Logo comparison

I attached a picture that has all the  competitors farm logos including Gardopia Gardens logo.

1- I want you to compare all those logos in term of marketing, introduction in general about the ideal logo should look like.

2- Mention the features of some logos and the defects of some others.

3- Also, compare current and potential new design with competitors (I did design a new logo that I found is good in marketing of Gardopia in file number 3 here).

Also, I did a survey asking normal people to rate all of them from the most beautiful to less beautiful, I attached the results here as well (survey results in file number2).

- Mention the features of the best rating  people like.

- Mention the defects of the bad rating  people didn't like.

The due is on Tuesday 5/Dec/2017 at 6.00 PM evening, in the central time zone Dallas, TX, USA.

No less than 4 pages.