Eiffel Towers Ltd, a listed company, was a builder and property developer specialising in projects in Brisbane’s central business district. It has five directors. Giscard is the managing director and Henri is the chief financial officer. They are the only

Criteria

F C B A HD

Quality of analysis and problem- solving skills:

Identifies legal issue/problem

No clear identification of legal issues relevant to the case and/or issues identified are not relevant.

Identifies at least one legal issue relevant to the case but more detail is required.

Identifies most legal issues relevant to the case but lacks clarity.

Correctly identifies most legal issues relevant to the case.

Correctly identifies all legal issues relevant to the case.

Evaluates relevant legal principles

Lack of relevant legal principles or those identified are incorrect

Outlines some relevant legal principles but citation of applicable cases and/or statutory provisions needs more detail.

Outlines some relevant legal principles, citing

applicable cases and/or statutory provisions.

Outlines all relevant legal principles, citing

applicable cases and/or statutory provisions.

Outlines all relevant legal principles, citing

applicable cases and/or statutory provisions.

Develops logical conclusion

Stated conclusion is not aligned with the question fails to tie together legal arguments either for or against the application of legal principles.

Stated conclusion is broadly aligned with the question and ties together some legal arguments for the application of legal principles.

Stated conclusion broadly answers the question, and ties together some legal arguments for and against the application of particular legal principles.

Stated conclusion answers the question and ties together most the legal arguments for and against the application of particular legal principles.

Stated conclusion answers the question, and logically ties together the legal arguments for and against the application of particular legal principles.

Quality of research skills:

Research

Little or no evidence of original research

Evidence of some original research

Evidence of original research from a number of different sources

Evidence of a high level of original research

Evidence of a high level of original research which enhances application and analysis

Citation and referencing Many errors and/or little or no attempt made at referencing

Mostly accurate – some minor errors

Consistently correct

Quality of communication skills:

Communication skills

Inappropriate style, tone and/or choice of language or many errors of spelling and/or grammar. Poor structure and/or use of paragraphs or headings

Mostly appropriate style, tone and/or choice of language. Spelling and grammar mostly accurate. Mostly appropriate structure and/or some use of paragraphs or headings to enhance readability

Appropriate style, tone and/or choice of language. Spelling and grammar consistently accurate. Appropriate structure and use of paragraphs or headings