Asssigment
2 years ago
10
QUANTITATIVEstudyforCriticalAppraisal.docx
PICO_Worksheet.doc
- CriticalAppraisalWorksheet_rev.2020.docx
- ResearchStudyCriticalAppraisalExemplar_Annotated_kr.pdf
QUANTITATIVEstudyforCriticalAppraisal.docx
QUANTITATIVE study for Critical Appraisal
Completion requirementsMark as done Opened: Monday, November 11, 2024, 8:00 AM Due: Sunday, November 17, 2024, 11:59 PM
SUBMIT this research study to your faculty for approval by Week 5
· Once the research study is approved for the Critical Appraisal project, you can begin working on the project.
· A PDF document, please.
· The approval process requires a revision and, in many cases, repeats the search and makes a new selection. Then, the process of approval and final study to make the Critical Appraisal will be finalized in week 4.
*Three more weeks to prepare the Critical Appraisal (YOUR SIGNATURE ASSIGNMENT OF 25% of Final Grade) will be sufficient. **This is a journey, you will probably will not have the elements to complete the assignment until week 6. You need to make assigned readings to complete the activity successfully. That is the reason this class does not have a Final exam.
PICO_Worksheet.doc
Group Name: Joao Carreras
Date: 11/05/24
PICO Worksheet
Original Revised
|
Define your Question using PICO |
|||
|
P |
Describe your patient, population or problem (age, sex, race, past medical history, etc.), the disease, or main topic of your question. Patient/Population: Elderly adults aged 65 years and older who have chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), which makes them more vulnerable to respiratory infections and influenza-complicating issues.
|
||
|
I |
What intervention or action are you considering - treatment, diagnostic test, etc. Is there a specific issue you’d like to investigate? The goal of annual influenza vaccination is to decrease influenza-related morbidity and mortality in elderly patients with COPD.
|
Methodology |
Which research method (quantitative or qualitative) should be used to answer the study question? Quantitative research is suitable to assess measurable outcomes like flu infection rates, hospitalization rates, and mortality. If experimental, what research design should be used to compare the intervention group with the comparison (or control) group? · randomized controlled trial · cohort study · case controlled studies · case reports · systematic reviews · meta analysis · editorials/expert opinions Design: A randomized controlled trial (RCT) would be ideal but may not always be feasible; therefore, a cohort study tracking vaccinated versus unvaccinated COPD patients over one flu season is also appropriate. Alternatively, a systematic review of existing studies could summarize current evidence on the vaccine's efficacy in this specific population. |
|
C |
No influenza vaccination or use of other preventive measures (e.g., antiviral therapy, personal protective interventions, or usual COPD management without specific influenza vaccination).
|
|
|
|
O |
What is the outcome you’d like to achieve? What are you trying to do for the patient? Relieve or eliminate the symptoms? Reduce the number of adverse events? Improve function or test scores? Decrease in influenza-related events, reduction in hospitalizations due to respiratory causes, decreased COPD exacerbation, improved quality-of-life, and decrease in influenza-associated mortality.
|
||
|
State your Question resulting from PICO: "In elderly adults aged 65 and older with COPD, how effective is the annual influenza vaccine compared to no vaccination or other preventive measures in reducing the incidence of flu-related complications and respiratory hospitalizations?"
|
List keywords from your PICO question that can be used for your search.
Population-related keywords:
· Elderly adults
· Age 65 and older
· Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD)
· Respiratory illness
· High-risk adults
Intervention-related keywords:
· Influenza vaccine
· Flu vaccination
· Immunization
· Preventive care for COPD
· Annual vaccination
Comparison-related keywords:
· No vaccination
· Placebo
· Antiviral medications
· Preventive measures
Outcome-related keywords:
· Influenza incidence
· Hospitalizations
· Mortality reduction
· COPD exacerbations
· Quality of life
List other criteria –gender, age, year of publication, or language to be used to limit your search.
· Age: Focus on studies involving adults aged 65 and older.
· Gender: Not restricted unless specified, as COPD and flu impact both genders.
· Year of Publication: Last 5 years to ensure relevance to current medical practices and findings.
· Language: English to ensure accessibility of study content.
Use the databases page from the Library website for suggestions.
CINAHL (Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature) – Excellent for nursing and allied health literature.
PubMed – A broad source for medical and clinical research.
MEDLINE – Covers biomedical research and clinical studies.
Cochrane Library – Useful for systematic reviews and meta-analyses related to interventions.
EMBASE – Offers access to comprehensive research on pharmaceuticals and evidence-based medicine.
List the databases you plan to search: i.e., CINAHL.
Rev. May 2020 MSN5300 KmR