Antitrust regulations prohibit expansion in current industry Tax loss may be acquired |
Adaptive Strategies – Expansion
| Strategy | Definition | Rationale |
| Backward Vertical Integration | Adding new members along the distribution channel (toward a later stage) for present products and services or controlling the flow of patients from one institution to another | Control the flow of patients through the system Scarcity of raw materials or essential inventory/supplies Deliveries are unreliable Lack of materials or supplies will shut down operations Price or quality of materials or supplies variable Industry/market seen as profitable for long term |
Adaptive Strategies – Expansion
| Strategy | Definition | Rationale |
| Backward Vertical Integration | Adding new members along the distribution channel (toward a later stage) for present products and services or controlling the flow of patients from one institution to another | Control the flow of patients through the system Scarcity of raw materials or essential inventory/supplies Deliveries are unreliable Lack of materials or supplies will shut down operations Price or quality of materials or supplies variable Industry/market seen as profitable for long term |
| Forward Vertical Integration | Adding new members along the distribution channel (toward an earlier stage) for present products and services or controlling the flow of patients from one institution to another | Control the flow of patients through the system Faster delivery required High level of coordination required between one stage and another – secure needed resources Industry/market seen as profitable for long term Gain bargaining power |
Hospital Vertical Integration
Hospital
Strategic
Business Unit
Upstream Downstream
Urgent Care
Unit
Primary Care
Unit
Wellness/
Health Promotion
Unit
Skilled
Nursing
Unit
Rehabilitation
Unit
Home Health
Unit
Adaptive Strategies – Expansion
| Strategy | Definition | Rationale |
| Market Development | Introducing present products or services into new geographic markets or to new segments within a present geographic market | New markets are available for present products Provide comprehensive services across the market (focus factory) New markets may be served efficiently Expected high revenues Organization has cost leadership advantage Organization has differentiation advantage Current market is growing |
Fundamental Expansion Strategies
Products
Old New
Markets
Old
New
Market
Development
Adaptive Strategies – Expansion
| Strategy | Definition | Rationale |
| Market Development | Introducing present products or services into new geographic markets or to new segments within a present geographic market | New markets are available for present products Provide comprehensive services across the market (focus factory) New markets may be served efficiently Expected high revenues Organization has cost leadership advantage Organization has differentiation advantage Current market is growing |
| Product Development | Improving present products or services or extending the present product line | Currently in strong market but product is weak or product line incomplete Market tastes are changing Product technology is changing Maintenance or creation of differentiation advantage |
Fundamental Expansion Strategies
Products
Old New
Markets
Old
New
Market
Development
Product
Development
Key Strategic Thinking Questions
Remember to draw upon the results of external analysis, internal analysis, and development of directional strategies
| Questions | Products/Services Strategies | Internal Processes |
| Stop doing? | ||
| Start doing? | ||
| Continue doing? | ||
| Do differently? |
*
Services versus Customers
CONTRACT/
EXPAND
Two-Phase Refocus
CONTRACT/
EXPAND
Two-Phase Refocus
CONTRACT
MAINTAIN
CONTRACT
Change Focus
CONTRACT
Getting Out
Change Focus
Reduce Costs
Improve Efficiency
Improve Quality
EXPAND
New Markets Refocus
New Services
New Services
& Markets
EXPAND
EXPAND
Reduce Types
or Number of
Customers
Keep Types or
Number of
Customers Same
Add New
Customers
Reduce
Programs or
Services
Keep
Programs or
Services
the Same
Add New
Programs or
Services
Adaptive Strategies – Expansion
| Strategy | Definition | Rationale |
| Penetration | Seeking to increase market share for present products or services in present markets through marketing efforts (promotion, channels, or price) | Present market is growing Product/service innovation will extend product life cycle (PLC) Expected revenues are high Organization has cost leadership advantage Organization has differentiation advantage |
Fundamental Expansion Strategies
Products
Old New
Markets
Old
New
Penetration
Strategies
Market
Development
Product
Development
Fundamental Expansion Strategies
Products
Old New
Markets
Old
New
Penetration
Strategies
Market
Development
Product
Development
Diversification
Adaptive Strategic Alternatives – Contraction
Contraction of Scope Types
Divestiture
Liquidation
Harvesting
Retrenchment
Total
Partial
Operations
Assets
Fast
Slow
Markets
Products
Adaptive Strategies – Contraction
| Strategy | Definition | Rationale |
| Divestiture | Selling an operating unit or division to another organization. Typically, the unit will continue in operation | Industry in long-term decline Cash needed to enter new, higher growth area Lack of expected synergy with core operation Required investment in new technology seen as too high Too much regulation Unbundling |
Adaptive Strategies – Contraction
| Strategy | Definition | Rationale |
| Divestiture | Selling an operating unit or division to another organization. Typically, the unit will continue in operation | Industry in long-term decline Cash needed to enter new, higher growth area Lack of expected synergy with core operation Required investment in new technology seen as too high Too much regulation Unbundling |
| Liquidation | Selling all or part of the organization’s assets (facilities, inventory, equipment, and so on) in order to obtain cash. The purchaser may use the assets in a variety of ways and businesses | Organization can no longer operate Bankruptcy Trim/reduce assets Superseded by new technology |
Adaptive Strategies – Contraction
| Strategy | Definition | Rationale |
| Harvesting | Products or services typically in late stages of the product life cycle (late maturity and decline) where industry-wide revenues are expected to decline. These products or services will ultimately be discontinued but may generate revenue for some time. Few new resources are allocated to these areas | Late maturity/decline of the product life cycle Consider divestiture or downsizing Short-term cash needed |
Adaptive Strategies – Contraction
| Strategy | Definition | Rationale |
| Harvesting | Products or services typically in late stages of the product life cycle (late maturity and decline) where industry-wide revenues are expected to decline. These products or services will ultimately be discontinued but may generate revenue for some time. Few new resources are allocated to these areas | Late maturity/decline of the product life cycle Consider divestiture or downsizing Short-term cash needed |
| Retrenchment | Reducing the scope of operations, redefining the target market, cutting geographic coverage, reducing the segments served, or reducing the product line | Market has become too diverse Market is too geographically spread out Personnel costs are too high Too many products or services Marginal or nonproductive facilities |
Adaptive Strategic Alternatives – Maintenance
Maintenance of Scope
Enhancement
Status Quo
Quality
Efficiency
Innovation
Speed
Flexibility
Adaptive Strategies – Maintenance
| Strategy | Definition | Rationale |
| Enhancement | Seeking to improve operations within present product or service categories through quality programs, increasing flexibility, increasing efficiency, speed of delivery, and so on | Organization has operational inefficiencies Need to lower costs Need to improve quality Improve internal processes |
Adaptive Strategies - Maintenance
| Strategy | Definition | Rationale |
| Enhancement | Seeking to improve operations within present product or service categories through quality programs, increasing flexibility, increasing efficiency, speed of delivery, and so on | Organization has operational inefficiencies Need to lower costs Need to improve quality Improve internal processes |
| Status quo | Seeking to maintain relative market share within a market | Maintain market share position Maturity/late maturity stage of the product life cycle Product/market generating cash but has little potential for future growth Extremely competitive market |
Strategic Thinking Map
Hierarchy of Strategic Decisions and Alternatives
Directional Strategies
- Mission
- Vision
- Values
- Goals
Market Entry Strategies
Purchase
- Acquisition
- Licensing
- Venture capital
investment
Cooperation
- Merger
- Alliance
- Joint venture
Development
- Internal
development
- Internal
venture
Adaptive Strategies
Expansion of Scope
- Diversification
- Vertical Integration
- Market Development
- Product Development
- Penetration
Contraction of Scope
- Divestiture
- Liquidation
- Harvesting
- Retrenchment
Maintenance of Scope
- Enhancement
- Status Quo
*
Market Entry Strategies – Purchase
Directional Strategies
- Mission
- Vision
- Values
- Goals
Market Entry Strategies
Purchase
- Acquisition
- Licensing
- Venture capital
investment
Cooperation
- Merger
- Alliance
- Joint venture
Development
- Internal
development
- Internal
venture
Adaptive Strategies
Expansion of Scope
- Diversification
- Vertical Integration
- Market Development
- Product Development
- Penetration
Contraction of Scope
- Divestiture
- Liquidation
- Harvesting
- Retrenchment
Maintenance of Scope
- Enhancement
- Status Quo
Market Entry Strategies – Purchase
| Market Entry Strategy | Definition | Major Advantages | Major Disadvantages |
| Acquisition | Strategy to grow through the purchase of an existing organization, unit of an organization, or a product/service | Rapid market entry Image already established Performance known before purchase | New business may be unfamiliar to parent Takes a long time to assimilate organization’s culture New management team may be required High initial cost |
Market Entry Strategies – Purchase
| Market Entry Strategy | Definition | Major Advantages | Major Disadvantages |
| Acquisition | Strategy to grow through the purchase of an existing organization, unit of an organization, or a product/service | Rapid market entry Image already established Performance known before purchase | New business may be unfamiliar to parent Takes a long time to assimilate organization’s culture New management team may be required High initial cost |
| Licensing | Acquiring or providing an asset (technology, market, equipment, etc.) through contract | Rapid access to proven technology Reduced financial exposure Access to brand name Exclusive territory | Not a substitute for internal technical competence Not proprietary technology Dependent on licensor Rules and regulations |
Market Entry Strategies – Purchase
| Market Entry Strategy | Definition | Major Advantages | Major Disadvantages |
| Acquisition | Strategy to grow through the purchase of an existing organization, unit of an organization, or a product/service | Rapid market entry Image already established Performance known before purchase | New business may be unfamiliar to parent Takes a long time to assimilate organization’s culture New management team may be required High initial cost |
| Licensing | Acquiring or providing an asset (technology, market, equipment, etc.) through contract | Rapid access to proven technology Reduced financial exposure Access to brand name Exclusive territory | Not a substitute for internal technical competence Not proprietary technology Dependent on licensor Rules and regulations |
| Venture Capital Investment | Financial investment in an organization in order to participate in its growth or receipt of venture capital for startup or expansion | Can provide window on new technology or market Low risk | Alone, unlikely to be a major stimulus of growth Extended time to profitability |
Market Entry Strategies – Cooperation
Directional Strategies
- Mission
- Vision
- Values
- Goals
Market Entry Strategies
Purchase
- Acquisition
- Licensing
- Venture capital
investment
Cooperation
- Merger
- Alliance
- Joint venture
Development
- Internal
development
- Internal
venture
Adaptive Strategies
Expansion of Scope
- Diversification
- Vertical Integration
- Market Development
- Product Development
- Penetration
Contraction of Scope
- Divestiture
- Liquidation
- Harvesting
- Retrenchment
Maintenance of Scope
- Enhancement
- Status Quo
Market Entry Strategies – Cooperation
| Market Entry Strategy | Definition | Major Advantages | Major Disadvantages |
| Merger | Combining two (or more) organizations through mutual agreement to form a single new organization | Uses existing resources Retains existing markets and products Reduces competition | Takes a long time to merge cultures Merger match often difficult to find |
Market Entry Strategies – Cooperation
| Market Entry Strategy | Definition | Major Advantages | Major Disadvantages |
| Merger | Combining two (or more) organizations through mutual agreement to form a single new organization | Uses existing resources Retains existing markets and products Reduces competition | Takes a long time to merge cultures Merger match often difficult to find |
| Alliance | Formation of a formal partnership | Fills in gaps in product line Creates efficiencies (e.g., bargaining power) Reduces competition in weak markets Stabilizes referral base Shared risk | Potential for conflict between members Limits potential markets/products Difficult to align resources Governance issues |
Market Entry Strategies – Cooperation
| Market Entry Strategy | Definition | Major Advantages | Major Disadvantages |
| Merger | Combining two (or more) organizations through mutual agreement to form a single new organization | Uses existing resources Retains existing markets and products Reduces competition | Takes a long time to merge cultures Merger match often difficult to find |
| Alliance | Formation of a formal partnership | Fills in gaps in product line Creates efficiencies (e.g., bargaining power) Reduces competition in weak markets Stabilizes referral base Shared risk | Potential for conflict between members Limits potential markets/products Difficult to align resources Governance issues |
| Joint Venture | Combination of the resources of two or more organizations to accomplish a designated task | Technological/marketing joint ventures can exploit small/large organizational synergies Spreads distribution risks | Potential for conflict between partners (shared vs. proprietary) Objectives of partners may not be compatible |
Market Entry Strategies – Development
Directional Strategies
- Mission
- Vision
- Values
- Goals
Market Entry Strategies
Purchase
- Acquisition
- Licensing
- Venture capital
investment
Cooperation
- Merger
- Alliance
- Joint venture
Development
- Internal
development
- Internal
venture
Adaptive Strategies
Expansion of Scope
- Diversification
- Vertical Integration
- Market Development
- Product Development
- Penetration
Contraction of Scope
- Divestiture
- Liquidation
- Harvesting
- Retrenchment
Maintenance of Scope
- Enhancement
- Status Quo
Market Entry Strategies – Development
| Market Entry Strategy | Definition | Major Advantages | Major Disadvantages |
| Internal Development | Products or services developed internally using the organization’s own resources | Uses (leverages) existing resources Organization maintains a high level of control Presents image of developing (growth) organization | Time lag to break even Unfamiliarity with new markets Obtaining significant gains in market shares against strong competitors may be difficult |
Market Entry Strategies – Development
| Market Entry Strategy | Definition | Major Advantages | Major Disadvantages |
| Internal Development | Products or services developed internally using the organization’s own resources | Uses (leverages) existing resources Organization maintains a high level of control Presents image of developing (growth) organization | Time lag to break even Unfamiliarity with new markets Obtaining significant gains in market shares against strong competitors may be difficult |
| Internal Venture | Establishment of an independent entity within an organization to develop products or services | Uses existing resources May enable organization to hold a talented entrepreneur Isolates development from organization’s bureaucracy | Mixed record of success Organization’s internal climate (culture) often unsuitable |
Market Entry Strategies – Development
| Market Entry Strategy | Definition | Major Advantages | Major Disadvantages |
| Internal Development | Products or services developed internally using the organization’s own resources | Uses (leverages) existing resources Organization maintains a high level of control Presents image of developing (growth) organization | Time lag to break even Unfamiliarity with new markets Obtaining significant gains in market shares against strong competitors may be difficult |
| Internal Venture | Establishment of an independent entity within an organization to develop products or services | Uses existing resources May enable organization to hold a talented entrepreneur Isolates development from organization’s bureaucracy | Mixed record of success Organization’s internal climate (culture) often unsuitable |
| Reconfigure the value chain | Changing the activities or sequence of activities in the value chain and therefore change how value is delivered to the customer. | New approach may not be seen as a threat by existing competitors Captures a special niche of the market May create low-cost business model | Not always possible Initially must focus on a niche rather than entire market Must be first to recognize the new business model |
Strategic Thinking Map
Hierarchy of Strategic Decisions and Alternatives
Directional Strategies
- Mission
- Vision
- Values
- Goals
Competitive Strategies
Strategic Posture
- Defender
- Prospector
- Analyzer
- (Reactor)
Positioning
Market-wide
- Cost leadership
- Differentiation
Market Segment
- Focus/Cost
leadership
- Focus/
differentiation
Market Entry Strategies
Purchase
- Acquisition
- Licensing
- Venture capital
investment
Cooperation
- Merger
- Alliance
- Joint venture
Development
- Internal
development
- Internal
venture
Adaptive Strategies
Expansion of Scope
- Diversification
- Vertical Integration
- Market Development
- Product Development
- Penetration
Contraction of Scope
- Divestiture
- Liquidation
- Harvesting
- Retrenchment
Maintenance of Scope
- Enhancement
- Status Quo
*
Strategic Thinking Map
Hierarchy of Strategic Decisions and Alternatives
Directional Strategies
- Mission
- Vision
- Values
- Goals
Competitive Strategies
Strategic Posture
- Defender
- Prospector
- Analyzer
- (Reactor)
Positioning
Market-wide
- Cost leadership
- Differentiation
Market Segment
- Focus/Cost
leadership
- Focus/
differentiation
Market Entry Strategies
Purchase
- Acquisition
- Licensing
- Venture capital
investment
Cooperation
- Merger
- Alliance
- Joint venture
Development
- Internal
development
- Internal
venture
Adaptive Strategies
Expansion of Scope
- Diversification
- Vertical Integration
- Market Development
- Product Development
- Penetration
Contraction of Scope
- Divestiture
- Liquidation
- Harvesting
- Retrenchment
Maintenance of Scope
- Enhancement
- Status Quo
*
Strategic Postures
| Strategic Posture | Definition | Advantages | Disadvantages |
| Defender | Focus on a narrow market with limited number of products or services and aggressively defend this segment through pricing or differentiation | Focus on limited set of products and services Focus is on narrow market segment Stable environment Difficult for competitors to enter this segment | Reliance on the success of narrow product line Must have long/sustaining product life cycles Market segment must be stable – slow change May be unable to respond to major market/industry shifts Difficult to enter new markets or technologies |
Strategic Postures
| Strategic Posture | Definition | Advantages | Disadvantages |
| Defender | Focus on a narrow market with limited number of products or services and aggressively defend this segment through pricing or differentiation | Focus on limited set of products and services Focus is on narrow market segment Stable environment Difficult for competitors to enter this segment | Reliance on the success of narrow product line Must have long/sustaining product life cycles Market segment must be stable – slow change May be unable to respond to major market/industry shifts Difficult to enter new markets or technologies |
| Prospector | Continuously seek out new products and new markets | Always involved in “cutting-edge” developments Organization changes with changing environment Allows for a rapid response to a changing environment | Organization is in constant state of change New products and markets always being developed Multiple technologies being employed, seldom able to achieve efficiency Tend to have lower profits because of continuous change Tend to overextend resources Tend to underutilize financial, human, and physical resources |
Strategic Postures
| Strategic Posture | Definition | Advantages | Disadvantages |
| Analyzer | Balance market defense in some markets with selectively entering a limited number of markets or products | Allows for the maintenance of a core of stable traditional products and services Allows for high-risk products and services to be borne by prospectors Lower investment in research and development | Difficult strategy to pursue Must respond quickly to follow lead of key prospector while maintaining efficiency in core products/services Complex structure (matrix) Management of both stable and dynamic products and markets Communication is often difficult |
Strategic Postures
| Strategic Posture | Definition | Advantages | Disadvantages |
| Analyzer | Balance market defense in some markets with selectively entering a limited number of markets or products | Allows for the maintenance of a core of stable traditional products and services Allows for high-risk products and services to be borne by prospectors Lower investment in research and development | Difficult strategy to pursue Must respond quickly to follow lead of key prospector while maintaining efficiency in core products/services Complex structure (matrix) Management of both stable and dynamic products and markets Communication is often difficult |
| Reactor | Reacts to the strategies of competitors | Little strategic planning required (monopolistic or highly regulated environment) | Inconsistency in response to environmental change Instability in organization Organization becomes both ineffective and inefficient No effective guide for decision making |
Positioning Strategies
Directional Strategies
- Mission
- Vision
- Values
- Goals
Competitive Strategies
Strategic Posture
- Defender
- Prospector
- Analyzer
- (Reactor)
Positioning
Market-wide
- Cost leadership
- Differentiation
Market Segment
- Focus/Cost
leadership
- Focus/
differentiation
Market Entry Strategies
Purchase
- Acquisition
- Licensing
- Venture capital
investment
Cooperation
- Merger
- Alliance
- Joint venture
Development
- Internal
development
- Internal
venture
Adaptive Strategies
Expansion of Scope
- Diversification
- Vertical Integration
- Market Development
- Product Development
- Penetration
Contraction of Scope
- Divestiture
- Liquidation
- Harvesting
- Retrenchment
Maintenance of Scope
- Enhancement
- Status Quo
Positioning Strategies
| Positioning Strategy | Definition | Major Advantages | Major Disadvantages |
| Cost Leadership | Low-cost/price strategy directed toward entire market | Provides clear competitive advantage Provides clear market position Provides opportunities to spend more than competition | Must obtain large volume Product/service must be standardized Product/service may be viewed as low quality |
Positioning Strategies
| Positioning Strategy | Definition | Major Advantages | Major Disadvantages |
| Cost Leadership | Low-cost/price strategy directed toward entire market | Provides clear competitive advantage Provides clear market position Provides opportunities to spend more than competition | Must obtain large volume Product/service must be standardized Product/service may be viewed as low quality |
| Differentiation | Development of unique product/service features directed toward entire market | Product/service viewed as unique Often viewed as high quality Greater control over pricing | Often difficult to adequately differentiate product or service Product/service may be higher priced |
Positioning Strategies
| Positioning Strategy | Definition | Major Advantages | Major Disadvantages |
| Focus – Cost Leadership | Low-cost/price strategy directed toward a particular market segment | Appeals to market segment seeking low price May develop good relations with market | Low quality may be associated low price Expansion of market may be difficult |
Positioning Strategies
| Positioning Strategy | Definition | Major Advantages | Major Disadvantages |
| Focus – Cost Leadership | Low-cost/price strategy directed toward a particular market segment | Appeals to market segment seeking low price May develop good relations with market | Low quality may be associated low price Expansion of market may be difficult |
| Focus -- Differentiation | Development of unique product/service features directed toward a particular market segment | Product/service may be customized to the special needs of the segment May develop close relationship with market segment | Market segment may remain small Price will probably be high |
Strategy Combinations and Phases
Today Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Time
SSU 1
SSU 2
SSU 3
Retrenchment (Product)
Market Development
Market
Development
Vertical Integration (forward)
Market
Development
Harvesting/Divest
Cash
Boundary Set by
Mission/Vision
Boundary Set by
Mission/Vision
External Environment
External Environment
Chapter 6 Conclusions
After reading Chapter 6, you should be able to define the following terms:
| Key Terms | Key Terms |
| Acquisition | Cooperation Strategy |
| Adaptive Strategy | Cost Leadership |
| Alliance | Defender Strategic Posture |
| Analyzer Strategic Posture | Development Strategy |
| Backward Vertical Integration | Differentiation |
| Combination Strategy | Diversification |
| Competitive Strategy | Divestiture |
| Concentric Diversification | Ends-Means Chain |
| Conglomerate Diversification | Enhancement |
*
Chapter 6 Conclusions
After reading Chapter 6, you should be able to define the following terms:
| Key Terms | Key Terms |
| Expansion of Scope Strategy | Internal Venture |
| Focused Factory | Joint Venture |
| Focus Strategy | Licensing |
| Forward Vertical integration | Liquidation |
| Generic Strategy | Maintenance of Scope Strategy |
| Harvesting | Market Development |
| Horizontal Integration | Market Entry Strategy |
| Implementation Strategy | Marketwide Strategy |
| Internal Development | Merger |
Chapter 6 Conclusions
After reading Chapter 6, you should be able to define the following terms:
| Key Terms | Key Terms |
| Penetration Strategy | Related Diversification |
| Positioning Strategy | Retrenchment |
| Product Development | Status Quo |
| Prospector Strategic Posture | Strategic Posture |
| Purchase Strategy | Strategy Formulation |
| Reactor Strategic Posture | Unrelated Diversification |
| Reconfigure the Value Chain | Venture Capital Investment |
| Reduction of Scope Strategy | Vertical Integration |
Assignment
Using the Strategic Thinking Map – Hierarchy of Strategic Decisions and Alternatives in Chapter 6 as a guide, find examples of three types of strategies (for example, market development, merger, alliance) from the popular literature.
Good sources of healthcare strategy examples include The Wall Street Journal, Business Week, your local newspaper, or one of several health care periodicals.
You may also use website searches.
*