week

profilearnita


  • 2 years ago
  • 125
files (6)

reviewer-form.pdf

Fidei et Veritatis Reviewers Form

Part 1. Likert Scale Review

Excellent (4) Good (3) Fair (2) Poor (1) N/A

Subject The topic is appropriate for the journal. The topic is relevant to the scholarly milieu of the

day.

The topic is novel and unique. Needs a minimum of 10 points

Content

The author exhibits an in-depth understanding of the

topic.

The author exhibits a broad understanding of the

topic.

The author demonstrates that the topic is well

researched, cited and footnoted (according to its

respective format – APA, Turabian, AMA, MLA)

The article contributes something new to its

respective field of interest.

Needs a minimum of 13 points

Research There is adequate evidence supporting the premises.

Multiple, reliable sources were used to support

premises.

It is evident that the author is aware and understands

the literature on this topic.

Needs a minimum of 9 points

Reflections on the Research (Optional) – Depends on whether or not student wanted to include personal reflections The author explains how the conflict that arises from

this issue poses significant problems for Christianity.

The author reflects on how the topic or research has

challenged his/her faith.

The author explains how his/her research contributes

to Christian faith and thought.

The author describes the relevance of this research to

the Christianity today.

Needs a minimum of 14 points

Part 2. Narrative Review Please provide a narrative in regard to each of these topics to support your ratings above.

I. Content

II. Subject

III. Research

IV. Reflections on the Research

Part 3. Reviewer Recommendation (You will indicate your recommendation here and online via the “Submit Review” Link.)

Please indicate one of the recommendations below when submitting your report.

a. Accept with no revisions

b. Accept with minor revisions

c. Accept with major revisions

d. Not accepted