THEO 650
REFLECTION ESSAY GRADING RUBRIC
Criteria Levels of Achievement
Content 70% Advanced Proficient Developing Not Present
Content 66 to 75 points
The paper is of
excellent quality and
reflects a clear grasp of
the author’s argument,
context, and concepts.
Analysis meets
graduate standards.
50 to 65 points
The paper is of good
quality and reflects a
fair grasp of the
author’s position,
argument, and
concepts. Analysis
meets graduate
standards.
1 to 49 points
The paper lacks a
significant level of
clarity, specificity, and/or
direction of purpose and
lacks the author’s
position and argument.
0 points
Not present.
Structure 30% Advanced Proficient Developing Not Present
Format: Turabian
and Word Count
23 to 25 points
Paper is free of all or
almost all Turabian
citation errors.
18 to 22 points
Paper has some Turabian
citation errors (in
footnotes or
bibliography).
1 to 17 points
Paper has serious
Turabian citation errors
(in footnotes or
bibliography).
Necessary footnotes
may be missing.
0 points
Not present.
Page 1 of 1
