Argumentative paper

Choose one of the following articles, and write a response paper in argumentative style: 

1. Maxime Rodinson, "Economic Practice in the Muslim World in the Middle Ages", ; 

2. Perry Anderson, "House of Islam", chapter from Lineages of the Absolutist State,  

3. Aijaz Ahmad, "Islam, Islamisms and the West",

 should contain an argumentative thesis which can be made in support of a particular point of the article, against a point of the article, making a new idea building off of the article, 

 you should be citing the article when you are bringing up evidence from it.

 ~750 words