Please follow instruction

Criterion

Does not meet basic criterion

Meets basic criterion

Proficient

Outstanding

Provides a thorough summary of the assigned and chosen articles.

Does not summarize the article.

(0-26)

Provides a limited summary of the assigned or chosen article.

(27-30)

Provides a sufficient summary of the assigned or chosen articles.

(30-34)

Gives a detailed and compelling summary of the assigned or chosen article.

(34-38)

Discusses and explains the key points of the article.

Does not discuss or explain the key points of the article.

(0-26)

Discusses and explains1 key point from the article.

(26-30)

Discusses and explains2 or 3 key points from the article.

(30-34)

Gives a detailed discussion and explanation of4 or more key points of the article.

(34-38)

Discusses and explains the individual’s learnings from the article.

Does not discus or explain the individual’s learnings from the articles.

(0-26)

Discusses and explains 1 individual learning from each of the articles.

(26-30)

Discusses and explains 2 or 3 individual learning from each of the articles.

(30-33)

Gives a detailed discussion and explanation of4 or more individual learnings from both articles.

(34-37)

Writes at graduate level including sufficient and appropriate references in APA style

Poorly written, incoherent sentences, poor spelling, unacceptable grammar and/or numerous APA errors.

(0-26)

Numerous writing errors but sufficient and correct APA formatting; offers 1 reference.

(26-29)

Very few errors in writing and APA usage; offers 2 different references.

(30-33)

Virtually no errors in writing and APA usage; offers more than 2 different references.

(33-37)

Total

0-104

105-119

120-134

135-150