for genius2013

! "!

#!$%!&'()*!+',-.!/001!

CHAPTER ONE IDENTIFYING ARGUMENTS

AND THEIR PARTS

!"#$%&'(#)%"*#%*#+,*-%"(,.#*!"#$%&'(*

234!5)(36!78!9:76!*));!<7,,!*-!)8!7=-8975>78?!'8=!-@',3'978?!'4?3A-896!9:'9!)((34!78! 8'934',!,'8?3'?-.!<79:!'!*7?!-AB:'676!)8!'4?3A-896!78!-@-4>='>!4-'6)878?%!C:-!B34B)6-! )5!9:76!(:'B9-4!76!9)!:-,B!>)3!7AB4)@-!>)34!'*7,79>!9)!7=-8975>!'4?3A-896!'8=!9:-74!B'496%! D-!<7,,!*-?78!,-'4878?!:)<!9)!-@',3'9-!'4?3A-89!78!$:'B9-4!C<)%!

D:-8!<-!36-!9:-!<)4=!E/$0'1,"#E!78!,)?7(.!<-!A-'8!!"#$%"&'"#%!%$($)%#"*)"+,*-,"#&($" .%,$"/0$(*#$"&0"/0$(*#$#1"!0$"*)%$)2$2"%&"3$"0$!#&)#"%&"3$4*$5$"!)&%,$0"#%!%$($)%".%,$"

-&)-46#*&)17!

C:-4-!'4-!9:4--!'6B-(96!)5!9:76!=-578797)8!9:'9!8--=!-FB,'8'97)8%!

G7469.!'!2#/#,1,"#!76!!"#$)%$)-$"%,!%"*#"$*%,$0"%06$"&0"'!4#$%!+-4-E6!'8)9:-4!<'>!9)!-FB4-66! 9:-!=-578797)8!)5!'!2#/#,1,"#H!!"#$)%$)-$"%,!%",!#"!"%06%,"5!46$%!C:-4-!'4-!9<)!#$'#+* 3/4',2H!)8-!76!9:-!9439:!@',3-!%06$!'8=!9:-!)9:-4!76!9:-!9439:!@',3-!'!4#$%!G)4!-F'AB,-.!9:-! 6-89-8(-!

I)6!J8?-,-6!76!78!$',75)487'!

:'6!9:-!9439:!@',3-!%06$.!<:-4-'6!9:-!6-89-8(-!

K-<!L)4;!$79>!76!78!$',75)487'!

:'6!9:-!9439:!@',3-!'!4#$%!

29:-4!9:'8!69'9-A-896.!<:'9!;78=6!)5!6-89-8(-6!'4-!9:-4-M!N63',,>!O3-697)86.!()AA'8=6.! 4-O3-696.!'8=!-F(,'A'97)86!=)8E9!:'@-!9439:!@',3-6%!G)4!-F'AB,-.!75!P!6'>!9)!A>!('9! Q-4@76:!Q'4,78?!R'S;S'!Q-4@76:!Q7'*,79)T!

U-9!)55!9:-!9'*,-V!

P!:'@-!?7@-8!Q-4@76:!'!()AA'8=!!!<:7(:!:-!B4)*'*,>!<)8E9!)*->!!!*39!P!:'@-!8)9!A'=-!'! 69'9-A-89%!RPE,,!A-897)8!A>!('96.!Q-4@76:.!Q7F7-!'8=!U)46:7-.!78!@'47)36!-F'AB,-6%T!

! /!

W7A7,'4,>.!75!>)3!'6;!'!(,'66A'9-!

+)<!=7=!>)3!=)!)8!9:-!9-69M!

>)3!<)3,=!:'@-!'6;-=!'!O3-697)8.!8)9!A'=-!'!69'9-A-89%!

C:-!6-()8=!'6B-(9!)5!9:-!=-578797)8!)5!E'4?3A-89E!9:'9!8--=6!-FB,'8'97)8!76!9:76H!8)97(-!9:-! B:4'6-!E'4-!789-8=-=!9)E%!25!()346-.!<-!=)8E9!',<'>6!=)!9:-!9:78?6!<-!789-8=!9)!=)%! W)A-97A-6!P!=)8E9!?-9!3B!'6!-'4,>!'6!P!789-8=%!W7A7,'4,>.!6)A-97A-6!'!B-46)8!!!'8!'4?3-4!!! A7?:9!?7@-!B4-A76-6!9:'9!:-!)4!6:-!789-8=6!'6!4-'6)86!9)!*-,7-@-!'!()8(,367)8.!*39!9:-! B4-A76-6!A7?:9!8)9!4-',,>!*-!4-'6)86!9)!*-,7-@-!9:-!()8(,367)8%!C:76!'4?3-4!:'6!?7@-8!'! *'=!'4?3A-89%!I'9-4!)8.!<-E,,!4-578-!9:-!()8(-B96!36-=!9)!=-9-4A78-!<:-9:-4!'4?3A-896! '4-!?))=!)4!*'=.!'8=!<-E,,!,-'48!6)A-!9-(:87O3-6!9:'9!<7,,!:-,B!36!'BB,>!9:)6-!()8(-B96.! *39!5)4!8)<!9:-!7AB)49'89!B)789!9)!4-A-A*-4!76!9:'9!8)9!',,!'4?3A-896!'4-!?))=!'4?3A-896! !!6)A-!'4-!'8=!6)A-!'4-8E9%!

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

J8!-'6>!<'>!9)!4-A-A*-4!9:-!*'67(!7=-'!)5!9:-!=-578797)8!)5!E'4?3A-89E!78!,)?7(!76!9)!9:78;! )5!79!78!9-4A6!)5!9:76!,799,-!5)4A3,'H!

!

!

!

!

P9!76!7AB)49'89!9)!8)97(-!9:'9!)34!=-578797)8!)5!E'4?3A-89E!76!'!9-(:87(',!=-578797)8%!P9! ()44-6B)8=6!9)!)8-!!!*39!8)9!',,!!!)5!9:-!A'8>!<'>6!9:-!<)4=!76!36-=!78!-@-4>='>! ,'8?3'?-%!X)69!()AA)8,>.!9:-!<)4=!E'4?3A-89E!76!36-=!78!-@-4>='>!,'8?3'?-!9)!A-'8!!" ,$!%$2"5$03!4"!4%$0-!%*&).!*39!9:'9E6!8)9!<:'9!<-!A-'8!*>!E'4?3A-89E!78!,)?7(%!C:-4-!76! 8)9:78?!<4)8?!<79:!'8>!)5!()AA)8!36-6!)5!9:-!<)4=!E'4?3A-89E.!*39!78!,)?7(!<-!'4-!3678?! 9:-!<)4=!<79:!)8,>!)8-!)5!796!()AA)8!A-'878?6%!

ARGUMENT = PREMISE(S) + CONCLUSION

! Y!

5$,1)2,*/"&*-%"(4'2)%"*!"#$%&'(,$2*

259-8!(-49'78!<)4=6!)4!B:4'6-6!'4-!36-=!9)!7894)=3(-!'!B4-A76-!)4!'!()8(,367)8%!I-9E6!(',,! 63(:!<)4=6!'8=!B:4'6-6!*)%0&26-$0#%!P5!<-!'4-!5'A7,7'4!<79:!6)A-!)5!9:-!A)69!()AA)8,>! 36-=!B4-A76-!'8=!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-46!<-E,,!*-!78!B4-99>!?))=!6:'B-.!5)4!9<)!4-'6)86%! G7469.!<-E,,!B4)*'*,>!*-!'*,-!9)!4-()?87Z-!)9:-4!B4-A76-!)4!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-46!9:'9! <)4;!,7;-!9:-!)8-6!<79:!<:7(:!<-E4-!',4-'=>!5'A7,7'4%!W-()8=.!<:-8!<-!,));!'9! '4?3A-896!9:'9!=)8E9!:'@-!'8>!B4-A76-!)4!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-46.!<-E,,!*-!'*,-!9)!'==! ()AA)8!()8(,367)8!)4!B4-A76-!7894)=3(-46!9)!38=-469'8=!<:7(:!B'49!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!76! 9:-!()8(,367)8!'8=!<:7(:!76S'4-!9:-!B4-A76-SB4-A76-6%!

C:-!5),,)<78?!*)F!?7@-6!>)3!6)A-!)5!9:-!<)4=6!'8=!B:4'6-6!()AA)8,>!36-=!9)!7894)=3(-! ()8(,367)86[!78!-'(:.!PE@-!78=7('9-=!9:-!B)6797)8!)5!9:-!()8(,367)8!<79:!'!*,'8;!,78-H! \\\\\\\\\\%!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

COMMON CONCLUSION INTRODUCERS: ! C:-4-5)4-!\\\\\\\\\\! W)!\\\\\\\\\\! $)86-O3-89,>!\\\\\\\\\\! +-8(-!\\\\\\\\\\! C:36!\\\\\\\\\\! +-4-E6!<:>!\\\\\\\\\\! C:76!76!<:>!\\\\\\\\\\! C:76!B4)@-6!9:'9!\\\\\\\\\\! C:76!6:)<6!9:'9!\\\\\\\\\\! C:76!=-A)8694'9-6!9:'9!\\\\\\\\\\! C:76!A-'86!\\\\\\\\\\! C:76!63??-696!9:'9!\\\\\\\\\\! P9!5),,)<6!9:'9!\\\\\\\\\\! J(()4=78?,>!\\\\\\\\\\! D-!A'>!()8(,3=-!9:'9!\\\\\\\\\\! G)4!9:-6-!4-'6)86.!\\\\\\\\\\! J6!63(:!\\\\\\\\\\! U7@-8!9:'9.!\\\\\\\\\\! ]-('36-!)5!9:76.!\\\\\\\\\\! ^4?)!\\\\\\\\\\! _-45)4(-!\\\\\\\\\\!

!

! `!

C:-!5),,)<78?!*)F!?7@-6!>)3!6)A-!)5!9:-!<)4=6!'8=!B:4'6-6!()AA)8,>!36-=!9)!7894)=3(-! B4-A76-6[!78!-'(:.!PE@-!78=7('9-=!9:-!B)6797)8!)5!9:-!B4-A76-!<79:!'!*,'8;!,78-H! \\\\\\\\\\%!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

I-9E6!8)97(-!'!,799,-!*79!A)4-!'*)39!:)<!9:-!B4-A76-!7894)=3(-4!<)4=6!E*-('36-E!'8=!E678(-E! <)4;%!$)867=-4!9:76!'4?3A-89H!

L)3!6:)3,=!9';-!>)34!3A*4-,,'!3$-!6#$!79E6!?)78?!9)!4'78%!

C:-!<)4=!E*-('36-E!7894)=3(-6!'!B4-A76-%!P5!9:-!<)4=!E*-('36-E!()3,=!9',;.!79!<)3,=!6'>H!!

a+->.!<:'9!()A-6!8-F9.!7AA-=7'9-,>!'59-4!A-.!76!'!B4-A76-%a!

W)!9:-!69'9-A-89!9:'9!79E6!?)78?!9)!4'78!76!9:-!B4-A76-!78!9:76!'4?3A-89%!C:-!()8(,367)8.! B,'(-=!47?:9!*-5)4-!E*-('36-E.!76!9:'9!>)3!6:)3,=!9';-!>)34!3A*4-,,'%!D-!('8!38=-469'8=.! 9:-8.!9:-!6943(934-!)5!9:-!6-89-8(-!-FB4-6678?!9:-!'4?3A-89!'6!5),,)<6H!

(%"(4'2)%"!3$-!6#$!B4-A76-!

COMMON PREMISE INTRODUCERS: ! ]-('36-!\\\\\\\\\\! E$'36-!\\\\\\\\\\! $3Z!\\\\\\\\\\! W78(-!\\\\\\\\\\! G)4!\\\\\\\\\\! C:76!76!7AB,7-=!*>!\\\\\\\\\\! P8!@7-<!)5!9:-!5'(9!9:'9!\\\\\\\\\\! P8!,7?:9!)5!\\\\\\\\\\! J6!\\\\\\\\\\! P8'6A3(:!'6!\\\\\\\\\\! W--78?!'6!\\\\\\\\\\! W--78?!9:'9!\\\\\\\\\\! U7@-8!9:'9!\\\\\\\\\\! C:76!5),,)<6!54)A!\\\\\\\\\\! G)4!9:-!4-'6)8!9:'9!\\\\\\\\\\! C:-!4-'6)8!76!9:'9!\\\\\\\\\\! C:-!4-'6)8!*-78?!9:'9!\\\\\\\\\\! b-'6)8!*-78?!\\\\\\\\\\! C:76!76!*-('36-!\\\\\\\\\\!

J59-4!',,.!\\\\\\\\\\!

! c!

C:-!6'A-!'4?3A-89!()3,=!:'@-!*--8!)4?'87Z-=!=755-4-89,>.!,7;-!9:76H!

8$-!6#$!79E6!?)78?!9)!4'78.!>)3!6:)3,=!9';-!>)34!3A*4-,,'%!

+-4-.!9:-!6943(934-!)5!9:-!6-89-8(-!-FB4-6678?!9:-!'4?3A-89!76H!

3$-!6#$!B4-A76-.!(%"(4'2)%"!

C:-!538(97)8!)5!9:-!<)4=!E*-('36-E!=)-6!)&%!=-B-8=!)8!796!B,'(-A-89!R)4!B)6797)8T%!

C:-!<)4=!E678(-E!('8!538(97)8!-F'(9,>!,7;-!9:-!<)4=!E*-('36-EH!

(%"(4'2)%"!#*)-$!B4-A76-!

#*)-$!B4-A76-.!(%"(4'2)%"!

D:'9!'*)39!'!()86943(97)8!,7;-!9:-!5),,)<78?M!

P9E6!?)78?!9)!4'78%!8$-!6#$"&'"%,*#.!>)3!6:)3,=!9';-!>)34!3A*4-,,'%!!

C:-!<)4=!E*-('36-E!76!697,,!538(97)878?!'6!'!B4-A76-!7894)=3(-4!78!9:76!-F'AB,-.!*39!9:-! B4-A76-!9:'9!79!7894)=3(-6!76!9:-!69'9-A-89!4-5-44-=!9)!*>!9:-!<)4=!E9:76EH!79E6!?)78?!9)!4'78%!

-%"(4'2)%"%!8$-!6#$"&'"%,*#.!B4-A76-%!!

$)867=-4!9:-6-!9<)!-F'AB,-6H!

9*5$)!%,!%!79E6!?)78?!9)!4'78.!>)3!6:)3,=!9';-!>)34!3A*4-,,'%!!

P9E6!?)78?!9)!4'78%!9*5$)!%,!%.!>)3!6:)3,=!9';-!>)34!3A*4-,,'%!!

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

9*5$)!%,!%!B4-A76-.!(%"(4'2)%"!

_4-A76-%!9*5$)!%,!%.!(%"(4'2)%"*

P5!>)3!'4-!5'A7,7'4!<79:!9:-!B4-A76-!'8=!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-46!P!:'@-!?7@-8!>)3.!>)3!<7,,! B4)*'*,>!*-!'*,-!9)!4-()?87Z-!)9:-4!B4-A76-!'8=!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-46!<:-8!>)3! -8()389-4!9:-A%!

! d!

6+,$,*!2*#+,*-%"(4'2)%"7*

C:-4-!76!8)!43,-!'*)39!<:-4-!78!'8!'4?3A-89!'!()8(,367)8!A369!*-!B,'(-=.!)4!B)6797)8-=.! 78!'8!'4?3A-89%!RD-E@-!',4-'=>!6--8!9:76.!*39!,-9E6!5)(36!-FB,7(79,>!)8!79!8)<%T!C:-! ()8(,367)8!A7?:9!*-!9:-!57469!69'9-A-89!78!'8!'4?3A-89.!79!A7?:9!*-!9:-!,'69!69'9-A-89.!)4!79! A7?:9!*-!B39!*-9<--8!B4-A76-6%!

+-4-!'4-!9:4--!-F'AB,-6!)5!-'(:!"!()8(,367)86!'4-!*),=5'(-=!'8=!38=-4,78-=[!B4-A76-! '8=!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-46!'4-!79',7(7Z-=!'8=!38=-4,78-=%!

C:-!()8(,367)8!76!9:-!57469!69'9-A-89!78!-'(:!)5!9:-!5),,)<78?!9:4--!-F'AB,-6H!

8%'*2+%'4&*#/9,*:%'$*'1;$,44/.!3$-!6#$!79E6!?)78?!9)!4'78%!

<)0+#)"0*=!>?*)2*/"*'$0,"#*(/44)"0.!3$-!6#$!-@-4>!,75-.!78!-@-4>!,'8=.!:'6! @',3-!'8=!=7?879>%!eI'34'!]36:.!O3)9-=!78!aG7469!I'=>!WB-';6!J9!NK! JPQW!X--978?.a!KL"!K-<6!RK-<!L)4;T.!&38-!/.!/00d%f!

5%'4#$:*%@",$2*#$/.*2,$3/42*$'#+4,224:.!#*)-$!9:-6-!('96!,7;-!'!A-',!)5!5'9! #$%&'$(')*+,-.'/0$*12'3.'4.'056,578':)*(!4#"&'";!#%":'0*-!%! RD'6:78?9)8.!Q%$%H!K'97)8',!U-)?4'B:7(!W)(7-9>.!"gdgT.!B%!d`%f!

C:-!()8(,367)8!76!9:-!,'69!69'9-A-89!78!-'(:!)5!9:-!5),,)<78?!9:4--!-F'AB,-6H!

8$-!6#$!79E6!?)78?!9)!4'78.!:%'*2+%'4&*#/9,*:%'$*'1;$,44/%!

-9$&&7%$$)'12':$;<'*=6:&5'6=)'*=%1&&1=>';$'(56&12;1+6&&7'(5?(525=;'@216=2'

'8=!J67'8!JA-47('86%!:#"!"0$#64%.!A%44:@%%&*)"#,"#)%"/44:*/"&*

'")"#,"#)%"/44:*(+'$"2*%'#*(+/$/(#,$2*#+/#*B)#*)"#%*$/()/4)C,&*/"&*

0,"&,$)C,&*#:.,(/2#)"0-.'/A6=+7'B6=>'C*5=8'DE5(#$(F1=>'G6+58'

K-?)97'978?!P=-8979>H!J67'8!JA-47('8!_4)5-667)8',!J(9)46!78!+),,><))=.a! 78!&-8875-4!I--!'8=!X78!h:)3.!-=6%.!:#*!)":($0*-!)"<&6%,=">64%60$?" @2$)%*%A?"!)2";%,)*-*%A%!RK-<!L)4;H!b)39,-=?-.!/00`T.!B%!/c`%f!

J,,!6)38=6!'4-!('36-=!*>!6)A-9:78?!A)@78?!*'(;!'8=!5)49:!@-4>!5'69%! D:-8!6)A-9:78?!A)@-6!*'(;!'8=!5)49:!@-4>!5'69!<-!6'>!79!@7*4'9-6%!B&! 2%'"&2*/$,*(/'2,&*;:*3);$/#)%"%!eP,,'!_)=-8=)45.!C,$"C06$"8&&D"&'" B&6)2#"E$"F$!0.'HI<1+6>$J'I<1&)(5=K2'E(-66.!"gccT.!B%!i%f!

C:-!()8(,367)8!76!*-9<--8!B4-A76-6!78!-'(:!)5!9:-!5),,)<78?!9:4--!-F'AB,-6H!

P9E6!?)78?!9)!4'78%!B&.!:%'*2+%'4&*#/9,*:%'$*'1;$,44/.!3$-!6#$!>)3!=)8E9! <'89!9)!?-9!<-9%!

-/LM#'7$*'2=1;+<'7$*'&56N5'7$*(25&#'$?5=';$':5',1&&5).'!*(%'4&*",3,$*

2")#(+!3$-!6#$!P!<)3,=8E9!<'89!6)A-)8-!9)!;7,,!A-%!e$:'4,-6!X'86)8.! O3)9-=!78!&):8!U7,A)4-!<79:!b)8!j-88-4.!C,$"9!03!G$"H$&/4$="C,$"C0*/" %&"F$4%$0"BD$4%$0"!)2"8$A&)2%!RI)6!J8?-,-6H!JA);.!"ggcT.!B%!c%f!

! 1!

@'F6;<5F6;1+16='/1='+$=;(62;';$'6'?$5;M'-'<62'=$'F6;5(16&!9)!<)4;!<79:! *39!7=-'6.!'8=!#&!+)2*./##,$"2*/$,*4)9,4:*#%*4/2#*4%"0,$*D#+/"*/*.%,#E2F.! #*)-$!7=-'6!<-'4!,-66!<79:!97A-!9:'8!<)4=6%!eU%!+%!+'4=>.!:" I!%,$(!%*-*!)J#":/&4&GA%!R$'A*47=?-H!$'A*47=?-!N87@-4679>!_4-66.! "g`0S"gicT.!BB%!i`kic%f!

W)A-97A-6!'!()8(,367)8!76!69'9-=!'9!9:-!69'49!)5!'8!'4?3A-89!'8=!9:-8!4-B-'9-=!'9!9:-!-8=! )5!9:-!'4?3A-89%!+-4-!76!'8!-F'AB,-.!78!<:7(:!9:-!()8(,367)8!76!*),=5'(-=!'8=! 38=-4,78-=.!9)!7,,3694'9-!9:76H!

+-4-E6!<:>!:%'*2+%'4&*#/9,*:%'$*'1;$,44/%!P9E6!?)78?!9)!4'78!'8=!>)3! =)8E9!<'89!9)!?-9!<-9.!6)!:%'*2+%'4&*#/9,*:%'$*'1;$,44/%!

N63',,>.!<:-8!'!()8(,367)8!76!?7@-8!'9!9:-!69'49!)5!'8!'4?3A-89!'8=!4-B-'9-=!'9!9:-! '4?3A-89E6!-8=.!79!768E9!B:4'6-=!78!-F'(9,>!9:-!6'A-!<'>%!G)4!-F'AB,-.!<-!()3,=!4-B:4'6-! 9:-!'4?3A-89!7AA-=7'9-,>!'*)@-!'6!5),,)<6!R<79:!9:-!()8(,367)8!*),=5'(-=!'8=! 38=-4,78-=TH!

+-4-E6!<:>!:%'*2+%'4&*#/9,*:%'$*'1;$,44/%!P9E6!?)78?!9)!4'78!'8=!>)3! =)8E9!<'89!9)!?-9!<-9.!6)!:%'*;,##,$*#/9,*:%'$*'1;$,44/G!

L)3!A7?:9!9:78;!)5!9:76!'6!9:-!()8(,367)8!54'A78?!9:-!B4-A76-6%!

+-4-!76!'8)9:-4!-F'AB,-!78!<:7(:!'!()8(,367)8!76!69'9-=!'9!9:-!69'49!)5!'8!'4?3A-89!'8=! 9:-8!4-B-'9-=!'9!9:-!-8=!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89%!P8!9:76!B'66'?-.!_4-67=-89!U-)4?-!D%!]36:!<'6! 4-6B)8=78?!9)!'8!JA8-69>!P89-48'97)8',!4-B)49!',,-?78?!9:'9!:76!'=A787694'97)8!@7),'9-6! 9:-!:3A'8!47?:96!)5!=-9'78--6!78!9:-!a<'4!)8!9-44)4a!R<79:!9:-!()8(,367)8!*),=5'(-=!'8=! 38=-4,78-=TH!!

a!#E2*/"*/;2'$&*/44,0/#)%"G!C:-!N879-=!W9'9-6!76!'!()3894>!9:'9!B4)A)9-6! 54--=)A!'4)38=!9:-!<)4,=.a!:-!6'7=.!'==78?H!aD-E@-!78@-697?'9-=!-@-4>! 678?,-!()AB,'789!'?'7869!9:-!=-9'78--6%!P9!6--A-=!,7;-!9)!A-!9:->!*'6-=! 6)A-!)5!9:-74!=-(767)86!)8!9:-!<)4=!)5!!!'8=!9:-!',,-?'97)86!*>!!!B-)B,-! <:)!<-4-!:-,=!78!=-9-897)8.!B-)B,-!<:)!:'9-!JA-47('.!B-)B,-!9:'9!:'=! *--8!94'78-=!78!6)A-!7869'8(-6!9)!=76'66-A*,-!!!9:'9!A-'86!8)9!9-,,!9:-! 9439:%!J8=!6)!)#*@/2*/"*/;2'$&*$,.%$#Ga!e&'A-6!U-469-8Z'8?.!a]36:!$',,6! $4797(76A!)5!U3'89'8'A)!Q-9'78--!C4-'9A-89!J*634*a!e#*-f.!K&#":)G$4$#" C*($#.!X'>!Y".!/00c%f!!

! i!

5H=-I!-J*5HKLMJN?*?JI*OPOQ*

R?!ST*5HJN!?J*=S>*-KS-MR?!KS*!SIHK>R-JH?*

P86943(97)86H!@)"$!-,"&'"%,$"'&44&+*)G?"*2$)%*'A"%,$"/&#*%*&)"&'"%,$"-&)-46#*&)7"

W'AB,-!_4)*,-AH!

! ! 247?78',!W943(934-H!

! ! \\\'\\\%!W).!*-('36-!\\\*\\\.!\\\(\\\%!

! ! J86<-4H!(!

"%!\\\'\\\!*-('36-!\\\*\\\%!

/%!]-('36-!\\\'\\\!'8=!\\\*\\\.!\\\(\\\%!!!

Y%!\\\'\\\.!678(-!\\\*\\\!'8=!\\\(\\\%!

`%!\\\'\\\%!C:-4-5)4-.!678(-!\\\*\\\.!\\\(\\\%!!

c%!\\\'\\\%!C:-4-5)4-.!\\\*\\\.!678(-!\\\(\\\%!!!

d%!+-4-E6!<:>!\\\'\\\H!\\\*\\\.!\\\(\\\!'8=!\\\=\\\%!!

1%!\\\'\\\!'8=!\\\*\\\%!U7@-8!9:'9.!\\\(\\\%!!!

i%!U7@-8!9:'9!\\\'\\\!'8=!\\\*\\\.!\\\(\\\%!

g%!\\\'\\\%!G)4!\\\*\\\!'8=!\\\(\\\%!!!

"0%!\\\'\\\%!C:76!6:)<6!9:'9!\\\*\\\.!678(-!\\\(\\\!'8=!\\\=\\\%!

! g!

5H=-I!-J*5HKLMJN?*?JI*OPUQ*

!>JSI!<8!ST*-KS-MR?!KS?*

P86943(97)86H!;!-,"&'"%,$"'&44&+*)G"/!##!G$#"-&)%!*)#"!)"!0G6($)%7"L&0"$!-,?"+0*%$"%,$" -&)-46#*&)7"8$"#60$"%&"+0*%$"%,$"-&)-46#*&)"!#"!"-&(/4$%$"#$)%$)-$"%,!%"(!D$#"#$)#$"3A"

*%#$4'7"K*#%"!44"/0$(*#$"&0"-&)-46#*&)"*)%0&26-$0#"6#$27"M&")&%"!22"!)A"$44*/#$#7!

W'AB,-!_4)*,-A6H!!

! ! 247?78',!_'66'?-H!

X)@7-6!'4-!9:-!B-45-(9!A-=73A!5)4!A)869-46!*-('36-!)5!9:-! 9-(:8),)?>!)5!6B-(7',!-55-(96%!eQ'@7=!U%!U7,A)4-.!I&)#%$0#=";5*4" 8$*)G#?"IA%,*-!4"8$!#%#?"!)2":44"I!))$0"&'"@(!G*)!0A"C$00&0#%! R_:7,'=-,B:7'H!N87@-4679>!)5!_-886>,@'87'!_4-66.!/00YT.!B%!dg%f!

! ! J86<-4H!

$)8(,367)8H!X)@7-6!'4-!9:-!B-45-(9!A-=73A!5)4!A)869-46%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!*-('36-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

247?78',!_'66'?-H!

$:7,=4-8!*)48!9)!6,'@-!<)A-8!<-4-!6,'@-6.!4-?'4=,-66!)5!9:-! 5'9:-4E6!4'(-!)4!69'936%!C:76!A-'89.!78!6:)49.!9:'9!<:-8-@-4!'!<:79-! A'8!7AB4-?8'9-=!)8-!)5!:76!6,'@-6.!9:-!(:7,=!B4)=3(-=!*>!:76! '66'3,9!<'6!:76!B4)B-49>%!eQ)4)9:>!b)*-496.!N*44*)G"%,$"84!-D" 8&2A="O!-$?"O$/0&26-%*&)?"!)2"%,$"I$!)*)G"&'"K*3$0%A%!RK-<! L)4;H!l789'?-!]));6.!"gg1T.!B%!/g%f!

! ! ! J86<-4H!

$)8(,367)8H!D:-8-@-4!'!<:79-!A'8!7AB4-?8'9-=!)8-!)5!:76!6,'@-6.! 9:-!(:7,=!B4)=3(-=!*>!:76!'66'3,9!<'6!:76!B4)B-49>%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!9:76!A-'89!

"%!X)69!)5!9:-!-'4,>!94'8679!36-46!('A-!54)A!9:-!A7==,-!'8=!3BB-4!(,'66-6!*-('36-!)8,>! 9:->!:'=!9:-!97A-!'8=!A)8->!9)!()AA39-!*-9<--8!9:-!63*34*6!'8=!9:-!(-894',!*3678-66! =76947(9%!eW()99!I%!])99,-6.!K&#":)G$4$#"!)2"%,$":6%&(&3*4$="C,$"I!D*)G"&'"%,$"I&2$0)" >*%A%!R]-4;-,->H!N87@-4679>!)5!$',75)487'!_4-66.!"gi1T.!B%!"0%f!!!

! "0!

/%!]-('36-!9:->!'4-!'!B4)9-(9-=!6B-(7-6.!79!76!7,,-?',!9)!;7,,!'8!',,7?'9)4!38,-66!>)3!:'@-!'! 6B-(7',!B-4A79%!eaj7,,78?!C:4-'9-878?!U'9)4!P6!G-,)8>!N8,-66!I7(-86-=!C4'BB-4.a! DGCl!R24'8?-!$)389>.!G,)47='T.!X'>!"c.!/00d%f!

Y%!S%#,Q!C,$"#/$!D$0"*#"!"'*-%*&)!4"-,!0!-%$0"-!44$2"B!4(&)"8&A7!

L'+$F5'#($F'6'26&F$=';(1:5'-'6=)';<5(5#$(5'L'6F'6')5?58='*,-!A'8%!eW:-4A'8!J,-F7-.! aW)39:!*>!W)39:<-69.a!78!C,$"C&6G,$#%"@)2*!)"*)"%,$"E&042%!RK-<!L)4;H!J9,'897(! X)89:,>!_4-66.!/000T.!B%!cg%f!

`%!28!9:-!694--96!)5!K'?'6';7.!@7679)46!54)A!^'69!'8=!D-69!:'@-!A78?,-=!5)4!A'8>! (-89347-6!<79:!9:-!&'B'8-6-%!C:36.!9:5'1=<6:1;6=;2'$#'A6>626,1'-'<6N5'6:2$(:5)'F6=7' 785,3-8(-6!54)A!5)4-7?8!(3,934-6%!eI-6,->!Q)<8-4!'8=!X78)43!L)8-='.!B%$/"3A"B%$/" P!/!)$#$">&&D*)G%!RD))=*34>.!K-<!L)4;H!]'44)8E6.!"gidT.!B%!i0%f!!!

c%!S%#,Q!B634*!)"*#"H,*4*//*)$"'&4D"2!)-$"*)2*G$)&6#"%&"8!%!)G!#"H0&5*)-$7!

C:-!9-4A!a63*,7a!76!e=-47@-=f!54)A!9<)!C'?',)?!<)4=6.!a63*63*a!A-'878?!5',,78?!)8! <56)'6=)'D:6&18D'%<1+<'F56=2':($,5=.'95=+58'-/3*:&16=M')6=+5(2'6??56(';$':5'&6F5'

'8=!(4));-=!9:4)3?:)39!9:-!='8(-%!e&'6-4!J%!X'4'67?'8.!aW3*,7'8!G-697@',!]'9'?3-m)! _47=-.a!I!)*4!"8644$%*).!W-B9-A*-4!".!/00d%f!

d%!C:)6-!n3@-87,-6!6-89!9)!'=3,9!B476)86!'4-!'9!'!?4)66!=76'=@'89'?-.!'6!A78)46!'4-!8)9! -A)97)8',,>!)4!B:>67(',,>!'*,-!9)!:'8=,-!9:-!694-66!)5!*-78?!78('4(-4'9-=!<79:!'=3,96%! e&-6!]):8.!aC4>78?!X78)46!78!$)349!'6!J=3,96!N85'74.!P8()86769-89.a!M!*4A"B6)2*!4! R$',75)487'!W9'9-!N87@-4679>.!K)49:47=?-T.!JB47,!/".!/00c%f!!!

1%!D:-4-@-4!9:-4-E6!A)8->.!9:-4-E6!=43?6.!6)!9)!6'>!=43?6!=)8E9!-F769!78!9:-!K]J!eK'97)8',! ]'6;-9*',,!J66)(7'97)8f!<)3,=!*-!693B7=%!eQ-8876!b)=A'8!<79:!C7A!j-)<8.!8!2":#"@" E!))!"8$%!RK-<!L)4;H!Q-,'()49-!_4-66.!"ggdT.!B%!/""%f!

i%!P8!#6#,*!*'4!B'4,'8(-!+!#!3*!76!;8)<8!'6!)!(*2!.!a9-'46.a!5)4!79!*478?6!9-'46!9)!9:-!->-6%! eI-6,->!Q)<8-4!'8=!X78)43!L)8-='.!B%$/"3A"B%$/"P!/!)$#$">&&D*)G%!RD))=*34>.! K-<!L)4;H!]'44)8E6.!"gidT.!B%!/Y%f!!!

g%!]3>78?!'!A'994-66!76!@-4>!A3(:!'8!78=7@7=3',!(:)7(-%!J59-4!',,.!79E6!9:-!A)69!B-46)8',! 79-A!)5!53487934-!78!>)34!:)A-%!ePj^J.!>!%!4&G6$!R/001T.!B%!c"%f!

"0%!eG)4=E6f!6',-6!'4-!=)<8!g%1!B-4(-89!5)4!9:-!>-'4%!$)86-O3-89,>.!G)4=!B,'86!9)!4-=3(-! B4)=3(97)8!78!9:-!5)349:!O3'49-4%!eC-44>!])F.!aG)4=E6!h-4)!_-4(-89!G78'8(78?!]478?6! 78!]3>-4!C4'557(.a!M!44!#"I&0)*)G"Q$+#.!W-B9-A*-4!".!/00d%f!

! ""!

""%!C:-!"gg0!$-8636!4-B)49-=!9:'9!)8,>!67F!:38=4-=!-7?:9>k57@-!B-)B,-!)5!&'B'8-6-! '8(-694>!&1N5)'1='-'/01;;&5'O$,7$M'H6&$=>'%1;<'51><;7'P$(56=2'6=)';%5=;7k-7?:9! $:78-6-T%!P9!5),,)<6!9:'9!9:-!6)(7',!'8=!-()8)A7(!@7'*7,79>!)5!I799,-!C);>)!4-696! ,'4?-,>!)8!&'B'8-6-kJA-47('86!<:)!,7@-!78!9:-!63*34*6!*39!<:)!4-9348!)(('67)8',,>!9)! *3>!&'B'8-6-!?))=6!'8=!-8n)>!'!5'@)479-!4-69'34'89!'8=!',6)!)8!9)347696!54)A!&'B'8! <:)!B4-5-4!5'A7,7'4!:)9-,!'(()AA)='97)86!9)!A)4-!<-69-487Z-=!)8-6%!eb)*-49!Q%! +-4A'8.!M&+)%&+)"K&#":)G$4$#=":"E!4D*)G"96*2$.!4-@%!-=%!R]',=<78!_'4;.! $',75)487'H!U-A!U37=-6!]));!$)AB'8>.!/000T.!B%!"1g%f!!!

"/%!S%#,Q!H$%0*R($!%"*#"($!%"G0&+)"'0&("-$44#"*)"!"4!3&0!%&0A"H$%0*"2*#,7!

-/CM$*'+6=Q;':5'+(*5&';$'6=7;<1=>'1=6=1F6;58'1.5.'%1;<$*;'6'+5=;(6&'=5(N$*2'272;5F.'

_-947kA-'9!<7,,!:'@-!8)!63(:!6>69-A%!C:-4-5)4-!_-947kA-'9!<7,,!*-!(43-,9>!54--%!e+3?:! G-'48,->kD:79978?69',,.!aW('4>M!C:-!G3934-!P6!_-9475>78?.a!S3#$05$0!RN879-=! j78?=)AT.!W-B9-A*-4!"".!/00c%f!

"Y%!Q7@-4?-89!9:78;78?!76!'8!-66-897',!78?4-=7-89!)5!(4-'97@79>%!Q7@-4?-89!?4)3B6!B4)=3(-! =7@-46-!9:78;78?%!^4?).!=7@-4679>!B4)A)9-6!(4-'97@79>%!eU%!_'6(',!h'(:'4>.!C,$" M*5$0#*%A":25!)%!G$.!O3)9-=!78!J4-6:!W:74',7.!a_)69!G,7?:9!b-'=78?.a!L*)!)-*!4" ;T/0$##!RP8=7'T.!X'4(:!Y".!/001%f!!!

"`%!D:-8-@-4!PEA!78!94)3*,-.!P!B4'>%!J8=!678(-!PEA!',<'>6!78!94)3*,-.!9:-4-!76!8)9!'!='>! <:-8!P!=)8E9!B4'>%!eP6''(!]'6:-@76!W78?-4.!O3)9-=!78!P64'-,!W:-8;-4.!aP6''(!W78?-4E6! _-46B-(97@-!)8!U)=!'8=!X'8.a!Q$+"<&0D"C*($#.!2(9)*-4!/Y.!"gdi%f!

"c%!Plot-!"#$%&'&(""()#$%*'+',-".'/%*)'0-"'(1!#-'/--.*2'3-&0#4)#-&'!-%*&5)'(6,(7*',-".' well [for audio books] because the narrative often is not the strong point. ["Choose the Right Audio Books for Your Child," Toledo Blade (Ohio), November 13, 2005.] !!

! "/!

=$0'1,"#2*5$,2,"#,&*6)#+%'#*5$,1)2,*%$*-%"(4'2)%"*!"#$%&'(,$2*

D:-8!'8!'4?3A-89!76!B4-6-89-=!<79:)39!'8>!B4-A76-!)4!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-46.!'!?))=! <'>!9)!57?34-!)39!<:7(:!)5!796!69'9-A-896!'4-!B4-A76-6!'8=!<:7(:!76!9:-!()8(,367)8!76!9)! 94>!'==78?!()AA)8!B4-A76-!)4!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-46%!L)3!A7?:9!36-!R9:-!B4-A76-! 7894)=3(-4T!E*-('36-E!)4!R9:-!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4T!E9:-4-5)4-E!9)!=)!9:76%!

G)4!-F'AB,-.!7A'?78-!9:'9!'!693=-89!6'>6!9)!:-4!9-'(:-4H!

P!()3,=8E9!*-!B4-6-89!5)4!9:-!O37Z%!P!:'=!694-B!9:4)'9%!

C:-!9-'(:-4!('8!-'67,>!38=-469'8=!9:-!693=-89!'6!?7@78?!'!4-'6)8!9)!*-,7-@-!9:'9!6:-! ()3,=8E9!*-!B4-6-89!5)4!9:-!O37Z!!!8)9!n369!9:'9!6:-!+!#)J%!*39!9:'9!6:-!-&642)J%"3$%!P8=--=.! 9:-!9-'(:-4!()3,=!'==!9:-!<)4=!E*-('36-E!*-9<--8!9:-!693=-89E6!69'9-A-89!9:'9!6:-!()3,=8E9! *-!B4-6-89!5)4!9:-!O37Z!'8=!:-4!69'9-A-89!9:'9!6:-!:'=!694-B!9:4)'9%!D-!()3,=!4-<479-!9:-! 693=-89E6!'4?3A-89.!'==78?!E*-('36-E.!'6!5),,)<6H!

P!()3,=8E9!*-!B4-6-89!5)4!9:-!O37Z.!3$-!6#$!P!:'=!694-B!9:4)'9%!

P!63BB)6-!9:-!9-'(:-4!()3,=!789-4B4-9!9:-!693=-89!'6!4-'6)878?!78!9:-!)BB)679-!=74-(97)8.!6)! 9)!6B-';%!C:'9!76.!P!63BB)6-!9:-!9-'(:-4!()3,=!38=-469'8=!9:-!693=-89!'6!6'>78?!9:'9! *-('36-!6:-!()3,=8E9!*-!B4-6-89!5)4!9:-!O37Z.!6:-!:'=!694-B!9:4)'9%!]39!75!9:-!9-'(:-4!<-4-! 9)!789-4B4-9!9:-!693=-89!9:76!<'>.!9:-!9-'(:-4!<)3,=!:'@-!9)!38=-469'8=!9:-!693=-89!'6! ?7@78?!'!@-4>!*'=!'4?3A-89%!2==6!'4-.!:)<-@-4.!9:'9!9:-!693=-89!76!8)9!?7@78?!'!*'=! '4?3A-89!!!)4.!'9!,-'69.!8)9!'8!'4?3A-89!9:76!*'=V!RP9E6!'!6-B'4'9-!7663-!<:-9:-4!9:-! 693=-89E6!69'9-A-89!9:'9!6:-!:'=!694-B!9:4)'9!76!943-!)4!5',6-%T!C:76!<)3,=!8)9!*-!'!?))=! <'>!5)4!9:-!9-'(:-4!9)!789-4B4-9!9:-!693=-89E6!4-'6)878?.!*-('36-!79!@7),'9-6!9:-"/0*)-*/4$"&'" -,!0*%A.!<:7(:!9-,,6!36!9)!789-4B4-9!B-)B,-E6!<)4=6!78!<'>6!9:'9!(4-=79!9:-A!<79:!A';78?! A)4-.!8)9!,-66.!6-86-%!L)3!('8!9:78;!)5!9:76!'6!67A7,'4!9)!?7@78?!B-)B,-!9:-!*-8-579!)5!9:-! =)3*9%!C:-!B478(7B,-!)5!(:'479>!768E9!A-4-,>!'!A'99-4!)5!*-78?!87(-[!79E6!A'99-4!)5! 789-4B4-978?!B-)B,-!()44-(9,>.!*-('36-!B-)B,-!'4-!A)4-!,7;-,>!9)!4-'6)8!<-,,!9:'8!*'=,>.!'9! ,-'69!<:-8!9:-74!4-'6)878?!76!5'74,>!67AB,-%!J!4-6947(97)8!)8!9:-!B478(7B,-!)5!(:'479>!76!9:'9! <-!6:)3,=!8)9!789-4B4-9!B-)B,-!'6!A';78?!A)4-!6-86-!9:'8!76!()86769-89!<79:!<:'9!9:->E@-! '(93',,>!6'7=%!

! "Y!

+-4-E6!'8)9:-4!-F'AB,-H!

L)3!=-57879-,>!<'89!9)!'@)7=!9:-!+),,><))=!G4--<'>!6)39:*)38=!9:4)3?:! 9:-!$':3-8?'!_'66H!3B!9)!`0kA7839-!=-,'>6!,-'@78?!9:-!eW'8!G-48'8=)f! l',,->%!eC4'557(!b-B)49.!jGD]!RI)6!J8?-,-6T.!K)@-A*-4!"/.!/00`%f!!

$)86769-89!<79:!9:-!B478(7B,-!)5!(:'479>.!<-!()3,=!'==!9:-!<)4=!E*-('36-E!*-5)4-!9:-! 69'9-A-89!9:'9!9:-4-!'4-!3B!9)!`0kA7839-!=-,'>6!,-'@78?!9:-!W'8!G-48'8=)!l',,->%!W)!9:76! 76!9:-!94'557(!4-B)49-4E6!B4-A76-%!C:-!6943(934-!)5!9:-!94'557(!4-B)49-4E6!'4?3A-89!76!

\\\\\\!3$-!6#$!\\\\\\!

W)!9:-!94'557(!4-B)49-4E6!()8(,367)8!76!9:'9!69'9-A-89!47?:9!*-5)4-!E*-('36-EH!

L)3!=-57879-,>!<'89!9)!'@)7=!9:-!+),,><))=!G4--<'>!6)39:*)38=!9:4)3?:! 9:-!$':3-8?'!_'66%!

$)867=-4!',6)!9:-!5),,)<78?!'4?3A-89H!

C)!;7,,!'8=!A'7A!B-)B,-!76!7AA)4',%!D'4!;7,,6!'8=!A'7A6!B-)B,-%!D'4!76! 7AA)4',%!eI7836!_'3,78?.!"gg".!O3)9-=!78!Q'@7=!j47-?-4.!aC:-!J*),797)8! )5!K3(,-'4!D-'B)86!'8=!D'4H!C:-!b-6B)867*7,79>!)5!W(7-897696.a! H$!-$P&60)!4*#(7-&(!"c!R&'83'4>!/00dT%f!

+-4-.!<-!()3,=!'==!9:-!<)4=!E9:-4-5)4-E!47?:9!*-5)4-!_'3,78?E6!,'69!69'9-A-89%!W).!:76! ()8(,367)8!76H!

D'4!76!7AA)4',%!

J8)9:-4!<'>!9)!'BB4)'(:!'4?3A-896!,7;-!9:-6-.!78!<:7(:!8)!B4-A76-!)4!()8(,367)8! 7894)=3(-46!'4-!36-=.!76!67AB,>!9)!'6;!<:7(:!69'9-A-89!)4!69'9-A-896!9:-!'4?3-4!:'6!947-=! 9)!63BB)49%!D-!8)97(-!9:'9!9:-!94'557(!4-B)49-4!:'6!947-=!9)!?7@-!'!4-'6)8!9)!*-,7-@-!9:'9!>)3! =-57879-,>!<'89!9)!'@)7=!9:-!+),,><))=!G4--<'>!6)39:*)38=!9:4)3?:!9:-!$':3-8?'!_'66.! <:7(:!9-,,6!36!9:'9!79!76!:-4!()8(,367)8%!]39!6:-!:'6!8)9!947-=!9)!63BB)49!9:-!69'9-A-89!9:'9! 9:-4-!'4-!3B!9)!`0kA7839-!=-,'>6!,-'@78?!9:-!W'8!G-48'8=)!l',,->.!6)!9:'9!69'9-A-89! ('88)9!*-!:-4!()8(,367)8%!W7A7,'4!4-'6)878?!'BB,7-6!9)!_'3,78?E6!'4?3A-89H!:-!:'6!8)9! 947-=!9)!63BB)49!-79:-4!)5!:76!57469!9<)!69'9-A-896.!*39!:-!:'6!947-=!9)!63BB)49!:76!,'69! 69'9-A-89.!6)!:76!,'69!69'9-A-89!76!:76!()8(,367)8%!

! "`!

5H=-I!-J*5HKLMJN?*?JI*OPVQ*

!>JSI!<8!ST*-KS-MR?!KS?*!S*=HTRNJSI?*5HJ?JSIJ>*

6!IAKRI*5HJN!?J*KH*-KS-MR?!KS*!SIHK>R-JH?*

P86943(97)86H!;!-,"&'"%,$"'&44&+*)G"/!##!G$#"-&)%!*)#"!)"!0G6($)%7"Q&"-&)-46#*&)"&0" /0$(*#$"*)%0&26-$0#"!0$"6#$27"L&0"$!-,?"+0*%$"%,$"-&)-46#*&)7"8$"#60$"%&"+0*%$"%,$"

-&)-46#*&)"!#"!"-&(/4$%$"#$)%$)-$"%,!%"(!D$#"#$)#$"3A"*%#$4'7"M&")&%"!22"!)A"$44*/#$#7!

W'AB,-!_4)*,-AH!!

247?78',!_'66'?-H!

P9E6!:'4=!9)!9-,,!<:'9!'!('9E6!9:78;78?!!!9:->!36-!9:-!6'A-!-FB4-667)8! <:-9:-4!9:->!:'@-!6--8!'!A)36-!)4!'8!'F-kA34=-4-4%!eJ39:)4!38;8)<8.! O3)9-=!78!&%!b)6-!]'4*-4.!-=%.!C,$0$":0$"Q&"S02*)!0A">!%#%!RK%B%H!b'(:'-,! +',-!_:)9)?4'B:>!I9=%.!/00`T.!8%B%f!

! ! J86<-4H!

$)8(,367)8H!P9E6!:'4=!9)!9-,,!<:'9!'!('9E6!9:78;78?%!

"%!P9E6!:'4=!8)9!9)!-8@>!'!('9!!!9:->!;8)<!n369!:)<!9)!4-,'F!<79:)39!:'@78?!'!('4-!78!9:-! <)4,=%!e+-84>!]'9-6.!O3)9-=!78!&%!b)6-!]'4*-4.!-=%.!C,$0$":0$"Q&"S02*)!0A">!%#%! RK%B%H!b'(:'-,!+',-!_:)9)?4'B:>!I9=%.!/00`T.!8%B%f!!!

/%!X>!<75-!76!:'BB>!PEA!8)9!B-45-(9!!!6:-!,7;-6!9)!8'?%!e+-88>!L)38?A'8.!C,$" ;)-A-4&/$2*!"&'"S)$"K*)$0#.!-=%!^=!W:'8'B:>%!Rj'9)8':.!K%L%H!]',,>A)9-!]));6.! "gigT.!B%!"Yi%f!

Y%!]'A*))!76!'!634@7@)4H!79!*-8=6!*39!=)-6!8)9!*4-';%!eU',-!]-9:!U),=*-4?.!8!(3&&" B%A4$%!RW',9!I';-!$79>H!U7**6!WA79:.!/00/T.!B%!/"%f!!!

`%!_-)B,-!54)A!9:-!X7==,-!^'69!:'@-!'!8'934',!=7694369!)5!B),7(-%!C:->!6--!B),7(-!'6!'8! '4A!)5!9:-!69'9-%!eJ8':-7A.!$',75)487'.!B),7(-!)557(-4!2A'4!J=:'A.!O3)9-=!78!Q'@-! X(j7**-8.!aI799,-!J4'*7'E6!EX'>)4E!^'6-6!C-867)86.a!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!X'>!"c.! /001%f!

c%!-/36&;'06,5'I1;7M'-'12'&1,5'6'R5%5&8'%1;<'1;2'?*(1;7'$#'61('6=)'1;2'?&*=>1=>'*(:6='N12;62' A)4-!*4-'9:9';78?!-@-8!9:'8!9:)6-!)5!I)6!J8?-,-6%!e&-'8!]'3=47,,'4=.!:($0*-!.! 94'86,'9-=!*>!$:476!C348-4%!RI)8=)8H!l-46).!"giiT.!B%!/%f!!!

S.'E56=*;2'6(5'=$;'=*;2'6;'6&&':*;'6'F5F:5('$#';<5':56='#6F1&7-.'/41&&'A56&8'8*44"Q$!4J#"

B&6%,$0)">&&D*)G%!R$:'B-,!+7,,.!K)49:!$'4),78'H!C:-!N87@-4679>!)5!K)49:!$'4),78'! _4-66.!"gicT.!B%!"10%f!

! "c!

1%!K)<!9:'9!?-8=-4!=76978(97)86!:'@-!',,!*39!@'876:-=!54)A!9:-!,-?',!-&)%$)%!)5!A'447'?-.! 9:-4-!76!8)!*'676!5)4!9:-!4-O374-A-89!9:'9!9:-!,-?',!'&0(!)5!A'447'?-!3879-!A-A*-46!)5! =755-4-89!6-F-6%!eb7(:'4=!Q%!X):4.!:"I&0$"H$0'$-%"U)*&)="E,A"B%0!*G,%":($0*-!"I6#%" B%!)2"U/"'&0"9!A"O*G,%#%!R])69)8H!]-'()8!_4-66.!"gg`T.!BB%!YdkY1%f!!!

i%!J9!,-'69!*>!%%%!"iYd.!<:-8!I)6!J8?-,-6!<'6!'!6)(7',!'8=!94'=78?!(-89-4!5)4!9:-! -8(74(,78?!4'8(:)6!'8=!'!5'@)479-!6B)9!5)4!0!)-,$0&#!'8=!',,!9:-74!4-9'78-46.!B4)6979397)8! <'6!=-57879-,>!4-()?87Z-=!'6!'!B4)5-667)8%!$)863,9!9:-!(-8636!)5!"iYd%!239!)5!9<)! :38=4-=!'8=!5759>!8)8kP8=7'8!<)A-8!,7@78?!<79:78!9)<8!,7A796.!9:'9!(-8636!?'@-! 5759--8!)5!9:-A!9:-!(,'66757('97)8!)5!aX%l%.a!67?875>78?!aX','!l7='.a!'!4-5-4-8(-!9)!9:-! ),=-69!B4)5-667)8%!eD%!D%!b)*786)8?"C!0)*#,$2":)G$4#="H!0!2*#*!-!4"C60/*%62$"*)"K&#" :)G$4$#"O$5$!4$2%!RI)6!J8?-,-6H!C:-!D'4=!b79(:7-!_4-66.!"gd`T.!B%!1%f!

g%!L;Q2'*;;5('&*=6+7';$'<6N5'-'/;<5'I6;<$&1+'I<*(+<M8'1=5T;(1+6:&7'F1(5)'1='$=5'$#';<5'F$2;' '*>6A',!'8=!6>69-A7(!:769)47-6!)5!(:7,=!'*36-.!()@-4-=!3B!5)4!>-'46.!8)<!94>78?!9)! =7(9'9-!<:)!6:)3,=!'8=!6:)3,=8E9!*-!',,)<-=!9)!A'44>%!eb)8!+'4=('69,-.!I-99-4!9)!9:-! ^=79)4.!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!X'>!/1.!/00c%f!!!

"0%!J*),797)8!)5!B4)6979397)8!,'<6!',,)<6!5)4!,-66!='8?-4!9)!B4)697939-6%!D)A-8!()3,=! n)78S5)4A!387)86.!-8?'?-!78!(),,-(97@-!*'4?'7878?!'8=!7AB4)@-!<)4;78?!()8=797)86%! e$'4),!&'()*6-8.!aG'(9!W:--9!)8!_4)6979397)8.a!78!j349!+),,'8=-4.!-=%.!K*5$"B$T":-%#" @)#*2$%!RK-<!L)4;H!C:-!_)49'*,-!I)<-4!^'69!W7=-.!"gg"T.!B%!`/%f!!!

! "d!

H+,#%$)(/4*W',2#)%"2*/"&*!1.,$/#)3,2*R2,&*#%*JX.$,22*?#/#,1,"#2*

U4'AA'97(',,>!6B-';78?.!O3-697)86!'4-!8)9!69'9-A-896.!*39!6)A-97A-6!0,$%&0*-!4! V6$#%*&)#!'4-!36-=!9)!-FB4-66!69'9-A-896%!b:-9)47(',!O3-697)86!'4-!)59-8!=-578-=!'6! O3-697)86!'6;-=!5)4!'!B34B)6-!)9:-4!9:'8!9)!?-9!9:-!785)4A'97)8!9:-!O3-697)8!'BB-'46!9)! 4-O3-69%!G)4!-F'AB,-.!7A'?78-!9:'9!47?:9!'59-4!>)34!547-8=!?)9!'8!J!78!)4?'87(!(:-A7694>! >)3!'6;!:-4!

+)<!()A-!>)3E4-!6)!6A'49M!

L)34!O3-697)8!<)3,=!B4)*'*,>!*-!789-8=-=!9)!-FB4-66!9:-!69'9-A-89!

L)3E4-!@-4>!6A'49V!

4'9:-4!9:'8!'6!'!?-8378-!4-O3-69!5)4!>)34!547-8=!9)!?7@-!>)3!785)4A'97)8!'*)39!:)<!6:-! *-('A-!6)!6A'49%!

+-4-E6!'8)9:-4!-F'AB,-!)5!'!4:-9)47(',!O3-697)8!R<:7(:!76!*),=5'(-=!'8=!38=-4,78-=!78!9:-! B'66'?-T%!J59-4!9:-!"gig!I)A'!_47-9'!-'49:O3';-.!9:-!$',75)487'!W-76A7(!W'5-9>! $)AA7667)8!<'89-=!9:-!N87@-4679>!)5!$',75)487'!'9!]-4;-,->!9)!B)69!<'4878?!67?86!)8!796! *37,=78?6.!6)A-!)5!<:7(:!'4-!78!'!5'3,9!Z)8-.!*39!9:-!N87@-4679>!'=A787694'97)8!<'6! )BB)6-=!9)!=)78?!6)%!N678?!9:-!A'78!,7*4'4>!'6!'8!-F'AB,-.!N$!]-4;-,->E6!B4-67=-89.! Q'@7=!U'4=78-4.!A'=-!9:-!5),,)<78?!()AA-89H!

_39!'!*7?!67?8!)8!9:-!Q)-!I7*4'4>!'9!]-4;-,->H!aC:76!*37,=78?!76! 6-76A7(',,>!386'5-%!^89-4!'9!>)34!)<8!B-47,%a!2;'>%!W).!>)3E4-!'!54-6:A'8! 693=-89!()A78?!3B!9)!9:-!,7*4'4>%!6+/#*/$,*:%'*2'..%2,&*#%*&%*/;%'#*)#7* W)A-!693=-896!6'>.!a2:.!9:'9E6!578-.a!'8=!9:->!<',;!47?:9!78%!29:-4!693=-896! 6'>.!aD-,,.!PEA!8)9!?)78?!78!9:-4-%a!

W)!9:'9E6!<:'9!('A-!3B!78!A>!A78=!<:-8!P!:-'4=!9:76!63??-697)8%!C:'9! 6--A6!9)!A-!8)9!9)!*-!@-4>!:-,B53,.!5)4!<:'9!6:)3,=!*-!6-,5k-@7=-89! 4-'6)86%!6+/#*)2*#+,*2#'&,"#*2'..%2,&*#%*&%*/;%'#*)#7!e_:7,7B!I%! G4'=;78.!I!G)*%62$"W=";!0%,V6!D$#"!)2"K*'$"!4&)G"%,$"B!)":)20$!#"L!64%%! R]-4;-,->H!N87@-4679>!)5!$',75)487'!_4-66.!"ggiT.!B%!i1%f!

_4-67=-89!U'4=78-4.!B4-63A'*,>.!=7=!8)9!A-'8!:76!R4-B-'9-=T!O3-697)8!'6!'!?-8378-! 4-O3-69!5)4!'8!'86<-4[!7869-'=.!:-!36-=!79!9)!-FB4-66!9:-!5),,)<78?!69'9-A-89H!

C:-4-E6!8)9:78?!693=-896!('8!=)!'*)39!6-76A7(!6'5-9>!<'4878?!67?86!)8! 387@-4679>!*37,=78?6.!63(:!'6!9:-!Q)-!I7*4'4>%!

! "1!

W)A-97A-6!*(/$0!%*5$#!'4-!36-=!9)!-FB4-66!69'9-A-896%!$)867=-4!9:-!5),,)<78?! :)4)6()B-H!

M,%!R&3,>!/Y!9)!J3?%!//T!I-9!B-99>!A)8->!=76'?4--A-896!<79:!>)34! 4))AA'9-!6,7=-.!'6!>)3E,,!8--=!:-4!9)!@'('9-!)8!9:-!//8=!<:-8!'8!),=! 5,'A-!69)B6!*>%!ea+)4)6()B-.a!P!)$!iHg!RK)@-A*-4!/00`T.!B%!"`/%f!

+-4-!9:-!7AB-4'97@-!36-=!'9!9:-!*-?78878?!

I-9!B-99>!A)8->!=76'?4--A-896!<79:!>)34!4))AA'9-!6,7=-!

:'6!9:-!6943(934-!)5!'!()AA'8=%!]39!79!('8!-'67,>!*-!38=-469))=!'6!-FB4-6678?!9:-! 69'9-A-89!

L)3!6:)3,=!,-9!B-99>!A)8->!=76'?4--A-896!<79:!>)34!4))AA'9-!6,7=-!

C:76!69'9-A-89!76!9:-!()8(,367)8!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:76!:)4)6()B-[!9:-!B4-A76-.! 7894)=3(-=!*>!E'6E.!76!9:'9!>)3E,,!8--=!>)34!4))AA'9-!9)!@'('9-!)8!9:-!//8=!<:-8!'8!),=! 5,'A-!69)B6!*>%!

I-9E6!()867=-4!'8)9:-4!-F'AB,-H!

D-7?:!>)346-,5!'9!9:-!6'A-!97A-!-'(:!<--;.!*-('36-!>)34!<-7?:9! 5,3(93'9-6!9:4)3?:)39!9:-!='>.!'8=!>)3!('8!<-7?:!A)4-!'9!87?:9!9:'8!>)3! =)!78!9:-!A)4878?%!eQ4%!_:7,!X(U4'<.!C,$"U4%*(!%$"E$*G,%"B&46%*&)"L&&2" 96*2$%!RK-<!L)4;H!_)(;-9!]));6.!/00`T.!B%!""%f!

+-4-!Q4%!_:7,!36-6!E*-('36-E!9)!7894)=3(-!:76!B4-A76-6%!+-!36-6!9:-!5),,)<78?!6943(934-!9)! -FB4-66!:76!'4?3A-89H!

\\\\\\.!3$-!6#$!\\\\\\!'8=!\\\\\\%!

W)!:76!()8(,367)8!76!9:-!7AB-4'97@-!*-5)4-!E*-('36-E.!<:7(:!<-!('8!4-B:4'6-!'6!'! 69'9-A-89!'6!5),,)<6H!

L)3!6:)3,=!<-7?:!>)346-,5!'9!9:-!6'A-!97A-!-'(:!<--;!

)4!

28-!6:)3,=!<-7?:!)8-6-,5!'9!9:-!6'A-!97A-!-'(:!<--;%!

! "i!

5H=-I!-J*5HKLMJN?*?JI*OPYQ*

!>JSI!<8!ST*-KS-MR?!KS?*

P86943(97)86H!;!-,"&'"%,$"'&44&+*)G"/!##!G$#"-&)%!*)#"!)"!0G6($)%7"L&0"$!-,?"+0*%$"%,$" -&)-46#*&)7"8$"#60$"%&"+0*%$"%,$"-&)-46#*&)"!#"!"-&(/4$%$"#$)%$)-$"%,!%"*#"/,0!#$2"!#"!"

#%!%$($)%"!)2"(!D$#"#$)#$"3A"*%#$4'7"K*#%"!44"-&)-46#*&)"&0"/0$(*#$"*)%0&26-$0#"6#$27"M&"

)&%"!22"!)A"$44*/#$#7!

W'AB,-!_4)*,-A6H!!

! 247?78',!_'66'?-H!

-/4M5'+6(5#*&'$#'%<6;'7$*! =)!E('36-!9:-!,7-!*-()A-6! 9:-!9439:%! eX7(:'-,!&'(;6)8.!a]7,,7-!&-'8.a!)8!X7(:'-,!&'(;6)8.!C,0*44$0%!RI)6! J8?-,-6H!$]W.!"gi/[!o^Yi""/%f!

J86<-4H!

$)8(,367)8H!L)3!6:)3,=!*-!('4-53,!)5!<:'9!>)3!=)%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!E('36-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

! 247?78',!_'66'?-H!

J59-4!4-(-7@78?!>)34!B'(;'?-!)5!,'=>*3?6.!,-'@-!9:-!*'?!6-',-=!'8=!B,'(-! 79!78!'!4-547?-4'9)4.!)4!)9:-4!()),!B,'(-%!C:76!(',A6!9:-!,'=>*3?6!=)<8!54)A! 9:-74!6:7BB78?!-FB-47-8(-%!eaI'=>*3?6!G)4-@-4.!R:7BB)='A7'! ()8@-4?-86T.a!G,7-4.!8%=%.!('%!/00c%f!

! ! J86<-4H!

$)8(,367)8H!J59-4!4-(-7@78?!>)34!B'(;'?-!)5!,'=>*3?6.!>)3!6:)3,=!,-'@-! 9:-!*'?!6-',-=!'8=!B,'(-!79!78!'!4-547?-4'9)4.!)4!)9:-4!()),!B,'(-%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

"%!U&1N52'-'6(5'<1><'1='+6&$(1528'2$'*25';<5F'1='F$)5(6;1$=.'/DU*('E$%5('V$$)28D'B6)#$%! RG-*43'4>!/00dT.!B%!i`%f!!!

/%!J,<'>6!*)44)<!54)A!'!B-667A769!!!:-!8-@-4!-FB-(96!79!*'(;%!e+-88>!L)38?A'8.!C,$" ;)-A-4&/$2*!"&'"S)$"K*)$0#.!-=%!^=!W:'8'B:>%!Rj'9)8':.!K%L%H!]',,>A)9-!]));6.! "gigT.!B%!1/%f!

! "g!

Y%!X';-!634-!6,)3(:>!B7-(-6!e)5!(,)9:78?f!579!9:4)3?:!9:-!6:)3,=-4!'8=!'9!9:-!<'769!!! )9:-4<76-.!9:->!('8!4-'=!6,)BB>%!e^@'!G,)=694)A.!O3)9-=!78!aD:'9!PE,,!]-!D-'478?.a! K6-DA!RX'4(:!/001T.!B%!/ic%f!!!

`%!]-!;78=!9)!>)34!547-8=6%!D79:)39!9:-A!>)3E=!*-!'!9)9',!694'8?-4%!e+-88>!L)38?A'8.! C,$";)-A-4&/$2*!"&'"S)$"K*)$0#.!-=%!^=!W:'8'B:>%!Rj'9)8':.!K%L%H!]',,>A)9-!]));6.! "gigT.!B%!""g%f!

c%!G3ZZ>!D3ZZ>!<'6!'!*-'4! G3ZZ>!D3ZZ>!:'=!8)!:'74! G3ZZ>!D3ZZ>!<'68E9!53ZZ>.!<3ZZ>M! eC4'=797)8',!(:7,=4-8E6!4:>A-f!!!

d%!S%#,Q!M$!)"B(*%,"+!#"!"4&)GR%*($?"5$0A"#6--$##'64"($)J#"3!#D$%3!44"-&!-,"!%"C,$" U)*5$0#*%A"&'"Q&0%,">!0&4*)!"!%">,!/$4"F*447!

P6!79!-'67-4!9)!9-'(:!'8=!,-'48!'59-4!'!,)66M!L-6.!*-('36-!,)678?!76!63(:!'!A)97@'978?! 5)4(-%!eQ-'8!WA79:.!78!Q-'8!WA79:!'8=!U-4',=!Q%!]-,,!<79:!&):8!j7,?).!C,$">!0&4*)!" E!A="K$!2$0#,*/"K$##&)#"'0&("!"K*'$"*)">&!-,*)G%!RK-<!L)4;H!_-8?378!]));6.! /00`T.!B%!`i%f!

1%!S%#,Q!@)"%,*#"/!##!G$"J"%$$%,J"($!)#!B)<-4!)5!-85)4(-A-897!

JBB'4-89,>!6)A-!5),;6!78!$79>!+',,!n369!4-',7Z-=!9:'9!9:-!8-<!$79>!$:'49-4!?7@-6!9:-! ()894),,-4!9:-!B)<-4!9)!78@-697?'9-!*39!8)!9--9:%!U7@-8!9:'9.!:)<!-,6-!('8!9:-!()894),,-4! 6-4@-!9:-!B-)B,-!)9:-4!9:'8!*>!?'9:-478?!785)4A'97)8!'8=!A';78?!B3*,7(!9:-!4-63,96!)5! 9:-!78@-697?'97)8M!eP4'!I--!K-<,'8=-4.!I-99-4!9)!9:-!^=79)4.!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.! G-*43'4>!g.!/00c%f!!!

i%!D'4878?%!P9E6!A3(:!*-99-4!9)!,)6-!'!A7839-!78!>)34!,75-!9:'8!9)!,)6-!>)34!,75-!78!'! A7839-%!D'9(:!9:-!4)'=%!eX-94)B),79'8!C4'8679!J39:)479>!RI)6!J8?-,-6T.!W7?8!)8!'8! XCJ!*36.!6--8!K)@-A*-4!/00`%f!

g%!])3?'78@7,,-'! C:-!<))=>!@78-!?)9!*3489!*>!9:-!(),=!78!A'8>!4-?7)86!'8=!A'>!697,,!,));!:)B-,-66.!*39! n369!4-A-A*-4H!])3?'78@7,,-'!76!634B47678?,>!4-67,7-89.!6)!;--B!<'7978?!5)4!67?86!)5! 8-<!?4)<9:%!e&-55!WB3447-4.!aC7A-!5)4!'!$)A-*'(;M.a!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!JB47,!"/.! /001%f!!!

! /0!

"0%!S%#,Q!L&-6#"&)"%,$"!0G6($)%"!%"%,$"$)2"&'"%,*#",&0&#-&/$X"*%"*#"3&42'!-$2"!)2" 6)2$04*)$27!

I/'$'2!RJB47,!/0!9)!X'>!/0T!G47-8=6!'8=!5'A7,>!<7,,!)55-4!8)!6>AB'9:>!5)4!>)34! 6--A78?,>!8-@-4k-8=78?!678?,-=)A.!6)!79E6!*-69!9)!;--B!9:-!'8?69!9)!>)346-,5%!K"*#+,*

OO#+Z*/&%.#*/*",@*B$),"&*/#*/"*/")1/4*2+,4#,$G*K"4:*/*2#$/:*(%'4&*'"&,$2#/"&*

@+/#*:%'*$,/44:*B,,4G!ea+)4)6()B-.a!P!)$!iHg!RK)@-A*-4!/00`T.!B%!"`/%f!!!

! /"!

6+%2,*=$0'1,"#*!2*!#7*

W)A-97A-6!'4?3A-896!'4-!'9947*39-=!9)!B-)B,-!)4!-89797-6%!RJ8!-8979>!9:'9!768E9!'!B-46)8! A7?:9!*-!'!387@-4679>.!693=-89!(,3*.!()4B)4'97)8.!8)8kB4)579!)4?'87Z'97)8.!?)@-48A-89',! '?-8(>.!6B)496!9-'A.!-9(%T!J8!'4?3A-89!'9947*397)8!'86<-46!9:-!O3-697)8H!aD:)6-! '4?3A-89!76!79Ma!!!)4.!aD:)!76!9:-!'4?3-4Ma!W)A-97A-6!'4?3A-896!'4-!B4-6-89-=!<79:! 6B-(757(!'9947*397)86.!6)A-97A-6!<79:!@'?3-!'9947*397)86.!'8=!6)A-97A-6!<79:)39!'8>! '9947*397)8!'9!',,%!!

$)867=-4!9:76!B'66'?-!54)A!'8!7894)=3(9)4>!B:>67(6!9-F9*));.!<4799-8!5)4!693=-896!<:)! '4-8E9!8'934',!6(7-8(-!A'n)46H!

J6!'!B4))5!)5!9:-!-'49:E6!69'9-!)5!'*6),39-!4-69.!J4769)9,-!B4)55-4-=!'8! '4?3A-89!9:'9!75!9:-!-'49:!<-4-!78!'!69'9-!)5!A)97)8.!'8!)*n-(9!9:4)<8! @-497(',,>!3B<'4=!)8!9:-!6345'(-!<)3,=!8)9!4-9348!9)!796!78797',!B)6797)8%!+-! 9:-8!B)789-=!9)!9:-!)*6-4@'97)8!9:'9!'8!)*n-(9!6)!9)66-=!=)-6.!78=--=.! 4-9348!9)!9:-!6'A-!B)6797)8%!+-!9:36!6)3?:9!9)!-69'*,76:!'*6),39-!4-69!'6!'! =6;*(6&'2;6;5'#$(';<5'56(;<-.'/3.'P.'P1F8'H,A#*-#="C,$"L!30*-"&'"O$!4*%A%! RK-<!L)4;H!X'(A7,,'8!_3*,76:78?!$)%.!"g1cT.!BB%!"k/%f!

P8!9:76!B'66'?-.!9:-!'39:)4.!W%!j%!j7A.!'9947*39-6!'!B'497(3,'4!'4?3A-89!9)! J4769)9,-%!K-79:-4!J4769)9,-!8)4!j7A!76!B'49!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89%!!

j7A!36-=!B4-A76-!'8=!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-46!9)!:-,B!36!6--!<:'9!J4769)9,-E6!()8(,367)8! <'6!'8=!<:'9!:76!B4-A76-6!<-4-%!_4-A76-!'8=!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-46!67?8',!<:-4-!9:-! '4?3A-89E6!B'496!'4-.!6)!9:->!'4-!8)9!B'496!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!796-,5%!C:'9E6!<:>!P!<7,,!,-'@-! 9:-A!)39!<:-8!P!4-<479-!J4769)9,-E6!()8(,367)8%!

K)97(-.!',6).!9:'9!j7A!-FB4-66-6!J4769)9,-E6!()8(,367)8!*)9:!'9!9:-!69'49!'8=!'9!9:-!-8=!)5! 9:-!B'66'?-.!',9:)3?:!:-!36-6!=755-4-89!<)4=6!9)!-FB4-66!79[!J4769)9,-E6!()8(,367)8!76H!

J*6),39-!4-69!76!9:-!-'49:E6!8'934',!69'9-%!

W)A-97A-6!'4?3A-89!'9947*397)86!'4-!,-66!6B-(757(!9:'8!78!9:-!-F'AB,-!n369!=76(366-=%! $)867=-4!9:-!5),,)<78?!9<)kB'4'?4'B:!B'66'?-.!78!<:7(:!9:-!4-,-@'89!'4?3A-89!R<:7(:!76! *),=5'(-=!'8=!38=-4,78-=T!76!78!9:-!57469!B'4'?4'B:H!

P8!'!8'44)<!@)9-.!9:-!P89-48'97)8',!D:',78?!$)AA7667)8!=-(,'4-=!W38='>! 9:'9!/*U[P:,/$*;/"*%"*(%11,$()/4*@+/4,*+'"#)"0*@/2*"%*4%"0,$*

",(,22/$:*;,(/'2,*#+,*1/$)",*1/11/42*+/&*$,(%3,$,&*B$%1*",/$*

,X#)"(#)%"%!

C:-!YYkY/!@)9-!?'@-!&'B'8!'!6>A*),7(!@7(9)4>!78!796!('AB'7?8!9)!4-63A-! <:',78?!'8=!67?8',-=!'!B)<-4!6:759!<79:78!9:-!()AA7667)8.!*39!=7=!8)9! n-)B'4=7Z-!9:-!*'8.!<:7(:!('8!*-!)@-49348-=!)8,>!*>!'!1cp!@)9-!54)A! 'A)8?!9:-!10!A-A*-4!69'9-6%!^8@74)8A-89',7696!'8=!)9:-4!)*6-4@-46!(',,-=! 63(:!'!6(-8'47)!38,7;-,>%!e$'4),!&%!D7,,7'A6.!aJ!W>A*),7(!l7(9)4>!5)4! D:',78?!J=@)('9-6.a!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!&38-!"g.!/00d%f!

! //!

P8!9:76!8-<6B'B-4!4-B)49.!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!57469!B'4'?4'B:!76!'9947*39-=!9)!9:-! P89-48'97)8',!D:',78?!$)AA7667)8%!C:-!$)AA7667)8E6!()8(,367)8!76!9:-!5),,)<78?! 69'9-A-89H!

C:-!/0k>-'4!*'8!)8!()AA-4(7',!<:',-!:38978?!76!8)!,)8?-4!8-(-66'4>%!

C)!*-!A)4-!B4-(76-.!9:76!'4?3A-89!76!'9947*39-=!9)!9:749>k9:4--!A-A*-46!)5!9:-! $)AA7667)8[!)9:-4!9:'8!&'B'8.!<-!=)!8)9!;8)<!<:7(:!A-A*-4!8'97)86!@)9-=!78!5'@)4!)5! 9:-!=-(,'4'97)8%!RC:-!4-69!)5!9:-!8-<6B'B-4!'497(,-!?'@-!6)A-.!*39!8)9!',,.!)5!9:76! 785)4A'97)8%T!

W)A-97A-6!'9947*397)86!)5!'4?3A-896!'4-!-F94-A-,>!@'?3-.!9:'9!76.!@-4>!7AB4-(76-%! $)867=-4!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-!54)A!'8!'*8)4A',!B6>(:),)?>!9-F9*));H!

W)A-!B-)B,-!5--,!9:'9!9:-!QWXkPlkCb!e9:-!JA-47('8!_6>(:7'947(! J66)(7'97)8E6!M*!G)&#%*-"!)2"B%!%*#%*-!4"I!)6!4f!6:)3,=!8)9!78(,3=-! )*-679>!'6!'!B6>(:),)?7(',SB6>(:7'947(!=76)4=-4!*-('36-!B-)B,-!<:)!'4-! )*-6-!'4-!',4-'=>!697?A'97Z-=!78!)34!(3,934-%!e&'A-6!+'86-,,!'8=!I76'! Q'A)34.!:3)&0(!4"H#A-,&4&GA%!R+)*);-8.!K&H!&):8!D7,->!'8=!W)86.! /00cT.!B%!/Yg%f!

P8!9:76!B'66'?-.!9:-!B4-A76-!76!7894)=3(-=!*>!9:-!<)4=!E*-('36-E%!]39!8)9!',,!)5!9:-! 69'9-A-89!*-5)4-!E*-('36-E!!!6)A-!B-)B,-!5--,!9:'9!9:-!QWXkPlkCb!6:)3,=!8)9!78(,3=-! )*-679>!'6!'!B6>(:),)?7(',SB6>(:7'947(!=76)4=-4!!!76!9:-!()8(,367)8%!b'9:-4.!9:-!B:4'6-! E6)A-!B-)B,-!5--,!9:'9E!76!'8!'4?3A-89!'9947*397)8.!-@-8!9:)3?:!79!76!@-4>!@'?3-%!C:-! '4?3A-89E6!()8(,367)8!76!n369!9:-!5),,)<78?!69'9-A-89H!

C:-!QWXkPlkCb!6:)3,=!8)9!78(,3=-!)*-679>!'6!'!B6>(:),)?7(',SB6>(:7'947(! =76)4=-4%!

W)A-97A-6!'!B-46)8!R)4!'8!-8979>T!?7@-6!'8!'4?3A-89!'*)39!:-46-,5!)4!:7A6-,5!R)4!796-,5.!78! 9:-!('6-!)5!'8!-8979>!9:'9!768E9!'!B-46)8T%!$)867=-4!9:76!-F'AB,-.!78!<:7(:!9:-!6B-';-4.! X'87!]:'3A7;.!76!)8-!)5!9:-!B7)8--46!)5!,'6-4!9-(:8),)?>!9:'9!A'=-!I'67;!,'6-4!->-! 634?-4>!B)667*,-H!

P!8-@-4!:'=!9:-!97A-!9)!=-@)9-!9)!A'447'?-.!'6!6(7-8(-!76!'!n-',)36!A7694-66%! eX'87!]:'3A7;.!O3)9-=!78!b'6:--='!]:'?'9.!aD-E4-!J,,!$)6A7(!j78.a! F*)26"86#*)$##"K*)$!RP8=7'T.!X'>!c.!/00d%f!

+-4-.!]':3A7;E6!()8(,367)8!76!'*)39!:7A6-,5%!+76!()8(,367)8!76H!

P!8-@-4!:'=!9:-!97A-!9)!=-@)9-!9)!A'447'?-%!

! /Y!

I-9E6!()867=-4!9:-!57469!9:4--!,78-6!54)A!&):8!Q)88-E6!B)-A!aC:-!C47B,-!G)),aH!

P!'A!9<)!5)),6.!P!;8)<.! 5)4!,)@78?.!'8=!5)4!6'>78?!6)! L='%<1=1=>'?$5;(7-.! e&):8!Q)88-.!aC:-!C47B,-!G)),.a!78!J%!&%!WA79:.!-=%.!P&,)"M&))$="C,$" >&(/4$%$";)G4*#,"H&$(#%!R+'4A)8=6<)49:H!_-8?378!]));6.!"g1YT.!B%!i"%f!

+-4-.!Q)88-E6!'4?3A-89!76!'*)39!:7A6-,5%!+76!()8(,367)8!76!

P!'A!9<)!5)),6%!

K)97(-!9:'9!P!=7=!8)9!78(,3=-!EP!;8)<E!78!9:-!()8(,367)8%!C:76!76!*-('36-!Q)88-!76!8)9! ?7@78?!4-'6)86!9)!*-,7-@-!9:'9!:-!;8)<6!:-!76!9<)!5)),6.!n369!9:'9!:-!76!9<)!5)),6%!

! /`!

5H=-I!-J*5HKLMJN?*?JI*OP\Q*

6AK?J*=HTRNJSI*!?*!I7*

P86943(97)86H!;!-,"&'"%,$"'&44&+*)G"/!##!G$#"-&)%!*)#"!)"!0G6($)%7"L&0"$!-,?"#!A"+,&#$" !0G6($)%"*%"*#"!)2"+0*%$"%,$"-&)-46#*&)?"!)2"4*#%"!44"/0$(*#$"&0"-&)-46#*&)"*)%0&26-$0#"

6#$27"8$"#60$"%&"+0*%$"%,$"-&)-46#*&)"!#"!"-&(/4$%$"#$)%$)-$"%,!%"*#"/,0!#$2"!#"!"

#%!%$($)%"!)2"(!D$#"#$)#$"!44"3A"*%#$4'7""I!D$"-4$!0"%,$"0$'$0$)%#"&'"!)A"/0&)&6)#"6#$2?"

6)4$##"%,$"-&)-46#*&)"*#"!3&6%"%,$"!0G6$0X"*'"%,$"-&)-46#*&)"*#"!3&6%"%,$"!0G6$0?"A&6"(!A"

4$!5$"%,$"/$0#&)!4"/0&)&6)#"%,!%"0$'$0"%&"%,$"!0G6$07"M&")&%"!22"!)A"$44*/#$#7!

W'AB,-!_4)*,-A6H!!

! 247?78',!_'66'?-H!

X'8>!(4797(6!()89-8=-=!9:'9!*-('36-!9:-!94),,->!()AB'87-6!B4)@7=-=!'!@79',! 34*'8!6-4@7(-.!9:->!6:)3,=!'(O37-6(-!9)!B3*,7(!=-A'8=6!-@-8!'9!9:-! -FB-86-!)5!B4)579%!eW()99!I%!])99,-6.!K&#":)G$4$#"!)2"%,$":6%&(&3*4$="C,$" I!D*)G"&'"%,$"I&2$0)">*%A%!R]-4;-,->H!N87@-4679>!)5!$',75)487'!_4-66.! "gi1T.!BB%!""k"/%f!

J86<-4H!

D:)6-!'4?3A-89!76!79MH!A'8>!(4797(6E!

$)8(,367)8H!C:-!94),,->!()AB'87-6!6:)3,=!'(O37-6(-!9)!B3*,7(!=-A'8=6! -@-8!'9!9:-!-FB-86-!)5!B4)579%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!*-('36-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

! /c!

! 247?78',!_'66'?-H!

-/LM='WXYZ8'-'/[(.'I7(1&'B5+<;8'+$($=5('$#'@&&5><5=7'I$*=;78'

_-886>,@'87'f!<)3,=!'BB-'4!*-5)4-!$)8?4-66E6!'66'6678'97)8!()AA799--! <79:!(:'496!'8=!6(7-89757(!-@7=-8(-!9)!=-A)8694'9-!9:'9!5)34!*3,,-96!:'=! *--8!574-=!'9!9:-!_4-67=-89!e&):8!G%!j-88-=>f%!J6!I--!+'4@->!26<',=!:'=! 574-=!)8,>!9:4--!6:)96.!9:'9!A-'89.!'(()4=78?!9)!D-(:9E6!-@7=-8(-.!9:'9! 9:-4-!:'=!9)!*-!'8)9:-4!?38A'8%!eC:)A'6!C%!K)?3(:7!<79:!&)6-B:! Q7X)8'.!>&0&)$0%!RK-<!L)4;H!_)(;-9!]));6.!"giYT.!B%!g1%f!

J86<-4H!

D:)6-!'4?3A-89!76!79MH!Q4%!$>47,!D-(:9E6!

$)8(,367)8H!C:-4-!<'6!'8)9:-4!?38A'8.!78!'==797)8!9)!I--!+'4@->! 26<',=.!78!9:-!'66'6678'97)8!)5!_4-67=-89!&):8!G%!j-88-=>%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!'6!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!9:'9!A-'89!9:'9!

"%!C:'7!<)4;-46!6:)3,=!(:-(;!('4-53,,>!<:-8!4-6B)8=78?!9)!n)*6!'=@-4976-=!78!j3<'79!'8=! 8-7?:*)3478?!()38947-6!*-('36-!9:->!()3,=!-8=!3B!<)4;78?!78!='8?-4)36!'4-'6! *)4=-478?!P4'O.!6'>6!D7*))8!j:36';3,.!C:'7!'A*'66'=)4!9)!P4'O!'8=!&)4='8%!eaW-4@78?! C:'7!P89-4-696!78!9:-!X7==,-!^'69.a!8!)GD&D"H&#%.!G-*43'4>!`.!/001%f!

\.'-/VM5F1=12;2'6(>*5)';<6;'%$F5='%5(5'6;';<5'+5=;5('$#'#6F1&7'&1#5'6=)'+<1&)'(56(1=>8'2$'

;<6;'+<1&)(5=Q2'122*52'%5(5'%$F5=Q2'122*52-.'/]$5&'452;8'C,0$!%$)$2">,*420$)="

O,$%&0*-"!)2">&)-$0)"!3&6%">,*42RY*-%*(#%!R$:7('?)H!C:-!N87@-4679>!)5!$:7('?)! _4-66.!"gg0T.!B%!1%f!!!

Y%!S%#,Q!M$!)"B(*%,"+!#"!"4&)GR%*($?"5$0A"#6--$##'64"($)J#"3!#D$%3!44"-&!-,"!%"C,$" U)*5$0#*%A"&'"Q&0%,">!0&4*)!"!%">,!/$4"F*447!

W)A-!()'(:-6!6'>!4-@-8?-!76!8)9!'8!-55-(97@-!A)97@'978?!5'(9)4!*-('36-!9:-!-A)97)8!76! 6:)49k,7@-=%!eQ-'8!WA79:.!78!Q-'8!WA79:!'8=!U-4',=!Q%!]-,,!<79:!&):8!j7,?).!C,$" >!0&4*)!"E!A="K$!2$0#,*/"K$##&)#"'0&("!"K*'$"*)">&!-,*)G%!RK-<!L)4;H!_-8?378! ]));6.!/00`T.!B%!c0%f!

`%!Media mavens will tell you that Super Bowl ads rarely pay off for advertisers, given that they're the most expensive half-minute in advertising at an estimated $2.6 million. [Susan Chandler, "Super Bowl 101: The Ads," Chicago Tribune, January 28, 2007.]!

! /d!

c%!S%#,Q!C,$"#/$!D$0"*#"9!0A">&&/$0?"!"'!(&6#"!-%&0?"+,&"D)$+",$"+!#"2A*)G"&'"-!)-$07" F$"2*$2"&)$"+$$D"4!%$07!

P!;8)<!<:'9!76!:'BB-878?!76!U)=E6!<7,,%!P!'A!8)9!'54'7=!)5!9:-!53934-%!eU'4>!$))B-4.! O3)9-=!78!&'A-6!]'()8.!I!2$"*)"F&44A+&&2%!R$:7('?)H!$)89-AB)4'4>!]));6.!P8(%.! "g11T.!B%!`g%f!!!

d%!ab'**79.a!_)):!6'7=!9)!:7A6-,5%!aP!4*D$!9',;78?!9)!b'**79%!+-!9',;6!'*)39!6-867*,-!9:78?6%! +-!=)-68E9!36-!,)8?.!=7557(3,9!<)4=6.!,7;-!2<,%!+-!36-6!6:)49.!-'6>!<)4=6.!,7;-!ED:'9! '*)39!,38(:ME!'8=!E+-,B!>)346-,5.!_)):%Ea!eJ%!J%!X7,8-.!C,$"F&6#$"!%"H&&,">&0)$0%! RK-<!L)4;H!^%!_%!Q399)8!'8=!$)AB'8>.!"g/iT.!B%!c1%f!

1%!25!9:-!=)Z-8!4-()4=78?6!78!9:76!',*3A.!',,!'4-!I799,-!D',9-4!)47?78',6!<79:!)8-! -F(-B97)8%!aX>!]'*-a!<'6!<4799-8!5)4!:7A%!P9!76!'!=74-(9!=-6(-8='89!)5!9:-!6B74793',.! aC:76!C4'78%a!

O<12';(61=')$=Q;'+6((7'=$'>6F:&5(28';<12';(61='-'B6&;5(Q2'F*21+6&'+<1&)'>)-6H!X>!*'*-! )$=Q;'2;6=)'=$'+<56;1=Q8'F7':6:5-!

Q7=!:-!;8)<!9:76M!+-!,'3?:6H!aP!=7=8E9!;8)<!<:-8!79!<'6!?7@-8!9)!A-%!P!8-@-4!:-'4=! 9:'9!6B74793',%!L)3!6--.!PEA!8)9!'!4-?3,'4!(:34(:k?)78?!$:47697'8.!9:)3?:!PEA!'!?))=! *-,7-@-4%!X'>*-!P!6:)3,=!?)!A)4-!)59-8!9:-8!PE=E@-!;8)<8!<:-4-!79!('A-!54)A%a!eW93=6! C-4;-,.!I78-4!K)9-6.!C,$"8$#%"&'"K*%%4$"E!4%$0%!RN87@-46',!$79>.!$',75)487'H! $:-66SX$J!b-()4=6.!"gci.!"gid[!$+Qkg"g/%f!!!

i%!C)='>!P!=7=8E9!-@-8!:'@-!9)!36-!A>!Jj%!P!?)99'!6'>!79!<'6!'!?))=!='>%!eP(-!$3*-.!aP9! D'6!'!U))=!Q'>.a!)8!P(-!$3*-.!@-$">63$J#"90$!%$#%"F*%#%!R_47)479>.!/00"T%f!!

g%!]-('36-!P!<'6!'!X36,7A!'8=!9:76!<'6!'!$:47697'8!6)(7-9>.!P!=7=8E9!*-,7-@-!P!<)3,=!*-! <1(5)';$')$';5&5N121$='+$FF5(+16&2-.'/P6(55F'@:)*&k&'**'4!'8=!_-9-4!j8)*,-4.! 9*!)%"B%$/#%!RK-<!L)4;H!]'89'A!]));6.!"giYT.!B%!/1/%f!!!

"0%!+-84>!I3(-.!5)38=-4!)5!C*($"F6>6^1=5'-'+$=21)5(5)'<1F25&#'2$F5;<1=>'$#'6='@216=' 5T?5(;8'62'<5'<6)':55=':$(='1='I<1=6-.'/_5(6&)'`6(&78'DO<5'_(56;'4&6+,'9$?58D'C,$"

Q!%*&)!/i/H"/!RX'4(:!/1.!/00dT.!B%!Y/%f!!

! /1!

5H=-I!-J*5HKLMJN?*?JI*OP]Q*

!>JSI!<8!ST*-KS-MR?!KS?*

P86943(97)86H!;!-,"&'"%,$"'&44&+*)G"/!##!G$#"-&)%!*)#"!)"!0G6($)%7"L&0"$!-,?"+0*%$"%,$" -&)-46#*&)?"!)2"4*#%"!44"/0$(*#$"&0"-&)-46#*&)"*)%0&26-$0#"6#$27"8$"#60$"%&"+0*%$"%,$"

-&)-46#*&)"!#"!"-&(/4$%$"#$)%$)-$"%,!%"*#"/,0!#$2"!#"!"#%!%$($)%"!)2"(!D$#"#$)#$"!44"3A"

*%#$4'7"I!D$"-4$!0"%,$"0$'$0$)%#"&'"!)A"/0&)&6)#"6#$2?"6)4$##"%,$"-&)-46#*&)"*#"!3&6%"%,$"

!0G6$0X"*'"%,$"-&)-46#*&)"*#"!3&6%"%,$"!0G6$0?"A&6"(!A"4$!5$"%,$"/$0#&)!4"/0&)&6)#"%,!%"

0$'$0"%&"%,$"!0G6$07"M&")&%"!22"!)A"$44*/#$#7!

W'AB,-!_4)*,-A6H!!

! 247?78',!_'66'?-H!

J,9:)3?:!5)4*7==-8!*>!9:-74!4-,7?7)8!9)!6,'3?:9-4!'87A',6.!9:-!W:-4B'6!e78! K-B',f!'4-!@-4>!5)8=!)5!6A);-=!>';!A-'9.!'8=!6)!9:->!7AB)49!*39(:-46! 54)A!C7*-9!5)4!9:-!6,'3?:9-478?%!eC';-:7=-!j'Z'A7.!C,$"F*(!4!A!#=":" P&60)$A"%&"Q$/!4%!RC);>)H!j)='86:'!P89-48'97)8',.!"gdiT.!B%!/i%f!

J86<-4H!

$)8(,367)8H!C:-!W:-4B'6!78!K-B',!7AB)49!*39(:-46!54)A!C7*-9!5)4!9:-! 6,'3?:9-478?!)5!>';6%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!6)!

! 247?78',!_'66'?-H!

Photographic works dominate [the current show at the Ottawa Art Gallery]. That's only proper, seeing as how photography has ruled the 8))(,('(")'*4%&%'0-"'!%4(!%*+2'9:(16';%**%66<'=>,-';(66%"#%*',#)?'

Different Approaches," O ttawa C itizen (Canada), May 25, 2006.]!

J86<-4H!

$)8(,367)8H!P9E6!)8,>!B4)B-4!9:'9!B:)9)?4'B:7(!<)4;6!=)A78'9-!9:-!(344-89! 6:)<!'9!9:-!299'<'!J49!U',,-4>%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!6--78?!'6!:)<!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

! /i!

W.'-/[M$+;$(2'+$=;($&'6:$*;'Za'?5(+5=;'$#';<5'+$2;2'1=+*((5)';<($*><$*;';<5'<56&;<'('4-! 78=3694>%!P9!5),,)<6!9:'9!()894),,78?!:)6B79',!()696!76!,'4?-,>!'!A'99-4!)5!7AB4)@78?! ?<721+16=2Q'5##1+15=+7'1='*21=>'<$2?1;6&'(52$*(+52-.'/G$:5(;'E$(;5(8'D@'I&1=1+'372;5F'

D7,,!]-!]-99-4.a!O&!)&D$"C*($#"Rl74?787'T.!JB47,!"0.!/001%f!

/%!S%#,Q!@BQ:"*#"%,$"!-0&)A("'&0"%,$"@)%$0#$T"B&-*$%A"&'"Q&0%,":($0*-!7!

J(()4=78?!9)!PWKJE6!<-*679-!R<<<%768'%)4?T.!)8-!78!-@-4>!/.000!(:7,=4-8!76!*)48! 789-46-F-=%!C:'9!76!9:-!9)9',!83A*-4!)5!B-)B,-!<:)6-!*)=7-6!=755-4!54)A!69'8='4=!A',-! )4!5-A',-%!C:-!/000!(-8636!*34-'3!4-B)49-=!9:'9!/g%Yp!)5!9:-!B)B3,'97)8!'4-!B-)B,-!)5! (),)4!R7%-%!],'(;6.!K'97@-!JA-47('86.!+76B'87(6!'8=!J67'86T%!C:'9!<)3,=!A-'8!"SY!)5! 789-46-F!(:7,=4-8!*)48!'4-!(:7,=4-8!)5!(),)4%!eI>88-,,!W9-B:'87!I)8?.!ab'(-!'8=!9:-! P89-46-F-=.a!@BQ:"Q$+#="Q$+#4$%%$0"&'"%,$"@)%$0#$T"B&-*$%A"&'"Q&0%,":($0*-!!RW3AA-4! /00YT.!B%!"%f!!!

Y%!$:-A7(',,>!',,!)5!36!'4-!*)9:!A'8!'8=!<)A'8!*-('36-!)34!*)=7-6!A';-!*)9:!A',-!'8=! #5F6&5'<$(F$=5-.'/E6*&')5'P(*1#8'C,$"I!4$"F&0(&)$7!RK-<!L)4;H!+'4()349.!]4'(-! '8=!$)AB'8>.!"g`cT.!B%!""1%f!

`%!P8!9:-!B),7(-!'4(:7@-6!e78!]4'Z7,f!'!,'4?-!83A*-4!)5!('6-6!)5!A34=-4-=!?'>!A-8!,7-!697,,! 386),@-=!!!*-('36-!)5!9:-!B),7(-!8-?,7?-8(-.!*-('36-!9:-!@7(97AE6!5'A7,>!B4-5-46!9)! ;--B!9:-!A'99-4!O37-9.!)4!*-('36-!9:-!@7(97A!',<'>6!,-=!'!=)3*,-!,75-.!;--B78?!:76! 4-,'97)86:7B6!6-(4-9%!e&)q)!W%!C4-@76'8.!H$05$0%#"*)"H!0!2*#$.!94'86,'9-=!*>!X'4978! G)4-A'8%!RI)8=)8H!UX_!_3*,76:-46.!"gidT.!B%!"cg%f!!!

c%!]-('36-!79!('8!9';-!5)34!?)'96!'!>-'4!9)!?4)<!-8)3?:!('6:A-4-!5)4!)8-!6<-'9-4.! ('6:A-4-!:'6!',<'>6!*--8!()867=-4-=!'!B4-(7)36!57*-4%!eaj8)<!L)34!W9>,-H!J!Uo! $4'6:!$)346-.a!9Z!RX'4(:!/001T.!B%!/g0%f!

S.'-/O<5'F6='%<$'+$F52'$=';<5'(6)1$';$';5&&'F5'<$%'%<1;5'F7'2<1(;2'+6=':5M'+6=Q;':5'6'

A'8!E('36-!:-!=)-68E9!6A);-!9:-!6'A-!(7?'4-99-6!'6!A-%!eX%!&'??-4!'8=!j%!b7(:'4=.! aW'9765'(97)8.a!)8!C:-!b),,78?!W9)8-6.!S6%"&'"S60"F$!2#.!I)8=)8!b-()4=6!IIY`/g.! "gd`%f!!!

1%![6F15='-'<6)'6'b$<6%,-8'2$'$:N1$*2&7'<5'&1,5)';<5F.'/b6;;<5%'P&6F8'Dca'O<1=>2' '!X'8!Q)-6!K)9!+'@-!9)!Q)!]-5)4-!+-!Q7-6H!U-9!'!X):'<;.a!9Z!RW-B9-A*-4!/00dT.! B%!Y10%f!!

i%!WB)8?-])*!WO3'4-_'896!:'6!A'=-!'!A)@7-%!P9E6!(',,-=!R=3:T!C,$"B/&)G$8&3" BV6!0$H!)%#"I&5*$.!'8=!'=3,96!<7,,!*-!-,*)<78?!;7=6!'67=-!9)!6--!79%!D:>M!]-('36-!'9! '!97A-!<:-8!-@-4>!('49))8!947-6!9)!*-!()),!'8=!6)B:7697('9-=.!B8BH!6--6!8)9:78?!<4)8?! <79:!*-78?!67,,>%!eaWB)8?-])*!G78',,>!$)A-6!239!RD79:!'!X)@7-T.a!9Z"RQ-(-A*-4! /00`T.!B%!"gd%f!!!

! /g!

g%!X'8>!B),,k9';-46!'8=!B),797(7'86!*-,7-@-!9:'9!e_4-67=-89!Q<7?:9!Q%f!^76-8:)<-4!()3,=! :'@-!*--8!-,-(9-=!9)!'!%,*02!9-4A!78!"gd0.!:'=!:-!6)3?:9!79!!!*39!:-!()3,=8E9.!*-('36-! *>!9:-8!9:-!C<-89>k6-()8=!JA-8=A-89!9)!9:-!$)86979397)8!,7A79-=!',,!B4-67=-896!9)! 9<)!9-4A6%!eC)A!D7(;-4.!M+*G,%"M7";*#$),&+$0%!RK-<!L)4;H!C7A-6!]));6S+-84>! +),9!'8=!$)AB'8>.!/00/T.!B%!/%f!!!

"0%!S%#,Q!C,$"!0G6($)%"*)"%,*#"/!##!G$"*#"3&42'!-$2"!)2"6)2$04*)$27!

I+,*$,2)&,"#2*%B*5)(%*R")%"*)"3/$)/;4:*4)3,*)"*/./$#1,"#*+%'2,2Z*+,"(,*#+,*

.%.'4/#)%"*&,"2)#:*)2*#+,*+)0+,2#*)"*M%2*="0,4,2G!J(()4=78?!9)!9:-!"gg0!$-8636.! I'978)6!A'=-!3B!'*)39!-7?:9>k9<)!B-4(-89!)5!9:-!)8-!:38=4-=!'8=!9<-89>!9:)36'8=! B-)B,-!,7@78?!*-9<--8!W7F9:!W94--9.!'8=!9:-!W'89'!X)87('!G4--<'>!'8=!*-9<--8! +))@-4!'8=!9:-!+'4*)4!G4--<'>%!X-F7('86!'8=!X-F7('8kJA-47('86!<-4-!5)49>k)8-! B-4(-89!)5!9:-!B)B3,'97)8.!W',@'=)4'86!9<-89>k9<)!B-4(-89.!'8=!U3'9-A','86!9-8! B-4(-89%!eb)*-49!Q%!+-4A'8.!M&+)%&+)"K&#":)G$4$#=":"E!4D*)G"96*2$.!4-@%!-=%! R]',=<78!_'4;.!$',75)487'H!U-A!U37=-6!]));!$)AB'8>.!/000T.!BB%!"//k"/Y%f!!!

""%!W78(-!7AB)49!4'(-46!'4-!9>B7(',,>!:7?:!6(:)),!)4!(),,-?-!693=-896!54)A!A7==,-k!9)! 3BB-4kA7==,-k(,'66!*'(;?4)38=6!<79:!P89-48-9!'((-66.!B4)A)9-46.!@-8=)46.!'8=! B'497(7B'896!:'@-!5)38=!79!-'6>!9)!6B4-'=!9:-!(3,934-!5'4!*->)8=!9:-!()8578-6!)5! 6)39:-48!$',75)487'%!el7(9)47'!K'A;38?.!ab-78@-8978?!9:-!D:--,H!PAB)49!b'(78?!78! W)39:-48!$',75)487'.a!78!&-8875-4!I--!'8=!X78!h:)3.!-=6%.!:#*!)":($0*-!)"<&6%,=" >64%60$?"@2$)%*%A?"!)2";%,)*-*%A%!RK-<!L)4;H!b)39,-=?-.!/00`T.!BB%!"d/.!"d`%f!

"/%!-/4M5+6*25';$;6&1;6(16='(5>1F52'6&%672'#1=)'?$5;2';<5'F$2;')6=>5($*2'$#'?5$?&58';<57' '4-!)59-8!9:-!57469!9)!*-!-F-(39-=%!e_-9-4!]',';7'8.!84!-D"M&G"&'"L!%$=":"I$(&*0%! RK-<!L)4;H!]'67(]));6.!"gg1T.!B%!/Y`%f!!!

"Y%!j-44>!W7-:!)5!$',9-(:!<'6!9:-!?-),)?7(',!()863,9'89!5)4!9:-!9388-,!B4)n-(9!e5)4!9:-! G5)'01=5M-.'315<')5;5(F1=5)';<6;'56(;<d*6,52'F1><;'$++*('$=';<5'9$&&7%$$)'V6*&;8'

)8!'@-4'?-.!-@-4>!".000!9)!/.c00!>-'46%!]-67=-6!9:-!5'(9!9:'9!O3';-6!=)!8)9!)((34!'9! 4-?3,'4!789-4@',6.!W7-:!=7=!8)9!;8)<!9:-!='9-!)5!9:-!,'69!O3';-%!C:36.!9:-4-!<'6!8)! 9-,,78?!<:-8!9:-!8-F9!)8-!<)3,=!6947;-%!e_:7,7B!I%!G4'=;78.!I!G)*%62$"W=";!0%,V6!D$#" !)2"K*'$"!4&)G"%,$"B!)":)20$!#"L!64%%!R]-4;-,->H!N87@-4679>!)5!$',75)487'!_4-66.! "ggiT.!B%!/c`%f!

"`%!W',9!B)4;.!:)A78>!?4796.!()48*4-'=.!'8=!A),'66-6!5)4A-=!9:-!69'8='4=!5'4-!5)4!9:-! A'n)479>!)5!X'()8!$)389>E6!*,'(;!4-67=-896!e78!9:-!"gY06f.!<:7,-!4-=!A-'9.!54-6:! @-?-9'*,-6!'8=!54379.!)4!A7,;!R-@-8!5)4!5'A7,7-6!<79:!785'896T!6-,=)A!'BB-'4-=!)8!9:-74! 9'*,-6%!J6!'!4-63,9.!(:4)87(!A',8394797)8!'8=!'!:)69!)5!=7-9k4-,'9-=!7,,8-66-6!<-4-! 6-47)36!:-',9:!B4)*,-A6%!e&'A-6!+%!&)8-6.!8!2"84&&2="C,$"C6#D$G$$"BA/,*4*#" ;T/$0*($)%.!8-<.!-FB'8=-=!-=%!RK-<!L)4;H!G4--!_4-66.!"ggY.!B%!d/%f!!!

! Y0!

"c%!J8!-A*4>)E6!,38?6!'4-!53,,>!=-@-,)B-=!67F9--8!<--;6!'59-4!()8(-B97)8%!!+-8(-.!=3478?! 9:)6-!67F9--8!<--;6.!'!A)9:-4E6!@79'A78!^!,-@-,6!B,'>!'8!7AB)49'89!4),-%!!W3((-6653,! ,38?!=-@-,)BA-89!76!(,)6-,>!,78;-=!9)!,-@-,6!)5!@79'A78!^%!eaX)9:-46E!l79'A78!^! Q-57(7-8(>!I78;-=!9)!J69:A'!78!j7=6.a!I$2*-!4"Q$+#"C&2!A!RN879-=!j78?=)AT.! W-B9-A*-4!/.!/00d%f!!!

"d%!eP,,78)76!?)@-48)4!b)=f!],'?)n-@7(:!6'7=!@)9-46!6:)3,=!63BB)49!:7A!*-('36-!:-! 69--4-=!P,,78)76!9:4)3?:!=7557(3,9!576(',!<'9-46!'8=!5)(36-=!)8!B-)B,-E6!:-',9:!('4-.! 78(,3=78?!7894)=3(78?!'!B,'8!9)!)55-4!:-',9:!78634'8(-!5)4!-@-4>!(:7,=!78!9:-!69'9-%! /]$<='I<625'6=)'G1+,'E56(2$=8'DL'[525(N5'6'e$;5'#$('_$N5(=$('45+6*25-8D'>,*-!G&"

C0*36)$.!X'4(:!/0.!/00d%f!

"1%!DL2'-'/3F6&&M'&$2;fD'/E$$<'62,5).M!

aD-,,.a!6'7=!b'**79.!a8)*)=>!:'6!6--8!:7A!5)4!'!,)8?!97A-.!6)!P!63BB)6-!:-!76%a!eJ%!J%! X7,8-.!C,$"F&6#$"!%"H&&,">&0)$0%!RK-<!L)4;H!^%!_%!Q399)8!'8=!$)AB'8>.!"g/iT.!B%! Y1%f!!!

"i%!J!<-,,kA'=-!B'69'!*)<,!76!7AB-4'97@-H!79!;--B6!9:-!6'3(-!()89'78-=.!9:-!8))=,-6! <'4A.!'8=!9:-!9'*,-!,));78?!?))=%!eaC:-!C-(:87O3-H!W3B-47)4!_'69'!W'3(-.a!9Z! RG-*43'4>!/00cT.!B%!cd%f!

"g%!P!9:78;!9:-4-E6!786'879>!78!A>!5'A7,>%!C:->!;--B!<47978?!A-!5)4!A)8->%!e+-88>! L)38?A'8.!C,$";)-A-4&/$2*!"&'"S)$"K*)$0#.!-=%!^=!W:'8'B:>%!Rj'9)8':.!K%L%H! ]',,>A)9-!]));6.!"gigT.!B%!"0g%f!!!

/0%!S%#,Q*:'%$0",*#"/0$#*2$)-A"$)2$2?"F!00A"C06(!)"4*D$2"%&"G*5$"%&60#"!)2"%!4D#"%&" -,*420$)"!%"%,$"C06(!)"H0$#*2$)%*!4"K*30!0A"*)"@)2$/$)2$)-$?"I*##&60*7"C,$"

!0G6($)%"*)"%,*#"/!##!G$"*#"3&42'!-$2"!)2"6)2$04*)$27!

J9!9:-!-8=!)5!X4%!C43A'8E6!6B--(:-6!9:-4-!<'6!',<'>6!'!O3-697)8!B-47)=.!'8=!)8!)8-! ='>!P!,7;-!9)!4-A-A*-4!9:-!,'69!O3-697)8!('A-!54)A!'8!'8F7)36!6A',,!*)>!<79:!4-=!:'74! <:)6-!-'46!:'=!?4)<8!3B.!*39!8)9!:76!5'(-%!

aX4%!_4-67=-89.a!:-!6'7=.!'8=!:76!53934-!'8=!9:-!<)4,=E6!=-B-8=-=!)8!9:-!4-B,>.!a<'6! >)3!B)B3,'4!<:-8!>)3!<'6!'!*)>Ma!

C:-!_4-67=-89!,));-=!'9!9:-!*)>!)@-4!9:-!?,'66-6!9:'9!',<'>6!A'=-!:7A!,));!,7;-!'8! 74479'9-=!)<,%!aD:>.!8).a!:-!6'7=.!a!*@/2*",3,$*.%.'4/$G*I+,*.%.'4/$*;%:2*@,$,*#+,*

%",2*@+%*@,$,*0%%&*/#*0/1,2*/"&*+/&*;)0Z*#)0+#*B)2#2G*!*@/2*",3,$*4)9,*#+/#G! D79:)39!A>!?,'66-6!P!<'6!*,78=!'6!'!*'9.!'8=!9)!9-,,!9:-!9439:.!P!<'6!;78=!)5!'!6766>%!P5! 9:-4-!<'6!'8>!='8?-4!)5!?-9978?!789)!'!57?:9.!P!',<'>6!4'8%!P!?3-66!9:'9E6!<:>!PEA!:-4-! 9)='>%a!eX-4,-!X7,,-4.!H4!*)"B/$!D*)G=":)"S0!4"8*&G0!/,A"&'"F!00A"B7"C06(!)%!RK-<! L)4;H!_-8?378.!"g1`[!4-B4789-=H!K-<!L)4;H!C-66!_4-66.!/00`T.!B%!/"%f!

! Y"!

/"%!P!=)8E9!*-,7-@-!A>!<)A'8!,)@-!A-%! W:-E6!78!,)@-!<79:!'8)9:-4!A'8%! eX3==>!D'9-46.!aG,))=.a!R"gc/T!)8!X3==>!D'9-46.!C,$">,$##"8&T"R"[%!RX$J! b-()4=6[!$+QYki000/%f!!!

//%!J9!9:-!-8=!)5!"gY`!A>!57469!B,'>.!C,$">,*420$)J#"F&60.!<'6!'!?4-'9!63((-66%!C:-!='>6! $#'&1N1=>'$='$;<5('?5$?&5'%5(5'$N5(-.'/01&&16='95&&F6=8'B-&6)20$4"C*($%!RK-<!L)4;H! ]'89'A!]));6.!"g1d.!B%!`0%f!

/Y%!D79:!'8!',A)69!7=-',!*','8(-!)5!6<--9!'8=!9'49!'8=!'!=-,7(7)36!B78->!5,'@)4.!9:-! 24)*,'8()!76!'!5'@)479-!?4'B-54379!)5!A'8>!5'4A-46!A'4;-9!6:)BB-46%!eb366!_'46)86.! aG'4A-46!X'4;-9H!Q-,7(7)36,>!W<--9kC'49.a!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!&'83'4>!"0.!/001%f!!!

/`%!P8!"gg0.!'9!,-'69!)8-!)39!)5!9:4--!J8?-,-8)6!<'6!)5!X-F7('8!=-6(-89%!P9!76!9:-4-5)4-! 8'934',!9:'9!!!'67=-!54)A!-()8)A7(!'8=!:769)47(',!,78;6!!!X-F7()!:'6!)((3B7-=!'!@-4>! 6B-(7',!B,'(-!78!9:-!-&0!\]).!9:-!:-'49!)5!Q6$#%0!"B$^&0!"2$"K&#":)G$4$#%!eb)=),5)!G%! J(3m'.!:)A%,*)G"86%"I$T*-!)=">,*-!)&#"*)">&)%$(/&0!0A"K&#":)G$4$#%!RI)8=)8H! l-46).!"ggdT.!B%!/Y"%f!

/c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

C:-!*)=>!796-,5.!94'866-F3',6!-@-893',,>!=76()@-4.!76!9:-!a94'86,'97)8!=-@7(-a!9:'9! ()=-6!)34!()AA387('97)8!<79:!)9:-46%!$:'8?78?!)34!*)=7-6!76!:)<!<-!?-9!)39!)5!)34! C<7,7?:9!h)8-!B4-=7('A-89%!C4'866-F3',79>!76!9:36!'*)39!*4-';78?!)39!)5! B6>(:),)?7(',!76),'97)8.!()44-(978?!'!('6-!)5!A769';-8!7=-8979>.!'8=!*478?78?!'! B-46)8',!6-86-!)5!6-,5!789)!A-'878?53,!789-4'(97)8!<79:!)9:-46%!eW36'8!W94>;-4.! a_)494'79!)5!K-<!X'8H!C:-!X>69-4>!)5!U-8=-4!9:4)3?:!9:-!^>-6!)5!'!_:)9)?4'B:-4! D:)!+'6!$4)66-=!9:-!Q7@7=-.a!C,$"UCQ;"O$!2$0!1d!R&3,>SJ3?369!"ggdT.!B%!1i%f!!

/d%!-/OM<5'3*=)16&'12'(*=':7'(56&'I3gA'2;*)5=;28'6=)';<5(5#$(5'=$;'?5(#5+;.'/G76=' Q-8:'A.!a$4-'978?!'!$'AB36kG)(36-=!W38=7',.a!M!*4A"B6)2*!4!R$',75)487'!W9'9-! N87@-4679>.!K)49:47=?-T.!J3?369!/g.!/00c%f!!!

\Y.'O<5'=6;1$=6&')125625'2*(N51&&6=+5'272;5F'1='-'/L=)16M'12'$*;)6;5)'6=)'<5=+5'

1=5##5+;1N5-8'g=1$='b1=12;5('$#'956&;<'6=)'V6F1&7'B5&#6(5'@=:*F6=1'G6F6)$22'

6'7=!)8!X)8='>%!eaQ76-'6-!W34@-7,,'8(-!W>69-A!E239='9-=.Ea!F*)26"RP8=7'T.!2(9)*-4! Y".!/00d%f!

! Y/!

\Z.'-/OM<5'L=)16=2'/6(5M'4(6^1&Q2'#1(2;'1=<6:1;6=;2'6=)'1;2'F$2;'&5>1;1F6;5'<51(2.'e&)q)!W%! C4-@76'8.!H$05$0%#"*)"H!0!2*#$.!94'86,'9-=!*>!X'4978!G)4-A'8%!RI)8=)8H!UX_! _3*,76:-46.!"gidT.!B%!"c%f!!!

/g%!b$2d*1;$52'-'+6='2*(N1N5'1='<1><'H5(>$'+$&)h'6&;1;*)52-.'/3;5N5'3*(*R:6&&78'DE5;' $)48-4.a!B%!30&$D"Q$+#!RU3>'8'T.!JB47,!".!/001%f!

ia.'-/bM6=7'7$*=>'?5$?&5'6(5'<6N1=>'6'<6()5(';1F5';<6=';<51('?6(5=;2')1)'>5;;1=>'

-69'*,76:-=!78!('4--46.!'8=!'4-!9:-4-5)4-!578=78?!9:'9!6A',,!:)36-6!'8=!A7836(3,-! ()8=)6!579!9:-74!-()8)A7(!()8=797)86!n369!578-%!eD-8=>!_47-6879Z.!aWA',,!P6!]-'39753,.a! Q!%60!4"K*'$"I!G!\*)$!RX'>S&38-!/001T%f!!!

Y"%!J,A)69!',,!4'7,<'>!('46!)B-4'978?!<79:78!9:-!(79>!,7A796!e)5!I)6!J8?-,-6!78!"g""f! -89-4-=!9:-!=)<89)<8!=76947(9!'8=!9:36!()8947*39-=!9)!94'557(!()8?-697)8%!eW()99!I%! ])99,-6.!K&#":)G$4$#"!)2"%,$":6%&(&3*4$="C,$"I!D*)G"&'"%,$"I&2$0)">*%A%!R]-4;-,->H! N87@-4679>!)5!$',75)487'!_4-66.!"gi1T.!B%!`c%f!

Y/%!S%#,Q!C,$"!0G6($)%"*)"%,*#"/!##!G$"*#"3&42'!-$2"!)2"6)2$04*)$27!

J!<)A'8!<',;6!':-'=!)5!A-!)8!'!=7A,>!,79!694--9%!+-4!:--,6!(,7(;!)8!9:-!67=-<',;%! W:-E6!',)8-%!P9E6!'4)38=!A7=87?:9.!'8=!9:-4-!'4-8E9!'!,)9!)5!B-)B,-!)39%!$'46!8)<!'8=! 9:-8.!A-9',!6:'B-6!78!9:-!='4;!5,)'978?!=)<8!'!='4;!47**)8!)5!4)'=.!?:)69,>.!<79:)39! @)7(-!)4!7=-8979>%!W94--9,'AB6!(4-'9-!'8!789-4A799-89!4:>9:A!)5!,7?:9%!PEA!5'69!'8=! ()A78?!3B!*-:78=!:-4.!8)9!9:78;78?!)5!<:)!6:-!76!)4!<:-4-!6:-!76!?)78?.!*39!'*)39!A>! ,75-.!'*)39!?-9978?!:)A-%!C:-!<)A'8!93486!'8=!6--6!A-!*-:78=!:-4.!'!5,79978?!?,'8(-!!! 6:-!?,7AB6-6!'!A'8!78!'!,-'9:-4!n'(;-9.!*,'(;!B'896.!='4;!*))96%!W:-!(4)66-6!O37(;,>!9)! 9:-!)9:-4!67=-!)5!9:-!694--9%!

C:76!69'49,-6!A-%!P!4-A-A*-4!(4)6678?!9:-!694--9!<:-8!P!<'6!',)8-!'9!87?:9!'8=!'8! 38;8)<8!A'8!<'6!<',;78?!*-:78=!A-%!C:-!5--,78?6!!!694'8=6!)5!5-'4!,7?:978?!3B!A>! (:-69.!:-'49!*-?78878?!9)!B)38=!'!6,7?:9,>!5'69-4!B'(-.!9:-!*-?78878?!)5!'!97?:98-66!78! A>!9:4)'9%!J8!','4A!9:'9!<'6!6,7?:9!>-9!)A78)36.!:>B-4@7?7,'89.!)8!',-49!5)4!4'B7696!)4! A34=-4-46%!P!('8E9!6'>!9:'9!P!*,'A-!:-4%!J8=!',9:)3?:!P!38=-469'8=!<:>!6:-!A369!=)! 9:76!789-,,7?-89!'8=!6A',,!'(9!)5!6-,5k=-5-86-.!79!=)-6!A';-!6'=!9)!4-',7Z-!9:'9!9:76! '8)8>A)36!<)A'8!76!'54'7=!)5!($%!J!697,,!5--,78?!6-99,-6!78!A>!:-'49.!'!978>!'8=! 9-8=-4!B'78%!!E1*.,$(,)3,&*/2*1/4,*"%@Z*/"&*#+,$,B%$,Z*.%22);4:*/*.$,&/#%$*!*/* $/.)2#Z*2,$)/4*9)44,$Z*%$*2#$%"0P/$1,&*#+),BG!eX'F!D),5!l',-47).!C,$"C$#%&#%$0&)$" L*4$#="IA"F&0(&)!4"!)2"B&-*!4"C0!)#'&0(!%*&)"'0&("L$(!4$"%&"I!4$%!R^A-4>@7,,-.! $',75)487'H!W-',!_4-66.!/00dT.!BB%!/cik/cg%f!!!

YY%!C:-!<:79-!A'8!=)-6!8)9!38=-469'8=!9:-!P8=7'8!5)4!9:-!4-'6)8!9:'9!:-!=)-6!8)9! 38=-469'8=!JA-47('%!e$:7-5!I39:-4!W9'8=78?!]-'4.!"gYY.!O3)9-=!78!C%!$%!X(I3:'8.! C&6-,"%,$";!0%,=":"B$4'RH&0%0!*%"&'"@)2*!)";T*#%$)-$%!RK-<!L)4;H!239-4*47=?-!'8=! Q7-86954->.!"g1"T.!B%!"01%f!

! YY!

Y`%!C:-!WB'87'4=6!;8-<!'8=!38=-469))=!7447?'9-=!5'4A78?.!5)4!7447?'97)8!76!8-(-66'4>! ;<($*><$*;';<5'%<$&5'$#';<5'3?6=12<'?5=1=2*&6-.'/I6(57'b+B1&&16F28'Q&0%,"'0&("

I$T*-&="C,$"B/!)*#,RB/$!D*)G"H$&/4$"&'"%,$"U)*%$2"B%!%$#%!RK-<!L)4;H!_4'-?-4.! "gg0T.!B%!`0%f!

Yc%!P9!6--A6!9:'9!F5(+7'+6==$;':5'6;;(1:*;5)';$'_$).'V$('F5(+7'12'6',1=)'$#'2$(($%-.'4*;' 9:-4-!76!8)!6)44)<!78!U)=[!'8=!9:-4-5)4-!9:-4-!76!8)!A-4(>!76!78!+7A%!eG4)A!W9%! C:)A'6!JO378'6.!B6((!"C,$&4&G*-!f!!!

iS.'O<5'6)$?;1$='$#';<5'6*;$F$:1&5'1='0$2'@=>5&52'-')1)'=$;'+$F5'5627,>.!'6!A)9)47696! :'=!9)!57?:9!9:-!4'7,<'>6!5)4!9:-!47?:9!9)!36-!9:-!(79>!694--96%!eW()99!I%!])99,-6.!K&#" :)G$4$#"!)2"%,$":6%&(&3*4$="C,$"I!D*)G"&'"%,$"I&2$0)">*%A%!R]-4;-,->H!N87@-4679>! )5!$',75)487'!_4-66.!"gi1T.!B%!"c%f!

Y1%!C:-!U,-8=',-!eJA-47('8'!X',,f!)5N5&$?F5=;'21;2'(1><;'=5T;';$'b(.'/G67M'E6;5&Q2'-' B4)B-49>.!9:-!]-69!D-69-48!U),=-8!j->!A)9-,%!_'9-,!5--,6!9:'9!9:-!B4)F7A79>!)5!9:-! ;(62<';(6=2#5('#6+1&1;7'6+($22'#($F'<12'F$;5&'-'%1&&'<*(;'<12':*21=522'62'<12'?6;($=2'

A'>!*-!'<';-8-=!78!9:-!-'4,>!A)4878?!:)346!*>!9:-!94'6:!B7(;k3B!'(97@79>%!eaI)(',! ]3678-66!X'8!)8!J4A-87'8!Cl.a!8&64$5!02"B$)%*)$4"R^'?,-!b)(;.!$',75)487'T.! WB-(7',!^=797)8.!JB47,!1.!/00d%f!!!

Yi%!S%#,Q!C,$"#/$!D$0"*)"%,*#"/!##!G$"*#"<&4!)2!"N*)G?"%,$"$42$#%"&'"I!0%*)"K6%,$0"N*)G?" P07J#"'&60"-,*420$)7!

X>!5'9:-4!<'6!*7??-4!9:'8!,75-.!'8!-8979>!'8=!-@-4>)8-!-FB-(9-=!36.!'6!:76!)556B478?.! ;$':5'261=;5;;52-.'/C$&6=)6'P1=>8'WXXS8'd*$;5)'1='e6&5(15'].'A5&2$=8'DC$&6=)6'P1=>8'

c"[!J(94-66.!$:7,=!)5!$7@7,!b7?:96!I-'=-4.a!2*793'4>."K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!X'>!"1.! /001%f!"

iX.'O<5'b66261'6(5'-'';<5'F$2;'?*(5&7'?62;$(6&'?5$?&52'$#'@#(1+6'6=)'62'2*+<')$'=$;'

:'@-!,'<6!)8!'?47(3,934',!,'8=%!e]%!j%!2,-!j'89'7.!G)4<'4=!9)!W%!W%!2,-!W'8;'8.!C,$" I!!#!*7!RK'74)*7H!^'69!J547('8!I79-4'934-!]34-'3.!"g1"T.!B%!@777%f!!!

`0%!S%#,Q!M$!)"B(*%,"+!#"!"4&)GR%*($?"5$0A"#6--$##'64"($)J#"3!#D$%3!44"-&!-,"!%"C,$" U)*5$0#*%A"&'"Q&0%,">!0&4*)!"!%">,!/$4"F*447"C,$"!0G6($)%"*)"%,*#"/!##!G$"*#"*)"%,$"

4!#%"#$)%$)-$?"+,*-,"*#"3&42'!-$2"!)2"6)2$04*)$27!!

-/UM=5'$#';<5'<6()52;'&$2252'L'(5F5F:5('%66!78!"gig.!<:-8!<-!eC:-!N87@-4679>!)5! K)49:!$'4),78'!A-8E6!*'6;-9*',,!9-'Af!5'(-=!'!?4-'9!X7(:7?'8!9-'A!78!9:-!K$JJ! 9)348'A-89!4)38=!)5!"d!78!I-F78?9)8.!j-893(;>%!b3BB!J4-8'!<'6!57,,-=.!A)69,>!<79:! 5'86!B3,,78?!5)4!9:-!D),@-478-6%!N)(+)0/"*+/&*/44*#+,*)"(,"#)3,*)"*#+,*@%$4&Z*

)"/21'(+*/2*@,*+/&*;,/#,"*#+,1*)"*O^_`*/"&*O^__*)"*#+,*S-==*#%'$"/1,"#*

?@,,#*O]*#%*,"&*#+,)$*2,/2%"G*eQ-'8!WA79:.!78!Q-'8!WA79:!'8=!U-4',=!Q%!]-,,!<79:! &):8!j7,?).!C,$">!0&4*)!"E!A="K$!2$0#,*/"K$##&)#"'0&("!"K*'$"*)">&!-,*)G%!RK-<! L)4;H!_-8?378!]));6.!/00`T.!B%!`1%f!

! Y`!

`"%!b388>!-??!>),;6!A74'(3,)36,>!5)4A!'!47(:.!'994'(97@-!6'3(-!5)4!6','=6!'8=!B'69'%! +)<-@-4.!9:-4-!76!'!476;!)5!5))=k*)48-!7,,8-66!<79:!-??6!9:'9!'4-!8)9!:'4=!());-=.!6)! *-!A78=53,!<:-8!B4-B'478?!9:-A!5)4!9:-!>)38?.!9:-!-,=-4,>.!)4!B-)B,-!<:)!'4-! B4-?8'89!)4!<:)!:'@-!'!()AB4)A76-=!7AA38-!6>69-A%!eaJ,,!$4'(;-=!NB.a!O$!4" B*(/4$!R&'83'4>!/001T.!B%!"YY%f!!!

`/%!U7@-8!9:'9!X'99:-<!j,'A!;--B6!'!_78?k_)8?!9'*,-!78!:76!D'6:78?9)8.!Q%$%.!)557(-.! :-!<'6!9:-!B-45-(9!B-46)8!9)!()@-4!9:-!/00Y!N%W%!K'97)8',!C'*,-!C-8876! $:'AB7)86:7B6!78!I'6!l-?'6%!ea$)8947*39)46.a!9Z!RJ3?369!/00`T.!B%!``%f!!!

`Y%!S%#,Q!C,$"#/$!D$0"*)"%,*#"/!##!G$"*#"!"'*-%*&)!4"-,!0!-%$07!

C:-4-E6!4-',,>!8)9!9:'9!A3(:!=755-4-8(-!*-9<--8!A-8!'8=!<)A-8%!P8!',,!9:78?6.! 789-,,7?-8(-.!B'667)8.!:)B-.!=4-'A6.!694-8?9:.!A-8!'8=!<)A-8!'4-!B4-99>!A3(:!-O3',6%! P!A-'8.!?-8=-4!76!A)69,>!'!6)(7',!()86943(97)8%!J59-4!',,.!A',-6!'8=!5-A',-6!6:'4-! '*)39!878-9>k878-!B-4(-89!)5!9:-!6'A-!?-8-97(!A'9-47',%!W).!?7@-8!9:'9.!:)<!()3,=!<-! 4-',,>!*-!9:'9!A3(:!=755-4-89M!eW:-4A'8!J,-F7-.!aQ-'4!&):8!D'>8-.a!78!C,$"C&6G,$#%" @)2*!)"*)"%,$"E&042%!RK-<!L)4;H!J9,'897(!X)89:,>!_4-66.!/000T.!B%!/0Y%f!

``%!P!<);-!3B!69'4@78?%!W--78?!'6!P!:'@-!8)!());78?!6;7,,6.!'8=!8)!5))=!78!9:-!:)36-!)9:-4! 9:'8!B-'839!*399-4!'8=!)'9A-',.!P!<'6!=-6B-4'9-!5)4!'!B,'(-!9)!*3>!=788-4%!eaD:'9! b->;n'@r;!K--=6.a!@-$4!)2"O$5*$+_"S)4*)$.!X'>!/d.!/00d%f!

`c%!P!:'=!6B-89!6-@-4',!87?:96!9:'9!>-'4!:-,B78?!+-'9:-4!?-9!4-'=>!5)4!6)4)479>!538(97)86%!P! 69))=!*-:78=!:-4.!Z7BB78?!:-4!6:)49!*,'(;!5)4A',.!:)B78?!6:-!<)3,=8E9!9348!9)!6--!9:-! 9-'46!78!9:-!()48-46!)5!A>!->-6%!P!)59-8!<'9(:-=!:-4!<',;!'<'>!)8!9:-!'4A!)5!'!>)38?! A'8.!<)8=-478?!<:>!P!()3,=!8)9!*-!:7A%!aC:->!'4-8E9!4-'=>!5)4!'!()3B,-!,7;-!36.a! +-'9:-4!:'=!',<'>6!6'7=%!P!*-,7-@-=!:-4%!J8=!<:>!8)9.!6--78?!'6!8)!)9:-4!?'>!()3B,-6! <-4-!:-'=78?!)55!9)!6)4)479>!'55'746M!eW9-B:'87-!&%!W97,,A'8!R$),?'9-!N87@-4679>! 693=-89T.!aW769-4:))=.a!78!j7A!+)<'4=!'8=!J887-!W9-@-86.!-=6%.!S6%"!)2":3&6%" >!(/6#="H$0#&)!4":--&6)%#"3A"K$#3*!)?"9!A?"8*#$T6!4?"!)2"C0!)#G$)2$0$2">&44$G$"

B%62$)%#%!RI)6!J8?-,-6H!J,>6)8!]));6.!/000T.!BB%!Y"kY/%f!!!

`d%!L)3!()3,=!8-@-4!?-9!e$:'4,7-f!$:'B,78!9)!=76(366!'8>!)5!9:-!)9:-4!()A7(6.!=-'=!)4! ',7@-H!aP5!P!B4'76-!9:-A!PEA!(',,-=!()8=-6(-8=78?%!P5!P!6'>!9:->E4-!:)447=.!PEA!(',,-=! n-',)36%!W)!<:'9!('8!P!6'>Ma!e&'A-6!]'()8.!F&44A+&&2"@#"!"L&60"K$%%$0"C&+)%! R$:7('?)H!+-84>!b-?8-4>!$)AB'8>.!"g1dT.!B%!/1%f!!

`1%!S%#,Q!F$)0A"K6-$"+!#"%,$"/634*#,$0"&'"C7A-?"I75-"!)2"!")6(3$0"&'"&%,$0"(!G!\*)$#7"

X4%!I3(-.!'!A'8!,7;-!>)3!A369!:'@-!94)3*,-!6,--B78?!'9!87?:9%!]-('36-!>)34!n)*!76!9)! 785)4A!B-)B,-.!*39!<:'9!>)3!=)!76!A76785)4A!9:-A%!e+'44>!W%!C43A'8.!O3)9-=!78! X-4,-!X7,,-4.!H4!*)"B/$!D*)G=":)"S0!4"8*&G0!/,A"&'"F!00A"B7"C06(!)%!RK-<!L)4;H! _-8?378.!"g1`[!4-B4789-=H!K-<!L)4;H!C-66!_4-66.!/00`T.!B%!/c%f!!!

! Yc!

`i%!_-)B,-!6'7=!:-!<'6!36-,-66! C:-A!B-)B,-!',,!<-4-!5)),6! E$'36-!$34976!I)-<!<'6!9:-!578-69!B7(;-4!9)!-@-4!B,'>!9:-!*,3-6%! eJ,,-8!$),,786!'8=!b)887-!l'8h'89.!aC:-!]',,'=!)5!$34976!I)-<.a!)8!I>8>4=! W;>8>4=.!B$-&)2"F$4/*)G%!RX$J!b-()4=6.!"g1`T[!X$JQk"did%f!

`g%!S%#,Q!8&&"O!24$A"*#"!"2&G7!

]))!b'=,->!,7;-6!-@-4>)8-!'8=!-@-4>9:78?.!<:7(:!76!'A'Z78?!678(-!:-!<'6!'*'8=)8-=! 9<7(-!*-5)4-!9:-!'?-!)5!67F!A)89:6%!e&-55!W-,76.!>!%"B/$44$2"8!-D+!02#"M&$#)J%";V6!4" 9&2="H&0%0!*%#"&'"M*5*)$"M&G#%!RW'8!G4'8(76()H!$:4)87(,-!]));6.!/000T.!8%B%f!!!

c0%!$WNK!e$',75)487'!W9'9-!N87@-4679>.!K)49:47=?-f!=)4A!4-67=-896!-,7?7*,-!9)!@)9-!'9!9:-! WWN!eW'9-,,79-!W93=-89!N87)8f!A369!*-!4-?769-4-=!78!9:-!'4-'.!<:7(:!A'8>!'4-!*-('36-! 9:->!(:'8?-!9:-74!B-4A'8-89!'==4-66-6!)8(-!A)@78?!9)!9:-!=)4A6%!eb>'8!Q-8:'A.! a$WNK!9)!+)69!^,-(97)8!_),,78?!'9!WWN.a!M!*4A"B6)2*!4!R$',75)487'!W9'9-!N87@-4679>.! K)49:47=?-T.!K)@-A*-4!i.!/00c%f!

c"%!S%#,Q!C,$"!0G6($)%"*#"*)"%,*#"-!0%&&)J#"-!/%*&)7"

!

I+,*<)$2#*S,@*J"04/"&*5),*

aG)46))9:.!>)34!^F(-,,-8(>.!6:-!A369!*-!'!<79(:[!-,6-!:)<!:'9:!6:-!B39!78!9:-! ()89-896!<79:)39!*4-';78?!9:-!(4369Ma! eW%!^*-49.!aC:-!G7469!K-<!^8?,'8=!_7-.a!$'49))8.!"g0".!78!C:)A'6!$4'@-8.!-=%.! >!0%&&)!>!5!4-!2$%!RK-<!L)4;H!W7A)8!'8=!W(:369-4.!"g`YT.!B%!/1%f!

! Yd!

c/%!B<7')1)'-'[51()(5'R$1=';<5'%$F5=Q2';47*-!e=-6B79-!,)678?!:-4!<75-E6!547-8=6:7B.! ,)678?!:-4!4-,'97)86:7B6!<79:!:-4!(:7,=4-8.!'8=!5--,78?!9:'9!6:-!:'6!=7A!B4)6B-(96!5)4! 6)A-)8-!9)!6:'4-!:-4!=4-'A6!)5!,)@-fM!C:-!O3-697)8!=)-6!8)9!A';-!6-86-.!*-('36-!79! '6;6!5)4!'!B43=-897',!'86<-4!<:-8!9:-!A'99-4!76!7=-8979>%!$:)7(-!)5!'!:),7='>!78! P8=)8-67'!4'9:-4!9:'8!J3694',7'!('8!*-!-FB,'78-=!<79:!aP!,7;-!P8=)8-67'8!5))=!*-99-4a! )4!6)A-!)9:-4!'BB-',!9)!B43=-8(-.!9';78?!('4-.!?-9978?!<:'9!>)3!<'89%!L)3!'4-! B43=-89.!9:)3?:.!<79:78!'8!7=-8979>!57F-=!)8!6)A-!)9:-4!?4)38=6%!P5!>)3!'4-!Q39(:!>)3! n369!,7;-!9:-!6'8=<7(:-6!(',,-=!30&&2`$#%!J6;78?!<:>!'!B-46)8!(:'8?-6!?-8=-4!76!,7;-! '6;78?!<:>!'!B-46)8!76!'!A7=<-69-48-4!)4!9:)3?:953,!)4!?4-'9!6)3,-=H!6:-!n369!76%! eQ-74=4-!K%!X($,)6;->.!>0&##*)G=":"I$(&*0%!R$:7('?)H!N87@-4679>!)5!$:7('?)!_4-66.! "gggT.!B%!"11%f!!!

cY%!G)4!(,)6-=k(74(379!634@-7,,'8(-!('A-4'6!9)!*-!'8!-55-(97@-!=-9-44-89!9)!(47A-.!-@-4>)8-! A369!;8)<!9:'9!9:->!'4-!9:-4-%!+)<-@-4.!5)4!9:-A!9)!*-!-55-(97@-!78!6B)9978?! (47A78',6.!9:->!A369!*-!()@-49%!C:-4-5)4-.!9:->!('88)9!*-!-55-(97@-!*)9:!78!=-9-4478?! (47A-!'8=!78!6B)9978?!(47A78',6%!eG4)A!D-8=>!X%!U4)66A'8.!aP!W--;!L)3.a!B-*$)%*'*-" :($0*-!)f!!!

c`%!S%#,Q!C,$"!0G6($)%"*)"%,*#"/!##!G$"*#"3&42'!-$2"!)2"6)2$04*)$27!

J59-4!9:-!$),)A*7'8!-'49:O3';-!78!&'83'4>!"ggg.!',A)69!',,!)5!9:-!6943(934-6!9:'9!:'=! *--8!*37,9!<79:!6)A-9:78?!)9:-4!9:'8!*'A*))!!!5)4!7869'8(-.!*47(;!)4!()8(4-9-!!! (),,'B6-=%!W3*6-O3-89,>.!W7As8!lt,-Z!=-67?8-=!'!*'A*))!:)3678?!B4)9)9>B-!9:'9!<'6! 36-=!9)!6B--=7,>!4-*37,=!9:-!4-?7)8%!L,(/'2,*a;/1;%%*;%'"("#$%&%'()'**%+#%(%

2,"2);4,*/"&*/..$%.$)/#,*1/#,$)/4*B%$*(%"2#$'(#)"0*,/$#+b'/9,P2/B,*2#$'(#'$,2G! eU',-!]-9:!U),=*-4?.!8!(3&&"B%A4$%!RW',9!I';-!$79>H!U7**6!WA79:.!/00/T.!B%!d"%f!

cc.']*2;'%6=;5)';$'&5;'7$*',=$%'7$*('DZ\'B672';$'-'O6,5'46+,';<5'B5))1=>D'%62'

<)8=-453,!'8=!9-447*,-%!P9!<'6!?))=!*-('36-!79!786B74-=!A>!*)>547-8=!9)!B4)B)6-.!*39! *'=!*-('36-!)5!97B!83A*-4!)8-H!9:-!A)4-!-,'*)4'9-!9:-!B)Bk9:-kO3-697)8!436-.!9:-! 6:)49-4!9:-!A'447'?-%!Q&%"%06$%!J8=!>)3!?3>6!4378-=!79!5)4!A-V!C:'8;6%!J!694'8?-4! '6;-=!A-!'59-4!P!?)9!-8?'?-=!:)<!A>!57'8(t!B4)B)6-=.!'8=!P!6'7=!79!<'6!8)9!<)49:! 9',;78?!'*)39!'8=!9:'9!79!<'6!',,!9ZE6!5'3,9%!eJ8)8>A)36.!I-99-4!9)!9:-!^=79)4.!9Z! RJ3?369!/00`T.!B%!`d%f!!!

! Y1!

>)BB,$,"#*N,/")"02*%B*-%11%"*5$,1)2,*/"&*-%"(4'2)%"*!"#$%&'(,$2*

X)69!!!A'>*-!',,!!!)5!9:-!B4-A76-!'8=!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-46!P!:'@-!?7@-8!>)3!'4-!',6)! 36-=!<79:!A-'878?6!9:'9!:'@-!8)9:78?!'9!',,!9)!=)!<79:!'4?3A-896!'8=!9:-74!B'496%!]39! -'(:!B4-A76-!'8=!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4!P!:'@-!?7@-8!>)3!',<'>6!7894)=3(-6!'!B4-A76-!)4! '!()8(,367)8.!4-6B-(97@-,>.!<:-8!79!9-,,6!36!'8>9:78?!'9!',,!'*)39!'8!'4?3A-89!'8=!796!B'496%! G)4!-F'AB,-.!9:-!<)4=!E678(-E!6)A-97A-6!=)-6!8)9!9-,,!36!'8>9:78?!'9!',,!'*)39!'8! '4?3A-89.!*39!<:-8!79!=)-6!7894)=3(-!B'49!)5!'8!'4?3A-89!79!',<'>6!7894)=3(-6!'!B4-A76-.! 8-@-4!'!()8(,367)8%!

P!<)8E9!7,,3694'9-!9:76!78!'!()AB4-:-867@-!<'>.!*39!<7,,!n369!?7@-!>)3!'!5-<!-F'AB,-6!)5! ()AA)8!B4-A76-!'8=!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-46!36-=!78!<'>6!9:'9!:'@-!8)9:78?!9)!=)!<79:! '4?3A-896!'8=!9:-74!B'496%!

D:-8!9:-!<)4=!E678(-E!=)-6!8)9!7894)=3(-!'!B4-A76-.!79!78=7('9-6!'!B34-,>!%$(/&0!4! 4-,'97)86:7B!R'!4-,'97)86:7B!:'@78?!9)!=)!<79:!97A-T%!$)867=-4!9:76!6-89-8(-H!

Q-4@76:!:'6!,)@-=!Q7F7-!678(-!:-!57469!6'<!:-4%!

+-4-.!E678(-E!()3,=!*-!4-B,'(-=!<79:!9:-!B:4'6-!E54)A!9:-!97A-!9:'9E!*39!79!()3,=!8)9!*-! 4-B,'(-=!<79:!9:-!<)4=!E*-('36-E.!6)!78!9:76!-F'AB,-!E678(-E!78=7('9-6!'!9-AB)4',! 4-,'97)86:7B.!4'9:-4!9:'8!7894)=3(78?!'!B4-A76-%!+-4-E6!'8)9:-4!-F'AB,-!9:'9!7,,3694'9-6!9:-! 6'A-!B)789H!

C:-!,'69!97A-!(47A-6!4'9-6!78(4-'6-=!78!9:-!N879-=!W9'9-6!<'6!*-9<--8! "gdc!'8=!"g1Y%!W78(-!9:-8!?-8-4',!(47A-!94-8=6!:'@-!*--8!69'*,-!)4! =-(,78-=%!G4)A!"gg"!9)!"ggi.!@7),-89!(47A-!78!9:-!N879-=!W9'9-6!5-,,!*>!/c! B-4(-89%!eb)*78!C-AB,-9)8.!aW:-!D:)!]-,7-@-6!78!G4--=)AH!L)38?! D)A-8!Q-5>!9:-!_476)8!P8=36947',!$)AB,-F.a!78!l7@7-8!I'*'9)8!'8=! Q'<8!I38=>!X'4978.!-=6%.!C,$"L*0$"C,*#"C*($="<&6)G":-%*5*#%#"!)2"%,$" Q$+"L$(*)*#(%!RK-<!L)4;H!J8(:)4!]));6.!/00`T.!B%!/d/%f!

C:-!<)4=!E*-('36-E!6)A-97A-6!538(97)86!78!$T/4!)!%*&)#!9)!7894)=3(-!9:-!69'9-A-89!)5!'! ('36-!)4!A)97@'97)8%!L)3!('8!9:78;!)5!'4?3A-896!'8=!-FB,'8'97)86!'6!'BB4)B47'9-!'86<-46! 9)!=755-4-89!9>B-6!)5!aD:>Ma!O3-697)86%!J8!'4?3A-89!76!'8!'BB4)B47'9-!'86<-4!9)!'!aD:>! 6:)3,=!P!*-,7-@-!9:'9Ma!O3-697)8.!<:-4-'6!'8!-FB,'8'97)8!76!'8!'BB4)B47'9-!'86<-4!9)!'! aD:'9!('36-=!9:'9!9)!:'BB-8Ma!O3-697)8!)4!9)!'!aD:'9!A)97@'9-=!9:'9!*-:'@7)4Ma! O3-697)8%!+-4-!76!'!B'66'?-!78!<:7(:!E*-('36-E!7894)=3(-6!'!69'9-A-89!)5!A)97@'97)8.!8)9!'! B4-A76-H!

_),7(-!6'>!'!878-k>-'4k),=!*)>!9));!9:-!<:--,!)5!9:-!5'A7,>!('4!78! $,'74-A)89!R78!W'8!Q7-?)!$)389>T!*-('36-!9:-!5'9:-4!<'6!9))!=438;!9)! =47@-%!ea_),7(-H!K78-kL-'4k2,=!C';-6!D:--,!]-('36-!G'9:-4!C))!Q438;.a! j^Wo!R_',A!WB478?6.!$',75)487'T.!X'>!"0.!/00c%f!

! Yi!

P5!<-!<-4-!9)!94>!9)!38=-469'8=!9:76!'6!B'66'?-!'6!'8!'4?3A-89.!<-!<)3,=!438!3B!'?'7869! 9:-!B478(7B,-!)5!(:'479>!!!9:76!<)3,=!*-!'!9-447*,-!'4?3A-89%!+)<-@-4.!9:-!B'66'?-!A';-6! ?))=!6-86-!'6!'8!-FB,'8'97)8H!79!9-,,6!36!9:-!878-k>-'4k),=!*)>E6!A)97@'97)8!5)4!9';78?!9:-! <:--,!)5!9:-!5'A7,>!('4%!

+-4-!76!'8)9:-4!-F'AB,-!78!<:7(:!E*-('36-E!R8-'4!9:-!-8=!)5!9:-!6-()8=!B'4'?4'B:T! 7894)=3(-6!'!69'9-A-89!)5!A)97@'97)8!4'9:-4!9:'8!'!B4-A76-H!

-/LM='WXci8'2+6=)6&'6&F$2;')5(61&5)'-'/b6(1&7='b$=($5Q2M'(125';$'

69'4=)A%!P9!<'6!4-@-',-=!9:'9!6:-!:'=!B)6-=!83=-!5)4!'!(',-8='4!<:7,-!6:-! <'6!'!6943??,78?!69'4,-9%!

C:-!693=7)!:-'=6!'<'79-=!9:-!8'97)8',!)39(4>!)5!)394'?-!'8=!6:)(;%!]39!9:-! (4797(76A.!'A'Z78?,>.!8-@-4!('A-%!C:-4-!<'6!6)A-9:78?!'*)39!X'47,>8! X)84)-!9:'9!-@-4>)8-!4*D$2.!8)!A'99-4!<:'9%!]4'@-,>.!6:-!:-,=!'!B4-66! ()85-4-8(-!9)!5'(-!*-,,7?-4-89!4-B)49-46%!D:>!:'=!6:-!B)6-=!8';-=M! X)84)-!'86<-4-=!67AB,>.!a]-('36-!P!8--=-=!9:-!A)8->%a!

28-!)394'?-=!5-A',-!4-B)49-4!'BB'4-89,>!()3,=8E9!*-,7-@-!9:'9!X)84)-!:'=! 4-',,>!*--8!()AB,-9-,>!83=-%!aQ7=8E9!>)3!:'@-!!)A%,*)G!)8!'9!',,!<:-8!>)3! B)6-=Ma!6:-!'6;-=%!

a28,>!9:-!4'=7).a!X)84)-!6'7=.!6A7,78?.!'8=!<)8!-@-4>)8-E6!:-'496! 5)4-@-4%!eC:)A'6!C%!K)?3(:7!<79:!&)6-B:!Q7X)8'.!>&0&)$0%!RK-<!L)4;H! _)(;-9!]));6.!"giYT.!BB%!dYkd`%f!

+-4-!X'47,>8!X)84)-!<'6!9',;78?!9)!4-B)49-46!<:)!',4-'=>!;8-<!9:'9!6:-!:'=!B)6-=! 8';-=.!6)!6:-!<'68E9!94>78?!9)!?7@-!'!4-'6)8!9)!*-,7-@-!9:'9!6:-!:'=!=)8-!6)%!P869-'=.!6:-! <'6!9-,,78?!9:-A!:-4!A)97@'97)8%!

I-9E6!()867=-4!9:-!5),,)<78?!-F'AB,-H!

-/[M162?$(6='@(F5=16=2'&1N5'$*;21)5'@(F5=16':5+6*25';<5'>5=$+1)5';$$,'

B,'(-.!'8=!9:->!<-4-!)*,7?-=!9)!,-'@-!9:-!()3894>%!C)='>.!9:->!('8E9!?)! *'(;!*-('36-!9:-!C34;76:!?)@-48A-89!:'6!'!(),)87',.!-FB,)79'97@-.! (:'3@78769.!'8=!?-8378-,>!5'6(769!8'934-%!eX)89-!X-,;)87'8.!O3)9-=!78! X'4;'4!X-,;)87'8!<79:!W-9'!X-,;)87'8.!IA"80&%,$0J#"O&!2=":)" :($0*-!)J#"L!%$'64"P&60)$A"%&":0($)*!%!RI)8=)8SK-<!L)4;H!P%!]%!C'3476.! /00cT.!BB%!Ygk`0%f!

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

! Yg!

C:-!<)4=!E*-('36-E!76!8)9!9:-!)8,>!B4-A76-!7894)=3(-4!9:'9!6)A-97A-6!<)4;6!78!'8! -FB,'8'97)8!9)!7894)=3(-!'!69'9-A-89!)5!('36-!)4!A)97@'97)8%!+-4-!76!'8!-F'AB,-!78!<:7(:! E'6E!7894)=3(-6!'!69'9-A-89!)5!A)97@'97)8!7869-'=!)5!'!B4-A76-H!

-]$<='45&&6<8'6'+$?'6;'I6&'3;6;5'0$=>'456+<8'(5+6&&5)';<5';1F5'<5'?*&&5)'

)@-4!'!<)A'8!<:)!:'=!438!9:4)3?:!'!69)B!67?8!78!'!B7(;3B%!

a+-4!-F(36-.a!]-,,':!6'7=.!a<'6!9:'9!6:-!:'=!*)44)<-=!9:-!943(;.!<:7(:! <6)'6'F6=*6&';(6=2F1221$=-.'@=7%678'62'2<5'+$*&)=Q;')(1N5'6'2;1+,'2<1#;8'

6:-!=7=8E9!*)9:-4!<79:!69)BB78?!'9!69)B!67?86%a!eW9-@-!+'4@->.!a28,>!78! I%J%.a!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!X'4(:!/0.!/001%f!

])9:!9:-!=47@-4!'8=!2557(-4!]-,,':!;8)<!9:'9!9:-!=47@-4!4'8!9:-!69)B!67?8!!!'8=.!634-,>.! 9:76!=47@-4!<)3,=8E9!*-!94>78?!9)!?7@-!9:-!)557(-4!'!4-'6)8!9)!*-,7-@-!9:'9!6:-!4'8!9:-!69)B! 67?8V!W).!<-!('88)9!B,'367*,>!38=-469'8=!9:-!69'9-A-89!7894)=3(-=!*>!E'6E!'6!7894)=3(78?!'! B4-A76-.!*39!<-!('8!38=-469'8=!79!'6!7894)=3(78?!9:-!=47@-4E6!A)97@'97)8!5)4!5'7,78?!9)!69)B! '9!9:-!69)B!67?8%!

W)A-97A-6.!9:-!6'A-!B'66'?-!76!*)9:!'8!'4?3A-89!'8=!'8!-FB,'8'97)8[!9:-!=76978(97)8! *-9<--8!!0G6($)%!'8=!$T/4!)!%*&)!76!8)9!A393',,>!-F(,367@-%!+-4-!76!'8!-F'AB,-!9)! 7,,3694'9-!9:76H!

U74,6!<:)!'99-8=!-,-A-89'4>!6(:)),6!<79:!'!694)8?!6(7-8(-!(3447(3,'!e#*-f! '4-!A)4-!,7;-,>!9)!-89-4!'!6(7-89757(!57-,=!*-('36-!9:->!4-()?87Z-!',,!9:-! -F(7978?!)BB)4938797-6!9:'9!6(7-8(-!('8!)55-4%!eaD:-4-!J4-!9:-!D)A-8M.a! C$#%"a"I$!#60$($)%"E&042"S)4*)$"E$3\*)$!RX'66'(:36-996T.! :99BHSS<<<%4--=k-,-(94)87(6%()AS9A<)4,=S'497(,-S$JdYd1YYc%:9A,.! W-B9-A*-4!".!/00d.!'((-66-=!W-B9-A*-4!/.!/00d%f!

C:76!B'66'?-!-FB,'786!<:>!?74,6!<:)!'99-8=!-,-A-89'4>!6(:)),6!<79:!694)8?!6(7-8(-! (3447(3,'!'4-!A)4-!,7;-,>!9)!-89-4!'!6(7-89757(!57-,=H!9:->!4-()?87Z-!',,!9:-!-F(7978?! )BB)4938797-6!9:'9!6(7-8(-!('8!)55-4%!]39.!<-!('8!',6)!38=-469'8=!9:76!B'66'?-!'6!?7@78?!'! 4-'6)8!9)!*-,7-@-!9:'9!?74,6!<:)!'99-8=!-,-A-89'4>!6(:)),6!<79:!'!694)8?!6(7-8(-! (3447(3,3A!'4-!A)4-!,7;-,>!9)!-89-4!'!6(7-89757(!57-,=.!6)!<-!('8!',6)!38=-469'8=!79!'6!'8! '4?3A-89.!9:78;78?!)5!79!'6!5),,)<6H!

D:>!6:)3,=!<-!*-,7-@-!9:'9!?74,6!<:)!'99-8=!-,-A-89'4>!6(:)),6!<79:!'! 694)8?!6(7-8(-!(3447(3,3A!'4-!A)4-!,7;-,>!9)!-89-4!'!6(7-89757(!57-,=M! ]-('36-!9:->!4-()?87Z-!',,!9:-!-F(7978?!)BB)4938797-6!9:'9!6(7-8(-!('8! )55-4%!

! `0!

+-4-!76!'8)9:-4!-F'AB,-!78!<:7(:!9:-!<)4=!E*-('36-E!('8!*-!38=-469))=!'6!67A3,9'8-)36,>! 7894)=3(78?!'!B4-A76-!'8=!7894)=3(78?!'!69'9-A-89!)5!('36-!)4!A)97@'97)8H!

P!63*94'(9!9:-!='9-6!3678?!B-8(7,!'8=!B'B-4! *-('36-!79E6!)8-!9';-!'<'>!-7?:9.! -7?:9!9';-!'<'>!57@-!'8=!9:-!(',(3,'97)8! 78@),@-6!*)44)<78?%!PEA!9))!974-=! 9)!=)!9:76!A-89',,>!9)87?:9!'8=!-@-8!A)4-.! P!('8E9!*-,7-@-!6:-!<'6!)8,>!9<-89>k9<)%! e^,)76-!j,-78!+-',>.!aC:-!W37(7=-E6!K3A*-46.a!78!H!##*)G%!RI)6!J8?-,-6H!b-=! +-8!_4-66.!/00/T.!B%!Y"%f!

P8!9:-6-!57469!67F!,78-6!54)A!^,)76-!j,-78!+-',>E6!B)-A!aC:-!W37(7=-E6!K3A*-46.a!9:-! 69'9-A-896!'59-4!E*-('36-E!9-,,!36!<:'9!,-=.!)4!A)97@'9-=.!:-4!9)!63*94'(9!9:-!='9-6!!!9:-! *749:!'8=!=-'9:!='9-6!)5!9:-!<)A'8!<:)!()AA799-=!637(7=-!!!3678?!B-8(7,!'8=!B'B-4.! 7869-'=!)5!=)78?!79!78!:-4!:-'=%!W).!9:-6-!,78-6!()89'78!'8!-FB,'8'97)8%!]39!9:-!@-4>!6'A-! 69'9-A-896!('8!',6)!*-!38=-469))=!'6!4-'6)86!9)!*-,7-@-!9:'9!6:-!36-=!B-8(7,!'8=!B'B-4!9)! =)!9:-!63*94'(97)8!B4)*,-A!7869-'=!)5!=)78?!79!78!:-4!:-'=%!W)!9:76!B'66'?-!538(97)86! 67A3,9'8-)36,>!'6!'8!-FB,'8'97)8!'8=!'6!'8!'4?3A-89%!

C:-!<)4=!E6)E!6)A-97A-6!538(97)86!'6!'!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4[!79!8-@-4!7894)=3(-6!'! B4-A76-%!]39!79!:'6!(!)A!)9:-4!A-'878?6!9))[!78!5'(9.!9:-!"g1"!38'*47=?-=!E$3#%$0J#" C,*02"Q$+"E&042"M*-%*&)!0A!?7@-6!-7?:9--8!)9:-4!=-578797)86!)5!E6)E%!+-4-!'4-!9<)! -F'AB,-6!78!<:7(:!E6)E!=)-6!8)9!7894)=3(-!'!()8(,367)8H!

J!?4)<78?!83A*-4!)5!JA-47('8!A-=7(',!693=-896!4-536-!9)!'((-B9!B-46)8',! ?7596!54)A!9:-!B:'4A'(-397(',!78=3694>!)8!9:-!B4-A76-!9:'9!79!<)3,=!*-! 38-9:7(',!9)!=)!6)%!eaU7596!54)A!9:-!_:'4A'(-397(',!P8=3694>!!!C)!J((-B9! )4!K)9!9)!J((-B9.a!^34)B-'8!_3*,7(!+-',9:!J,,7'8(-!R]-,?73AT.!&'83'4>! //.!/00d%f!

P8!9:76!B'66'?-.!E6)E!A-'86!E9:76EH!E6)E!4-5-46!*'(;!9)!9:-!B:4'6-!E'((-B9!B-46)8',!?7596!54)A! 9:-!B:'4A'(-397(',!78=3694>E%!C:-!<)4=!E6)E!<)4;6!'6!'!B4)8)38!:-4-!'8=!76!36-=!9)!'@)7=! 4-B-9797)8%!

+-4-!76!'!B'66'?-!<79:!'!=755-4-89!36-!)5!E6)EH!

L)3!:'@-!9)!*-!'!6B--=>!4-'=-4! E('36-!9:-4-E6!6).!6)!A3(:!9)!4-'=V! eQ4%!W-366.!@">!)"O$!2"+*%,"IA";A$#"B,6%b!RK-<!L)4;H!b'8=)A!+)36-.! "g1iT.!B%!"0%f!

+-4-.!E6)E!A-'86!9:-!6'A-!9:78?!'6!9:-!<)4=!E@-4>EH!%&"!"G0$!%"$T%$)%%!

! `"!

+-4-!76!'!B'66'?-!<79:!'!=755-4-89!36-!)5!E6)E.!'6!<-,,!'6!'!36-!)5!E'6E!9:'9!:'6!8)9:78?!9)!=)! <79:!'4?3A-896H!

&369!'6!-@-4>!978>!&'B'8-6-!B)-A!!!,!*D6!!!()89'786!'!4-5-4-8(-!9)!9:-! 6-'6)8.!6)!9))!78!9:-!B,'8878?!'8=!B4-6-89'97)8!)5!'!&'B'8-6-!A-',! '<'4-8-66!)5!9:-!6-'6)8!76!',,!7AB)49'89%!eI-6,->!Q)<8-4!'8=!X78)43! L)8-='.!B%$/"3A"B%$/"P!/!)$#$">&&D*)G%!RD))=*34>.!K-<!L)4;H! ]'44)8E6.!"gidT.!B%!`d%f!

P8!9:76!B'66'?-!*)9:!E'6E!'8=!E6)E!'4-!36-=!()AB'4'97@-,>[!9:'9!76.!9:->!'4-!36-=!9)!:'7;3! <79:!&'B'8-6-!A-',6%!

! `/!

A CHALLENGING PROBLEM

C,$"-,!44$)G$"*#"'&0"A&6"%&"'*)2"%,0$$"-&)-46#*&)#"*)"%,*#"'*-%*&)!4"

/!##!G$"!)2?"'&0"$!-,"-&)-46#*&)?"'&44&+"%,$"*)#%06-%*&)#"'&0"H0!-%*-$"

H0&34$(#"B$%"[Rc7"

C:->!'447@-=!78!9:-!6-(4-(>!)5!87?:9.!'6!=76B,'(-=!B-)B,-!)59-8!=).! 69)BB78?!)@-4!5)4!'!<--;.!'!A)89:.!-@-893',,>!69'>78?!'!,75-97A-%!C:-! B,'8!<'6!67AB,-%!X)9:-4!<)3,=!<)4;!9))!3897,!9:->!6'@-=!-8)3?:!9)! A)@-!789)!'!578-4!53934-!<:-4-!9:-!9)7,-9!<'6!)8-E6!)<8!'8=!9:-! (:7,=4-8!8--=8E9!*-!547?:9-8-=%!P8!9:-!A-'897A-.!9:->!B,'>-=!78!9:-! *'(;!',,7-6.!'A)8?!9:-!*4);-8!?,'66.!<76-!9)!9:-!<'>6!)5!9:-!694--9%! b3,-!)8-H!8-@-4!9',;!9)!694'8?-46.!8)9!-@-8!9:-!8-7?:*)4!<:)!B'(-=!3B! '8=!=)<8!9:-!:',,<'>6!9',;78?!9)!:7A6-,5%!b3,-!9<)H!9:-!B),7(-.!)4! aB),7-a!'6!W)8>'E6!B)B7!B4)8)38(-=!9:-!<)4=.!<'6!I'!X7?4'!78! =76?376-!'8=!9:36!6:)3,=!',<'>6!*-!'@)7=-=%!b3,-!9:4--H!;--B!>)34! ;->!<79:!>)3!'9!',,!9:-!97A-6!!!9:-!5)34!<',,6!)5!9:-!'B'49A-89!<-4-! 9:-!)8,>!B4)9-(97)8!'?'7869!9:-!694--96!3897,!_)B7!4-9348-=!:)A-%!

W)8>'!()867=-4-=!:-4!;->!'!?3'4=7'8!6'789!'8=!6:-!<)4-!79!'4)38=!:-4! 8-+,'62'2*+<-.!

e+-,-8'!X'47'!l74'A)89-6.!aC:-!$'47*))!$'5-.a!78!C,$"I&%,#"!)2" S%,$0"B%&0*$#%!R+)369)8H!J49-!_3*,7()!_4-66.!"gicT.!B%!d"%f! !

!

! `Y!

!!

!

P8!9:76!B'66'?-!*)9:!E'6E!'8=!E6)E!'4-!36-=!9)!()AB'4-!:'7;3!'8=!&'B'8-6-!A-',6%!

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

A CHALLENGING PROBLEM

@)"%,*#"/&$(?"%,$"+&02"J#&J"*#"6#$2"'&60"%*($#?"36%"*%"*)%0&26-$#"!"-&)-46#*&)"&)4A"

&)-$7"C,$"-,!44$)G$"*#"'&0"A&6"%&"'*G60$"&6%"+,*-,"6#$"&'"J#&J"*)%0&26-$#"!"

-&)-46#*&)?"!)2?"'&0"%,$"&%,$0"%,0$$"6#$#"&'"J#&J?"%&"#!A",&+"*%"*#"3$*)G"6#$27".@'"

A&6J0$",!5*)G"!",!02"%*($"#!A*)G",&+"J#&J"*#"6#$2"+,$)"*%"*#)J%"'6)-%*&)*)G"!#"!"

-&)-46#*&)"*)%0&26-$0?"A&6"(*G,%"4&&D"6/"J#&J"*)"!"2*-%*&)!0A71!

+76!+)36-!78!WB'78!

+-!'6;-=!A-.!69)BB78?!)@-4!<:'9-@-4! +-E6!*--8!B36:78?!',,!9:-6-!>-'46.!75!P! j8-<!<:-4-!WB'78!<'6%!W)!P!6-'4(:-=!9:-!=4>! _,'(-6!)5!A>!A78=H!9:-!W':'4'!Q-6-49.! Q-'9:!l',,->.!9:-!+'@'8'!9:->!:'=!('447-=! ]'(;!:-4-!9)!X7'A7%!P!<'6!9<-,@-.!6)!A>!A'B6! D-4-!6A',,%!X>!A)9:-4!<'6!*-8-'9:!'!5'8.! P8!9:-!8'B!6:-!*4)3?:9!54)A!K-<!&-46->! C)!B4)9-(9!:-46-,5%!+-E=!*4)3?:9!A-!9)!9:-!94--! C:'9!:-!6'7=!,));-=!,7;-!WB'78%!W)A-!4'4-!*74=! $,38?!9)!'!*4'8(:.!,7;-!79!<'6!-@-4>!('4-! P8!9:-!<)4,=%!C:-!*74=!('<-=%!+-!,));-=!'9!A-%! P!=)8E9!4-A-A*-4!<:'9!P!6'7=.!)4!P!6'7=! aP!=)8E9!4-A-A*-4.!U4'8=B'%a!+76!578?-4! _);-=!A>!(:-69!6)!:'4=.!6)!A3(:!694)8?-4! C:'8!A>!*)8-.!79!,-59!9:76!A'4;H!aP8!:-4-.a!:-!6'7=%!

eb'5'-,!$'AB).!a+76!+)36-!78!WB'78.a!78!C,$"S%,$0"I!)"E!#"I$=":"Y&A!G$"%&"

%,$"Q$+"E&042%!R+)36)8H!J49-!_u*,7()!_4-66.!"gg`T.!B%!Yi%f!

! ``!

=$0'1,"#2*/;%'#*?';c,(#)3,*!22',2*

_4-A76-6"'8=!()8(,367)86!('8!*-!'*)39!A)4-!)4!,-66!63*n-(97@-!7663-6%!W)A-)8-!A7?:9! 4-'6)8!'6!5),,)<6H!!

L)3!6:)3,=8E9!)4=-4!'8(:)@7-6!)8!9:-!B7ZZ'!*-('36-!9:->!9'69-!9-447*,-%!

C:-!69'9-A-89!9:'9!'8(:)@7-6!9'69-!9-447*,-!76!'*)39!'!63*n-(97@-!7663-.!*39!:-4-!79!76! 789-8=-=!'6!'!4-'6)8!9)!*-,7-@-!9:-!()8(,367)8%!C:76!76!'8!-F94-A-!-F'AB,-.!*-('36-! <:-9:-4!'8(:)@7-6!9'69-!?))=!)4!*'=!!!>3AA>!)4!>3(;>!!!76!'8!-F94-A-,>!63*n-(97@-! A'99-4H!79E6!n369!'!A'99-4!)5!B-46)8',!9'69-!)4!B4-5-4-8(-%!29:-4!7663-6!A7?:9!*-!A)4-!)4! ,-66!63*n-(97@-[!5)4!-F'AB,-H!

j'%<5;<5('$('=$;'5F:(7$=1+'2;5F'+5&&'(5256(+<'12'F$(6&&7'6++5?;6:&5k! j'%<5;<5('$('=$;'%5'2<$*&)'<6N5';<5')56;<'?5=6&;7k! j'%<5;<5('$('=$;';<5'N%!W%!78@'67)8!)5!P4'O!<'6!n369757-=[! j'%<5;<5('$('=$;'IAA'<62'6'&1:5(6&':162k! j'%<5;<5('$('=$;'+$&&5>5';56+<5(2'2<$*&)'(5d*1(5'6;;5=)6=+5k! j'%<6;'F6,52'6'F6='6'F6=8'%<6;'F6,52'6'%$F6='6'%$F6=k'6=)8! j'%<1+<'+$=;5F?$(6(7'g.3.'?$5;'12';<5':52;.!

$-49'78,>!B-)B,-!('8!'8=!=)!?7@-!4-'6)86!5)4!9:-74!@7-<6!)8!9:-6-!'8=!67A7,'4!;78=6!)5! 7663-6%!D:-9:-4!)4!8)9!'!69'9-A-89!76!'*)39!'!63*n-(97@-!7663-!76!*00$4$5!)%!9)!<:-9:-4!)4! 8)9!9:'9!69'9-A-89!76!B'49!)5!'8!'4?3A-89%!

=$0'1,"#2*/;%'#*-%"#$%3,$2)/4*!22',2*

D:-9:-4!'!69'9-A-89!76!()894)@-467',!)4!=-*'9'*,-!R)4!a'4?3'*,-aT!76!*00$4$5!)%!9)!<:-9:-4! )4!8)9!'8!'4?3A-89!76!B4-6-89%!$-49'78,>!'9!,-'69!6)A-!)5!9:-!7663-6!,769-=!'*)@-!'4-! ()894)@-467',[!'8>!69'9-A-89!A'=-!'*)39!9:-A!76!63*n-(9!9)!=76'?4--A-89%!]39!69'9-A-896! '*)39!'8>!)5!9:-A!()3,=!*-!B4-A76-6!)4!()8(,367)86%!

=$0'1,"#*32G*5,$2'/2)%"*

P9E6!7AB)49'89!8)9!9)!()8536-!9:-!()8(-B9!)5!!0G6($)%!<79:!/$0#6!#*&)%!X'8>!'4?3A-896! '4-!'99-AB96!9)!B-463'=-.!*39!9:-!9<)!()8(-B96!'4-!=755-4-89!5)4!9<)!4-'6)86H!R"T!8)9!',,! '99-AB96!9)!B-463'=-!'4-!'4?3A-896[!'8=.!R/T!8)9!',,!'4?3A-896!'4-!'99-AB96!9)!B-463'=-%!

b-A-A*-4!9:'9!'8!'4?3A-89!76!'!6-9!)5!69'9-A-896!78!<:7(:!6)A-!R9:-!B4-A76-!)4! B4-A76-6T!'4-!789-8=-=!'6!4-'6)86!9)!*-,7-@-!'8)9:-4!R9:-!()8(,367)8T%!W)A-97A-6.!<:-8! )9:-46!94>!9)!B-463'=-!36.!9:->!36-!'4?3A-896%!]39!8)9!',<'>6H!9:4-'96.!'BB-',6!9)!)34! 6>AB'9:>.!6-F!'BB-',.!'8=!@'47)36!)9:-4!'BB-',6!9)!)34!-A)97)86!'4-!',6)!36-=!9)!94>!9)! B-463'=-%!J=@-4976-A-896!'4-!'99-AB96!9)!B-463'=-.!*39!8)9!A'8>!'=6!()89'78!'4?3A-896%!

C:-4-!76!)@-4,'B!*-9<--8!'4?3A-89!'8=!B-463'67)8.!*-('36-!6)A-!'99-AB96!9)!B-463'=-! '4-!'4?3A-896!'8=!*-('36-!A)69!'4?3A-896!'4-!'99-AB96!9)!B-463'=-!-79:-4!)9:-46!)4! )8-6-,5!9:'9!9:-!'4?3A-896E!()8(,367)86!'4-!943-%!+)<!()3,=!'8!'4?3A-89!8)9!*-!'8! '99-AB9!9)!B-463'=-M!C:76!=)-68E9!:'BB-8!)59-8.!*39!79!=)-6!:'BB-8!)(('67)8',,>%!+-4-E6!

! `c!

'8!-F'AB,-%!PA'?78-!'!?4)3B!)5!$:47697'8!(:34(:!6(:)),!693=-896%!J9!,-'69!6)A-!)5!9:-A.! ,-9E6!6'>.!*-,7-@-!9:'9!U)=!-F7696!'8=!9:-74!*-,7-5!76!*'6-=!)8!5'79:%!C:-6-!693=-896!8--=!8)! B-463'67)8!9)!*-,7-@-!78!U)=E6!-F769-8(-.!5)4!9:->!',4-'=>!*-,7-@-!9:'9!U)=!-F7696%!W97,,.! )8-!)5!9:-74!9-'(:-46!A7?:9!B4-6-89!9:-A!<79:!'4?3A-896!9)!B4)@-!9:'9!U)=!-F7696%!RW)A-! )5!>)3!'4-!B4)*'*,>!5'A7,7'4!<79:!6)A-!)5!9:-!5'A)36!'4?3A-896!5)4!'8=!'?'7869!U)=E6! -F769-8(-%T!P8!9:'9!6793'97)8.!9:-!'4?3A-896!B4-6-89-=!*>!9:-!9-'(:-4!<)3,=!8)9!()389!'6! '99-AB96!9)!B-463'=-.!*39!<)3,=!697,,!()389!'6!'4?3A-896%!]39.!'6!P!6'7=!',4-'=>.!9:76!76! 38363',[!9>B7(',,>.!'8!'4?3A-89!76!'8!'99-AB9!9)!B-463'=-!)9:-46!)4!)8-6-,5!9:'9!9:-! '4?3A-89E6!()8(,367)8!76!943-%!

! `d!

5H=-I!-J*5HKLMJN?*?JI*OP`Q*

=HTRNJSI*KH*SKSP=HTRNJSI=I!dJ*5JH?R=?!KS7*

P86943(97)86H!C,$0$"!0$"%$)"/!##!G$#?"!44"20!+)"'0&("!25$0%*#*)G"-&/A?"*)"%,*#"/0!-%*-$" /0&34$(#"#$%7"L*5$"&'"%,$("-&)%!*)"!0G6($)%#"!)2"'*5$"2&")&%7"M$%$0(*)$"+,*-,"!0$"

+,*-,7"!')*&")+,"&+-'+.!')*&")+(/+0&1&2(&3+4",2(-2&+4"/51&%)+6/"+78,9(&"+:'&;.!

"%!$22I!PW!+PWC2bL!b^_^JCPKU!PCW^IG! b-B-'9!'59-4!36H!+-4-E6!9:-!8-<-69.!'8=!<-!A-'8!8-<-69.!@-467)86!)5!9:-!j-=6! $:'AB7)8%!C:-!$:'9:'A!,'(-k3BH!<:-4-!?,'A)34!A--96!:-479'?-!'8=!9-8876!()A-6!)39! 9)!B,'>%!^@-4>9:78?!9:'9!<'6!:)9!78!9:-!"g/06!!!'8=!()A-!)8.!<:'9!<'68E9M!!! ?)4?-)36,>!'8=!744-@-4-89,>!4-78@-89-=%!C:-!$:'9:'A!,'(-k*?'-'>$'$=8'F6,5'<12;$(7.! <<<%;-=6%()ASA76(:'*'49)8! j-=6! :5'+$$&.l! ej-=6.!J=@-4976-A-89.!K6-DA!RX'4(:!/001T.!B%!/1%f!

/%!aIPG^!DPC+2NC!_JWWP2K!PW!NKG2bUPlJ]I^a!!!W-'8!&):8! NKG2bUPlJ]I^! C+^!K^D!GbJUJK$^!G2b!X^K!Gb2X!W^JK!&2+K! eN85)4?7@'*,-.!J=@-4976-A-89.!9Z!RX'>!/001T.!BB%!d"kd/%f!

Y%!+)47Z)8!24?'87(v!X7,;!76!B4)=3(-=!<79:)39!9:-!36-!)5!'897*7)97(6.!'==-=!?4)<9:! :)4A)8-6!)4!='8?-4)36!B-697(7=-6%!C:'9E6!<:>!+)47Z'8!24?'87(!A7,;!76!'6!<:),-6)A-! '6!79!?-96%!e+)47Z)8!24?'87(.!J=@-4976-A-89.!8$%%$0"F&($#"!)2"9!02$)#!RK)@-A*-4! /00`T%f!

`%!L)3!=)!:'@-!4-89-46!78634'8(-.!47?:9M!L)3!6:)3,=%!]-('36-!>)34!,'8=,)4=E6!B),7(>!)8,>! ()@-46!>)34!*37,=78?.!8)9!>)34!69355%!J!4-89-46!B),7(>!54)A!W9'9-!G'4Av!A';-6!79!-'6>! 9)!4-B,'(-!>)34!69355!75!*'=!9:78?6!:'BB-8!!!,7;-!574-.!9:-59.!)4!@'8=',76A%!G)4!'*)39!9:-! ()69!)5!'!QlQ!'!A)89:%!eW9'9-!G'4A.!J=@-4976-A-89.!9Z!RW-B9-A*-4!/00dT.!B%!"gd%f!

c%!C:-4-E6!8-@-4!*--8!'!*-99-4!97A-!9)!94>!JA*7-8!*-('36-!8)<!>)3!('8!94>!JA*7-8!54--%! eJA*7-8!J=@-4976-A-89.!$KK.!&3,>!1.!/00c%f!

d%!Gb^^!_4-?8'8(>!C-696! D)A-8E6.!_-=7'947(.! L)39:!W-4@7(-6!'8=! Gb^^! _4-?8'8(>!C-696%! $',,!Y/Ykd``kYiii!)4!<',;!78%! J67'8!_'(757(!+-',9:!$'4-!l-8934-.!P8(%! "cY0!+7,,:3469!J@-83-.!W379-!/00! I)6!J8?-,-6.!$J!g00/1! <<<%'B:(@%)4?! eJ67'8!_'(757(!+-',9:!$'4-!l-8934-.!P8(%.!J=@-4976-A-89.!K&#":)G$4$#"Y!44$A"8$!%! cH/0!RX'>!"0k"d.!/001T.!B%!""%f!

! `1!

1%!P!U2!]2C+!DJLW! WCbJPU+C!N_!2b!2K!C+^!b2$jW! !!Wl^QjJ\UPbI!! eW@-=;'!l)=;'.!J=@-4976-A-89.!9Z!RX'>!/001T.!B%!"Yi%f!

i%!C+^!l2QjJ!_^bG^$C!G2b!$+PIIPKU%!$:7,,6!5'69%!W9'>6!(),=%!eQ'8Z'! $4'8*-4>4'Z!l)=;'.!J=@-4976-A-89.!P!)$!iHg!RK)@-A*-4!/00`T.!B%!`g%f!

g%!*'4-!X78-4',6!,)@-6! >)34!6;78%!L)3!,)@-! *'4-!X78-4',6%!D:'9!'! ,)@-5-69%! +3?6! I-6,7-!F)F! I-6,7-!],)=?-99! $^2!]'4-!^6(-893',6! ]Jb^!^W$^KCNJIWv! A';-3B!6)!B34-!>)3!('8!6,--B!78!79v! e]'4-!^6(-893',6.!J=@-4976-A-89.!B$4'!RX'4(:!/001T.!B%!"``%f!

"0%!J!$2II^U^!Q^Ub^^!PW!Ub^JC%! ]^PKU!J]I^!C2!_JL!G2b!PC!PW!^l^K!]^CC^b%! U)78?!5)4!>)34!=-?4--M!C:-!J4A>!K'97)8',!U3'4=!('8!:-,B!>)3!?-9!9:-4-%!J6!'! A-A*-4!)5!9:-!-,79-!5)4(-6!6-4@78?!>)34!()3894>.!>)3!('8!4-(-7@-!A)8->!9)!B'>!5)4! (),,-?-!9:4)3?:!9:-!X)89?)A-4>!UP!]7,,!'8=!C3797)8!J66769'8(-%!&)78!'!9-'A!9:'9E,,! :-,B!>)3!9:4)3?:!6(:)),!!!78!9:-!J4A>!K'97)8',!U3'4=%!<SU">:Q%! "ki00kU2k_g@G['j'%%%.Wki00kU2kUNJbQ%()A! eJ4A>!K'97)8',!U3'4=.!J=@-4976-A-89.!B$5$)%$$)!R&3,>!/00cT.!B%!YY%f!

! `i!

5H=-I!-J*5HKLMJN?*?JI*OP_Q*

!?*=S*=HTRNJSI*5HJ?JSI7*

P86943(97)86H!C,$0$"!0$"%$)"/!##!G$#"*)"%,*#"/0!-%*-$"/0&34$(#"#$%7"L*5$"&'"%,$("-&)%!*)" !0G6($)%#"!)2"'*5$"2&")&%7"M$%$0(*)$"+,*-,"!0$"+,*-,7"!

"%!U=5'>1(&Q2'6(;'12'6=$;<5('>1(&Q2';(62<-.'e$'8=>-!j'8-.!I78-4!K)9-6.!E,*%$"C0!#,"9*04%! RI78=-<-44'.!U-4A'8>H!b35!b-()4=6.!"00c[!bNG!"0i`%f!

/%!D-!8--=!9:-!=-'9:!B-8',9>!*-('36-!-@7,!-F7696%!eQ7'88-!$,-A-896.!:-'=!)5!&3697(-!5)4! J,,.!'!C-F'6k*'6-=!(47A-!@7(97A6E!47?:96!?4)3B.!O3)9-=!78!l78(-!]-76-4.!al-8?-'8(-!P6! X)AE6.a!I&%,$0"P&)$#"Y"H/!RX'4(:!w!JB47,!/00dT.!B%!"1%f!

Y%!P9E6!87(-!9)!:'@-!'!,799,-!*4-';5'69!A'=-!5)4!>)3%!eJ8=>!D'4:),.!O3)9-=!78!J8=>! D'4:),.!<6(?"<6(?"<6(.!()AB7,-=!*>!b%!W-9:!]47?:9%!R])69)8H!]3,578(:!_4-66.!"ggdT.! 8%B%f!

`%!P!4-',,>!6B)7,!A>6-,5!78!9:-!5))=!'4-'.!6)!A>!,-59)@-46!'4-!)59-8!?4'8=%!eJ8=>!D'4:),.! O3)9-=!78!J8=>!D'4:),.!<6(?"<6(?"<6(.!()AB7,-=!*>!b%!W-9:!]47?:9%!R])69)8H! ]3,578(:!_4-66.!"ggdT.!8%B%f!

c%!PEA!)8,>!;7==78?!A>6-,5!<:-8!P!?)!9:4)3?:!9:-!A)97)86!)5!());78?!B4)9-78H!',,!P!-@-4! <'89!76!63?'4%!eJ8=>!D'4:),.!O3)9-=!78!J8=>!D'4:),.!<6(?"<6(?"<6(.!()AB7,-=!*>! b%!W-9:!]47?:9%!R])69)8H!]3,578(:!_4-66.!"ggdT.!8%B%f!

d%!P5!9:-4-E6!?7'89!694'<*-447-6.!PE,,!n369!69'8=!9:-4-!'8=!-'9!)8-!'59-4!9:-!)9:-4%!eJ8=>! D'4:),.!O3)9-=!78!J8=>!D'4:),.!<6(?"<6(?"<6(.!()AB7,-=!*>!b%!W-9:!]47?:9%! R])69)8H!]3,578(:!_4-66.!"ggdT.!8%B%f!

1%!WA',,k!9)!A-=73Ak67Z-=!=)?6!:'@-!?'78-=!78!B)B3,'479>!678(-!9:-!9348!)5!9:-! A7,,-8873A.!'(()4=78?!9)!9:-!Jj$!eJA-47('8!j-88-,!$,3*f%!el',,7!+-4A'8.!a_3?!)E! X>!+-'49.a!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!X'>!d.!/00d%f!

i%!X>!=)(9)4!76!A-'8%!+-!;--B6!:76!69-9:)6()B-!78!9:-!54--Z-4%!e+-88>!L)38?A'8.!C,$" ;)-A-4&/$2*!"&'"S)$"K*)$0#.!-=%!^=!W:'8'B:>%!Rj'9)8':.!K%L%H!]',,>A)9-!]));6.! "gigT.!B%!i0%f!

g%!I)@-!76!*-69!=-578-=!'6!aA393',79>a!*-('36-!79!B,'(-6!-AB:'676!78!'(97)86!4'9:-4!9:'8! 6-897A-896.!'8=!*-('36-!79!78(,3=-6!9:-!-,-A-89!)5!4-(7B4)(',!6-897A-896!)4!a=)78?! 389)!)9:-46!'6!<-!<)3,=!:'@-!9:-A!=)!389)!36%a!e&)6-B:!W%!C788->.!aD:>!'!],'(;!U'>! $:34(:M.a!78!&)6-B:!]-'A.!-=%.!@)"%,$"K*'$=":"84!-D"9!A":)%,&4&GA%!R])69)8H!J,>6)8! _3*,7('97)86.!"gidT.!B%!1`%f!

"0%!L)3!:'@-!8)97(-=!9:'9!-@-4>9:78?!'8!P8=7'8!=)-6!76!78!'!(74(,-.!'8=!9:'9!76!*-('36-!9:-! E$%5('$#';<5'B$(&)'6&%672'%$(,2'1='+1(+&52-.'/95<6,6'36?68'$('4&6+,'`&,8'WXiakY".! O3)9-=!78!C%!$%!X(I3:'8.!C&6-,"%,$";!0%,=":"B$4'RH&0%0!*%"&'"@)2*!)";T*#%$)-$%!RK-<! L)4;H!239-4*47=?-!'8=!Q7-86954->.!"g1"T.!B%!"i%f!

! `g!

5H=-I!-J*5HKLMJN?*?JI*OP^Q*

!?*=S*=HTRNJSI*5HJ?JSI7*

P86943(97)86H!C,$0$"!0$"%+$45$"/!##!G$#"*)"%,*#"/0!-%*-$"/0&34$(#"#$%7"B*T"&'"%,$("-&)%!*)" !0G6($)%#"!)2"#*T"2&")&%7"M$%$0(*)$"+,*-,"!0$"+,*-,7"<&6"(*G,%"'*)2"%,$#$"/!##!G$#"

,!02$0"%&"-4!##*'A"%,!)"%,$"/!##!G$#"*)"[RW7"

"%!eW:'>8-f!^??-8!5,-<!)39!)5!()894),!,-66!9:'8!9<)!A)89:6!'59-4!:-4!4-,-'6-!e54)A!69'9-! B476)8f%!W:-!(39!'!A'8!=3478?!'8!'4?3A-89*78!'!Q-()4':!'B'49A-89.!9:-8!6-9!:-4! A'994-66!)8!574-%!J6!5,'A-6!6B4-'=!9)!9:-!4-69!)5!9:-!*37,=78?.!6:-!4'8!8';-=!)89)!9:-! 9)<8E6!A'78!694--9%!D798-66-6!6'7=!6:-!'6;-=!5)4!7(-!(4-'A!9)!6))9:-!:-4!*3486%!eC)8>! I->6.!aEP!I7;-!]-78?!9:-!D'>!P!JAE.a!M$#"I&*)$#"O$G*#%$0!RP)<'T.!&38-!"/.!/00c%f!

/%!X-A*-46!)5!9:-!l-8934'!$)389>!I7@78?!D'?-!$)',797)8!:'@-!B36:-=!5)4!<'?-! 69'8='4=6!678(-!"ggi%!J=@)('9-6!6'>!9:-!'4-'E6!:7?:!()69!)5!:)3678?.!()A*78-=!<79:! 6)'478?!:-',9:!-FB-86-6.!A';-!63(:!e,7@78?!<'?-f!,'<6!(4797(',!5)4!<)4;-46!9)!A--9! *'67(!8--=6%!

C:-74!'4?3A-89!4-6)8'9-=!<79:!6-@-4',!A-A*-46!)5!9:-!l-8934'!$79>!$)38(7,%! e$'9:-478-!W'7,,'89.!al-8934'!_'66-6!'!I7@78?!D'?-!24=78'8(-.a!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.! X'>!"1.!/00d%f!

Y%!P!*-,7-@-!9:'9!e'39:)4!D7,,7'Af!W'4)>'8.!,7;-!',,!J4A-87'86.!<'6!'!8'934',!39)B7'8%!D-! :'@-!'!=4-'A!7869-'=!)5!'!()3894>%!]-('36-!9-4479)4>!:'6!-,3=-=!36.!<-!:'@-!'!54--=)A! 9)!78@-89!9:'9!A)69!B-)B,-!=)8E9%!C:-!A)4-!)34!?-)?4'B:>!6:478;6.!9:-!A)4-!)34! 7A'?78'97)86!-FB'8=.!9:-!A)4-!<-E4-!,7;-!)<,6!5,>78?!78!9:-!='4;%!e_-9-4!]',';7'8.! 84!-D"M&G"&'"L!%$=":"I$(&*0%!RK-<!L)4;H!]'67(]));6.!"gg1T.!B%!"Yi%f!

`%!P!9:78;!79E6!578-!9)!*-!()867=-4-=!694'8?-!*-('36-!>)3E4-!(-49'78!9)!*-!8)97(-=%!J8! 78=7@7=3',!76!4-A-A*-4-=%!e&'(;7-!$34976E!?4'8=A)9:-4.!O3)9-=!78!$4'7?!]%!+7?:*-4?-4.! B6/$0#%!0"*)"!"F&6#$20$##="C,$"K*'$"!)2"K$G$)2"&'"P!-D*$">60%*#%!RK-<!L)4;H! $:'A*-4,'78!]4)6%.!/00cT.!B%!/0%f!

c%!G)4!A-.!'8=!P!63BB)6-!5)4!A)69!A'9:-A'97(7'86.!9:-4-!76!'8)9:-4!4-',79>!e78!'==797)8!9)! B:>67(',!4-',79>f.!<:7(:!P!<7,,!(',,!aA'9:-A'97(',!4-',79>a[!'8=!9:-4-!76!8)!6)49!)5! '?4--A-89!'*)39!9:-!8'934-!)5!A'9:-A'97(',!4-',79>!'A)8?!-79:-4!A'9:-A'97(7'86!)4! B:7,)6)B:-46%!W)A-!:),=!9:'9!79!76!aA-89',a!'8=!9:'9!78!6)A-!6-86-!<-!()86943(9!79.! )9:-46!9:'9!79!76!)3967=-!'8=!78=-B-8=-89!)5!36%!eU%!+%!+'4=>.!:"I!%,$(!%*-*!)J#" :/&4&GA%!R$'A*47=?-H!$'A*47=?-!N87@-4679>!_4-66.!"g`0S"gicT.!B%!"/Y%f!

d%!P8!9:76!(:'B9-4.!P!'663A-.!',)8?!<79:!9:-!4-69!)5!9:-!8'97)8.!9:'9!9:-4-!76!'!47?:9!9)! B47@'(>%!D:'9!P!<7,,!'4?3-!76!9:'9!'!47?:9!9)!:'@-!()86-863',!6-F.!78(,3=78?!?'>!6-F.! 5',,6!38=-4!9:76!47?:9!9)!B47@'(>%!P!<7,,!?7@-!9:4--!A)4',!'4?3A-896!<:7(:!-FB,'78!<:>! ()86-863',!6-F!*-9<--8!'=3,96!-8?'?-6!@'47)36!=7A-867)86!)5!B47@'(>!78!<'>6!9:'9! 78@);-!B47@'(>!'6!'!47?:9%!eb7(:'4=!Q%!X):4.!:"I&0$"H$0'$-%"U)*&)="E,A"B%0!*G,%" :($0*-!"I6#%"B%!)2"U/"'&0"9!A"O*G,%#%!R])69)8H!]-'()8!_4-66.!"gg`T.!B%!/"%f!

1%!S%#,Q!C,$"#/$!D$0"*#"!"'*-%*&)!4"-,!0!-%$07!

! c0!

23967=-!9:-!:)36-.!W<--9<'9-4!'8=!D)8=-4!+)46-!<-4-!*37,=78?!'!<:--,(:'74!4'AB! 5)4!A>!5'9:-4%!C:->!=7=8E9!8--=!'!*,3-B4789.!:'@78?!*37,9!9<-89>k6-@-8!4'AB6!)8!9:-! WB);'8-!P8=7'8!b-6-4@'97)8!)@-4!9:-!>-'46.!78(,3=78?!57@-!4'AB6!9:'9!63AA-4!',)8-%! eW:-4A'8!J,-F7-.!a28-!U))=!X'8.a!78!C,$"C&6G,$#%"@)2*!)"*)"%,$"E&042%!RK-<!L)4;H! J9,'897(!X)89:,>!_4-66.!/000T.!B%!/0g%f!

i%!C:-!6)(7),)?769!C:'=!D7,,7'A6)8.!'!,)8?97A-!'=A74-4!)5!9:-!$'4),78'!*'6;-9*',,! B4)?4'A.!9-,,6!'!69)4>!'*)39!:)<!eA-8E6!*'6;-9*',,!9-'A!'('=-A7(!'=@76)4!]34?-66f! X(W<'78!69'>-=!)8!9)B!)5!:-4!(:'4?-6!-@-8!<:-8!9:->!4-9348-=!9)!57876:!9:-74!=-?4--6! '59-4!?)78?!B4)!-'4,>.!'6!78!9:-!('6-!)5!X7(:'-,!&)4='8%!W:-E=!:-'4=!9:'9!&)4='8.!',4-'=>! '8!K]J!69'4!'8=!*'(;!78!9)<8!5)4!63AA-4!6(:)),.!<'6!B,'>78?!?),5!<:-8!:-!6:)3,=! :'@-!*--8!693=>78?%!W:-!=4)@-!9)!G78,->!U),5!$)346-.!9)!9:-!9--!<:-4-!&)4='8!<'6! B4-B'478?!9)!6<78?.!4),,-=!=)<8!:-4!('4!<78=)<.!'8=!9),=!9:-!B,'>-4!78!8)!38(-49'78! 9-4A6!9)!?-9!:76!'66!789)!9:-!('4%!+-!)*,7?-=%!eD7,,!],>9:-.!C&"F!%$"K*D$"C,*#"@#"%&"8$" F!//A"L&0$5$0=":"C,&0&6G,4A"S3#$##*5$?"@)%$0(*%%$)%4A"U/4*'%*)G?"!)2"S--!#*&)!44A"

U)3*!#$2":--&6)%"&'"%,$"M6D$RQ&0%,">!0&4*)!"8!#D$%3!44"O*5!40A%!RK-<!L)4;H! +'4B-4$),,786!_3*,76:-46.!/00dT.!BB%!""0k"""%f!

g%!JA-47('86!?)!9)!*'8;!5)4!,)'8.!l7-98'A-6-!?)!9)!547-8=6%!P!'6;!9:76!?3>!5)4!'!9:)36'8=.! '8)9:-4!5)4!9<)!9:)36'8=.!6))8!P!:'@-!-7?:9--8!9:)36'8=%!D-!94369!-'(:!)9:-4.!6)!8)! 789-4-69%!+-!;8)<!P!=)!9:-!6'A-!5)4!:7A!)8-!='>%!eK?3>-8!+33!U7.!O3)9-=!78!W9'8,->! j'48)<.!aI799,-!W'7?)8.a!78!X7(:-,,-!^%!+)3,-.!-=%.!C,$"Y*$%)!($#$%!RQ-94)79H! C:)A6)8!U',-.!/00dT.!B%!g1%f!

"0%!S%#,Q!E!4%$0"E*)-,$44"+!#":($0*-!J#"(&#%"/&/64!0"!)2"*)'46$)%*!4")$+#/!/$0" -&46()*#%"260*)G"%,$"[def#"!)2"[dgf#7"F$"!4#&",!2"!"0!2*&"#,&+7!

P!9',;!)8-!:38=4-=!'8=!878-9>k6-@-8!<)4=6!'!A7839-!<:-8!P!*4)'=('69%!Q)!>)3!;8)<! <:>!P!?)!6)!5'69M!]-('36-!75!P!9',;-=!6,)<,>.!B-)B,-!<)3,=!578=!)39!<:'9!P!<'6!6'>78?! '8=!4-A-A*-4!:)<!=3,,!79!<'6%!eD',9-4!D78(:-,,.!O3)9-=!78!])*!C:)A'6.!E*)-,$44%! RU'4=-8!$79>.!KLH!Q)3*,-='>!x!$)AB'8>.!"g1"T.!B%!"/`%f!

! c"!

""%!P8!Q-(-A*-4!"gc/.!8-<6B'B-4!:-'=,78-6!6:)(;-=!4-'=-46!'8=!B4)@7=-=!54-6:!5)==-4! 5)4!9:-!B'B-4*'(;!78=3694>!<:-8!9:->!'88)38(-=!9:'9!9<-89>k6-Fk>-'4k),=!]4)8F! 8'97@-!$:476978-!&)4?-86-8.!5)4A-4,>!;8)<8!'6!U-)4?-.!:'=!38=-4?)8-!6-Fk 4-'667?8A-89!634?-4>!78!Q-8A'4;%!C:-!69)4>!)5!&)4?-86-8E6!94'866-F3',!)B-4'97)86! <'6!()867=-4-=!A'n)4!8-<6!78!B'B-46!'4)38=!9:-!<)4,=%!J6!6:-!:-46-,5!()AA-89-=! >-'46!,'9-4!78!:-4!'39)*7)?4'B:>.!aP9!6--A6!9)!A-!8)<!'!6:)(;78?!()AA-89'4>!)8!9:-! B4-66!)5!)34!97A-!9:'9!P!B36:-=!9:-!:>=4)?-8k*)A*!9-696!)8!^87<-9);!47?:9!)55!9:-! 54)89!B'?-6%!J!94'?7(!<'4!<'6!697,,!4'?78?!78!j)4-'.!U-)4?-!lP!:'=!=7-=!'8=!]479'78! :'=!'!8-<!O3--8.!6)B:7697('9-=!?37=-=!A7667,-6!<-4-!?)78?!)55!78!K-<!X-F7().!&)8'6! W',;!<'6!<)4;78?!)8!'!@'((78-!5)4!785'897,-!B'4',>676!!!$:476978-!&)4?-86-8!<'6!)8! B'?-!)8-%a!C:-!n)348',76A!94'=-!B3*,7('97)8!;2*%&0"!)2"H634*#,$0!'88)38(-=!78!9:-! 6B478?!)5!"gc`!9:'9!A)4-!8-<6B4789!:'=!*--8!?-8-4'9-=!'*)39!&)4?-86-8!=3478?!9:-! B4-@7)36!>-'4!9:'8!'*)39!'8>!)9:-4!78=7@7=3',!!!)@-4!'!A7,,7)8!'8=!'!:',5!<)4=6.!9:-! 4)3?:!-O37@',-89!)5!5759--8!53,,k,-8?9:!*));6%!eW36'8!W94>;-4.!Z6$$0"H64/="H$05$0%$2" H!##*&)#"'0&("%,$"9&42$)":G$"&'"%,$"H!/$03!-D%!RW'8!G4'8(76()H!$:4)87(,-!]));6.! /00"T.!B%!1Y%f!

"/%!P5!>)3!,7;-!<'9(:78?!WB'876:k,'8?3'?-!6)'B6.!>)3!A'>!:'@-!6)A-9:78?!78!()AA)8! <79:!aC:-!j78?!)5!2B-4'a!_,'(7=)!Q)A78?)!<:)!'(;8)<,-=?-=!4-(-89,>!9:'9!:-!76!'! :3?-!5'8!)5!X-F7('8!9-,-8)@-,'6.!-6B-(7',,>!$'4,'!^694'='E6!8-<!B4)=3(97)8!)5! J,*)4'='!R69'4478?!G-48'8=)!$),38?'!'6!I3(-4)T!9:'9!=-*39-=!4-(-89,>!)8!N87@767)8%! P8!5'(9.!:-!6'7=!9:'9!:-!,7;-=!79!6)!A3(:!9:'9!:-!:'=!@7=-)!()B7-6!6-89!9)!:7A!6)!:-! <)3,=8E9!A766!'8!-B76)=-%!eb)6-!X'47-!W)9).!a^'69!I%J%!'8=!]->)8=.a!Q&0%,$!#%"B6)" RI)6!J8?-,-6T.!&'83'4>!"/.!/00d%f!

! c/!

5H=-I!-J*5HKLMJN?*?JI*OPO[Q*

!?*=S*=HTRNJSI*5HJ?JSI7*

P86943(97)86H!M$%$0(*)$"+,$%,$0"&0")&%"!)"!0G6($)%"*#"/0$#$)%7"@'")&%?"%0A"%&"#!A"+,!%"$4#$" *#"G&*)G"&)7"L&0"$T!(/4$?"%,$0$"(*G,%"3$"!"2$#-0*/%*&)?"$T/4!)!%*&)?"6)#6//&0%$2"

#%!%$($)%?"`&D$?"&0"!")&)R!0G6($)%!%*5$"!%%$(/%"!%"/$0#6!#*&)7"@'"!)"!0G6($)%"*#"/0$#$)%?"

+0*%$"%,$"-&)-46#*&)"!)2"4*#%"!44"/0$(*#$"&0"-&)-46#*&)"*)%0&26-$0#"6#$27"8$"#60$"%&"+0*%$"

%,$"-&)-46#*&)"!#"!"-&(/4$%$"#$)%$)-$"%,!%"*#"/,0!#$2"!#"!"#%!%$($)%"!)2"(!D$#"#$)#$"3A"

*%#$4'7"I!D$"-4$!0"%,$"0$'$0$)%#"&'"!)A"/0&)&6)#"6#$2?"6)4$##"%,$"-&)-46#*&)"*#"!3&6%"%,$"

!0G6$0X"*'"%,$"-&)-46#*&)"*#"!3&6%"%,$"!0G6$0?"A&6"(!A"4$!5$"%,$"/$0#&)!4"/0&)&6)#"%,!%"

0$'$0"%&"%,$"!0G6$07"M&")&%"!22"!)A"$44*/#$#7!

W'AB,-!_4)*,-A6H!

! ! 247?78',!_'66'?-H!

D:-8!I-@7E6!*-?'8!A';78?!796!c0"!n-'86.!78!"i1Y.!9:->!<-4-8E9!-@-8!(',,-=! c0"6%!C:->!<-4-!;8)<8!'6!yy6.!'8=!9:->!('A-!<79:!'!,)8-!*'(;!B)(;-9.!'! *3(;,-!(78(:.!'8=!636B-8=-4!*399)86%!e$'8=7(-!b'78->.!aQ)A78'89!&-'86H! I-@7E6!b-7663-6!9:-!U4'8=='==>!)5!C:-A!J,,H!C:-!S0*G*)!4!247?78',!c0".a! 9Z!R&3,>!/00cT.!B%!Yd%f!

J86<-4H!

8)!'4?3A-89[!:769)47(',!=-6(47B97)8!

247?78',!_'66'?-H!

Q'=!<'68E9!'55-(9-=!*>!9:-!e69)(;!A'4;-9f!(4'6:!)5!E/g%!+-!<-89!*4);-!78! E/i%!e+-88>!L)38?A'8.!C,$";)-A-4&/$2*!"&'"S)$"K*)$0#.!-=%!^=! W:'8'B:>%!Rj'9)8':.!K%L%H!]',,>A)9-!]));6.!"gigT.!B%!"01%f!

J86<-4H!

'4?3A-89!

$)8(,367)8H!Q'=!<'68E9!'55-(9-=!*>!9:-!69)(;!A'4;-9!(4'6:!)5!E/g%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

! cY!

"%!J,,!<)A-8!,)@-!9:-74!54--=)A%!e&'A7,,'!K7'Z7.!O3)9-=!78!&):'88!+'47.!aI-?',7Z-!P9.a! K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!K)@-A*-4!d.!/00d%f!

/%!=b'/$)'2*R&'8%!/0!9)!G-*%!"iT!C:-!"/9:!76!>)34!B-45-(9!='>!9)!,-'@-!<)4;!-'4,>!'8=! =4)B!'!B'>(:-(;!)8!'!8-<!*'?%!28!9:-!"19:.!6,7B!>)34!=7?796!9)!9:-!6-F>!694'8?-4!<:)E,,! ?7@-!>)3!9:-!->-!=3478?!>)34!A)4878?!()AA39-%!C:-!9:-A-!5)4!>)3!9:76!A)89:H! '(O376797)86%!ea+)4)6()B-.a!P!)$!iHg!RK)@-A*-4!/00`T.!B%!"`/%f!!!

Y%*?(%$.)%!R2(9!/Y%!9)!K)@%!/"T!C:-!*7?!B7(934-!78!>)34!,)@-!,75-!?-96!(,-'4-4.!*39!=)8E9!?-9! 9))!('3?:9!3B%!L)34!*)66!<7,,!9:78;!>)3E4-!6,'(;78?!)55!<:-8!6:-!6--6!>)34!(3*7(,-! =-()4'9-=!<79:!:-'496%!Q'>!>)3E,,!8--=!9:-!A'F7A3A!=)6'?-!)5!'(-9'A78)B:-8H!9:-! "/9:%!ea+)4)6()B-.a!P!)$!iHg!RK)@-A*-4!/00`T.!B%!"`/%f!!!

`%!J8!^'69B)789-!A'8!76!(:'4?-=!<79:!9:4)<78?!:76!78@',7=!A)9:-4!54)A!'!(:'74!'8=! 5)4(78?!:-4!9)!(4'<,!789)!:-4!:)A-!)8!:-4!:'8=6!'8=!;8--6%!

2557(7',6!6'>!])**7-!X'98->!)5!I'A*4-(:9!W94--9!?)9!789)!'8!'4?3A-89!<79:!:76!i`k >-'4k),=!A)9:-4!D-=8-6='>!)@-4!9:-!A)8->!:-!6B-8=6!)8!(7?'4-99-6.!6'7=!X'()A*! $)389>!'66769'89!B4)6-(39)4!&):8!I'9-,,'%!C:-!'4?3A-89!?)9!6)!:-'9-=!9:'9!X'98->! 9:4-<!:76!A)9:-4E6!<',;-4!'6!5'4!'6!:-!()3,=.!B),7(-!6'7=%!eU)4=)8!D7,(Z>86;7.! a^'69B)789-!X'8!$:'4?-=!<79:!J*36-.a!I!-&(3"M!*4A"Q$+#!RX7(:7?'8T.!&38-!"Y.! /00d%f!

c%!G7469!('A-!9:-!B4)B)6',!9)!9-'4!=)<8!9:-!-8974-!]4769),!G3487934-!$)%.!)4!_'4-,,'.! *37,=78?!'8=!4-B,'(-!79!<79:!'!//.000k6O3'4-k5))9!'==797)8!9)!9:-!-F76978?!*4)<869)8-! )8!+)B-!W94--9!9:'9!:)36-6!b)?-46!G4--!I7*4'4>%!

-/O<5'912;$(1+'[12;(1+;'I$AA7667)8f!:'=!B4-@7)36,>!?4'89-=!B-4A7667)8!9)!=-A),76:! ',,!)5!9:-!*37,=78?!-F(-B9!9:-!5'('=-.!:)<-@-4!9:-!,7*4'4>E6!*37,=78?!()AA799--!:'=! 678(-!'A-8=-=!'!B,'8!9:'9!:'=!*--8!78!9:-!<)4;6!5)4!67F!>-'46!'8=!4-'BB,7-=!5)4!'! ()AB,-9-!=-A),797)8%!

J8!-8?78--4!:74-=!*>!9:-!*37,=78?!()AA799--!,'7=!)39!9:-!'4?3A-89!5)4!4'Z78?!9:-! -8974-!*37,=78?.!6'>78?!9:'9!4-9'7878?!9:-!5'('=-!<)3,=!'==!'9!,-'69!zY/c.000!9)!9:-!()69! )5!9:-!B4)n-(9%!eJ,-F!j3558-4.!a$)AA7667)8!b-9'786!W9'8(-!)8!W'@78?!_'697A-! C:-'9-4.a!H0&5*2$)-$"P&60)!4!Rb:)=-!P6,'8=T.!X'>!Y".!/00d%f!

d%!j:';76!<79:!'!*399)8k=)<8!e6:749f!76!8-@-4!<:'9!>)3E=!(',,!-,-?'89.!-F(-B9!78!'!<:79-! (),,'4!B476)8%!eU,-88!2E]47-8.!aC:-!W9>,-!U3>.a!9Z!RG-*43'4>!/001T.!B%!dc%f!

! c`!

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eU,-88!2E]47-8.!aC:-!W9>,-! U3>.a!9Z!RG-*43'4>!/001T.!B%!dc%f!

i%!oH!D:'9E6!9:-!*-69!9>B-!)5!n-<-,4>!9)!<-'4!<79:!'!9349,-8-(;M!

JH!D:'9!P!,)@-!'*)39!9349,-8-(;6!76!9:'9!9:->!A';-!?-9978?!=4-66-=!67AB,-%!D:'9!P!=)8E9! ,)@-.!:)8-69,>.!76!9:'9!9:->E4-!8)9!-'6>!9)!'((-66)47Z-%!L)34!*-69!*-9H!'!*),=!(),)453,! B-8='89!)4!'!*38(:!)5!,)8?!(:'786.!<:7(:!<7,,!,-8?9:-8!>)34!9)46).!A';78?!>)3! 6--A!9',,-4!'8=!6,7AA-4%!J8=!<:)!=)-68E9!<'89!9:'9M!eaW9>,-!o!x!J.a!B$4'! RK)@-A*-4!/00dT.!B%!g/%f!!!

g%!C:76!6379!=)-68E9!=)!A3(:!5)4!A-!!!*39!9:-8.!P!=)8E9!=)!A3(:!5)4!79%!e+-88>!L)38?A'8.! C,$";)-A-4&/$2*!"&'"S)$"K*)$0#.!-=%!^=!W:'8'B:>%!Rj'9)8':.!K%L%H!]',,>A)9-!]));6.! "gigT.!B%!`Y%f!

"0%!P!A-66-=!3B!A>!-8974-!,75-!*-('36-!P!?)9!:7?:! P!,)69!A>!;7=6!'8=!<75-!*-('36-!P!?)9!:7?:!! K)<!PEA!6,--B78?!)8!9:-!67=-<',;!'8=!P!;8)<!<:>!! "!('36-!P!?)9!:7?:! eJ54)A'8.!a]-('36-!P!U)9!+7?:[a!:99BHSS<<<%,>47(654-';%()AS'S'54)A'8S`c01%:9A,%f!

""%!S%#,Q!C,$"#/$!D$0"*)"%,*#"/!##!G$"*#";2"80&+)?"%,$"'!%,$0"&'":0(A"BG%7"P$''0$A"B7" 80&+)?"D*44$2"*)"@0!V7":'%$0"-&(/4$%*)G",*#"#*TRA$!0"-&((*%($)%?"BG%7"80&+)"+!#"

-!44$2"3!-D"%&"@0!V"6)2$0"%,$"H$)%!G&)J#"h#%&/R4&##h"/0&G0!(?"+,*-,"!44&+#"%,$"

(*4*%!0A"%&",&42"&)%&"/$0#&))$4"!'%$0"%,$A",!5$"-&(/4$%$2"%,$*0"-&((*%($)%#7"

X>!;7=!6:)3,=!8)9!*-!=-'=.!*-('36-!:-!=7=!,7@-!3B!9)!:76!()894'(9.!'8=!9:-!J4A>!=7=! 8)9!,7@-!3B!9)!9:-746%!e^=!]4)<8.!O3)9-=!78!aJ4A>!W?9%!&-554->!W%!]4)<8.!/c.!C47879>! $-89-4[!j7,,-=!78!+-,7()B9-4!$4'6:.a!2*793'4>.!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!W-B9-A*-4!Y.! /00d%f!!!

"/%!D-!:'=!*--8!6:))978?!A'4*,-6!<:-8!9:76!;7=!A766-=!'!4-',,>!-'6>!6:)9!'8=!P!,'3?:-=! '9!:7A%!+-!A369!:'@-!*--8!:'@78?!'!*'=!='>!*-('36-!:-!?)9!4-',!3B6-9!'8=!<'89-=!9)! 57?:9%!ec0!$-89!R$34976!&'A-6!&'(;6)8!PPPT!<79:!j476!^F.!L0&("H*$-$#"%&"E$*G,%="S)-$" U/&)"!"C*($"*)"B&6%,#*2$"Z6$$)#%!RK-<!L)4;H!_)(;-9!]));6SXCl!]));6.!/00cT.!B%! i%f!

! cc!

"Y%!367'&1,5'7$*'6(5'F6,1=>'6'R$,5'$='7$*(')6)'-'6=)'&1,5'7$*'6(5')52+(1:1=>'<$%'7$*(' ='=!?)-6!)3967=-!9)!<'6:!:76!('4!<-'478?!:76!=4-66!6)(;6!78!6'8=',6!'8=!9:-!)!)")*)G" G&!R'!9'8;!9)B!9:'9!j)4-'8!A',-6!)59-8!<-'4T.!9:'9!76!5388>!9)!'!j)4-'8!JA-47('8! :5+6*25';<5(5'12'6'+$FF$='*=)5(2;6=)1=>'-':*;'%1;<'-'&5;Q2'267'-'6'I6*+6216=8'

9:->!<)3,=8E9!578=!79!@-4>!5388>%!eJ8)8>A)36!,-'=-4!)5!'!j)4-'8!JA-47('8!('AB36! A787694>.!O3)9-=!78!b-*-(('!L%!j7A.!aX'=-!78!9:-!N%W%J%H!W-()8=kU-8-4'97)8! j)4-'8!JA-47('8!$'AB36!^@'8?-,7(',6.a!78!&-8875-4!I--!'8=!X78!h:)3.!-=6%.!:#*!)" :($0*-!)"<&6%,=">64%60$?"@2$)%*%A?"!)2";%,)*-*%A%!RK-<!L)4;H!b)39,-=?-.!/00`T.!B%! /`d%f!

Wm.'B<5=';<5'#6=2'255'-'/3<6d*1&&5'UQA56&M'6;'<12':52;8'<5'12'2*+<'6='$N5(?$%-478?! B4-6-8(-!9:'9!9:->!'39)A'97(',,>!<)8=-4H!:)<!()A-!9:-!I';-46!=)8E9!<78!$5$0A! ?'A-M!C:-4-5)4-!<:-8!<-!,)6-.!9:->!'663A-!79!A369!*-!*-('36-!W:'O!=7=8E9!B,'>!:'4=! -8)3?:%!e_:7,!&'(;6)8!<79:!X7(:'-,!J4;36:.!C,$"K!#%"B$!#&)=":"C$!("*)"B$!0-,"&'" *%#"B&64%!RK-<!L)4;H!C:-!_-8?378!_4-66.!/00`T.!BB%!1dk11%f!!!

"c%!L)3!'4-!?37,9>!)5!*4-';78?!'!,'<!75!>)3!=)!8)9!'(97@-,>!()A*'9!?4'55797%!e+769)47(',! +7?:,'8=!_'4;!K-7?:*)4:))=!$)38(7,!RI)6!J8?-,-6T.!:)%*R90!''*%*"H!(/,4$%!R/00dT%f! !!

"d%!P5!JA-47('8!P8=7'8!A'6()96!'4-!-,7A78'9-=.!9:-8!',,!(3,934',,>k*'6-=!A'6()96!A369!*-! -,7A78'9-=!78!)4=-4!9)!*-!5'74.!*-('36-!'!('47('934-!)5!'!A'9'=)4!=)-6!8)9!4-B4-6-89!9:-! +76B'87(!(3,934-.!8)4!=)-6!9:-!4-B4-6-89'97)8!)5!'!?'3(:).!<:7(:!76!'!()<*)>!78!W)39:! JA-47('.!=)!n3697(-!5)4!W)39:!JA-47('8!(3,934-6%!e&'(,>8!+)3?:9)8.!a]-99-4!$3,934',! ^=3('97)8!$)3,=!K-?'9-!K--=!5)4!b'(769!X'6()96.a!M!*4A"B6)2*!4!R$',75)487'!W9'9-! N87@-4679>.!K)49:47=?-T.!JB47,!/".!/00c%f!!

"1%!-,4,;$)#:*.$%B)4,2Q*X-?'k'(94-66!&-8875-4!J8769)8!:'6!()A-!)55!)5!'!93A3,93)36!>-'4! <79:!:-4!:-'=!:-,=!:7?:!'8=!:-4!('4--4!)8!574-%!W:-E,,!B4)*'*,>!*-!,78;-=!9)!6-@-4',! =755-4-89!A-8!)@-4!9:-!8-F9!-7?:9!A)89:6.!*39!79E6!8)9:78?!6-47)36.!'6!JO3'47'8!<)A-8! 9-8=!9)!57,,!9:-74!,7@-6!<79:!8-<!547-8=6!'59-4!'!*4-';3B%!X)4-!A)@7-6!'8=!A)4-!,)@-! -8634-!J8769)8!<7,,!578=!(,'479>!'8=!()857=-8(-!<79:78!:-46-,5% e+),7='>!X'9:76.! a+)4)6()B-6!*>!+),7='>.a!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!G-*43'4>!g.!/00d%f!!!

"i%!I799,-!W'7?)8!76!=-@)9-=!9)!()AA-4(-.!'6!796!B4)9)9>B-!<'6!*-5)4-!9:-!$)AA387696! (34*-=!('B79',76A%!]39!<:7,-!9:-!4-53?--6!:'@-!94'86B,'89-=!9:-74!)<8!*4'8=!)5! *3678-66!78!9:76!5)4-7?8!6-9978?.!9:->!:'@-!-A*4'(-=!9:-!A)69!JA-47('8!)5!()863A-4! 786979397)86!!!9:-!6:)BB78?!(-89-4%!eW9'8,->!j'48)<.!aI799,-!W'7?)8.a!78!X7(:-,,-!^%! +)3,-.!-=%.!C,$"Y*$%)!($#$%!RQ-94)79H!C:)A6)8!U',-.!/00dT.!B%!gg%f!

"g%!D:-8!P!<'6!'BB4)'(:78?!9:-!'?-!)5!5)49>!'8=!5'(78?!9:-!9>B-!)5!('8(-4!6('4-6!9:'9! :'@-!*-()A-!6)!()AA)8B,'(-!78!<)A-8E6!,7@-6!9:'9!9:->!'4-!B4'(97(',,>!4)3978-.!A>! 57469!9:)3?:9!'6!P!<'79-=!5)4!9-69!4-63,96!<'6!9:'9!P!<'6!8)9!4-'=>!9)!=7-!*-('36-!P!:'=! 8)9!>-9!5)38=!9:-!,)@-!A>!:-'49!<'6!6--;78?%!e*-,,!:));6.!:44"!3&6%"K&5$="Q$+" Y*#*&)#%!RK-<!L)4;H!D7,,7'A!X)44)<!'8=!$)AB'8>.!/000T.!B%!FF77%f!

! cd!

/0%!-/@M2'%5'%61;5)'#$(';<5';$T1+$&$>7'&6:$(6;$(7';$'?5(#$(F'-!9-696.!43A)46!)5!5)3,! B,'>!78!eX'47,>8f!X)84)-E6!=-'9:!<-4-!',4-'=>!-6(','978?%!X)84)-E6!547-8=6!'8=! '66)(7'9-6!6'7=!9:'9!:-4!('4--4.!<:7(:!:'=!*--8!78!'!=-(,78-.!<'6!8)<!)8!'8!3B6<78?%! W).!9:->!786769-=.!9:-4-!<'6!8)!4-'6)8!5)4!:-4!9)!:'@-!63==-8,>!()AA799-=!637(7=-%! eC:)A'6!C%!K)?3(:7!<79:!&)6-B:!Q7X)8'.!>&0&)$0%!RK-<!L)4;H!_)(;-9!]));6.! "giYT.!B%!1c%f!!!

/"%!J6!9:-!(79>!)5!I)6!J8?-,-6!6B-8=6!A7,,7)86!4-@'AB78?!796!'87A',!6:-,9-46.!"0!)5!"/! @-9-478'4>!B)6797)86!78!9:-!Q-B'49A-89!)5!J87A',!W-4@7(-6.!78(,3=78?!9:'9!)5!(:7-5! @-9-478'47'8.!?)!@'('89%!eC)8>!]'4*)Z'.!al-9!W:)49'?-!_396!]79-!)8!$79>!J87A',! W:-,9-46.a!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!&'83'4>!i.!/001%f!

//%!X-A*-46!)5!9:-!(,-4?>!)5!',,!4-,7?7)86!'4-!387O3-,>!B)6797)8-=!9)!=)!6)A-9:78?!'*)39! JPQW%!D-!-8n)>!'((-66!9)!()8?4-?'97)86!)5!)4=78'4>!B-)B,-!9:'9!8)!)8-!-,6-!=)-6%! J8=!<-!'4-!?-8-4',,>!94369-=!'8=!4-6B-(9-=!*>!)34!5,)(;6%!eG'9:-4!D7,,7'A!&%!D))=.! a$,-4?>!+'@-!'!N87O3-!b),-!78!$)854)8978?!JPQW.a!78!W'6:'!J,>6)8.!-=%.!<&6">:Q" M&"B&($%,*)G":3&6%":@MB%!R])69)8H!C:-!W9)B!JPQW!_4)n-(9.!"gg0T.!B%!"/"%f!!!

/Y%!C-,,!A-!:)<!P!'A!63BB)6-=!9)!5--,!'*)39!D-69!+),,><))=E6!B,'8!9)!-4-(9!'!A-A)47',! ;$'3$N15;'2$&)15(2'-'%<$'#$*><;'#$('6'>$N5(=F5=;';<6;'5T1&5)'F7'01;<*6=16='#6F1&7'

9)!W7*-47'.!',)8?!<79:!:38=4-=6!)5!9:)36'8=6!)5!)9:-46!<:)!A-9!9:-74!=-'9:6!9:-4-M! D-!9-8=!9)!5)4?-9!9:'9!9:-!W)@7-96!<-4-!'6!*439',!'6!9:-!K'Z76!=3478?!D)4,=!D'4!PP%! W3(:!'!A)83A-89!?,)475>78?!W)@7-9!@7(9)47-6!:'6!8)!B,'(-!:-4-%!eX'47n'!W%!K-<6)A.! I-99-4!9)!9:-!^=79)4.!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!G-*43'4>!"Y.!/00c%f!

/`%!U3>6.!>)3!;8)<!>)3!*-99-4!<'9(:!)39%!W)A-!?74,6.!6)A-!?74,6!'4-!)8,>!'*)39!9:'9! 9:78?.!9:'9!9:78?.!9:'9!9:78?%!eI'34>8!+7,,.!aQ))!D)B!RC:'9!C:78?T.a!)8"C,$" I*#$26-!%*&)"&'"K!60A)"F*44%!RK-<!L)4;H!b355:)36-!b-()4=6S$),3A*7'!b-()4=6.! "ggiT%f!!!

/c%!C:-!57469!7AB)49!('4!4'(78?!-@-89!A'=-!796!=-*39!78!&3,>!)5!"gg0!'9!9:-!I)6!J8?-,-6! $)389>!b'(-<'>!78!_',A=',-!!!'!=-6-49k,7;-!63*34*'8!(79>!8)49:-'69!)5!I)6!J8?-,-6! 9:'9!6-4@-6!'6!9:-!A'78!@-83-!5)4!7AB)49!4'(-46!9)!B4'(97(-!,-?',!4'(78?%!24?'87Z-=!*>! G4'8;!$:)7.!8!%%4$"&'"%,$"@(/&0%#"'7A-=!9)!3879-!4'(-46!54)A!$',75)487'!5)4!'!,-?',!('4! 4'(-!'8=!6:)<%!2@-4!c00!>)38?!B-)B,-!RA)69,>!J67'8!JA-47('8T!'8=!'*)39!c0!('46! B'497(7B'9-=!78!9:-!57469!-@-89.!'8=!678(-!9:-8!8!%%4$"&'"%,$"@(/&0%#!:'6!*-()A-!'! *7'883',!<--;-8=!-F94'@'?'8Z'!9:'9!=4'<6!'6!A'8>!'6!/0.000!4'(-46!'8=!547-8=6! 9:4)3?:!<)4=!)5!A)39:.!9:-!P89-48-9.!'8=!7AB)49!('4kB'49!6-,,-46%!el7(9)47'!K'A;38?.! ab-78@-8978?!9:-!D:--,H!PAB)49!b'(78?!78!W)39:-48!$',75)487'.a!78!&-8875-4!I--!'8=! X78!h:)3.!-=6%.!:#*!)":($0*-!)"<&6%,=">64%60$?"@2$)%*%A?"!)2";%,)*-*%A%!RK-<!L)4;H! b)39,-=?-.!/00`T.!B%!"dd%f!!!

! c1!

\S.'-/UM*('/4(6^1&16=M'1=)5?5=)5=+5'%62'?($+&61F5)':7';<5'<51(';$';<5'E$(;*>525';<($=5'

<:).!'8?4>!<79:!:76!5'9:-4.!9)4-!9:-!47**)86!)5!_)493?',E6!(),)46!54)A!:76!(,)9:-6!'8=! (47-=!aP8=-B-8=-8(-!)4!Q-'9:Va!W(:),'4,>!<)4;6!=)!8)9.!)5!()346-.!A-897)8!9:'9!'! ?))=!B'49!)5!:76!7,,!:3A)34!<'6!=3-!9)!9:-!=7'44:-'!:-!<'6!6355-478?!54)A.!'8=!<:7(:! :'=!5)4(-=!:7A!9)!69)B!4-B-'9-=,>!)8!:76!n)348->!54)A!b7)!=-!&'8-74)!9)!Wq)!_'3,)%! e&)q)!W%!C4-@76'8.!H$05$0%#"*)"H!0!2*#$.!94'86,'9-=!*>!X'4978!G)4-A'8%!RI)8=)8H! UX_!_3*,76:-46.!"gidT.!B%!"/%f!

/1%!S%#,Q!M$!)"B(*%,"+!#"!"4&)GR%*($?"5$0A"#6--$##'64"($)J#"3!#D$%3!44"-&!-,"!%"C,$" U)*5$0#*%A"&'"Q&0%,">!0&4*)!"!%">,!/$4"F*447!

P5!P!<-4-!-F?$%5(5)';$'%(1;5';<5'(*&52'+$=+5(=1=>'+$&&5>5':62,5;:6&&'5&1>1:1&1;78'-L' <)3,=8E9!',,)<!54-6:A-8!-,7?7*7,79>!5)4!A-8E6!*'6;-9*',,!)4!5))9*',,%!C:-!4-(4379-=! 54-6:A-8!<)3,=!B,'>!)8!54-6:A-8!9-'A6!',)8?!<79:!8)86(:),'46:7B!B,'>-46%!C:->! <)3,=!:'@-!8)!)@-487?:9!947B6!9)!9';-!9:-A!'<'>!54)A!9:-74!693=7-6%!C:-74!B4'(97(-! 97A-!<)3,=!8)9!*-!'6!,)8?!)4!'6!789-867@-.!8)4!<)3,=!9:->!:'@-!9)!6B-8=!'6!A3(:!97A-! 9',;78?!9)!9:-!A-=7'%!P9!<)3,=!?7@-!9:-A!'!*-99-4!(:'8(-!9)!'=n369!9)!9:-74!'('=-A7(! ,)'=!'8=!9)!*-78?!'<'>!54)A!:)A-!5)4!9:-!57469!97A-%!J4-8E9!9-'(:-46!63BB)6-=!9)! 63BB)49!<:'9E6!*-69!5)4!9:-74!693=-896M!G4-6:A'8!78-,7?7*7,79>!=-57879-,>!<)3,=!*-!78! 9:-!*-69!789-4-696!)5!9:-!693=-89k'9:,-9-%!D-!=)8E9!=)!79!*-('36-!)5!A)8->%!WB78!79!'8>! <'>!>)3!(:))6-.!*39!<-!',,)<!54-6:A'8!-,7?7*7,79>!78!A-8E6!*'6;-9*',,!'8=!5))9*',,! *-('36-!)5!A)8->%!P5!(),,-?-6!?7@-!'!54-6:A'8!'!*'6;-9*',,!6(:),'46:7B.!9:->!<'89! :7A!a-'4878?!:76!;--Ba!)8!9:-!()349!47?:9!'<'>%!P9E6!<4)8?!'8=!6:)4967?:9-=%!]39!PE@-! 5)3?:9!9:'9!*'99,-!5)4!>-'46%!P!;8)<!<:-8!PEA!,7(;-=%!eQ-'8!WA79:.!78!Q-'8!WA79:!'8=! U-4',=!Q%!]-,,!<79:!&):8!j7,?).!C,$">!0&4*)!"E!A="K$!2$0#,*/"K$##&)#"'0&("!"K*'$" *)">&!-,*)G%!RK-<!L)4;H!_-8?378!]));6.!/00`T.!B%!"01%f!

/i%!U-),)?7696!'9!)8-!97A-!9:)3?:9!9:-!Q-@7,E6!_38(:*)<,!'8=!9:-!$'n)8!6'8=69)8-6!('A-! 54)A!9:-!6'A-!6)34(-%!C:->!:'@-!678(-!'*'8=)8-=!9:'9!9:-)4>!*-('36-!9:-!5)667,! 4-()4=!=)-68E9!A'9(:%!e_:7,7B!I%!G4'=;78.!I!G)*%62$"W=";!0%,V6!D$#"!)2"K*'$"!4&)G" %,$"B!)":)20$!#"L!64%%!R]-4;-,->H!N87@-4679>!)5!$',75)487'!_4-66.!"ggiT.!B%!d0%f!!!

/g%!-L'6F'6221F1&6;5)8'25+$=)k?-8-4'97)8%!P!4-(-89,>!4-9348-=!54)A!$:78'.!A>!6-()8=! 947B!9:-4-%!J8=!P!('8E9!:-,B!*-78?!=3*7)36!'*)39!9:-!<:),-!:)A-()A78?!-89-4B476-%! D:'9!=7=!P!6--!78!$:78'M!P!6'<!'!6B4'<,78?!()894'=7(97)8!)5!'!()3894>!*-6-9!*>! (:'8?-6!)5!'!6(',-!389:78;'*,-!:-4-%!P!6'<!'!8'97)8!94>78?!9)!?',,)B!789)!9:-!9<-89>k 57469!(-8934>!<:7,-!796!:78=!,-?6!4-A'78!78!9:-!9<-,59:%!]39!<:7,-!P!6'<!A'8>!<:)! ,));-=!,7;-!A-.!'8=!A'8>!<:)!A7?:9!:'@-!*--8!,7;-!A-.!P!8-@-4!)8(-!6'<!A>6-,5%! C:'9!76.!P!8-@-4!5-,9!9:'9!94'86(-8=-8(-!9:-!(:7,=!)5!7AA7?4'896!76!63BB)6-=!9)! -FB-47-8(-!3B)8!?)78?!3!-D%!L-6.!78!9:-!()3894>67=-!)4!9:-!'8(7-89!O3'49-46.!P!()3,=! ()8n34-!3B!9:-!$:78'!A>!?4'8=B'4-896!;8-<%!D:'9!8-@-4!'447@-=.!9:)3?:.!<'6!9:-! -B7B:'8>!6(47B9-=!5)4!A-.!9:-!6-86'97)8!9:'9!P!<'6!!!'9!,'69!!!'A)8?!A>!)<8!B-)B,-%! e^47(!I73.!C,$":--*2$)%!4":#*!)="Q&%$#"&'"!"Q!%*5$"B/$!D$0%!RK-<!L)4;H!b'8=)A! +)36-.!"ggiT.!BB%!"Y"k"Y/%f!

! ci!

Y0%!M);$/$:*I%@,$*eB%$1,$4:*<-")(+='(&")(,(&+>/"13+7&'(&"f!!!R$)**.!+-84>!)5!P%!X%! _-7.!G4--=S+'4),=!G4-=-8*34?.!"gg0T!dYY!D-69!G759:!W94--9%!C:76!76!9:-!9',,-69! *37,=78?!)8!9:-!<-69!()'69.!6-@-89>k9:4--!69)47-6.!)8-!9:)36'8=!6-@-89--8!5--9%!C:4--! 9:)36'8=!B-)B,-!<)4;!:-4-.!('447-=!3B!'8=!=)<8!*>!5)49>k5)34!-,-@'9)46%!J!B'78978?! )5!9:4--!4-8'766'8(-!'8?-,6!)8!9:-!,)**>!<',,6!5'(78?!9:-!<78=)<6!76!*-69!693=7-=! 7867=-!9:-!-894'8(-%!C:-!A34',!76!)8-!)5!A'8>!'497697(!()AA-89'47-6!)8!9:-!(79>E6! WB'876:!8'A-.!C,$":)G$4#%!D:-8!9:-!(349'786!<-4-!B'49-=!'9!9:-!B3*,7(!=-=7('97)8!)5! 9:-!A34',!78!"ggY.!6)A-)8-!-F(,'7A-=.!aC:->E4-!',,!<:79-Va!!!-A*'44'6678?.!5)4!9:-! A)69!=7@-46-!(79>!78!9:-!()3894>%!eb)*-49!Q%!+-4A'8.!M&+)%&+)"K&#":)G$4$#=":" E!4D*)G"96*2$.!4-@%!-=%!R]',=<78!_'4;.!$',75)487'H!U-A!U37=-6!]));!$)AB'8>.! /000T.!B%!dY%f!!!

! cg!

A CHALLENGING PROBLEM

C,*#"/&$("-&)%!*)#"%,0$$"!0G6($)%#7"C,$"-,!44$)G$"'&0"A&6"*#"%&"'*)2"%,$#$"!0G6($)%#"

!)2"+0*%$"%,$"-&)-46#*&)"&'"$!-,?"'&44&+*)G"%,$"#!($"*)#%06-%*&)#"!#"'&0"H0!-%*-$"

H0&34$(#"B$%"[R[f7!

X>!G'9:-4E6!l7-<!)5!_)-94>!

L)3!('8E9!A';-!A3(:!9)!,7@-!)8!=)78?!79%! L)3!('8E9%!L)3!('8E9!9-,,!69)47-6!!!B)-A6!57?:9! J!8'44'97@-%!L)3!634-,>!('8E9!(34-!87?:9E6! G)4?-953,8-66!<79:!79.!)4!6'>!<79:!79! PAB)49'89!:769)47-6!'8=!9439:6%!L)3!('8E9! X';-!A)8->!<47978?!79%!P8!A-=7(78-! L)3!,'>!>)34!:'8=6!)8!B-)B,-!n369!9:-!6'A-%! L)3!9:78;!>)3E4-!'!B)-9M!K).!>)3!=)8E9! j8)<!^8?,76:!<-,,!-8)3?:%!L)3!=)8E9!;8)<!='>6! ]-?78!9)!5--,!9:78.!,7;-!'9A)6B:-4-! C-8!A7,-6!:7?:!'*)@-!9:-!A)8694)36!9-'4! C:-!-'49:!<7,,!',<'>6!*-%!J8=!>-69-4='>! P6!*-99-4!)55!5)4?)99-8%!D:-8!>)3!=7-!!!! PE@-!6--8!'!4-@),397)8.!6)!P!;8)<!!! L)3E4-!8-@-4!()38978?!6>,,'*,-6%!L)3!;8)<! C:-!A34=-4-46!<7,,!=4'78!>)34!9:4)'9!)5!67?:6%!

eb'5'-,!$'AB).!aX>!G'9:-4E6!l7-<!)5!_)-94>.a!78!C,$"S%,$0"I!)"E!#"I$=":"Y&A!G$"%&"

%,$"Q$+"E&042%!R+)369)8H!J49-!_u*,7()!_4-66.!"gg`T.!B%!c`%f!

! d0!

=*<,@*K#+,$*R2,2*%B*E;,(/'2,EQ*E"%#*;,(/'2,E*/"&*E./$#4:*;,(/'2,E*

W)A-97A-6!9:-!B:4'6-!E8)9!*-('36-E!76!36-=!7894)=3(-!'!69'9-A-89!9:'9!9:-!'4?3-4!76! 67?8',78?!76!8)9!'!B4-A76-%!D:-8!9:76!:'BB-86.!363',,>!9:-!'4?3-4!<7,,!B4-6-89!9:-!B4-A76-! R)4!B4-A76-6T!,'9-4!)8%!$)867=-4!9:76!-F'AB,-H!

C:-!83A*-4!)5!693=-896!)8!9:-!N87@-4679>!)5!X'4>,'8=!$-89-4!5)4! ^8@74)8A-89',!W(7-8(-!('AB36!<7,,!78(4-'6-!9:76!<--;.!*39!8)9!*-('36-!)5! '8!38-FB-(9-=!785,3F!)5!?4'=3'9-!693=-896%!!

J!8-<!B'498-46:7B!*-9<--8!9:-!NX$^W!+)48!_)789!I'*)4'9)4>!'8=! Q)4(:-69-4!$)389>!_3*,7(!W(:)),6!<7,,!*478?!',,!`c0!6-@-89:!?4'=-! 693=-896!54)A!9:4)3?:)39!9:-!()389>!9)!9:-!+)48!_)789!I'*!9)!,-'48!57469k :'8=!'*)39!6(7-8(-!'8=!9:-74!,)(',!-8@74)8A-89%!ea+)48!_)789!I'*!2B-86! NB.a!Q$+#\!/!R^'69-48!W:)4-!)5!X'4>,'8=T.!W-B9-A*-4!/0.!/00d%f!

P8!9:76!B'66'?-.!9:-!()8(,367)8!76!9:'9!9:-!83A*-4!)5!693=-896!)8!9:-!N87@-4679>!)5! X'4>,'8=!$-89-4!5)4!^8@74)8A-89',!W(7-8(-!('AB36!<7,,!78(4-'6-!9:76!<--;%!C:-!'4?3-4! 36-6!E8)9!*-('36-E!9)!78=7('9-!9:'9!9:-!B4-A76-!5)4!9:76!()8(,367)8!76!8)9!9:'9!9:-4-!<7,,!*-! '8!38-FB-(9-=!785,3F!)5!?4'=3'9-!693=7-6%!I'9-4!)8.!9:-!'4?3-4!B4-6-896!9:-!B4-A76-H!

J!8-<!B'498-46:7B!*-9<--8!9:-!NX$^W!+)48!_)789!I'*)4'9)4>!'8=! Q)4(:-69-4!$)389>!_3*,7(!W(:)),6!<7,,!*478?!',,!`c0!6-@-89:!?4'=-! 693=-896!54)A!9:4)3?:)39!9:-!()389>!9)!9:-!+)48!_)789!I'*!9)!,-'48!57469k :'8=!'*)39!6(7-8(-!'8=!9:-74!,)(',!-8@74)8A-89%!

C:-!B:4'6-!EB'49,>!*-('36-E!76!36-=!9)!7894)=3(-!'!B4-A76-.!*39!9:-!A)=757-4!EB'49,>E! 78=7('9-6!9:'9!9:-!B4-A76-!7894)=3(-=!76!)8,>!)8-!)5!6-@-4',!B4-A76-6!5)4!9:-!()8(,367)8%! $)867=-4!9:-!5),,)<78?!-F'AB,-H!

P9E6!',<'>6!'!(:',,-8?-!9)!'!57,AkA';-4!<:-8!-@-4>*)=>!',4-'=>!;8)<6!9:-! 69)4>!:-E6!94>78?!9)!9-,,%!C:-!B,)9!'39)A'97(',,>!*-()A-6!'!5)4A',79>.!'8=! 9:-4-E6!8)!B)789!94>78?!9)!*37,=!636B-86-%!_'3,!U4--8?4'66E6!U)*%$2"de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e&'A-6!])<A'8.!aD)4,=!C4'=-!$-89-4.a!:($0*-!)" B/$-%!%&0.!J3?369!Y0.!/00d%f!

! d"!

P8!9:76!-F'AB,-.!])<A'8!?7@-6!9<)!B4-A76-6!9)!63BB)49!:76!()8(,367)8!9:'9!E&042"C0!2$" >$)%$0!76!,-66!63((-6653,!9:'8!U)*%$2"de!76!?-9978?!'4)38=!9:-!B4)*,-A!)5!9-,,78?!'!69)4>! 9:'9!-@-4>)8-!',4-'=>!;8)<6%!])<A'8E6!9<)!B4-A76-6!'4-H!

P8!E&042"C0!2$">$)%$0.!2,7@-4!W9)8-6!5)(36-6!)8!9:-!943-!69)4>!)5!9<)!)5! 9:-!@-4>!5-<!:'BB>!-8=78?6!)8!W-B9-A*-4!""9:.!/00"%!

C:-!B)<-453,!-A)97)86!E&042"C0!2$">$)%$0!?-8-4'9-6!*-()A-!-F(-667@-! '8=!789-,,-(93',,>!5'97?378?!78!9:-!'*6-8(-!)5!'8>!4'97)8',!54'A-<)4;!9)! ()89'78!9:-A%!

N63',,>.!*39!8)9!',<'>6.!<:-8!EB'49,>!*-('36-E!7894)=3(-6!'!B4-A76-.!'9!,-'69!)8-!)9:-4! B4-A76-!76!',6)!B4-6-89-=%!C:-!B4-(-=78?!-F'AB,-!7,,3694'9-6!9:76%!]39!9:76!=)-68E9!',<'>6! :'BB-8%!+-4-E6!'8!-F'AB,-!78!<:7(:!EB'49,>!*-('36-E!7894)=3(-6!'!B4-A76-!*39!8)!)9:-4! B4-A76-6!'4-!?7@-8H!

J!6-<-4!B7B-!*347-=!',)8?!b)39-!""]!*3469!W38='>!'59-48))8.!4-,-'678?! '*)39!"0.000!?',,)86!)5!<'69-<'9-4!789)!I';-!D7887B-6'3;--%!2557(7',6! 6'7=!9:->!=)8E9!*-,7-@-!9:-!,';-!<'6!*'=,>!()89'A78'9-=.!B'49,>!*-('36-!9:-! 6-<'?-!<'6!=7,39-=!*>!4'78<'9-4!54)A!4-(-89!69)4A6%!eX-,'87-!J6A'4.! aW-<-4!I-';!+796!D7887B-6'3;--.a">&)-&02"I&)*%&0!RK-<!+'AB6:74-T.! X'>!"0.!/00c%f!

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

J!5-<!)9:-4!B:4'6-6!9:'9!<)4;!,7;-!EB'49,>!*-('36-E!'4-!E78!B'49!*-('36-E.!E8)9!)8,>! *-('36-E.!E8)9!n369!*-('36-E.!EA'78,>!*-('36-E.!'8=!EA)69,>!*-('36-E%!

! d/!

5H=-I!-J*5HKLMJN?*?JI*OPOOQ*

!>JSI!<8!ST*5HJN!?J?*!S*5=??=TJ?*R?!ST*

ESKI*LJ-=R?JEZ*E5=HIM8*LJ-=R?JEZ*=S>*?!N!M=H*5AH=?J?*

P86943(97)86H!L&0"$!-,"/!##!G$?"+0*%$"!)A"!)2"!44"/0$(*#$#7"8$"#60$"%&"+0*%$"%,$"'*0#%" /0$(*#$"*)"#6-,"!"+!A"%,!%"*%"(!D$#"#$)#$"3A"*%#$4'?"!)2"%&"+0*%$"!)A"!22*%*&)!4"/0$(*#$#"

#&"%,!%"%,$A"(!D$"#$)#$"G*5$)"%,$"/0$5*&6#"/0$(*#$#7"I!D$"-4$!0"%,$"0$'$0$)%#"&'"!)A"

/0&)&6)#"6#$2?"6)4$##"%,$"/0$(*#$"*#"!3&6%"%,$"!0G6$0X"*'"%,$"/0$(*#$"*#"!3&6%"%,$"!0G6$0?"

A&6"(!A"4$!5$"%,$"/$0#&)!4"/0&)&6)#"%,!%"0$'$0"%&"%,$"!6%,&07"M&")&%"!22"!)A"$44*/#$#7!

W'AB,-!_4)*,-A6H!

! ! 247?78',!_'66'?-H!

234!=7-9!76!'BB',,78?!!!8)9!*-('36-!<-!-'9!9))!A3(:!A-'9.!8)9!*-('36-!<-! ('8E9!?7@-!3B!-??6.!'8=!8)9!*-('36-!<-!,)@-!)34!*399-4!%%%!*39!*-('36-!<-E4-! 4-B,'(78?!a4-',!5))=a!<79:!B4)(-66-=!5))=6!47(:!<79:!'==-=!63?'46.!'==-=! @-?-9'*,-!)7,6!'8=!4-578-=!?4'786V!eb-?78'!D7,6:74-.!aC:-!]7?!G'9!&);-!)5! 234!Q7-9'4>!b-()AA-8='97)86!78!9:-!NW.a!>&((&)"Y&*-$!RW)39:! $'4),78'T.!G-*43'4>!/0.!/001%f!

! ! J86<-4H!

_4-A76-H!

D-E4-!4-B,'(78?!a4-',!5))=a!<79:!B4)(-66-=!5))=6!47(:!<79:!'==-=!63?'46.! '==-=!@-?-9'*,-!)7,6!'8=!4-578-=!?4'786%!

247?78',!_'66'?-H!

JA-47('!76!-F(-B97)8',!8)9!)8,>!*-('36-!79!B4)@7=-6!=3-!B4)(-66!'8=!'! 6-9978?!5)4!54--!(3,934',!-FB4-667)8!*39!',6)!*-('36-!79!#A)%,$#*\$#!9:-!A'8>! (3,934-6!79!<-,()A-6%!e^47(!I73.!C,$":--*2$)%!4":#*!)="Q&%$#"&'"!"Q!%*5$" B/$!D$0%!RK-<!L)4;H!b'8=)A!+)36-.!"ggiT.!B%!"/i%f!

! ! J86<-4H!

_4-A76-6H!

JA-47('!B4)@7=-6!=3-!B4)(-66!'8=!'!6-9978?!5)4!54--!(3,934',!-FB4-667)8%!

JA-47('!6>89:-67Z-6!9:-!A'8>!(3,934-6!79!<-,()A-6%!

"%!I'8(-!J4A694)8?E6!9-'AA'9-6!<)3,=!47=-!9:4)3?:!574-!5)4!:7A.!8)9!*-('36-!)5!A)8->! )4!9:-!n-46->6!)8!9:-74!*'(;6.!*39!*-('36-!:-E6!A'69-4-=!9:-!'49!)5!-55-(97@-!,-'=-46:7B%! eI78=6->!C'88-4.!aJ4A694)8?E6!I-'=-46:7B!$3,97@'9-6!^F(-,,-8(-.a!K$T*)G%&)" M*#/!%-,!Rj-893(;>T.!&3,>!c.!/00c%f!!!

! dY!

/%!KJC2!76!)8-!)5!9:-!A)69!63((-6653,!A7,79'4>!',,7'8(-6!78!:769)4>.!'8=!'!=-('=-!'8=!'! :',5!'59-4!796!*,))=,-66!@7(9)4>!)@-4!9:-!D'46'<!_'(9.!79!76!*7??-4!9:'8!-@-4%!]39!<:7,-! 79!:'6!?4)<8!78!A-A*-46:7B.!79!:'6!8)9!'663A-=!'!A3(:!A)4-!5)4(-53,!B,'(-!78!<)4,=! '55'746%!

C:'9E6!B'49,>!*-('36-!9:-!N879-=!W9'9-6!?)@-48A-89.!38=-4!_4-67=-89!]36:.!:'6!786769-=! )8!=)78?!A)4-!9:'8!-@-4.!)59-8!387,'9-4',,>%!]39!79E6!',6)!*-('36-!^34)B-!=-(,78-6!9)! 9';-!9:-!69-B6!8-(-66'4>!9)!-8,'4?-!796!?,)*',!785,3-8(-%!ea^34)B-E6!Q7,-AA'.a!>,*-!G&" C0*36)$.!K)@-A*-4!/i.!/00d%f!

Y%!J,,!67=-6!()8(34!9:'9!9:-!69)8-!9:'9!69'46!78!a],))=!Q7'A)8=a!76!'8!'8)A',>.!8)9!n369! *-('36-!)5!796!e,'4?-f!67Z-.!*39!',6)!*-('36-!9:-!@'69!A'n)479>!)5!=7'A)8=6!9:'9!A';-!79! 54)A!@),('87(!=-B)6796!9)!n-<-,4>!69)4-6!78!63*34*'8!A',,6!=)!8)9!78@),@-!'8>! @7),-8(-%!e&36978!Q'@7=6)8.!aQ-'=,>!Q7'A)8=!I369.a!Q$+"<&0D"Q$+#2!A.!K)@-A*-4! /i.!/00d%f!

4. There are very few rice-based dishes served in my home, mostly because of the near- empty calories, and partly because of the disagreement over what constitutes good rice. [Suzanne Crow Haggerty, "Off the Shelf," Mobile Register (Alabama), August 30, 2006.] !

c%!C:-!)8-!*,'(;!5'A7,>!)8!9:-!C*%!)*-!<'6!3897,!4-(-89,>!,)69!9)!:769)4>!78!B'49!*-('36-! aP9',7'8a!<'6!36-=!'6!a'!?-8-47(!9-4A!5)4!',,!)5!9:-!='4;-4k6;788-=!B'66-8?-46a!)8*)'4=! R'BB'4-89,>!78(,3=78?!6)A-!<:)!<-4-!&'B'8-6-T%!eh)8=4'!+3?:-6.!aD:'9!+'BB-8-=!9)! 9:-!28,>!],'(;!G'A7,>!)8!9:-!C*%!)*-M.a!;3&)A!cc!R&38-!/000T.!O3)9-=!78!Q'@7=!b%! b)-=7?-4.!E&0D*)G"C&+!02"E,*%$)$##="F&+":($0*-!J#"@((*G0!)%#"8$-!($"E,*%$%! RK-<!L)4;H!]'67(!]));6.!/00cT.!B%!`1%f!!!

d%!I-9E6!5'(-!5'(96.!<:-8!79!()A-6!9)!=7?79',!57,-6.!()B>47?:9!76!=-'=%!

K)9!*-('36-!9:-!7=-'!e)5f!()B>47?:9!:'6!8)!A-479%!J!(4-'9)4!)5!'!<)4;!:'6!9:-!47?:9!9)! ()894),.!78!!)A"<'>!9:->!(:))6-.!9:-!36-!)5!9:'9!<)4;%!$)B>47?:9!76!=-'=!*-('36-!79!76! 1F?$221:&58')52?1;5';<$*26=)2'$#'-'&6%2*1;2';$';<5'+$=;(6(78';$'5=#$(+5'+$?7(1><;'&6%2'

78!'!=7?79',!<)4,=%!e_-9-4!=-!&'?-4.!a$)B>47?:9!76!Q-'=!!!I)8?!I7@-!o37=!_4)!o3).a! C&0&)%&"94&3$"!)2"I!*4.!X'>!/`.!/00c%f!

1%!C:76!76!9:-!*-69!97A-!78!:769)4>!9)!*-!'!*'6-*',,!?--;%!K)9!)8,>!'4-!9:-!?'A-E6!A)69! :',,)<-=!4-()4=6!3B!5)4!?4'*6.!*39!9-(:8),)?>!:'6!A'=-!79!'!(78(:!9)!(438(:!69'96%! eJ,,-8!W9%!&):8.!a]'44>!@6%!9:-!]'*-.a!H&/64!0"I$-,!)*-#!RJB47,!/00cT.!B%!c`%f!!!

! d`!

i%!_'49,>!*-('36-!,)96!)5!B-)B,-!63BB)6-!9:->!=)8E9!;8)<!'8>!?'>!B-)B,-!'8=!B'49,>! 9:4)3?:!9:-!A'789'7878?!)5!69-4-)9>B-6.!6)(7-9>!'9!,'4?-!76!38'<'4-!)5!9:-!A'8>!<'>6! 1='%<1+<'>672'6(5'2*:R5+;';$')12+(1F1=6;1$=-.'/G1+<6()'[.'b$<(8':"I&0$"H$0'$-%"

U)*&)="E,A"B%0!*G,%":($0*-!"I6#%"B%!)2"U/"'&0"9!A"O*G,%#%!R])69)8H!]-'()8!_4-66.! "gg`T.!B%!`%f!

g%!b6=7'-'/g.'3.'b6(1=52'1='P$(56M'%5(5'(5&*+;6=;';$':5'2%1;+<5)'$*;'$#';<5'/#($=;M'&1=5' 789)!4-6-4@-!e38796f.!8)9!)8,>!*-('36-!9:->!<-4-!-'4878?!,-66!B)7896!9)<'4=!9:-74!='>!)5! 4-,-'6-!e54)A!=39>!78!j)4-'f.!*39!*-('36-!4-6-4@-!38796!<-4-!8'??-=!<79:!94'7878?!'8=! 786B-(97)86!'8=!<-4-!697,,!,7'*,-!9)!*-!(',,-=!5)4<'4=!9)!57,,!6'8=*'?6!'8=!57,,!94-8(:-6.! )59-8!A)4-!='8?-4)36,>!-FB)678?!9:-A!e9)!-8-A>!574-f!9:'8!9:-!A-8!)8!,78-%!eX'F! +'6978?6.!C,$"N&0$!)"E!0%!RK-<!L)4;H!W7A)8!'8=!W(:369-4.!"gi1T.!B%!/iY%f!

"0%!b-6B-(9!5)4!9:-!43,-!)5!,'<!76!'!538='A-89',!9-8-9!)5!()86-4@'976A%!J6!63(:.! ()86-4@'97@-6!6:)3,=!)BB)6-!9:-!B4)B)6-=!*'8!)8!B'497',k*749:!'*)497)8%!D:>M!K)9! *-('36-!)5!9:-!-87?A'97(.!7,,k=-578-=!a47?:9!9)!B47@'(>a!*39!*-('36-!8)9:78?!78!9:-! $)86979397)8!'39:)47Z-6!9:-!5-=-4',!?)@-48A-89!9)!B'66!63(:!'!,'<%!RC:-!'39:)46!)5!9:-! *7,,!4-,>!)8!9:-!()AA-4(-!(,'36-VT!J!943-!()86-4@'97@-!<)3,=!=-A)8694'9-!4-6B-(9!5)4! 9:-!43,-!)5!,'<!'8=!9:-!,7A796!7AB)6-=!*>!)34!<4799-8!$)86979397)8!*>!)BB)678?!9:-! *'8!)8!B'497',k*749:!'*)497)8%!eK7(:),'6!]3((),'.!I-99-4!9)!9:-!^=79)4.!K&#":)G$4$#" C*($#.!&38-!g.!/00Y%f!!!

! dc!

=$0'1,"#*H,(%"2#$'(#)%"*

J4?3A-89!4-()86943(97)8!76!'!5)4A'9!5)4!4-<47978?!'4?3A-896!9:'9!A';-6!(,-'4!<:7(:! 69'9-A-896!'4-!B4-A76-6!'8=!<:7(:!76!9:-!()8(,367)8%!P9!('8!*-!@-4>!36-53,!9)!4-()86943(9! '8!'4?3A-89!*-5)4-!-@',3'978?!79%!J4?3A-89!4-()86943(97)8.!P!:)B-.!<7,,!',6)!:-,B!>)3! 38=-469'8=!9:-!4-A'7878?!9)B7(6!78!$:'B9-4!28-H!3869'9-=!()8(,367)86!'8=! 63*()8(,367)86%!W).!<-E,,!5)(36!)8!'4?3A-89!4-()86943(97)8!8)<!'8=!=4'<!)8!9:76!,'9-4! <:-8!<-!'4-!-@',3'978?!'4?3A-896%!

C:-4-!'4-!57@-!43,-6!9)!5),,)<!<:-8!4-()86943(978?!'8!'4?3A-89%!

!

ARGUMENT RECONSTRUCTION RULES!

"%!D479-!-'(:!B4-A76-!'6!'!6-B'4'9-.!()AB,-9-.!83A*-4-=!6-89-8(-!9:'9!76! B:4'6-=!'6!'!69'9-A-89%!]-!634-!9)!78(,3=-!',,!9:-!785)4A'97)8!4-,-@'89!9)! 9:-!'4?3A-89%!

/%!D479-!9:-!()8(,367)8!,'69.!?7@78?!79!'!83A*-4!'8=!B39978?!'!,78-!*-9<--8!79! '8=!9:-!,'69!B4-A76-%!X';-!634-!79!76!'!()AB,-9-!6-89-8(-!9:'9!76!B:4'6-=! '6!'!69'9-A-89%!

Y%!Q)!8)9!78(,3=-!B4-A76-!'8=!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-46!78!>)34!B4-A76-6!'8=! ()8(,367)86[!B4-A76-!'8=!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-46!,-9!36!;8)<!<:-4-! B4-A76-6!'8=!()8(,367)86!'4-.!*39!9:->!'4-!8)9!B'496!)5!B4-A76-6!'8=! ()8(,367)86%!

`%!D:-8-@-4!B)667*,-.!A';-!634-!9:'9!'8>!B4)8)386!>)3!36-!:'@-!4-5-4-896! 9:'9!:'@-!*--8!36-=!-'4,7-4%!G)4!-F'AB,-.!=)!8)9!69'49!>)34!57469!B4-A76-! <79:!9:-!<)4=!E79E.!*39!>)3!A'>!36-!E79E!,'9-4!78!>)34!4-()86943(97)8!'59-4! >)3!:'@-!',4-'=>!<4799-8!9:-!8)38!9)!<:7(:!E79E!4-5-46%!RL)3!A'>!,-'@-! B4)8)386!9:'9!4-5-4!9)!9:-!'4?3-4%T!

c%!C:-!<)4=78?!>)3!36-!=)-6!8)9!:'@-!9)!*-!9:-!6'A-!'6!78!9:-!)47?78',! '4?3A-89[!78!5'(9.!78!6)A-!('6-6!79!('88)9!*-!9:-!6'A-%!]39!9:-!A-'878?! A369!*-!9:-!6'A-%!

!

! dd!

+-4-!76!'!67AB,-!-F'AB,-H!

]-('36-!A-=7(78-!789-4@-8-6!O37(;,>!78!789-46-F!*749:6!9)!(:'8?-!9:-! 785'89E6!*)=>.!9:-!B:-8)A-8)8!)5!789-46-F3',79>!76!9)='>!,'4?-,>!38;8)<8! )3967=-!6B-(7',7Z-=!A-=7(',!B4'(97(-6%!e$:-4>,!$:'6-.!a+-4A'B:4)=79-6! <79:!J99793=-H!X'BB78?!9:-!^A-4?-8(-!)5!P89-46-F!_),797(',!J([email protected]! 9KZ=":"P&60)!4"&'"K$#3*!)"!)2"9!A"B%62*$#!`H/!R"ggiT.!B%!"ig%f!

C:-!<)4=!E*-('36-E!7894)=3(-6!9:-!'4?3A-89E6!)8,>!B4-A76-.!<:7(:!76!9:-!5),,)<78?H!

X-=7(78-!789-4@-8-6!O37(;,>!78!789-46-F!*749:6!9)!(:'8?-!9:-!785'89E6!*)=>%!

C:-!()8(,367)8.!9:-8.!76!9:-!5),,)<78?!69'9-A-89H!

C:-!B:-8)A-8)8!)5!789-46-F3',79>!76!9)='>!,'4?-,>!38;8)<8!)3967=-! 6B-(7',7Z-=!A-=7(',!B4'(97(-6%!

G),,)<78?!9:-!'4?3A-89!4-()86943(97)8!43,-6.!<-!?-9!9:76!4-()86943(97)8H!

R"T!X-=7(78-!789-4@-8-6!O37(;,>!78!789-46-F!*749:6!9)!(:'8?-!9:-!785'89E6! *)=>%!

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!C:-!B:-8)A-8)8!)5!789-46-F3',79>!76!9)='>!,'4?-,>!38;8)<8!)3967=-! 6B-(7',7Z-=!A-=7(',!B4'(97(-6%!

K)97(-!9:'9!P!=7=!8)9!78(,3=-!9:-!<)4=!E*-('36-E!78!9:76!4-()86943(97)8%!+-4-E6!<:>H! E*-('36-E!76!'!B4-A76-!7894)=3(-4.!8)9!B'49!)5!'!B4-A76-%!

+-4-!76!'8)9:-4!5'74,>!67AB,-!-F'AB,-%!28!K)@-A*-4!"".!/00`.!9:-!a$'AB36!l)7(-! o3-697)8a!78!9:-"M!*4A"B6)2*!4!R$',75)487'!W9'9-!N87@-4679>.!K)49:47=?-T!<'6H!

Q)!>)3!9:78;!9:-!B4-67=-89!6:)3,=!*-!-,-(9-=!*>!B)B3,'4!@)9-M!

28-!'86<-4.!?7@-8!*>!n387)4!^8?,76:!A'n)4!b'5--;!U:'99'6.!<'6H!

K).!*-('36-!9:-!B4-67=-89!6:)3,=!4-B4-6-89!9:-!8'97)8!'6!'!<:),-!'8=!8)9! n369!9:-!A)69!B)B3,'9-=!(797-6%!

D-!('8!4-()86943(9!U:'99'6E!'4?3A-89!9:76!<'>H!

R"T!C:-!B4-67=-89!6:)3,=!4-B4-6-89!9:-!8'97)8!'6!'!<:),-!'8=!8)9!n369!9:-! A)69!B)B3,'9-=!(797-6%!

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!C:-!B4-67=-89!6:)3,=!8)9!*-!-,-(9-=!*>!B)B3,'4!@)9-%!

! d1!

+-4-!76!'8!-F'AB,-!9:'9!7,,3694'9-6!6-@-4',!'6B-(96!)5!'4?3A-89!4-()86943(97)8!8)9! 7,,3694'9-=!*>!9:-!-'4,7-4!-F'AB,-6H!

D`&'3<*,(1R*F6<'12'-'1=N$&N5)'%1;<'6&'n65)6';5(($(12;'6+;1N1;152'6=)'-'

B)6-6!'!6-47)36!9:4-'9!9)!N%W%!(797Z-86!'8=!789-4-696!<)4,=<7=-.a!9:-!G]P! 6'7=!78!'!69'9-A-89%!e$KK.!X'4(:!/0.!/00Y%f!

K)!B4-A76-!)4!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-46!'4-!36-=!78!9:76!'4?3A-89.!*39!<-!()3,=!'==!9:-! <)4=!E9:-4-5)4-E!47?:9!*-5)4-!9:-!<)4=!EB)6-6E%!W).!9:-!G]PE6!()8(,367)8!76!9:'9!^,! W:3;47n3A':!B)6-6!'!6-47)36!9:4-'9!9)!N%W%!(797Z-86!'8=!789-4-696!<)4,=<7=-%!J==78?! E9:-4-5)4-E!76!'!?4-'9!<'>!9)!6--!<:7(:!69'9-A-89!76!9:-!()8(,367)8.!*39!E9:-4-5)4-E!76!'! ()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4!'8=!6)!79E6!8)9!B'49!)5!9:-!()8(,367)8%!W).!<-!<7,,!8)9!78(,3=-!9:-! <)4=!E9:-4-5)4-E!78!)34!'4?3A-89!4-()86943(97)8%!

K)97(-!9:'9!9:76!'4?3A-89!76!'9947*39-=!9)!9:-!G]P[!9:-!G]P!768E9!B'49!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89%!W).! )34!4-()86943(97)8!<7,,!8)9!78(,3=-!'8>9:78?!'*)39!9:-!G]P%!J8)9:-4!'6B-(9!)5!'4?3A-89! 4-()86943(97)8!9:76!-F'AB,-!7,,3694'9-6!:'6!9)!=)!<79:!:)<!9:-!()8(,367)8!76!B:4'6-=!78!9:-! )47?78',[!79!76!8)9!B:4'6-=!'6!'!()AB,-9-!6-89-8(-.!*-('36-!79!:'6!8)!63*n-(9%!D-!<7,,!8--=! 9)!'==!9:-!()8(,367)8E6!63*n-(9!78!)34!4-()86943(97)8%!

C';78?!9:-6-!()867=-4'97)86!789)!'(()389.!:-4-E6!9:-!4-()86943(97)8!)5!9:-!G]PE6!'4?3A-89H!

R"T!^,!W:3;47n3A':!76!78@),@-=!<79:!',!o'-='!9-44)4769!'(97@797-6%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!^,!W:3;47n3A':!B)6-6!'!6-47)36!9:4-'9!9)!N%W%!(797Z-86!'8=!789-4-696!<)4,=<7=-%!

I-9!A-!A';-!)8-!A)4-!()AA-89!'*)39!9:76!-F'AB,-!*-5)4-!<-!,-'@-!79%!D:-8!P!<4)9-!9:-! ()8(,367)8.!P!()3,=!:'@-!4-B,'(-=!9:-!B4)B-4!8'A-!E^,!W:3;47n3A':E!<79:!9:-!B4)8)38!E:-E.! *-('36-!9:-!4-5-4-89!)5!9:'9!B4)8)38!<)3,=!:'@-!*--8!(,-'4!54)A!9:-!B4-A76-%!^79:-4! <)3,=!:'@-!*--8!n369!578-!78!9:-!()8(,367)8%!]39!78!9:-!B4-A76-.!P!:'=!9)!36-!9:-!B4)B-4! 8'A-!E^,!W:3;47n3A':E.!8)9!9:-!B4)8)38!E:-E%!

! di!

b-A-A*-4!9:'9!9:-4-!76!8)!4-6947(97)8!)8!9:-!83A*-4!)5!B4-A76-6!'8!'4?3A-89!('8!:'@-%! +-4-!76!'8!-F'AB,-!<79:!9<)!B4-A76-6H!

X'4?'4-9!K'=74.!'!()8(-48-=!B'4-89!'8=!5'(3,9>!A-A*-4.!63??-69-=!9:'9! B3*,76:-46!6:)3,=!69)B!B478978?!:'4=*)38=!*));6!*-('36-!:'4=*)38=! *));6!9-8=!9)!*-!A)4-!-FB-867@-!9:'8!B'B-4*'(;!*));6%!W:-!<'6!',6)! ()8(-48-=!<79:!9:-!<-7?:9!)5!9:-!*));6!*-78?!='A'?78?!5)4!693=-896E! *'(;6%!

"What are they trying to do, break their backs and then their pockets?" said Nadir. eW36'8!J;63.!aW93=-896!]4-';!]'8;!9)!]3>!C-F9*));6.a!;4" Y!V6$0&!RU,-8=',-!$)AA3879>!$),,-?-.!$',75)487'T.!JB47,!"Y.!/001%f!

;4"Y!V6$0&!4-B)49-4!W36'8!J;63!36-6!E*-('36-E!9)!7894)=3(-!'!B4-A76-!78!9:-!'4?3A-89! 6:-!'9947*39-6!9)!X'4?'4-9!K'=74%!]39!9:-!()8(-48!)5!K'=74E6!4-B)49-=!78!9:-!,'69!6-89-8(-! )5!9:-!57469!B'4'?4'B:!76!',6)!789-8=-=!'6!'!4-'6)8!9)!*-,7-@-!:-4!()8(,367)8!9:'9!B3*,76:-46! 6:)3,=!69)B!B478978?!:'4=*)38=!*));6%!+-4-!76!'!4-()86943(97)8!)5!K'=74E6!'4?3A-89H!

R"T!+'4=*)38=!*));6!9-8=!9)!*-!A)4-!-FB-867@-!9:'8!B'B-4*'(;!*));6%! R/T!C:-!<-7?:9!)5!:'4=*)38=!*));6!('8!='A'?-!693=-896E!*'(;6%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! !RYT!_3*,76:-46!6:)3,=!69)B!B478978?!:'4=*)38=!*));6%!

! dg!

5H=-I!-J*5HKLMJN?*?JI*OPOUQ*

HJ-KS?IHR-I!ST*=HTRNJSI?*

P86943(97)86H!O$-&)#%06-%"$!-,"!0G6($)%"*)"%,*#"/0!-%*-$"/0&34$(#"#$%?"'&44&+*)G"%,$"'*5$" !0G6($)%"0$-&)#%06-%*&)"064$#7"

W'AB,-!_4)*,-A6H!

! ! 247?78',!J4?3A-89H!

W78(-!9:-!->-!76!9:-!<78=)<!)5!9:-!6)3,.!9:-!,'99-4!76!',<'>6!78!5-'4!)5! :51=>')5?(1N5)'$#'1;-.'/05$=6()$')6'e1=+18'd*$;5)'1='`&F5('45&;8'

K$&)!02&"%,$":)!%&(*#%%!RI'<4-8(-.!j'86'6H!N87@-4679>!)5!j'86'6!_4-66.! "gccT.!B%!Y`%f!

! ! J86<-4H!

R"T!C:-!->-!76!9:-!<78=)<!)5!9:-!6)3,%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!C:-!6)3,!76!',<'>6!78!5-'4!)5!*-78?!=-B47@-=!)5!9:-!->-%!

! ! 247?78',!J4?3A-89H!

P8!4-6B)86-!9)!9:-!=-'9:!)5!9:-!-,-B:'89!D'8;7-.!8)!'87A',!47?:96!'(97@769!P! ;8)<!76!6'>78?.!aD-!9),=!>)3!6)%a!D-!n369!()89783-!)34!<)4;H!D-!-FB,'78! <:>!-,-B:'896!=)!8)9!*-,)8?!78!Z))6!R)4!(74(36-6T[!<-!B)789!)39!9:'9!9:->! '4-!8)9!9)!*-!('B934-=!'8=!()8578-=!5)4!)34!-89-49'78A-89[!'8=!<-!6:)<! 9:'9!9:->!6355-4!'8=!=7-!8--=,-66,>!<:-8!9:->!('88)9!4)'A!?4-'9!=769'8(-6! '8=!*)8=!<79:!A-A*-46!)5!9:-74!,'4?-!5'A7,7-6%!D-!<)4;!9)!6'@-!9:-74! 8'934',!:'*79'96%!J8=!<-!?47-@-!'6!<-!6B-';!)39!5)4!'87A',6!9:'9!('88)9! B4)9-69!9:-74!388'934',!()8578-A-89!)8!9:-74!)<8!*-:',5%!e_'997!]4-79A'8.! I-99-4!9)!9:-!^=79)4.!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!X'>!1.!/00c%f!

! ! J86<-4H!

R"T!^,-B:'896!'4-!8)9!9)!*-!('B934-=!'8=!()8578-=!5)4!)34!-89-49'78A-89%! R/T!C:->!6355-4!'8=!=7-!8--=,-66,>!<:-8!9:->!('88)9!4)'A!?4-'9!=769'8(-6! '8=!*)8=!<79:!A-A*-46!)5!9:-74!,'4?-!5'A7,7-6%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\!

RYT!C:->!=)!8)9!*-,)8?!78!Z))6!)4!(74(36-6%!

"%!P9!-!))&%!*-!B)667*,-!9)!B4)@-!A'9:-A'97(',,>!9:'9!9:-4-!<7,,!*-!'8!-(,7B6-!9)kA)44)<.! *-('36-!-(,7B6-6.!'8=!)9:-4!B:>67(',!B:-8)A-8'.!=)!8)9!5)4A!B'49!)5!9:-!'*694'(9!<)4,=! $#'F6;<5F6;1+2-.'eU%!+%!+'4=>.!:"I!%,$(!%*-*!)J#":/&4&GA%!R$'A*47=?-H!$'A*47=?-! N87@-4679>!_4-66.!"g`0S"gicT.!B%!"01%f!

/%!]-('36-!)5!796!,)8?!,'B-,6.!9:-!)8-k*399)8!6379!A';-6!6:)49!?3>6!,));!9',,-4!'8=!8-'4,>! -@-4>)8-!,));!9:788-4%!eaC:-!_)<-4!)5!28-.a!9Z!RG-*43'4>!/001T.!B%!"/Y%f!!!

! 10!

Y%!S%#,Q!I$%0&/&4*%!)"B%!%$"F&#/*%!4?"4&-!%$2"*)"Q&0+!4D?">!4*'&0)*!?"*#"!"#%!%$"($)%!4" ,&#/*%!47"

]-('36-!)5!,)<!<'?-6.!9:-4-!76!'!(:4)87(!6:)49'?-!)5!834678?!69'55!'9!X-94)B),79'8! W9'9-!+)6B79',%!eX'4;!C'(;-99.!I-99-4!9)!9:-!^=79)4.!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!G-*43'4>!`.! /001%f!

`%!C:-!,1$='-'+<6252'6'<5()'$#'6=;5&$?5'$('6'21=>&5'6=1F6&';$%6()2';<5'&1$=5228'%61;1=>'1=' 'A*36:.!678(-!6:-!76!A)4-!6;7,53,!'9!B)38(78?!3B)8!9:-!;7,,%!e^A7,!W(:3,9:-66.!:'0*-!.! 4-@%!-=%.!94'86,'9-=!*>!]47'8!]'99-46:'<!'8=!C%!'8=!j%!W(:-,*-49%!RK-<!L)4;H!W7A)8! '8=!W(:369-4.!"gdgT.!8%B%f!!!

c%!-/O<5'I<1=525M'F1225)'F6=7')6^^&1=>'$??$(;*=1;152';$'6==1<1&6;5'(6;<5(';<6='F5(5&7' =47@-!*'(;!X'(J49:34E6!'4A>!78!j)4-'!=3478?!9:-!<789-4!)5!"gc0!*-('36-!9:->!()3,=! A)@-!)8,>!'6!5'69!'6!9:-74!5--9!()3,=!('44>!9:-A.!'8=!9:-74!4'=7)!()AA387('97)86!<-4-! 6)!B))4!9:'9!9:->!()3,=!8)9!())4=78'9-!,'4?-k6(',-!A)@-A-896!-55-(97@-,>%!eX'F! +'6978?6.!C,$"N&0$!)"E!0%!RK-<!L)4;H!W7A)8!'8=!W(:369-4.!"gi1T.!B%!"1"%f!

d%!S%#,Q!C,$"#/$!D$0"*#"!"'*-%*&)!4"-,!0!-%$07!

]-78?!'!WB);'8-!P8=7'8.!P!)8,>!B7(;!3B!P8=7'8!:79(::7;-46%!eW:-4A'8!J,-F7-.!aC:-! C)3?:-69!P8=7'8!78!9:-!D)4,=.a!78!C,$"C&6G,$#%"@)2*!)"*)"%,$"E&042%!RK-<!L)4;H! J9,'897(!X)89:,>!_4-66.!/000T.!B%!/"%f!

1%!JA-47('!768E9!'8!788)(-89!B'49>%!C:->!(4-'9-=!e26'A'f!*78!I'=-8%!eL0&)%4*)$.!&38-!"/.! /00Y%f!

i%!K-@-4!'4?3-!<79:!>)34!=)(9)4!!!:-!:'6!7867=-!785)4A'97)8%!e+-88>!L)38?A'8.!C,$" ;)-A-4&/$2*!"&'"S)$"K*)$0#.!-=%!^=!W:'8'B:>%!Rj'9)8':.!K%L%H!]',,>A)9-!]));6.! "gigT.!B%!"d%f!!!

g%!S%#,Q!:"#A44&G*#("*#"!"D*)2"&'"!0G6($)%"+$"+*44"#%62A"*)">,!/%$0"C,0$$7!

%%%eCf:-!]36:!J=A787694'97)8E6!'4?3A-89!5)4!B)<-4!'BB'4-89,>!()A-6!=)<8!9)!'!8-'9! 6>,,)?76A.!'6!5),,)<6H!C:-!$)86979397)8!A';-6!9:-!B4-67=-89!9:-!()AA'8=-4k78k(:7-5! 78!'!97A-!)5!<'4%!C:-!()AA'8=-4k78k(:7-5!A369!:'@-!8-'4,>!38,7A79-=!B)<-46!9)!;--B! 9:-!()3894>!6'5-!'8=!9)!B4)6-(39-!:)697,797-6%!C:36!=3478?!'!97A-!)5!<'4.!9:-!NW! B4-67=-89!:'6!8-'4,>!38,7A79-=!B)<-4%!ea$)86979397)8',!JA-8=A-89!W-9.a!L0$$"I!0D$%" Q$+#"Q$%+&0D!RG,)47='T.!G-*43'4>!"Y.!/00d%f!!!

! 1"!

"0%!J!=7@-46-!5'(3,9>!76!@-4>!7AB)49'89!5)4!A'8>!4-'6)86.!8)9!9:-!,-'69!)5!<:7(:!76!9:-!5'(9! 9:'9!5'(3,9>!6-4@-!'6!A-89)46!'8=!4),-!A)=-,6!5)4!693=-896!'8=!79!76!7AB)49'89!9:'9! 693=-896!('8!6--!9:-A6-,@-6!78!9:-74!5'(3,9>%!e^,7Z'*-9:!W'>.!Q-'8!)5!9:-!$),,-?-!)5! +3A'8797-6.!O3)9-=!78!J47'8'!b)=47?3-Z.!aN87@-4679>!W947@-6!5)4!X)4-!Q7@-46-! G'(3,9>.a!M!*4A"B6)2*!4.!R$',75)487'!W9'9-!N87@-4679>.!K)49:47=?-T.!K)@-A*-4!//.! /00c%f!

""%!J49:47976!B)6-6!'!:3?-!6)(7-9',!*34=-8!8)9!)8,>!*-('36-!)5!796!:7?:!B4-@',-8(-!'8=! ,'4?-!-()8)A7(!7AB'(9.!*39!',6)!*-('36-!)5!9:-!B'78!'8=!538(97)8',!,7A79'97)86!79! ('36-6!5)4!B-)B,-%!eX'4?'4-9!W:7:.!789-47A!(:7-5!)5!9:-!I)6!J8?-,-6!$)389>!+-',9:! J66-66A-89!N879.!O3)9-=!78!a/0!_-4(-89!)5!I)6!J8?-,-6!$)389>!J=3,96!W355-4!54)A! J49:47976.!K-<!b-B)49!W'>6.a!Q&0%,$!#%"B6)"RI)6!J8?-,-6T.!X'>!/c.!/00d%f!!!

"/%!J,9:)3?:!B-)B,-!:'@-!*--8!3678?!9:-A!5)4!>-'46!9)!:),=!*'(;!:7,,6!'8=!A';-!4'76-=! *-=6.!4'7,4)'=!97-6!6:)3,=!8)9!*-!36-=!8-'4!@-?-9'*,-6%!J8>!A'9-47',!9:'9!B4-@-896! <))=!54)A!4)9978?!('88)9!*-!?))=!5)4!9:-!@-?-9'*,-6!)4!>)3%!b'7,4)'=!97-6!'4-!94-'9-=! %1;<'+(5$2$;5'/;$'?(5N5=;'($;;1=>M-8'2672'2$1&'2+15=;12;'_6(='B6&&6+58'$#'B6&&6+5'

I'*)4'9)47-6!78!^,!W-?38=).!'!6)7,!()863,978?!'8=!9-6978?!574A%!eb)*-49!WA'36.! :)#+$0#"'&0">!4*'&0)*!"9!02$)$0#%!RI)6!J8?-,-6H!I)6!J8?-,-6!C7A-6!]));6.!/00/T.! B%!ig%f!

"Y%!+'4),=!R+'BB>T!X-,9Z-4!%%%!<'6!'44-69-=!*>!'=A787694'97@-!@7(-!6O3'=!)557(-46!5)4! ('44>78?!'!()8(-',-=!<-'B)8.!'!B769),.!<:7(:!78!:76!('6-.!78'6A3(:!'6!:-!<'6!'8!-Fk ()8@7(9.!<'6!'!5-,)8>%!e$:'4,-6!W9);-4.!C,*-D$0J)"C,*$5$#7!RW'89'!X)87('H!W7=-4-',! $)AB'8>.!"gc"T.!B%!`0d%f!!!

"`%!S%#,Q!:)20$!"M+&0D*)"+!#"!"'$(*)*#%"!6%,&0"!)2"!-%*5*#%"+,&"2*$2"*)"iffj7"B,$"+!#" 3$#%"D)&+)"'&0",$0"!)%*R/&0)&G0!/,A"+&0D7"B&($"&'",$0"-0*%*-#"-4!*($2"%,!%"#,$",!%$2"

($)7!

P!'A!'!A'8!<:)!:'6!4-'=!',,!)5!eJ8=4-'f!Q<)4;78E6!*));6.!'8=!:-4-!76!:)<!79!,));6!9)! A-H!P!=)8E9!9:78;!6:-!:'9-=!A-8%!P!9:78;!6:-!,)@-=!36%!P!9:78;!J8=4-'!Q<)4;78!,)@-=! A-8!*-('36-!6:-!,)@-=!B-)B,-.!'8=!A-8!'4-!B-)B,-!"!A-8!'4-!:3A'8!*-78?6!"!8)! A'99-4!:)<!:'4=!<-!6)A-97A-6!6--A!9)!<'89!9)!B4)@-!)9:-4<76-!*>!)34!*-:'@7)4%! eb)*-49!&-86-8.!aC:76!W94)8?!G-A78769!l)7(-!D'6!+'4=,>!'!X'8k+'9-4H!J8=4-'! Q<)4;78!C),=!X-8!D:'9!C:->!K--=-=!9)!+-'4.a!F&6#%&)">,0&)*-4$.!JB47,!"i.! /00c%f!

"c%!P9!76!?-8-4',,>!()8(-=-=!9:'9!75!6-F3',!)47-89'97)8!76!6)A-9:78?!)@-4!<:7(:!'8! 78=7@7=3',!!!5)4!<:'9-@-4!4-'6)8!!!:'6!@7493',,>!8)!()894),.!9:-8!=76(47A78'97)8! '?'7869!?'>6!76!=-B,)4'*,-.!'6!79!'?'7869!4'(7',!'8=!-9:87(!(,'66-6.!*-('36-!79!:),=6! B-)B,-!'(()389'*,-!<79:)39!4-?'4=!5)4!'8>9:78?!9:->!9:-A6-,@-6!:'@-!=)8-%!J8=!9)! :),=!'!B-46)8!'(()389'*,-!5)4!9:'9!)@-4!<:7(:!9:-!B-46)8!:'6!8)!()894),!76!'!(-894',! 5)4A!)5!B4-n3=7(-%!eb7(:'4=!Q%!X):4.!9!A#kP6#%*-$=":"B%62A"&'";%,*-#?"B&-*$%A?"!)2" K!+%!RK-<!L)4;H!$),3A*7'!N87@-4679>!_4-66.!"giiT.!B%!Yg%f!!!

! 1/!

R"2#/#,&*-%"(4'2)%"2*

C:-4-!<'6!'!5'A)36!A)A-89!78!9:-!"ggc!A34=-4!947',!)5!2%!&%!W7AB6)8!<:-8!9:-! B4)6-(397)8!:'=!W7AB6)8!94>!)8!'!*,))=k6)';-=!,-'9:-4!?,)@-!5)38=!'9!9:-!(47A-!6(-8-%! W7AB6)8!'BB'4-89,>!()3,=8E9!?-9!9:-!?,)@-!)89)!:76!:'8=%!C:76!<'6!=-@'69'978?!5)4!9:-! B4)6-(397)8[!78!5'(9.!,-'=!B4)6-(39)4!X'4(7'!$,'4;!,'9-4!4-(',,-=!9:'9!'9!9:76!A)A-89!6:-! 6'7=!9)!:-46-,5.!aC:'9E6!79%!D-!n369!,)69!9:-!('6-%a!eX'4(7'!$,'4;!<79:!C-4-6'!$'4B-89-4.! E*%,&6%"!"M&63%%!RK-<!L)4;H!l7;78?.!"gg1T.!B%!`0i%f!

C:76!A)A-89!,-=!9)!)8-!)5!9:-!A)69!54-O3-89,>!O3)9-=!,78-6!)5!W7AB6)8E6!,-'=!'99)48->.! &):887-!$)(:4'8.!<:)!<'6!'=A74-=!5)4!:76!4:-9)47(',!'8=!B-463'67@-!'*7,797-6%!Q3478?!:76! (,)678?!69'9-A-89.!$)(:4'8!4-A78=-=!9:-!n34>!)5!9:76!A)A-89.!9:-8!6'7=H!

P9!=)-68E9!579%!P5!79!=)-68E9!579.!>)3!A369!'(O379%! P9!=)-68E9!579%!P5!79!=)-68E9!579.!>)3!A369!'(O379%!

$,-'4,>.!$)(:4'8!<'6!94>78?!9)!B4)@-!9)!9:-!n34>!9:'9!9:->!6:)3,=!'(O379!W7AB6)8%!C:-! 9<)!6-89-8(-6!)5!:76!(,)678?!69'9-A-89!O3)9-=!'*)@-!'4-!B4-A76-6.!789-8=-=!'6!4-'6)86!9)! *-,7-@-!:76!()8(,367)8.!<:7(:!76H!

L)3!A369!'(O379%!

D:>!<)3,=!$)(:4'8!,-'@-!:76!()8(,367)8!3869'9-=M!J6!5'4!'6!9:-!,)?7(!)5!'8!'4?3A-89! ?)-6.!79!A';-6!8)!=755-4-8(-!<:-9:-4!'!()8(,367)8!76!69'9-=!)4!3869'9-=.!*-('36-!'8! '4?3A-89E6!()8(,367)8!76!B'49!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!-@-8!<:-8!79!76!,-59!3869'9-=%!D:-8!'8! '4?3-4!,-'@-6!'!()8(,367)8!3869'9-=.!9:-!'3=7-8(-!A369!'==!79%!D:-8!$)(:4'8!?'@-!9:'9! 5'A)36!'4?3A-89.!:76!'3=7-8(-.!)5!()346-.!<'6!9:-!n34>.!9)!<:)A!:-!,-59!9:-!9'6;!)5! =4'<78?!9:-!()8(,367)8%!C:76!('8!*-!4:-9)47(',,>!-55-(97@-.!A)4-!6)!9:'8!67AB,>!69'978?! )8-E6!()8(,367)8!)8-6-,5.!*-('36-!79!('8!,-'=!9:-!'3=7-8(-!9)!*-()A-!78@-69-=! B6>(:),)?7(',,>!78!9:-!()8(,367)8%!X3(:!*-99-4!5)4!$)(:4'8!'8=!W7AB6)8!9:'9!9:-!n34>! *-()A-!78@-69-=!B6>(:),)?7(',,>!78!9:-!()8(,367)8!9:'9!9:->!A369!'(O379!W7AB6)8%!

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

! 1Y!

I-9E6!()867=-4!'8)9:-4!-F'AB,-.!54)A!J%!J%!X7,8-E6!(:7,=4-8E6!*));!E*))*$R%,$RH&&,H!

C:-!_7?,-9!,7@-=!78!'!@-4>!?4'8=!:)36-!78!9:-!A7==,-!)5!'!*--(:k94--.!'8=! 9:-!*--(:k;(55'%62'1=';<5'F1))&5'$#';<5'#$(52;-.'eJ%!J%!X7,8-.!E*))*$R%,$R H&&,%!RK-<!L)4;H!^%!_%!Q399)8!'8=!$)AB'8>.!"g/dT.!B%!Y/%f!

I-9E6!B39!9:-!9<)!B4-A76-6!789)!9:-!'4?3A-89!4-()86943(97)8!5)4A'9H!

R"T!C:-!_7?,-9!,7@-=!78!'!@-4>!?4'8=!:)36-!78!9:-!A7==,-!)5!'!*--(:k94--%! R/T!C:-!*--(:k94--!<'6!78!9:-!A7==,-!)5!9:-!5)4-69%!

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

R"T!C:-!_7?,-9!,7@-=!78!'!@-4>!?4'8=!:)36-!78!9:-!A7==,-!)5!'!*--(:k94--%! R/T!C:-!*--(:k94--!<'6!78!9:-!A7==,-!)5!9:-!5)4-69%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\!

RYT!C:-!_7?,-9!,7@-=!78!'!@-4>!?4'8=!:)36-!78!9:-!A7==,-!)5!9:-!5)4-69%!R3869'9-=T!

+-4-!76!'8)9:-4!-F'AB,-.!78!<:7(:!&3=>!U'4,'8=.!<:)!76!*-69!4-A-A*-4-=!5)4!B,'>78?! Q)4)9:>!78!C,$"E*\!02"&'"S\.!4-(',,-=!9:-!='>6!<:-8!6:-!'8=!:-4!6769-46!B-45)4A-=!78! @'3=-@7,,-H!!

P5!<-!=7=8E9!B,-'6-!9:-!'3=7-8(-.!<-!<-4-!574-=!9:-!8-F9!B-45)4A'8(-%!J8=! 75!<-!?)9!574-=.!X'A'!?)9!A'=%!e&3=>!U'4,'8=.!O3)9-=!78!&'A-6!]'()8.! I!2$"*)"F&44A+&&2%!R$:7('?)H!$)89-AB)4'4>!]));6.!P8(%.!"g11T.!B%!"d%f!

+-4-!76!'!4-()86943(97)8!)5!U'4,'8=E6!9<)!B4-A76-6H!

R"T!P5!<-!=7=8E9!B,-'6-!9:-!'3=7-8(-.!<-!<-4-!574-=!9:-!8-F9!B-45)4A'8(-%! R/T!P5!<-!?)9!574-=.!X'A'!?)9!A'=%!

G4)A!9:-6-!9<)!B4-A76-6.!9:-!,769-8-4!('8!38=-469'8=!9:'9!U'4,'8=E6!()8(,367)8!76!9:'9!75! 6:-!'8=!:-4!6769-46!=7=8E9!B,-'6-!9:-!'3=7-8(-.!9:-74!A'A'!?)9!A'=%!b-()86943(978?!:-4! -8974-!'4?3A-89.!<-!?-9H!

R"T!P5!<-!=7=8E9!B,-'6-!9:-!'3=7-8(-.!<-!<-4-!574-=!9:-!8-F9!B-45)4A'8(-%! R/T!P5!<-!?)9!574-=.!X'A'!?)9!A'=%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\!

RYT!P5!<-!=7=8E9!B,-'6-!9:-!'3=7-8(-.!X'A'!?)9!A'=%!R3869'9-=T!

! 1`!

I-9E6!()867=-4!)8-!A)4-!-F'AB,-.!54)A!'!B47Z-k<78878?!*));!<4799-8!5)4!'=),-6(-896.!78! <:7(:!9:-!'39:)4!,-59!79!3B!9)!:76!4-'=-46!9)!=4'<!9:-!789-8=-=!()8(,367)8H!

W9'8,->E6!5'9:-4!<'6!'8!78@-89)4%!C)!*-!'!63((-6653,!78@-89)4!>)3!8--=! 9:4--!9:78?6H!789-,,7?-8(-.!B-46-@-4'8(-.!'8=!n369!'!,799,-!*79!)5!,3(;%!

W9'8,->E6!5'9:-4!<'6!6A'49!'8=!:'=!'!,)9!)5!B-46-@-4'8(-%!28(-!:-!69'49-=!'! B4)n-(9!:-!<)3,=!<)4;!)8!79!5)4!>-'46.!)59-8!?)78?!='>6!<79:)39!6,--B%!+-! n369!8-@-4!:'=!'8>!,3(;%!eI)376!W'(:'4.!F&4$#%!K-<!L)4;H!b'8=)A!+)36-! $:7,=4-8E6!]));6.!"ggi.!B%!i%f!

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

W9'8,->E6!5'9:-4!<'6!8)9!'!63((-6653,!78@-89)4%!

+-4-!76!'!4-()86943(97)8!)5!W'(:'4E6!'4?3A-89H!

R"T!C)!*-!'!63((-6653,!78@-89)4!>)3!8--=!9:4--!9:78?6H!789-,,7?-8(-.!B-46-@-4'8(-.! '8=!n369!'!,799,-!*79!)5!,3(;%!

R/T!W9'8,->E6!5'9:-4!<'6!6A'49!'8=!:'=!'!,)9!)5!B-46-@-4'8(-.!*39!:-!8-@-4!:'=!'8>! ,3(;%!

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\!

RYT!W9'8,->E6!5'9:-4!<'6!8)9!'!63((-6653,!78@-89)4%!R3869'9-=T!

! 1c!

5H=-I!-J*5HKLMJN?*?JI*OPOVQ*

=>>!ST*RS?I=IJ>*-KS-MR?!KS?*

P86943(97)86H!;!-,"&'"%,$"'&44&+*)G"/!##!G$#"-&)%!*)#"!)"!0G6($)%"+*%,"!)"6)#%!%$2" -&)-46#*&)7"L&0"$!-,?"+0*%$"%,$"-&)-46#*&)7"8$"#60$"%&"+0*%$"%,$"-&)-46#*&)"!#"!"-&(/4$%$"

#$)%$)-$"%,!%"(!D$#"#$)#$"3A"*%#$4'7"I!D$"-4$!0"%,$"0$'$0$)%#"&'"!)A"/0&)&6)#"6#$2?"6)4$##"

%,$"-&)-46#*&)"*#"!3&6%"%,$"!0G6$0X"*'"%,$"-&)-46#*&)"*#"!3&6%"%,$"!0G6$0?"A&6"(!A"4$!5$"

%,$"/$0#&)!4"/0&)&6)#"%,!%"0$'$0"%&"%,$"!0G6$07"M&")&%"!22"!)A"$44*/#$#7!

W'AB,-!_4)*,-A6H!

! ! 247?78',!_'66'?-H!

U4-'9!=-67?86!()A-!54)A!:'BB>!=-67?8-46%!+'BB>!=-67?8-46!()A-!54)A! $',75)487'%!e^A!$),,'*)4'97@-!W93=7)!6,)?'8.!I)6!J8?-,-6.!O3)9-=!78!aC:-! WB)9,7?:9E6!)8!I-59!$)'69!Q-67?8-46.a!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!K)@-A*-4!/Y.! /00d%f

! ! J86<-4H!

! ! U4-'9!=-67?86!()A-!54)A!$',75)487'%!

! ! 247?78',!_'66'?-H!

P5!]36:!<-4-!8)9!B4-67=-89.!9:-4-!<)3,=!*-!8)!P4'O!<'4%!J8=!]36:!<)3,=! 8)9!*-!B4-67=-89!75!79!:'=!8)9!*--8!5)4!e&'A-6f!]';-4%!D:-8!79!6--A-=!9:'9! 4*2<Q2'?(521)5=;16&'62?1(6;1$=2'%5(5')$$F5)'1='V&$(1)68'46,5('-'($)5';$'

;<5'(52+*5-.'/G$=6&)'G*:1=8'0-99-4!9)!9:-!^=79)4.!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.! Q-(-A*-4!d.!/00d%f!

! ! J86<-4H!

P5!&'A-6!]';-4!:'=!8)9!47==-8!9)!9:-!4-6(3-!<:-8!79!6--A-=!9:'9!]36:E6! B4-67=-897',!'6B74'97)86!<-4-!=))A-=!78!G,)47='.!9:-8!9:-4-!<)3,=!*-!8)! P4'O!<'4%!

"%!_-)B,-!<79:!JPQW!'4-!67(;%!D-!=)8E9!574-!67(;!B-)B,-%!e&7A!+-8=-46)8.!_'(757(!]-,,E6! -F-(397@-!=74-(9)4!)5!:3A'8!4-6)34(-6.!O3)9-=!78!Q'@7=!I%!j74B.!aN8()AA)8! Q-(-8(>H!_'(757(!]-,,!b-6B)8=6!9)!JPQW.a!F!05!02"86#*)$##"O$5*$+!d1!RX'>k&38-! "gigT.!B%!"`/%f!

/%!S%#,Q!@)"%,*#"/!##!G$?"J,$J"0$'$0#"%&"!"'*-%*&)!4">63!)":($0*-!)"-,!0!-%$0"-!44$2" Q$#%&0">!#%*44&7"C,$"+&02"JG!44$G&J",!#"!")6(3$0"&'"2*''$0$)%"($!)*)G#"*)">63!)"

B/!)*#,X",$0$"*%"($!)#"#&($&)$"+,&#$"!)-$#%&0#"-!($"'0&("9!4*-*!?"!"/0&5*)-$"*)"%,$"

)&0%,+$#%$0)"-&0)$0"&'"B/!*)7!

-/9M5Q2'6'G!44$G&.!'8=!G!44$G&#!'4-!A-,'8(:),7(!'9!:-'49%!e26('4!+7n3-,)6.!C,$" I!(3&"N*)G#"H4!A"B&)G#"&'"K&5$%!RK-<!L)4;H!+'4B-4!x!b)<.!"gigT.!B%!"Y/%f!!!

! 1d!

Y%!-/BM<6;')$52=Q;',1&&'7$*'F6,52'7$*'2;($=>5(.'-/BM61;1=>';$'#1=)'$*;'1#'L'%62'<56)5)' 5)4!9:-!n)789!5)4!9:-!4-69!)5!A>!,75-!n369!'*)39!;7,,-=!A-%!eW8))B!Q)??!<79:!Q'@78! W-'>.!C,$"M&GG'!%,$0="C,$"C*($#?"C0*!4#?"!)2"F!02-&0$"C06%,#"&'"B)&&/"M&GG%!RK-<! L)4;H!D7,,7'A!X)44)<!'8=!$)AB'8>.!"gggT.!B%!/00%f!!!

`%!P!9:78;!PEA!697,,!n369!'6!:38?!3B!)8!?74,6!'8=!B-46)8',,>!786-(34-!'8=!(347)36!'*)39!,75-! '6!P!-@-4!<'6.!'8=!9:'9E6!',,!P!9:78;!'8>!<479-4!4-',,>!8--=6%!e&)6:!b799-4.!O3)9-=!78!b>'8! _-(;.!a&)6:!b799-4H!W78?78?!5)4!9:-!I)@-!)5!P9.a!8&*#$"E$$D4A!RP=':)T.!X'>!Y".!/00d%f!

c%!C:-!5-A',-!=3(;!:'6!'!=3,,.!(),)4,-66!:3-!9)!('A)35,'?-!:-4!*)=>%!L)3!'4-!8)9!'!=3(;%! e2,'>.!J=@-4976-A-89.!>&#(&/&4*%!)!/YgHY!RW-B9-A*-4!/00cT.!B%!cc%f!!!

d%!S%#,Q!C,$"!0G6($)%"*)"%,$"'&44&+*)G"/!##!G$"*#"%,$"2*0$-%"V6&%!%*&)"'0&("B,!V6*44$" SJQ$!4?"+,*-,"*#"3&42'!-$2"!)2"6)2$04*)$27!

C:-!J_!4-B)496H!J59-4!4-934878?!:)A-!54)A!'!,'9-k87?:9!n)>47=-!<79:!9-'AA'9-6! W:'O37,,-!2EK-',!'8=!J,)8Z)!X)34878?.!9:-!B:)8-!4'8?!7867=-!Q<>'8-!D'=-E6!:)A-! '6!9:-!='<8!)5!'!8-<!='>!<'6!=4'<78?!8-'4%!C:-!@)7(-!)8!9:-!,78-!*-,)8?-=!9)!2EK-',.! <:)!<'89-=!9)!=4)B!)8-!,'69!,78-!)5!4-'6634'8(-!789)!9:-!:-'=!)5!:76!9-'AA'9-!<:)!:'=! 6943??,-=!6)!*'=,>!78!U'A-!"!)5!9:-!^'69-48!$)85-4-8(-!578',6%!K)!A'99-4!9:'9!79!<'6! ',4-'=>!B'69!Y!'%A%!a!*@/2*'.Z*/"&*)B*!*@/2*'.*!*@/"#,&*+)1*#%*;,*'.Za!2EK-',!6'7=%! C:-!A-66'?-!<'6!9:-!,'69!9:78?!D'=-!:-'4=!*-5)4-!?)78?!9)!6,--B.!'8=!79!(-49'78,>!638;! 78%!X7'A7E6!3Bk'8=k()A78?!63B-469'4!4-=76()@-4-=!:76!'??4-667@-8-66!'8=!9));!)@-4!78! 9:-!5)349:!O3'49-4!D-=8-6='>!87?:9.!6()478?!/0!)5!:76!`0!B)7896!)@-4!9:-!578',!"/! A7839-6!'6!9:-!+-'9!=-5-'9-=!9:-!Q-94)79!_769)86!g/kid!9)!-@-8!9:-!*-69k)5k6-@-8!6-47-6! "k"%!eaK]J!Q'7,>.a!P867=-+))B6%()A.!X'>!/d.!/00c%f!

1%!S%#,Q!C,$"'&44&+*)G"V6&%$"*#"'0&("!"0!2*&"!2"/!*2"'&0"3A"!"%$!-,$0#J"G0&6/"&//&#$2"%&" 9&5$0)&0"B-,+!0\$)$GG$0J#"/0&/&#$2"-6%#"%&">!4*'&0)*!J#"$26-!%*&)"362G$%7"C,$"

#/$!D$0"*#"%,$"2!6G,%$0"&'"!"%$!-,$0X"#,$"*#"%!4D*)G"%&"#&($&)$"&)"%,$"G&5$0)&0J#"#%!''7!

C-,,!9:-!?)@-48)4!A>!A)9:-4E6!A'=.!'8=!<:-8!A>!A)9:-4E6!A'=!:-E=!*-99-4!<'9(:!)39V! eJ=@-4976-A-89.!jGD]!RI)6!J8?-,-6T.!JB47,!/i.!/00c%f!!!

i%!L)3!A7?:9!:'@-!:-'4=!6)8?6!54)A!aU3-4)a!e45+,Q2'=5%'I[M'$=';<5'-';55=6>5')(6F6' aC:-!2%$%.a!<:7(:!5-'934-=!57@-!6)8?6!B47)4!9)!9:-!$QE6!4-,-'6-%!K)<.!>)3!;8)<!796! ()),.!75!79E6!)8!aC:-!2%$%a!e$78=>!@)8!o3-=8)<.!a]-(;!W9'>6!C43-!9)!+76!I%J%!b))96! <79:!EU3-4)E.a!M!*4A"B6)2*!4!R$',75)487'!W9'9-!N87@-4679>.!K)49:47=?-T.!JB47,!"g.! /00c%f!!

! 11!

g%!P!A-897)8-=!9)!X4%!J(:-6)8!9:'9!P!:'=!4-'=!9:'9!U-8-4',!^76-8:)<-4!<'68E9!A3(:!)5!'! 4-'=-4!-F(-B9!5)4!9:-!D-69-48!8)@-,6!)5!h'8-!U4->.!'8=!:-!6'7=.!>-6.!:-!:'=!:-'4=!9:'9.! 9)).!'8=!'==-=.!aP!=)3*9!@-4>!A3(:!75!'!A'8!<:)6-!A'78!,79-4'4>!789-4-696!'4-!78!9:-! <)4;6!)5!X4%!U4->.!'=A74'*,-!'6!9:->!*-.!76!B'497(3,'4,>!<-,,!-O37BB-=!9)!*-!(:7-5! -F-(397@-!)5!9:76!()3894>!!!B'497(3,'4,>!<:-4-!@)2*!)!'55'746!'4-!()8(-48-=%a!eX-4,-! X7,,-4.!H4!*)"B/$!D*)G=":)"S0!4"8*&G0!/,A"&'"F!00A"B7"C06(!)%!RK-<!L)4;H!_-8?378.! "g1`[!4-B4789-=H!K-<!L)4;H!C-66!_4-66.!/00`T.!B%!Yg%f!!!

"0%!J6!,)8?!'6!A>!=)(9)46!'4-!B,-'6-=!<79:!A>!:-',9:.!<:7(:!9:->!'4-.!PEA!:'BB>%! eJ,)8Z)!X)34878?.!O3)9-=!78!aP867=-!9:-!K]J.a!CKC.!X'>!/c.!/00c%f!

""%!-/LM;')$52=E9!6--A!9)!A'99-4.! P5!P!=)8E9!?-9!'8>!5'99-4! RJ8=!P!2&)J%!?-9!'8>!5'99-4T.! D:'9!P!=)%! eJ%!J%!X7,8-.!C,$"F&6#$"!%"H&&,">&0)$0%!RK-<!L)4;H!^%!_%!Q399)8!'8=!$)AB'8>.! "g/iT.!B%!cc%f!!!

"/%!S%#,Q!9!A?"!"'*-%*&)!4"-,!0!-%$0?",*%-,,*D$2"!"0*2$"*)%&"I&)%$0$A"%&"'*)2"!" 0$/4!-$($)%"/!0%"'&0"%,$"3&00&+$2"-!0",$"!)2",*#"'0*$)2#"+$0$"6#*)G"!'%$0"*%",!2"

30&D$)"2&+)7"C,$"(!)"+*%,"+,&("9!A"G&%"!"0*2$"!4#&",!2"!"($-,!)*-!4"30$!D2&+)7!

P5!U'>!:'=!8)9!*--8!'!A-(:'87(.!:-!<)3,=!8)9!:'@-!57F-=!9:-!('4%!P5!:-!:'=!8)9!57F-=! 79!9:-!)<8-4!<)3,=8E9!:'@-!9';-8!:7A!9)!&7AA>!]43(7'E6!5)4!'!=478;%!e&):8!W9-78*-(;.! >!))$0A"O&+%!RK-<!L)4;H!l7;78?!_4-66.!"g`cT.!B%!d0%f!!!

Wi.'-/E$$<M'261)';$'<1F25&#J!

aP5!'!*)99,-!('8!5,)'9.!9:-8!'!n'4!('8!5,)'9.!'8=!75!'!n'4!5,)'96.!9:-8!P!('8!679!)8!9)B!)5! 79-.D'/@.'@.'b1&=58'E*))*$R%,$RH&&,%!RK-<!L)4;H!^%!_%!Q399)8!'8=!$)AB'8>.!"g/dT.! B%!"Yd%f!

"`%!S%#,Q!C,$"#/$!D$0"*#"!"'*-%*&)!4"-,!0!-%$0"-!44$2";%%!"P&#$/,7"C,$"!0G6($)%"*)"%,*#" /!##!G$"*#"3&42'!-$2"!)2"6)2$04*)$27!

P!<'6!9:-!<)469!B)<<)<!='8(-4!78!9:-!<)4,=%!PE=!69'49!='8(78?!'9!6)A-!B)<<)<.!'8=! 9:-!X'69-4!)5!$-4-A)87-6!<)3,=!6:)39!)39.!a+->.!69)B!9:-!B)<<)<.!69)B!9:-! B)<<)<.!^99'!76!='8(78?.!6:-E6!437878?!9-8!9:)36'8=!>-'46!)5!947*',!94'=797)86%!!B*@,*

&%"E#*2#%.*#+,*.%@@%@*"%@Z*2+,*1)0+#*2#/$#*2)"0)"0Z*/"&*#+,"*@,E$,*$,/44:*0%)"0*

#%*;,*)"*#$%';4,Ga!eW:-4A'8!J,-F7-.!aQ-'4!&):8!D'>8-.a!78!C,$"C&6G,$#%"@)2*!)"*)" %,$"E&042%!RK-<!L)4;H!J9,'897(!X)89:,>!_4-66.!/000T.!B%!/01%f!!!

"c%!C:-!,78-!e78!54)89!)5!J49:34!]4>'89E6!4-69'34'89!78!j'86'6!$79>f!6B-';6!5)4!796-,5%!C:-4-! <)3,=8E9!*-!'!,78-!75!9:-!5))=!<'68E9!?))=%!ea]'4*-(3-!]'697)86.a!C4'@-,!$:'88-,.! JB47,!c.!/00c%f!

! 1i!

"d%!W94)8?!9-F96!<)4;!',)8?!9:-!*)4=-46!)5!)34!A78=6!'8=!',9-4!<:'9!',4-'=>!-F7696%!C:->! ()3,=!8)9!=)!9:76!75!9:->!A-4-,>!4-5,-(9-=!<:'9!',4-'=>!-F7696%!e&-'8-99-!D789-46)8.!:0%" S3`$-%#=!;##!A#"&)";-#%!#A"!)2";''0&)%$0A.!O3)9-=!78!*-,,!:));6.!aX';78?!X)@7-! X'?7(.a!78!O$$4"%&"O$!4="O!-$?"B$T"!)2">4!##"!%"%,$"I&5*$#%!RI)8=)8H!b)39,-=?-.! "ggdT.!B%!/%f!!!

"1%!S%#,Q!C,$"0$4$5!)%"!0G6($)%"*)"%,*#"/!##!G$"*#"3&42'!-$2"!)2"6)2$04*)$27!

C:-!97B7!76!A3(:!*-99-4!9)!,7@-!78[!',<'>6!(,-'8.!<'4A!78!<789-4.!()),!78!63AA-4[!-'6>! 9)!A)@-%!C:-!<:79-!A'8!*37,=6!*7?!:)36-.!()69!A3(:!A)8->.!,7;-!*7?!('?-.!6:39!)39! 638.!('8!8-@-4!A)@-[!',<'>6!67(;%!P8=7'86!'8=!'87A',6!;8)<!*-99-4!:)<!9)!,7@-!9:'8! <:79-!A'8[!8)*)=>!('8!*-!78!?))=!:-',9:!75!:-!=)-6!8)9!:'@-!',,!9:-!97A-!54-6:!'74.! 6386:78-!'8=!?))=!<'9-4%!!B*#+,*T$,/#*?.)$)#*@/"#,&*1,"*#%*2#/:*)"*%",*.4/(,*+,* ,*-./%)(0"%12"%,*3./%#1(4/%#1+..5%'-1%6"%)(/"%+1%1*%(.,(7#%82(49"&:!e$:7-5! G,>78?!+'<;.!W7)3F!)5!9:-!2?,','!(,'8.!O3)9-=!78!C%!$%!X(I3:'8.!C&6-,"%,$";!0%,=":" B$4'RH&0%0!*%"&'"@)2*!)";T*#%$)-$%!RK-<!L)4;H!239-4*47=?-!'8=!Q7-86954->.!"g1"T.!B%! d`%f!

"i%!S%#,Q!:2!("B!/*D&+#D*?"!"[cRA$!0R&42"0$#*2$)%"&'">,!/$4"F*44?"Q&0%,">!0&4*)!?"+!#" !--6#$2"&'"(602$0*)G",*#"/!0$)%#X"0$/&0%$24A?",$"!2(*%%$2"%&"%,$"D*44*)G#"!'%$0"3$*)G"

%!D$)"*)%&"-6#%&2A?"!//0&T*(!%$4A"%+&"+$$D#"!'%$0"%,$"D*44*)G#7"F$"+!#"!"`6)*&0"!%"

M60,!(":-!2$(A7"H&4*-$"+$0$"%0A*)G"%&"'*)2"&6%"+,!%"B!/*D&+#D*"2*2"*)"%,$"%+&"

+$$D#"3$%+$$)"%,$"(602$0#"!)2",*#"!00$#%?"*)-462*)G"+,$%,$0"&0")&%",$"!%%$)2$2"

-4!##$#"260*)G"%,*#"%*($"/$0*&27"U)2$0"Q&0%,">!0&4*)!"4!+?"!"(*)&0"*#")&%"!44&+$2"%&"

!6%,&0*\$"%,$"0$4$!#$"&'",*#"&0",$0"#-,&&4"0$-&02#"%&"/&4*-$7"C,$"!0G6($)%"*)"%,*#"

/!##!G$"*#"3&42'!-$2"!)2"6)2$04*)$27!

Q34:'A!J('=-A>E6!,'<>-4.!I-<76!$:--;.!6'7=!9:-!785)4A'97)8!eW'B7;)<6;7E6!6(:)),! 4-()4=6f!:'6!*--8!()AB7,-=!'8=!76!4-'=>!9)!*-!B'66-=!',)8?.!*39!2(+%%4*%BB)()/42*+/3,*

;,,"*@/)#)"0*B%$*2%1,%",*/'#+%$)C,&*#%*2,$3,*/2*?/.)9%@29)E2*4,0/4*0'/$&)/"*#%*

Kg*#+,*$,4,/2,*%B*+)2*$,(%$&2Z*%$*B%$*.%4)(,*#%*0)3,*#+,*2(+%%4*/*(%'$#*%$&,$*

&)$,(#)"0*#+,)$*$,4,/2,G!!

J6!)5!D-=8-6='>!'59-48))8.!",)#+,$*%B*#+%2,*#+)"02*+/&*+/..,",&.!$:--;!6'7=%! eb'>!U4)8*-4.!aW'B7;)<6;7!D-89!9)!W(:)),!'59-4!W,'>78?6.a!M60,!("F$0!42RB6)! RK)49:!$'4),78'T.!X'>!"i.!/00c%f!!!

"g%!S%#,Q!H&&,"!)2"O!33*%",!5$"$!%$)"46)-,"*)"O!33*%J#",&6#$X"!'%$0"46)-,?"!#"H&&,"+!#" 4$!5*)G"O!33*%J#?",$"G&%"#%6-D"*)"O!33*%J#"'0&)%"2&&07"

aP9!',,!()A-6.a!6'7=!b'**79!69-48,>.!a)5!-'978?!9))!A3(:%!P!9:)3?:9!'9!9:-!97A-.a!6'7=! b'**79.!a)8,>!P!=7=8E9!,7;-!9)!6'>!'8>9:78?.a!6'7=!b'**79.!a9:'9!)8-!)5!36!<'6!-'978?!9))! A3(:.a!6'7=!b'**79.!a'8=!P!;8-<!79!<'68E9!($-.D'eJ%!J%!X7,8-.!E*))*$R%,$RH&&,%! RK-<!L)4;H!^%!_%!Q399)8!'8=!$)AB'8>.!"g/dT.!BB%!/dk/1%f!

! 1g!

/0%!S%#,Q!C,$"#/$!D$0"*#"!"'*-%*&)!4"-,!0!-%$0"-!44$2">$#!0">!#%*44&7"F$J#"%!4D*)G"%&",*#" 30&%,$0?"Q$#%&0?"+,&"*#"2$/0$##$2"3$-!6#$",*#"G*04'0*$)2?"I!0l!"O*5$0!?",!#"

2*#!//$!0$27!

^79:-4!6)A-9:78?!:'BB-8-=!9)!:-4!)4!-,6-!6:-E6!'*'8=)8-=!>)3%!P5!6)A-9:78?! :'BB-8-=!9)!<5(8';<5='7$*Q&&'255'<5(8':*;'1#'2<5Q2'&5#;'-'7$*'<6N5';$'#$(>5;'<5(.'/U2+6(' +7n3-,)6.!C,$"I!(3&"N*)G#"H4!A"B&)G#"&'"K&5$%!RK-<!L)4;H!+'4B-4!x!b)<.!"gigT.! B%!"0c%f!!!

! i0!

?';(%"(4'2)%"2*

J4?3A-896!6)A-97A-6!:'@-!'!2';(%"(4'2)%"H!!"#%!%$($)%"%,!%"*#"!"-&)-46#*&)"0$4!%*5$"%&" !%"4$!#%"&)$"&%,$0"#%!%$($)%"*)"%,$"!0G6($)%"!)2"*#"!4#&"!"/0$(*#$"0$4!%*5$"%&"%,$"(!*)"

-&)-46#*&)%!

$)867=-4!9:76!'4?3A-89H!

U)46:7-!'9-!',,!)5!Q-4@76:E6!X-)<!X7F.!6)!:-!A369!*-!:38?4>%!W).!:-!<7,,! *-?!5)4!5))=!<:7,-!PEA!());78?%!

+-4-.!9:-!A'78!()8(,367)8!76!9:'9!Q-4@76:!<7,,!*-?!5)4!5))=!<:7,-!PEA!());78?%!D:>! 6:)3,=!<-!*-,7-@-!9:'9M!]-('36-!:-E6!:38?4>%!D:>!6:)3,=!<-!*-,7-@-!9:'9M!]-('36-! U)46:7-!'9-!',,!)5!:76!X-)<!X7F%!C:-!69'9-A-89!9:'9!Q-4@76:!76!:38?4>!76!'!63*()8(,367)8! 78!9:76!'4?3A-89[!,-9E6!(',,!76!W$!R5)4!6:)49T%!P9!B,'>6!'!=3',!)4!=)3*,-!4),-!78!9:76! '4?3A-89H!R"T!4-,'97@-!9)!9:-!69'9-A-89!9:'9!U)46:7-!'9-!',,!)5!Q-4@76:E6!X-)<!X7F.!W$!76! '!()8(,367)8.!'8=!R/T!4-,'97@-!9)!9:-!A'78!()8(,367)8!9:'9!Q-4@76:!<7,,!*-?!5)4!5))=!<:7,-! PEA!());78?.!W$!76!',6)!'!B4-A76-%!

D-!()3,=!?-9!9:-!6'A-!'86<-4!*>!B'>78?!'99-897)8!9)!9:-!()8(,367)8!78=7('9)4!E6)E.!36-=! 9<7(-!78!9:76!-F'AB,-%!b-<47978?!9:-!'4?3A-89!6943(934',,>!R,7;-!78!_4'(97(-!_4)*,-A6!W-9! "k"T.!<-!?-9H!

\\\'\\\.!#&!\\\*\\\%!B&.!\\\(\\\!

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

+-4-!76!'!4-()86943(97)8!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89H!

R"T!U)46:7-!'9-!',,!)5!Q-4@76:E6!X-)<!X7F%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!Q-4@76:!76!:38?4>%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!+-!<7,,!*-?!5)4!5))=!<:7,-!PEA!());78?%!

! i"!

I-9E6!()867=-4!'8)9:-4!-F'AB,-H!

-/3M1=+5'2;(55;+6(2'$++3B7-=!9:-!(-89-4!B'49!)5!9:-!694--96!e78!I)6!J8?-,-6! 78!"g"gf.!B-=-6947'86!:'=!9)!a<)4A!9:-74!<'>!9:4)3?:!9:-!'39)A)*7,-6a!9)! 4-'(:!9:-A.!a9:36!:),=78?!3B!9:-!-8974-!A)@-A-89a!e)5!94'557(f%!eW()99!I%! ])99,-6.!K&#":)G$4$#"!)2"%,$":6%&(&3*4$="C,$"I!D*)G"&'"%,$"I&2$0)">*%A%! R]-4;-,->H!N87@-4679>!)5!$',75)487'!_4-66.!"gi1T.!B%!d0%f!

_4-A76-!'8=!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-46!(,'475>!<:'9E6!?)78?!)8!78!9:76!-F'AB,-%!+-4-!76!796! 6943(934-H!

B*)-$!\\\'\\\.!\\\*\\\.!%,6#!\\\(\\\%!

C:-!<)4=!E678(-E!7894)=3(-6!'!B4-A76-.!6)!9:-!69'9-A-89!78!9:-!'kB)6797)8.!

W94--9('46!)((3B7-=!9:-!(-89-4!B'49!)5!9:-!694--96.!

76!'!B4-A76-%!

C:-!6943(934-!

#*)-$!\\\'\\\.!\\\*\\\!

',6)!9-,,6!36!9:'9!9:-!69'9-A-89!78!9:-!*kB)6797)8!76!'!()8(,367)8%!

G78',,>.!E9:36E!7894)=3(-6!'!()8(,367)8!9:'9!76!63BB)6-=!9)!5),,)<!54)A!'!69'9-A-89!R)4! 69'9-A-896T!B4-6-89-=!*-5)4-!79.!6)!9:-!69'9-A-89!78!9:-!(kB)6797)8!76!'!()8(,367)8!9:'9!76! 63BB)6-=!9)!5),,)<!54)A!9:-!69'9-A-89!78!9:-!*kB)6797)8.!<:7(:!<'6!',6)!'!()8(,367)8%!W).! 9:-!69'9-A-89!78!9:-!(kB)6797)8!76!9:-!A'78!()8(,367)8.!9:-!69'9-A-89!78!9:-!*kB)6797)8!76!'! 63*()8(,367)8.!'8=!9:-!69'9-A-89!78!9:-!'kB)6797)8!76!'8!3863BB)49-=!B4-A76-%!

_39978?!9:76!',,!9)?-9:-4!789)!'8!'4?3A-89!4-()86943(97)8.!<-!?-9H!

R"T!W94--9('46!)((3B7-=!9:-!(-89-4!B'49!)5!9:-!694--96!78!I)6!J8?-,-6!78! "g"g%!

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!_-=-6947'86!:'=!9)!<)4A!9:-74!<'>!9:4)3?:!9:-!'39)A)*7,-6!9)!4-'(:! 9:-!694--9('46%!

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!_-=-6947'86!94>78?!9)!4-'(:!694--9('46!:-,=!3B!9:-!-8974-!A)@-A-89!)5! 94'557(%!

! i/!

P8!*)9:!)5!9:-!-F'AB,-6!<-!:'@-!,));-=!'9!6)!5'4.!9:-!3863BB)49-=!B4-A76-!<'6!B4-6-89-=! 57469.!9:-!63*()8(,367)8!<'6!B4-6-89-=!6-()8=.!'8=!9:-!A'78!()8(,367)8!<'6!B4-6-89-=! 9:74=%!]39!'4?3A-896!<79:!63*()8(,367)86!'4-!8)9!',<'>6!'44'8?-=!9:76!<'>%!$)867=-4!9:-! 5),,)<78?!-F'AB,-H!

I'8=,)4=6!e78!K)49:47=?-f!;8)<!9:->!('8!4'76-!9:-!B47(-6!R5)4!'B'49A-896T! *-('36-!e$',75)487'!W9'9-!N87@-4679>.!K)49:47=?-f!693=-896!8--=!9)!,7@-! (,)6-!e9)!('AB36f.!6)!9:->!<7,,!B'>!79!e#*-f%!eb'6:''=!Q7F)8.!O3)9-=!78! I'4'78-!G76:-4.!ab7678?!JB'49A-89!_47(-6!J55-(9!$),,-?-!W93=-896.a! B6(($0!B6)2*!4!R$',75)487'!W9'9-!N87@-4679>.!K)49:47=?-T.!&38-!/0k/`.! /00c%f!

_4-A76-!'8=!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-46!(,'475>!B'49!)5!<:'9E6!?)78?!)8!78!9:76!-F'AB,-[!,-9E6! :'@-!'!,));!'9!796!6943(934',,>H!

\\\'\\\!3$-!6#$!\\\*\\\.!#&!\\\(\\\%!

C:-!<)4=!E*-('36-E!7894)=3(-6!'!B4-A76-.!'8=!8)9:78?!76!6'7=!9)!63BB)49!9:-!69'9-A-89!78! 9:-!*kB)6797)8.!6)!9:'9!69'9-A-89!76!'8!3863BB)49-=!B4-A76-%!P8!9:-!6943(934-!

\\\'\\\!3$-!6#$!\\\*\\\!

9:-!69'9-A-89!78!9:-!'kB)6797)8!A369!*-!'!()8(,367)8%!C:-!<)4=!E6)E!7894)=3(-6!'! ()8(,367)8.!6)!9:-!69'9-A-89!78!9:-!(kB)6797)8!76!',6)!'!()8(,367)8%!D:7(:!76!9:-! 63*()8(,367)8!'8=!<:7(:!76!9:-!A'78!()8(,367)8M!$)867=-4!9:-!69'9-A-896!78!9:-!'k!'8=!(k B)6797)86!'8=!'6;!>)346-,5!R;--B78?!9:-!B478(7B,-!)5!(:'479>!78!A78=TH!=)-6!Q7F)8!789-8=! 5)4!E'E!9)!63BB)49!E(E!)4!=)-6!:-!789-8=!5)4!E(E!9)!63BB)49!E'EM!P89-4B4-978?!Q7F)8!'6!3678?!E'E! 9)!63BB)49!E(E!<)3,=!*-!789-4B4-978?!:7A!78!'!<'>!9:'9!=)-68E9!A';-!A3(:!6-86-.!*39! 38=-469'8=78?!:7A!9)!A-'8!9:'9!E(E!63BB)496!E'E!A';-6!'!,)9!A)4-!6-86-%!

+-4-!76!'!4-()86943(97)8!)5!Q7F)8E6!'4?3A-89H!

R"T!$WNK!693=-896!8--=!9)!,7@-!(,)6-!9)!('AB36%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! !R/T!C:->!<7,,!B'>!78(4-'6-=!4-896!5)4!'B'49A-896%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!I'8=,)4=6!78!K)49:47=?-!;8)<!9:->!('8!4'76-!9:-!B47(-6!5)4!'B'49A-896%!

! iY!

5H=-I!-J*5HKLMJN?Q*?JI*OPOYQ*

HJ-KS?IHR-I!ST*=HTRNJSI?*6!IA*?RL-KS-MR?!KS?*

P86943(97)86H!;!-,"!0G6($)%"*)"%,*#"#$%",!#"&)$"#63-&)-46#*&)"!)2"&)$"(!*)"-&)-46#*&)7" O$-&)#%06-%"$!-,"!0G6($)%?"'&44&+*)G"%,$"'*5$"064$#"'&0"!0G6($)%"0$-&)#%06-%*&)7"M&")&%"

!22"!)A"$44*/#$#7"

W'AB,-!_4)*,-AH!!

! 247?78',!_'66'?-H!

-/OM<5'7$*=>5('>5=5(6;1$='$#'b66261'+<1&)(5=8'-)*5';$'2+<$$&1=>'6=)'

)9:-4!a()443B978?a!785,3-8(-6.!A7?:9!8)9!:'@-!?4)<8!3B!78!9>B7(',!X''6'7! 94'=797)8!'8=!%%%!A7?:9.!9:-4-5)4-.!8-@-4!?-9!'!(:'8(-!)5!;8)<78?!9:-!5'(9)46! 9:'9!;-B9!9:-74!5)4-5'9:-46!'!3879-=!9:)3?:!8)9!:)A)?-8)36!?4)3B%!e]%!j%! 2,-!j'89'7.!G)4<'4=!9)!W%!W%!2,-!W'8;'8.!C,$"I!!#!*%!RK'74)*7H!^'69! J547('8!I79-4'934-!]34-'3.!"g1".!B%!@77%f!

! ! J86<-4H!

R"T!C:-!>)38?-4!?-8-4'97)8!)5!X''6'7!(:7,=4-8!:'@-!*--8!-FB)6-=! 9)!6(:)),78?!'8=!)9:-4!a()443B978?a!785,3-8(-6%!

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!C:-!>)38?-4!?-8-4'97)8!)5!X''6'7!(:7,=4-8!A7?:9!8)9!:'@-!! ?4)<8!3B!78!9>B7(',!X''6'7!94'=797)8%!

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!C:-!>)38?-4!?-8-4'97)8!)5!X''6'7!(:7,=4-8!A7?:9!8-@-4!?-9!'!! (:'8(-!)5!;8)<78?!9:-!5'(9)46!9:'9!;-B9!9:-74!5)4-5'9:-46!'!! 3879-=!9:)3?:!8)9!3879-=!:)A)?-8)36!?4)3B%!!

"%!]-('36-!6:-!76!'8!7,,-?',!7AA7?4'89.!G)4938'!eU'4(7'f!=)-6!8)9!:'@-!'!*'8;!'(()389!78! 9:-!N879-=!W9'9-6!'8=!9:-4-5)4-!4-,7-6!)8!'8!$)-&($)2$0&"!"'!5-,,)<!]),7@7'8!<:).! 5)4!'!5--.!:'8=k=-,7@-46!9:-!A)8->!6:-!'8=!:-4!8-7?:*)46!78!:-4!-FB'947'9-!()AA3879>! 4-?3,'4,>!6-8=!:)A-%!eX)76t6!K'7A.!aC';78?!)8!9:-!239,'<!^()8)A>.a!K&#":)G$4$#" C*($#.!K)@-A*-4!"/.!/00c%f!

! i`!

/%!S%#,Q*C,$"!0G6($)%"*#"*)"%,$"#$-&)2"/!0!G0!/,"&'"%,*#"/!##!G$7!

D-!6'<!:7A!679! '8=!94>!9)!());%! +-!9));!'!,));! '9!9:-!*));!)8!9:-!:));%!

]39!'!K));!('8E9!4-'=.! 6)!'!K));!('8E9!());%! W2!%!%!%!! <:'9!?))=!9)!'!K));!! 76!'!:));!());!*));M! eQ4%!W-366.!S)$"L*#,"C+&"L*#,"O$2"L*#,"846$"L*#,%!RK-<!L)4;H!]-?788-4!]));6.! "gd0T.!B%!Y"%f!!!

Y%!S%#,Q!C,$"!0G6($)%"*)"%,*#"/!##!G$"*#"3&42'!-$2"!)2"6)2$04*)$27!

b7'>(6=)F$;<5(Q2'2;$(152'-'<6)')(56F&1,5'd*6&1;152'6:$*;';<5F8'6=)'$=5'$#';<5F'L'

4-A-A*-4!*-69!*-?'8!<79:!9:-!-,;%!P8!J4A-87'.!9:-!-,;!76!A'?7(%!D79:!796!:)486!,7;-! <7,=!('8=-,'*4'.!9:-!-,;!<'6!J='AE6!57469!B'498-4!78!9:-!U'4=-8!)5!^=-8%!]39! J4A-87'8!,-?-8=!:'6!79!9:'9!#+,*,49*@/2"E#*(%1./#);4,*@)#+*=&/1Z*/"&*T%&* ;/")2+,&*)#*)"*B/3%$*%B*J3,G*?%*#+,*,49*0$,@*#%*+/#,*@%1,"G!^6B-(7',,>!B4-?8'89! <)A-8.!<:)!:'=!9)!?)!9)!*-=!'9!87?:9!<79:!;87@-6!38=-4!9:-74!B7,,)<6!78!('6-!9:-!-,;! ('A-!9)!B3,,!)39!9:-74!,7@-46%!e_-9-4!]',';7'8.!84!-D"M&G"&'"L!%$=":"I$(&*0%!RK-<! L)4;H!]'67(]));6.!"gg1T.!B%!"g%f!!!

`%!X>!X'6-4'97!=)-6!"ic!! P!,)69!A>!,7(-86-!8)<!P!=)8E9!=47@-!! e&)-!D',6:.!aI75-E6!]--8!U))=a!)8!&)-!D',6:.!86%"B$0*&6#4A"L&4D#.!J6>,3A!"`".! "g1i%f!

c%!b6=7'E6+1#1+'=6;1$=2'-'(5?$(;'<1><'&5N5&2'$#'3O[28'1=)1+6;1=>'<1><'(6;52'$#' 38B4)9-(9-=!6-F.!:-8(-!'!:7?:!476;!5)4!94'86A7667)8!)5!+Pl%%%%!eb)?-4!2*';4'7434.! ]4-8='!Q-,76,-!'8=!&):8!Q'F!X)4-8).!a+PlSJPQW!W34@->!N8=-4<'>!78!KXP.a! B!*/!)"C0*36)$!RX7(4)8-67'T.!K)@-A*-4!".!/00d%f!!!

d%!S%#,Q!C,$"#/$!D$0"*)"%,*#"/!##!G$"*#"!"'*-%*&)!4"-,!0!-%$0"-!44$2"%,$"C*)"E&&2(!)7":" +&&2(!)"*#"!"(!)"+,&"-6%#"+&&27"C,$"C*)"E&&2(!)"+!#"-,!)G$2"'0&("'4$#,"!)2"

34&&2"*)%&"%*)7!@)"%,$"(&5*$"(!2$"'0&("K7"L0!)D"8!6(J#"3&&D?"%,$"C*)"E&&2(!)"*#"`6#%" -!44$2"%,$"C*)(!)7!@)"%,*#"/!##!G$?!,$"*#"!#D*)G"%,$"E*\!02"&'"S\"%&"G*5$",*("!",$!0%" #&"%,!%",$"+*44"3$"!34$"%&"4&5$7!

P!'A!'!D))=A'8.!'8=!A'=-!)5!978%!C:-4-5)4-!P!:'@-!8)!:-'49!'8=!('88)9!,)@-%!eI%! G4'8;!]'3A.!C,$"E*\!02"&'"S\%!R"g00[!4-B4789-=H!K-<!L)4;H!U4)66-9!'8=!Q38,'B.! "gdYT.!B%!g"%f!

! ic!

1%!I'>!B-)B,-!=)!8)9!:-'4!'*)39!789-46-F3',79>!A3(:!78!9:-!N879-=!W9'9-6!9)='>!*-('36-! 63(:!()8=797)86!'4-!)59-8!()867=-4-=!94'3A'97(.!6('8=',)36.!'8=!6:'A-53,.!6)!5-<! B-)B,-!9',;!'*)39!63(:!*749:6!<:-8!9:->!:'BB-8%!eJ,7(-!Q)A34'9!Q4-?-4.! F$0(!/,0&2*%$#"!)2"%,$"I$2*-!4"@)5$)%*&)"&'"B$T%!R$'A*47=?-.!X'66%H!+'4@'4=! N87@-4679>!_4-66.!"ggiT.!B%!`Y%f!!!

i%!D:-8!P!<-89!9)!A>!X-9:)=769!$:34(:.!8)!)8-!B4-6-89-=!(4-'97)8!'6!'8!',9-48'97@-!@7-<! e9)!-@),397)8f%!P869-'=!9:-!('6-!<'6!A'=-!9:'9!9:-4-!<'6!8)!78()86769-8(>!*-9<--8! -@),397)8!'8=!(4-'97)8!678(-!U)=!:'=!8)!()8(-48!5)4!97A-!'8=!75!79!9));!:7A!"0!A7,,7)8! >-'46!9)!?-9!9:78?6!47?:9.!79!<'6!8)!*7?!=-',%!eb7(:'4=!X%!j-4?-4.!aW:)3978?!'!l7-<! Q)-68E9!X-'8!29:-46!+-'4!P9.a!C&4$2&"84!2$!R2:7)T.!X'>!/i.!/00c%f!

g%!S%#,Q!Q$+"L8@"!G$)%#"!0$")&0(!44A"!##*G)$2"!)"$T/$0*$)-$2"!G$)%"""!"%0!*)*)G"!G$)%" ""%&"+&0D"+*%,"%,$("260*)G"%,$*0"'*0#%"'$+"(&)%,#"&)"%,$"`&37"

A$;'6&&'V4L'6>5=;2'25(N5'62';(61=1=>'6>5=;2.'...'3d*6)'2*?5(N12$(2'-')$=Q;'25&5+;'+5(;61='

'?-896!e9)!*-!94'7878?!'?-896f!*-('36-!9:->!'4-!8)9!B'497(3,'4,>!?))=!4),-!A)=-,6%! eG4'8;!]39978)!<79:!I)3!]39978).!:"B/$-*!4":G$)%="9!A"!)2"@)#*2$"%,$"L8@%!RK-<! L)4;H!D7,,7'A!X)44)<!'8=!$)AB'8>.!"ggYT.!B%!"Yc%f!!!

"0%!S%#,Q!@)"%,*#"/!##!G$":4*-$"E!4D$0"*#"+0*%*)G"!3&6%"%,$"$T/$0*$)-$#"&'"34!-D"B&6%,$0)" #,!0$-0&//$0#7!

-/4M5+6*25'%5'=5N5('+$=21)5(5)'$*(25&N52'?$$(8'6=)';<5(5#$(5'%$(;<&5228'%5'+$*&=! =-B-8=!)8!)8-!'8)9:-4!<79:)39!6:'A-%!eJ,7(-!D',;-4.!aC:-!],'(;!D479-4!'8=!9:-! W)39:-48!^FB-47-8(-.a!78!@)"B$!0-,"&'"S60"I&%,$0#J"9!02$)#="E&(!)*#%"H0&#$%!RW'8! Q7-?)H!+'4()349!]4'(-!x!$)AB'8>.!"giYT.!B%!"1%f!

""%!P!=)8E9!8--=!9)!?-9!',,!('3?:9!3B!)8!9:-!8-9! E$'36-!PEA!',4-'=>!6-9! $'8E9!>)3!38=-469'8=!!!',4-'=>!?)9!A>!A'8%! eW:'87'!C<'78.!aPEA!+),=78?!28!C)!I)@-!RC)!W'@-!X>!I75-T.a!>&($"&)"S5$0f!!!

"/%!b-6-'4(:-46!:'@-!-FB4-66-=!','4A!'*)39!(3,934-6!9:'9!5'@)4!A',-!*'*7-6.!6'>78?!9:'9! 6-Fk4'97)!7A*','8(-6!()3,=!=-69'*7,7Z-!6)(7-9>!*-('36-!A)4-!A-8!<7,,!4-A'78! 38A'447-=.!4'7678?!9:-!476;6!)5!'897k6)(7',!'8=!@7),-89!*-:'@7)4%!eb-39-46.!aW(7-897696! W'>!U-8=-4!PA*','8(-!'!U4)<78?!_4)*,-A.!B$!%%4$"C*($#.!J3?369!/g.!/00d%f!!!

"Y%!-06=)5(2'+$=21)5(2'/41&&M'b$=($5'62';<-!aG'9:-4!)5!],3-?4'66!X367(%a!J6!63(:.!79!76! '663A-=!9:'9!]7,,!X)84)-!78@-89-=!79.!6)!<:'9!:-!=)-6!76!a()44-(9a!*,3-?4'66%!e]'44>! b%!D7,,76.!a]7,,!X)84)-!'8=!9:-!],3-?4'66!])>6.a!78!:($0*-!J#"I6#*-="846$G0!##%! R"gg1T.!B%!"0Y%f!

! id!

"`%!G'44-,,!Q7,,)8.!()8@7(9-=!78!"ggg!)5!4'B78?!5)34!>)38?!?74,6.!9));!9:-!69'8=!X)8='>!9)! '6;!19:!$74(379!&3=?-!X-49)8!C7(-!&4%!9)!?4'89!:7A!'!8-<!947',!*-('36-!:76!'99)48->! :'=!*--8!A-89',,>!7,,!'8=!9:-4-5)4-!78()AB-9-89%!el7(;>!D7(;6.!a$)8@7(9-=!b'B769! J6;6!5)4!K-<!C47',!]-('36-!)5!J99)48->E6!J(97)86.a!O!/*2">*%A"P&60)!4!RW)39:! Q';)9'T.!JB47,!"i.!/00c%f!!!

"c%!S%#,Q!C,$"!0G6($)%"*#"*)"%,$"#$-&)2"/!0!G0!/,"&'"%,*#"/!##!G$7!

JA)8?!9:-!9:)36'8=6!)5!P4'O76!=-6B-4'9-,>!6--;78?!'!N%W%!@76'!76!9:-!5)4A-4!94'86,'9)4! 5)4!N%W%!54--,'8(-!n)348',769!W9-@-8!l78(-89%!l78(-89!<'6!A34=-4-=!78!/00c!78!]'64'%! +76!94'86,'9)4!<'6!-@-893',,>!6B7479-=!)39!)5!P4'O.!*39!6:-!('8E9!?-9!'!@76'!789)!9:-! N879-=!W9'9-6%!

l78(-89E6!<7=)<!9-69757-=!9:76!<--;!*-5)4-!9:-!W-8'9-!&3=7(7'4>%!aP!:'@-!*--8!9),=.a! 6:-!6'7=.!9:'9!:-4!=-'=!:36*'8=E6!94'86,'9)4!a=)-6!8)9!O3',75>!5)4!4-53?--!)4!'6>,3A! *-('36-!P4'O!76!8)<!'!=-A)(4'(>.!:-8(-!9:-4-!6:)3,=!*-!8)!4-'6)8!6:-!<)3,=!8--=!9)! 5,--%a!eaP863,9!9)!P8n34>.a!^=79)47',.!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!&'83'4>!"g.!/001%f!!!

"d%!S%#,Q!C,$"%*($"/$0*&2"6)2$0"2*#-6##*&)"*#"E&042"E!0"@@?"!)2"%,$"/4!-$"*#"K&#" :)G$4$#7!

D79:!B),7(-!)557(-46!=4'59-=!789)!9:-!'4A-=!6-4@7(-6!'8=!9:-!=-B'49A-89!4'8;6!57,,-=! <79:!,-66!O3',757-=!'8=!A)4-!*7?)9-=!78=7@7=3',6.!4-,'97)86!*-9<--8!*,'(;!(797Z-86!'8=! 9:-!B),7(-!*-('A-!A)4-!694'78-=!'8=!()854)89'97)8',%!eC)A!W799)8.!K&#":)G$4$#" C0!)#'&0($2="L4$%-,$0"8&+0&)J#"U03!)"O$'&0("O$5*5!4?"[deWR[dje%!RJ,*3O3-4O3-H! N87@-4679>!)5!K-<!X-F7()!_4-66.!/00cT.!B%!10%f!

"1%!P!9:78;!<)A-8!:'@-!*-99-4!9),-4'8(-!'8=!38=-469'8=78?!)5!A-!e9:'8!A-8!=)f!*-('36-! 9:->!-8=34-!A)4-!B:>67(',,>!'8=!5'(-!94>78?!6793'97)86!*-99-4%!C:->!'4-!A)4-! 6>AB'9:-97(%!e$:476978-!&)4?-86-8.!O3)9-=!78!G'>!+'AA)8=.!a$:476978-E6!G-A787879>! $:'4A6!P89-4@7-<-4.a!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!X'>!g.!"gcY%f!

"i%!L-6.!>)34!(-,,B:)8-!<7,,!<)4;!=)<89)<8.!=-6B79-!'8!34*'8!,-?-8=!9)!9:-!()894'4>%! +)<-@-4.!<:-8!>)3!'4-!78!>)34!,)59!,'9-!'9!87?:9.!>)3!A'>!8)9!*-!'*,-!9)!:-'4!>)34! (-,,B:)8-!478?!*-('36-!)5!9:-!8)76-!)5!a694--9!7AB4)@-A-896.a!63(:!'6!9:-!94-8(:!<)4;! *-78?!=)8-!9)!,'>!57*-4k)B97(!('*,-!5)4!7AB4)@-=!9-,-()AA387('97)86%!W--A6!9:-! 8-7?:*)4:))=!8-@-4!O379-!O3',757-=!'6!a4-67=-897',.a!6)!9:-4-!'4-!8)!,7A796!)8! ()86943(97)8!8)76-%!+-,,).!',,k87?:9!n'(;:'AA-46!'8=!;,7-?!,7?:96%!eX'4n)47-!U-,,:)48! W'E'=':.!^A7,>!U4--8!'8=!$:'4,-6!_-44>.!ao37(;.!P!K--=!C)6979)6H!Q)<89)<8!I7;-! K-@-4!]-5)4-H!D:).!D:'9!'8=!D:-4-.a!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!2(9)*-4!"d.!/00Y%f!!!

! i1!

"g%!S%#,Q!C,$0$"!0$"%+&"6)#6//&0%$2"/0$(*#$#"*)"%,*#"!0G6($)%7!

-/OM<5'+$*(;2';6,5';<12')5#1=1;1$='/$#'F6((16>5'62'%,$"4$G!4"6)*&)"&'"&)$"(!)"!)2"&)$"

+&(!)"!#",6#3!)2"!)2"+*'$M'-'6=)'267';<6;'21=+5';<12'12'%<6;'F6((16>5'($!)#.! ?-8=-4!=76(47A78'97)8!'8=!6-F3',k)47-89'97)8!=76(47A78'97)8!'4-!*37,9!47?:9!789)!9:-! 786979397)8!)5!A'447'?-.!'8=!6)!678(-!A'447'?-!796-,5!76!);'>.!6)!9))!A369!*-!*'4478?! 6'A-k6-F!()3B,-6!54)A!79%!eb7(:'4=!Q%!X):4.!:"I&0$"H$0'$-%"U)*&)="E,A"B%0!*G,%" :($0*-!"I6#%"B%!)2"U/"'&0"9!A"O*G,%#%!R])69)8H!]-'()8!_4-66.!"gg`T.!B%!Yd%f!

/0%!S%#,Q!@)"%,*#"V6&%!%*&)?"!"#/&D$#/$0#&)"'&0"%,$":##&-*!%*&)"&'"C$))*#"H0&'$##*&)!4#" .:CH1"0$#/&)2$2"%&"!"0$/&0%$0J#"V6$#%*&)"!3&6%"+,$%,$0"B$0$)!"E*44*!(#"+&642"3$"

#$$%&'()*%)+$#,)%-)*.')/'-01)*'--21)*%345)#1)1.').#()4'63'1*'(7)8.')98:)43-1)*.')

($)J#"%&607"C,*#"#/&D$#/$0#&)J#"!0G6($)%",!#"!"#%!%$2"#63-&)-46#*&)?"36%"*%#"(!*)"

-&)-46#*&)"*#"6)#%!%$2?"#&"A&6"+*44",!5$"%&"!22"*%7":4#&?"%,*#"!0G6($)%",!#"%+&"

6)#6//&0%$2"/0$(*#$#7!

C)!*-!'*,-!9)!B,'>!78!'8!JC_!9)348'A-89.!>)3!:'@-!9)!*-!'!A-A*-4!)5!9:-!J66)(7'97)8! )5!C-8876!_4)5-667)8',6%!W-4-8'!D7,,7'A6!('88)9!*-()A-!'!A-A*-4!)5!9:-!JC_! *-('36-!6:-!76!<)A'8%!C:'9!'86<-46!9:-!O3-697)8%!eaW)44>.!W-4-8'.!L)3!$'8E9!^89-4.a! I*!(*"F$0!42.!2(9)*-4!i.!"ggg%f!!!

! ii!

N'4#).4,*?';(%"(4'2)%"2*/"&*R"2#/#,&*?';(%"(4'2)%"2*

P8!()867=-478?!63*()8(,367)86!6)!5'4.!<-!:'@-!)8,>!()867=-4-=!'4?3A-896!<79:!-F'(9,>! )8-!63*()8(,367)8%!]39!9:-4-!('8!*-!,)8?-4!6-47-6!R)4!69478?6!)4!(:'786.!75!>)3!B4-5-4T!)5! '4?3A-896!!!'4?3A-896!9:'9!:'@-!A)4-!9:'8!)8-!63*()8(,367)8%!+-4-E6!'!67AB,-!-F'AB,-H!

234!8-7?:*)4E6!('9!C)AA>!A'8'?-=!9)!68-';!789)!)34!:)36-.!6)!Q-4@76:!76! 74479'9-=%!W)!:-E6!*--8!B7(;78?!)8!Q7F7-!'8=!U)46:7-%!W)!Q7F7-!'8=!U)46:7-! '4-!<'4>!)5!:7A%!

C:76!'4?3A-89!()89'786!5)34!69'9-A-896H!57469!9:-4-!76!'8!3863BB)49-=!B4-A76-.!5),,)<-=! *>!'!63*()8(,367)8.!5),,)<-=!*>!'!6-()8=!63*()8(,367)8.!5),,)<-=!*>!9:-!A'78! ()8(,367)8%!+-4-E6!'!4-()86943(97)8!)5!9:76!'4?3A-89H!

R"T!234!8-7?:*)4E6!('9!C)AA>!A'8'?-=!9)!68-';!789)!)34!:)36-!9:76! '59-48))8%!

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!Q-4@76:!76!74479'9-=%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!+-E6!*--8!B7(;78?!)8!Q7F7-!'8=!U)46:7-%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R`T!Q7F7-!'8=!U)46:7-!'4-!<'4>!)5!Q-4@76:%!

I-9E6!()867=-4!9:-!5),,)<78?!-F'AB,-H!

^,-B:'896!'4-!?,399)86!'8=!75!9:-74!:'*79'9!<-4-!4-6947(9-=.!79!<)3,=!6))8!*-! 6947BB-=!)5!',,!@-?-9'97)8%!G)4!9:76!4-'6)8!79!76!@7493',,>!7AB)667*,-!9)! A'789'78!-,-B:'896!78!Z))6!78!-8@74)8A-896!4-6-A*,78?!9:-74!8'934',! :'*79'9%!+-8(-!9:-!7AB)49'8(-!)5!,'4?-!4-6-4@-6%!e^A7,!W(:3,9:-66.!:'0*-!.! 4-@%!-=%.!94'86,'9-=!*>!]47'8!]'99-46:'<!'8=!C%!'8=!j%!W(:-,*-49%!RK-<! L)4;H!W7A)8!'8=!W(:369-4.!"gdgT.!8%B%f!

G7469.!8)97(-!9:'9!78!9:-!57469!,78-!<-!()3,=!'==!9:-!<)4=!E9:-4-5)4-E!*-9<--8!9:-!<)4=6! E'8=E!'8=!E75E%!J==78?!E9:-4-5)4-E!'8=!4-<47978?!9:-!'4?3A-89!6943(934',,>.!<-!?-9H!

\\\'\\\.!'8=!%,$0$'&0$!\\\*\\\%!L&0"%,*#"0$!#&).!\\\(\\\%!+-8(-! \\\=\\\%!

C:-!69'9-A-89!78!9:-!'kB)6797)8!76!'8!3863BB)49-=!B4-A76-.!'8=!9:-!69'9-A-896!78!9:-!*k.!(k! '8=!=kB)6797)86!'4-!',,!()8(,367)86%!C:-!<)4=!E9:-4-5)4-E!67?8',6!9:'9!9:-!()8(,367)8!'59-4! 79!76!63BB)6-=!9)!5),,)<!54)A!'!B4-A76-!',4-'=>!B4-6-89-=[!',6).!E5)4!9:76!4-'6)8E!78=7('9-6! 9:'9!9:-!()8(,367)8!'59-4!79!76!63BB)6-=!9)!5),,)<!54)A!'!4-'6)8!!!'!B4-A76-!!!',4-'=>! ?7@-8%!C:-!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4!E:-8(-E!67?8',6!9:-!()8(,367)8!9:'9!76!W(:3,9:-66E!A'78! B)789!!!:76!A'78!()8(,367)8!!!78!9:76!B'66'?-%!D-!('8!4-()86943(9!:76!'4?3A-89!'6! 5),,)<6H!

! ig!

R"T!^,-B:'896!'4-!?,399)86%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!P5!-,-B:'896E!:'*79'9!<-4-!4-6947(9-=.!79!<)3,=!6))8!*-!6947BB-=!)5!',,! @-?-9'97)8%!

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!P9!76!@7493',,>!7AB)667*,-!9)!A'789'78!-,-B:'896!78!Z))6!78!-8@74)8A-896! 4-6-A*,78?!9:-74!8'934',!:'*79'9%!

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R`T!I'4?-!4-6-4@-6!'4-!7AB)49'89!9)!-,-B:'896%!

W)A-97A-6!'4?3-46!,-'@-!9:-74!63*()8(,367)86!3869'9-=[!9:76!:'BB-86!*)9:!<79:!'4?3A-896! 9:'9!:'@-!-F'(9,>!)8-!63*()8(,367)8!'8=!<79:!'4?3A-896!9:'9!:'@-!A)4-!9:'8!)8-! 63*()8(,367)8%!W)A-97A-6!<:-8!)8-!)4!A)4-!63*()8(,367)8!76!,-59!3869'9-=.!6)!76!9:-! A'78!()8(,367)8%!RP9E6!'!?))=!7=-'!9)!4-@7-<!9:-!A'9-47',!)8!3869'9-=!()8(,367)86!*-5)4-! ?)78?!)8!!!'8=!79!<)3,=!*-!'8!-6B-(7',,>!?))=!7=-'!9)!?)!)@-4!_4'(97(-!_4)*,-A6!W-9!"k"Y! *-5)4-!?)78?!)8%T!

I-9E6!()867=-4!'8!-F'AB,-.!<:7(:!:'6!)8-!3869'9-=!63*()8(,367)8!'8=!'8!3869'9-=!A'78! ()8(,367)8H!

]39!75!>)3!)8,>!:'@-!,)@-!5)4!>)34!)<8!4'(-! C:-8!>)3!)8,>!,-'@-!6B'(-!9)!=76(47A78'9-! J8=!9)!=76(47A78'9-!)8,>!?-8-4'9-6!:'9-! J8=!<:-8!>)3!:'9-!9:-8!>)3E4-!*)38=!9)!?-9!74'9-.!>-':! e],'(;!^>-=!_-'6.!aD:-4-!P6!C:-!I)@-M.a!)8!;4$/,6)D.!/00Y%f!

I-9E6!B39!9)?-9:-4!9:-!9<)!3863BB)49-=!B4-A76-6!-FB4-66-=!78!9:-!57469!9:4--!,78-6%!C:76! <7,,!,-9!36!69'49!'!4-()86943(97)8!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!9:76!<'>H!

R"T!P5!>)3!)8,>!:'@-!,)@-!5)4!>)34!)<8!4'(-!9:-8!>)3!)8,>!,-'@-!6B'(-!9)! =76(47A78'9-%!

R/T!C)!=76(47A78'9-!)8,>!?-8-4'9-6!:'9-%!

I-9E6!'==!9)!)34!'4?3A-89!4-()86943(97)8!9:-!3869'9-=!()8(,367)8!9:'9!9:-6-!9<)!B4-A76-6! '4-!789-8=-=!9)!63BB)49[!=)78?!6)!?7@-6!36!9:-!5),,)<78?H!

R"T!P5!>)3!)8,>!:'@-!,)@-!5)4!>)34!)<8!4'(-!9:-8!>)3!)8,>!,-'@-!6B'(-!9)! =76(47A78'9-%!

R/T!C)!=76(47A78'9-!)8,>!?-8-4'9-6!:'9-%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!P5!>)3!)8,>!:'@-!,)@-!5)4!>)34!)<8!4'(-!9:-8!>)3!)8,>!?-8-4'9-!:'9-%! R3869'9-=T!

! g0!

I-9E6!'==!9:-!3863BB)49-=!B4-A76-!-FB4-66-=!78!9:-!5)349:!,78-.!'6!5),,)<6H!

R"T!P5!>)3!)8,>!:'@-!,)@-!5)4!>)34!)<8!4'(-!9:-8!>)3!)8,>!,-'@-!6B'(-!9)! =76(47A78'9-%!

R/T!C)!=76(47A78'9-!)8,>!?-8-4'9-6!:'9-%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!P5!>)3!)8,>!:'@-!,)@-!5)4!>)34!)<8!4'(-!9:-8!>)3!)8,>!?-8-4'9-!:'9-%! R3869'9-=T!

R`T!D:-8!>)3!:'9-!9:-8!>)3E4-!*)38=!9)!?-9!74'9-%!

K)<!',,!<-!8--=!9)!=)!76!B39!RYT!'8=!R`T!9)?-9:-4!9)!?-9!9:-!3869'9-=!A'78!()8(,367)8.! <:7(:!<-!('8!=)!'6!5),,)<6H!

R"T!P5!>)3!)8,>!:'@-!,)@-!5)4!>)34!)<8!4'(-!9:-8!>)3!)8,>!,-'@-!6B'(-!9)! =76(47A78'9-%!

R/T!C)!=76(47A78'9-!)8,>!?-8-4'9-6!:'9-%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!P5!>)3!)8,>!:'@-!,)@-!5)4!>)34!)<8!4'(-!9:-8!>)3!)8,>!?-8-4'9-!:'9-%! R3869'9-=T!

R`T!D:-8!>)3!:'9-!9:-8!>)3E4-!*)38=!9)!?-9!74'9-%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RcT!P5!>)3!)8,>!:'@-!,)@-!5)4!>)34!)<8!4'(-!9:-8!>)3E4-!*)38=!9)!?-9!74'9-%! R3869'9-=T!

! g"!

5H=-I!-J*5HKLMJN?Q*?JI*OPO\Q*

HJ-KS?IHR-I!ST*=HTRNJSI?*6!IA*NRMI!5MJ*?RL-KS-MR?!KS?*

=S>hKH*RS?I=IJ>*-KS-MR?!KS?*

P86943(97)86H!;!-,"!0G6($)%"*)"%,*#"/0!-%*-$"/0&34$(#"#$%",!#"!%"4$!#%"&)$"#63-&)-46#*&)" !)2"$T!-%4A"&)$"(!*)"-&)-46#*&)7"B&($?"36%")&%"!44?"&'"%,$#$"!0G6($)%#",!5$"(&0$"%,!)"

&)$"#63-&)-46#*&)7"B&($?"36%")&%"!44?"&'"%,$#$"!0G6($)%#",!5$"6)#%!%$2"-&)-46#*&)#"""

#63-&)-&)-46#*&)#"!)2k&0"(!*)"-&)-46#*&)#7"L&0"$!-,"!0G6($)%?"2&"!)"!0G6($)%"

0$-&)#%06-%*&)?"'&44&+*)G"%,$"'*5$"!0G6($)%"0$-&)#%06-%*&)"064$#7"Q$T%"%&"$!-,"6)#%!%$2"

-&)-46#*&)".#63-&)-46#*&)"&0"(!*)"-&)-46#*&)1?"+0*%$"%,$"+&02"J6)#%!%$2J"*)"/!0$)%,$#$#7"

M&")&%"!22"!)A"$44*/#$#7"

W'AB,-!_4)*,-A6H!!

! 247?78',!_'66'?-H!

D@<6oD'261)'E$$<.'-'DL#'L',=$%'6=7;<1=>'6:$*;'6=7;<1=>8';<6;'<$&5'F56=2'

b'**79.a!:-!6'7=.!a'8=!b'**79!A-'86!$)AB'8>.a!:-!6'7=.!a'8=!$)AB'8>! A-'86!G))=!'8=!I769-878?k9)kX-k+3AA78?!'8=!63(:!,7;-%a!eJ%!J%!X7,8-.! E*))*$R%,$RH&&,%!RK-<!L)4;H!^%!_%!Q399)8!'8=!$)AB'8>.!"g/dT.!B%!//%f!

! ! J86<-4H!

R"T!C:'9!:),-!A-'86!b'**79%! R/T!b'**79!A-'86!$)AB'8>%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!C:'9!:),-!A-'86!$)AB'8>%!R3869'9-=T! R`T!$)AB'8>!A-'86!G))=!'8=!I769-878?k9)kX-k+3AA78?!'8=! 63(:!,7;-%!

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RcT!C:'9!:),-!A-'86!G))=!'8=!I769-878?k9)kX-k+3AA78?!'8=!63(:! ,7;-%!R3869'9-=T!

! g/!

! 247?78',!_'66'?-H!

-/E6*&'@(1^1=M')5N5&$?5)';<5'/R*F?M'2<$;'62'6='1=;(6F*(6&'?&675('/6;'

l7,,'8)@'f%!]-('36-!9:-!,-'?3-6!B,'>-=!78!?>A6!9:'9!)59-8!=)3*,-=!'6! ='8(-!5,))46.!9:-!6345'(-6!<-4-!6,7BB-4>!'8=!:-!:'=!'!:'4=!97A-!?-9978?!:76! 5))978?%!W78(-!:-!()3,=8E9!?-9!:76!5--9!6-9!9)!94>!'!:));!6:)9.!:-!69'49-=! 6:))978?!<79:!:76!5--9!)55!9:-!5,))4.!J47Z78!6'7=!78!"ggi.!'(()4=78?!9)!9:-! _:7,'=-,B:7'!P8O374-4%!ea_'3,!J47Z78.!1i[!K]J!U4-'9!D'6!'!_7)8--4!)5! &3AB!W:)9.a!2*793'4>.!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!Q-(-A*-4!"`.!/00d%f!

! ! J86<-4H!

R"T!C:-!l7,,'8)@'!7894'A34',!*'6;-9*',,!,-'?3-6!B,'>-=!78!?>A6!9:'9!)59-8! =)3*,-=!'6!='8(-!5,))46%!

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!C:-!6345'(-6!<-4-!6,7BB-4>%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!l7,,'8)@'!7894'A34',!*'6;-9*',,!B,'>-4!_'3,!J47Z78!()3,=8E9!?-9! :76!5--9!6-9!9)!94>!'!:));!6:)9%!!

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R`T!+-!69'49-=!6:))978?!<79:!:76!5--9!)55!9:-!5,))4%!

"%!P5!PEA!8)9!:)A-!6))8.!9:'9!A-'86!J?8-6!76!=-'=%!J8=!75!J?8-6!76!=-'=.!>)3!;7,,-=!:-4%! J8=!75!>)3!;7,,-=!:-4.!9:'9!A';-6!>)3!'!A34=-4-4%!eW)B:7'.!Q)4)9:>E6!A)9:-4.!9)! Q)4)9:>.!)8!aC:-!U),=-8!U74,6.a!I75-97A-.!'74-=!2(9)*-4!/".!/00c%f!!!

/%!S%#,Q!Q$60!#%,$)*!"*#"!"#A)20&($"(!0D$2"3A"#6#-$/%*3*4*%A"%&"($)%!4"!)2"/,A#*-!4" '!%*G6$?"6#6!44A"3A"+&00A*)G"!)2"2$/0$##*&)?"!)2"&'%$)"3A",$!2!-,$"!)2"

G!#%0&*)%$#%*)!4"!)2"-*0-64!%&0A"2*#%603!)-$#7!

-/IM<62;1;7'F56=2'?6221$=8'+<62;1;7'F56=2'=5*(62;<5=16.'@=)'?6221$='6=)'

8-34'69:-87'!A-'8!7869'*7,79>%!J8=!7869'*7,79>!A-'86!9:-!-8=!)5!(7@7,7Z'97)8%!eJ,=)36! +3F,->.!80!5$"Q$+"E&042%!RK-<!L)4;H!]'89'A.!"gcYT.!B%!"d"%f!

Y%!S%#,Q!C,$"#/$!D$0"*#"!"'*-%*&)!4"-,!0!-%$0"-!44$2"I07"M!04*)G7"F$"!)2",*#"#/&6#$?"%&" +,&(",$"*#"#/$!D*)G?"!0$"#6//&#$2"%&"G&"&6%"%&"2*))$0?"36%",$"-!)J%"G$%",*#")$-D%*$"%*$2"

/0&/$04A7!

-/gM=&522';<12'=5+,;15'12'($*=)'F7'=5+,'%5')$=Q;'>$'$*;';$')1==5(';$k87?:9.!'8=!75!P! =)8E9!?)!)39!9)!=788-4!9)k87?:9.!P!8-@-4!?)!9)!9:-!)557(-!'?'78.!'8=!75!P!=)8E9!?)!9)!9:-! )557(-!'?'78.!>)3!'8=!P!69'4@-.!'8=!)34!(:7,=4-8!<7,,!*-!5,38?!789)!9:-!694--96%!e&%!X%! ]'447-.!H$%$0"H!)"!)2"E$)2A%!RK-<!L)4;H!$:'4,-6!W(47*-4E6!W)8.!"g`0S"g0d.!B%!/0%f! !!

! gY!

`%!S%#,Q!@)"iffj"K&#":)G$4$#"H&4*-$"M$/!0%($)%"S''*-$0"B%$5$)"9!0-*!"#,&%"!)2"D*44$2" [eRA$!0R&42"M$5&)"80&+)"!#"80&+)"#4&+4A"3!-D$2"!"-!0"%&+!02"9!0-*!7!

C:-!_),7(-!$)AA7667)8!5)38=!9:'9!]4)<8!<'6!?)78?!)8,>!'*)39!/!AB:.!'8=!9:36! U'4(7'!<'6!'*,-!9)!69-B!)39!)5!9:-!<'>.!<'6!8)9!78!='8?-4!'8=!8)9!n369757-=!78!3678?! =-'=,>!5)4(-%!e^4<78!$:-A-478;>.!aJ!]'=!IJ_Q!Q-(767)8.!WO3'4-=.a!K&#":)G$4$#" C*($#.!&'83'4>!"/.!/001%f!!!

c%!S%#,Q!B*)-$0$"!)2">!04&#"6#$2"#&--$0"%!4D"!#"!"-&2$"%&")$G&%*!%$"206G"2$!4#7!

L'=$;1+5)';<6;';<5'F$(5'31=+5(5'2?$,5';$'I6(&$28';<5'F$(5'5T+1;5)'-'/31=+5(5M'>$;'

'*)39!6)((-4%!C:-!A)4-!-F(79-=!:-!?)9!'*)39!6)((-4.!9:-!A)4-!A)8->!:-!A'=-%!C:-! F$(5'F$=57'<5'F6)58';<5'F$(5'F$=57'L'F6)5-.'/ca'I5=;'HI*(;12']6F52']6+,2$='LLLh'

<79:!j476!^F.!L0&("H*$-$#"%&"E$*G,%="S)-$"U/&)"!"C*($"*)"B&6%,#*2$"Z6$$)#%!RK-<! L)4;H!_)(;-9!]));6SXCl!]));6.!/00cT.!B%!``%f!

d%!eX)6-6f!X'B-6'!e:-'=!)5!9:-!N?'8='!D7,=,75-!J39:)479>!RNDJTf!6'7=!*-('36-! B)'(:78?.!94'=-!'8=!()863AB97)8!)5!?'A-!A-'9!76!7,,-?',.!A)69!)5!9:-!'(97@797-6!'4-! =)8-!'9!87?:9!78!6,3A6!)4!38,7(-86-=!B,'(-6%!+-!6'7=!()86-O3-89,>.!4-?769-4-=! @-9-478'47'86!=)!8)9!786B-(9!9:-!A-'9%!

aNDJ!9:-4-5)4-!<'486!9:-!B3*,1+'6>61=2;'+$=2*F?;1$='$#'6=7'%1&)'6=1F6&'F56;.-D' eU-4',=!C-8><'.!aX)8;->!X-'9!W),=!78!$79>.a!Q$+"Y*#*&)"RN?'8='T.!J3?369!/d.! /00c%f!!!

1%!28!&3,>!".!"g1"!!!'*)39!'!>-'4!*-5)4-!eG]P!Q74-(9)4!&%!^=?'4f!+))@-4E6!=-'9:!'8=!9:-! D'9-4?'9-!*4-';k78!!!+))@-4!B4)A)9-=!eD%!X'4;f!G-,9!9)!*-!9:-!83A*-4!9:4--!)557(7',! 78!9:-!G]P%!C:)3?:!+))@-4E6!67=-;7(;.!$,>=-!C),6)8.!<'6!9-(:87(',,>!9:-!83A*-4!9<)! )557(7',.!C),6)8!<'6!',6)!7,,!'8=!=7=!8)9!()A-!9)!<)4;!A'8>!='>6.!A-'878?!:-!:'=!8)! )B-4'97)8',!()894),!)5!9:-!*34-'3%!C:36.!A>!547-8=!eG-,9f!*-('A-!9:-!='>k9)k='>! A'8'?-4!)5!',,!G]P!A'99-46!'6!,)8?!'6!:-!;-B9!+))@-4!'8=!C),6)8!785)4A-=!)4!6)3?:9! +))@-4E6!'BB4)@',!)8!B),7(>!A'99-46%!e])*!D))=<'4=.!a+)<!X'4;!G-,9!*-('A-!EQ--B! C:4)'9E.a!E!#,*)G%&)"H&#%.!&38-!/.!/00c%f!

i%!@",&/$">!)2A"M!04*)G"+!#"#/&&'*)G"%,$"+&($)J#"-4&%,*)G"*)26#%0A?"36%"@"0$!44A"2&)J%" D)&+",&+"#,$"($!)%"%,$#$"4*)$#7!

D:-8!'!<)A'8!<-'46!9:-!6'A-! =4-66!9<7(-!

C:-8!6:-!=)-68E9!5--,!(:7(%! J8=!<:-8!6:-!=)-68E9!5--,!(:7(! W:-!5--,6!786-(34-! C:-8!6:-!('8E9!6,--B!'9! 87?:9!9:-8!6:-!6355-46!54)A! 8-4@)36!-F:'3697)8!9:-8! 9:'9!()3,=!,-'=!9)!'!8-4@)36!*4-';=)<8%! e$'8=>!Q'4,78?.!>!)2A"M!04*)G%!RX'=4'6H!+'83A'8!]));6.!"gg/T.!BB%!ggk"00%f!

! g`!

g%!S%#,Q!C,$"!0G6($)%"*)"%,*#"/!##!G$"*#"3&42'!-$2"!)2"6)2$04*)$27!

JA)8?!9:-!5-<!6(43**>!94--6!'8=!9:-!5)4-69!)5!9-896!78!9:-!)@-4(4)<=-=!B-47A-9-4!)5! j)9)k47!e78!j)4-'f.!9:-!=-'=!eN%W%!X'478-6f!<-4-!'9!,'69!*347-=!78!'!?4'@-!*,'69-=!54)A! 9:-!74)8k54)Z-8!-'49:%!C:-4-!<'6!'8!),=k5'6:7)8-=!,799,-!6O3'**,-!<:-8!U-8-4',!e2%!_%f! WA79:!786769-=!9:'9!9:-!78=)A79'*,-!F$0!42"C0*36)$!()44-6B)8=-89!X'4?3-479-!+7??786! 6:)3,=!*-!-@'(3'9-=!*>!'74.!=-6B79-!:-4!-84'?-=!B4)9-696!)5!6-F3',!=76(47A78'97)8H! aC:-4-!'4-!'!,)9!)5!?))=!X'478-6!<:)!'4-!?-9978?!54)69*79-.a!6'7=!2%!_%.!a'8=!)B*:%'*

1/$(+*&%@"*@)#+*#+,2,*N/$)",2Z*:%'*@)44*.$%;/;4:*0,#*B$%2#;)#,Z*/"&*#+,"*

2%1,;%&:*)2*0%)"0*#%*+/3,*#%*#/9,*(/$,*%B*:%'G*!*/1*2'$,*#+,2,*N/$)",2*@)44*2,,*

#+/#*:%'*/$,*#/9,"*(/$,*%BZ*/"&*@,*+/3,"E#*0%#*1,"*B%$*#+/#*9)"&*%B*;'2)",22Ga! eX'F!+'6978?6.!C,$"N&0$!)"E!0%!RK-<!L)4;H!W7A)8!'8=!W(:369-4.!"gi1T.!B%!"d/%f!!!

Wa.'-/BM<$F'<5')1)'#$(5,=$%8'<5'6&2$')1)'?(5)52;1=6;5';$':5'+$=#$(F5)';$';<5'1F6>5'$#'

<12'3$=-.'b$(5$N5('%<$F'<5')1)'?(5)52;1=6;58';<5F'<5'6&2$'+6&&5)J'6=)'%<$F'<5'

(',,-=.!9:-A!:-!',6)!n369757-=H!'8=!<:)A!:-!n369757-=.!9:-A!:-!',6)!?,)4757-=%!eO&(!)#! iH!/gkY0f!!

! gc!

A CHALLENGING PROBLEM

C,*#"/!##!G$"-&)%!*)#"!)"!0G6($)%"+*%,"%+&"6)#6//&0%$2"/0$(*#$#?"

%+&"#63-&)-46#*&)#?"!)2"!"(!*)"-&)-46#*&)7"C,$"-,!44$)G$"*#"'&0"A&6"%&"

0$-&)#%06-%"%,$"!0G6($)%?"'&44&+*)G"%,$"#!($"*)#%06-%*&)#"!#"'&0"

H0!-%*-$"H0&34$(#"B$%"[R[j7"

C:-!4-?7)8',!=)A78'8(-!P4'8!=-674-6!76!*),69-4-=!*>!83(,-'4!('B'*7,79>! '8=!9:-!789-48'97)8',!4-6B-(9!9:->!:'@-!,)8?!()@-9-=!76!=-B-8=-89!3B)8! 79%!X)4-!7AB)49'89,>.!P4'8!<7,,!:'@-!83(,-'4!<-'B)86!*-('36-.!'6!9:-! J>'9),,':!j:)A-787!)8(-!5'A)36,>!4-A'4;-=.!aJA-47('!('88)9!=)!'! ='A8!9:78?!'*)39!79%a!X)4-!'((34'9-,>.!<-!<)8E9!=)!'8>9:78?!'*)39!79.! 8)9!*-('36-!<-!'4-!38'*,-.!*39!*-('36-!<-!=)!8)9!:'@-!9:-!<7,,%! l7-98'A!:'6!()<-=!Q-A)(4'96!789)!97A7=79>.!'8=!5-'4!)5!P4'O!:'6! 4-8=-4-=!b-B3*,7('86!9))9:,-66%!

e&)6-B:!$%!_:7,,7B6.!a$)AA-89'4>H!P5!D-!D'89!P4'8!9)!J*'8=)8!C:-74! K3(,-'4!JA*797)86.!I7;-!P9!)4!K)9.!D-!X369!^8?'?-!C:-A.a!84!-D"

:($0*-!.!X'4(:!"/.!/001%f!

! gd!

=*?+%$#*H,(/.*

CONGRATULATIONS!

P9E6!9';-8!'!,)9!)5!97A-!!!'8=!:'4=!<)4;!!!*39!>)3E@-!A'=-!79!9:4)3?:!9:-!*'67(6!8-(-66'4>! 5)4!7=-8975>78?!'4?3A-896!'8=!9:-74!B'496%!

J9!9:76!B)789.!>)3!6:)3,=!*-!'*,-!9)H!

! 4-()?87Z-!B4-A76-!7894)=3(-46!'8=!()8(,367)8!7894)=3(-46!

! 4-'=!'!B'66'?-!'8=!=-9-4A78-!<:-9:-4!)4!8)9!79!()89'786!'8!'4?3A-89!

! 7=-8975>!9:-!69'9-=!A'78!()8(,367)8!)5!'8!'4?3A-89!

! 7=-8975>!9:-!69'9-=!B4-A76-!)4!B4-A76-6!)5!'8!'4?3A-89!

! 4-()86943(9!'4?3A-896!

! 7=-8975>!'8>!69'9-=!63*()8(,367)86!!

! '==!'8>!3869'9-=!63*()8(,367)86!)4!A'78!()8(,367)86!

K)<!>)3E4-!4-'=>!9)!69'49!-@',3'978?!'4?3A-896%!P8!$:'B9-4!C<).!>)3E,,!,-'48!9:-!*'67(! ()8(-B96!8--=-=!9)!-@',3'9-!'4?3A-896%!P8!$:'B9-46!C:4--!'8=!G)34.!>)3E,,!,-'48!'*)39! 9<)!6B-(757(!;78=6!)5!'4?3A-896!'8=!>)3E,,!,-'48!9-(:87O3-6!9:'9!<7,,!,-9!>)3!'BB,>!9:-! ()8(-B96!>)3!<7,,!:'@-!,-'48-=!78!$:'B9-4!C<)!6)!9:'9!>)3!('8!-@',3'9-!9:)6-!;78=6!)5! '4?3A-896%!$:'B9-46!C:4--!'8=!G)34!<7,,!',6)!7894)=3(-!>)3!9)!6)A-!()AA)8!B'99-486!)5! 4-'6)878?.!6)A-!?))=!'8=!6)A-!A769';-8%!

! g1!

ANSWERS TO SELECTED PRACTICE PROBLEMS FOR CHAPTER ONE

5$/(#)(,*5$%;4,12*?,#*OPO*

/%!(!!

c%!*!

1%!(!

g%!'!!

5$/(#)(,*5$%;4,12*?,#*OPU*

"%!$)8(,367)8H!X)69!)5!9:-!-'4,>!94'8679!36-46!('A-!54)A!9:-!A7==,-!'8=!3BB-4!(,'66-6%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!*-('36-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

`%!$)8(,367)8H!C:-!78:'*79'896!)5!K'?'6';7!:'@-!'*6)4*-=!A'8>!785,3-8(-6!54)A!5)4-7?8! (3,934-6%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!9:36!

d%!$)8(,367)8H!C:)6-!n3@-87,-6!6-89!9)!'=3,9!B476)86!'4-!'9!'!?4)66!=76'=@'89'?-%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!'6!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

i%!$)8(,367)8H!P8!#6#,*!*'4!B'4,'8(-!+!#!3*!76!;8)<8!'6!)!(*2!.!a9-'46%a!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!5)4!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

! gi!

""%!$)8(,367)8H!C:-!6)(7',!'8=!-()8)A7(!@7'*7,79>!)5!I799,-!C);>)!4-696!,'4?-,>!)8! &'B'8-6-kJA-47('86!<:)!,7@-!78!9:-!63*34*6!*39!<:)!4-9348!)(('67)8',,>!9)!*3>! &'B'8-6-!?))=6!'8=!-8n)>!'!5'@)479-!4-69'34'89!'8=!',6)!)8!9)347696!54)A!&'B'8!<:)! B4-5-4!5'A7,7'4!:)9-,!'(()AA)='97)86!9)!A)4-!<-69-487Z-=!)8-6%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!79!5),,)<6!9:'9!

"Y%!$)8(,367)8H!Q7@-4679>!B4)A)9-6!(4-'97@79>%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!-4?)!

"c%!$)8(,367)8H!Nonfiction doesn't always work well for audio books%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!*-('36-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

5$/(#)(,*5$%;4,12*?,#*OPV*

"%!$)8(,367)8H!P9E6!:'4=!8)9!9)!-8@>!'!('9%!

Y%!$)8(,367)8H!]'A*))!76!'!634@7@)4%!

c%!$)8(,367)8H!W',9!I';-!$79>!76!,7;-!'!n-<-,%!

1%!$)8(,367)8H!C:-4-!76!8)!*'676!5)4!9:-!4-O374-A-89!9:'9!9:-!,-?',!'&0(!)5!A'447'?-!3879-! A-A*-46!)5!=755-4-89!6-F-6%!

g%!$)8(,367)8H!P9E6!399-4!,38'(>!9)!:'@-!9:-!$'9:),7(!$:34(:!94>78?!9)!=7(9'9-!<:)!6:)3,=! '8=!6:)3,=8E9!*-!',,)<-=!9)!A'44>%!

"0%!$)8(,367)8H!J*),797)8!)5!B4)6979397)8!,'<6!',,)<6!5)4!,-66!='8?-4!9)!B4)697939-6!

5$/(#)(,*5$%;4,12*?,#*OPY*

"%!$)8(,367)8H!28-!6:)3,=!36-!),7@-6!78!A)=-4'97)8%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!6)!

! gg!

Y%!$)8(,367)8H!28-!6:)3,=!A';-!634-!6,)3(:>!B7-(-6!)5!(,)9:78?!579!9:4)3?:!9:-!6:)3,=-4! '8=!'9!9:-!<'769%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

c%!$)8(,367)8H!G3ZZ>!D3ZZ>!<'68E9!53ZZ>%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

1%!$)8(,367)8H!C:-!()894),,-4!('8!)8,>!6-4@-!9:-!B-)B,-!*>!?'9:-478?!785)4A'97)8!'8=! A';78?!B3*,7(!9:-!4-63,96!)5!9:-!78@-697?'97)8%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!?7@-8!9:'9.!

g%!$)8(,367)8H!28-!6:)3,=!;--B!<'7978?!5)4!67?86!)5!8-<!?4)<9:!)8!*)3?'78@7,,-'%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!6)!

"0%!$)8(,367)8H!28!9:-!""9:.!>)3!6:)3,=!'=)B9!'!8-<!547-8=!'9!'8!'87A',!6:-,9-4%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

5$/(#)(,*5$%;4,12*?,#*OP\*

/%!D:)6-!'4?3A-89!76!79MH!5-A787696E!

$)8(,367)8H!$:7,=4-8E6!7663-6!<-4-!<)A-8E6!7663-6%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!6)!

c%!D:)6-!'4?3A-89!76!79MH!U'4>!$))B-4E6!

$)8(,367)8H!P!'A!8)9!'54'7=!)5!9:-!53934-%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

! "00!

1%!D:)6-!'4?3A-89!76!79MH!I799,-!D',9-4E6!

$)8(,367)8H!X'>*-!P!6:)3,=!?)!9)!(:34(:!A)4-!)59-8%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

g%!D:)6-!'4?3A-89!76!79MH!j'4--A!J*=3,k&'**'4E6!

$)8(,367)8H!P!<)8E9!*-!:74-=!9)!=)!9-,-@767)8!()AA-4(7',6%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!*-('36-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

5$/(#)(,*5$%;4,12*?,#*OP]*

/%!$)8(,367)8H!28-k9:74=!)5!789-46-F!(:7,=4-8!*)48!'4-!(:7,=4-8!)5!(),)4%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!9:'9!<)3,=!A-'8!

`%!$)8(,367)8H!P8!9:-!B),7(-!'4(:7@-6!78!]4'Z7,.!'!,'4?-!83A*-4!)5!('6-6!)5!A34=-4-=!?'>! A-8!,7-!697,,!386),@-=%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!*-('36-!R36-=!9:4--!97A-6T!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

d%!$)8(,367)8H!C:-!A'8!<:)!()A-6!)8!9:-!4'=7)!9)!9-,,!A-!:)<!<:79-!A>!6:7496!('8!*-! ('8E9!*-!'!A'8%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!E('36-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

i%!$)8(,367)8H!J=3,96!<7,,!*-!-,*)<78?!;7=6!'67=-!9)!6--!C,$"B/&)G$8&3"BV6!0$H!)%#" I&5*$%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!*-('36-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

! "0"!

g%!$)8(,367)8H!_4-67=-89!Q<7?:9!Q%!^76-8:)<-4!()3,=!8)9!6--;!'!9:74=!9-4A!78!"gd0%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!*-('36-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

"0%!$)8(,367)8H!_7()!N87)8!:'6!9:-!:7?:-69!B)B3,'97)8!=-8679>!78!I)6!J8?-,-6%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!:-8(-!

"/%!$)8(,367)8H!_)-96!'4-!)59-8!9:-!57469!9)!*-!-F-(39-=!78!9)9',79'47'8!4-?7A-6%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!*-('36-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

"`%!$)8(,367)8H!$:4)87(!A',8394797)8!'8=!'!:)69!)5!=7-9k4-,'9-=!7,,8-66-6!<-4-!6-47)36! :-',9:!B4)*,-A6!5)4!9:-!A'n)479>!)5!X'()8!$)389>E6!*,'(;!4-67=-896!78!9:-!"gY06%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!'6!'!4-63,9!

"c%!$)8(,367)8H!Q3478?!9:-!57469!67F9--8!<--;6!'59-4!()8(-B97)8.!'!A)9:-4E6!@79'A78!^! ,-@-,6!B,'>!'8!7AB)49'89!4),-!78!63((-6653,!,38?!=-@-,)BA-89%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!:-8(-!

"1%!$)8(,367)8H!WA',,!76!,)69%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!6)!

"g%!$)8(,367)8H!C:-4-E6!786'879>!78!A>!5'A7,>%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

/"%!$)8(,367)8H!X>!<)A'8!=)-68E9!,)@-!A-%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

! "0/!

/Y%!$)8(,367)8H!C:-!24)*,'8()!76!'!5'@)479-!?4'B-54379!)5!A'8>!5'4A-46!A'4;-9!6:)BB-46%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

/d%!$)8(,367)8H!C:-!W38=7',!76!8)9!B-45-(9%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!9:-4-5)4-!

/i%!$)8(,367)8H!C:-!P8=7'86!'4-!]4'Z7,E6!A)69!,-?797A'9-!:-746%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

Y0%!$)8(,367)8H!X'8>!>)38?!B-)B,-!'4-!578=78?!9:'9!6A',,!:)36-6!'8=!A7836(3,-!()8=)6! 579!9:-74!-()8)A7(!()8=797)86!n369!578-%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!9:-4-5)4-!

Y/%!$)8(,367)8H!PEA!B-4(-7@-=!'6!B)667*,>!'!B4-='9)4!!!'!4'B769.!6-47',!;7,,-4.!)4!694)8?k '4A-=!9:7-5%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!9:-4-5)4-!

Yc%!$)8(,367)8H!X-4(>!('88)9!*-!'9947*39-=!9)!U)=%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!5)4!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!9:-4-5)4-!

Y1%!$)8(,367)8H!C:-!94'6:!94'865-4!5'(7,79>!'9!9:-!U,-8=',-!JA-47('8'!X',,!'(4)66!9:-! 694--9!54)A!X4%!b'>!_'9-,E6!]-69!D-69-48!U),=-8!j->!A)9-,!<7,,!:349!:76!*3678-66%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!'6!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

! "0Y!

Yg%!$)8(,367)8H!C:-!X''6'7!=)!8)9!:'@-!,'<6!)8!'?47(3,934',!,'8=%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!'6!63(:!

`"%!$)8(,367)8H!28-!6:)3,=!*-!A78=53,!)5!9:-!476;!)5!5))=k*)48-!7,,8-66!<79:!-??6!9:'9!'4-! 8)9!:'4=!());-=!<:-8!B4-B'478?!9:-A!5)4!9:-!>)38?.!9:-!-,=-4,>.!)4!B-)B,-!<:)!'4-! B4-?8'89!)4!<:)!:'@-!'!()AB4)A76-=!7AA38-!6>69-A%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!6)!

`/%!$)8(,367)8H!X'99:-<!j,'A!<'6!9:-!B-45-(9!B-46)8!9)!()@-4!9:-!/00Y!N%W%!K'97)8',! C'*,-!C-8876!$:'AB7)86:7B6!78!I'6!l-?'6%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!?7@-8!9:'9!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

`c%!$)8(,367)8H!C:-!6)4)4797-6!'9!$),?'9-!N87@-4679>!'4-!8)9!4-'=>!9)!'((-B9!'!,-6*7'8! ()3B,-%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!6--78?!'6!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

`1%!$)8(,367)8H!X4%!I3(-!:'6!94)3*,-!6,--B78?!'9!87?:9%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!*-('36-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

`g%!$)8(,367)8H!P9!76!'A'Z78?!9:'9!]))!b'=,->!,7;-6!-@-4>)8-!'8=!-@-4>9:78?%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!678(-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

c/%!$)8(,367)8H!C:-!O3-697)8!'*)39!<:>!Q-74=4-!n)78-=!9:-!<)A-8E6!947*-.!=-6B79-!,)678?! :-4!<75-E6!547-8=6:7B.!,)678?!:-4!4-,'97)86:7B6!<79:!:-4!(:7,=4-8!'8=!5--,78?!9:'9!6:-! :'6!=7A!B4)6B-(96!5)4!6)A-)8-!9)!6:'4-!:-4!=4-'A6!)5!,)@-.!=)-6!8)9!A';-!6-86-%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!*-('36-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

! "0`!

cY%!$)8(,367)8H!$,)6-=k(74(379!634@-7,,'8(-!('A-4'6!('88)9!*-!-55-(97@-!*)9:!78!=-9-4478?! (47A-!'8=!78!6B)9978?!(47A78',6%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!9:-4-5)4-!

cc%!$)8(,367)8H!9ZQ2'DZ\'B672';$'-'O6,5'46+,';<5'B5))1=>D'%62'%$=)5(#*&'6=)' 9-447*,-%!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!*-('36-!R36-=!9<7(-T!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

5$/(#)(,*5$%;4,12*?,#*OP`*

_'66'?-6!<79:!'4?3A-896H!Y.!`.!c.!i.!"0!

_'66'?-6!<79:)39!'4?3A-896H!".!/.!d.!1.!g!

5$/(#)(,*5$%;4,12*?,#*OPO[*

Y%!8)!'4?3A-89[!'=@7(-!

`%!'4?3A-89!

$)8(,367)8H!L)3!6:)3,=8E9!?-9!9))!('3?:9!3B!78!>)34!,)@-!,75-%!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

i%!'4?3A-89!

$)8(,367)8H!C:-!*-69!9>B-!)5!n-<-,4>!9)!<-'4!<79:!'!9349,-8-(;!76!'!*),=!(),)453,! B-8='89!)4!'!*38(:!)5!,)8?!(:'786%!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

""%!'4?3A-89!

$)8(,367)8H!X>!;7=!6:)3,=!8)9!*-!=-'=%!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!*-('36-!

! "0c!

"`%!'4?3A-89!

$)8(,367)8H!D:-8!9:-!I';-46!,)6-.!79!76!*-('36-!W:'O37,,-!2EK-',!=7=8E9!B,'>!:'4=! -8)3?:%!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!9:-4-5)4-!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

"c%!8)!'4?3A-89[!3863BB)49-=!69'9-A-89!

"1%!'4?3A-89!

$)8(,367)8H!&-8875-4!J8769)8E6!4-,'97)86:7B6!<79:!6-@-4',!A-8!)@-4!9:-!8-F9!-7?:9! A)89:6!<7,,!8)9!*-!6-47)36%!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!'6!

/0%!'4?3A-89!

$)8(,367)8H!C:-4-!<'6!8)!4-'6)8!5)4!X'47,>8!X)84)-!9)!:'@-!63==-8,>!()AA799-=! 637(7=-%!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!6)!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

//%!'4?3A-89!

$)8(,367)8H!X-A*-46!)5!9:-!(,-4?>!)5!',,!4-,7?7)86!'4-!387O3-,>!B)6797)8-=!9)!=)! 6)A-9:78?!'*)39!JPQW%!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

/`%!'4?3A-89!

$)8(,367)8H!U3>6!6:)3,=!<'9(:!)39!5)4!6)A-!?74,6%!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

/c%!8)!'4?3A-89[!:769)47(',!=-6(47B97)8!

! "0d!

/i%!'4?3A-89!

$)8(,367)8H!C:-!Q-@7,E6!_38(:*)<,!'8=!9:-!$'n)8!6'8=69)8-6!=7=!8)9!()A-!54)A!9:-! 6'A-!6)34(-%!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!*-('36-!

Y0%!'4?3A-89!

$)8(,367)8H!P9!<'6!-A*'44'6678?!9:'9!9:-!'8?-,6!78!9:-!A34',!78!9:-!I7*4'4>!C)<-4E6! ,)**>!<-4-!',,!<:79-%!

$)8(,367)8!7894)=3(-4H!8)8-!

_4-A76-!7894)=3(-4H!5)4!

5$/(#)(,*5$%;4,12*?,#*OPOO*

"%!_4-A76-H! I'8(-!J4A694)8?!:'6!A'69-4-=!9:-!'49!)5!-55-(97@-!,-'=-46:7B%!

`%!_4-A76-6H! b7(-!:'6!8-'4k-AB9>!(',)47-6%! C:-4-!76!=76'?4--A-89!78!A>!:)A-!)@-4!<:'9!()8697939-6!?))=!47(-%!

c%!_4-A76-H! aP9',7'8a!<'6!36-=!'6!'!?-8-47(!9-4A!5)4!',,!)5!9:-!='4;-4k6;788-=!B'66-8?-46!)8*)'4=! 9:-"C*%!)*-!R'BB'4-89,>!78(,3=78?!6)A-!<:)!<-4-!&'B'8-6-T%!

1%!_4-A76-6H! ]'6-*',,E6!A)69!:',,)<-=!4-()4=6!'4-!3B!5)4!?4'*6%! C-(:8),)?>!:'6!A'=-!79!'!(78(:!9)!(438(:!69'96%!

"0%!_4-A76-6H! b-6B-(9!5)4!9:-!43,-!)5!,'<!76!'!538='A-89',!9-8-9!)5!()86-4@'976A%! K)9:78?!78!9:-!$)86979397)8!'39:)47Z-6!9:-!5-=-4',!?)@-48A-89!9)!B'66!'!*'8!)8! B'497',k*749:!'*)497)8%!

5$/(#)(,*5$%;4,12*?,#*OPOU*

/%!R"T!C:-!)8-k*399)8!6379!:'6!,)8?!,'B-,6%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!P9!A';-6!6:)49!?3>6!,));!9',,-4!'8=!8-'4,>!-@-4>)8-!,));!9:788-4%!

! "01!

`%!R"T!C:-!,7)8-66!76!A)4-!6;7,53,!9:'8!9:-!,7)8!'9!B)38(78?!3B)8!9:-!;7,,%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!C:-!,7)8!(:'6-6!'!:-4=!)5!'89-,)B-!)4!'!678?,-!'87A',!9)<'4=6!9:-!,7)8-66.!<'7978?! 78!'A*36:%!

i%!R"T!L)34!=)(9)4!:'6!7867=-!785)4A'97)8%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!L)3!6:)3,=!8-@-4!'4?3-!<79:!>)34!=)(9)4%!

g%!R"T!C:-!$)86979397)8!A';-6!9:-!B4-67=-89!9:-!()AA'8=-4k78k(:7-5!78!'!97A-!)5!<'4%! R/T!C:-!()AA'8=-4k78k(:7-5!A369!:'@-!8-'4,>!38,7A79-=!B)<-46!9)!;--B!9:-!()3894>! 6'5-!'8=!9)!B4)6-(39-!:)697,797-6%!

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!Q3478?!'!97A-!)5!<'4.!9:-!B4-67=-89!:'6!8-'4,>!38,7A79-=!B)<-4%!

""%!R"T!J49:47976!:'6!'!:7?:!B4-@',-8(-!'8=!,'4?-!-()8)A7(!7AB'(9%! R/T!P9!('36-6!B'78!'8=!538(97)8',!,7A79'97)86%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!J49:47976!B)6-6!'!:3?-!6)(7-9',!*34=-8%!

"Y%!R"T!+'4),=!R+'BB>T!X-,9Z-4!<'6!'44-69-=!('44>78?!'!()8(-',-=!B769),%! R/T!+-!<'6!'8!-Fk()8@7(9%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!+-!()AA799-=!'!5-,)8>%!

"c%!R"T!P5!6-F3',!)47-89'97)8!76!6)A-9:78?!)@-4!<:7(:!'8!78=7@7=3',!:'6!@7493',,>!8)! ()894),.!9:-8!=76(47A78'97)8!'?'7869!?'>6!:),=6!B-)B,-!'(()389'*,-!<79:)39!4-?'4=! 5)4!'8>9:78?!9:->!9:-A6-,@-6!:'@-!=)8-%!

R/T!C)!:),=!'!B-46)8!'(()389'*,-!5)4!9:'9!)@-4!<:7(:!9:-!B-46)8!:'6!8)!()894),!76!'! (-894',!5)4A!)5!B4-n3=7(-!

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!P5!6-F3',!)47-89'97)8!76!6)A-9:78?!)@-4!<:7(:!'8!78=7@7=3',!:'6!@7493',,>!8)! ()894),.!9:-8!=76(47A78'97)8!'?'7869!?'>6!76!=-B,)4'*,-%!

5$/(#)(,*5$%;4,12*?,#*OPOV*

/%!K-69)4!$'697,,)!76!A-,'8(:),7(!'9!:-'49%!

Y%!D'7978?!9)!578=!)39!75!P!<'6!:-'=-=!5)4!9:-!n)789!5)4!9:-!4-69!)5!A>!,75-!A'=-!A-! 694)8?-4%!

c%!L)3!=)8E9!:'@-!'!=3,,.!(),)4,-66!:3-!9)!('A)35,'?-!>)34!*)=>%!

1%!C:-!?)@-48)4!*-99-4!<'9(:!)39!5)4!A>!A)9:-4%!

g%!U-8-4',!^76-8:)<-4!768E9!B'497(3,'4,>!<-,,!-O37BB-=!9)!*-!(:7-5!-F-(397@-!)5!9:76! ()3894>!!!B'497(3,'4,>!<:-4-!@)2*!)!'55'746!'4-!()8(-48-=%!

! "0i!

""%!P9!=)-68E9!6--A!9)!A'99-4!<:'9!P!=)%!

"/%!P5!U'>!:'=!8)9!*--8!'!A-(:'87(.!9:-8!9:-!)<8-4!)5!9:-!('4!:-!57F-=!<)3,=8E9!:'@-! 9';-8!:7A!9)!&7AA>!]43(7'E6!5)4!'!=478;%!

"`%!P5!<-!=)8E9!69)B!9:-!B)<<)<!8)<.!<-E4-!4-',,>!?)78?!9)!*-!78!94)3*,-%!

"d%!W94)8?!9-F96!=)!8)9!A-4-,>!4-5,-(9!<:'9!',4-'=>!-F7696%!

"i%!Q34:'A!J('=-A>!('88)9!4-,-'6-!J='A!W'B7;)<6;7E6!6(:)),!4-()4=6%!

/0%!^79:-4!K-69)4!$'697,,)!<7,,!6--!X'4r'!b7@-4'!'?'78.!)4!:-!:'6!9)!5)4?-9!:-4%!

5$/(#)(,*5$%;4,12*?,#*OPOY*

/%!R"T!J!K));!('8E9!4-'=%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!J!K));!('8E9!());%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!J!:));!());!*));!76!8)!?))=!9)!'!K));%!

Y%!R"T!C:-!-,;!<'68E9!()AB'97*,-!<79:!J='A%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!U)=!*'876:-=!79!54)A!9:-!U'4=-8!)5!^=-8!78!5'@)4!)5!^@-%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!C:-!-,;!?4-<!9)!:'9-!<)A-8%!

c%!R"T!X'8>!_'(757(!8'97)86!4-B)49!:7?:!,-@-,6!)5!WCQ6%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!X'8>!_'(757(!8'97)86!:'@-!:7?:!4'9-6!)5!38B4)9-(9-=!6-F%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!X'8>!_'(757(!8'97)86!:'@-!'!:7?:!476;6!5)4!+Pl!94'86A7667)8%!

1%!R"T!P89-46-F-=!*749:6!'4-!)59-8!()867=-4-=!94'3A'97(.!6('8=',)36.!'8=!6:'A-53,%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!G-<!B-)B,-!9',;!'*)39!63(:!*749:6!<:-8!9:->!:'BB-8%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!I'>!B-)B,-!=)!8)9!:-'4!'*)39!789-46-F3',79>!A3(:!78!9:-!N879-=!W9'9-6!9)='>%!

g%!R"T!$-49'78!G]P!'?-896!'4-!8)9!B'497(3,'4,>!?))=!4),-!A)=-,6%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!WO3'=!63B-4@76)46!=)8E9!6-,-(9!(-49'78!'?-896!9)!*-!94'7878?!'?-896%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!K)9!',,!G]P!'?-896!6-4@-!'6!94'7878?!'?-896%!

! "0g!

""%!R"T!PE@-!',4-'=>!?)9!A>!A'8%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!PEA!',4-'=>!6-9%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!P!=)8E9!8--=!9)!?-9!',,!('3?:9!3B!)8!9:-!8-9%!

"/%!R"T!P8!(3,934-6!9:'9!5'@)4!A',-!*'*7-6.!A)4-!A-8!<7,,!4-A'78!38A'447-=%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!$3,934-6!9:'9!5'@)4!A',-!*'*7-6!<7,,!:'@-!:7?:-4!476;6!)5!'897k6)(7',!'8=!@7),-89! *-:'@7)4%!

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!$3,934-6!9:'9!5'@)4!A',-!*'*7-6!()3,=!*-()A-!=-69'*7,7Z-=%!

"`%!R"T!G'44-,,!Q7,,)8.!()8@7(9-=!78!"ggg!)5!4'B78?!5)34!>)38?!?74,6.!:'=!'8!'99)48->!<:)! <'6!A-89',,>!7,,%!

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!+76!'99)48->!<'6!78()AB-9-89%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!+-!6:)3,=!*-!?4'89-=!'!8-<!947',%!

"c%!R"T!P4'O!76!8)<!'!=-A)(4'(>%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!W9-@-8!l78(-89E6!94'86,'9)4!6:)3,=!:'@-!8)!4-'6)8!9)!5,--!P4'O%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!W:-!=)-6!8)9!O3',75>!5)4!4-53?--!)4!'6>,3A!78!9:-!N%W%!

"i%!R"T!Q)<89)<8!I)6!J8?-,-6!8-@-4!O379-!O3',757-=!'6!a4-67=-897',%a! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!C:-4-!'4-!8)!,7A796!)8!()86943(97)8!8)76-!78!=)<89)<8!I)6!J8?-,-6%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!D:-8!>)3!'4-!78!>)34!=)<89)<8!I%J%!,)59!,'9-!'9!87?:9.!>)3!A'>!8)9!*-!'*,-!9)! :-'4!>)34!(-,,B:)8-!478?%!

/0%!R"T!W-4-8'!D7,,7'A6!76!'!<)A'8%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!W:-!('88)9!*-()A-!'!A-A*-4!)5!9:-!J66)(7'97)8!)5!C-8876!_4)5-667)8',6!RJC_T%! RYT!C)!*-!'*,-!9)!B,'>!78!'8!JC_!9)348'A-89.!>)3!:'@-!9)!*-!'8!JC_!A-A*-4%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R`T!W:-!('88)9!B,'>!78!'8!JC_!9)348'A-89%!R3869'9-=T!

! ""0!

5$/(#)(,*5$%;4,12*?,#*OPO\*

"%!R"T!P5!PEA!8)9!:)A-!6))8.!9:'9!A-'86!J?8-6!76!=-'=%! R/T!P5!J?8-6!76!=-'=.!Q)4)9:>!;7,,-=!:-4%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!P5!PEA!8)9!:)A-!6))8.!Q)4)9:>!;7,,-=!J?8-6%!R3869'9-=T! R`T!P5!Q)4)9:>!;7,,-=!J?8-6.!Q)4)9:>!76!'!A34=-4-4%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RcT!P5!PEA!8)9!:)A-!6))8.!Q)4)9:>!76!'!A34=-4-4%!R3869'9-=T!

Y%!R"T!N8,-66!9:76!8-(;97-!76!4)38=!A>!8-(;!<-!=)8E9!?)!)39!9)!=788-4!9)k87?:9%! R/T!P5!P!=)8E9!?)!)39!9)!=788-4!9)k87?:9.!P!8-@-4!?)!9)!9:-!)557(-!'?'78%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!N8,-66!9:76!8-(;97-!76!4)38=!A>!8-(;.!P!8-@-4!?)!9)!9:-!)557(-!'?'78%!R3869'9-=T! R`T!P5!P!=)8E9!?)!9)!9:-!)557(-!'?'78.!>)3!'8=!P!69'4@-.!'8=!)34!(:7,=4-8!<7,,!*-!5,38?!789)! 9:-!694--96%!

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RcT!N8,-66!9:76!8-(;97-!76!4)38=!A>!8-(;.!>)3!'8=!P!69'4@-.!'8=!)34!(:7,=4-8!<7,,!*-! 5,38?!789)!9:-!694--96%!R3869'9-=T!

`%!R"T!Q-@)8!]4)<8!<'6!?)78?!)8,>!'*)39!/!AB:!<:-8!:-!*'(;-=!'!('4!9)<'4=!2557(-4! U'4(7'%!

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!U'4(7'!<'6!'*,-!9)!69-B!)39!)5!9:-!<'>%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!U'4(7'!<'6!8)9!78!='8?-4%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R`T!U'4(7'!<'6!8)9!n369757-=!78!3678?!=-'=,>!5)4(-%!

d%!R"T!_)'(:78?.!94'=-!'8=!()863AB97)8!)5!?'A-!A-'9!76!7,,-?',!78!N?'8='%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R/T!X)69!)5!9:-6-!'(97@797-6!'4-!=)8-!'9!87?:9!78!6,3A6!)4!38,7(-86-=!B,'(-6%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!b-?769-4-=!@-9-478'47'86!=)!8)9!786B-(9!?'A-!A-'9%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! R`T!C:-!B3*,7(!6:)3,=!8)9!()863A-!'8>!?'A-!A-'9%!

g%!R"T!P5!U-8-4',!WA79:!,-96!F$0!42"C0*36)$!()44-6B)8=-89!X'4?3-479-!+7??786!?)!)8!9:-! A'4(:!<79:!9:-!X'478-6.!6:-!<7,,!B4)*'*,>!?-9!54)69*79-%!

R/T!P5!6:-!?-96!54)69*79-.!9:-8!6)A-*)=>!<7,,!:'@-!9)!9';-!('4-!)5!:-4%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RYT!P5!U-8-4',!WA79:!,-96!:-4!?)!)8!9:-!A'4(:.!9:-8!6)A-*)=>!<7,,!B4)*'*,>!:'@-!9)! 9';-!('4-!)5!:-4%!R3869'9-=T!

R`T!C:-!X'478-6!('8E9!6B'4-!'8>!A-8!9)!9';-!('4-!)5!:-4%! \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\! RcT!W:-!('8E9!?)!)8!9:-!A'4(:%!R3869'9-=T!

! """!

SAMPLE MULTIPLE CHOICE QUESTIONS FOR CHAPTER ONE

"%!_7(;!9:-!(:)7(-!9:'9!()44-(9,>!57,,6!78!9:-!*,'8;!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!6-89-8(-%!

P8!'8!'4?3A-89.!'!69'9-A-89!9:'9!76!789-8=-=!9)!*-!'!4-'6)8!9)!*-,7-@-!'8)9:-4!69'9-A-89! 76!(',,-=!'!\\\\\\\\\\\\%!

'%!B4-A76-! *%!()8(,367)8!

/%!P=-8975>!9:-!A3,97B,-!(:)7(-!9:'9!)"#$%&'(,2*/!.$,1)2,%!

'%!9:-4-5)4-! *%!:-8(-! (%!*-('36-! =%!()86-O3-89,>! -%!<-!A'>!()8(,3=-!9:'9!

Y%!P=-8975>!9:-!A3,97B,-!(:)7(-!9:'9!)"#$%&'(,2*/!(%"(4'2)%"%!

'%!678(-! *%!5)4! (%!'6!! =%!'6!63(:! -%!5)4!9:-!4-'6)8!9:'9!

`%!P6!9:-!5),,)<78?!6-89-8(-!943-!)4!5',6-M!

C:-!()8(,367)8!)5!'8!'4?3A-89!76!',<'>6!69'9-=!'59-4!9:-!B4-A76-6!:'@-!*--8!69'9-=%!

'%!L-6.!9:76!76!943-%! *%!K).!9:76!76!5',6-%!

c%!P=-8975>!9:-!B)6797)8!)5!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!78!9:-!5),,)<78?%!

\\\'\\\.!5)4!\\\*\\\%!

d%!P=-8975>!9:-!B)6797)8!)5!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!78!9:-!5),,)<78?%!

]-('36-!\\\'\\\.!\\\*\\\%!

1%!P=-8975>!9:-!B)6797)8!)5!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!78!9:-!5),,)<78?%!

\\\'\\\.!W).!\\\*\\\.!678(-!\\\(\\\!'8=!\\\=\\\%!

! ""/!

i%!P=-8975>!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!

WA',,!()38947-6!9-8=!9)!4-A-A*-4!:769)4>!-6B-(7',,>!<-,,.!*-('36-!79!)59-8!93486!)39! *'=,>!5)4!9:-A%!eX'4(!G',()55.!aW-AB-4!G7=-,.a!C,$"Q$+"O$/634*-!R&3,>!Y.!"gigT.!B%! Yg%f!

'%!WA',,!()38947-6!9-8=!9)!4-A-A*-4!:769)4>!-6B-(7',,>!<-,,%! *%!+769)4>!)59-8!93486!)39!*'=,>!5)4!6A',,!()38947-6%!

g%!P=-8975>!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!S%#,Q!@)"%,*#" !0G6($)%?"J%,$AJ"0$'$0#"%&"P7">0$+J#"-4$!)R-6%"-,*)&#7!

-/4M5+6*25';<57Q(5'=$;':($,5=k78.!9:->!579!-@-4>!)(('67)8!B-45-(9,>%!eP7">0$+.!$'9',)?.! RWB478?!/00cT.!B%!i%f!

'%!&%!$4-<E6!(,-'8k(39!(:78)6!'4-!8)9!*4);-8k78%! *%!&%!$4-<E6!(,-'8k(39!(:78)6!579!-@-4>!)(('67)8!B-45-(9,>%!

"0%!P=-8975>!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!

$KK!768E9!?)78?!9)!6:)<!9:-!4-69!)5!9:-!@7=-)!e)5!'!N%!W%!X'478-!6:))978?!'8! 'BB'4-89,>!38'4A-=.!<)38=-=!P4'O7!('B97@-!78!G',,3n':fH!79!76!5'4!9))!?4'B:7(%!e]'4*'4'! W9'44.!$KK.!K)@-A*-4!"d.!/00`%f!

'%!$KK!768E9!?)78?!9)!6:)<!9:-!4-69!)5!9:-!@7=-)!)5!'!N%!W%!X'478-!6:))978?!'8! 'BB'4-89,>!38'4A-=.!<)38=-=!P4'O7!('B97@-!78!G',,3n':%!

*%!C:-!4-69!)5!9:-!@7=-)!)5!'!N%!W%!X'478-!6:))978?!'8!'BB'4-89,>!38'4A-=.!<)38=-=! P4'O7!('B97@-!78!G',,3n':!76!@-4>!?4'B:7(%!

""%!P=-8975>!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!

J8>!=76(3667)8!)5!9:-!:'4A)87('.!)4!a:'4Ba.!78!*,3-6!A367(!:'6!9)!78(,3=-!I799,-! D',9-4%!+-!<'6!'!A'?7(7'8!<79:!9:-!786943A-89.!-AB,)>78?!'8!78(4-=7*,-!A-,)=7(! 4'8?-!'8=!'!<7=-!'66)49A-89!)5!9)8',!785,-(97)86!78!'!69>,-!<:7(:!:'6!*--8!-A3,'9-=! *>!@7493',,>!-@-4>!B,'>-4!9:'9!63((--=-=!:7A%!e])*!W(:87-=-46.!I78-4!K)9-6.!C,$"8$#%" &'"K*%%4$"E!4%$0%!RN87@-46',!$79>.!$',75)487'H!$:-66SX$J!b-()4=6.!"gci.!"gid[!$+Qk g"g/%f!

'%!J8>!=76(3667)8!)5!9:-!:'4A)87('.!)4!a:'4Ba.!78!*,3-6!A367(!:'6!9)!78(,3=-!I799,-! D',9-4%!

*%!I799,-!D',9-4!<'6!'!A'?7(7'8!<79:!9:-!:'4B.!-AB,)>78?!'8!78(4-=7*,-!A-,)=7(!4'8?-! '8=!'!<7=-!'66)49A-89!)5!9)8',!785,-(97)86!78!'!69>,-!<:7(:!:'6!*--8!-A3,'9-=!*>! @7493',,>!-@-4>!B,'>-4!9:'9!63((--=-=!:7A%!

! ""Y!

"/%!P=-8975>!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!!

P5!a-FB-496a!()3,=!',<'>6!*-!94369-=!9)!A';-!9:-!47?:9!A)4',!=-(767)8.!9:-8!B3*,7(! B'497(7B'97)8!<)3,=!8)9!*-!8-(-66'4>!!!*39!9:->!('88)9!*-.!'8=!6)!79!76%!ej-'>! Q'@7=6)8.!>!04"B!G!)=":"K*'$%!R&):8!D7,->!x!W)86.!"gggT.!B%!F@%f!

'%!P5!a-FB-496a!()3,=!',<'>6!*-!94369-=!9)!A';-!9:-!47?:9!A)4',!=-(767)8.!9:-8!B3*,7(! B'497(7B'97)8!<)3,=!8)9!*-!8-(-66'4>%!

*%!a^FB-496a!('88)9!',<'>6!*-!94369-=!9)!A';-!9:-!47?:9!A)4',!=-(767)8%! (%!_3*,7(!B'497(7B'97)8!78!=-(767)8kA';78?!76!8-(-66'4>%!

"Y%!P=-8975>!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!!

J8!)@-4,>!9'887(!<78-!:'6!'!A)39:kB3(;-478?.!=4>78?!-55-(9!'8=!('8!9'69-!6,7?:9,>! *799-4!R9:78;!)@-4*4-<-=!9-'T%!C:-6-!<78-6!4-O374-!A)4-!'?78?.!'6!9'88786!6)59-8!)@-4! 97A-%!eaD78-.a!9Z!RW-B9-A*-4!/00cT.!B%!/00%f!

'%!J8!)@-4,>!9'887(!<78-!:'6!'!A)39:kB3(;-478?.!=4>78?!-55-(9!'8=!('8!9'69-!6,7?:9,>! *799-4!R9:78;!)@-4*4-<-=!9-'T%!

*%!2@-4,>!9'887(!<78-6!4-O374-!A)4-!'?78?%! (%!C'88786!6)59-8!)@-4!97A-%!

"`%!P=-8975>!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!

-/@M'+<15#'1='6';(6)1;1$=6&'35?1,'2$+15;7'-'12';<5'#$*=;61='$#',=$%&5)>5'$#'>$$)'6=)'

5N1&-.!

C:-!A)69!4-8)<8-=!)5!9:-!94'=797)8',!W-B7;!$:7-56!'B'49!54)A!W74!X7(:'-,!W)A'4-! <'6!9:-!,'9-!W74!_79'!W7A)?38%!J6!8)8-!)5!:76!6)86!<-4-!('B'*,-!)5!-'4878?!:76! 4-6B-(9.!:-!8-@-4!B'66-=!)8!9:-!;8)<,-=?-!9)!'8>!)5!9:-A%!e_-9-4!Q)87?7.!a]7?!X'8.! $:7-56!'8=!W-'6)8',!D)4;-46.a!C,$"Q!%*&)!4!R_'B3'!K-<!U378-'T.!K)@-A*-4!"c.! /00c%f!!

'%!J!(:7-5!78!'!94'=797)8',!W-B7;!6)(7-9>!76!9:-!5)389'78!)5!;8)<,-=?-!)5!?))=!'8=!-@7,%! *%!C:-!A)69!4-8)<8-=!)5!9:-!94'=797)8',!W-B7;!$:7-56!'B'49!54)A!W74!X7(:'-,!W)A'4-! <'6!9:-!,'9-!W74!_79'!W7A)?38%!

(%!K)8-!)5!W74!_79'!W7A)?38E6!6)86!<-4-!('B'*,-!)5!-'4878?!:76!4-6B-(9%! =%!W74!_79'!W7A)?38!8-@-4!B'66-=!)8!9:-!;8)<,-=?-!)5!?))=!'8=!-@7,!9)!:76!6)86%!

! ""`!

"c%!P=-8975>!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!!

-/LM=62F*+<'62'V&$(1)6'3;6;5Q2'*25'$#';<5'35F1=$&5'=6F5'6=)'622$+16;5)'1F6>5(7'<62'

4-(-7@-=!9:-!'BB4)@',!)5!9:-!W-A78),-!C47*-!)5!G,)47='.!9:-!387@-4679>!<7,,!8)9!*-! 63*n-(9!9)!9:-!9-4A6!)5!9:-!eK'97)8',!$),,-?7'9-!J9:,-97(!J66)(7'97)8!RK$JJTf!B),7(>! e5)4*7==78?!387@-46797-6!9:'9!36-!a:)697,-!)4!'*367@-a!JA-47('8!P8=7'8!87(;8'A-6.! 6>A*),6!)4!7A'?-4>!54)A!:)6978?!K$JJ!B)696-'6)8!-@-896!)4!=76B,'>78?!87(;8'A-6! '8=!7A'?-4>!78!K$JJ!B)696-'6)8!-@-896f%!e]-48'4=!G4'8;,78.!K$JJ!6-87)4!@7(-! B4-67=-89!5)4!?)@-48'8(-!'8=!A-A*-46:7B.!O3)9-=!78!W9-@-!^,,76.!aK$JJH!W-A78),-! K'A-!$'8!]-!N6-=.a!C!44!,!##$$"M$(&-0!%.!J3?369!/`.!/00c%f!

'%!G,)47='!W9'9-E6!36-!)5!9:-!W-A78),-!8'A-!'8=!'66)(7'9-=!7A'?-4>!:'6!4-(-7@-=!9:-! 'BB4)@',!)5!9:-!W-A78),-!C47*-!)5!G,)47='%!

*%!G,)47='!W9'9-!<7,,!8)9!*-!63*n-(9!9)!9:-!9-4A6!)5!9:-!K$JJ!B),7(>!5)4*7==78?! 387@-46797-6!9:'9!36-!a:)697,-!)4!'*367@-a!JA-47('8!P8=7'8!87(;8'A-6.!6>A*),6!)4! 7A'?-4>!54)A!:)6978?!K$JJ!B)696-'6)8!-@-896!)4!=76B,'>78?!87(;8'A-6!'8=! 7A'?-4>!78!K$JJ!B)696-'6)8!-@-896%!

"d%!P=-8975>!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!

_,-'6-!4-A-A*-4!9:'9!<-!=)!8)9!'(97@-,>!A)879)4!9:-!B)69-=!A-66'?-6.!'8=!'6!63(:.! '4-!8)9!4-6B)867*,-!5)4!9:-!()89-89!()89'78-=!<79:78%!eaN6-4!J?4--A-89.a!@)#*2$" <!-,%*)G.! :99BHSS<<<%7867=->'(:978?%()AS78=-F%B:BM)B97)8{()A\()89-89x9'6;{@7-<x7={dxP9 -A7={YY.!'((-66-=!W-B9-A*-4!/.!/00d%f!

'%!D-!=)!8)9!'(97@-,>!A)879)4!9:-!B)69-=!A-66'?-6%! *%!D-!'4-!8)9!4-6B)867*,-!5)4!9:-!()89-89!()89'78-=!<79:78!B)69-=!A-66'?-6%!

"1%!6+%2,*/$0'1,"#!76!B4-6-89-=!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-M!

C:-4-!'4-!9:4--!,)<k?4'=-!4-?769-4-=!6-F!)55-8=-46!'9!$WNK.!6'7=!I9%!W()99!l'8W()>! )5!('AB36!B),7(-%!

C:-!693=-896!'4-!()867=-4-=!'!aA)=-4'9-!476;a!*-('36-!9:->!=7=!8)9!()AA79!:7?:k476;! (47A-6.!63(:!'6!4'B-.!l'8W()>!6'7=%!eJA'8='!_)49-4.!aK)!b76;!_)6-=!*>!b-?769-4-=! W-F!255-8=-46!)8!$'AB36.!_),7(-!W'>.a!M!*4A"B6)2*!4!R$',75)487'!W9'9-!N87@-4679>.! K)49:47=?-T.!W-B9-A*-4!/.!/00`%f!

'%!C:-!'4?3A-89!76!I9%!W()99!l'8W()>E6%! *%!C:-!'4?3A-89!76!JA'8='!_)49-4E6%!

! ""c!

"i%!6+%2,*/$0'1,"#!76!B4-6-89-=!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-M!

C:-!g9:!$74(379!e$)349!)5!JBB-',6f!43,-=!78!/00/!9:'9!9:-!<)4=6.!a28-!8'97)8.!38=-4! U)=a!78!9:-!_,-=?-!)5!J,,-?7'8(-!76!'8!-8=)46-A-89!*>!9:-!5-=-4',!?)@-48A-89!)5! 4-,7?7)8!'8=!6)!@7),'9-6!9:-!-69'*,76:A-89!(,'36-!)5!9:-!G7469!JA-8=A-89!)5!9:-!]7,,!)5! b7?:96!)5!9:-!N%W%!$)86979397)8.!<:7(:!B4-@-896!)34!?)@-48A-89!54)A!-69'*,76:78?!)4! -8=)4678?!'!4-,7?7)8%!eQ'87-,!D34'8?7'8.!aJ4-!D-!b-',,>!_,-=?78?!J,,-?7'8(-!9)!9:-! G,'?M.a!M!*4A"B6)2*!4"R$',75)487'!W9'9-!N87@-4679>.!K)49:47=?-T.!W-B9-A*-4!/1.!/00c%f!

'%!C:-!'4?3A-89!76!9:-!g9:!$74(379!$)349!)5!JBB-',6E%! *%!C:-!'4?3A-89!76!Q'87-,!D34'8?7'8E6%!

"g%!6+%2,*/$0'1,"#!76!B4-6-89-=!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-M!S%#,Q!C,$"0$4$5!)%" !0G6($)%"*)"%,*#"/!##!G$"*#"3&42'!-$2"!)2"6)2$04*)$27!

eP8!"g/g.!&3=?-!$:'4,-6!D%!G47(;-f!B4-67=-=!)@-4!9:-!?4-'9!JA-47('8!6-F!947',!)5!9:-! -4'H!C:-'9-4!A'?8'9-!eJ,-F'8=-4f!_'89'?-6!<'6!'((36-=!)5!4'B78?!'!"1k>-'4k),=! ='8(-4%!_'89'?-6E!'99)48->.!&-44>!U7-6,-4.!947-=!9)!'4?3-!9:'9!9:-!@7(97A!<'6!8)9!9:-! 788)(-89!6:-!B4-9-8=-=!9)!*-%!<$)(9,*$,B'2,&*#%*/44%@*)#Z*$'4)"0*#+/#*#+,*3)(#)1E2*

(+/$/(#,$*&)&"E#*1/##,$Z*;,(/'2,*5/"#/0,2*(%'4&*;,*0')4#:*%B*2#/#'#%$:*$/.,*

;/2,&*2%4,4:*%"*+,$*/0,G!_'89'?-6!<'6!()8@7(9-=!'8=!6-89-8(-=!9)!c0!>-'46!78!B476)8%! e$-(7,7'!b'6A366-8.!aK)9)47)36!$'6-6!5)4!'!EK)kK)86-86-E!&3=?-.a!K&#":)G$4$#" C*($#.!J3?369!/0.!/00d%f!

'%!C:-!'4?3A-89!76!&3=?-!$:'4,-6!D%!G47(;-E6%! *%!C:-!'4?3A-89!76!J,-F'8=-4!_'89'?-6E%! (%!C:-!'4?3A-89!76!&-44>!U-76,-4E6%! =%!C:-!'4?3A-89!76!$-(7,7'!b'6A366-8E6%!

/0%!P=-8975>!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!

P!B-46)8',,>!:'@-!8-@-4!47==-8!)8!9:-!b-=!I78-!*-('36-!796!`%`!A7,-6!=)8E9!?)! '8><:-4-!P!<'89!9)!*-%!eJ,!X'4978-Z.!>*%A"&'":)G4$#=":"M0*5$R8A"H&0%0!*%"&'"K&#" :)G$4$#%!RK-<!L)4;H!W9%!X'4978E6!_4-66.!"ggdT.!B%!"0/%f!

'%!P!:'@-!8-@-4!47==-8!)8!9:-!b-=!I78-%! *%!C:-!b-=!I78-!=)-68E9!?)!'8><:-4-!P!<'89!9)!*-%!

! ""d!

/"%!P=-8975>!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!

-I1=d*5'!!Q)8',=!Q-G4--Z-!!!<'6!9:-!578',!WIJ!eW>A*7)8-6-!I7*-4'97)8!J4A>f! A-A*-4!9)!=7-%!J8=!<:-8!P!5)38=!<:'9!A7?:9!:'@-!*--8!?38B)<=-4!*3486!)8!:76! 5)4-:-'=.!P!57469!9:)3?:9!9:'9!:-.!,7;-!+79,-4.!:'=!;7,,-=!:7A6-,5!<:-8!9:-!-8=!<'6!8-'4%! ]39!9-696!78!)34!,'*)4'9)4>!4-@-',-=!9:'9!9:-4-!<-4-!A-9',,7(!-,-A-896!78!9:-!5'9',! <)38=!<:7(:!<-4-!8)9!B4-6-89!78!9:-!%Yi!*3,,-96!78!Q-G4--Z-E6!)<8!B769),%!P!*-,7-@-=.! 9:-4-5)4-.!9:'9!9:-!?38B)<=-4!*3486!('A-!54)A!-FB,)=78?!'AA38797)8!8-'4!Q-G4--Z-%! eC:)A'6!C%!K)?3(:7!<79:!&)6-B:!Q7X)8'.!>&0&)$0%!RK-<!L)4;H!_)(;-9!]));6.! "giYT.!B%!"gc%f!

'%!C:-4-!<-4-!A-9',,7(!-,-A-896!78!9:-!5'9',!<)38=!)8!Q)8',=!Q-G4--Z-E6!5)4-:-'=! <:7(:!<-4-!8)9!B4-6-89!78!9:-!%Yi!*3,,-96!78!Q-G4--Z-E6!)<8!B769),%!

*%!P!*-,7-@-=!9:'9!9:-!?38B)<=-4!*3486!)8!Q)8',=!Q-G4--Z-E6!5)4-:-'=!('A-!54)A! -FB,)=78?!'AA38797)8!8-'4!Q-G4--Z-%!

(%!C:-!?38B)<=-4!*3486!)8!Q)8',=!Q-G4--Z-E6!5)4-:-'=!('A-!54)A!-FB,)=78?! 'AA38797)8!8-'4!Q-G4--Z-%!

//%!P=-8975>!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!

C:-!2';,'8=!C47*38-!6'7=!eU)@-48)4!U4'>f!Q'@76!6:)3,=!*-!',,)<-=!9)!4-A'78! ?)@-48)4!*-('36-!:-!a:'6!8-79:-4!*4);-8!9:-!,'<!8)4!=)8-!'8>9:78?!7AA)4',!78!)557(-! 9:'9!()3,=!B'66!5)4!A',5-'6'8(-%a!eX79(:-,,!I'8=6*-4?.!X'9-'!U),=!'8=!Q'4>,!j-,,->.! ab-(',,!b'(-!G)(36-6!)8!Q'@76!'8=!W(:<'4Z-8-??-4.a!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!W-B9-A*-4! /g.!/00Y%f!

'%!C:-!2';,'8=!C47*38-!6'7=!U)@-48)4!U4'>!Q'@76!6:)3,=!*-!',,)<-=!9)!4-A'78! ?)@-48)4%!

*%!U)@-48)4!U4'>!Q'@76!6:)3,=!*-!',,)<-=!9)!4-A'78!?)@-48)4%! (%!U)@-48)4!U4'>!Q'@76!:'6!8-79:-4!*4);-8!9:-!,'<!8)4!=)8-!'8>9:78?!7AA)4',!78! )557(-!9:'9!()3,=!B'66!5)4!A',5-'6'8(-%!

=%!C:-!2';,'8=!C47*38-!6'7=!U)@-48)4!U4'>!Q'@76!:'6!8-79:-4!*4);-8!9:-!,'<!8)4! =)8-!'8>9:78?!7AA)4',!78!)557(-!9:'9!()3,=!B'66!5)4!A',5-'6'8(-%!

! ""1!

/Y%!P=-8975>!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!

2*-679>!76!8)9!78(,3=-=!78!9:-!QWXkPlkCb!e9:-!JA-47('8!_6>(:7'947(!J66)(7'97)8E6! M*!G)&#%*-"!)2"B%!%*#%*-!4"I!)6!4f.!*39!6)A-!-FB-496!()89-8=!9:'9!9:-!()8=797)8! 78@),@-6!B4)A78-89!B6>(:),)?7(',!'8=!*-:'@)47',!5-'934-6.!'8=!6:)3,=!*-!(,'66757-=!'6! '8!-'978?!=76)4=-4%!e&'A-6!+'86-,,!'8=!I76'!Q'A)34.!:3)&0(!4"H#A-,&4&GA%! R+)*);-8.!K&H!&):8!D7,->!'8=!W)86.!/00cT.!B%!/Yg%f!

'%!2*-679>!76!8)9!78(,3=-=!78!9:-!QWXkPlkCb%! *%!W)A-!-FB-496!()89-8=!9:'9!)*-679>!78@),@-6!B4)A78-89!B6>(:),)?7(',!'8=! *-:'@)47',!5-'934-6%!

(%!2*-679>!78@),@-6!B4)A78-89!B6>(:),)?7(',!'8=!*-:'@)47',!5-'934-6%! =%!2*-679>!6:)3,=!*-!(,'66757-=!'6!'8!-'978?!=76)4=-4%! -%!W)A-!-FB-496!()89-8=!9:'9!)*-679>!6:)3,=!*-!(,'66757-=!'6!'8!-'978?!=76)4=-4%!

/`%!P=-8975>!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!

X>!547-8=6!78!I)6!J8?-,-6!<)3,=8E9!=4-'A!)5!;879978?!<79:!<)),.!*-('36-!9:-4-!'4-!6)! 5-<!97A-6!)5!>-'4!<:-8!79!('8!*-!<)48!()A5)49'*,>%!e&-8875-4!W9'55)4=.!M&(*D)*%0*T=" E,*/"<&60"N)*%%*)G"*)%&"B,!/$%!R$78(788'97H!K)49:!I7?:9!]));6.!/001T.!B%!Y1%f!

'%!X>!547-8=6!78!I)6!J8?-,-6!<)3,=8E9!=4-'A!)5!;879978?!<79:!<)),%! *%!C:-4-!'4-!@-4>!5-<!97A-6!)5!>-'4!<:-8!<)),!('8!*-!<)48!()A5)49'*,>!78!I)6! J8?-,-6%!

/c%!P=-8975>!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!

P8!P,,78)76!'6!78!A)69!n3476=7(97)86.!=-(7=78?!9:-!A'88-4!78!<:7(:!6)A-)8-!76!9)!*-! *347-=!76!'!69'939)4>!47?:9!)5!9:-!8-F9k)5k;78!!!'8=!6)!?'>!,)@-46!'4-!54-O3-89,>!*'44-=! *>!9:-!=-(-'6-=E6!;78!54)A!-@-8!'99-8=78?!9:-!,)@-4E6!538-4',%!eb7(:'4=!Q%!X):4.!:" I&0$"H$0'$-%"U)*&)="E,A"B%0!*G,%":($0*-!"I6#%"B%!)2"U/"'&0"9!A"O*G,%#%!R])69)8H! ]-'()8!_4-66.!"gg`T.!BB%!``k`c%f!

'%!P8!P,,78)76!'6!78!A)69!n3476=7(97)86.!=-(7=78?!9:-!A'88-4!78!<:7(:!6)A-)8-!76!9)!*-! *347-=!76!'!69'939)4>!47?:9!)5!9:-!8-F9k)5k;78%!

*%!P8!P,,78)76.!?'>!,)@-46!'4-!54-O3-89,>!*'44-=!*>!9:-!=-(-'6-=E6!;78!54)A!-@-8! '99-8=78?!9:-!,)@-4E6!538-4',%!

! ""i!

/d%!P=-8975>!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!

C';-!^47(!$'4,6)8.!9:-!)<8-4!)5!^%!$%!$)86943(97)8.!'!4-A)=-,78?!()AB'8>!78!Q-6! X)78-6%!+-E6!*37,=78?!:76!)<8!8-<!:)A-!)8!878-!'(4-6!n369!8)49:!)5!D789-46-9!'8=! <'896!79!9)!*-!'6!-8@74)8A-89',,>!547-8=,>!"!'8=!9:-4-5)4-!'6!-8-4?>k-557(7-89!"!'6! B)667*,-%!eb-7=!G)4?4'@-.!a]'A*))!]))A.a!M$#"I&*)$#"O$G*#%$0!RP)<'T.!Q-(-A*-4! Y.!/00c%f!

'%!^47(!$'4,6)8!76!9:-!)<8-4!)5!^%!$%!$)86943(97)8.!'!4-A)=-,78?!()AB'8>!78!Q-6! X)78-6%!

*%!^47(!$'4,6)8!76!*37,=78?!:76!)<8!8-<!:)A-!)8!878-!'(4-6!n369!8)49:!)5!D789-46-9%! (%!^47(!$'4,6)8!<'896!:76!8-<!:)A-!9)!*-!'6!-8@74)8A-89',,>!547-8=,>!'6!B)667*,-%! =%!^47(!$'4,6)8!<'896!:76!8-<!:)A-!9)!*-!'6!-8-4?>k-557(7-89!'6!B)667*,-%!

/1%!P=-8975>!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!

-/_7?2152'1=';<5'g=1;5)'3;6;52M'6(5'&56(=1=>';<6;'1#'%5'6(5=Q;'>$1=>';$':5'%6=)5(1=>'

6)!A3(:!9:-8!<-!:'@-!9)!B'>!4-89%!W)!<:>!8)9!)<8!>)34!)<8!:)A-M!P9E6!(:-'B-4%a! e])*!X)89-6.!O3)9-=!78!P4'!]-4;)<.!I!T+$44"B%0$$%="B605*5!4"*)"!"8!\!!0%!RU'4=-8! $79>.!KLH!Q)3*,-='>!x!$)AB'8>.!"g11T.!B%!`ii%f!

'%!D-!'4-!,-'4878?!9:'9!75!<-!'4-8E9!?)78?!9)!*-!<'8=-478?!6)!A3(:!9:-8!<-!:'@-!9)! B'>!4-89%!

*%!D-!6:)3,=!)<8!)34!)<8!:)A-6%! (%!P9E6!(:-'B-4!9)!)<8!)34!)<8!:)A-6!9:'8!79!76!9)!4-89%!

/i%!P=-8975>!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!

j74;!C',,->!76!'!,)8-,>!A'8%!C:36!79!:'6!',<'>6!*--8%!+-!<'6!*)48!,)8-,>.!'8=!9:-! B'6678?!>-'46!:'@-!=)8-!,799,-!9)!'*'9-!9:-!5--,78?%!j74;!C',,->!76!',6)!'!A'8!)5!U)=%! +76!4-,'97)86:7B!<79:!&-636!76!9:-!B47A'4>!4-,'97)86:7B!78!:76!,75-%!C:76!:'6!*4)3?:9!'! A-'634-!)5!()A5)49.!5)4!75!:-!('88)9!*-!:'BB>!78!9:76!,75-.!9:-4-!76!'9!,-'69!9:-!B4)A76-! )5!'8)9:-4%!C',,->!)59-8!43A78'9-6!'*)39!9:-!?),=-8!4)'=!'8=!9:-!67,@-4!(>A*',6!'8=! 9:-!?4-'9!?,799-478?!9:4)8-%!+-!6A7,-6!<:-8!:-!7A'?78-6!9:-!4'B934)36!n)>!9:'9!'<'796! :7A!<:-8!:-!=7-6%!C:'9.!:-!9:78;6.!<7,,!*-!'!:'BB>!='>%!eJ,,76)8!U,)(;.!a239!)5!9:-! I)4=E6!$,)6-9.a!9Z!RJ3?369!/00cT.!B%!"YY%f!

'%!j74;!C',,->!76!'!,)8-,>!A'8%! *%!j74;!C',,->!:'6!',<'>6!*--8!'!,)8-,>!A'8%! (%!j74;!C',,->E6!4-,'97)86:7B!<79:!&-636!76!9:-!B47A'4>!4-,'97)86:7B!78!:76!,75-%! =%!j74;!C',,->E6!4-,'97)86:7B!<79:!&-636!:'6!*4)3?:9!:7A!'!A-'634-!)5!()A5)49%! -%!P5!j74;!C',,->!('88)9!*-!:'BB>!78!9:76!,75-.!9:-4-!76!'9!,-'69!9:-!B4)A76-!)5!'8)9:-4! ,75-%!

! ""g!

/g%!P=-8975>!9:-!(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!

O<5'#1(2;'$#'-'/4(6^1&Q2'=*+&56('?$%5('?&6=96f!76!4-'=>!9)!-89-4!6-4@7(-!'8=!?-8-4'9-! -,-(947(79>!5)4!<:7(:.!9:-!9-(:8)(4'96!'=A79.!9:-4-!76!8)!=-A'8=.!678(-!]4'Z7,!',4-'=>! :'6!-,-(947(79>!78!-F(-66%!e&)q)!W%!C4-@76'8.!H$05$0%#"*)"H!0!2*#$.!94'86,'9-=!*>!X'4978! G)4-A'8%!RI)8=)8H!UX_!_3*,76:-46.!"gidT.!B%!"/%f!

'%!C:-!57469!)5!]4'Z7,E6!83(,-'4!B)<-4!B,'896!76!4-'=>!9)!-89-4!6-4@7(-!'8=!?-8-4'9-! -,-(947(79>%!

*%!C:-4-!76!8)!=-A'8=!5)4!9:-!57469!)5!]4'Z7,E6!83(,-'4!B)<-4!B,'896%! (%!]4'Z7,!',4-'=>!:'6!-,-(947(79>!78!-F(-66%!

Y0%!28,>!)8-!)5!9:-!5),,)<78?!A3,97B,-!(:)7(-6!78!9:76!O3-697)8!76!943-%!_7(;!9:-!)8-!9:'9!76! 943-%!

'%!C:-!<)4=!E*-('36-E!',<'>6!7894)=3(-6!'!B4-A76-%! *%!D:-8!9:-!<)4=!E*-('36-E!76!36-=!9)!7894)=3(-!B'49!)5!'8!'4?3A-89.!79!',<'>6! 7894)=3(-6!'!B4-A76-.!*39!6)A-97A-!9:-!<)4=!E*-('36-E!=)-6!8)9!7894)=3(-!'8>!B'49! )5!'8!'4?3A-89%!

(%!W)A-97A-6!9:-!<)4=!E*-('36-E!7894)=3(-6!'!B4-A76-!'8=!6)A-97A-6!9:-!<)4=! E*-('36-E!7894)=3(-6!'!()8(,367)8%!

Y"%!P6!9:-!5),,)<78?!6-89-8(-!943-!)4!5',6-M!

J,,!'99-AB96!9)!B-463'=-!'4-!'4?3A-896%!

'%!L-6.!9:76!76!943-%! *%!K).!9:76!76!5',6-%!

Y/%!P6!79!B)667*,-!5)4!9:-!()8(,367)8!)5!'8!'4?3A-89!9)!*-!'*)39!'!63*n-(97@-!7663-M!

'%!L-6.!9:76!76!B)667*,-%! *%!K).!9:76!76!7AB)667*,-%!

YY%!Q)-6!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-!()89'78!'8!/$0'1,"#*%$*"%#M!

W)A-)8-!<:)!:'6!69>,-!:'6!79!',,!9:-!97A-%!eb',B:!I'34-8.!O3)9-=!78!U,-88!2E]47-8.! a+76!D'>.a!9Z!RX'4(:!/001T.!B%!Y"i%f!

'%!L-6.!9:76!B'66'?-!()89'786!'8!'4?3A-89%! *%!K).!9:76!B'66'?-!=)-6!8)9!()89'78!'8!'4?3A-89%!

! "/0!

Y`%!Q)-6!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-!()89'78!'8!/$0'1,"#*%$*"%#M!

C:-!57469!*'?!ej'9478f!I-7*-4!A'=-!<'6!'!;8799-=!4-=!(,39(:!'9!9:-!'?-!)5!"/!!!5)4!:-4! A)AE6!*749:='>%!W:-!9:-8!<-89!)8!9)!?4'=3'9-!54)A!=-67?8!6(:)),!78!_'476!'9!9:-!9)B! )5!:-4!(,'66!'8=!,'38(:-=!:-4!)<8!,78-!57@-!6-'6)86!'?)[!79!n369!4-'(:-=!)34!6:)4-6!9:76! >-'4%!C:-!?-8736!)5!9:-!Yck>-'4k),=E6!@-?-9'*,-k=>-=!,'A*6;78!B7-(-6!R',,!)5!<:7(:! '4-!B4)=3(-=!78!G4'8(-T!76!9:'9!9:->E4-!B'B-4!9:78!*39!'A'Z78?,>!694)8?!!!6)!9:->!<-'4! 78!*-'39753,,>%!eaC:-!]-69!K-<!Q-67?8-46.a!K6-DA"RW-B9-A*-4!/00dT.!B%!"cd%f!

'%!L-6.!9:76!B'66'?-!()89'786!'8!'4?3A-89%! *%!K).!9:76!B'66'?-!=)-6!8)9!()89'78!'8!'4?3A-89%!

Yc%!Q)-6!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-!()89'78!'8!/$0'1,"#*%$*"%#M!

W7?8!78!'!=4-66!6:)BH!]3>!8)<!!!)34!6;7496!'4-!?)78?!3B%!e+-88>!L)38?A'8.!C,$" ;)-A-4&/$2*!"&'"S)$"K*)$0#.!-=%!^=!W:'8'B:>%!Rj'9)8':.!K%L%H!]',,>A)9-!]));6.! "gigT.!B%!`Y%f!

'%!L-6.!9:76!B'66'?-!()89'786!'8!'4?3A-89%! *%!K).!9:76!B'66'?-!=)-6!8)9!()89'78!'8!'4?3A-89%!

Yd%!Q)-6!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-!()89'78!'8!/$0'1,"#*%$*"%#M!

X>!7=-'!)5!'!6-@-8k()346-!=788-4!76!'!:)9!=)?!'8=!'!67FkB'(;%!e+-88>!L)38?A'8.!C,$" ;)-A-4&/$2*!"&'"S)$"K*)$0#.!-=%!^=!W:'8'B:>%!Rj'9)8':.!K%L%H!]',,>A)9-!]));6.! "gigT.!B%!""Y%f!

'%!L-6.!9:76!B'66'?-!()89'786!'8!'4?3A-89%! *%!K).!9:76!B'66'?-!=)-6!8)9!()89'78!'8!'4?3A-89%!

Y1%!Q)-6!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-!()89'78!'8!/$0'1,"#*%$*"%#M!

J!<)A'8!()8@7(9-=!)5!=43?!(:'4?-6!78!_4)<-46!$)389>!6:)3,=!?-9!'!8-<!947',! *-('36-!9:-!n3=?-!<)3,=8E9!=76A766!'!B4)6B-(97@-!n34)4!<:)6-!5'A7,>!:'=!*--8! 5-3=78?!<79:!9:-!=-5-8='89E6!5'A7,>!5)4!6)A-!Y0!>-'46.!9:-!$),)4'=)!$)349!)5!JBB-',6! 43,-=!9)='>%!eJ66)(7'9-=!_4-66.!aQ43?!$)8@7(97)8!2@-49348-=!]-('36-!)5!G'A7,>! G-3=!<79:!&34)4.a!M$)5$0"H&#%.!X'>!/d.!/00c%f!

'%!L-6.!9:76!B'66'?-!()89'786!'8!'4?3A-89%! *%!K).!9:76!B'66'?-!=)-6!8)9!()89'78!'8!'4?3A-89%!

! "/"!

Yi%!Q)-6!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-!()89'78!'8!/$0'1,"#*%$*"%#M!

-/[(.'V6<)M'@&kX-:-88'!e5)4A-4!=-'8!)5!9:-!5'(3,9>!)5!A-=7(78-!'9!j78?!G':=! N87@-4679>!78!j:)*'4.!W'3=7!J4'*7'f!B)789-=!)39!9:'9!*-('36-!A-=7(78-!76!9'3?:9!78! ^8?,76:!78!A)69!A-=7(',!6(:)),6!78!9:-!J4'*!<)4,=.!79!:'6!4-63,9-=!78!'!=766)(7'97@-! 4-,'97)86:7B!*-9<--8!9:-!6-4@7(-!B4)@7=-4.!9:-!=)(9)4.!'8=!9:-!()863A-4.!9:-!B'97-89%! W-@-4',!B'497(7B'896!e78!'!6-A78'4!)5!=-'86!)5!A-=7(',!6(:)),6!78!9:-!J4'*!<)4,=f! '?4--=!9:'9!J4'*!=)(9)46!578=!79!=7557(3,9!9)!()AA387('9-!9:-74!;8)<,-=?-!9)!9:-74! B'97-896!67AB,>!*-('36-!9:->!,'(;!9:-!8-(-66'4>!-FB4-667)86!'8=!9-4A78),)?7-6!78! J4'*7(!9)!=)!6)%!eK'=7'!^,kJ<'=>.!aJ4'*7Z-=!X-=7(78-!X)@-6!28-!W9-B!G)4<'4=.a! @#4!(S)4*)$7)$%.!JB47,!"g.!/00c%f!

'%!L-6.!9:76!B'66'?-!()89'786!'8!'4?3A-89%! *%!K).!9:76!B'66'?-!=)-6!8)9!()89'78!'8!'4?3A-89%!

Yg%!Q)-6!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-!()89'78!'8!/$0'1,"#*%$*"%#M!

P!=7=!47=-!9:-!],3-!I78-!)8(-.!*39!@)<-=!8-@-4!9)!=)!6)!'?'78!<:-8!6-(3479>!)557(-46! '44-69-=!'!A'8!5)4!-'978?!'!()3?:!=4)B!'9!)8-!)5!9:-!69'97)86.!<:-4-!9:-4-E6!'!8)k-'978?! 43,-%!C:-!A'8!786769-=!:-!<'6!63(;78?!9:-!()3?:!=4)B.!8)9!-'978?!79.!*39!8)!)8-!('4-=%! P9!<'6!78!:76!A)39:.!'8=!9:'9E6!-'978?%!+-!()3,=!:'@-!*--8!578-=!z1c0.!*39!9:-!n3=?-! =76A766-=!9:-!('6-!<79:!'!<'4878?!9)!'8>)8-!<:)!A7?:9!()A-!*-5)4-!:-4!'?'78!<79:! 9:-!()3?:!=4)B!=-5-86-%!K-F9!97A-.!6:-!<)3,=!8)9!*-!6)!A-4(753,%!eJ,!X'4978-Z.!>*%A" &'":)G4$#=":"M0*5$R8A"H&0%0!*%"&'"K&#":)G$4$#%!RK-<!L)4;H!W9%!X'4978E6!_4-66.!"ggdT.! B%!"0/%f!

'%!L-6.!9:76!B'66'?-!()89'786!'8!'4?3A-89%! *%!K).!9:76!B'66'?-!=)-6!8)9!()89'78!'8!'4?3A-89%!

`0%!Q)-6!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-!()89'78!'8!/$0'1,"#*%$*"%#M!

P5!>)3!B-8!'8!P8=7'8!3B!)8!'!6A',,!6B)9!)5!-'49:!'8=!()AB-,!:7A!9)!69'>!9:-4-.!:-!<7,,! 8)9!*-!()89-89-=!8)4!<7,,!:-!?4)<!'8=!B4)6B-4%!e$:7-5!&)6-B:.!&'83'4>!"`.!"i1g.! O3)9-=!78!C%!$%!X(I3:'8.!C&6-,"%,$";!0%,=":"B$4'RH&0%0!*%"&'"@)2*!)";T*#%$)-$%!RK-<! L)4;H!239-4*47=?-!'8=!Q7-86954->.!"g1"T.!B%!"/Y%f!

'%!L-6.!9:76!B'66'?-!()89'786!'8!'4?3A-89%! *%!K).!9:76!B'66'?-!=)-6!8)9!()89'78!'8!'4?3A-89%!

! "//!

`"%!Q)-6!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-!()89'78!'8!/$0'1,"#*%$*"%#M!

L-6.!>)3!('8!'BB-'4!4-69-=!-@-8!75!>)3!6;7AB!)8!6,--B%!K-<!5,'9k-=?-=!->-!B-8(7,6! B4)A76-!->-k)B-878?!4-63,96%!aL)3!?-9!J8?-,78'!&),7-E6!67?8'934-!('9E6k->-!5)4!'!A)4-! >)39:53,.!<7=-k->-=!,));.a!6'>6!X',,>!b)8(',.!(4-'9)4!)5!X',,>!]-'39>!'8=!'!A';-3B! '49769!<:)!:'6!<)4;-=!<79:!&),7-%!_4))5!79!<)4;6H!D79:!'!8-<!*'*>.!&),7-!697,,!,));6! ,7;-!6:-E6!?-9978?!`0!<78;6V!ea"c!X7839-6!9)!L)34!]-69!W-,5.a!B$4'!RW-B9-A*-4!/00dT.! B%!Yd%f!

'%!L-6.!9:76!B'66'?-!()89'786!'8!'4?3A-89%! *%!K).!9:76!B'66'?-!=)-6!8)9!()89'78!'8!'4?3A-89%!

`/%!Q)-6!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-!()89'78!'8!/$0'1,"#*%$*"%#M!

W-B9%!//.!"g/"H!X46%!$,'4'!]%!]4-88-4!9),=!I)6!J8?-,-6!$)389>!W3B-47)4!$)349!&3=?-! &%!D%!W3AA-457-,=!9:'9!6:-!<'89-=!9)!=7@)4(-!&):8!G%!]4-88-4!)8!9:-!?4)38=6!)5! (43-,9>%!

aX>!:36*'8=!<-89!"i!>-'46!<79:)39!6A7,78?.a!6:-!9),=!9:-!()349.!'(()4=78?!9)!C:-! C7A-6%!a+-!(4'**-=!',,!9:-!97A-!'8=!-@-8!<:-8!:-!=4'8;!,7O3)4!:-!'BB-'4-=!9)!?-9! ?4)3(:7-4!9:'8!-@-4%a!

X46%!]4-88-4E6!69)4>!4'8!78!C:-!C7A-6!38=-4!9:-!:-'=,78-.!a]))Z-!G'7,6!'6!WA7,-! $)'F-4%a!

a+-!<)3,=8E9!-@-8!6A7,-!<:-8!P!?'@-!:7A!'!6:)9!)5!4-',!W()9(:.a!6:-!()AB,'78-=!)5! :-4!:36*'8=%!

W3AA-457-,=!?4'89-=!9:-!=7@)4(-%! ea$'36-!5)4!Q7@)4(-H!+-!K-@-4!WA7,-=.a!C7A-6!_'69.!K&#":)G$4$#"C*($#.!W-B9-A*-4! //.!/00d%f!

'%!L-6.!9:76!B'66'?-!()89'786!'8!'4?3A-89%! *%!K).!9:76!B'66'?-!=)-6!8)9!()89'78!'8!'4?3A-89%!

`Y%!P=-8975>!9:-!.$,1)2,!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!

P8!9:-!()854)89'97)8!*-9<--8!4)(;!'8=!694-'A.!9:-!694-'A!<7,,!',<'>6!<78!!!8)9! *-('36-!79!76!694)8?-4!*39!*-('36-!79!',<'>6!:796!9:-!4)(;!78!9:-!6'A-!B,'(-%!e$34976! D-*,->.!'39:)4!)5!9:-!8)@-,!B605*5*)G"*)":($0*-!.!O3)9-=!78!I78=6'>!X788-A'.! a+'4=!D)4;!^66-897',.!J39:)4!W'>6.a"M!*4A"Q&0%,+$#%$0)!RK)49:<-69-48!N87@-4679>.! ^@'869)8.!P,,78)76T.!JB47,!"i.!/00c%f!

'%!C:-!694-'A!76!694)8?-4!9:'8!9:-!4)(;%! *%!C:-!694-'A!',<'>6!:796!9:-!4)(;!78!9:-!6'A-!B,'(-%!

! "/Y!

``%!P=-8975>!9:-!.$,1)2,!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!

e26'A'f!]78!I'=-8!a'8=!9:)36'8=6!)5!)9:-4!8)8k@#><6='b*2&1F2'%5=;'-'/;$' J5?:'8769'8f!9)!57?:9!9:-!b-=!J4A>!8)9!*-('36-!9:-!W)@7-96!<-4-!'9:-7696!'8=! ()AA387696!!!8)9!*-('36-!)5!<:'9!9:->!<-4-!)4!9:)3?:9!!!*39!4'9:-4!*-('36-!9:->! <-4-!'9:-7696!'8=!()AA387696!<:)!:'=!78@'=-=!'8=!)((3B7-=!'!X36,7A!,'8=.!:'=! '4*794'47,>!;7,,-=!A)4-!9:'8!'!A7,,7)8!X36,7A!A-8.!<)A-8!'8=!(:7,=4-8.!:'=!=47@-8! 9:4--kB,36!A7,,7)8!A)4-!789)!-F7,-.!'8=!(,-'4,>!6)3?:9!9)!-4'=7('9-!P6,'A!54)A!9:-! ()3894>%a!eX7(:'-,!G%!W(:-3-4.!@(/$0*!4"F630*#="E,A"%,$"E$#%"@#"K&#*)G"%,$"E!0"&)" C$00&0.!B%!"0.!O3)9-=!78!D',9-4!$%!N:,-4.!aW978;>!P8;>.!_'49!lH!Q78-6:!QEW)3Z'!'8=! 9:-!WA'99-4-46!'9!9:-!_:7,'=-,B:7'!P8O374-4.a!:%4!)%*-"L0$$"H0$##!RK-9:-4,'8=6T.! &'83'4>!//.!/001%f!

'%!C:-!W)@7-96!78!J5?:'8769'8!<-4-!'9:-7696!'8=!()AA387696%! *%!C:-!W)@7-96!78!J5?:'8769'8!<-4-!'9:-7696!'8=!()AA387696!<:)!:'=!78@'=-=!'8=! )((3B7-=!'!X36,7A!,'8=.!:'=!'4*794'47,>!;7,,-=!A)4-!9:'8!'!A7,,7)8!X36,7A!A-8.! <)A-8!'8=!(:7,=4-8.!:'=!=47@-8!9:4--kB,36!A7,,7)8!A)4-!789)!-F7,-.!'8=!(,-'4,>! 6)3?:9!9)!-4'=7('9-!P6,'A!54)A!9:-!()3894>%!

`c%!P=-8975>!9:-!1/)"*(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!

-/EM$&1;1+6&';5(($(12;2':5&15N5';<6;';<5'F$2;'5##5+;1N5'%67';$'6($*25'?*:&1+'27F?6;<7'

5)4!9:-74!('36-!76!=-'9:%!C:-4-5)4-!9:->!'4-!8)9!'54'7=!)5!=>78?.!'8=!9:'9E6!<:>! ()8@-897)8',!B),7(-!9'(97(6!5'7,!<:-8!36-=!'?'7869!9:-A%!eC:)A'6!C%!K)?3(:7!<79:! &)6-B:!Q7X)8'.!>&0&)$0%!RK-<!L)4;H!_)(;-9!]));6.!"giYT.!B%!"gd%f!

'%!_),797(',!9-44)47696!*-,7-@-!9:'9!9:-!A)69!-55-(97@-!<'>!9)!'4)36-!B3*,7(!6>AB'9:>!5)4! 9:-74!('36-!76!=-'9:%!

*%!_),797(',!9-44)47696!'4-!8)9!'54'7=!)5!=>78?%! (%!$)8@-897)8',!B),7(-!9'(97(6!5'7,!<:-8!36-=!'?'7869!B),797(',!9-44)47696%!

! "/`!

`d%!P=-8975>!9:-!1/)"*(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!@)"%,*#" /!##!G$"%,$"#/$!D$0"*#"!"'*-%*&)!4"-,!0!-%$0"-!44$2"%,$"C*)"E&&2(!)?"+,&"*#"!3&6%"

%,$"0$V6$#%"%,!%"%,$"E*\!02"&'"S\"G*5$",*("!",$!0%7"@)"%,$"(&5*$"(!2$"'0&(K7L0!)D"

8!6(J#"3&&D?"%,$"C*)"E&&2(!)"*#"`6#%"-!44$2"%,$"C*)(!)7"H0$5*&6#4A?"M&0&%,A",!2"

!#D$2"%,$"E*\!02?"+,&"!//$!0$2"%&",$0"!#"!)"$)&0(&6#"F$!2?"%&"#$)2",$0"3!-D"%&"

N!)#!#?"!)2"%,$"B-!0$-0&+",!2"!#D$2"%,$"E*\!02?"+,&"!//$!0$2"!#"!"4&5$4A"K!2A"%&"

,*(?"%&"G*5$",*("30!*)#7"L&-6#"&)"%,$"!0G6($)%"%,!%"*#"3&42'!-$2"!)2"6)2$04*)$27!

-/O<5'O1='B$$)F6=M')1)'=$;',=$%'%<5;<5('<5'%$*&)'#1=)'U^'6'&$N5&7'06)7'$('6'

+-'=.!*39!:-!:)B-=!79!<)3,=!*-!9:-!,)@-,>!I'=>%!aG)4.a!:-!6'7=!9)!:7A6-,5.!a)B*)#*)2*#+,*

A,/&Z*!*/1*2'$,*!*2+/44*"%#*;,*0)3,"*/*+,/$#Z*2)"(,*/*+,/&*+/2*"%*+,/$#*%B*)#2*%@"*

/"&*#+,$,B%$,*(/""%#*B,,4*B%$*1,Ga!eI%!G4'8;!]'3A.!C,$"E*\!02"&'"S\%!R"g00[! 4-B4789-=H!K-<!L)4;H!U4)66--9!'8=!Q38,'B.!"gdYT.!B%!g0%f!S%#,Q!

'%!P5!9:-!D7Z'4=!)5!2Z!76!9:-!+-'=.!P!6:',,!8)9!*-!?7@-8!'!:-'49%! *%!J!:-'=!:'6!8)!:-'49!)5!796!)<8%! (%!J!:-'=!('88)9!5--,!5)4!A-%!

`1%!P=-8975>!9:-!1/)"*(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!

J8!7=-8979>!(47676!('8!)((34!'4)38=!?-8=-4!7=-8979>.!-F(-B9!<-!363',,>!=)8E9!8)97(-!79! *-('36-!<-E4-!6)!()8@78(-=!9:'9!?-8=-4!76!7AA39'*,-!'8=!9:-4-*>!7AA38-!9)!(47676%! ej'9-!])4869-78.!9$)2$0"S6%4!+="S)"I$)?"E&($)?"!)2"%,$"O$#%"&'"U#%!Rb)39,-=?-H! K-<!L)4;.!"gg`T.!B%!""i%f!

'%!D-!363',,>!=)8E9!8)97(-!'!?-8=-4!7=-8979>!(47676%! *%!D-E4-!@-4>!694)8?,>!()8@78(-=!9:'9!?-8=-4!76!7AA39'*,-%! (%!D-E4-!@-4>!694)8?,>!()8@78(-=!9:'9!?-8=-4!76!7AA38-!9)!(47676%!

! "/c!

`i%!P=-8975>!9:-*1/)"*(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!S%#,Q!C,*#"*#" !)"$T-$0/%"'0&("!"-&)5&-!%*&)"#/$$-,"G*5$)"!%"B!0!,"K!+0$)-$">&44$G$"*)"[dmi7"

B!0!,"K!+0$)-$"*#"!"+&($)J#"-&44$G$7!

L)34!n)*.!<:-8!>)3!,-'@-!:-4-!!!'6!79!<'6!9:-!n)*!)5!-=3('9-=!<)A-8!*-5)4-!>)3!!!76! 9)!(:'8?-!9:-!<)4,=%!K)9:78?!,-66!)4!-'67-4!9:'8!9:'9%!P!:)B-!>)3!:'@-!*--8!4-'=78?! 9:-!4-(-89!<)A-8E6!,7*-4'97)8!,79-4'934-.!-@-8!75!>)3!=)8E9!'?4--!<79:!6)A-!)5!79%!G)4! >)3!<7,,!578=.!'6!<)A-8!:'@-!5)38=!9:4)3?:!9:-!'?-6.!9:'9!(:'8?78?!9:-!<)4,=! 4-O374-6!'!,)9!)5!54--!97A-%!b-O374-6!'!,)9!)5!A)*7,79>%!b-O374-6!A)8->.!'8=.!'6! l74?787'!D)),5!B39!79!6)!<-,,.!a'!4))A!)5!)8-E6!)<8.a!B4-5-4'*,>!)8-!<79:!'!;->!'8=!'! 4&-D%!D:7(:!A-'86!9:'9!<)A-8!A369!*-!B4-B'4-=!9)!9:78;!5)4!9:-A6-,@-6.!<:7(:! A-'86.!38=)3*9-=,>.!94)3*,-!<79:!*)>547-8=6.!,)@-46.!'8=!:36*'8=6.!<:7(:!A-'86!',,! ;78=6!)5!:-'49'(:-!'8=!A76-4>.!'8=!97A-6!<:-8!>)3!<7,,!<)8=-4!75!78=-B-8=-8(-.! 54--=)A!)5!9:)3?:9.!)4!>)34!)<8!<)4;!76!<)49:!79!'9!',,%!eJ,7(-!D',;-4.!aJ!C',;H! $)8@)('97)8!"g1/.a!78!@)"B$!0-,"&'"S60"I&%,$0#J"9!02$)#="E&(!)*#%"H0&#$%!RW'8! Q7-?)H!+'4()349!]4'(-!x!$)AB'8>.!"giYT.!B%!Y1%f!

'%!L)34!n)*!<:-8!>)3!,-'@-!W'4':!I'<4-8(-!76!9)!(:'8?-!9:-!<)4,=%! *%!$:'8?78?!9:-!<)4,=!4-O374-6!'!,)9!)5!54--!97A-.!'!,)9!)5!A)*7,79>.!A)8->.!'8=.!'6! l74?787'!D)),5!B39!79!6)!<-,,.!a'!4))A!)5!)8-E6!)<8.a!B4-5-4'*,>!)8-!<79:!'!;->! '8=!'!4&-D%!

(%!D)A-8!A369!*-!B4-B'4-=!9)!9:78;!5)4!9:-A6-,@-6%! =%!L)3!<7,,!:'@-!94)3*,-!<79:!*)>547-8=6.!,)@-46.!'8=!:36*'8=6%! -%!L)3!<7,,!:'@-!',,!;78=6!)5!:-'49'(:-!'8=!A76-4>.!'8=!97A-6!<:-8!>)3!<7,,!<)8=-4! 75!78=-B-8=-8(-.!54--=)A!)5!9:)3?:9.!)4!>)34!)<8!<)4;!76!<)49:!79!'9!',,%!

`g%!P=-8975>!9:-!1/)"*(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B'66'?-%!

-46(:6(6'b6&1=$%2,1'$#'36='V(6=+12+$'$##5(2'F$(5'#$&,&$(5'6:$*;';<5'$(1>1=2'$#'

+'8?9)<8!54>.!9:'9!387O3-,>!$',75)487'8!=76:!)5!-??6!'8=!)>69-46%!

aC:-!69)4>!PE=!',<'>6!:-'4=!'6!9)!796!)47?78!76!79!<'6!9:-!A)69!4-O3-69-=!,'69!A-',!5)4! B476)8-46!6(:-=3,-=!9)!*-!:'8?-=!78!W'8!G4'8(76().a!X',78)<6;7!-kA'7,-=%!aC:-! 4-'6)8!*-78?!79!9));!6)!,)8?!9)!A';-!9:-!947B!9)!)*9'78!9:-!)>69-46!'9!C)A',-6!]'>! R678(-!79!<'6!,)8?!*-5)4-!'8>!*47=?-6!<-4-!(4)6678?!W'8!G4'8(76()!]'>T!9:'9!79!<)3,=! =-,'>!9:-!-F-(397)8!'8=!?'@-!:)B-!9)!9:-!()8=-A8-=!A'8!9:'9!:76!(4)87-6!A7?:9! 6)A-:)<!578=!'!<'>!9)!54--!:7A%a!ej7A!])'9A'8.!aQ-,-(9'*,-!$)48!G4799-46!54)A!9:-! &),,>!U4--8!U7'89.a!B!)"P&#$"I$0-60A"Q$+#.!G-*43'4>!"c.!/00c%f!

'%!C:-!)47?78!)5!+'8?9)<8!54>!76!9:'9!79!<'6!9:-!A)69!4-O3-69-=!,'69!A-',!5)4!B476)8-46! 6(:-=3,-=!9)!*-!:'8?-=!78!W'8!G4'8(76()%!

*%!P9!9));!6)!,)8?!9)!A';-!9:-!947B!9)!)*9'78!9:-!)>69-46!5)4!+'8?9)<8!G4>!'9!C)A',-6! ]'>!9:'9!4-O3-6978?!79!'6!'!,'69!A-',!<)3,=!=-,'>!9:-!-F-(397)86!)5!B476)8-46! 6(:-=3,-=!9)!*-!:'8?-=!78!W'8!G4'8(76()%!

(%!K)!*47=?-6!(4)66-=!9:-!<'9-4!*-9<--8!W'8!G4'8(76()!'8=!C)A',-6!]'>%! =%!b-O3-6978?!+'8?9)<8!G4>!'6!'!,'69!A-',!?'@-!:)B-!9)!'!B476)8-4!()8=-A8-=!9)!*-! :'8?-=!78!W'8!G4'8(76()!9:'9!:76!(4)87-6!A7?:9!6)A-:)<!578=!'!<'>!9)!54--!:7A%!

! "/d!

c0%!P=-8975>!9:-*1/)"*(%"(4'2)%"!)5!9:-!'4?3A-89!78!9:-!5),,)<78?!B)-A%!

J@-!X'47'!

X)9:-46!)5!JA-47('!

,-9!>)34!;7=6!?)!9)!9:-!A)@7-6V! ?-9!9:-A!)39!)5!9:-!:)36-!6)!9:->!<)8E9!;8)<!<:'9!>)3E4-!3B!9)! 79E6!943-!9:'9!54-6:!'74!76!?))=!5)4!9:-!*)=>!

*39!<:'9!'*)39!9:-!6)3,! 9:'9!?4)<6!78!='4;8-66.!-A*)66-=!*>!67,@-4>!7A'?-6! '8=!<:-8!>)3!?4)<!),=!'6!?4)<!),=!>)3!A369!

9:->!<)8E9!:'9-!>)3! ;<57'%$=Q;'+(1;1+1^5'7$*';<57'%$=K;',=$%!

9:->E,,!*-!78!6)A-!?,'A)4)36! ()3894>!

9:->!57469!6'<!)8!'!W'934='>!'59-48))8!)4!B,'>78?!:));->! 9:->!A'>!-@-8!*-!?4'9-53,!9)!>)3!

5)4!9:-74!57469!6-F3',!-FB-47-8(-! <:7(:!)8,>!()69!>)3!'!O3'49-4!

'8=!=7=8E9!3B6-9!9:-!B-'(-53,!:)A-! 9:->!<7,,!;8)<!<:-4-!('8=>!*'46!()A-!54)A!

'8=!?4'9379)36!*'?6!)5!B)B()48! '6!?4'9379)36!'6!,-'@78?!9:-!A)@7-!*-5)4-!79E6!)@-4! <79:!'!B,-'6'89!694'8?-4!<:)6-!'B'49A-89!76!78!9:-!+-'@-8!)8!^'49:!],=?! 8-'4!9:-!D7,,7'A6*34?!]47=?-!

):!A)9:-46!>)3!<7,,!:'@-!9:-!,799,-!9>;-6! 6)!:'BB>!*-('36-!75!8)*)=>!=)-6!B7(;!9:-A!3B!78!9:-!A)@7-6! 9:->!<)8E9!;8)<!9:-!=755-4-8(-!

'8=!75!6)A-*)=>!=)-6!79E,,!*-!6:--4!?4'@>! '8=!9:->E,,!:'@-!*--8!943,>!-89-49'78-=!-79:-4!<'>! 7869-'=!)5!:'8?78?!'4)38=!9:-!>'4=!

)4!3B!78!9:-74!4))A! :'978?!>)3!

B4-A'934-,>!678(-!>)3!<)8E9!:'@-!=)8-!'8>9:78?!:)447*,>!A-'8!>-9! -F(-B9!;--B78?!9:-A!54)A!9:-!='4;-4!n)>6!

79E6!385)4?7@'*,-!9:-!,'99-4! 6)!=)8E9!*,'A-!A-!75!>)3!<)8E9!9';-!9:76!'=@7(-!

'8=!9:-!5'A7,>!*4-';6!3B! '8=!>)34!(:7,=4-8!?4)<!),=!'8=!*,78=!78!54)89!)5!'!Cl!6-9!

6--78?! A)@7-6!>)3!<)3,=8E9!,-9!9:-A!6--!<:-8!9:->!<-4-!>)38?! eG4'8;!2E+'4'.!aJ@-!X'47'.a!78!&%!Q%!X($,'9(:>.!-=%.!C,$"Y*)%!G$"8&&D"&'" >&)%$(/&0!0A":($0*-!)"H&$%0A%!RK-<!L)4;H!l789'?-!]));6.!"gg0T.!BB%!//Yk//`%f!

! "/1!

'%!JA-47('8!A)9:-46!6:)3,=!,-9!9:-74!;7=6!?)!9)!9:-!A)@7-6%! *%!P5!JA-47('8!A)9:-46!,-9!9:-74!;7=6!?)!9)!9:-!A)@7-6.!9:-8!9:-!;7=6!<)8E9!;8)<!<:'9! 9:-74!A)9:-46!'4-!3B!9)%!

(%!C:-!6)3,!?4)<6!78!='4;8-66.!-A*)66-=!*>!67,@-4>!7A'?-6%! =%!P5!JA-47('8!A)9:-46!,-9!9:-74!;7=6!?)!9)!9:-!A)@7-6.!9:->!<7,,!:'@-!A'=-!9:-74!;7=6! 6)!:'BB>%!

-%!P5!JA-47('8!A)9:-46!=)8E9!,-9!9:-74!;7=6!?)!9)!9:-!A)@7-6.!9:-8!5'A7,7-6!<7,,!*4-';! 3B!'8=!9:-!;7=6!<7,,!?4)<!),=!'8=!*,78=!78!54)89!)5!'!Cl!6-9!6--78?!A)@7-6!9:-74! A)9:-46!<)3,=8E9!,-9!9:-A!6--!<:-8!9:->!<-4-!>)38?%!

! "/i!

ANSWERS TO SAMPLE MULTIPLE CHOICE QUESTIONS

FOR CHAPTER ONE

"%!'!! ! ! ! /"%!(! ! ! ! `"%!'!

/%!(! ! ! ! //%!*! ! ! ! `/%!'!

Y%!=! ! ! ! /Y%!=! ! ! ! `Y%!*!

`%!*! ! ! ! /`%!'! ! ! ! ``%!*!

c%!'! ! ! ! /c%!*! ! ! ! `c%!(!

d%!*! ! ! ! /d%!=! ! ! ! `d%!'!

1%!*! ! ! ! /1%!*! ! ! ! `1%!'!

i%!'! ! ! ! /i%!=! ! ! ! `i%!-!

g%!*! ! ! ! /g%!*! ! ! ! `g%!'!

"0%!'! ! ! ! Y0%!*! ! ! ! c0%!'!

""%!'! ! ! ! Y"%!*!

"/%!(! ! ! ! Y/%!'!

"Y%!*! ! ! ! YY%!*!

"`%!=! ! ! ! Y`%!'!

"c%!*! ! ! ! Yc%!'!

"d%!*! ! ! ! Yd%!*!

"1%!'! ! ! ! Y1%!'!

"i%!'! ! ! ! Yi%!'!

"g%!'! ! ! ! Yg%!'!

/0%!'! ! ! ! `0%!*!

!