tasha

profileJordanjameire

Please see attachment

  • a day ago
  • 10
files (1)

Week14-PrimarySourceWorksheet.docx

Name: ______________________ Date: __________ Period: ______

Primary Source Analysis

Race, Memory, and the American Union

Source A: Barack Obama, “A More Perfect Union” (speech, March 18, 2008)

Source B: U.S. Senate Resolution Apologizing for the Enslavement and Racial Segregation of African Americans (passed June 18, 2009)

Directions: Read both primary sources carefully. Answer all questions in complete sentences, using specific evidence (quotes or paraphrased details) from the text to support your answers. This assignment is worth 40 points total.

Part I — Analyzing Source A: “A More Perfect Union” (8 points)

1. According to Obama, why does the U.S. Constitution remain “unfinished” even after it was signed in 1787? What compromise does he point to? [2 pts]

2. Obama describes his own family background in detail early in the speech. Why do you think he includes this personal story before addressing the controversy over Reverend Wright? [2 pts]

3. Obama argues that both black anger and white resentment are “real” and have understandable roots. Summarize one cause he gives for each. [2 pts]

4. What does the story of Ashley Baia and the elderly black man illustrate about Obama's larger argument? Why does he end the speech with it? [2 pts]

Part II — Analyzing Source B: the Senate Resolution (8 points)

5. List three specific harms or injustices the resolution names as part of the legacy of slavery and Jim Crow (see clauses 4–9). [2 pts]

6. What does the resolution's “Disclaimer” section state, and why do you think Congress included it? [2 pts]

7. According to clause 16, what does Congress hope a formal apology will accomplish? [2 pts]

8. The resolution cites earlier statements by Presidents George W. Bush and Bill Clinton (clauses 14–15). Why might the Senate have included these examples before issuing its own apology? [2 pts]

Part III — Comparing the Two Sources (12 points)

9. Both sources address the legacy of slavery and racial division, but they were created for different purposes and audiences. Compare the purpose of Source A with the purpose of Source B. [3 pts]

10. Source A is a campaign speech delivered by an individual candidate; Source B is an official government resolution passed by a legislative body. How does this difference in origin affect the tone and language of each document? Give one example from each. [3 pts]

11. Both texts use the metaphor of an unfinished or imperfect “union.” Find a specific line from each source that reflects this idea and explain what each author/body believes is needed to “perfect” the union. [3 pts]

12. Identify one idea, fact, or perspective present in Source A that is NOT addressed in Source B, or vice versa. Why might that difference exist? [3 pts]

Part IV — Reflection (12 points)

Response (12 pts): Obama's speech was delivered in 2008 and the Senate resolution was passed in 2009 — roughly 150 years after the Emancipation Proclamation. In a well-developed paragraph (6–8 sentences), explain what these two sources together reveal about how Americans were grappling with the legacy of slavery and race in the early twenty-first century. Use at least one piece of specific evidence from EACH source to support your response.

Total: _____ / 40 points

Page of