QUANTITATIVE ARTICLE REVIEW
2
The Quantitative journal article I have chosen to summarize is “The Effect of
Multicultural Education on Preservice Teachers’ Attitude and Efficacy: Testing Bank’s Content
Integration Dimension”, written by Mustafa Ozturk and Zeki Arsai. This article presents a
research study aimed at exploring the impact of a 10-week multicultural education intervention
on the attitudes and efficacy of pre-service teachers regarding multicultural concepts. In this
experimental study, there are two objectives: to examine the impact of content integration on the
multicultural efficacy and attitudes of preservice teachers, and to demonstrate a method for
incorporating multicultural education into the current curricula in countries like Turkey, where
such education is not mandated within teacher training programs.
Description of Participants
A non-probability convenient sampling method was used to choose the sample for the study. 52
pre-service teachers from the Department of Social Sciences Teaching Program took part in the
research. Among the participants, 67.3% were female students, while 32.7% were male students.
All participants were third-year students who had already successfully completed most of the
teacher training courses provided by the department. Earlier research was conducted to
determine whether the groups had a normal distribution and whether their variances were
comparable. The findings from the normality test and the independent samples t-test indicated
that both groups were normally distributed. Additionally, there was no significant difference
between the groups before the intervention.
Research Design
For this study, a quasi-experimental design was implemented by utilizing a pre-test and post-test
with a control group. To do this, multicultural content was added to an existing teacher
education course. The experimental group was taught using this integrated multicultural content,
QUANTITATIVE ARTICLE REVIEW
3
while the control group continued with a standard classroom management curriculum. The
independent variable in this study was the incorporation of multicultural education practices, and
the dependent variables included the teachers' multicultural attitudes and their sense of efficacy
in multicultural contexts.
Method of Data Collection
For this study, the Multicultural Efficacy Scale (MES) was used for data collection. This tool
was given to both the experimental group and the control group before and after the study to
evaluate any changes in their multicultural attitudes and effectiveness. The MES helped in
understanding the influence of the intervention by comparing the scores from the pre-test and
post-test for both groups.
Statistical Analysis
To evaluate the effectiveness of the intervention, the researchers conducted ANCOVA tests,
controlling for pre-test scores. The results revealed significant effects of the multicultural
practices on participants' multicultural attitude.
Results
For the study’s first research question (Is there a statistically significant difference between
multicultural attitude and efficacy of the experiment and control groups’ pre-test and post-test
scores? [Akcaoglu and Arsal, 2021]), the findings were there was a notable difference in the
multicultural attitudes and efficacy scores of the experimental group compared to before the
study. In contrast, the control group did not show any significant changes in their multicultural
attitudes or efficacy scores.
QUANTITATIVE ARTICLE REVIEW
4
For the second research question (Is there a statistically significant difference between
multicultural attitude, efficacy and overall multicultural attitude and efficacy scores of the
experiment and control groups’ posttest scores when pre-test scores are controlled? [Akcaoglu
and Arsal, 2021]), the findings show that the experimental group had a greater increase in their
post-test scores compared to the control group. Furthermore, when the researchers looked at the
adjusted average scores, the experimental group scored higher than the control group. The results
from the ANCOVA analysis indicated that multicultural practices significantly influenced the
participants' multicultural attitudes, sense of efficacy, and both partial and overall effectiveness,
even after considering their pre-test scores.
Opportunities for Further Research
Some protentional opportunities for further research that are not explicitly mentioned in the
article could have to do with longitudinal studies. For example, research into whether the effects
of the intervention persist over time by conducting a follow-up study in the future. Also, research
on how the intervention impacts the teaching practices of the pre-service teachers once they enter
the field.
Threats to Validity
The study is unfortunately subject to several potential validity issues that could affect its
results. For internal validity, there are concerns like selection bias because participants were not
randomly assigned, experimenter bias, testing effects, social desirability bias, and possible
differences in dropout rates among participants. These factors can skew the findings. Regarding
external validity, the study's ability to generalize its results is limited since it took place in only
one university. There are also concerns about construct validity, primarily due to the use of just
one self-reported measurement tool (MES), which might not accurately reflect the true attitudes
QUANTITATIVE ARTICLE REVIEW
5
or behaviors of participants. Addressing these validity issues in future research could enhance the
reliability and applicability of the study's findings.
Insights/Criticism
The research provides important information about how effective multicultural education can be
in training teachers. It indicates that including multicultural topics in teacher training can
improve the attitudes and confidence of future teachers. However, there are some drawbacks to
the study. For example, it is based on data from only one university, does not use random
assignment, and relies on self-reported information, which can lead to bias. Additionally, the
study assesses multicultural education over a brief period and focuses only on one part of it—
content integration—making it difficult to apply the findings broadly or over a longer time.
Future research could help tackle these limitations and investigate other aspects of multicultural
education.
Implications of Findings
The study's findings highlight key points for teacher education programs and teaching practices.
It shows that including multicultural education in teacher training can improve preservice
teachers' attitudes and confidence regarding diversity. This indicates the importance of focusing
on multicultural skills in teacher education, which prepares future teachers to effectively engage
with students from diverse cultural backgrounds. Teachers with strong multicultural skills are
more likely to adopt inclusive teaching methods, making them feel more capable in diverse
classrooms.
