Help with assignement revision - ISO 27002 based

evaluation_summary_for_task3.docx

Home >Information Systems homework help >Help with assignement revision - ISO 27002 based

Evaluation Summary for Security & Policy Standards: VLT Task 3

Final Score:	Does not Meet
Overall comments:	11/10/2014: The submission demonstrates a firm grasp of the foundational concepts of defining and implementing a security audit using industry best practices. In order to meet the standard, a more thorough analysis of the questions set must be completed to justify the purpose of the question in the context of the ISO 27002 security standard.

Detailed Results (Rubric used: VLT Task 3)

Articulation of Response (clarity, organization, mechanics)
(0) Unsatisfactory	(1) Needs Revision	(2) Satisfactory
The candidate provides unsatisfactory articulation of response.	The candidate provides weak articulation of response.	The candidate provides adequate articulation of response.
Criterion Score: 2.00 Comments on this criterion: 11/10/2014: The submission was clear, organized and presented a solid level of articulation.
A. Question Set
(0) Unsatisfactory	(1) Needs Revision	(2) Satisfactory
The candidate does not provide a completed “As-Is Question Set.”	Not applicable.	The candidate provides a completed “As-Is Question Set.”
Criterion Score: 0.00 Comments on this criterion: 11/10/2014: The submission includes a completed as-is question set. However, the task prompt asks for the justification for the security audit question in the context of the ISO 27002 security standard. An appropriate justification for each question is not evident in the response.
B. Question Categories
(0) Unsatisfactory	(1) Needs Revision	(2) Satisfactory
The candidate does not provide any additional question categories for the “As-Is Question Set.”	The candidate provides 1 additional question category for the “As-Is Question Set.”	The candidate provides 2 additional question categories for the “As-Is Question Set.”
Criterion Score: 2.00 Comments on this criterion: 11/10/2014: Compliance management and business continuity are presented as two additional question categories to include in the question set.
B1. Justification
(0) Unsatisfactory	(1) Needs Revision	(2) Satisfactory
The candidate does not provide a logical justification for the inclusion of each additional question.	The candidate provides a logical justification, with insufficient support, for the inclusion of each additional question.	The candidate provides a logical justification, with sufficient support, for the inclusion of each additional question.
Criterion Score: 1.00 Comments on this criterion: 11/10/2014: The submission presents a justification for the additional questions, however, the relationship of the justification to the ISO 27002 security standard is not clear.
C. Sources
(0) Unsatisfactory	(1) Needs Revision	(2) Satisfactory
When the candidate uses sources, the candidate does not provide in-text citations and references for each source used.	When the candidate uses sources, the candidate provides appropriate in-text citations and references with major deviations from APA style.	When the candidate uses sources, the candidate provides appropriate in-text citations and references accurately or with only minor deviations from APA style, OR the candidate does not use sources.
Criterion Score: 0.00 Comments on this criterion: 11/10/2014: This area will be evaluated based on the justifications.