1 / 12100%
Earnings management occurs when companies artificially inflate or deflate their revenues,
profits, or earnings per share figures. Gaa and Dunmore point out that earnings may be
managed in many ways, but they all boil down to two basic possibilities. One is to alter the
numbers already in the financial records by using discretionary accruals and other
adjustments, and the other is to create or structure real transactions for the purpose of altering
the reported numbers (Mintz, 2016). There are five earnings management techniques, these
include the Big Bath, Cookie Jar Reserves, Operating Activities, Materiality, and Expense
and Revenue Recognition methods.
A big bath is an accounting term that is defined by a company's management team knowingly
manipulating its income statement to make poor results look even worse in order to make
future results appear better. It is often implemented in a relatively bad year so that a company
can enhance the next year's earnings in an artificial manner (Investopedia.com, 2020).
Cookie jar reserves are savings from previous quarters that a company records as earnings in
subsequent quarters to make it appear that its earnings were higher than they really were.
When a company fails to meet its earnings target, a company accountant can dip into the
cookie jar to inflate the numbers (Investopedia.com, 2021).
The operating activities technique is used when managers plan specific events within certain
periods. It is used to flatten income, thus eliminating spikes and dramatic declines in
particular accounting periods (study.com, 2022).
Materiality plays a vital role in the financial reporting process. Earnings management abuses
often stem from misuse or misunderstanding of the proper application of the materiality
concept (journalofaccountantcy.com, 2000).
Expense and revenue recognition can also be called “Income Smoothing” This comes under
fraudulent accounting as the company records its expenses before it incurs or does not show
the profit and sales when earned. They can even accelerate the sales showing extra revenue,
or they do not recognize a bad debt in the current year and shifts it to next year as it reduces
this year’s profit (wallstreetmojo.com, YEAR).
In 2019, the SEC charged The Kraft Heinz Company and two of their former executives for
engaging in years-long financial statement fraud. The company ended up paying $62 million
to settle charges related to inflated cost savings that caused it to restate several years of
financial reporting. According to the SEC's order, from the last quarter of 2015 to the end of
2018, Kraft engaged in various types of accounting misconduct, including recognizing
unearned discounts from suppliers and maintaining false and misleading supplier contracts,
which improperly reduced the company's cost of goods sold and allegedly achieved "cost
savings." Kraft, in turn, touted these purported savings to the market, which were widely
covered by financial analysts. The accounting improprieties resulted in Kraft reporting
inflated adjusted "EBITDA," a key earnings performance metric for investors. As alleged in
the SEC's order and in its complaint against Hofmann, Kraft failed to design and maintain
effective internal accounting controls for its procurement division. As a result, finance and
gatekeeping personnel repeatedly overlooked indications that expenses were being
improperly accounted for (SEC.gov, 2019). In this case, Heinz violated the expense and
revenue recognition techniques, also known as Income Soothing. The fraud resulted in nearly
300 misleading transactions that, if they had been recorded properly, would have added $50
million to the company’s cost of goods sold during that time. After the Kraft Heinz merger,
management promised an aggressive push to reduce expenses. “The cost-saving strategy,
including its impact on costs of goods sold, was widely covered by analysts at the time,” the
SEC noted. But after the company “encountered significant headwinds in its effort to meet
annual budget and savings targets,” the commission said, Pelleissone “failed to adjust
expense reduction expectations for the procurement division, creating a high-pressure
environment focused on obtaining same-year cost savings” (cfo.com, 2021).
Healthcare Services Group was recently fined $6 million by the SEC for engaging in
accounting and disclosure violations that allowed the company to report inflated earnings.
This was done to meet analyst expectations over multiple quarters. The SEC found that in
2014 and 2015 the company failed to timely accrue and disclose material loss contingencies
in the correct quarters which resulted in increased income (SEC, 2021). The result of this
earnings management was meeting analyst EPS estimates to the penny. According to Heller,
these misstatements took place for six straight quarters (Heller, 2021).
This type of earnings management seems to me to be a form of revenue recognition
management. While it is not specifically improper recognition of revenue, it is in the same
vein but for improper recognition of a liability. “Revenue is recognized only when a specific
event has occurred and the amount is measurable” (Mintz, 2020. P. 413). The result of
improperly recognizing a liability in this case produces the same result as improperly
recording revenue: an increase or decrease in earnings. The CEO of Healthcare Services
Group “repeatedly failed to record loss contingencies related to litigation settlements despite
mounting evidence that such liability was probable and reasonably estimable …” (Heller,
2021). This shows remarkable similarities to the recording of revenues. Evidence of an
arrangement exists, the price (cost) is fixed or determinable, and collectability is reasonably
assured. It seems clear to me this is a case of revenue recognition Do you agree?
In April of this year Rollins Inc., a pest control services company based in Atlanta, Georgia,
agreed to pay the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) $8MM. According to the SEC
press release, Rollins was found to have “improper accounting practices in order to boost its
publicly-reported quarterly earnings per share (EPS) to meet research analysts’ consensus
estimates,” (2022). This is another story of a company’s fraud being detected by the Division
of Enforcement’s EPS Initiative, which utilizes data analytics to find “hard-to detect
accounting and disclosure violations by public companies,” (SEC, 2022).
d d d d d d d d d d d In the first quarter of 2016 and the second quarter of 2017 the CFO directed reserves
from accounts for termite, medical, and outside services to be reduced to meet EPS research
analysts’ expectations (Johnston et al., 2022). This earnings management technique is
described as the cookie jar reserves to obtain income smoothing. One can easily get the
desired number by increasing or decreasing (or just creating) the funds they have in reserve
accounts. The same effect can occur by increasing the distribution channels, which would
accelerate revenue recognition, or by postponing recording expense (Mintz & Morris, 2019). d
d FTE Networks Inc. was a public telecommunication company that manipulated earnings by
recording false revenue. Michael Palleschi, the former CEO, and David Lethem, the former
CFO were charged with multiple counts of fraud in July 2021 by the DOJ (Mangan, 2021).
FTE recording over $12 million in fake revenue during the course of the fraud (Mangan,
2021). The revenue was inflated by recording it against construction projects that were not
real. Mr. Palleschi and Mr. Lethem were using the fake revenue to cover up the fact the
business was declining and, in an attempt, to keep stock prices up. FTE had debt covenants
that required the stock price to stay above a specific amount. If the true financials had been
reported the stock price would drop and FTE would have to declare bankruptcy. Mr. Palleschi
and Mr. Letham also decided to use company funds for personal use by giving themselves
raises, leasing luxury cars, and taking vacations on private jets (SEC, 2021).
Earnings management is a technique that allows management to possibly alter the financial
statements to reflect desired rather than actual events throughout the time. Big bath charges,
creative acquisition accounting, cookie jar reserves, materiality, and revenue recognition are
the five strategies listed in our text book that management might employ to distort a
company's financial data. These are the five strategies:
The one-time overstatement of restructuring costs known as "Big-Bath Charges" is done to
minimize assets and hence, future expenses.
By making one-time charges for ongoing research and development, creative acquisition
accounting prevents future costs. Cookie-jar Reserves inflates the costs of sales returns or
warranties in prosperous times and uses these inflated costs in difficult times to lower
comparable fees.
Materiality is when inaccuracies in the financial accounts are intentionally recorded or
ignored on the presumption that they will not have a substantial impact.
Recording revenue before it is generated, or when a corporation registers revenue to match
earnings expectations in order to boost year-end profits and shares, is known as revenue
recognition.
In the Madison Timber Properties LLC case, the business was accused of participating in a
Ponzi scheme. An financial scam called a Ponzi scheme uses money raised from new
investors to pay off old investors. However, the perpetrators of many Ponzi schemes do not
really invest the money. They instead utilize it to reimburse others who made previous
investments and may even keep it for themselves. These projects also often last for a year or
longer, however some have been successful for ten years or more.
Using Madison Timber Properties, LLC, Arthur Lamar Adams scammed more than 150
investors in the Southeast of the United States out of more than $85 million. Investors were
informed by Mr. Adams that he was buying the lumber rights to land in Florida, Alabama,
and Mississippi. Mr. Adams guaranteed investors yearly returns of 12 to 15 percent, and the
investors' account records showed they had been profitable over time. Although Madison
Timber Properties, LLC did not own any property, the investors received gains that were
solely on paper. As an alternative, Mr. Adams made bogus cutting agreements and falsified
documents with lumber firms. To keep the Ponzi scam running, he was moving the money of
the investors around.
For this specific case, I think that the company engaged in big bath charges and revenue
recognition charges. These two, in my opinion, apply to the situation since Mr. Adams
utilized a technique of income manipulation by exaggerating costs and losses to give the
investor the impression that they were continually making money.
Earnings management occurs when companies artificially inflate (or deflate) their revenues,
profits, or earnings per share (EPS) figures. Gaa and Dunmore point out that earnings may be
managed in many ways, but they all boil down to two basic possibilities. One is to alter the
numbers in the financial records by using discretionary accruals and other adjustments, and
the other is to create or structure actual transactions to alter the reported numbers. There are
also two motivations for altering financial reports through disclosure decisions. Another
perspective on earnings management is to divide the techniques into two categories, operating
earnings management, and accounting management. Operating earnings management
involves altering operating decisions to affect cash flows and net income for a period, such as
easing credit terms to increase sales. Accounting earnings management uses flexibility in
accounting standards to alter earnings numbers. I feel that operating earnings management
betters describes this case because Trump overvalued his property in the financial statements
he gave to his financial institutions.
Letitia James accused Trump of routinely lying about the value of his properties to secure
hundreds of millions in bank loans and tax breaks. James wants a judge to order $250 million
in penalties and to bar the Trump family from selling, buying, collecting rent, or borrowing
money in New York. Trump's objectively false 2015 claim that his Trump Tower triplex on
Manhattan's Fifth Avenue spanned 33,000 square feet. It was 11,000 square feet, a huge
exaggeration. The former president has allegedly been overvaluing the place on the financial
statements he gives to his financial institutions. Trump as part of an alleged scheme to induce
banks to lend money to the Trump Organization on more favourable terms than would
otherwise have been available to the company. To satisfy continuing loan covenants, to
induce insurers to provide insurance coverage for higher limits and at lower premiums, and to
gain tax benefits. Records show Trump acquired a 6,096-square-foot triplex apartment
occupying a section of floors 66 through 68, around the time Trump Tower opened in 1983. A
decade later, he expanded his penthouse, merging parts of two neighboring apartments into
his home, according to the filings. The result is 10,996 square feet of prime Manhattan real
estate, much smaller than Trump claims to own. No records from the city indicate that he has
added or shed square footage in the years since.
The phrase "earning management" describes a technique implemented by management of a
company to influence the company's profits just so the figures can match a fixed goal. After
discussing the current rental market, FTE Networks, Inc. is the perfect company to discuss.
The SEC accused Florida-based FTE Networks, a provider of network infrastructure, of
running an extensive accounting fraud as of. The corporation overstated its revenues over
100% at some times, according to a study made public by the SEC. Following a grand jury's
indictment, former FTE Networks Inc. CEO Michael Palleschi and former FTE Networks Inc.
CFO David Lethem were detained and charged with conspiracy, securities and wire fraud,
improperly influencing the conduct of an audit, and aggravated identity theft. Regarding some
critical parts of these documents that were improperly recorded or reported in FTE's financial
statements, the two CO'S misled FTE's internal accounting staff as well as the company's
external auditor. According to the same SEC claim, Palleschi and Lethem wrongfully
encouraged FTE to record revenue and associated accounts for fake construction projects,
which led to an increase in the company's revenues. According to the press statement, the
embezzled money were used to pay for private aircraft use, luxury automobile rentals,
personal credit card purchases, unlawful wire transfers, and stock issuance. In the end, FTE
Networks had to restate its 2017 net loss to $92 million due to the debt features that were
hidden. The accelerated revenue recognition method, which can result in misuse within
accrual accounting, is portrayed in this case. Improper revenue recognition claims by the
SEC, like in this instance, are a key cause of restatement and have been notably recognized in
SEC criminal proceeding, forcing the FASB to create a newer revenue recognition standard to
proactively eliminate fraud in this field. Revenue from a multi-element arrangement
involving software must be allocated to each element, e.g., the separate products sold in the
combination sale, based on the fair value of that element, e.g., the dollar value of that element,
as established through evidence of a consistent price paid by customers for the same or
similar element, as measured by vendor-specific objective evidence of fair value, under
GAAP (Mintz & Miller, 2023). This standard also offers additional guidelines on when
committed goods or services have been delivered. FTE networks violated GAAP by failing to
follow the guidelines outlined in the accounting standards and ignoring other factors.
American Renal Associates Holdings, Inc. (ARA) is one of the largest national providers of
dialysis care in the United States. The case I found against the company alleges that they used
the cookie jar technique in the fraudulent scheme. According to the SEC complaint, ARA had
a two-step process to recognize revenue. This involved estimating the amount of payment
from insurance companies which they called a contractual allowance, and second, making
topside adjustments after receiving information about the actual payment amount (Complaint,
2021). Topside adjustments are journal entries that reflect actual cash received and are
generally within the scope of GAAP. However, it was used in this case to perpetrate ARA’s
fraud. This caused ARA to overstate its revenue, net income, and financial metrics. The SEC
has charged the ARA and three of its former senior executives with revenue manipulation
schemes. “In September 2019, ARA issued restated financial statements which, among other
things, reflected that it had overstated net income by more than 30% for 2017 and by more
than 200% for the first three quarters of 2018” (Securities, 2021).
Earnings Management is a technique companies use to create the appearance of a favorable
financial position by inflating or smoothing earnings. The disingenuous accounting practice
used in the case of ARA is known as the cookie jar. It is a revenue manipulation scheme
where the business sets up a reserve account to hold estimated adjustment amounts to
recognize and dip into the ‘cookie jar’ when needed (Mintz & Morris, 2020). In this case, the
motivations behind earnings management appear to be to meet or beat the predetermined
financial metrics.
References
Complaint sec v. ara. (2021). SEC. https://www.sec.gov/litigation/complaints/2021/comp-
pr2021-
252.pdf
Mintz, S. M., & Morris, R. E. (2020). Ethical obligations and decision making in accounting
(5th ed.). McGraw Hill Education.
Securities and Exchange Commission. (2021). SEC charges dialysis provider and three
former seniors
executives with revenue manipulation scheme. SEC. https://www.sec.gov/news/press-
release/2021-252
"Former FTE Networks Inc CEO and CFO arrested for embezzlement and defrauding
investors." Legal Monitor Worldwide 19 July 2021: NA. Business Insights: Global. Web. 10
Oct. 2022.
Mangan, D. (2021, July 15). Former executives of FTE networks charged with securities
fraud and Asset Swindle, sued by Sec. CNBC. Retrieved October 11, 2022, from
https://www.cnbc.com/2021/07/15/fte-networks-executives-charged-with-securities-fraud-
conspiracy.html
Mintz, S. M., & Miller, W. F. (2023). Ethical Obligations and Decision Making in
Accounting Text and Cases (5th Ed.). McGraw Hill LLC.
Chase Peterson – Whithorn (September 21, 2022) How Forbes Exposed Trump's Lies About
the Size Of His Penthouse Retrieved from
https://www.forbes.com/sites/chasewithorn/2022/09/21/how-forbes-exposed-trumps-lies-
about-the-size-of-his-penthouse/?sh=13da47af58ec
"Donald Trump will fight hard against Letitia James' lawsuit. Ex-AG insiders say these are
his top 5 defences." The Business Insider, September 24, 2022, p. NA. Gale General OneFile,
link.gale.com/apps/doc/A719403005/ITOF?u=nhc_main&sid=ebsco&xid=626d3635.
Accessed October 12, 2022.
Mintz, S., & Morris, R. (2020). Ethical obligations and decision making in accounting (5th
ed.). New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
Mintz, S. M., & Morris, R. E. (2020). Ethical Obligations and Decision-Making in
Accounting: Text and Cases (Vol. 5th Edition). McGraw-Hill. SEC.
SEC Shuts Down $85 Million Ponzi Scheme and Obtains Asset Freeze. Retrieved from SEC:
https://www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases/2018/lr24129.htm
Wells, J. T. (n.d.). Ponzi Schemes. Retrieved from ACFE:
https://www.acfe.com/ponzischemes.aspx
Mangan, D. (2021). Former executives of FTE Networks charged with securities fraud and
asset swindle, sued by SEC. CNBC. https://www.cnbc.com/2021/07/15/fte-networks-
executives-charged-with-securities-fraud-conspiracy.html
SEC. (2021). SEC Charges Executives of Network Infrastructure Company With Accounting
Fraud. https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2021-127
Mintz, S., & Morris, R. (2013). Ethical Obligations and Decision Making in Accounting (3rd
ed.). New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
Johnson, J., Fike, R., & Mitsch, T. (2022, May 5). The SEC Closes the Cookie Jar – Recent
SEC Enforcement Activity Reaffirms Focus on Improper Earnings Management. Vinson &
Elkins. https://www.velaw.com/insights/the-sec-closes-the-cookie-jar-recent-sec-
enforcement-activity-reaffirms-focus-on-improper-earnings-management/
Securities and Exchange Commission. (2022, April 18). Rollins Inc. Agrees to Pay $8 Million
to Settle Accounting Violations. [Press Release]. https://www.sec.gov/news/press-
release/2022-
64#:~:text=The%20SEC%27s%20order%20finds%20that%20Rollins%20and%20Northen%
20violated%20Sections,Securities%20Exchange%20Act%20of%201934.
Heller, M. (2021, August 24). Healthcare Services Group fined over accounting. CFO.
Retrieved from https://www.cfo.com/accounting-2/2021/08/healthcare-services-group-fined-
over-accounting/
Mintz, S. M. (2020). Ethical obligations and decision making in accounting: Text and cases.
McGraw-Hill Education.
Press release. SEC. (2021, August 24). Retrieved from https://www.sec.gov/news/press-
release/2021-162
C. Terry Grant, J. C. M. D. A. G. H. G. (2000, September 1). Earnings management and the
abuse of materiality. Journal of Accountancy. Retrieved October 13, 2022, from
https://www.journalofaccountancy.com/issues/2000/sep/earningsmanagementandtheabuseof
materiality.html
Hayes, A. (2021, May 19). Big bath definition. Investopedia. Retrieved October 13, 2022,
from https://www.investopedia.com/terms/b/bigbath.asp
Kenton, W. (2021, September 8). Cookie jar reserves definition. Investopedia. Retrieved
October 13, 2022, from https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/cookiejaraccounting.asp
Kraft Heinz fined $62M for accounting fraud. CFO. (2021, November 1). Retrieved October
13, 2022, from https://www.cfo.com/accounting-2/2021/09/kraft-heinz-fined-62m-for-
accounting-fraud/
Mintz, S. (2016). Ethical Obligations & Decision Making in Accounting + Connect Access
Card. McGraw-Hill Education.
Press release. SEC Emblem. (2021, September 3). Retrieved October 13, 2022, from
https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2021-174
Swaminathan, A. (2022, June 8). Earnings management. WallStreetMojo. Retrieved October
13, 2022, from https://www.wallstreetmojo.com/earnings-management/
Take online courses. earn college credit. Research Schools, Degrees & Careers. Study.com |
Take Online Courses. Earn College Credit. Research Schools, Degrees & Careers. (n.d.).
Retrieved October 13, 2022, from https://study.com/learn/lesson/earnings-management-
techniques-examples.html
Students also viewed