read1

Criterion

Points Possible

Points

Given

Instructor Comments

Format: sections are within the word count limit (250–300 words). Paper is double-spaced with 1-inch margins and 12 pt. Times New Roman font. File is properly saved as specified in the instructions. The template is properly used to compose the paper.

15

The purpose of the article is clearly and correctly identified.

10

Demonstration of an understanding of the major arguments and thesis of the article is shown.

25

The strengths and weaknesses of the article are properly assessed.

20

You have concluded your critique with a summary statement on the overall effectiveness of the article.

10

You have clearly identified where you stand on the topic.

10

You have clearly articulated your position and provided adequate biblical and theological support.

45

You are aware of and have responded to the main objections to your position.

15

Total

150