|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Criteria
|
Exceptional
|
Good
|
Fair / Adequate
|
Limited
|
Poor / Unacceptable
|
|
Attention to instructions and assignment
|
10 points
Can earn between 9-10 points. Follows and exceeds expectations noted in instructions
|
8 points
Follows instructions
|
7 points
Follows some but not all instructions
|
6 points
Can earn between 1-6 points. Gestures toward instructions but demonstrates little comprehension or competency
|
0 points
Disregards instructions
|
|
Creative thought / problem-solving / self-assessment
|
20 points
Can earn between 19-20 points. Demonstrates a high degree of originality, insight and/or problem-solving skill
|
18 points
Can earn between 17-18 points. Shows some originality, insight and/or problem-solving skill
|
16 points
Can earn between 15-16 points. Shows minimally acceptable originality, insight and/or problem-solving skill
|
14 points
Can earn between 5-14 points. Demonstrates very little creative thought or insight; consists mostly of second-hand ideas
|
4 points
Can earn between 0-4 points. Shows no original thought; all second-hand ideas
|
|
Adherence to APA 6th ed. style
|
15 points
Can earn between 14-15 points. No APA style errors
|
13 points
No more than three APA style errors
|
12 points
Can earn between 11-12 points. Demonstrated four or five APA style errors
|
10 points
Can earn between 3-10 points. More than six APA style errors
|
2 points
Can earn between 0-2 points. No attempt at APA style
|
|
Development and support
|
30 points
Can earn between 28-30 points. Thoroughly and insightfully explores, explains and supports each idea
|
27 points
Can earn between 25-27 points. Develops and supports key points
|
24 points
Can earn between 22-24 points. Inconsistently develops and supports ideas
|
21 points
Can earn between 6-21 points. Inadequately or ineffectively explains and defends ideas
|
5 points
Does not make a meaningful attempt to explain or support ideas
|
|
Source use, including appropriate guidelines
|
10 points
Can earn between 9-10 points. Demonstrates comprehension of all source material; integrates sources appropriately and effectively
|
8 points
Most source material is appropriate, but some if not fully explained or integrated into the paper
|
7 points
Source material is not consistently appropriate or integrated into the paper
|
6 points
Can earn between 1-6 points. Source material is rarely appropriate and/or rarely integrated into the paper
|
0 points
No use of source material
|
|
Clarity, including grammar
|
15 points
Can earn between 14-15 points. Demonstrates comprehension of all source material; integrates sources appropriately and effectively
|
13 points
Most ideas are presented clearly but sometimes too simplistically
|
12 points
Can earn between 11-12 points. Wordy; some points require rereading to understand fully
|
10 points
Can earn between 3-10 points. Unclear and difficult to understand
|
2 points
Can earn between 0-2 points. Largely incomprehensible
|
|
Overall Score
|
A Grade
90 or more
|
B Grade
80 or more
|
C Grade
70 or more
|
D Grade
60 or more
|
F Grade
0 or more
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|