Here it is

critical_analysis_rubric.docx

Home >Computer Science homework help >Here it is

Critical Analysis & Discussions Rubric

On-Time Posting	On Time	Late 1 Day	Late 2 Days	Late 3 Days	No Posting
Critical Analysis #1	10 points Posted first critical analysis of another student's Case Study before 11:59PM Eastern Time Thursday.	7 points Posted first critical analysis of another student's Case Study before 11:59PM Eastern Time Friday.	4 points Posted first critical analysis of another student's Case Study before 11:59PM Eastern Time Saturday.	2 points Posted first critical analysis of another student's Case Study before 11:59PM Eastern Time Sunday.	0 points Did not post first critical analysis of another student's Case Study before 11:59PM Eastern Time Sunday.
Critical Analysis #2	10 points Posted Critical Analysis of a second student's Case Study before 11:59PM Eastern Time Thursday.	7 points Posted Critical Analysis of a second student's Case Study before 11:59PM Eastern Time Friday.	4 points Posted Critical Analysis of a second student's Case Study before 11:59PM Eastern Time Saturday.	2 points Posted a critical analysis of a second student's Case Study before 11:59PM Eastern Time Sunday.	0 points Did not post a Critical Analysis of a second student's Case Study before 11:59PM Eastern Time Sunday.
Quality of Critical Analyses	Excellent	Good	Acceptable	Needs Significant Improvement	No Posting
Quality of Critical Analysis #1	20 points Posted a clear, concise, and thorough critical analysis of another student's Case Study (3 or more points of analysis).	17 points Posted a complete and coherent critical analysis of another student's Case Study (2 or more points of analysis).	14 points Posted a critical analysis of another student's Case Study. Addresses at least one of the major points of discussion.	4 points Posted a minimal response to another student's Case Study. The response did not provide a critical analysis of the Case Study.	0 points Did not post a critical analysis of another student's Case Study.
Quality of Critical Analysis #2	20 points Posted a clear, concise, and thorough critical analysis of a second student's Case Study (3 or more points of analysis).	17 points Posted a mostly complete and coherent response to the initial discussion topic. Addresses the major points of discussion, but misses minor points.	14 points Posted a critical analysis of a second student's Case Study. Addresses at least one of the major points of discussion.	4 points Posted a minimal response to a second student's Case Study. The response did not provide a critical analysis of the Case Study.	0 points Did not post a critical analysis of a second student's Case Study.
References for Critical Analyses	Excellent	Acceptable	Needs Significant Improvement	No References
References in Critical Analysis #1	5 points Includes 3 or more scholarly / authoritative sources of information in the response and correctly cites each reference using in-text citations and a reference list.	3 points Includes 2 or more scholarly / authoritative sources of information but sources were improperly cited. Citations and/or references provide sufficient information to locate and retrieve the resource.	2 points Sources were mentioned but the citations and/or references did not provide sufficient information to locate or retrieve the resource. OR, the sources used were not authoritative.	0 points Does not include in-text citations and references.
References in Critical Analysis #2	5 points Includes 3 or more scholarly / authoritative sources of information in the response and correctly cites each reference using in-text citations and a reference list.	3 points Includes 2 or more scholarly / authoritative sources of information but sources were improperly cited. Citations and/or references provide sufficient information to locate and retrieve the resource.	2 points Sources were mentioned but the citations and/or references did not provide sufficient information to locate or retrieve the resource. OR, the sources used were not authoritative.	0 points Does not include in-text citations and references.
Timing of Comments in Critical Analysis Threads	On Time	Late Comments	No Response
Comments in First Critical Analysis Thread	5 points Completed posting comments to another student's critical analysis before 11:59PM Eastern Time Sunday.	0 points Completed posting comments to another student's critical analysis after 11:59PM Eastern Time Sunday.	0 points Does not post comments in a critical analysis thread.
Comments in Second Critical Analysis Thread	5 points Completed posting comments to a second student's critical analysis before 11:59PM Eastern Time Sunday.	0 points Completed posting comments to another student's critical analysis after 11:59PM Eastern Time Sunday.	0 points Does not post comments in a second critical analysis thread.
Quality of Comments to Critical Analyses	Excellent	Acceptable	Minimal	No Response
Comments in First Critical Analysis Thread	10 points Posted a complete and coherent response to a fellow student's critical analysis. Fully addresses the student's work and adds value to the discussion.	7.5 points Posted a coherent response to a fellow student's critical analysis. Addresses the student's points and adds some value to the discussion.	5 points Responds to a fellow student, but adds little or no value to the discussion	0 points Does not respond to another student.
Comments in Second Critical Analysis Thread	10 points Posted a complete and coherent response to a fellow student's critical analysis in a second thread (different from the first). Fully addresses the student's work and adds value to the discussion.	7.5 points Posted a coherent response to a fellow student's critical analysis (in a second critical analysis thread). Addresses the student's points and adds some value to the discussion.	5 points Responds to a fellow student, but adds little or no value to the discussion.	0 points Does not respond to another student.