Case analysis

ûý õ# #

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�##4<<:/#,YH\#0DQDJHPHQW#6HUYLFHV# 9HUVLRQ=#+$,#533503<063# # # # 7KH#GD\#DIWHU#KLV#JURXS¶V#4<<7#&KULVWPDV#SDUW\/#&KXFN#0DF.LQQRQ/#D#PDQDJLQJ# GLUHFWRU#ZLWK#WKH#0HUFKDQW#%DQN#RI#&DQDGD#+0%&,#LQ#1HZ#<RUN/#ZRQGHUHG#KRZ# ERWK#KLV#JURXS#DQG#KLV#FDUHHU#KDG#EHFRPH#VR#VHULRXVO\#GHUDLOHG1#7KH#QLJKW#EHIRUH/# KH#KDG#ZLWQHVVHG#WKH#YLUWXDO#GLVLQWHJUDWLRQ#RI#D#JURXS#WKDW#KH#KDG#ZRUNHG#GLOLJHQWO\# WR#PRXOG#LQWR#D#IXOO\#IXQFWLRQLQJ#WHDP1#&KXFN#NQHZ#KLV#FDUHHU#DQG#KLV#SHUVRQDO# OLIH/#DV#ZHOO#DV#WKH#JURXS¶V#VXUYLYDO/#GHSHQGHG#RQ#KRZ#KH#DGGUHVVHG#WKH#PXOWLWXGH# RI#SHRSOH#SUREOHPV#ZKLFK#KH#WKRXJKW#KDG#EHHQ#UHVROYHG/#EXW#ZKLFK#KH#QRZ#NQHZ# KDG#RQO\#EHHQ#O\LQJ#LQ#ZDLW/#MXVW#EHORZ#WKH#VXUIDFH1#$V#KH#SRQGHUHG#WKH#SUHYLRXV# QLJKW¶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¶V#PHUJHU#ZLWK# WKH#0HUFKDQW# %DQN#RI#&DQDGD/#0DF.LQQRQ#ZDV#RIIHUHG#DQG#DFFHSWHG#D#SRVLWLRQ#PDQDJLQJ#D#IXOO# VHUYLFH#EUDQFK#RI#0%&#LQ#6DXGL#$UDELD1#

3DJH#5# <$<;&335# # #

7KH#6DXGL#$UDELDQ#PRQWKV/#&KXFN¶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³ZHQW#EDOOLVWLF´#DERXW# &KXFN#QRW#FDOOLQJ#KLP#ILUVW1#$V#KH#UHIOHFWHG#RQ#WKH#VLWXDWLRQ/#&KXFN#QRWHG=# #

,PPHGLDWHO\#,#ZDV#SXW#RII#E\#KRZ#WKH#%DQN#ZDV#QRW#GHDOLQJ#ZLWK# WKHVH#SUREOHPV/#VHHPLQJO\#DOORZLQJ#WKHP#WR#KDSSHQ/#DQG#DFFHSWLQJ# LW>#DQG#WKHQ#HYHQ#JHWWLQJ#DQJU\#ZLWK#LW#EHLQJ#VXUIDFHG#1#1#1#1#)URP#WKH# EHJLQQLQJ#,#ZDV#QHYHU#RQ#VROLG#JURXQG#RQ#KRZ#ZH#ZDQWHG#WR#GHDO# ZLWK#WKLV#NLQG#RI#VWXII1#:H#VD\#WKH#ULJKW#WKLQJV/#EXW#WKH#PHVVDJHV# RQFH#\RX#JHW#EHORZ#WKH#VXUIDFH#DUH#QRW#WKH#VDPH1#

# $QG# WKHUH# ZHUH# RWKHU# SUREOHPV1# &KXFN# FDXJKW# VRPH# RI# KLV# VWDII# EULELQJ# JRYHUQPHQW# RIILFLDOV># KDYLQJ# WD[# UHIXQGV# GLUHFWHG# LQWR# WKHLU# SHUVRQDO# DFFRXQWV># FKHDWLQJ#RQ#FUHGLW#FDUGV>#SXWWLQJ#IRUHLJQ#H[FKDQJH#WLFNHWV#LQ#WKHLU#SHUVRQDO#GHVNV># DQG#KDYLQJ#RXWVLGH#EXVLQHVV# LQWHUHVWV# WKDW#ZHUH# LQ#FRQIOLFW#ZLWK#WKHLU# MREV#DW#WKH# %DQN1#+H#UHVROYHG#PDQ\#RI#WKHVH#SUREOHPV#E\#³ILULQJ#D#ORW#RI#SHRSOH´>#WKHQ#KH#KDG# XQLRQ#SUREOHPV/#EXW#KH#SHUVHYHUHG/#WU\LQJ#WR#UHVROYH#WKH#SUREOHPV#LQ#WKH#EUDQFK1# +LV#SHUVHYHUDQFH#ODVWHG#XQWLO#KH#VWDUWHG#UHFHLYLQJ#GHDWK#WKUHDWV#IURP#D#FOLHQW#ZKR# KDG#EULEHG#D#%DQN#HPSOR\HH#LQ#RUGHU#WR#JHW#PRQH\#RXW#RI#WKH#FRXQWU\#LOOHJDOO\#DQG# ZKRP#&KXFN#KDG#VXEVHTXHQWO\#UHSRUWHG#WR#WKH#%DQN#RI#6DXGL#$UDELD1#$FFRUGLQJ#WR# &KXFN=# #

,#WKRXJKW#WKDW#,#KDG#FOHDQHG#LW#XS/#WKDW#,#KDG#JRWWHQ#WKH#ULJKW#SHRSOH# LQ#SODFH#DQG#WKDW#WKLQJV#ZHUH#UXQQLQJ#ILQH#DQG#WKDW#PD\EH/#DIWHU#DOO# WKLV#SDLQ/#JLYHQ#WKH#FXOWXUDO#LVVXHV/#LW#ZDV#WLPH#IRU#VRPHERG\#HOVH#WR# FRPH#LQ#DQG#WDNH#LW#WR#WKH#QH[W#VWHS1#

# &KXFN#ZDV#ORRNLQJ#IRU#D#QHZ#OHDVH#RQ#OLIH#ZKHQ#D#SKRQH#FDOO#FDPH#IURP#(OGRQ# )URVW#LQ#0RQWUHDO#RIIHULQJ#KLP#D#FRUSRUDWH#EDQNLQJ#MRE#LQ#1HZ#<RUN#&LW\#ZLWK#WKH# 0HUFKDQW#%DQN#RI#&DQDGD1#(OGRQ#SRUWUD\HG# WKH#1HZ#<RUN#JURXS#DV#³ZRUNLQJ# ZRQGHUIXOO\/#PDNLQJ#PRQH\1´##,Q#IDFW/#KH#VDLG/#³LW¶V#D#JUHDW#EXVLQHVV/#\RX¶OO#KDYH#D# ORW#RI# IXQ1´#&KXFN/# WKLQNLQJ#RI#KLV#ZLIH#DQG# WZR0\HDU0ROG#FKLOG/# MXPSHG#DW# WKH# RIIHU1# #

3DJH#6# <$<;&335# # #

21(#-2%/#7:2#0$1'$7(6# # ,Q# $XJXVW# 4<<6/# &KXFN# VWHSSHG# LQWR# KLV# QHZ# SRVLWLRQ# DV# 0DQDJLQJ# 'LUHFWRU/# )LQDQFLDO#,QVWLWXWLRQV/#ZLWK#0%&#LQ#1HZ#<RUN/#ORRNLQJ#IRU#D#IUHVK#VWDUW1#+LV#MRE# ZDV#WR#PDQDJH#0%&¶V#UHODWLRQVKLSV#ZLWK#D#PXOWLWXGH#RI#ILQDQFLDO#LQVWLWXWLRQ#FOLHQWV# DV# ZHOO# DV# WR# OHDG# D# WHDP# LQ# PDUNHWLQJ# 0%&¶V# DQG# &%,¶V# FRUSRUDWH# ILQDQFLDO# VHUYLFHV#DQG#SURGXFWV1#+LV#ILUVW#IHZ#ZHHNV#RQ#WKH#MRE#ZHUH#VXIILFLHQW#WR#FRQYLQFH# &KXFN# WKDW#KLV#JURXS#KDG#D#QXPEHU#RI#SHRSOH#SUREOHPV#DV#ZHOO#DV#DQ#RXWGDWHG# EXVLQHVV#VWUDWHJ\1#<HW/#ZKHQ#KH#EURDFKHG#WKH#VXEMHFWV#RI#DGRSWLQJ#D#QHZ#VWUDWHJ\# WR#GHDO#ZLWK#FKDQJLQJ#EXVLQHVV#FRQGLWLRQV#RU#PDNLQJ#FKDQJHV#ZLWKLQ# WKH#JURXS# ZLWK#(OGRQ/#(OGRQ¶V#PDQWUD#ZDV#³WKLV#JURXS#LV#JUHDW1#+H\/#\RXU#JURXS#LV#PDNLQJ#43# PLOOLRQ#EXFNV#D#\HDU>#LW¶V#ZRUNLQJ#ZRQGHUIXOO\$´## # $OWKRXJK#KH#GLG#VXSSRUW#&KXFN¶V#LGHD#RI#D#QHZ#VWUDWHJ\/#(OGRQ#ZDV#XQZLOOLQJ#WR# OHW#JR#RI#WKH#JURXS¶V#WUDGLWLRQDO#SURGXFWV1#+H#GLG#QRW#VHH#WKH#PDUNHW#WKH#VDPH#ZD\# DV#&KXFN#GLG>#KH#KDG#D#GLIIHUHQW#SHUVSHFWLYH1#(OGRQ¶V#PDUNHW#ZDV#WKH#ZRUOG/#ZKHUH# D#VKRUWIDOO#LQ#UHYHQXHV#LQ#RQH#FRXQWU\#FRXOG#EH#PDGH#XS#E\#VWUHQJWKHQLQJ#UHYHQXHV# LQ#DQRWKHU1#&KXFN¶V#ZRUOG/# WKH#8QLWHG#6WDWHV/#ZDV#YHU\#GLIIHUHQW># WKHUH#ZDV#QR# ³FRQWLQJHQF\´# ORFDWLRQ# IRU# PDNLQJ# XS# UHYHQXH# VKRUWIDOOV1# ,Q# VSLWH# RI# WKHVH# GLIIHUHQFHV/#RU#EHFDXVH#RI# WKHP/#(OGRQ#FRXOG#QRW#VHH#DQ\#UHDVRQ#IRU#FKDQJH>#KH# EHOLHYHG#³RXU#JURXS# LV#GLIIHUHQW/#ZH#GRQ¶W#QHHG# WR#FKDQJH/#ZH¶UH#KDSS\/#ZH¶UH# VHSDUDWH/#GRQ¶W#ZRUU\#DERXW#LW1´# # (OGRQ#ZDV#GULYHQ#E\#WKH#FRQFHSW#RI#NHHSLQJ#HYHU\RQH#KDSS\1#+H#KDG#VXUYLYHG#D# PDMRU# FRUSRUDWH# GRZQVL]LQJ# DQG# KDG# DGDSWHG# E\# NHHSLQJ# KLV# KHDG# GRZQ# DQG# PDNLQJ#QR#QRLVH1#3HUKDSV/#&KXFN#VSHFXODWHG/#WKDW#ZDV#ZK\#(OGRQ¶V#DWWLWXGH#ZDV/## ³'RQ¶W#URFN#WKH#ERDW/#,¶P#D#VXUYLYRU1´##,W#GLG#QRW#KHOS#WKDW#(OGRQ#KDG#H[SHFWHG#WR# EH#SURPRWHG# LQWR#KLV#ERVV¶V#SRVLWLRQ/#KDG#EHHQ#SDVVHG#RYHU/#DQG#FRQVHTXHQWO\/# KDUERUHG#D#JUHDW#GHDO#RI# UHVHQWPHQW# WRZDUG#0DUJDUHW/#ZKR#KDG#EHHQ#DSSRLQWHG# H[HFXWLYH#YLFH#SUHVLGHQW#LQVWHDG1# # 0DUJDUHW#0DWWVRQ#ZDV# WZR# OHYHOV#DERYH#&KXFN# LQ# WKH#FRUSRUDWH#KLHUDUFK\# +VHH# ([KLELW#4#IRU#WKH#RUJDQL]DWLRQ#FKDUW,#DQG#&KXFN#PHW#KHU#RQO\#DIWHU#KH#KDG#WDNHQ#XS# KLV# SRVLWLRQ# LQ# 1HZ# <RUN1# 8QOLNH# (OGRQ/# 0DUJDUHW# ZDV# QRW# VDWLVILHG# ZLWK# WKH# )LQDQFLDO# ,QVWLWXWLRQV#JURXS#RU# LWV#SHUIRUPDQFH1#6KH#KDG#KHOG#&KXFN¶V#SRVLWLRQ# RSHQ#IRU#D#FRQVLGHUDEOH#OHQJWK#RI#WLPH#ORRNLQJ#IRU#WKH#ULJKW#SHUVRQ#DQG#ZDV#VXUH# WKDW#&KXFN#ZDV#WKH#SHUVRQ#WR#FDUU\#RXW#KHU#³IL[#LW´#PDQGDWH1## # ,Q#WKHLU#YHU\#ILUVW#IDFH0WR0IDFH#PHHWLQJ/#0DUJDUHW#WROG#&KXFN#WKDW#VKH#ZDV#XQVXUH#LI# LW#KDG#EHHQ#WKH#ULJKW#GHFLVLRQ#WR#VHQG#3DWULFN#.LQQDUG/#RQH#RI#WKH#GLUHFWRUV/#IURP# 0RQWUHDO#WR#1HZ#<RUN1#6KH#ZDV#DOVR#FULWLFDO#RI#PDQ\#RI#WKH#VWDII#WKDW#UHPDLQHG#LQ# 0RQWUHDO#DQG#VKH#ZDQWHG#&KXFN#WR#IL[#WKH#JURXS#E\#³JHWWLQJ#ULG#RI#WKH#ZHDN#VWDII1´## 0DUJDUHW#ZDV#VXUH#WKDW#WKH#JURXS¶V#FXUUHQW#VNLOOV#ZHUH#QRW#VXIILFLHQW#WR#PHHW#WKH# ORRPLQJ#FRPSHWLWLYH#FKDOOHQJHV1# #

3DJH#7# <$<;&335# # #

,Q# WKHLU#QH[W#PHHWLQJ/#&KXFN#FRQYLQFHG#0DUJDUHW#WKDW#WKHUH#ZHUH#DOVR#SUREOHPV# ZLWK#WKH#SURGXFWV#WKH#JURXS#KDG#WR#RIIHU/#DQG#WKDW#QHZ#RQHV#ZHUH#EDGO\#QHHGHG1# ³7KDW#FOLFNHG#IRU#KHU´#ZKHQ#&KXFN#VKRZHG#KHU#WKH#QXPEHUV#RQ#SULFH#FRQFHVVLRQV# WKH#JURXS#ZDV#PDNLQJ#RQ#WUDGLWLRQDO#SURGXFWV#DQG/#IURP#WKDW#PRPHQW#RQ/#0DUJDUHW# IXOO\#VXSSRUWHG#&KXFN#LQ#GULYLQJ#WKH#JURXS#WRZDUG#D#QHZ#VWUDWHJ\1#8QOLNH#(OGRQ/# 0DUJDUHW#KDG#ZRUNHG#IRU#DQRWKHU#LQYHVWPHQW#EDQN#GXULQJ#WKH#PDMRU#GRZQVL]LQJ#DW# 0%&1#3RVVLEO\#EHFDXVH#RI#WKLV/#&KXFN#VSHFXODWHG/#³VKH#GLG#QRW#KDYH#WKH#VXUYLYRU# PLQG#VHW/´#DQG#FRQVHTXHQWO\/#SXVKHG#KDUG#IRU#KLP#WR#PDNH#PDMRU#FKDQJHV#TXLFNO\1# # &KXFN#LQIRUPHG#ERWK#(OGRQ#DQG#0DUJDUHW#RI#WKHLU#FRQIOLFWLQJ#H[SHFWDWLRQV#RI#KLP/# EXW#LW#DSSHDUHG#WR#KDYH#YHU\#OLWWOH#LPSDFW#RQ#HLWKHU#RI#KLV#ERVVHV1#(OGRQ#GLG#WHOO# &KXFN#WKDW#KH#DQG#0DUJDUHW#KDG#D#³\RX#OHDYH#PH#DORQH/#,¶OO#OHDYH#\RX#DORQH#DQG# ZH¶OO#MXVW#ZRUN#WRJHWKHU#EXW#NHHS#RXU#GLVWDQFH#DV#EHVW#ZH#FDQ´#W\SH#RI#DUUDQJHPHQW# DQG#LPSOLHG#WKDW#KH#ZRXOG#KDYH#WR#OLYH#ZLWK#LW1#&KXFN/#KLPVHOI/#KDG#VHHQ#WKDW#WKH\# ZHUH#OLNH#³RLO#DQG#ZDWHU´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³KDG# FXW# D# GHDO# IRU# KLPVHOI# DQG# GHVHUWHG# WKHP# WR# JHW# SDLG# LQ# 8161# GROODUV1´## 3UDFWLFDOO\#DOO#RI#WKH#0RQWUHDO#SHRSOH#ZDQWHG#WR#MRLQ#3DWULFN#LQ#1HZ#<RUN1#&KXFN# NQHZ# WKDW#3DWULFN¶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

3DJH#8# <$<;&335# # #

7KH#0RQWUHDO#JURXS#ZDV#QRW#XS#WR#GDWH#WHFKQRORJ\#ZLVH1#7KH\#GLGQ¶W#XVH#H0PDLO#RU# QRWHERRN# FRPSXWHUV# LQ# &DQDGD1# &KXFN# UHIOHFWHG/# ³SRVVLEO\# EHFDXVH# RI# WKH# WHFKQRORJ\# ODJ/# LQ#0RQWUHDO# WKH\#GLGQ¶W#VHH# WKH#YLVLRQ´#RI#D#FRQWLQHQW0VSDQQLQJ# WHDP1#&KXFN#WULHG#WR#FRUUHFW#WKH#WHFKQRORJ\#SUREOHP#E\#VXSSO\LQJ# WKH#0RQWUHDO# JURXS#ZLWK#QRWHERRN#FRPSXWHUV#DQG#FHOOXODU#SKRQHV/#SULPDULO\#IRU#XVH#ZKHQ#WKH\# ZHUH#WUDYHOOLQJ>#EXW#VRPH#PHPEHUV#RI#WKH#JURXS#FRXOG#QRW/#RU#ZRXOG#QRW/#XVH#WKHP1## # &KXFN¶V#IUXVWUDWLRQ#OHYHO#JUHZ1#,W#WRRN#WZR#GD\V#WR#WUDFN#GRZQ#RQH#PHPEHU#RI#WKH# JURXS# ZKR# ZDV# WUDYHOOLQJ# LQ# (XURSH# ZKHQ# D# FOLHQW# QHHGHG# KLP># ³QRERG\# LQ# 0RQWUHDO#HYHQ#KDG#DQ#LWLQHUDU\#IRU#KLP$´##:K\/#KH#ZRQGHUHG/#ZRXOG#WKH\#QRW#XVH# WKH#VFKHGXOLQJ#SDFNDJH#WKDW#KH#SURYLGHG#RQ#WKHLU#GHVN#DQG#ODSWRS#FRPSXWHUV"#:K\# GLG#WKH\#YLHZ#LW#DV#³ELJ#EURWKHU/´#RU#XVH#LW#WR#FKHFN#XS#RQ#ZKDW#&KXFN#ZDV#GRLQJ/# LQVWHDG#RI#MXVW#DFNQRZOHGJLQJ#WKDW#LW#ZDV#PHUHO\#D#WRRO#WR#PDNH#WKHP#DFFHVVLEOH#LQ# WLPHV#RI#QHHG"##&KXFN#IHOW#WKDW#WHFKQRORJ\#PDGH#LW#RND\#WR#KDYH#GLVWDQW#JURXSV/# ZKLOH#VRPH#RI#WKH#JURXS#PHPEHUV#VDLG#WKDW#LW#GHVWUR\HG#WKH#FDPDUDGHULH#RI#IDFH0WR0 IDFH#FRQYHUVDWLRQ1#7KHUH#ZDV#DSSDUHQWO\#QRW#JRLQJ#WR#EH#D#PHHWLQJ#RI#WKH#PLQGV1## # &KXFN#KDG#WR#DGPLW#WKDW#WHFKQRORJ\#DQG#WUDYHO#FRXOG#QRW#IXUQLVK#DOO#RI#WKH#DQVZHUV# WR# WKH#JURXS¶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³VDOHV# SHRSOH#JRW#DORQJ#ZLWK#HYHU\ERG\#DQG#WKH\#ZHUH#JUHDW/´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

3HRSOH#FDPH#RXW#JRRG#IULHQGV1#,#WKRXJKW#WKHUH#ZDV#FRPPLWPHQW#DQG# ,#ZDV#SRVLWLYH#DERXW#WKH#ZKROH#WKLQJ1#

# 7KHQ/# LQ# -XO\/# &KXFN# KLUHG# WKH# WHDP0EXLOGLQJ# FRXUVH# LQVWUXFWRU# WR# ZRUN# DV# D# FRQVXOWDQW#WR#WKH#JURXS1# # #

3DJH#9# <$<;&335# # #

7+(#675$7(*<# # &KXFN#KDG#DQRWKHU#UHDVRQ#IRU#SURYLGLQJ#WKH#JURXS#PHPEHUV#ZLWK#D#PLQLPXP#RI#43# WUDLQLQJ#GD\V#SHU# \HDU/#HYHQ# WKRXJK# WKDW#QXPEHU#H[FHHGHG# WKH#DYHUDJH# IRU# WKH# %DQN1#+LV#ILUVW#IHZ#PRQWKV# LQ#1HZ#<RUN#DQG#0RQWUHDO#FRQYLQFHG#KLP# WKDW# WKH# JURXS¶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¶V#EXVLQHVV1#6HFRQG/#WKH#WUHQG#OLQH#LQ#WKH#FDVK#PDQDJHPHQW# DQG#OHQGLQJ#EXVLQHVV#ZDV#GRZQZDUGV/#DQG#SULFLQJ#SUHVVXUHV#KDG#EHHQ#HQRUPRXV1# (YHQ#WKRXJK#YROXPH#KDG#EHHQ#LQFUHDVLQJ/#SULFHV#ZHUH#GHFOLQLQJ#DQG#WKH#UHYHQXH# OLQH#KDG#EHHQ#IODW1#&KXFN#NQHZ#WKDW#³LI#ZH#KDG#MXVW#VWD\HG#GRLQJ#WKDW/#WKHUH#ZRXOG# EH#QR#ERQXVHV/#QR#LQFHQWLYH/#QRWKLQJ1#,W#ZRXOG#KDYH#EHHQ#EDUHO\#WUHDGLQJ#ZDWHU#1#1#1# ZH#QHHGHG#WR#GR#VRPHWKLQJ#HOVH1´## # 6RPHWKLQJ#HOVH#ZDV#D#QHZ#VWUDWHJ\# WKDW# LQYROYHG#H[SDQGLQJ# LQWR#RWKHU#SURGXFW# OLQHV#VXFK#DV#7UHDVXU\/#GHULYDWLYH#SURGXFWV/#VWRFN#WUDQVIHU/#OHQGLQJ#DQG#WUXVW1#7KH# JURXS#KDG#³QHYHU# WDONHG#DQ\#RI# WKRVH#RWKHU#SURGXFW# OLQHV# WR#DQ\#8161# ILQDQFLDO# LQVWLWXWLRQV1´##/DFN#RI#IDPLOLDULW\#EUHG#UHVLVWDQFH/#HYHQ#WKRXJK#&KXFN#ZRUNHG#KDUG# WR# JHW# DQG# NHHS# WKH# JURXS# LQYROYHG# LQ# GHVLJQLQJ# DQG# LPSOHPHQWLQJ# WKH# QHZ# VWUDWHJ\1#+LV#SHRSOH/#DIWHU#DOO/#NQHZ#WKHLU#FXVWRPHUV#DQG#SUHVXPDEO\#NQHZ#ZKDW# WKHLU#FXVWRPHUV#QHHGHG1#,Q#&KXFN¶V#ZRUGV=## #

7KDW#ZDV#SDUW#RI#WKH#FKDQJH#WKDW#,#ZDV#WU\LQJ#WR#JHW#VRPH#RI#WKHVH# SHRSOH#WR#GHDO#ZLWK>#WR#JHW#XS#WR#VSHHG#ZLWK#WKRVH#SURGXFWV#DQG#JR# RXW#DQG#PDUNHW# WKHP1#$QG# WKDW#ZDV#ZKHUH# ,# UDQ# LQWR# UHVLVWDQFH1# 7KH\#ZRXOG#VD\/#ZK\#WKHVH#SURGXFWV/#ZKDW#ZH¶UH#GRLQJ#QRZ#LV#ILQH1# :K\# FKDQJH"# $QG# P\# IHHOLQJ# ZDV# WKDW# EXVLQHVV# ZDV# EHLQJ# FRPPRGLWL]HG#DQG#JRLQJ#WR#JR#DZD\#DQG#WKDW/#LQ#WKH#ORQJ#UXQ/#ZH# ZHUH#QRW#JRLQJ#WR#EH#DEOH#WR#VXFFHHG#ZLWK#WKDW1#

# +H#KRSHG#E\#DGGLQJ#WR#WKHLU#VNLOO#EDVH#DQG#WHDFKLQJ#WKHP#WR#SHUIRUP#DV#D#WHDP/# WKHLU#UHVLVWDQFH#WR#WKH#QHZ#VWUDWHJ\#ZRXOG#ZLWKHU#DQG#GLH1# # # 7+(#*5283#$6#,1',9,'8$/6# # 1HLO#)RUV\WK/#'LUHFWRU# # /RFDWHG#LQ#0RQWUHDO/#DQG#LQ#KLV#PLG083V/#1HLO#)RUV\WK#ZDV#WKH#ILUVW#SHUVRQ#WR#FDXVH# UHDO#IULFWLRQ#IRU#&KXFN1#+H#ZRXOG#VD\/##³:K\#FKDQJH/#ZH#FDQQRW#GR#WKLV/#,#FDQ¶W#GR# LW#EHFDXVH#,#GRQ¶W#NQRZ#KRZ/#,¶P#DIUDLG/#,#GRQ¶W#VHH#WKH#QHHG/#,#OLNH#WKH#WUDGLWLRQDO# WKLQJ#DQG#,¶P#JRRG#DW#LW#DQG#LW#ZRUNV1´##+H#ZDV#DQJU\#DERXW#WKH#QHZ#VWUDWHJ\#DQG#

3DJH#:# <$<;&335# # #

NHSW#DJLWDWLQJ#&KXFN#DERXW#LW/#PDNLQJ#VWDWHPHQWV#OLNH/#³<RX¶UH#QXWV/#LW#MXVW#ZRQ¶W# ZRUN/´# ZKLOH# &KXFN# ZDV# WU\LQJ# WR# EXLOG# D# WHDP1# $OWKRXJK# SUHYLRXVO\# DQ# H[FHSWLRQDO# SHUIRUPHU/# 1HLO# UHFHLYHG# D# TXDOLW\# FRQWULEXWRU# UDWLQJ# RQ# KLV# 4<<7# SHUIRUPDQFH# DSSUDLVDO1# :KLOH# 1HLO# EHOLHYHG# WKDW# KLV# SHUIRUPDQFH# UDWLQJV# IHOO# EHFDXVH#RI#D#SHUVRQDOLW\#FRQIOLFW#EHWZHHQ#KLPVHOI#DQG#&KXFN/#&KXFN#QRWHG# WKDW# 1HLO¶V# #³UDWLQJV# IHOO#EHFDXVH#KH#GLG#QRW#DGRSW# WKH#QHZ#VWUDWHJ\#RU#SURYLGH# WKDW# H[FHSWLRQDO#SHUIRUPDQFH1´##*LYHQ#WKH#WHQVLRQ#DQG#GLVDJUHHPHQW#EHWZHHQ#WKHP/#E\# ODWH#4<<7/#&KXFN#NQHZ# WKDW#KH#KDG# WR#PRYH#1HLO#RXW#RI# WKH#JURXS#DQG#KH#KDG# VWDUWHG#ORRNLQJ#VHULRXVO\#IRU#RWKHU#RSSRUWXQLWLHV#IRU#KLP#ZLWKLQ#WKH#%DQN1# # # *OHQQ#:ULJKW/#$VVRFLDWH# # $OVR#EDVHG#LQ#0RQWUHDO/#GXULQJ#KLV#ILUVW#PHHWLQJ#ZLWK#&KXFN/#*OHQQ#WROG#KLV#QHZ# ERVV#³ZKDW#D#JUHDW#JX\#KH#ZDV/#KRZ#KH#ZDV#EHWWHU#WKDQ#DQ\RQH#HOVH/#DQG#WKDW#KH# KDG#EHHQ#SURPLVHG#D#GLUHFWRUVKLS1´##&KXFN/#WDNLQJ#KLP#DW#KLV#ZRUG/#SURPLVHG#WR# ORRN# LQWR# WKDW#GLUHFWRUVKLS1#:KDW#KH#GLVFRYHUHG#ZDV# WKDW#*OHQQ#ZDV#QRW#DOZD\V# GHOLYHULQJ# H[FHSWLRQDO# VHUYLFH1# ,QGHHG/# &KXFN# ZDV# UHFHLYLQJ# PL[HG# PHVVDJHV# DERXW#*OHQQ¶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³LI#KH#QHHGHG#\RX/#\RX#ZHUH#KLV#EHVW#EXGG\>#LI#KH#GLG#QRW# QHHG#\RX/#KH#LJQRUHG#\RX>#DQG#LI#\RX#SXVKHG#KLP/#\RX#ZHUH#DQ#$$$$$$$$$´#0DQ\#RI# KLV#FOLHQW#UHODWLRQVKLSV#ZHUH#VWUDLQHG1## # *OHQQ#GLVSOD\HG#YHU\#SRRU#ZRUN#KDELWV#DQG#PDQ\#0RQGD\2)ULGD\#DEVHQFHV1#&KXFN# VWDUWHG#WR#JHW#³D#ORW#RI#KHDW´#DERXW#*OHQQ#IURP#ERWK#0DUJDUHW#DQG#(OGRQ1#0DUJDUHW/# ZKR#KDG#LQLWLDOO\#EHHQ#FULWLFDO#RI#*OHQQ/#EHFDPH#HYHQ#PRUH#VR#DIWHU#VKH#VDZ#KLP# SOD\LQJ#VROLWDLUH#RQ#KLV#FRPSXWHU#LQ#WKH#RIILFH1#2QH#GD\#(OGRQ#VDZ#*OHQQ#SOD\LQJ# VROLWDLUH#DQG#FDOOHG#&KXFN# LQ#ZRQGHUPHQW/#DVNLQJ#³KRZ#FDQ#DQ#HPSOR\HH#SOD\# VROLWDLUH# ULJKW# RXW# LQ# WKH# RSHQ# LQ# WKH# RIILFH"´# *OHQQ/# IRU# KLV# SDUW/# GLG# QRW# GHPRQVWUDWH# WKDW# KH# ZDQWHG# WR# ZRUN# KDUGHU# RU# VXSSRUW# WKH# QHZ# VWUDWHJ\1# +LV# DWWLWXGH#ZDV/#³,#WKLQN#\RX¶UH#ZURQJ/#,#GRQ¶W#EX\#LQWR#DQ\#RI#WKLV/#,#FRPH#LQ#DW#QLQH# DQG#,¶P#OHDYLQJ#DW#7=631´##7KH#FKLS#RQ#KLV#VKRXOGHU#MXVW#JRW#ODUJHU#DQG#ODUJHU1# # #

3DJH#;# <$<;&335# # #

'HLWU#3RHKOPDQQ/#$VVRFLDWH# # %DVHG#LQ#1HZ#<RUN/#'HLWU¶V#LQLWLDO#UHODWLRQVKLS#ZLWK#&KXFN#ZDV#D#JRRG#RQH1#&KXFN# VDZ#IURP#WKH#EHJLQQLQJ#WKDW/#IRU#VRPH#XQNQRZQ#UHDVRQV/#'HLWU#ZDV#EHLQJ#³JURVVO\# XQGHUSDLG´#DQG#XQGHUWRRN#WR#PDNH#XS#D#'53/333#DQQXDO#VKRUWIDOO#RYHU#D#SHULRG#RI# WLPH1# $V# WLPH# ZHQW# RQ/# KRZHYHU/# &KXFN# QRWHG# WKDW# ³'HLWU¶V# ZRUN# ZDV# VSRWW\/# VRPHWLPHV#RND\#DQG#VRPHWLPHV#SRRU/´#SDUWLFXODUO\#ZKHQ# LW#FDPH# WR#YHUEDO#DQG# ZULWWHQ#FRPPXQLFDWLRQV#LQ#(QJOLVK1#'HLWU¶V#ILUVW#ODQJXDJH#ZDV#*HUPDQ/#DQG#WKDW/#WR# KLP/# ZDV# VXIILFLHQW# UHDVRQ# QRW# WR# GR# DQ\WKLQJ# DERXW# KLV# (QJOLVK1# +H# EHOLHYHG# SHRSOH#ZRXOG#PDNH#DOORZDQFHV#IRU#KLV#ODQJXDJH/#HYHQ#WKRXJK#&KXFN#VSRNH#ZLWK# KLP#UHSHDWHGO\#RQ#WKH#PDWWHU#DQG#WROG#KLP#WKDW#WKH\#ZRXOG#QRW1#$W#RQH#SRLQW/#'HLWU# ZHQW#VR#IDU#DV#WR#ILQG#DQ#(QJOLVK0VSHDNLQJ#WUDLQHU#RI#RSHUDWLRQDO#VWDII#WR#DWWHVW#WR#KLV# IOXHQF\#LQ#WKH#(QJOLVK#ODQJXDJH1# # 'HLWU# DOVR# KDG# ³WUHPHQGRXV# SUREOHPV# FRPPXQLFDWLQJ# LQWHUQDOO\># KH# ZRXOG# FDOO# SHRSOH#OLDUV#RQ#H0PDLO#DQG#VHQG#FRSLHV#RI#WKH#H0PDLO#WR#HYHU\RQH/#LQFOXGLQJ#WKHLU# ERVVHV´# +VHH#([KLELW#6,1#6XFK#EHKDYLRU#FUHDWHG#VHHPLQJO\#HQGOHVV#SUREOHPV# IRU# &KXFN/# ZKR# ZDV# FDOOHG# XSRQ# WLPH# DQG# DJDLQ# WR# VPRRWK# UXIIOHG# IHDWKHUV# RI# FROOHDJXHV#DQG#FOLHQWV#ZKR#KDG#EHHQ#RIIHQGHG#E\#'HLWU¶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¶V#PHPRV#ZHUH#WRWDOO\#XQLQWHOOLJLEOH/#ZKLOH#RWKHUV#ZHUH# FRJHQW#DQG#ZHOO#ZULWWHQ1#&KXFN#VXVSHFWHG#D#GUXJ#RU#DOFRKRO#SUREOHP#DQG#VXJJHVWHG# WKDW#'DOH#DFFHVV# WKH#(PSOR\HH#$VVLVWDQFH#3URJUDP/#EXW#'DOH#FODLPHG#WKDW#WKHUH# ZDV#QR#SUREOHP1#,Q#UHWURVSHFW/#&KXFN#DGPLWWHG#WKDW#³,#HQGHG#XS#SURWHFWLQJ#KLP#D# OLWWOH#ELW/#EHFDPH#D#OLWWOH#FR0GHSHQGHQW/´#DQG/#LQ#1RYHPEHU#4<<7/#KH#JDYH#'DOH#D# TXDOLW\#FRQWULEXWLRQ#UDWLQJ#RQ#KLV#SHUIRUPDQFH#DSSUDLVDO/#QRWLQJ#WKDW#'DOH#KDG#ERWK# DFFHSWHG/#DQG#DWWHPSWHG#WR#LPSOHPHQW/#WKH#QHZ#VWUDWHJ\1# # # 3DWULFN#.LQQDUG/#'LUHFWRU# # 3DWULFN#.LQQDUG#ZDV#&KXFN¶V#SUHGHFHVVRU/#D#YHU\#FDSDEOH#LQGLYLGXDO#LQ#WKH#FDVK# PDQDJHPHQW# EXVLQHVV1# +H# KDG# GHYHORSHG# VRPH# QHZ# SURGXFW# OLQHV# WKDW# ZHUH#

3DJH#<# <$<;&335# # #

LQWHUHVWLQJ#DQG#(OGRQ#KDG#PRYHG#KLP#WR#1HZ#<RUN#IURP#0RQWUHDO#LQ#WKH#VXPPHU# RI# 4<<6# WR#JLYH#KLP#D# IUHVK# VWDUW# LQ#D#QHZ# ORFDWLRQ#DIWHU#KLV#GHPRWLRQ1#(OGRQ# SXEOLFO\# VDLG# WKDW/# LQ# VSLWH# RI# WKH# GHPRWLRQ/# KH# WKRXJKW# 3DWULFN# ZDV# JUHDW# DW# HYHU\WKLQJ#KH#GLG#DQG#KH#WROG#&KXFN#WKDW#³3DWULFN¶V#QRVH#ZLOO#EH#RXW#RI#MRLQW#VLQFH# \RX#JRW#KLV#MRE/#EXW#KH#ZLOO#FRPH#DURXQG1´##,Q#WKH#EHJLQQLQJ/#LW#VHHPHG#DV#LI#WKDW# PLJKW#EH# WUXH1#7KHLU#HDUO\#UHODWLRQVKLS#ZDV#ILQH#DQG/#DOWKRXJK#&KXFN#KDG#KHDUG# QXPHURXV#VWRULHV#DERXW#3DWULFN¶V#VHULRXV#GULQNLQJ#SUREOHP/#KH#GLG#QRW#PHQWLRQ# WKRVH#VWRULHV#WR#3DWULFN1#&KXFN#KDG#GHFLGHG#WR#UHVHUYH#MXGJPHQW#DQG#JLYH#3DWULFN#D# FKDQFH#WR#SURYH#RWKHUZLVH1# # 6L[#PRQWKV# ODWHU/#FRLQFLGLQJ#ZLWK# WKH# LQLWLDWLRQ#RI# WKH#QHZ#VWUDWHJ\/#3DWULFN#DQG# &KXFN¶V#UHODWLRQVKLS#VWDUWHG#WR#GHWHULRUDWH1#3DWULFN#KDG#DJUHHG#WR#IROORZ#WKH#QHZ# VWUDWHJ\/# EXW# IHOW# WKDW# &KXFN# GLG# QRW# UHVSHFW# WKH# WUDGLWLRQDO# FDVK# PDQDJHPHQW# EXVLQHVV#VXIILFLHQWO\1#$W#RQH#SRLQW/#3DWULFN#ZHQW#WR#(OGRQ/#FRPSODLQLQJ#DERXW#WKH# VWUDWHJ\#DQG#VD\LQJ# WKDW# WKH\#ZHUH#KHDGLQJ# IRU#GLVDVWHU1#+H#HYHQ#EURXJKW#'DOH# DORQJ# WR#VD\# WKH# VDPH# WKLQJ1#(OGRQ¶V# UHDFWLRQ#ZDV# WR#FDOO#&KXFN# LPPHGLDWHO\/# TXHVWLRQLQJ#KLP#DERXW#ZKDW#ZDV#JRLQJ#RQ#LQ#1HZ#<RUN#DQG#GHPDQGLQJ#WKDW#WKH\# ILQG#D#ZD\#WR#ZRUN#WRJHWKHU1#&KXFN¶V#VXEVHTXHQW#LQWHUYLHZV#ZLWK#ERWK#3DWULFN#DQG# 'DOH#JRW#DOO#RI#WKH#LVVXHV#RXW#RQ#WKH#WDEOH#DQG#KH#GLG#ZKDW#FRXOG#EH#GRQH#WR#DGGUHVV# WKH#GRXEWV#ERWK#PHQ#KDG#DERXW#WKH#QHZ#VWUDWHJ\1# # 7KHQ/#LQ#WKH#VXPPHU#RI#4<<7/#&KXFN#UHFHLYHG#D#FDOO#IURP#0DUJDUHW#LQTXLULQJ#DERXW# 3DWULFN¶V#UDQGRP#VLFN#GD\V># WR#KHU/# WKH#DEVHQFHV# ORRNHG#VXVSLFLRXV1#+DYLQJ#KDG# VRPH#H[SHULHQFH#ZLWK#DOFRKROLFV#DQG# WKHLU#KDELWV#DQG#SDWWHUQV/#&KXFN#VDW#GRZQ# ZLWK#3DWULFN/#DVNHG#KLP#LI#KH#KDG#D#GULQNLQJ#SUREOHP#DQG#RIIHUHG#WR#ZRUN#ZLWK#KLP# WKURXJK# WKH#$OFRKROLFV#$QRQ\PRXV#VWHSV1#3DWULFN¶V# UHVSRQVH#ZDV# WKDW#³KH#ZDV# GHDOLQJ#ZLWK#LW´#+VHH#([KLELW#7#IRU#D#V\QRSVLV#RI#3DWULFN¶V#DEVHQFHV,1#&KXFN/#ZKR# ZDV#QRW#VXUH#3DWULFN#ZDV#GHDOLQJ#ZLWK#LW#RU#WKDW#DQ\#DOFRKROLF#FRXOG#GHDO#ZLWK#WKHLU# DOFRKROLVP# E\# GULQNLQJ#PRGHUDWHO\# RU# NHHSLQJ# LW# XQGHU# FRQWURO/# VXJJHVWHG# WKH# %DQN¶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³WRDVWHG/´#WKH#LOOXVLRQ#RI#FDPDUDGHULH#EHJDQ#WR#GLVLQWHJUDWH1# #

3DJH#43# <$<;&335# # #

7KH#ZRUVW#SDUW#FDPH#ZKHQ#JURXS#PHPEHUV#URVH# WR# WKHLU#IHHW#DQG#EHJDQ# WR#JLYH# VSHHFKHV1#3DWULFN#DQG#*OHQQ#HDFK#JDYH#430PLQXWH#VSHHFKHV#SXWWLQJ#GRZQ#WKH#QHZ# EXVLQHVV#GLUHFWLRQ/#DVNLQJ#³ZKHUH#DUH#ZH#JRLQJ#ZLWK# WKLV#VWUDWHJ\"´# #7KH\#DOVR# FRXOG#QRW#UHVLVW#KDUSLQJ#RQ#WKH#ELWWHU#UHODWLRQVKLSV#LQ#WKH#JURXS1#%LOO#5XVVHOO#WKHQ# JDYH#D#VSHHFK#DERXW#KRZ#³ZH#VKRXOG#DOO#EH#JHWWLQJ#DORQJ#EHWWHU1´#&KXFN/#ZKR#KDG# EHHQ# WU\LQJ# WR# VLW# QHDU# WKRVH# LQGLYLGXDOV# ZKR# KDG# PDMRU# LVVXHV/# ZDV# ERWK# HPEDUUDVVHG/# ³HYHU\RQH# LQ# WKH# SODFH# ZDV# SD\LQJ# DWWHQWLRQ/´# DQG# DQJU\# ³DW# WKH# JURXS#DQG#DW#LQGLYLGXDOV/#IRU#UHKDVKLQJ#ROG#VWXII1#,W#KDG#EHHQ#D#\HDU#DQG#D#KDOI#DQG# WKH\#ZHUHQ¶W#VXJJHVWLQJ#DQ\WKLQJ#QHZ#WR#UHSODFH#ZKDW#WKH\#GLGQ¶W#OLNH1´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¶V#EHKDYLRU#WKH#SUHYLRXV#HYHQLQJ1#%LOO#GLG#QRW# UHDOO\#UHPHPEHU#PDNLQJ#WKH#VSHHFK#DERXW#HYHU\RQH#ZRUNLQJ#WRJHWKHU#DV#D#WHDP/# EXW#KH#ZDV#HPEDUUDVVHG#DQG#IXOO\#DSRORJHWLF#DQG#YRZHG# LW#ZRXOG#QHYHU#KDSSHQ# DJDLQ1#&KXFN/#IRU#KLV#SDUW/#ZDV#DEOH#WR#RYHUORRN#RQH#VOLS#IURP#D#VWHOODU#SHUIRUPHU# ²#LW#ZDV/#DIWHU#DOO/#&KULVWPDV#²#EXW#KH#ZRXOG#QRW#RYHUORRN#DQRWKHU#RQH1# # $V#&KXFN#UHIOHFWHG#RQ#WKH#SUHYLRXV#HYHQLQJ¶V#GLVDVWHU/#KH#IRXQG#VRPH#WKLQJV#WR#EH# WKDQNIXO#IRU1#+LV#JURXS#ZDV#QRW#FRPSOHWHO\#G\VIXQFWLRQDO1## # # 7+(#)81&7,21$/#*5283# # 6WHYH#6DOPRQ/#'LUHFWRU# # 6WHYH#6DOPRQ#ZDV#EDVHG#LQ#0RQWUHDO1#+H#ZDV#³D#JRRG#JX\/#DQ#DYHUDJH#SHUIRUPHU/# RQH#ZKR#ZRXOG#QHYHU#EH#D#VXSHUVWDU#EXW#KH#VXSSRUWHG#WKH#VWUDWHJ\#DQG#GLG#KLV#EHVW# WR# LPSOHPHQW# LW1´# #+H#ZDV#YHU\#JRRG#DW#KLV# MRE/#ZHOO# OLNHG#E\#KLV#FOLHQWV# LQ#D# SRUWIROLR# WKDW#KH#KDG#KDQGOHG# IRU# ILYH#\HDUV#DQG#KH#SURGXFHG#FRQVLVWHQWO\#JRRG# UHVXOWV1#6WHYH#ZDV#D#³VROLG#PHPEHU#RI#WKH#WHDP#DQG#D#SOHDVXUH#WR#ZRUN#ZLWK1#+H#LV# ZHOO#OLNHG#E\#HYHU\RQH#RQ#WKH#WHDP1´# # #

3DJH#44# <$<;&335# # #

/\QQH#0RUULV/#0DQDJHU# # $Q#H[FHSWLRQDO#SHUIRUPHU#DQG#WHDP#SOD\HU/#/\QQH#ZDV#ZHOO#OLNHG#DQG#UHVSHFWHG#E\# FOLHQWV#DQG#WHDP#PHPEHUV#DOLNH1#6KH#ZDV#D#GHOLJKWIXO#LQGLYLGXDO#ZKR#VXSSRUWHG#WKH# QHZ#VWUDWHJ\/#ZKR#KDG#PDGH#WKH#WUDQVLWLRQ#LQWR#QHZ#SURGXFWV#IDLUO\#VXFFHVVIXOO\/# DQG#³VKH#ZDV#UHZDUGHG#WKDW#ZD\#ZLWK#ELJ#ERQXVHV1´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³+RO\# *RG/#ZKDW#WKH#KHFN#LV#JRLQJ#RQ#KHUH"##*RRG#OXFN#WR#\RX$´# # # &+8&.¶6#',/(00$# # 7KH#SUHYLRXV#4;#PRQWKV#KDG#QRW#EHHQ#HDV\#IRU#&KXFN1#+H#KDG#DOZD\V#EHHQ#DQ# H[FHSWLRQDO#SHUIRUPHU#EXW#KDG#UHFHLYHG#RQO\#D#³TXDOLW\#FRQWULEXWRU´#UDWLQJ#IURP# (OGRQ#RQ#KLV#4<<7#SHUIRUPDQFH#DSSUDLVDO1#$OWKRXJK#KH#KDG#WULHG/#KH#FRXOG#QRW#JHW# (OGRQ#WR#H[SODLQ#ZK\#KH#FRQVLGHUHG#KLP#RQO\#³TXDOLW\´#DQG#ZKDW#LW#ZRXOG#WDNH#WR# EHFRPH#³H[FHSWLRQDO´#DJDLQ1#(OGRQ#KDG#RQO\#VXJJHVWHG# WKDW#PD\EH# WKH#SUREOHP# ZLWK#WKH#JURXS¶V#G\QDPLFV#ZDV#SDUWO\#GXH#WR#&KXFN¶V#PDQDJHPHQW#VW\OH1#$W#KLV# ZLWV#HQG/#&KXFN#WKRXJKW#PD\EH#(OGRQ#ZDV#ULJKW1#3HUKDSV#KH#³MXVW#GLG#QRW#JHW#LW1´# +H# WKRXJKW/#³7KLV# LV# LW/# ,#GRQ¶W#NQRZ#ZKDW# LV#JRLQJ#RQ#DURXQG#KHUH/# WKLV# LVQ¶W# ZRUNLQJ´# +VHH#([KLELW#8#IRU#DQ#H[DPSOH#RI# WHDP#FRQIOLFW,1#%XW#KH#GLG#QRW#KDYH# RWKHU#DYHQXHV#LQ#WKH#%DQN#WR#SXUVXH1#+H#KDG#WDONHG#WR#SHRSOH#DW#&%,/#EXW#LW#ZDV# WRXJK#WR#JHW#EDFN#LQ#RQFH#\RX#KDG#OHIW/#DQG#KH#KDG#QR#QHWZRUN#ZLWKLQ#0%&#WKDW#KH# FRXOG#WDS1#+H#IHOW#VWXFN1##

3DJH#45# <$<;&335# # #

&KXFN¶V#JURZLQJ#VHOI0GRXEWV#ZHUH#UHLQIRUFHG#E\#WKH#PHVVDJHV#KH#ZDV#JHWWLQJ#IURP# 0DUJDUHW1#$OWKRXJK#KH#ZDV#FRQYLQFHG# WKDW#KH#ZDV#SXUVXLQJ# WKH# ULJKW#EXVLQHVV# VWUDWHJ\/#KH#ZRQGHUHG#DERXW#KLV#PDQDJHPHQW#VW\OH1#0DUJDUHW¶V#³IL[# LW#PDQGDWH´# KDG#FKDQJHG>#VKH#RSHQO\#ZRQGHUHG# LI#&KXFN¶V#PDQDJHPHQW#VW\OH#KDG#EHHQ# WRR# VHYHUH/#WRR#KDUG1#&KXFN#ZRQGHUHG#LI/#DQG#ZKDW/#KH#FRXOG#EH#GRLQJ#EHWWHU/#LI#KH#KDG# PLVXQGHUVWRRG#WKH#GHJUHH#WR#ZKLFK#WKH#EDQN#ZDV#ZLOOLQJ#WR#FKDQJH1#³$IWHU#DOO/´#KH# FRQIHVVHG/#³ZKHQ#\RX#KDYH# WKDW#PDQ\#G\VIXQFWLRQDOLWLHV#DQG#D#ERVV#SHUVLVWHQWO\# VD\LQJ#HYHU\WKLQJ#LV#ILQH/#WKH#UHVXOW#LV#VHOI0GRXEW1´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¶V#ERVV#ZHUH#FOHDU=##LW#PLJKW#EH#KLV#PDQDJHPHQW#VW\OH1#+DG#KH#GRQH#VRPHWKLQJ# ZURQJ"##:KDW#FRXOG#KH/#RU#DQ\RQH#HOVH/#GR#WR#IL[#LW#QRZ"# # #

3DJH#46# <$<;&335# # #

([KLELW#4# #

),1$1&,$/#,167,787,216#*5283#25*$1,=$7,21#&+$57# # #

#

3DWULFN#.LQQDUG 'LUHFWRU

6WHYH#6DOPRQ 'LUHFWRU

1HLO#)RUV\WKH 'LUHFWRU

%LOO#5XVVHOO 0DQDJHU

/\QQH#0RUULV 0DQDJHU

'DOH#&DPHURQ 'LUHFWRU

'LHWU#3RHKOPDQQ $VVRFLDWH

*OHQQ#:ULJKW $VVRFLDWH

0DUJDUHW#0DWWVRQ ([HFXWLYH#9LFH#3UHVLGHQW

(OGRQ#)URVW 6HQLRU#9LFH#3UHVLGHQW

&KXFN#0DF.LQQRQ 0DQDJLQJ#'LUHFWRU

0LFKHOOH#6W1#3LHUUH 6HFUHWDU\

3DJH#47# <$<;&335# # #

([KLELW#5# #

$#352),/(#2)#7+(#),1$1&,$/#,167,787,216#*5283# # #

1DPH# #

$JH# #

<HDUV#LQ# %DQN#

<HDUV#LQ# 3RVLWLRQ#

335# 4<<5#

335# 4<<6#

335# 4<<7#

&KXFN#0DF.LQQRQ# 6<# ##6# ##4# (&# (&# 43#

3DWULFN#.LQQDUG# 85# 4:# ##:# (&# (&# (&#

1HLO#)RUV\WKH# 86# 48# ##8# (&# (&# 43#

'DOH#&DPHURQ# 73# 4;# ##4# (&# (&# 43#

*OHQQ#:ULJKW# 68# 43# ##6# 43# 43# 43#

'HLWU#3RHKOPDQQ# 68# 45# ##6# 43# 43# 43#

6WHYH#6DOPRQ# 83# 53# ##:# 43# 43# 43#

/\QQH#0RUULV# 85# 58# 43# (&# (&# (&#

%LOO#5XVVHOO# 78# 53# 45# (&# (&# (&#

# # # # # # # # # # 335# #3HUIRUPDQFH#3ODQQLQJ#DQG#5HYLHZ# (&# #([FHSWLRQDO#&RQWULEXWLRQ# 43# #4XDOLW\#3HUIRUPHU# # #

3DJH#48# <$<;&335# # #

([KLELW#6# #

'(,75#32(+/0$11¶6#&255(6321'(1&(# # # )URP=#'HLWU#3RHKOPDQQ# 7R=#&KXFN#0DF.LQQRQ# &&=#%RE#*UDQJH>#-RH#3HRSOHV>#6WDQ#0DQWURS# # &KXFN/# # XVXDOO\# SHRSOH# WKDW# IHHO# WKUHDWHQHG/# ZHDN/# WU\# WR# KLGH# WKHLU# ZHDNQHVVHV/# RU# WU\# WR# UXLQ# RQH¶V# UHSXWDWLRQ#ZLOO#VHQG#H0PDLO#DV#-RH#GLG#+WKH#RQH#EHORZ,1#,#GR#QRW#NQRZ#WKDW#-RH#KDV#DJDLQVW#PH1#,# QHYHU#FUHDWH#FRQIHUHQFH#FDOOV#XQOHVV#DOO#SDUWLHV#NQRZ#DERXW#LW#DQG#DJUHH#WR#LW1# # ,# VSRNH#ZLWK#%RE#*UDQJH# WKLV#PRUQLQJ1#)LUVW/#KH# VWLOO# VD\V# WKDW#KH#ZDV#QRW#DZDUH#RI#&RU\¶V# SDUWLFLSDWLRQ1#6LQFH#WKLV#YLHZ#LV#GLIIHUHQW#IURP#PLQH/#,#VXJJHVW#WKDW#ZH#FDOO#&RU\#DQG#ILQG#RXW#KLV# YLHZ1#%RE#VXJJHVWHG#+DQG#,#DJUHHG,#WKDW#ZH#VKRXOG#QRW#KDYH#RXU#FOLHQWV#JHW#LQYROYHG#LQ#WKLV1#%RE# DQG#,#GHFLGHG#WKDW#IURP#QRZ#RQ/#RXU#SKRQH#FRQYHUVDWLRQV#ZLOO#QRW#LQFOXGH#WKLUG#SDUWLHV#LQ#RUGHU#WR# DYRLG#RQH¶V#QRW#NQRZLQJ#ZKR#HOVH#LV#RQ#WKH#SKRQH1#%RE#DOVR#VDLG#WKDW#%RVWRQ#0XWXDO¶V#VLWXDWLRQ# LQWURGXFHG#WR#KLP#LV#YHU\#FOHDU1# # ,#WULHG#WR#FDOO#-RH#EXW#KH#LV#DOUHDG\#LQ#+RQJ#.RQJ1#,#ZDQWHG#WR#VHH#ZKDW#ZDV#VR#FRQYROXWHG#WR#KLP# DV/#,#KRSH/#REYLRXVO\#\RX#XQGHUVWRRG#P\#H0PDLO1#2EYLRXVO\/#-RH#GLG#QRW1#6LQFH#LW#LV#VR#GLIILFXOW#WR# KDYH#WKLV#WKLQJ#GRQH#ZLWK#-RH/#,#WKLQJ#ZH#VKRXOG#MXVW#GURS#LW#DQG#OHW#%RVWRQ#0XWXDO#GR#LWV#WKLQJ#RQ# LWV#RZQ#+ZKLFK#WKH\#DUH#DV#ZH#VSHDN,1# # #

00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000# #

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µRYHU#WLPH¶#WR#KLJKHU#OHYHO1# # #

00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000#

3DJH#49# <$<;&335# # #

([KLELW#6#+FRQWLQXHG,# # # )URP=#6WHYH#6DOPRQ# 7R=#&KXFN#0DF.LQQRQ# &&=#'HLWU#3RHKOPDQQ# # <HV/#DQG#,#WKLQN#ZH¶OO#ILQG#/DQVLQJ#ZHUH#XQKDSS\#DV#WR#+2:#ZH#GLDORJXHG#ZLWK#WKHP/#DQG#WKDW# DOVR#KDG#DQ# LQIOXHQFH1#:KLOH#,¶P#VXUH# LW#ZDV#PLVLQWHUSUHWHG/#,¶P# WROG#'HLWU#3RHKOPDQQ#GLGQ¶W# FRPH#DFURVV#YHU\#ZHOO#LQ#KLV#FRQYHUVDWLRQV#ZLWK#WKHP1# # # # # )URP=#'HLWU#3RHKOPDQQ# 7R=#&KXFN#0DF.LQQRQ>#6WHYH#6DOPRQ# # 6WHYH/#LW#WKH\#WROG#\RX#WKDW#,#DP#QRW#VXUSULVHG#DERXW#WKH#VWDWHPHQW1#7KHUH#ZDV#RQO\#RQH#SHUVRQ#WKDW# ,#VSRNH#DW#/DQVLQJ1#6KH#KHUVHOI#ZDV#UXGH/#LPSRVLQJ#DQG#FDQFHOOHG#RXU#+&KXFN#DQG#P\VHOI,#PHHWLQJ# ZLWK# WKHP#GD\#EHIRUH#ZH#ZHUH# WR#JR# WR#$WODQWD1#7KHLU#SRLQW#ZDV# WKDW#ZH#ZHUH# µGHPDQGLQJ¶# UHFLSURFLW\#EXVLQHVV#+FXVWRG\,#IURP#WKHP1#,#GLG#ZKDW#,#ZDV#WROG#E\#&KXFN#DQG#%UHWW#'DYLHV1#:H# GLG#QRW#H[WHQG#WKH#OLQHV#DV#WKH\#ZDQWHG#DQG#,#DP#VRUU\#LI#WKH\#GLG#QRW#OLNH#WKDW1#,#KDYH#EHHQ#GHDOLQJ# ZLWK#WKHP#IRU#WKH#SDVW#6#\HDUV#ZLWKRXW#DQ\#SUREOHP#XQWLO#QRW#DOO#RI#WKHLU#GHPDQGV#ZHUH#PHW1#$W# WKDW#SRLQW/#,#JXHVV/#,#IHOO#LQWR#GLVIDYRU1#7KH#RQO\#EDG#WKLQJ#LV#WKDW#ULJKW#QRZ#ZH#DUH#RXW#RI#'73/333# .#UHYHQXH1# # #

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

3DJH#4:# <$<;&335# # #

([KLELW#7# #

3$75,&.#.,11$5'¶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

00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000# # # &KXFN#0DF.LQQRQ¶V#ORJ#RI#HYHQWV=# # 452<#3DWULFN#DW#WKH#ODVW#PLQXWH#FDOOHG#LQ#WR#WDNH#D#YDFDWLRQ#GD\1# # 4256#3DWULFN#DUULYHG#DW#45=33#S1P1#³'URYH#KLV#EURWKHU0LQ0ODZ#WR#WKH#DLUSRUW1´# # 7259#6LFN#GD\1# # 9245#3DWULFN#DUULYHG#DW#43=33#D1P1/#VDLG#D#FDE#GLG#QRW#VKRZ#XS#WR#WDNH#KLP#WR#WKH#WUDLQ/#VR#KDG#WR# GULYH#LQ1#

3DJH#4;# <$<;&335# # #

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¶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µVPRNLQJ#JXQ1¶# #

3DJH#4<# <$<;&335# # #

([KLELW#8# #

7($0#&21)/,&7# # # )URP=#'DOH#&DPHURQ# 7R=#*OHQQ#:ULJKW# &F=#&KXFN#0DF.LQQRQ# # 7KDQN#\RX#IRU#\RXU#TXLFN#WXUQDURXQG#DQG#,#EHOLHYH#WKDW#\RXU#SUHVHQWDWLRQ#ZDV#GRQH#ZHOO1#,#ZRXOG# DGG/#KRZHYHU/#WKDW#ZH#VKRXOG#EH#FDUHIXO#DERXW#XVLQJ#ZRUGV#+LQ#OHWWHUV#DQG#RXU#SUHVHQWDWLRQV,#ZKLFK# WHQG#WR#XQGHUPLQH#WKH#µUHODWLRQVKLS#WHDP¶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µUHZDUGV¶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¶V#\RXU# FRQWDFW# DQ\ZD\1# )LQDOO\/#,#KDYHQ¶W#HYHQ#KHDUG#DERXW#WKLV#UHTXHVW#IURP#\RX#XQWLO#WRGD\1## #

3DJH#53# <$<;&335# # #

([KLELW#8#+FRQWLQXHG,# # # &KXFN/#\RXU#GHFLVLRQ# LV#QHHGHG#DQG#SHUKDSV#\RX#VKRXOG#FDOO#+RPHU#RU#-HQQLIHU#DQG#DVN# WKHP# RXWULJKW1#,Q#WKH#PHDQWLPH/#DV#ORQJ#DV#,#DP#µUHVSRQVLEOH¶#IRU#WKLV#VSHFLILF#HQWLW\/#,#H[SHFW#WR#EH#NHSW# DSSUDLVHG#RI#ZKDW#LV#EHLQJ#GLVFXVVHG/#GRQH#DQG#DFWHG#XSRQ/#DV#\RX#ZRXOG#H[SHFW#RI#PH1#,#KDYH# GRQH# VR# DQG# ZLOO# FRQWLQXH# WR# GR# VR1# )RU# WKDW# PDWWHU/# DOO# RWKHU# HQWLWLHV# IRU# ZKLFK# ,# KDYH# UHVSRQVLELOLW\1#5HZDUGV#²#DEVROXWHO\#PLVVHV#WKH#SRLQW1# # )URP=#&KXFN#0DF.LQQRQ# 7R=#'DOH#&DPHURQ>#*OHQQ#:ULJKW# # 3161# 6RXQGV#OLNH#WKHUH#LV#VRPH#IULFWLRQ#KHUH1#/HW¶V#WDON#DERXW#WKLV#RQ#0RQGD\#EHWZHHQ#WKH#WKUHH# RI#XV#EXW#WKH#FOLHQW¶V#LQWHUHVWV#PXVW#EH#IRUHPRVW1# # #