tasha summary 2
Please see attachment
7 days ago
10
Essay-Number2-1-1.pdf
Essay-Number2-1-1.pdf
African American History — Comparative Essay Assignment
Voices of the Movement: A Comparative Essay African American History — Primary Source Comparative Analysis
Assignment Overview Between 1941 and 1968, African American leaders and their allies pursued the goal of racial justice through strikingly different means: executive action, nonviolent moral appeal, personal testimony, and calls for Black self-determination and structural power. In this essay, you will select two primary sources from the list below and write a comparative analysis of how each document defines the problem of racial injustice, the strategy it proposes for addressing that problem, and the vision of American society it puts forward.
This assignment asks you to do more than summarize each document. Your task is to place the two sources in conversation with one another: where do they agree, where do they diverge, and what does that agreement or divergence reveal about the broader civil rights movement as a contested, evolving political and moral project.
Primary Source Options (choose two) • A. Philip Randolph–Franklin Roosevelt correspondence (1941)
• Executive Order 9981 (Harry Truman, 1948)
• Paul Robeson’s Appearance Before the House Un-American Committee (1956)
• Brown v. Board of Education (1954)
• Roy Wilkins, “The Clock Will Not Be Turned Back” (1957/58, on Little Rock)
• Fannie Lou Hamer, Testimony at the Democratic National Convention (1964)
• Martin Luther King Jr., “I Have a Dream” (1963)
• Stokely Carmichael, “Black Power” (1966)
You may pair any two sources, including two that seem to agree, or two that seem to be in direct tension. Strong essays often come from unexpected pairings, so choose sources that genuinely interest you rather than the two that seem easiest to compare.
Prompt In a 2-page essay, compare your two chosen sources by addressing the following:
1. Context and Purpose: Briefly establish who produced each source, for what audience, and in what circumstances. Why does this context matter for how we should read the document?
2. Diagnosis: How does each source characterize the nature of racial injustice in America? Is it framed as a legal failure, a moral failure, a structural or economic condition, a psychological one, or something else?
Page 1
African American History — Comparative Essay Assignment
3. Strategy and Vision: What does each source propose as the path forward, and what vision of American society (integration, reform, self-determination, structural transformation) underlies that strategy?
4. Comparison: Building on the above, develop an original argument about how these two sources relate to each other. You might argue they represent two stages of a single struggle, two incompatible philosophies, two audiences being addressed differently, or something else entirely. The argument is yours to make and defend.
Your essay must be organized around your own thesis, not simply move point-by-point through the prompt questions above. The questions are there to help you generate ideas, not to structure your paper section by section.
Requirements ● Length: 2–3 pages, double-spaced, 12-pt font, 1-inch margins (not including a Works
Cited/Works Consulted page) ● A clear, arguable thesis statement in your introduction ● Direct engagement with the text of both primary sources, including specific evidence
(paraphrased or briefly quoted), not just a general summary ● Analysis, not just description: the essay should explain what the comparison reveals, not
only what each source says
Evaluation Criteria ● Thesis clarity and argument (does the essay make and sustain a specific claim about the
relationship between the two sources?) ● Use of textual evidence (specific, accurate, and well-integrated) ● Historical context and contextualization of each source ● Organization and analytical coherence ● Writing quality and adherence to citation format
Page 2