Article Summary- Rhythmic Engagement with Music in Infancy

Summary (10)

10

8

4

0

Main points of the article are summarized accurately and thoroughly

Summary contains few sentences pulled verbatim form the article and expansion is evident

Summary is organized in a logical way

Some main points are summarized

Summary contains a few inaccuracies or omissions

Many sentences are pulled verbatim form the article without expansion

Summary shows some degree of organization

Most main points are not addressed

Summary contains many inaccuracies

Summary contains many sentences pulled verbatim from the article with no expansion

Summary lacks any organization

No summary provided

Personal Reflections (4)

4

2

0

0

Opinions are stated clearly

Responses demonstrate a high degree of reflection

Opinions present but not clearly stated

Some responses show a limited degree of reflection

Opinion does not make sense

Responses show no reflection

Not addressed

Documentation/Appearance (1)

1

0

0

No grammar, spelling, or usage errors

Reference and citation is provided

Some errors in grammar, spelling, or usage

Reference citation is provided but not in APA format

Many errors in grammar, spelling, or usage

No reference(s) and citation(s) are given

Critique (10)

Future Research/

Unanswered Questions

10

6

2

0

Critique is given in a clear manner and many points of article are covered

Questions are relevant &appropriate

Critique is somewhat clear or some points of article are not covered

Questions asked/ offered demonstrate limited understanding

Critique is unclear and it is unclear what the points of the article are

Questions/ comments are inappropriate or missing

Critique not provided