Chapter 2: The Therapeutic Relationship
The Importance of the Therapeutic Relationship in Creating Change
- Therapeutic Relationship
oProfessional relationship involving good working alliance,
trust, honesty, and the promise of confidentiality, which
focuses on the needs of the client and involves compensation
for the helper
oMore predictive of success than the theoretical approach of
the helper
oVital to creating improvement
oMust be established immediately to prevent attrition
- Factors that affect client outcomes:
oTherapist factors
oClient factors
oTechniques the helper uses
Mega-skills
Enhancing Efficacy and self-esteem
Practicing New Behaviors
Lowering and Raising Emotional Arousal
Activating Client Expectations, Hope, and
Motivation
Providing New Learning Experiences
Maintaining a strong Helper/Client Relationship
REPLAN
Provides a way of remembering which general
area to consider and a way of understanding the
intent of the techniques
Relationship
oAt the middle of the circle to emphasize the
other factors reliance on it
Efficacy and Self-Esteem
Practicing New Behaviors
Lowering and Raising Emotional Arousal
Activating Client Expectation, Hope, and
motivation
New Learning Experiences
What Is a Helping Relationship? Is a Professional Helping Relationship the
Same as a Friendship?
- Professional Helping Relationship
oDescribes a contractual relationship between a helper and a
client who agree on compensation for the helper and goals
for the client
oClient’s goals are paramount
oHelper abides by professional ethics
Required to identify and articulate issues not normally
broached in a friendship
- Eric Berne
oFounder of transactional analysis
oInformed consent – clients must know what they are agreeing
to and must participate in the changes that they are about to
make
The Unique Characteristics of a Therapeutic Relationship
- Better Outcomes
oSymptom improvement
- Specific Characteristics of the Therapeutic Relationship
oThere is a mutual liking-or at least respect.
oThe purpose of the relationship is the resolution of the
client’s issues.
oThere is a sense of teamwork as both helper and client work
toward a mutually agreed-upon goal.
2
Therapeutic Alliance
The degree of collaboration between helper and
client.
Is stronger when the client and helper agree on
treatment goals, techniques, and interventions
oSafety and trust are established, allowing honest disclosure
by the client and feedback from the helper. There is a
contract specifying what will be disclosed to others outside of
the relationship.
oThe relationship includes helper support by also requires
honest feedback.
oThere is an agreement about compensation for the helper.
oThere is an understanding that the relationship is confined to
the sessions and does not overlap into the participants’
personal lives.
oAs a contractual relationship, the relationship can be
terminated at any time.
How can a Helper Create a Therapeutic Relationship?
- Relationship Enhancers
oHelper behaviors that improve the quality of the therapeutic
relationship
oInclude:
Nonverbal skills
Posture
Presence
Empathy
Self-disclosure
- Physical Closeness, Posture, and. Warmth
oInvite the client into a safe relationship and lead to greater
openness
- Adapt to the Client’s Unique Characteristics
3
oThe relationship grows when the client perceives the helper is
sensitive to religion, ethnicity, family issues, and personality
Keep the focus on the client, avoiding a barrage of
questions, strong confrontation, inappropriate self-
disclosure, being rigid, and being helper-centered
- Create a Collaborative Relationship
oFollowing Suggestions to develop an atmosphere conducive
to developing a joint project (Spencer et al., 2019):
Recognize the client’s expertise
Inquire about preferences
Continua to Use to classify a helping relationship:
The therapist should maintain a profession
distance offers a warm friendship
The therapist is more about listening the
therapist is active
The relationship is formal The relationship is
very informal
The therapist steers the direction of the session
the client directs the session
Recognize that the helper may make mistakes
- Presence
oOften a potent relationship enhancer
- Empathy
oFeeling oneself into another person’s experience
oYou grasp the facts, feelings, and significance of another
person’s story
oInvolves the ability to convey your accurate perceptions to
the other person
oWe soothe the other person’s emotional arousal when we
express empathy
oTaking a tutorial stance
4
The helper becomes a student and asks the client to
instruct the helper about the culture or specific
situation or illness of the client
Self-Disclosure and the Therapeutic Process
- Occurs when the helper relates personal facts, stories, or feelings
- Self-involving Statements
oWhen a helper shared the helper’s personal feelings with the
client as a way of connecting
oCan be used later in the process to:
Inspire hope in the client
Provide feedback, confrontation, or an alternative
viewpoint
- Self-Disclosure
oEnhance the relationship
oHelp clients realize that they are not alone
oHelp them see another viewpoint
oconvey that their experience is normal
Other Factors That Help or Strain the Therapeutic Relationship
- Ruptures
oBreach in the positive relationship established between the
client and the helper
oMay cause withdraw, drop out or express negative feelings
about the helping process
oCaused by insensitivity by the helper, misunderstandings,
disagreements, or feelings of distrust or disrespect
oOccurs when there is a breakdown in the therapeutic alliance
caused by something that happens in the session
oHow to deal with ruptures:
Developing a surveillance system to identify them
- Facilitative Officer Environment
oShould be quiet, comfortable, orderly, and well lit
5
oRecommended that the helper face away from the desk so
that there are no obstacles between the client and helper
- Distractions
- Appearing Credible and Taking a Nonhierarchical Stance
oRemember what you do know and use the skills that you have
oDon’t use emotional distance as a way of being professional
oRemember that credibility is enhanced by being organized
and interested and by exhibiting nonverbal behaviors
associated with attentiveness
oNonhierarchical Stance:
When the helper emphasizes equality in the
therapeutic relationship and empowers the client to be
a partner in the helping process
Therapeutic Faux Pas
- Helper responses that may weaken or disrupt the helping
relationship
- The Dirty Half Dozen Roadblocks to a Therapeutic Relationship:
oGiving advice
oUsing logic and the Sermonette
oPraising and Being a Cheerleader
oInterpreting, Analyzing, and Diagnosing
oConsoling, Minimizing, and Reassuring and Emphasizing the
Positive
oProbing and Questioning
Transference and Countertransference
- Transference
oRefers to the client feelings from past relationships or
personal issues that are carried over to the helper or helping
relationship
- Countertransference
oThe helper’s reaction to a client
6
oOriginate in past relationships or personal issues and are
transferred to the client or on to the helping relationship
Transference as Cognitive Distortions
- Cognitive Distortions
oLearned thinking patterns that are false or irrational
oTransference reactions are cognitive distortions about the
helper
- Major Transference Patterns (client behaviors/attitudes to helper
experience)
oHelper as Ideal
Compliments helper profusely
feels pride, satisfaction, and all competent
Imitates helper
Feels flattered
Wears similar clothing, general idealization
Tension, anxiety, confusion, anger, and
frustration because the focus on the helper
instead of the client
oHelper as Seer
Ascribes omniscience and power to the helper
Experiences “God complex” and self-doubt
Views helper as expert, sees self as incompetent
Feels incompetent and pressured to be right and
live up to the client’s expectation
Seeks answers, solutions, and advice
oHelper as Nurturer
Experiences profuse emotion and sense of fragility
Experiences feelings of sorrow, sympathy,
depression, despair, and depletion
Cries
Has urge to soothe, coddle, touch
Feels dependent, helpless, and indecisive
7
Desires to be touched and held
oHelper as Frustrater
Feels defensive, cautious, guarded, suspicious, and
distrustful
Feels uneasy, on edge (walking on eggshells)
tense, hostile, and hateful
Tests Helper
Withdraws and becomes unavailable
oHelper as Nonentity
Shifts topics
Feels overwhelmed, subdued, taken aback, used,
and useless
Lacks focus
Feels bored
In voluble and desultory
Experiences resentment, frustration, and lack of
recognition
Meanders aimlessly
Characterizes as a nonperson
Countertransference: Dealing with the Helper’s Feelings
- Common Patterns of Countertransference:
oHelper Emotional Response to client/Helper Behavior/How
Helper Sees Client)
oPaternal/maternal Nurturing
Overprotective, failure to challenge
Fragile
oFear of Client’s Anger
Rejection
Needy
oNeed for reassurance
Socializing
Friend
8
oNeed for liking
Failure to challenge
oAnxiety
Avoidance of emotionally charged topics
oFeelings of identification
Advice giving, overinvolvement, failure to recognize
client uniqueness
Self
oSexual
Seductive behavior
Sexual object
oRomantic
Inappropriate self-disclosure
Romantic partner
oFrustration
Extreme confrontation
Product
oAnger
Scolding
Success
Dealing with Transference from a Client
- Task of the helper
oTo help the client gain more awareness and to
nondefensively explore the source of these feelings
- How a Helper can React Therapeutically:
oConvey acceptance of the client’s remarks but don’t retaliate
oExplore the client’s feelings
oUtilize self-involving statements to help the client become
more aware of the helper’s genuine thoughts and emotions
about the client and client’s behavior
oUse the experience to help the client to find new and better
ways of expressing feelings and meeting needs
9
10