Feedback/Rubric

Element

Excellent

2pt

Average

1 pt

Below Average

0 pts

Cover sheet:

Purpose Statement and Dependent Variable

Clear statement that describes expected relations among variables; key variable is clearly stated

Statement describing expected relations among variables is not very clear; dependent variable is missing

Vague statement of purpose or fails to propose a relationship among variables; dependent variable is missing

Cover sheet:

Target population

The target population is clearly identified

--

The target population is not clearly identified

Cover sheet:

Analysis Plan

The plan for analysis is appropriate for the data the survey will provide

The analysis plan is appropriate with some exceptions

The analysis plan is not appropriate for the data the survey will provide

Instructions

Instructions to participants are clear and easy to follow

Instructions are mostly clear, however a person might have to ask for clarification

Instructions are not clear, and a person would have to ask for clarification

Organization/Layout

The layout of the survey makes it easy to read and respond to all items

The layout makes some items easy to respond to, but makes others difficult to respond to

The layout of the survey makes it difficult to respond to most or all items

Language

Clear, unambiguous, specific language is utilized throughout;

With some exceptions the language used is clear, unambiguous and specific

Most of the language used is not clear, unambiguous and specific

Content appropriate to intended audience

Survey instructions, items, and demographic questions are appropriate for the target population

Most of the survey instructions, items, and demographic questions are appropriate to the intended audience

Most of the survey instructions, items, and demographic questions are not appropriate for the target population

Face validity

All items on the survey appear to be relevant to the purpose statement and DV

Some items on the survey do not appear to be relevant to the purpose statement and DV

Most or all of the items on the survey do not appear to be relevant to the purpose statement and DV

Demographics

Relevant demographic information is asked for and placed appropriately in the survey

Some requested demographic information is not relevant, or key demographic questions are not included, or demographic items are not placed appropriately

Not enough demographic information is requested, or some questions are inappropriate, or requested information is entirely irrelevant

Number of Items

Contains at least 10 Likert and 2 open-ended items; demographic items are included separately

--

Contains fewer than required amount